stats
globeandmail.com ctv.ca exn.ca sympatico.ca
space
HOME

NEW YORK RECOVERS

THE MUSLIM WORLD

A CHANGED AMERICA

CANADIAN CONNECTIONS

PHOTO GALLERY

COMMENT

VIDEO

ARCHIVES



  FEATURES

space

• Don't shackle us to 9/11
Canadian Muslims, horrified that last year's crime was carried out in the name of Islam, have a special duty to challenge intolerance head on, says SHEEMA KHAN  FULL STORY arrow
space
• Foolish to underestimate Bush, a man on a mission
Americans didn't elect George W. Bush to be a war leader. In fact, they barely elected him at all.  FULL STORY arrow
space
•  Flowers and tears in the swirling dust
NEW YORK -- Down the ramp the mourners stream to leave their flowers in the pit.   FULL STORY arrow
space
• Canadian strangers are bonded by fate
NEW YORK -- They are the widows from Canada: Maureen Basnicki, Tanja Tomasevic, Cindy Barkway. A year ago they'd never heard each other's names. Today, Maureen says, "We're like sisters."   FULL STORY arrow
space
• Legislative overkill? It's hard to tell
The al-Qaeda terrorists who slammed their hijacked airplanes into New York and Washington a year ago also punched a large hole in the protection of Canadians' civil rights. .  FULL STORY arrow
space
• Requiem 9/11 is a natural for New York
Deliver me, O Lord, from everlasting death on that dreadful day, when the heavens and the earth shall be moved . . . When Thou shalt come to judge the earth by fire. . .  FULL STORY arrow
space
• Africa: 'The jilted continent'
CTV's Africa Correspondent, Murray Oliver, describes why many Africans have mixed feelings about Sept. 11.  FULL STORY arrow
space
• Love among the ruins
From our earliest memories, we know that stories help us make sense of things. That's why, when it comes to Sept. 11, we like to hear the survivors talk.  FULL STORY arrow
space
• Where's the purple fury?
The victims of Sept. 11 have not been avenged, writes JOHN STACKHOUSE  FULL STORY arrow
space
• Russia: The new world order
CTV Moscow correspondent Ellen Pinchuk says Sept. 11. became a benchmark in a new world order, with Russia finally on the same side as the West.  FULL STORY arrow
space
• America is all right...
This was no natural disaster ... but a deliberate massacre of innocent people, writes MARGARET WENTE   FULL STORY arrow
space
• Afghanistan: It's still a war zone
CTV's South Asia correspondent Matt McClure says the war may be over in Afghanistan but the fight for survival continues.   FULL STORY arrow
space
• Things seen in darkness
This year has been defined by the compulsion to remember, the desire to move on, and the difficulty of knowing the difference, IAN BROWN writes  FULL STORY arrow
space
• England: 'The constant ally'
CTV's London Correspondent, TOM KENNEDY, looks at the enduring alliance between Britain and the U.S. 11.  FULL STORY arrow
space
• Good morning, America
America was forced to join the real world on Sept. 11, KEN WIWA writes  FULL STORY arrow
space
• Might makes right
Is the U.S. winning the war? Globe columnists MARCUS GEE and RICK SALUTIN debate  FULL STORY arrow
space
space

 
space
Russia: The new world order
CTV Moscow correspondent Ellen Pinchuk says Sept. 11. became a benchmark in a new world order, with Russia finally on the same side as the West
space
By ELLEN PINCHUK
CTV Moscow Bureau
Friday, September 6, 2002
space

When you live in Russia, you're used to turmoil. In my 11 years here, I've witnessed the death of the Soviet Union, the capitalist revolution, money reform, economic collapse, Gorbachev's ouster, Yeltsin's surprise resignation, and two wars in Chechnya. Never a dull moment, and never predictable.


Pinchuk

History has left deep scars on the Russian people. You really sense it, between the Second World War, Stalin and 70 years of a failed communist experiment, with Russians as guinea pigs. Each and every family has felt the uncompromising stamp of history.

And that hunger to see history being made is what kept me here and in love with this inscrutable place. I like to joke that it's akin to living on the rim of a volcano, but with lots of great art.

Being an American, the stability of home always offered a good respite from Russia's intensity. When I visited my family in the States, I was reassured by the thought that back at home, nothing is really changing. Presidents come and go, but the system stays pretty much the same. People are taking in their dry-cleaning, buying groceries, going to movies. Even the wars the United States has fought during my conscious lifetime have seemed more like minor blips on the radar. The world's troubles seemed far away, history meandering along, not being forged with white-hot energy, as in my beloved Russia.

On Sept. 11, history hit America. But I was sitting in Moscow thinking about bullfights and birthday cake. We were covering a story about a Portuguese bullfight in Moscow that was cancelled due to protests by the Russian Orthodox Church and a youth group arguing for animal rights. It was a meaty little story, but nothing earth-shattering. That day also happened to be my birthday, but I had decided to spend the evening writing the story and not celebrate until the weekend.

The TV was on, my laptop on my knees, and I was writing the story as the towers came down. The strangest sense came over me - wanting to do something, but not knowing what. I wanted suddenly to be back in America and go through this thing with the rest of my compatriots. My parents called from Los Angeles to ask why I picked this day to be born, and friends called from Boston and Chicago and L.A. to wish me a happy birthday and commiserate about how things would be different for everyone after this day. We were all trying to reach our friends in New York.

And many, many Russians called me to offer condolences and make sure my friends and family were okay. A lot more went to the U.S. Embassy in Moscow, bringing flowers. They arrived always in an even number, according to Russian tradition for the dead. Whatever anti-American sentiment was there, before or after, it wasn't felt on Sept. 11. Russians cried, knowing the horror at what America was facing. They know all about history being made.

This sentiment was echoed on the official level as well. President Vladimir Putin surprised many by being one of the first world leaders to offer condolences and assistance to President George W. Bush and the American people. Russia's foreign policy has, at times, been very much at odds with that of the West. Alliances with North Korea, Belarus and Iraq are just some examples. But there was no hesitation after the attacks, as Russia made it clear it would support Bush's war on terrorism.

Naysayers here grumbled that the U.S. had supported the mujahedeen in their prolonged war against the Soviet Union, which ultimately led to the rise of the Taliban. There was a sense in the press and among some Russians that the Sept. 11 attacks were a problem of the United States' own making. Still, the Russian government committed to intelligence, logistical and humanitarian assistance, and permitted the use of bases and airspace in the Central Asian republics in its sphere of influence. The Russians stopped short of sending troops to Afghanistan, having had such a painful history of warfare there. I heard many warnings from Russians who said the U.S. and its allies would lose a war in Afghanistan, just as the Soviets did.

Critics have pointed out that Russian policy since then has made use of the war on terrorism to justify its long war in Chechnya, long criticized by the West for large-scale human rights violations by the Russian military. Many Russian politicians and commentators jumped at the chance to say, "Now you know what we've been facing," and stressed that there were international terrorists fighting on the Chechen side, some with alleged ties to al Qaeda. It is interesting to note that international criticism of that ongoing war in Chechnya has almost disappeared in the months since the war on terrorism began.

While it is true that the issue of Chechnya has been an important consideration in Russian foreign policy in the past year, Russia's stance has much deeper significance.

The attacks afforded Russia an unexpected opportunity to make an unequivocal statement: Russia wants to turn toward the West. It wants to be a part of the political and economic life of its former opponents. It wants to be considered an ally with NATO countries and is not interested in taking the other side just to flex its military muscle. The Soviet enemy is gone, the Cold War is over, and alliances are redrawn. Sept. 11th is a benchmark in this new world order, one in which Russia is on the same side as the West. Again: history being made.


space
SHARE YOUR THOUGHTS
Join in a discussion of the impact of 9/11 and the outlook for the future

BREAKING NEWS
Visit globeandmail.com and CTV.ca for the latest breaking news about 9/11.
space


Bell Globemedia Publishing Inc. Copyright © 2002 Bell Globemedia Interactive Inc.
Help & Contact Us | Back to the top of this page