CTV News | Bin Laden was 'within grasp' at Tora Bora, report says

Top Stories -   

Bin Laden was 'within grasp' at Tora Bora, report says

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News Channel: Kamran Bokhari, Stratfor
Kamran Bokhari, with the intelligence firm Stratfor, says the findings aren't unprecedented, and it has been known for a while that the outsourcing of ground activity was the reason bin Laden got away.

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(25)

Photos

Slideshow image

View Larger Image

CTV.ca News Staff

Date: Sun. Nov. 29 2009 10:10 PM ET

A new U.S. Senate report says troops were within reach of capturing Osama bin Laden in Afghanistan's Tora Bora mountains, but the American military did not deploy thousands of troops to find him, instead choosing to keep specialized soldiers on the sidelines.

The 50-page report, called "How we failed to get bin Laden," says the failure to capture him when he was most vulnerable in December 2001 laid the foundation for today's Afghan insurgents and aggravated the internal strife afflicting Pakistan.

It says that in December 2001, bin Laden and bodyguards "walked unmolested out of Tora Bora and disappeared into Pakistan's unregulated tribal area."

But instead of deploying an attack with thousands of soldiers, which was within the means of the American military, the report found fewer than 100 U.S. commandos were assigned to work with Afghan militias to find him.

"The vast array of American military power, from sniper teams to the most mobile divisions of the Marine Corps and the Army, was kept on the sidelines," the report said.

At the time, Bush's defence secretary, Donald Rumsfeld, expressed concern that a large U.S. troop presence might fuel a backlash. He and others said the evidence was not conclusive about bin Laden's location.

But after looking at unclassified government documents and conducting interviews with officials, the report said it was "clear that Osama bin Laden was within our grasp at Tora Bora."

The report looks back at the last eight years of military operations and seeks to point the blame specifically at Rumsfeld and top military commander Tommy Franks.

It goes on to say that failing to find bin Laden "forever altered the course of conflict in Afghanistan and the future of international terrorism."

The report says that capturing the al Qaeda leader eight years ago would not have eliminated the worldwide threat of terrorism that exists today. But failing to capture him allowed bin Laden to "emerge as a potent symbolic figure who continues to attract a steady flow of money and inspire fanatics worldwide."

The report was prepared for Sen. John Kerry, chairman of the Committee on Foreign Relations, and comes out ahead of U.S. President Barack Obama's plans to send more troops to Afghanistan.

Kerry, who lost a race for U.S. President to George W. Bush in 2004, has long said Bush missed chances to get bin Laden since the September 11 attacks.

With files from The Associated Press

Comments are now closed for this story

Goldens
said
0 0

So! You cannot catch him now he is gone! The question should be not where he was but where is he now? That is the question that needs to be answered. Sen Kerry should start living in the future and not dithering in the past. John Wilson Bridgetown NS


JC
said
0 0

Heads should role for missing this chance to get Osama - but will they? This is why we can't trust neo-cons to run a war. Just like when they run banks, they screw it up trying to make a buck on the side.

Tyler
said
0 0

Bush missed him? Yeah right Bush was on the ground giving the orders.

bc grrl
said
0 0

should have, could have, would have??? this is just more rhetoric coming out of the u.s. this was back in december of 2001, another massive military failure caused by inaction by the general in charge proving that this 'war' will never be 'won'!i see this report as yet another reason to call it quits, bring our canadian soldiers home, refocus the canadian role as that of peacekeepers and start spending wisely on canadian soil instead of always feeling the need to back up nato and the u.s. i support our troops but i do not feel that the leadership always had their best interests at heart or even in the fore fronts of their minds. as i see it, many canadians were sidelined into the areas that the u.s. were afraid to go (who was in afghanistan first?) and there have been too many casualties to justify this military action any further.yet another report costing how much to tell us something that we already knew...bin laden is a ghost and he will haunt for the rest of his natural life and beyond.


elisa from northern ON
said
0 0

They didn't want to catch him and still don't...this war was and is all about money, power, money, oil, money and more money. Ending the war wouldn't be worth it. Our soldiers believe they are helping women and normal citizens to a better way of life in the end...and for this reason I support them...but the bigger picture is that this is all about money and power for the US...and capturing Bin Laden will never happen for this reason.

Samual
said
0 0

The Bush government was so incompetent at everything, his wonderful government put the whole world in a downward spiral. Happy he's gone Harper was & still is playing follow the leader of the US.Bush couldn't even speak proper english, with statements like: We can co-exist with the fishes.


Fact Check
said
0 0

A democratic party headed by a sore loser reports on the repulican who beat him, this is as biased as it gets.

Mark in TO
said
0 0

If I remember correctly, special forces on the ground had Bin Laden in sight and noted that he had been wounded from an earlier air strike. They could have snatched him then but command wanted it to be an "Afghan" operation and ordered them not to move in. There is certainly plenty of blame to go around but saying it's "Bush's" fault is a bit insane. Anyway he probably died or has been incapacitated from that wound which would explain why we haven't heard much from him in the past several years.

eddytoronto
said
0 0

What does our own FBI say? Here is a surprising but little-known fact, because it has scarcely been reported in the mainstream media: The FBI’s “Most Wanted Terrorist” webpage on “Usama bin Laden” does not list the 9/11 attacks as one of the crimes for which he is wanted. It does list bombings in Dar es Salaam, Tanzania, and Nairobi as terrorist acts for which he is wanted. But it makes no mention of 9/11.

jim from manitoba
said
0 0

no more audio/video messages from osama-bin-laden lately. is it possible that he's dead from kidney failure as reported?

Bill O'Reilly
said
0 0

This has been known for years. Did you really expect Bush to bust Bin Laden? Their families have been closely linked for decades. Bin Laden Group invested in GW Bush's Arbusto Oil company in the early 1980s. GHW Bush was meeting with Usama's relatives in New York at the exact moment the first plane hit the Trade Center. Because of this connection, the Bush administration decided to ignore warnings of terrorist plots coming from Saudi Arabia. On Sept 13 2001, the Bush Whitehouse gave permission for several planes carrying bin Ladens and Saudi royals to leave the US, although no other civilian aircraft were allowed to fly. Unless there is a full investigation (there has not been) Bush and co. are getting away with some atrocious acts.


Mitch In the East
said
0 0

Well this is no surprise. Michael Scheuer (Lead the CIA Bin Laden unit) has written extensively just about this.


Rick in NB, Ste Marie
said
0 0

Osama Bin Ladin was not caught because of the fear factor. This was Bush's way of keeping the public under control. Just change the colour of the Homeland alert system every time you need public support. Don.t you think that there is something familiar about that?


Tono
said
0 0

The Al-Qaeda are evil. End of story.


Ned the head
said
0 0

Has enough time passed yet to conclude that Bin Laden was twice as smart as Dubya?


noozwurld
said
0 0

Of course the US didn't want to catch Osama. Without him as their enemy they would have nobody to cause fear and panic in their own population. They are always telling their people, their soldiers and the rest of the world that they are fighting these wars for their freedom. Osama doesn't threaten their freedom, only their security. WW1 & 2 were about freedom. Korea-NOT....result stalemate and an ongoing cold war with N.Korea ever since. Vietnam - NOT....result -humiliating defeat. Iraq - NOT....result, defeat actually. When they leave, sectarian violence will rip the country apart while at the same time probably involving, empowering and emboldening Iran. After 60 years of such colossal foreign policy blunders and expensive wars costing so many lives is an awakening on America's horizon or an eternal foreign policy slumber party?


FreakAlert
said
0 0

Didn't Benazir Bhutto mention to David Frost, on his show, that Bin Laden was murdered or killed shortly after 9/11? Oh. She was killed herself about a month or so after stating this revelation on the David Frost's show.


Sandy NS
said
0 0

When Clinton was in power , he had plenty of chances .Remember the bombing of the SS cole? well Clinton did nothng! he was umm way too busy


Bill in BC
said
0 0

Find him and I'll pay the $2.11 for the bullet. Just end it already.


reece
said
0 0

The news reports at that time stated that a very tall man fitting Osama's description was mortally wounded on that mountain years ago. Ever since that report, Osama never made a video appearance. The only video of him that came out was quickly denounced as fake by British Intel. After that, only audio recordings. Audio recordings only? Apparently camcorders are hard to come by in that part of the country. Osama is DEAD and I promise each of you readers that he will never make a video recording EVER again. That's it!


I. M. Wright
said
0 0

Maybe he crashed the White House dinner party. US security command forces would never know.Ha ha ha. USA is a joke.


Robert in Courtice
said
0 0

I still think Bin Laden was obliterated by USAF B-52's at Tora Bora.They blew that area back to the stone-age and re-arranged entire mountain ranges.Stories of him "escaping to Pakistan" are just that--stories. No one person could possibly hide this long without someone leaking his whereabouts,especially someone with an ego as big as his.No credible trace of him has been found since Tora Bora.


Zhimmy
said
0 0

Isn't this like talking about the fish that got away around the campfire years later? The real question is where is he now and how has he been able to make such a mockery of us all! Let's remember people all the people that died on 9/11 and that 25 of them were Canadians! Its an afront that this man is still walking around the planet today!


Steve
said
0 0

Ladin has been dead since 2001 when the US Air Force destroyed Tora Bora. Wake up sheep!!!This war is about a natural gas pipeline and nothing more.Once you sheep figure that out maybe you'll come to terms with the fact Bush and Cheney orchestrated 9/11,


Big Papa
said
0 0

A bigger question is, if he were caught shortly after 911, what do you do with him? Execute him and make him a martyr?Perhaps put him in jail and at the first opportunity have his pals (In Iran, Syria, etc...) negotiate for his release?Or perhaps the real strategy is to try to catch him long after 911, and hopefully he will have disappeared from the the arab consiousness.In the meatime he could lead the americans to his terrorist buddies I am starting to believe the American military machine could have caught him if they really wanted to.


Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz