Top Stories -   

Top diplomat denies torture coverup allegations

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV National News: Craig Oliver in Ottawa
Canada's former top bureaucrat in Afghanistan testified at a House of Commons special committee on Thursday, denying allegations that he prevented reports warning of the abuse of detainees transferred to Afghan prisons by Canadian soldiers.
CTV News Channel: David Mulroney testifies, one
Ottawa's former top diplomat in Afghanistan denies allegations that his office tried to cover up reports on the detainee torture issue at a commons special committee on Afghanistan.
CTV News Channel: David Mulroney testifies, two
Ottawa's former top diplomat in Afghanistan explains the detainee transfer arrangement Canada had with Afghanistan at a House of Commons special committee on Afghanistan.
Power Play: Graeme Smith, The Globe and Mail
The testimony responding to the detainee torture allegations brought forth by former diplomat Richard Colvin took a more sober tone on Thursday, but there are still some frightening aspects to the government's narrative.
Power Play: MPS discuss the testimony
Liberal MP Bob Rae, NDP MP Jack Harris and Conservative MP Laurie Hawn discuss the testimony of diplomat David Mulroney in relation to the concerns of former diplomat Richard Colvin.
Power Play: Was detainee abuse common knowledge?
Paul Champ of Amnesty Inernational and Ottawa University's Nipa Banerjee talk about the problems in Afghanistan Diplomat David Mulroney spoke of in regards to the country's justice system.
Question period: Liberals questions government
Liberal Foreign Affairs Minister Bob Rae and Liberal MP Ujjal Dosanjh criticize the government for not calling on a public inquiry on Afghan detainees and accuse the Tories of having something to hide.
Question period: Bloc leader questions government
Bloc Quebecois leader Gilles Duceppe questions why the opposition have not received torture reports for security reasons, while former military officers received the reports.
CTV News Channel: Robert Fife from Ottawa
CTV's Ottawa bureau chief says the testimony of Rick Hillier will have a major impact on the case after Hillier denied receiving notification from Richard Colvin that Afghan Detainees were being tortured in Afghan Prisons.
Canada AM: Maj. Gen. Lewis Mackenzie
Canada's former top Generals contradict the testimony of top diplomat Richard Colvin. A military analyst weighs in on the testimony and where the facts and the alleged documents could be.

Font-size: Bigger  Smaller  Share Share Print Print

Photos

Slideshow image

View Larger Image

CTV.ca News Staff

Date: Thu. Nov. 26 2009 6:31 PM ET

Ottawa's former top diplomat in Afghanistan has denied claims that officials covered up reports that outlined the torture risk Afghan detainees faced when they were transferred to local authorities.

However, David Mulroney said that the government was in fact aware that torture reports were surfacing in 2006.

"The fact that there were allegations of mistreatment in Afghan prisons was known to us," Mulroney told a parliamentary committee.

Still, he stressed that there was little alternative to transferring detainees as Canadian troops were facing heavy fighting with the Taliban. Resources in the country were further stretched by the "chaotic" situation on the ground at the time.

Mulroney was responding to allegations made by diplomat Richard Colvin who has said that he repeatedly warned his superiors that abuse and torture was endemic in the Afghan justice system.

Colvin, who was second-in-command in Afghanistan between 2006 and 2007, has also said that he was told to keep quiet about the torture allegations.

Still, Mulroney said his office knew about Afghanistan's problems and worked to ensure that the country's justice system was held to international standards.

"The possibility of mistreatment could not be ignored," Mulroney told a parliamentary committee in Ottawa.

"We did not ignore it."

Mulroney noted that despite the torture reports, there was no firm proof that it was prisoners who had been transferred by Canadians that were the victims of the abuse.

However, he added that Canada's monitoring system -- created in 2005 -- may not have been sufficient at the time. The policy was changed in 2007 to improve oversight of Afghanistan's justice system.

Mulroney added that Colvin's reports "have left the impression that I discouraged honest reporting about the situation in Afghanistan."

"This is simply not true."

Colvin was second in command to Mulroney at the Canadian embassy in Afghanistan during the time in which the torture allegedly occurred.

"The view that I muzzled him or any other official is wrong," he said.

On Wednesday, Canada's former top soldier Gen. Rick Hillier denied that officials would have turned over Afghan detainees if they were aware of torture allegations.

Hillier, quoting intelligence reports from 2006 and 2007, said there was no clear evidence of repeated torture in Afghanistan's jails. He also called Colvin's testimony "ludicrous."

Hillier's comments were echoed by other military officials, including retired general Michel Gauthier and Maj.-Gen. David Fraser, who said that they did not receive torture reports until the spring of 2007.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Facebook

Share this article with Facebook

DIGG

Share this article with Digg

Newsvine

Share this article with Newsvine

Delicious

Share this article with delicious

Email

Share this article.
Send Email

Twitter

Share this article with Twitter

StumbleUpon

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Reddit

Share this article with Reddit

Yahoo! Buzz

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz

Most Talked about Stories

Naturally coming on the heels of the Gulf event, this will be jumped on by all involved with both feet and there will be no lack of criticism regardless of who does what. If they had of had it cleaned up within 24 hours, the governor would complain that nobody consulted her on how to do it. A no win situation. I seriously doubt that anyone is deliberately dragging their heels on this, it's too high profile.

Pugfire

Michigan governor criticizes oil spill clean-up effort