CTV News | New citizenship guide big on military, small on arts

Politics -   

New citizenship guide big on military, small on arts

Viewer

CTV News Video

Canada AM: Rudyard Griffiths, advisory board
A man who sat on the advisory board for the new citizenship guide outlines some of the changes and describes which info previous guides did not include.
CTV National News: Robert Fife on the new guide
The Harper government has overhauled the guidebook for preparing immigrants for their Canadian citizenship tests. The book puts a greater focus on Canada's history and symbols.
Power Play: Jason Kenney, immigration minister
According to Canada's immigration minister, Canada is suffering from 'historical amnesia,' which is why the guidebook for new Canadians must establish essential facts on Canada.
Power Play: Does the guidebook help immigrants?
Rudyard Griffiths of the Munk Debates and Sima Sahar Zerehi of Status Now discuss whether or not the new guidebook will actually help immigrants to integrate into Canadian society.
CTV News Channel: Marc Chalifoux, VP
The executive vice president of the Historica Dominion Institute says the new information makes substantive changes to the guide, and can be the basic toolkit new immigrants need to become part of the system.

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(25)

Photos

Slideshow image

View Larger Image

CTV.ca News Staff

Date: Thu. Nov. 12 2009 9:41 PM ET

Canada's new citizenship guide for aspiring immigrants places a new emphasis on the military, the history of Confederation and First Nations but also finds room to mention hockey and curling.

Immigration Minister Jason Kenney says the new study guide -- about 20 pages longer than the previous one -- promotes "a greater understanding of Canada's history, values, symbols and important Canadian institutions, such as Parliament and the Crown."

"(There's) a growing consensus that we need to recover a sense of civic memory, civic literacy about our democratic institutions and the history in which they are rooted," Kenney said.

The new 62-page document, entitled "Discover Canada: The Rights and Responsibilities of Citizenship," is the first substantive update since the study guide for those taking the Canadian citizenship test was introduced in 1995.

Kenney says the new version is more comprehensive in its promotion of Canadian values, such as freedom, democracy and human rights. There is also special emphasis on the country's view of equality between men and women.

Only a few pages into the guide, it says: "Canada's openness and generosity do not extend to barbaric cultural practices that tolerate spousal abuse, 'honour killings,' female genital mutilation or other gender-based violence."

"Those guilty of these crimes are severely punished under Canada's criminal laws."

The guide covers much of the major points of Canadian history from early Aboriginal settlements, the War of 1812 to Canada's contributions in both World Wars.

It also encourages immigrants to be proud of Canada's military and says the Canadian Forces is "a noble way to contribute to Canada and an excellent career choice."

The guide says there are three "founding people" - Aboriginals, French and English.

It also doesn't shrink from Canada's ill treatment of its aboriginals, including residential schools.

"From the 1800s until the 1980s, the federal government placed many Aboriginal children in residential schools to educate and assimilate them into mainstream Canadian culture.

"The schools were poorly funded and inflicted hardship on the students; some students were physically abused. Aboriginal languages and cultural practices were mostly prohibited. In 2008, Ottawa formally apologized to the former students," the guide states.

Multiculturalism and social programs

The guide speaks of the importance of Canadian multiculturalism in modern society.

It says Canada's largest religion is Christianity but adds the number of "Muslims, Jews, Hindus, Sikhs, and members of other religions, including atheists, are also growing."

However, the guide makes no mention of gay marriage in Canada and the only mention of Canada's gays and lesbians is in a photo caption of Olympic gold medalist Mark Tewksbury.

Universal health care and other social programs such as Employment Insurance and the Canadian Pension Plan are also discussed.

The arts and sport

Interestingly, the section titled "Arts and Culture in Canada" makes no mention of Canadian music -- despite international success stories like Neil Young, Celine Dion and The Arcade Fire. Canadian novelists are also looked over.

Canadian television gets a mention in the art section but no specific programs are named. However, Denys Arcand, Norman Jewison and Atom Egoyan are listed as "noteworthy Canadian filmmakers."

Sport in Canadian society is also promoted.

"Hockey is Canada's most popular spectator sport and is considered to be the national winter sport," the document states. "Canadian football is the second most popular sport. Curling, an ice game introduced by Scottish pioneers, is popular."

Controversially, Wayne Gretzky is listed only as "one of the greatest hockey players of all time."

Not just for immigrants

Kenney said that he's concerned about the "historical amnesia" of young Canadians and the guide can be used by those who are already citizens.

"We see polls that indicate the majority of young Canadians can't identify our first prime minister, or the battle of Vimy Ridge. I think this is responding to a growing public demand for a deep sense of citizenship," he said.

"I want to reinforce this is not just a resource for new citizens, it's hopefully a useful resource for all Canadians, particularly young Canadians."

The new guide was produced in consultation with such experts as former governor-general Adrienne Clarkson, military historian Jack Granatstein, ret-gen. John de Chastelain and historian Margaret MacMillan.

Comments are now closed for this story

Garry in NS
said
0 0

This is an excellent start. Now, if we could only educate Canadians about Canada. I also think that a greater emphasis/discussion should have taken place regarding gay/lesbian rights in Canada. Many immigrants arrive from countries where homosexuality is punishable by prison or even death. Making mention of our military traditions is excellent. Many immigrants arrive from countries where the military is feared.


allan
said
0 0

Sounds reasonable to me to have knowledge of Canada in order to live in this great country. The only requirement under the Liberal governments were for the immigrants to learn how to get welfare and use the system.


Nov 12 comment
said
0 0

Tories trying to create another wedge issue. the subtext to all of this is "we're doing our best to keep 'those' people out....."Pathetic!


Ron Vachiyer
said
0 0

"controversially"? What is controversial about mentioning Wayne Gretzky as the great one?


Ryder in CANADA
said
0 0

A fantastic idea!!! I would also add that there should be more emphasis put on the history of the RCMP as well. And to finish it off, you should only allow ONE passport! This would deter any convienient Canadians that get a Canadian Passport and then move away for years on end only to demand help when their original country is attacked.


simon
said
0 0

A Shift from Liberal values to Conservative values???????????????Three races. Aboriginals, French and English........No Irish !!!!!, No Scots !!!!!, No Germans !!!!!, No Russian !!!!!, No Chinese !!!! etc. Etc.No Gay rights !!!!!ART without Music, Theater and TV.......Is there anything that the Tories can do without PARTISAN Politics??????We know about the Tory stimulus checks...We know about the Tory commercials on the Economic Plan..We know about the Tory Reno rebates....We know about the Tory Olympics......Now we shall get Tory immigrants !!!!!!!!!!


Michael
said
0 0

Good ...and while they are at it they need to ask hard questions about preserving our culture and heritage and how it came to be that the idiot fringe introduced "political correctness" which has done more to screw up Canada rich heritage than anything else.


Dan Thody Calgary
said
0 0

I am glad there is mentioned we speak English French and Aborigional here. If they want to be Canadian speak the language. Unfortunatly many immigrants are here to take advantave of our lax criminal system and are not here to be Canadian. As soon as they becom citizens they go back to thier country and only come back when thier dated ways cause war etc.


Adam in Ottawa
said
0 0

There is likely no mention of gay marriage in the guide as | am sure that the Conservatives will be revoking it just as soon as it is possible for them to do so. They can either start a smear campaign like they did for the gun registry or just wait until they feel they have the upper hand and force it through Parliament. Obviously I'm not a Conservative supporter, but as long as they are in any position of power I'm glad to be a heterosexual WASP! All that aside, there is nothing wrong with both prospective and current citizens of this country learning more about it's history. We all could probably use a refresher course in Canadian history!


Intelligent Liberal
said
0 0

This is ridiculous Con waste of taxpayer money. IGGY has proven you can live in the US for decades and still become the next PRIME Minister of Canada!


KD
said
0 0

I was watching your show power play today and I ashamed by your guest Sima Sahar Zerehi. I can't believe that she is against the guide having links to the military as well as it teaching the history of Canada military. Canada has a proud military history and anyone who wants to become Canadian should have to know our history. And lets not forget that during WWI most of the Canadian Military were newly Canadian or the first generation born in Canada. If a person wants to become a Canadian they should also want to preserve and protect what makes it such a great country and that seems to go against what ever Sima Sahar Zerehi opinion of what Canadian is. She also was saying that the policy is to hard for people that don't speak either of our national languages and is more like an university course. Isn't that the point shouldn't we want our knew Canadians to be people that are educated and can contribute to society. It has happened to often in the past few decades that we have been excepting other countries criminals and gang members. Why shouldn't want the Doctors Lawyers and trades people instead of the people that other countries don't want.


Frank Buchan
said
0 0

I love arts, and culture is vital, but when did it even become a government's job to promote these aspects of society? Sate-supported arts are about as useful as a spoon is to dig a tunnel through granite. Unless they grow, by organic means, all artistic endeavours collapse into entropy, and the swiftest way to crush artistic expression is to make it a tertiary function of the state. You can extend the same to sports, and all entertainments, and it's proof that we have far too much government. We would be better off as a society if we had these systems performing to meet core needs rather than pandering to interest groups, large or small.


charlie
said
0 0

While you could always argue that this item or that is not covered sufficientlt/covered too extensively, etc., from the report, this seems a remarkably well balanced presentation. Welcome to Canada, here we are, blemishes and all, this is where and who we are and how we got here, and how things are done in contemportary Canadian society. I don't see any politicization of issues and attempts to spin this in that direction are misguided.


Peter in MB
said
0 0

Canada should do what Finland has done.End this multe cultural B.S. Why because after 50 years of trying Finland discovered that multeculturalism dose not work. 3ed and 4th generation immigrant that can’t speak one of the official languages. (English or Finnish), immigrant Gang problems and people declaring refugee Statius and leaching off the system. Much like Canada immigration problems today. Their solution you need to be fluent in one of the official languages, you must have skills to be employable. And you must know some history of the country and its constitution and laws. You are also on 3 year probation. If you commit a criminal offence you will get sent back to the place you came from. After all you all supposedly leaving your country and coming here for a better life are you not? not to bring you gang wars and racisms into our country.


pdm
said
0 0

Guides such as this should be developed by an arms length group which has no bias in presenting the astounding overiew of Canada today. This would ensure that every aspect of our history, cultures, languages, arts, citizenship, rights, politics, military could be covered without anyone having to be suspect of political leanings. Governments should know this by now. I just keep wondering why Canadians, who are a smart and educated people, put up with this waste of resources and simple minded approach by politicians. We deserve so much better on so many fronts.


MD
said
0 0

This makes me very happy to hear. This is a great stepping stone to re-unifying Canada after so many years of self hating government policies from the liberals. We're proud of our country, we're proud of our history, you marxists out there will never take it away from us!


Patrick
said
0 0

This is still a drop in the bucket. When I took the exam 11 years ago, I had the impression that the Canadian government didn't place much value on Canadian citizenship. The test itself consisted of 20 no-brainer questions. There was nothing about civics: an understanding of the Constitution or the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, how parliament works, how the legal system works, etc. It was even OK if a candidate couldn't communicate in one of the official languages well enough to take the test. They made a civil servant available to interpret body language and garbled speech. Let's have potential citizens demonstrate their commitment to Canada by requiring them to understand how really special it is.


Peter 1951
said
0 0

The lady that spoke on Powerplay today, Sima Sahar Zerehi also siad that canda should give "FREE" language classes to people when they come to this country. But as a Canadian who has live here all of my life 58 years if I want to learn to speak french I have to pay. I think what we have to do in this country is teach people Canada isn't just about a "FREE" hand out.


stevo
said
0 0

What's the problem with Wayne Gretzky listed as one of the greatest players. There is not unanimous agreement on his status as the greatest ever. I personally think Bobby Orr was a better player.


Tony
said
0 0

The guide should also stress that if anyone wants to be called Canadian he/she must be willing to embrace our values and culture. We should not have to adapt to outside retarded ways nor should we have to put up with religious fanatics, for example. I also dislike the fact that once people get their Canadian passport, they go back to their countries and only reach out to Canada when they are in trouble...guess who pays to get them out of trouble? WE do! There should be more restrictions because becoming a citizen of this great country is not a right it is a privilege!


Yie in Ottawa
said
0 0

I took the test 15 years ago. I never read the book but I had an ample amount of knowledge learned through school and practical involvement in the community. I had asked a Canadian, by birth, a few years ago about the last province to join. The answer given was BC in 1905. I told him it was Nfld in 1948. I was ridiculed by a few Canadians around at that time. Let's focus on educating Canadians about Canada, too. Too many Canadians have the misperception of Canada being similar to US with right to bare arms, etc. Misguided? Just ignorant perhaps.I don't know like how the Tories are labelling this book as a Tory Government's citizenship book and the previous as the Liberal Government's citizenship book. There is only one federal government and that is a Canadian government. Don't make an unnecessary distinction. That implies that new Canadians as a result of this publication are citizens to a specific political party.


Irritable Canadian
said
0 0

I am THRILLED with the new Citizenship Guide... and as for the snarky CTV headline about the guide being small on "arts"... let me just say that ballet dancers, painters and others in the "arts" are not the reason for my freedom, nor do I see any of these "artists" fighting for freedom in Afghanistan or Iraq. Nope, it's the "artists" (read: NDP and Liberal and Green Party support groups and advocacy networks) that dump all over anything that portends to represent what Canada is really about -- including a VERY strong and proud military history. And I'm da*n proud as a Canadian to finally have a government willing to stand up for our proud past and highlight it as opposed to shoveling under the rug and making up a false history of politically correct pap. I'm also proud to finally see the Forces being given the respect in the present that they so richly deserve.Oh -- and I'm very happy to see the Queen featured. About time we sluffed off this Trudeau-era avoidance of the fact that we are a successful and PROUD constitutional monarchy in a parliamentary democracy.GOD BLESS THE CANADIAN FORCES AND GOD SAVE THE QUEEN!Thank you Prime Minister.


Prof. Pye Chartt
said
0 0

As long as we're randomly picking and choosing (in a delightfully annoying, bureaucratic, and nonsensical fashion) a bunch of lame stereotypical tidbits and politically correct cultural notions, why not make reference to the back-bacon sandwich, too? Yummy...and so Canadian. Geez.P.S. Who the heck is The Arcade Fire?! (Are they street musicians who play in the Toronto subway system?)


Ian
said
0 0

When will you anti-tory crybabies just stop. Not happy about anything. You must live miserable lives. the guide is 100 times better than anything we've had before.


Ian
said
0 0

Hey Intelligent Liberal, please explain exactly how IGGY has proven that you can live in the US for a decade and still become the PM. the last time I checked Harper lived at 24 Sussex not IGGY. I think you should change you name!


Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz

Most Talked about Stories

The chance of the destruction of our planet is very very small with this collider, but who are these people to decide what risks are acceptable for all of mankind? It puts me at unease and adds to my anxiety. CERN acknowledges that there are miniscule risks -- they admit to it so please spare the convoluted retorts.

kc-bby

Hadron Collider back in action after year of repairs