News Sections
Michael Jackson and the false narrative phenomenon
Font-size:
Share
Print
Comments(100)
By: Josh Visser, CTV.ca News
Date: Wed. Jul. 8 2009 9:01 PM ET
It has been hours since Michael Jackson's funeral, but is it too soon to ask, "Can society have its sanity back?"
The global mourning and hysteria surrounding Jackson's death surpasses the grief and accolades given to Princess Diana when she died, and you really have to go back to Elvis Presley's 1977 death for such a reaction.
But here's the rub: Three weeks ago, Jackson was seen by most people as a joke at best; or another rich celebrity who got away with horrible crimes, at worst.
This is not to say Jackson didn't have his fans. Tens of thousands of people bought tickets for 50 comeback shows planned in London. But outside of his adoring hardcore fans, people wouldn't be caught dead wearing his T-shirts even ironically.
But in death, all that changed. The media in particular, and society at large, seemed to develop a mass amnesia -- the last 18 years of lacklustre musical output, the criminal allegations and civil settlements, and the just plain weirdness was forgotten.
Instead it was all about his incredible musical genius and tremendous showmanship -- a run that lasted from 1979's "Off the Wall" to "Bad" in 1987. Despite what you may think of the man, you can't deny the sheer awesomeness of songs like "Beat It" and "Billie Jean" -- songs that broke the colour barrier on MTV and still inspire random dance parties.
But for people under 30, Jackson has been "Wacko Jacko" for the majority of their lives, which is why I find it stunningly bizarre when I hear 20-somethings talking about the singular importance of Jackson's music to them. Especially weird, when I have never heard them once express that sentiment when MJ was alive.
I'm not the only person who has seen this mass "narrative revision," but I fear there are only a select few of us who have noticed -- like when Roddy Piper wears the sunglasses in John Carpenter's "They Live" and sees that half the people around him are really aliens in disguise.
Pop contrarian and author Chuck Klosterman also appears to wearing the MJ-charade exposing sunglasses. In an interview with ESPN's Bill Simmons just days after Jackson's death, he dared challenge the new-MJ worldview.
"Where have all these people been for 25 years? He's been an object of ridicule for almost two decades," Klosterman posed. "I understand people saying great things about him after he died . . . he was this iconic, brilliant musician . . . but what I think is weird, is all these people creating this false narrative about their relationship to his music.
"Go on Facebook now . . . and you see all these people talking about how "Thriller" was the soundtrack to their life . . . How come no one has mentioned this for a decade? It's almost like they watch television, see it's a big moment and they really want to feel like they are a part of this experience. It's so curious."
The false narrative phenomenon
Even U.S. President Barack Obama seems to have spotted the phenomena.
"There are certain figures in our popular culture that just capture peoples' imagination, and in death they become even larger. I have to admit that it's also fed by a 24/7 media that is insatiable," he told CBS.
The new-life after death for pop stars is hardly new. Tupac and Biggie Smalls were both hailed as rap pioneers much more in death than they ever were in life.
As Klosterman has pointed out in one of his books, everyone seems to forget that when Kurt Cobain killed himself in 1994, Pearl Jam was much more popular, both commercially and critically, than Nirvana. But after Cobain died, Nirvana flew into a beloved orbit and has never come back down.
But with Jackson's death, the first real important cultural figure of the Facebook/Twitter age to die, this entire "false narrative" phenomenon seems to have gone into hyper drive. No one has a story too small about what Jackson meant to them, even if in the 1980s their cassette players were only playing Boy George or Motley Crue.
The hyperbole culminated at Jackson's memorial with the Rev. Al Sharpton, giving the pop singer partial credit for paving the way for Obama's election. Okay, Jackson accomplished a great many things but of the bazillion reasons given for Obama election victory eight months ago, I don't think anyone ever mentioned, "Well, the King of Pop helped."
Why do we rewrite our histories in death? We do it for our gone-too-young celebrities and politicians, but we also do it for the regular people in our lives -- choosing to remember only the good -- rather than an accurate portrait of a person.
There was only one Michael Jackson -- there wasn't a brilliant entertainer who existed until 1987 and then his freakish clone who dabbled in plastic surgery, and spent some his time showing, at best, incredibly poor judgment around children.
You can choose to only remember his music -- in fact, you're probably best off for it. But let's not misremember his legacy, like we have for a dozen other artists. In life, Jackson won more accolades than any other artist in history, in death, he doesn't deserve any new ones created in our collective minds.
User Tools
Related Stories
In Pictures
CTV News Video Player
Dancing in the street
'Flash mob' takes over the streets in Montreal with amazing performance art in honour of the late Michael Jackson.
In Depth
User Tools
About the tools
Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.
-


Font-size
Print Article
Comments(100)-
Feedback
Share it with your network of friends
Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.
Most Viewed News Stories
Most Talked about Stories
This is a moral test for voters in the municipal election. Electing him will be a stamp of approval for his actions. I strongly believe that the first thoughts should be for the person he has publicly humiliated, his partner. By his conduct he has made of himself, merely, a footnote in the election.








Comments are now closed for this story
Yvon Loiselle
0
said
0
annette huneaiult
0
said
0
Louise in Utopia
0
said
0
I hope that the funeral yesterday humanized him as a man, father, brother and son who was loved and now will be missed.
I grew up with the Jackson 5 and Michael Jackson - their music was great and ground breaking. A wonderful legacy.
Does it hurt to remember the good? What good does it do to dwell on the faults?
Don DesChamps
0
said
0
Kelley in Edmonton
0
said
0
ENOUGH! Get back to the real world and news that is important to all of us!
ymseatte
0
said
0
Gary Michaels
0
said
0
The MJ hysteria has him all but walking on water and healing the blind.
Al Sharpton has rewritten much of US history to suit his own agenda. This is just another example.
There were so many "Kings" spoken about yesterday I got confused. MLK "the king" Elvis "the king" MJ "the king" Jesus "the king"
there are already reports of MJ sightings .
gimme a break already !!
Robert Harris
0
said
0
Mischa in TN
0
said
0
Shawn Holmes, Oshawa, Ontario
0
said
0
jossie
0
said
0
I can't stand these reverends with their jibberish. Michael aided in the election of Barack Obama? That's a delusional statement.
This MJ stuff should all be laid to rest now.
P in AB
0
said
0
Then you should have included noting how a young african american family living in Gary, Indiana chose to live a dream at a time where these opportunities were not even contemplated by black america. You should have considered how in spite of what most would deem to be insurmountable obstacles a young boy never abandoned his dream for stardom. Perhaps you should also note how he achieved a Guiness World Record for charitable contributions.
Perhaps you believe his legacy was his music? No, his music was a tool by which he accomplished his legacy as a human, breaking barriers, helping those in need.
In order to facilitate this he gave all of himself to the public, including his childhood. And yes he has had questionable activities.
What have you done for your brothers and sisters lately? Once your life is perfect go ahead, start your criticism.
rrp
0
said
0
rrp
0
said
0
you are 100% correct thats all so true !! well put!
Scott
0
said
0
That's what a funeral is all about. It's a false narrative. This one is just magnified a million times.
The passage of time will put things in perspective. It always does.
By the way, I love how it's become cool to say "please stop with the coverage". You just clicked on this story. You just read the story. You just read this comment. If "enough is enough", why are you even on this page?
"Billions of hits (of the internet variety) can't be wrong!"
johanne
0
said
0
MC QC
0
said
0
wanda boldebuck
0
said
0
(From a summer Yooper in Sault Ste Marie)
Lorette C. Luzajic
0
said
0
I'd also like to argue that MJ's more recent music was vastly underrated, and though his lyrics were either saccharine or immature, his genius didn't end with Thriller. Dangerous was always one of my faves- Give in to Me is brilliant. Other dark stuff like Blood on the Dance Floor, Scream, Morphine, Stranger in Moscow...killer. Will You Be There is gospel heaven. Break of Dawn, Speechless, Heaven Can Wait, Butterflies,Earth Song- I think it's time you dusted off your albums, too, and refresh your memory.
That said, I wrote about this exact phenomenon in my book, in an essay called The Perpetuation of Human Sacrifice Traditions in Popular Culture. Just like the complicit victim in ancient sacrifice rituals, dying in front of a culture makes the dead immortal. Being left on a mountaintop in the Andes, hurtled over Niagara Falls, no matter- you became a god. So it is with our tragic stars- Marilyn, Diana, Elvis, James Dean, Kurt Cobain, Jim Morrison, and MJ. And Jackson, who WAS the biggest entertainer of all time, however reviled he may have been, is of course hugely immortalized.
These patterns of myth making.. simply human nature.
David Chan
0
said
0
Germaine in Mtl
0
said
0
RIP MJ - if they'll let you...
Pat
0
said
0
Chicken
0
said
0
Who wants to bet that there is some silly subsection in his will that specifies his brain be frozen for future use.
Terri in Brantford
0
said
0
Sadly, I do think he had some sort of mental illness and don't think any illness should be ridiculed.
Jimmy
0
said
0
MJ..NEVER, EVER stopped identifying himself as a black man. Watch his videos!
All of them are pre-dominantly black. Thriller, Beat it, Bad, Do you Remember the Time all showcasing black people.
If MJ were to have turned "white" as the Peanut Gallery here professes....then why were his videos the opposite?
So what if he had kids with a white woman! A lot of black guys do. Heck black women have kids with white men! Racial barriers are gone...get over it!
Research Vitaligo and Lupus..it CAN remove skin pigment. Notice how Latoya has fairer skin????
Sheesh!
Rest in Peace MJ....with Mozart, Elvis, Cobain, Morrison, Hendrix and others in heaven it should be one heck of a concert!
You did pave the way for many!
C
0
said
0
smkeel
0
said
0
After all, he was tried and acquitted. Does that mean absolutely NOTHING to you? If that's how you all think then we are not the great United States of America. Not yet.
Mark
0
said
0
Mary
0
said
0
Will
0
said
0
There are also very very many who did not believe the ALLEGATIONS and never will. I don't see how anyone can judge as they have never lived in the showbiz eye, never gone throught what another has. This is only your opinion and much to your surprise ,not shared by everyone,
meerkat
0
said
0
Just sayin....
Ronald Meaghan
0
said
0
DJ
0
said
0
Sorrow
0
said
0
...still dealing...hope that he'll find peace at last. He deserves it.
Brandon Lee
0
said
0
Your facts are not correct. You say irrelevent 18 years when michael was doing his best work through 1997, where HIStory sold 40,000,000 units world wide, and is the best selling multi disc album of all time. In 2001 he had a #1 album, Invincible which did ok, going platnum and selling approx 10 million records with NO PROMOTIONAL ASSISTANCE from sony. His concerts @ O2 did not sell 10's of thousands....it sold over ONE MILLION TICKETS, to which 99% sold out in 45 mins., and a complete sell out in 4 hours.
Make no mistake about it Mr. V, the things that everyone is saying about Michael Jackson may make you feel angry inside, and you may have never even known that he was all that he is, but for you to try to say they are crediting him in vain is a travesty. IMO, they are not saying ENOUGH of what he has done in this world.
Where I agree with you is that the people who are coming out of the woodwork and supporting him now would not have done it when he was alive... I payed the price of being ridiculed for listening to MJ and supporting him through all of this. The sheep hated him, now the sheep love him... what can you do about that? Nothing man... let it rest, let him rest...
Emma Price
0
said
0
I agree with the comment below. Can we have some real news? I mean, let's live in the now people.
jessica
0
said
0
RIP Michael.
John Calgary
0
said
0
Bob in Ottawa
0
said
0
Not sure how these examples were the result of dealing with strange people?
Peter L
0
said
0
donna
0
said
0
M.U
0
said
0
He was just a great person who believed in humanity and created some of the best music. I'm over 30 and I "pop-ed" to his hits.
Ryodan
0
said
0
Do you know where this expression came from? Ha ha.. and who is to say the Holy One actually did walk on water or heal the blind? Do you accept that those stories too are myths propagated after his death?
Linda
0
said
0
That's the problem these days. People rely on what they do not know or what they are told by those who do not know and before you know it nobody knows anything and that's what get broadcasted or printed by the media. Stick to the facts, not what you think or want to think to make a story !
Glenn Alexander
0
said
0
If three weeks ago you'd have let a 10 yr old male child of yours stay over at Michael Jackson's home overnight, unsupervised, and with no thought or worry as to his safety, then truly you can lay claim to being a true fan and grieve away.
If on the other hand, that thought would've caused you concern, sufficient enough to intervene and/or prevent that child from going, and yet now you have found yourself caught up in the hype and immortalizing him as some sort of demi-god, well then "Huston we have a problem!"
Whatever your personal thoughts about the man's personal life may have been, the undeniable truth is that his mark on music and entertainment are permanent.
There are 2 schools of thought, clearly. One is that he was a deviant who managed to wriggle free, the other is that is innocent and he was unjustly maligned.
What I find of curious interest is how so many upstanding celebrities, who claim to have known him personally, staunchly believe he was innocent.
A good friend of mine said it best "it's not so hard to bring down a celebrity, 5 mins alone with them and then you can say anything happened"
It is also just as true that money can sometimes buy justice.
I don't have a clue anymore what is true, with Jordan Chandler (the first accuser) now recanting and with a few of the jurors on the second trial going public with their thoughts of MJ being totally innocent.
But I do know this. I count myself in the second group of people, since a few weeks ago, I would have stopped my nephew from an overnight visit with MJ.
So today I acknowledge the man, his talent and his contributions, period. RIP
mj-fan
0
said
0
Wayne Crawford
0
said
0
Charlotte
0
said
0
Mel
0
said
0
Why didn't people mention how much they enjoyed his music until now? Perhaps we were too embarrassed to admit it. Anyone who speaks out on his behalf is ridiculed on the basis that he was morally not deserving or because his talent was lightweight.
I think that the media has really advanced the narrative that he was so weird. Are you angry because that narrative wasn't repeated at the memorial service? Perhaps white Canadians are not in the best position to judge how important a figure he was in breaking down the colour barrier.
There was so much speculation about him and there were so many outright lies made up about him. Even now, the "serious allegations" keep getting brought up as though they were fact. Not only was he acquitted but those that actually looked into the case were left scratching their heads as to how it proceeded with so little evidence.
We do not know what accounted for the change in his skin colour or the reasons for his change in appearance. Doctors have confirmed his diagnosis of Vitiligo and Lupus.
Some may enjoy performances by Mick Jagger and Keith Richards. It's just a difference in taste. I don't think Michael Jackson looked any creepier than those two aging characters. They seem to be forgiven for their womanizing, hard-living, illicit drug taking. How about some understanding for Michael Jackson.
Warren
0
said
0
Monika Daoust
0
said
0
Last night, when I looked at a shelf in a gas station, five out of the six magazines had Michael Jackson on the cover, with two of them being the MJ tribute issues. Of course, death is always a bestseller, but the last two weeks of mass hysteria may as well be a media experiment. Just cashing in for the last time on the Jacko phenomenon? Not that it's hard to sell anything right now. The public that's so easily amused by Jon and Kate, Dancing with the Stars or some other nonsense will jump on just about anything.
The notion that the volume of ticket sales is indicative of quality gives me a headache. The Backstreet Boys concert in Winnipeg was sold out, too. Does it mean they're awesome and deserve a "larger than life" treatment?
You know what they say... "Millions of flies can't be wrong -- eat s***!"
Seriously though, I am glad to know that even though the majority of people are seriously mourning the passing of this "great genius," others remember the entire MJ personality.
Yes, he probably spent his entire life chasing the childhood he never had. Yet, Bubbles, and Neverland Ranch aside,no amount of money or fame should suffice as an excuse to hanging out with children in questionable circumstances. And, personally would anyone settle out of court with millions of dollars if fully innocent?
Jason QC.
0
said
0
donny
0
said
0
jaz
0
said
0
A little humility and empathy are in order.. get it??
MRC in Ontario
0
said
0
SF
0
said
0
D
0
said
0
I think he has helped with racial barriers, but I don't think he was instrumental in breaking them or electing Obama, to say that is ridiculous. This takes away from the Civil Rights workers in the 60's, Rosa Parks and other African Americans who fought harder and more valiantly, those are the people who paved the way for Mr. Obama, Michaela Jackson, and women. As for being the greatest entertainer, he was one among many greats and there were ones before him who sang, choreographed routines and are as every bit entertaining and in essence paved the way for him.
lynn ottawa
0
said
0
Lev-Tov (Lev) ZOHAR
0
said
0
Sab
0
said
0
Shark
0
said
0
KJ in Kingston Ontario
0
said
0
While this might be a fairly harmless BIG LIE -- there's a real BIG RISK that other fabrications and delusions might not be so harmless. It almost has a religious quality.
merikagu
0
said
0
steve
0
said
0
Llora
0
said
0
I know he was a brother, father, friend, son, etc. But what makes him any more special than these other brothers, friends, sons, fathers?
SAD. Pathetic.
pokes
0
said
0
merikagu
0
said
0
Karen
0
said
0
I believe it human nature to dwell on the positive attributes of the dearly departed, perhaps left over lessons from our childhood - "If you don't have anything nice to say, don't say anything at all".
I tried tuning in to the public memorial service, but found it far too grotesque and phony to watch it in its entirety. It was equivalent to sitting through a poorly acted movie. Who ever heard of a casket at a Memorial Service?
Yes indeed "mass amnesia"!
James Lee
0
said
0
Elvis was big but not a great worldwide.
Jackson's legacy influenced culture in a great way
Connie Agos
0
said
0
Steve G
0
said
0
Zand
0
said
0
I like a few of his songs, and will own up to that (I'm laughed at more for the fact of which songs I like rather than admitting it was MJ who sang them) but wow...
I totally get where this article is going. I don't really understand the correlation that Michael Johnson made Magic Johnson a better basket ball player.
But I also get where people are not dwelling on all the weirdness and accusations etc.
As a performer, a musician, an entertainer, he really was ground breaking. It also can't be overlooked his contributions to charity.
So what that his best friend was chimp! Michael Jackson wasn't the only notable person to have befriended something from the animal kingdom - take a look at recent history to see of folks leaving their pet dog's their entire estate's fortunes and nothing to their own offspring.
I don't agree with babies dangling etc. but stop hating folks. He's body is gone now but the memories live on - let the music play.
DH
0
said
0
Tina
0
said
0
Tina A - Toronto
cmanning
0
said
0
Joy Vogl
0
said
0
Joy
Oshawa, Ontario
David Coruthers
0
said
0
Lee
0
said
0
Sab
0
said
0
merikagu
0
said
0
Who would you let your kids with, unsupervised, other than your parents, family members, or close friends??? My mother never let me with anyone that wasn't in my family or close to my family and even then there is no garanty. Convicted pedophiles are mostly people in the family. Was MJ proven guilty? No! Isn't it a principle of law here and in the US that someone is innocent until proven guilty? Yes. And this basic principle of law, does it apply to everybody and not just white folks? Supposedly yes!
merikagu
0
said
0
jasmine
0
said
0
Jen
0
said
0
Judi
0
said
0
Tim
0
said
0
Paul Minard
0
said
0
Time for sanity.
Vero
0
said
0
Bob Roy
0
said
0
Yes, being human he also had major failings. So does everyone. However, he always worked hard and tried. One of his greatest gifts was as a humanitarian and he became the greatest money giver in history. He made the world a better place for us all.
Creativity never dies within the soul, had Michael Jackson lived I’m sure we would have been treated to a wealth of future artistic efforts. Probably quite different from his past. And that is what we miss in the death of an artistic genius.
davidovich
0
said
0
Thank God this tawdry spectacle is over and done with.
Time to move on.
P.S. Though I, like most people, respect Jackson as a performer, I find it amazing how some people, especially the various news agencies, just ignore the 10 thousand pound elephant in the room.
As much as I would love to ignore it, I just can't.
It's sad that there was such a disconnect between Jackson the performer and Jackson, the guy who liked little boys just a little too much.
Alex (Toronto)
0
said
0
george in manitoba
0
said
0
Talk about a criminal past...he takes the cake.
Enough about Michael Jackson already..quit.
SM from Brampton
0
said
0
Roger T
0
said
0
Now Beat it, just beat it!
Tomm, Winnipeg
0
said
0
Violet, Toronto
0
said
0
Alan McCready
0
said
0
Tom, Winnipeg
0
said
0
the kids are safe now :0)
0
said
0
Rob
0
said
0
RCC in BC
0
said
0