CTV News | Did a computer failure cause the D.C. train crash?

Top Stories -   

Did a computer failure cause the D.C. train crash?

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News: Joy Malbon on the search for clues
CTV News Channel: Adrian Fenty, mayor of Washington, with an update on the crash
CTV News Channel: CNN's Sandra Endo on the investigation into the D.C. crash
CTV National News: Joy Malbon reports on the casualties and injuries
CTV News Channel: Tom Bridge, welovedc.com, on what investigators will be looking at
CTV News Channel: Alan Etter, DC fire department, on the extent of the crash
CTV News Channel: Cathy Asato, Washington Metro Transit, on the rescue operations
Search and rescue crews help passengers from train wreck

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(15)

CTV.ca News Staff

Date: Tue. Jun. 23 2009 9:01 PM ET

Investigators in the U.S. capital were focusing Tuesday on why a computerized system apparently failed to stop a train from crashing head-on into another, even though the emergency brake was applied.

The train had been set on automatic mode, which means it was mainly under the control of a computer. That left the operator responsible for opening and the closing the doors, and taking over in an emergency.

At least nine people died in the Washington, D.C., crash, and more than 70 people were injured.

Train operator McMillan was two years on the job driving a bus, but only a few weeks as a train operator. It appears that she tried to turn on the emergency brake, but it's unclear whether the brake was actually engaged.

Investigators also said the train was part of an aging fleet that federal authorities had recommended be phased out or retrofitted because of safety concerns.

The aging train plowed into another train stopped on the tracks during rush hour on Monday as it reportedly waited for instructions to proceed.

The accident is the deadliest in the Metro train transit system's history.

The National Transportation Safety Board is heading the investigation. Spokesperson Debbie Hersman said the Metrorail transit system "was not able" to replace the older train despite warnings dating back to 2006.

Metrorail officials blame money. The subway system has 296 rail cars that were built more than 30 years ago, and it hasn't had enough money to cover the estimated US$888 million needed to replace them, spokesperson Candace Smith said.

Investigators were expected to recover recorders from the train that was stuck, which would have offered valuable information about what happened.

However, because the train that triggered the crash was so old, it was not equipped with the recorders.

It unclear whether age played a role in the rush-hour collision, however, investigators are looking at speed as a factor. They are trying to determine the speed of the train at the time of the crash.

Death toll

Speaking at a press conference Tuesday afternoon, Mayor Adrian Fenty confirmed the identity of some victims.

Among them were train operator Jeanice McMillan, 42, of Springfield; Mary Doolittle, 59, of northwest Washington; Ana Fernandez, 40, of Hyattsville, Md.; Dennis Hawkins, 64, of southeast Washington and Lavonda King, 23, of northeast D.C.

It was not immediately clear whether the passengers killed were on the train that was moving or the one that was stopped awaiting the train ahead of it to clear a station.

"It happened so fast, I flew out of the seat and hit my head," said passenger Jodie Wickett.

"The people that were hurt, the ones that could speak, were calling back as we called out to them. Lots of people were upset and crying."

Passenger Maya Maroto, 31, said, "We were going full speed -- I didn't hear any braking. Everything was just going normally. Then there was a very loud impact. We all fell out of our seats. Then the train filled up with smoke. I was coughing."

The Metrorail board has set up an emergency relief fund of 250,000 to be distributed among the victims and are seeking to replace the old models of trains.

Meanwhile, rescue crews have been using heavy equipment to cut through the mangled train cars.

The crash took place on a Metro route that shuttles tens of thousands of commuters each day between the Maryland suburbs and the city.

There has not been a Washington Metro collision fatality since January 1982.

With files from The Associated Press

Comments are now closed for this story

Sarah - Halifax
said
0 0

What a terrible tragedy. My condolences to all affected by this accident.


Terry - Pickering
said
0 0

This is just terrible, accidents can happen anywhere at anytime and we all have to be cautious and vigilant of our surroundings we all hope and pray for all the survivors and victims of this unfortunate accident.


VANESSA
said
0 0

The train was stopped on the tracks waiting for instructions?

That sounds like a terrible system! Definately time to re-think those methods of operation.

It was quite literally an accident waiting to happen. I'm very sorry for the families of the dead.


Shane - Montreal
said
0 0

Sarah from Halifax said

"What a terrible tragedy. My condolences to all affected by this accident."

Who the hell is clicking on thumbs down to that?


Sarah - Halifax
said
0 0

Thank you Shane - Montreal! I don't see anything negative about what I wrote...either way, I meant what I said.


DANIEL H
said
0 0

I hate seeing things like this happen. I design safety systems for various industries and I always have the same problem. Clients always try to save $$ when it comes to safety. What do you think passengers would do if there was a warning on the train doors that read "THIS OLD TRAIN MAY BE UNSAFE. USE AT YOUR OWN RISK"?


ADM Saskatchewan
said
0 0

I honestly have to say that the thumbs down on condolances really surprise me. this is a tragedy, and I too offer my condolances to the families.


Rick in NB
said
0 0

DANIEL H,
Don't be so quick to blame the train. The investigation is noy final. This could be human error.


Kevin
said
0 0

Re: Vanessa's comments: "...terrible system! Definately [sic] time to rethink those methods of operation". What a ridiculously glib and uninformed statement. The Washington Metro has run nearly flawlessly for years; the safety record is superb. This terrible tragedy has our city reeling precisely because of the infrequency and unexpected nature of such things as they pertain to one of the best subway systems in the world. Please educate yourself about our Metro before you post such an ignorant statement.


Ben
said
0 0

As a rail traffic controller, I know that when there is a signal based system present, signals should be protecting trains in close proximity to each other requiring an operator to interpret and follow the signals. While I wouldn't want to point fingers early on, short of a complete systems failure, such a signal system usually requires operator error for this sort of thing to happen. This is all based on my assumption that a rudimentry signal system exists as it does on most rapid transit systems. Further, unless the brakes failed while the train was doing high speeds, I cannot see the train itself as the problem, but I suppose the investigation will tell over time.


VANESSA
said
0 0

KEVIN

I'm a civil engineer, I have my education. There should never have been a train stoppped on the tracks waiting for orders. I may sound glib but it was an accident waiting to happen.

However, to appease you, we will have to wait to hear the actual results of the investigation.


Taryn From Toronto
said
0 0

Vanessa: Subways stop all the time and wait for instructions, they wait for signals, or workers to get clear from tracks. The article is not clear on the instructions it was waiting for. I ride the subway here in Toronto twice a day for 30 min each time. I would say that about 65% of my trips include some sort of stop. Again we will wait to see the results of the investigation, however I just wanted to point out that it is not rare to have a metro car or subway stop on the tracks between stations.


Rick in NB
said
0 0

VANESSA,
Could you please explain why a stopped train is a bad thing? The railway i worked for has trains stopped waiting orders all the time. This is done to prevent collisions not cause them.


Life is priceless!
said
0 0

They blame MONEY! Since when do they have the right to put a price on someones life?


SB
said
0 0

So sorry to hear of this devastating accident.

However, after reading that there had been a lack of money to replace/retrofit and upgrade these trains, I am angered. Angered that the U.S. seems to have an infinite supply of money to spend on "wars" (invasions of other countries),yet does not seem to have enough money to fix the problems in their own backyard. Shame on them.


Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

In Pictures

D.C. train crash

D.C. train crash

Rescue workers search through wreckage after two trains collide in D.C.

CTV News Video Player

Rescue

Raw footge

Watch raw footage of rescuers in Washington, D.C., prying apart trains to allow survivors to escape.

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz