News Sections
Canada must do more to curb human trafficking: report
Font-size:
Share
Print
Comments(21)
CTV.ca News Staff
Date: Wed. Jun. 17 2009 10:28 AM ET
Law enforcement officials must do more to protect Canadians, particularly women and children, from being dragged into the sex trade against their will, a new report says. The report, issued by the U.S. State Department, also said Canada must prosecute more of its own citizens who engage in so-called sex tourism abroad.
According to the U.S. State Department's "Trafficking in Persons Report 2009," Canada is "a source, transit and destination country for men, women and children trafficked for the purposes of commercial sexual exploitation and forced labor."
The report, released Tuesday, says Canadians are trafficked abroad for the purposes of sexual exploitation, while Canadian women and girls, "many of whom are aboriginal," are trafficked internally.
Benjamin Perrin, a University of British Columbia law professor and human trafficking expert, said Wednesday that while Canada has laws that make human trafficking a crime, it doesn't have a national action plan to investigate crimes and prosecute offenders.
"What's really missing though is putting the pieces of the puzzle all together," Perrin told CTV's Canada AM. "The report that came out yesterday criticized Canada for a lack of enforcing those laws against traffickers, and for a lack of co-ordination."
The report analyzed the progress being made in 175 countries to deal with human trafficking. The State Department told 52 countries and territories, primarily in Asia, Africa and the Middle East, that they could face sanctions if they do not improve their efforts on the issue. That is up from 40 countries the 2008 report put on notice.
The RCMP estimates that between 800 and 1,200 people in Canada have been victims of human trafficking, despite a 2005 law making it illegal. There have only been five convictions for human trafficking in the past year, according to Perrin.
One man convicted of trafficking a 17-year-old girl spent only a week in jail on a two-year sentence, because he was granted two-for-one credit for a year he spent in pre-trial custody, Perrin said.
And it was only in 2006 that Canada passed a law that allows foreign workers brought here for the purposes of sexual exploitation to gain temporary resident permits so they can get medical care.
Perrin also charged that little is being done to prosecute Canadians who travel abroad to engage in sex tourism and the exploitation of women and children.
"This is a global effort to deal with this problem because, quite frankly, offenders know no borders," Perrin said.
According to Perrin, a law prohibiting Canadians from engaging in sex tourism abroad "has only been used three times since 1997."
Victor Malarek, a correspondent for CTV's W-FIVE who has written two books on the subject, said the report sheds light on what amount to gross human rights abuses around the world, including in Canada.
He said Canadians need look no further than advertisements in the backs of free urban newspapers that advertise foreign escorts.
"You have to ask yourself: How did these women get here?" Malarek told CTV.ca.
These women are likely not landed immigrants, he said, nor are they business-savvy women who have decided to set up shop in Canada.
Malarek said that weak law enforcement against human trafficking and sexual exploitation largely boils down to misogyny.
"You have a lot of testosterone in police forces," Malarek said, "where they think these women are making money the easy way, on their backs."
The report did praise Canada for complying "with the minimum standards for the elimination of trafficking," and for its efforts in aiding victims.
But it also contained recommendations for Canada, including:
- Stepping up efforts to investigate and prosecute trafficking offences.
- Enacting more proactive law enforcement techniques to investigate trafficking cases.
- Increasing efforts to investigate and prosecute Canadians suspected of child sex tourism crimes overseas.
- Offering more protections for foreign trafficking victims.
A private member's bill, introduced by Conservative MP Joy Smith, calls for minimum five-year sentences for anyone convicted of trafficking someone under the age of 18.
Bill C-268 has passed its second reading in the House of Commons and is now before the Standing Committee on Justice and Human Rights.
We really need that law," Perrin said.
User Tools
Related Stories
Related Websites
User Tools
About the tools
Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.
-


Font-size
Print Article
Comments(21)-
Feedback
Share it with your network of friends
Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.
Most Viewed News Stories
Most Talked about Stories
I applaud the budget, even though Health Care and education may stay unscathed. Sadly this cannot last and I worry to later this year where cuts will become enviable. If anything, this provides the Wildrose Alliance plenty of ammo when an election is called.


Comments are now closed for this story
Proventus
0
said
0
They should clean up their own back yard before they go pointing fingers.
Layton in Moncton
0
said
0
It's no different than any other job except instead of trading your labour or skills for money, you trade sex. A skill some may argue.
JB in Ontario
0
said
0
Canadian laws should be made by Canadians. Not by Americans or any other country.
David P
0
said
0
And an abandonment of the double standard that sees the press publish names of accused when they are working in the sex trade, but johns get a free ride. In one notorious case in Ottawa, a well-known doctor (and senator) was outed as a john; that's the exception, rather than the rule.
Ted
0
said
0
Gaby
0
said
0
Renee
0
said
0
MuskyBuck
0
said
0
It's so bad that the US State Department has no idea of how many immigrants are being brought 'into' the US and are being used as forced slave labour.
When I say 'forced' slave labour, I'm talking about rich immigrants 'buying' Africans to use as household maids and chore workers.
The visual you may get when you read the word 'household maid' or 'chore workers' shouldn't be accepted.
Try imagining a maid who is 12 years old. Works from sun up until sundown.
Try imagining little girls who are denied school. And usually sleep in the spot alloted for house pets, such as the garage.
Now imagine thousands of these girls living all throughout the US, primarily in the richest areas of suburban life in the US.
The US State Department has done a great job by highlighting the depravity of our government in continueing to ignore how we treat aboriginals or the impoverished class in Canada.
What the US State Department should know is they have a bigger immigrant slave trade going on right in Beverly Hills.
And no one even knows about it.
But then again, when it comes to issues of people living and working within their borders, as we've seen in the past the US is the last government to know.
peggy
0
said
0
Johns' names should be published; it is indeed a double standard that only prostitutes' names are published.
That being said, if prostitution ever becomes legal, the johns should be subject to labour laws like any other business.
Joe Pigeon
0
said
0
Gordon in Ottawa
0
said
0
Ian in Ottawa
0
said
0
Divulging the names of Johns would solve nothing. Why is that even a tactic? Do we divulge the names of car thiefs? I'd like to know who stole my car so I can go over and... I know, I know, it's to embarass the Johns. Sure that would stop him from ever trying again. But since he got caught in the first place, I think he'd be less likely to try again. In the meantime, the prostitute will continue attracting new "Johns". Solves nothing. Legalize it and regulate it, and you'll see a huge difference. Sex shouldn't be made illegal! We're not in the 1800's or the 1950's!!
Kris
0
said
0
Oh right, the Conservatives tried to do that. The Liberals shot it down. I wonder why?
MRC in Ontario
0
said
0
Jeff in Eastern Ontario
0
said
0
Steven Baird
0
said
0
given the harshest sentence
possible and upon release, instantly become a registered sex offender for life. The same goes for any person purchasing the services of a child for sexual gratification.
Steven Baird
Managing Director
Street Smart Kidz
Canada
streetsmartkidz.ca
totaljustice
0
said
0
karen in calgary
0
said
0
CYL
0
said
0
It good that there'll be some kind of law to help but to enforce it has to have serious action.
MuskyBuck
0
said
0
It's sad how many people here don't understand that the Conservatives DO NOT care about human rights issues.
That's not meant as a slanderous attempt, the fact is the Conservative govnerment has no interest in affairs of human rights whether that be at home or abroad.
As a matter of record, the only thing the Harper government has done on issues of human rights is to:
Increase and expand the Temporary Migrant Workers Program.
Whats that you say?
Thats the little known program that allows large corporations to hire and house immigrants who have no status while working in Canada.
And as a matter of record, these immigrants are treated horribly while here.
Long hours, poor housing, bad food, no freedom.
Essentially a corporate slave and oh let's not forget, ....
Do as we do or we'll send you back without pay for your services.
This has been documented and reported and Canadians are clueless this is happening not only in Canada but with the expressed best wishes from the Harper Government who quietly increased the ability for corporations to continue this slap in the face of humanity.
I've lived around Alymer Ontario for a short period of time and was disgusted by the practice of the tobacco farmers being used as cattle.
I bore witness to the townsfolk mistreating these people when they came into town.
The racial prejudice doesn't always come from individuals but it most always starts at the government level.
Puzzled
0
said
0
I find it odd that they do nothing about the sweat shops and at the same time, force women into prostitution with their archaic stance when it comes to welfare and social assistance.
It's the American way...do as I say and not as I do.
The Americans need to fix their own back yard before they finger point to others in what their own failures contributed to and continue to contribute to.
The American way of forcing prostitutes out of one neighborhood to another, where the rich won't see them, because they are in poor neighborhoods does nothing for a final solution.
This attitude that the Americans have of "WE'LL GIVE YOU A HAND UP, BUT NOT A HAND OUT," has never worked.
This in itself, is the driving force that puts people into the position of Prostitution and Human Trafficking.
Necessity is the Mother of Invention and out of necessity to make a living, people simply invented Human Trafficking/Prostitution out of necessity to put food on the table, simply to live.