CTV News | Judge rejects Balsillie's bid to move Coyotes

Top Stories -   

Judge rejects Balsillie's bid to move Coyotes

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News: Scott Laurie covers the hockey rejection
CTV News Channel: Howard Bloom, publisher, SportsBusinessNews.com, on whether this is the end of Balsillie's NHL dream

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(51)

CTV.ca News Staff

Date: Mon. Jun. 15 2009 11:00 PM ET

A bankruptcy judge has rejected Jim Balsillie's bid to relocate the Phoenix Coyotes to Hamilton, but the Canadian billionaire is not giving up.

Arizona bankruptcy judge Redfield Baum said the possibility of the team's relocation presented significant issues for the court.

"There are no reported bankruptcy court decisions ordering a relocation of the magnitude proposed here," he said.

Baum also said the issue of a relocation fee -- in which Balsillie would have to pay millions of dollars to the NHL for the right to move the Coyotes to Ontario -- had not been resolved.

Finally, he said the court "is unconvinced that it should order that the NHL must decide the relocation application to meet the June 29th deadline." Balsillie had set that deadline for his $212.5-million offer to expire.

A spokesperson for Balsillie, Bill Walker, said his client was still seeking to bring a seventh NHL team to Canada.

"The court did not approve either our approach or the NHL's," Walker said in statement late Monday. "Judge Baum did state he does not have time to decide all the relocation issues. But the court still controls the sale process. As a result, we look forward to hearing from the NHL soon on its view of our relocation application and an appropriate relocation fee, so as to allow the court to determine if that fee is reasonable."

We still think there is enough time for the NHL to approve Mr. Balsillie's application and move the team to Hamilton by September," he added. "The court invited mediation on these issues and Mr. Balsillie is willing to participate in such mediation if the NHL is also willing to do so."

Baum had earlier said he wanted to ensure the team's creditors would not be left in the lurch if the team was moved. The NHL argued the franchise is still viable in Phoenix, but the team has reportedly lost more than $300 million since it moved there from Winnipeg in 1996.

NHL deputy commissioner Bill Daly said the league was "pleased" with Baum's decision.

"We will turn our attention now toward helping to facilitate an orderly sales process that will produce a local buyer who is committed to making the Coyotes' franchise viable and successful in the Phoenix/Glendale area," he said in a statement. "We are confident that we will be able to find such a buyer for the Coyotes and that the claims of legitimate creditors will be addressed."

One of the key issues in the dispute was whether majority owner Jerry Moyes had the authority to file for bankruptcy and negotiate the team's sale, or if the NHL had control of the Coyotes.

On May 5, Moyes announced he had put the team into Chapter 11 protection. That same day, Balsillie made an offer to purchase the team -- but only if he could relocate it to Ontario.

NHL commissioner Gary Bettman alleged in court filings that he had control of the team -- not Moyes -- and any talk of selling or moving the franchise should have been directed to him.

Balsillie, the 48-year-old co-CEO of Waterloo, Ont.-based Research In Motion -- which makes the BlackBerry wireless device -- has made two previous attempts to move a franchise to Canada.

He tried to purchase and move the Nashville Predators to Hamilton in 2007, but the league rebuffed him. He has also previously expressed interest in the Pittsburgh Penguins.

Despite Monday's ruling, Balsillie's dream of bringing an NHL franchise to Southern Ontario may not be dead yet, said sports writer Howard Bloom, publisher of SportsBusinessNews.com.

While Bloom said there is "little if any appeal process when it comes to bankruptcy," he predicted that the Coyotes will play one more season in Phoenix before they are put on the auction block by the NHL.

"Hockey is never going to work in Phoenix," Bloom told CTV News Channel on Monday night, noting that the team has lost some US$300 million over the past nine seasons in Arizona.

Bloom said that once the team is put up for auction, Balsillie could then bid on the franchise and move it north -- but with the NHL controlling the process.

"I think if Jim Balsillie's smart, he'll play by the rules," Bloom said, noting that the auction price could swell to $400 million.

"He's a hard guy to keep down."

Comments are now closed for this story

Remarkable
said
0 0

Well, Jim Balsillie was really acting on behalf of all the hockey fans in Canada. To bring back a team that is stuck in the south west US, in the middle of a desert with very few fans there, just doesn't make economic sense to me.

I think that somewhere down the road, there will be a seventh Canadian NHL franchise, but as long as Gary Bettman is in the NHL front office, it won't belong to Jim Balsillie and that is a real shame.


Ryan from Stratford, ON
said
0 0

Way to go! Everyone knows that Phoenix has a much, much more enthusiastic hockey fan base than southern Ontario. Oh wait... Please keep trying for us, Jim!


Mr. B.
said
0 0

Yeah, I bet there will be a line-up 10 miles long to buy the Coyotes. That team will lose money forever.


Lament for Leaves
said
0 0

So there you have it...again.

Unequivocally, this is not about the fans, but about potential revenue from a (as yet non existent) TV deal in the USA.

So lets forget about feeling shunned, it has nothing to do with SW Ontario supporting a team. We will watch no matter what.


donna
said
0 0

that is just f....GARBAGE...BOYCOTT LEAF AND BUFFALO GAMES

Mike from Ottawa
said
0 0

Typical American B.S.

Here is a guy who has bid way way more than the team is worth and just gets told to get lost......WHY......because he is Canadian!!

Thanks Bettman......no wonder the NBA rid themselves with you years ago. You make me sick!!


Brian In Sarnia
said
0 0

Yeah, I honestly think it's time we protest with our wallets. Gary Bettman's ego is ruining the NHL. This doesn't make sense at all.


Lynn in Hamilton
said
0 0

I don't understand why the NHL seems to think we don't want a hockey team here in Hamilton.... of course we do!! Steel town is hockey town!! There would be no worries of the team going bankrupt here. Makes one wonder if there isn't someone else's hand feeding your wallet there Judge Baum. I can't think of any other reason to deny the sale. If they stay in Arizona they will continue to just lose money and then what will the creditors get?? I am totally appalled by the fact that Wayne Gretzky wouldn't want the team in Hamilton since it's only 20 minutes from home or have you forgotten where you came from??? It's a sad day.... Mr Balsillie please appeal this decision we want this team here in Hamilton where it will truly be appreciated and not just taken for granted.




David (Windsor, Ontario)
said
0 0

I am convinced you could throw a dart at a map of Canada and where ever it landed, build an area, make a team and it will be sold out everynight.



Brad G - Edmonton
said
0 0

Despite his public comments to the contrary this is really about Bettman's attempts to maintain his questionable 'vision' of an increasing USA market. You will not see any additional Canadian teams under his watch no matter how lucrative the offer.


Maurice from Edmonton
said
0 0

Players union unite..get rid of Bettman who is not interested in the love of the game only his friends


Bernie Walsh
said
0 0

Bernie Walsh Halifax CANADA

Gary Bettmans time has come to ssek other employment he has no idea how to run the NHL better than a 2 year old could.He has in his stupid wisdom been trying to take all hockey away from Canada and make it out to be an American game. You are mistaken Mr. Bettman and I am sure a lot of other Canadians who have followed hockey sinc televisions arrived in Canada and all new fans in Canada agree take it but we will havew our own league without you and take away all the Canadian born players see how far you get then sir I dare say not to far. We have a lot of rich Canadians willing to invest in teams in all parts of Canada we don't need you and I say frankly we don't want you around trying to take the all the glory for something you had nothing to do with. So I say Canada lets stand up and make hockey once again Canada's game with Canadian players for Canadian fans.

Bucko
said
0 0

As long as Bettman and the majority of Owners are American Any Canadian expansion is a no no and we continue to be nothing more than excess baggage in their eyes.


Anthony
said
0 0

Jim Balsillie should stick to Blackberry, this way he will have less disappointments.
Unless of course he may try to start a different NHL like group - IHL - International Hockey League.
This way even far away Manitoba could participate.


Sensfan
said
0 0

Jimmy Blackberry didnt get his way ..serves him right for trying to end run the process that all other team owners followed.

The thing that bothers me most was this billionaire wanted over 100 million in government $ to renovate the rink. At least our billionaire owner (Eugene Melynk) pays his own way.


Bettina
said
0 0

Gary Betman is a joke. Canada deseves at leat 5 more teams. I have no idea what Gary is smoking.


David in NB
said
0 0

This is crazy. According to CTV News, the Coyotes have lost 300 million over the past several years. Then a guy with more money than Blackberries offers to buy the team and move it to a location that, in all probability, would be profitable, and the NHL fought it tooth and nail.

I just wonder if Mr. Bettman has the cajones to say "I goofed". I mean, he didn't hesitate when the Nordiques ran into trouble, moved them lock stock and barrel to Colorado, which already had its chance at a team and failed. And to add insult to injury, the Nordiques...er..Rockies won the cup that year! For shame NHL!


Brad B
said
0 0

As much as I'd love to see another team in Southern Ont, this wasn't the way to do it. Every time he tries to do it deviously, he gets more owners against him. I hope he eventually gets a team there, but it's got to be by NHL rules.

And no, there will not be another team in Winnipeg, at least not until the population base increases


meerkat
said
0 0

good thing phoenix has all those outdoor rinks and hockey this and hockey that eh.. good move judge.


R-in-ONT
said
0 0

Bettman still has future, it just should not be in the NHL.
Look for Bettman to star in "Batman, The Return of the Penquin" as of course the penquin.....
can't you see it.


Randy, London
said
0 0

This is complete garbage. I am done watching the NHL...for too long Canadian fans have been taken for granted.

I will be more than happy to spend my money watching OHL games.

Dan
said
0 0

Let the Phoenix Coyotes go under and the team and their Phoenix fans can blame Judge Redfield Baum and NHL Commissioner Gary Bettman.

To Jim Balsille you have tried to help this team...walk away with pride.

roy
said
0 0

I will never pay to go see another hockey game and I'll never watch another game on tv


bb
said
0 0

So what about the concept of starting a Canadian Hockey League - CHL?


Ryder
said
0 0

So, when the 'yotes fold, and they WILL. We know who to point the finger at. This Judge is not acting in the best interest of the franchise. Jim Balsillie's offer would have gotten the team out of debt and they'd prosper in Canda, whether be it in Hamilton (shudder) or in Winnipeg!


Adam, montreal
said
0 0

If canadians dont like it, stop watching (Boycott) the NHL and Bettman. Without canada the nhl is nothing.


Terry Shaw
said
0 0

Thats great news, it will save the tax payers alot of money.


Bettman must go!!!!!!!!
said
0 0

Bettman is bad for hockey, get rid of him now! Boycott NHL till he is gone. Soon they will have shootouts in the playoffs Bettman has ruined the game of hockey for me forever


Logan
said
0 0

Jim, build a whole new League... period. The old saying goes IF YOU BUILD IT, THEY WILL COME.


Paul, kingston
said
0 0

This is a great day for Hockey. Bettman has once again shown the commitment to keeping a great storied team in its original market, way to go bettman! such commitment! Im defineatly going to splurge on season tickets this season.

Never in a million years. Boycott here i came. No more hockey for this canuck


Shawn S, Calgary
said
0 0

Wow, seems most of you haven't a clue as to how the NHL works. This isn't Gary Bettman's vendetta against you. He is just a figurehead and works for the board of governors. He is doing THEIR bidding, not his. Get over your hate for him.


fordshipper
said
0 0

keep up the good work jim!


Tom in BC
said
0 0

For the most part I quit watching hockey when the NHL expanded. Now its mostly american teams. The players are all overpaid. The quality of the games went way down afetr expansion. A lot was lost with expansion. Too many teams. Once all the Canadian teams get eliminated I rarely bother watching. Best we can hopr for now it seems is that a canadian kid is on an american team thats playing for the cup. Truley sad. Too bad the coyotes hadn't come north. I feel for Jim B. I truly miss the glory days of hockey when Johnny Bower et.al. were playing.


John L
said
0 0

Dumbest move you ever made Gary! This team is going to sell for 70 million next year for sure. Vegas in 2011 for sure. Disappointed as a Canadian to be sure.


Fans havent spoken ....
said
0 0

"BS"

What else do you expect from Gary Bettman and the NHL cronies...

The BEST way to deal with this is to totally avoid any games by the Toronto Maple Leafs and I GUARANTEE you they will be crying for Mr. B to buy the team...



RZ
said
0 0

FIRE GARY BETTMAN! He simply has no right to block the sale of a hockey team to one who wishes to move it back to Canada, where it would be much more viable! I hope Balsillie appeals this ruling!


Tom in Toronto
said
0 0

Shameful.

Why do we keep buying tickets to watch American teams play?


jake
said
0 0

If Canadians had any guts they'd boycott this league. The NHL might get the message if we give them what they really deserve. (empty area's)


Great news! NHL franchise moves closer
said
0 0

to bankruptcy.

FlamesFan
said
0 0

This story isn't over. Very few fans are going to attend the games this year in Phoenix given the likelihood they'll move. Players will likely ask for a trade, and the ones that get stuck there will likely not be motivated. The team will lose tens of millions of dollars, and the other owners are going to have to foot the bill, while they're already struggling with their own teams. Then they'll ask (demand?) Bettman to reconsider Balsillie's offer. Either that or some other owner is going to sell to Balsillie. If the Coyotes lost $300 million, how we can teams like the Thrashers, Predators and the Islanders be doing? Not well is my guess.


Daniel P.
said
0 0

Good for the Phoenix team! 300 mills in the red and willing to weather another few. Wtf?!?


Join the Kontinental League. Crush the NHL.
said
0 0

Crush the NHL.

Repeat for emphasis:

Crush the NHL.


angela
said
0 0

For a country so screwed financially right now, I'm surprised they aren't jumping at the chance of this "bailout"...

They're just being stubborn at this point! Too afraid of losing something to The Canadians...


Sween in Indiana
said
0 0

Gosh, for an American TV deal? Really, there is not a lot of hockey on down here and it drives me nuts. I'm originally from Nova Scotia, and it does NOT make any sense to a hockey team in the middle of a bloody desert. Heck, having one in the Carolinas makes as much sense... If only someone would come in usurp Bettman's place... some who KNOWS what the game is about... there would be a lot of happy people. Mostly us Canadians :)


Jayme
said
0 0

IF think we may see very very low crowds.I would be shocked if they avg more the 10,000 a game.


Richard in Ontario
said
0 0

Good luck getting a Canadian
franchise, I for one just don't really want my tax money going to renovate Copp's Coloseum for another billionaire owner.


Canadian Eh!
said
0 0

Young Canadians do not remember when hockey was Canadian. When Clarence Campbell retired and the Americans took over it was bye-bye Canadian hockey. They changed the rules so the Yanks can understand it a little more increase the size of the goal crease so you have higher scoring games do away with the 2line offside so we don't slow the game down.Everything about hockey has been dummed down for the benefit of the yanks. Anyone who thinks hockey is still Canada's game has been living in a dream world.Hamilton or any surrounding area will never see an NHL franchise.To all you people who support American sports such as football and baseball and hockey,this is what you get. Canada has a football league and we have plenty of good junior hockey. All we have to do is SUPPORT IT.


Lorne
said
0 0

Jim - you gave it your best shot.
Sit back and watch the team, along with St. Louis fold, plus a few other teams.
The NHL cannot prop up all the teams that are near broke, so you will have your chance. Hell, you're still young.


Sam C
said
0 0

Remind me please -- is Bettman's job title "Emperor?"


hugh
said
0 0

Time to boycott the NHL. Let the owners know that Canada is the land of hockey,not the southern U.S.A. Boycott until they get Bettman gone.


thinker
said
0 0

Wonder if bettman made it this hard to move a team (winn,que) from Canada to the u.s.a.Didn't think so!


Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz