News Sections
Isotope issue 'sexy,' Raitt heard to say on tape
CTV News Video
Watch: See all Videos in the Player
Font-size:
Share
Print
Comments(98)
CTV.ca News Staff
Date: Mon. Jun. 8 2009 11:38 PM ET
Natural Resources Minister Lisa Raitt is again at the heart of a raging controversy after she disparaged Health Minister Leona Aglukkaq and called the medical isotope shortage a "sexy" issue on a newly unsealed audio tape.
The candid conversation, which took place between Raitt and her former communications director Jasmine MacDonnell, occurred in January, according to the Halifax Chronicle Herald.
The conversation was made public on Monday afternoon -- less than a week after MacDonnell resigned for leaving sensitive government documents at CTV News' Ottawa office.
Earlier on Monday, MacDonnell had sought a court order to prevent the Chronicle Herald, who have possession of the tape, from publishing its contents.
But MacDonnell's request was rejected by a Nova Scotia Supreme Court judge and the tape was released Monday afternoon on the paper's website.
During the court proceedings, Chronicle Herald columnist Stephen Maher testified that another reporter passed him the tape after she found it in a bathroom on Parliament Hill.
The paper held off listening to the tape until MacDonnell resigned last week.
On the tape, Raitt said the medical isotope shortage has been a difficult political issue "because it's confusing to a lot of people."
However, Raitt added: "But it's sexy ... Radioactive leaks. Cancer."
The Liberals have hammered Raitt and the Tories with pointed questions about Canada's growing shortage of medical isotopes caused by the shutdown at the Chalk River nuclear facility.
The conversation, which appears to have taken place not long after a reported heavy water leak at Chalk River, Ont., also includes a discussion about Aglukkaq and her ministry's handling of the isotope file.
"They're terrified of the issues," said Raitt, referring to the Ministry of Health.
"You know what? Good. Because when we win on this, we get all the credit. I'm ready to roll the dice on this."
Allegations related to previous job
Adding to Raitt's troubles are allegations she may have expensed thousands of dollars worth of expensive meals when she was the chief executive officer of the Toronto Port Authority.
NDP MP Olivia Chow claims four of the nine port authority directors have requested an examination into Raitt's expenses and other management practices at the port authority.
Complicating matters, Transport Minister John Baird was also accused of shuffling the port authority's board to "cover up" allegations of mismanagement against Raitt.
At issue is $80,000 in travel and hospitality expenses that Raitt ran up in two years while she was CEO of the federal public authority.
Raitt quit the job to run for the Conservatives.
Political fallout spreads
Earlier in the day in the House of Commons, the opposition hammered Raitt with questions about the audiotape.
Liberal environment critic David McGuinty led the charge, saying internal cabinet squabbling is undermining the confidence of Canadians at a time when the shutdown of the Chalk River nuclear reactor is creating a shortage of medical isotopes.
He said the file should be taken away from "this distracted minister."
"The minister of natural resources was recorded when she was making disparaging remarks about her colleague, the minister of health, who she described as not very competent," McGuinty said.
"Can she tell the House unequivocally, loud and clear, that those remarks about the minister of heath in the media are accurate or not?"
Raitt didn't respond about the audiotape, but lashed back at McGuinty for getting some of his facts wrong with respect to reactors, and which countries would help cover the shortfall of medical isotopes caused by the shutdown at Chalk River.
"He said that Australia would not be able to export a single medical isotope. And again that is false," Raitt charged, "And he confused the countries of Belgium and the Netherlands."
CTV's Ottawa Bureau Chief Robert Fife, quoting officials from Prime Minister Stephen Harper's office, reported that Raitt won't be asked to resign because she still has Harper's confidence.
Recorder left behind for months
In an affidavit filed to the Nova Scotia Supreme Court, Chronicle Herald reporter Maher writes that he notified MacDonnell several months ago about recorder.
"MacDonnell never directed me not to listen to the recordings," he writes.
Maher "assumed that she had abandoned it" when MacDonnell had resigned from her post last week and still hadn't picked up the recorder.
Speaking to CTV News Channel from Halifax on Monday night, Maher said that he knew MacDonnell professionally in Ottawa and initially had some concerns about publishing the recordings.
"I feel sympathy for Ms. MacDonnell, who's always been a likeable person," Maher said.
"I really had to impersonalize it in my mind and think 'this is a senior official in the government of Canada.'"
Maher added that the public interest led him to his final decision.
"Unfortunately, for her, her actions have brought her into the spotlight in a way that I don't think is very flattering or very pleasant for her, and I hope she gets past this and finds a career that's suitable for her."
With files from The Canadian Press
User Tools
Related Stories
User Tools
About the tools
Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.
-


Font-size
Print Article
Comments(98)-
Feedback
Share it with your network of friends
Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.
Most Viewed News Stories
Most Talked about Stories
I applaud the budget, even though Health Care and education may stay unscathed. Sadly this cannot last and I worry to later this year where cuts will become enviable. If anything, this provides the Wildrose Alliance plenty of ammo when an election is called.


Comments are now closed for this story
Chris
said
TIme for some sensitivity training
said
What is wrong with these people?
dawn
said
Ash (Ottawa)
said
In another note Mrs. Raitt confused her office with CTV's office !
Ian in Mississauga
said
American with Canadians
said
Jim Lad
said
Ms. MacDonnell manages to misplace secret documents and mistakenly tape her boss for five hours then lose the tape recorder?
Both articles end up in the hands of bureau chiefs and her dad just happens to be a top fundraiser for Michael Ignatieff.
I doubt that Ms Raitt can survive this.
I thought we had seen all of the dirty tactics during the Paul Martin days but clearly, the worst is yet to come.
bunny
said
Denny in SK
said
I doubt it was her fault the sensitive documents were left at CTV, but calling the Minister of Health incompetent on taped recording is incredibly irresponsible. This whole fiasco with the Chalk River plant and this minister's actions lately really cast a negative shadow on the government as a whole.
Eyes Wide Open
said
This is a competent woman who is being attacked for office politics. Is everything such a big deal? This is a matter for the Prime Minister to deal with. Either replace them or discipline them. It would seem more to me that the opposition are the ones not keeping their eye on the issues. Just making issues out of petty politics. Same ol' Same 'ol.
bono
said
Burlington Is Beautiful
said
Jason from SK
said
This is "Politics: The Game" ... making the shortage look like the failure of another party, and spinning the issue for "sexy" self-promotion. I don't care which party she is in, and I don't care which parties are grilling her. I'm sick of "anti-Cons" and "anti-Libs" barking back and forth when both parties are shameful. Deflecting blame back and forth makes everyone look bad, and anyone who claims to root for one team is too self-righteous to step back and look at the Big Picture.
At the end of the day, she's shown disregard for her constituency and a willingness to manipulate public opinion and spin blame away from herself. SHE IS NOT FIT TO REPRESENT.
bella-in-ottawa
said
Paul, Kingston
said
Herb
said
Realistic in Calgary
said
Shocking.
A politician noticing that the appearance of a problem and it's handling might provide more politican benefit than others?
Shocking.
People pretending the system working any other way and getting upset about it?
(can anyone spot a pattern here?)
Come on people, first clue, SHE'S A POLITICIAN!!! We made her first priority appearances, not substance over decades of stupid voting and knee jerk reactions. Pretending the world works any other way is just self delusion.
Chalk River-ite
said
This government is a JOKE.
Clean up your acts!
Matt from Cornwall
said
DB Cooper
said
Bunny, it's laughable that you smell a Liberal set up to a taped conversation, when it was the Conservatives who taped a closed-session NDP meeting and then bragged about it. This government has lost any shred of credibility that it may have had and needs to go. Come on Iggy, call an election so that we can throw these bums out!
Stacy
said
Opss
said
http://thechronicleherald.ca/Front/9012061.html
Ian in Mississauga
said
A shame that office politics was allowed to be made a big deal. This kind of back and forth squabbling happens in EVERY OFFICE in the country. If they don't get along...big deal! The Liberals see another oportunity to take the low road so they take. Along with the media who enjoys the slithering on the bottom...or so it seems.
=============================
Please explain why a minister forgetting documents in a TV station and making disparaging remarks about a colleague has ANYTHING to do with the LIBERALS or for that matter anyone but the Conservatives themselves???? Take off the partisan blinders please and call it like it is and that's INCOMPETENCE. Maybe with the latest Nanos numbers we won't have to worry about it much longer. Liberals 37% to the Conservatives at 32% and fading.
Jim Lad
said
Read it again. Jasmine MacDonnell left the tape in a press room and did not go back for it. (Even when asked)
Not Ms Raitt. She had no knowledge of it.
She taped her boss without her consent then took the tape recorder to the press room and left it there.
Doesn't get much lower than that.
Gord. Robson, Nova Scotia
said
This gives the appearance of the Minister being set up!
JUST think it was reported that the wrong person lost their job!!
It APPEARS the right person resigned! THIS is unbelievable!
Bogus Info
said
It is one of many tests to detect cancer.
Malwali Rhandister
said
dawn
said
Dumb thing to say, smells a little like a set up to me. This was recorded, nothing more to say.I am upset, but a private conversation, & taped? I smell a liberal set up.
how is that possible when the aide called the chronicle and asked them to hold the recording for her....
Michaele
said
Guess it would have nothing to do with the connection between Mcconnell's dad and Ignatieff.
Why is that not being reported?
Charles, BC
said
Take responsibility and do the right thing Harper, I dare you to do the right thing!
Reece
said
Ummm...IGGY!!!! HELP!!!
Michaele
said
Mcconnell's dad raises money for Ignatieff!
BP in Edmonton
said
K on the prairies
said
Jason Daniel Baker
said
The leader of the Opposition has little room for women as we have seen by the fact he has none amongst his senior advisors.
As for the rest... Overworked staffers and Malice in Blunderland...:(
They can't fire the same staffer twice over a similar mistake.
Duke Boags
said
It's typical of the Conservatives under "little stevie" No transparency, no accountability, Pas de Parole as we say en frencais.
Look it up!!
Max
said
conductor274
said
We're getting to point now where Harper is going to have to try to match wits with Ignatieff and just like Bush, Harper will be revealed as the unintelligent idealogue he really is.
Duke Boags
said
Unfortunatly is DOES get lower than this. These isotopes that Ms. Raitt refers to are used for medical testing to detect cancer etc. and for her to refer to the lack of production of these isotopes as a "sexy issue" sends all the wrong messages to the public about her devotion to serving the public and shows her complete indifference to those who really need these isotopes for medical reasons. It's not chewing gum that's in short supply.....get it?
m
said
Dan in Quebec
said
Who is running the country?
DB Cooper
said
Dave in Surrey
said
Ya, that is a great conspiracy theory you got going there folks... Maybe you should turn up the air conditioning in the conservative war room if that is the best you can come up with...
Phil from Ottawa
said
Josh in Mosse Jaw
said
Joe Sanity
said
Charlie
said
No wonder the way our press is so desperate to sensationalize any possible mistake or un guarded comment.
This is a perfect example of how you can't trust the press at any time. Sad.
The other Lowell in BC
said
Fraser
said
This reminds me of what my mother used to tell me "if you don't have anything nice to say better not say anything at all".
Brian Henley
said
Joe Sanity
said
"Compared to the Liberal bumbling and stumbling and being clueless about how to run a country this is minor"
By "clueless" would you be referring to the Liberals eliminating a $42 Billion deficit and several years of subsequent surpluses?
Time is running out for your Reform/Conservatives and it's culture of slander. At $50 Billion, it's becoming painfully obvious to Canadians which party is truly clueless and stumbling... Attack ads are all you have left.
Island Man
said
She was rightly fired as she appears to leave things lying about and now Rait needs to be fired for her self gratifying handling of a very life threatening crisis. Anyone close to a cancer patient knows this is anything but sexy.
West Coast Guy
said
hugh
said
Robin
said
Spence in Ontario
said
Trevor
said
Amazing that recordings of private conversations where people make the mistake of expressing an opinion is a 'scandal'. Only when a Conservative is involved.
I remember when the Liberals were crying foul over the release of tape recordings, that was back when they were attempting to bribe an MP. Of course then it was a 'scandal' for the Conservative to have recorded the crime in progress.
Private conversation, no crime committed, nobody was hurt, end of story.
Lorne Jordan
said
AH in Ottawa
said
We know what she said, there is proof. She should apologize in the house and to Canadians, and then quite or resign.
This time Harper should accept her resignation. If not, pay the price.
mcgil
said
How are we as citizens, taxpayers and electors supposed to react to these allegations?
"Incroyable, mes co-citoyens canadiens"!!!
Perhaps Mr. Ignatieff should pull the plug on this bunch of clowns...No words can do justice to my disappointment and anger towards the Neo-Cons and Harper.
Mike
said
Scott
said
Kevin in T.O.
said
That said, Ms. Raitt must resign immediately as she's clearly lost confidence of her staff.
Jim K
said
Niagara George
said
The Liberals don't need to take anything out of context. These Cons present a clear message from beginning to end.
Raitt, Baird, Harper... send them all packing.
Craig McGowan
said
Geoff
said
Why is no one asking the Liberals why they raised 56 billion in EI premiums illegally (according to the Supreme court of Canada Dec/08)? This was then transfer to the general coffiers and that is how the Liberals balanced their budget for the last three years they were in office.
Laura
said
Minister Raitt is void of any integrity or intelligence. With that said, I'm sure Mr. Harper will refuse to accept her resignation yet again proving the government lacks any ability in leading the country.
Frustrated in Ontario
said
Tom in Toronto
said
WTF!?
Ian in Mississauga
said
=============================
What an insane comment to make. It was the Conservatives (Harper himself) that were caught on tape trying to bribe an MP. Please don't show your ignorance here. It makes you look bad. Harper hasn't had much luck when it comes to tapes has he, Raitt, Lukiski, Cadman, and now he's going thru miles of tape on Iggy and so far has NOTHING.
Stephie in Ontario
said
"This is a competent woman who is bieng attaked for office politics" Have you actually bothered to read the article? Raitt was caught on tape saying that an Isotope shortage and people getting cancer "is sexy" that doesn't sound anywere close to ever being competent that sounds irresponsible to the extreme. I hope she is fired and replaced with a responsible person who can do the job right.
my take on this
said
Dale
said
John in king
said
Habs
said
Look at the ads they run against the liberals!
dirty american style politics
Harper, we are not Americans.
Samira
said
That was just a total job-suicide.
R.I.P
Doug
said
J.Hooper
said
Colour me 'red' Mike any way you choose
said
George in Calgary
said
Troy in B.C.
said
Dave from Alberta
said
Can't wait for the next time :-).
Cathie north of the Big Smoke
said
This was a set up pure and simple. The truth will come out over the next couple days.
Adam in Ottawa
said
georgian
said
SunCoaster
said
jed derekson
said
politicians aren't serious about politics, just making snappy comments to grab cheap headlines...
Dennis
said
Samual
said
If we don't have an election it should be law that all conservatives wear clown costumes.
My father died of cancer recently, my mom, 6 sisters & me don't think there is anything sexy about cancer.
Not only is this the worst government in Canadian history, it seems there are some very mentally sick people in the conservative party.
John Connolly, Pitt Meadows
said
Wendy
said
Obviously you have your eyes closed & didn't read the article.
Anyone that thinks cancer is sexy is very sick & in need of mental help.
So please get some.
Attack Ad-Man
said
Cameron in Deux-Montagnes, Quebec
said
As someone who has recently been diagnosed with cancer, is currently undergoing chemotherapy and has an aunt in the last stage of battling cancer, I can tell you that it is not sexy. Walk a day in my shoes and see how sexy you feel. Do the honourable thing and resign - not just from cabinet but as an M.P. as well. You have demonstrated the worst in human compassion and caring. May you never have this sexy disease!
Gary (Toronto)
said
Rick the cleaner
said
North of 60
said
Yes, the aide made a couple of huge mistakes in leaving the information lying around, but she didn't script what was said: that blame lies solely with Raitt.
Regardless of what party was involved in this, Raitt needs to step down and Harper needs to let her. There is zero credibility here.
Mark ( Toronto)
said
It was her own aid.
And even if the evil empire had a plant in her office, they don't have mind control to make her say such a horrible thing.