CTV News | Napolitano says tougher border good for Canada

Top Stories -   

Napolitano says tougher border good for Canada

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News: Robert Fife covers Napolitano's visit
Power Play: U.S. Secretary of Homeland Security Janet Napolitano explains why tough border security is necessary
Power Play: Public Safety Minister Peter Van Loan on Canadian security concerns

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(38)

CTV.ca News Staff

Date: Wed. May. 27 2009 10:54 PM ET

U.S. Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano says there are legitimate security concerns along the Canadian border that require tough new measures, and Canadians should realize that both sides will benefit.

But she would not comment on specific groups or individuals who may pose a concern, or whether suspected terrorists have been apprehended along the border without the public's knowledge.

"I think it is fair to say, and I think Canadian law enforcement would say, that there are individuals in Canada whose information is being shared with the United States and vice versa," Napolitano told CTV's Power Play on Wednesday.

During the interview, she repeatedly said that Canadians and U.S. citizens have a shared interest in border security.

"We know, for example, that we have some terrorist groups in the United States, and Canadians have an interest in being protected there, and likewise," she said at one point. "So we need to be working together to make sure we're sharing information."

She also touched on differences between immigration in Canada and the U.S., but would not say whether she felt those differences exposed a risk to the U.S.

"I don't want to say it that way in part because I have discovered Canada is very sensitive to that kind of implication," she said.

At an earlier press conference in Ottawa with Public Safety Minister Peter Van Loan, the two officials announced they had signed a number of new joint trade and security initiatives.

One of the programs is a joint assessment of threats to border security, while another would allow emergency vehicles, workers and equipment to cross the border more quickly in the event of an emergency.

The goal of both nations, Van Loan and Napolitano said, is to improve security and trade simultaneously -- saying one doesn't have to happen at the expense of the other.

But Napolitano, who cut her teeth as a politician in Arizona where problems along the Mexico-U.S. border is always a major issue, has come under criticism for seeming to focus on security over trade.

On March 25, she suggested the Mexican and Canadian borders should be treated the same.

Speaking on Power Play, Napolitano said there were obvious differences between the two borders, but U.S. law does not distinguish between the two.

"My job is to implement the law," she said. "But the techniques we use are going to be very different because the countries are very different and the challenges of the borders are very different."

But she added that contraband does enter the U.S. from Canada, and there is also illegal immigration -- although "the numbers are not the same as "Mexico" -- going both ways.

She also said she was taken aback by continuing criticism from Canadians after an embarrassing "misstatement," when she suggested some of the Sept. 11 terrorists entered the U.S. from Canada.

"In the United States, I've misspoken from time to time. I've been in elected office -- you immediately correct it, you apologize and move on," she said.

"What I regret is that Canada can't seem to get beyond one misstatement from what I'm trying to suggest. And what I am suggesting is that we share security concerns, just as we share trade concerns, and share all kinds of concerns. It behooves us both -- both nations -- to work together. We will, in the end, be stronger together."

Comments are now closed for this story

Mark Erwin
said
0 0

...and what I regret is that the United States Homeland Security Chief doesn't think that it's a big deal that she didn't realize that NONE of the 9-11 terrorists came into the US from Canada. I also regret any implication that the US/Canadian border is remotely like the one with Mexico. There are not many Canadians desperately trying to escape from Canada into the US. In fact these days, members of the US armed forces appear to be desperate to escape the US into Canada.

This woman is a lightweight.





Steve
said
0 0

Time to find some new trading partners.


MuskyBuck
said
0 0

Napolitano, take your concerns, your paranoia and your American fear mongering back to your quasi police state.

We don't need you or your culture of fear here.


Sean in Waterloo
said
0 0

LOL at the misstatement she is referring too...

She out right blamed Canada for 9/11. Americans are always blaming everyone else for their problems. Maybe they should focus more on themselves.


Bill
said
0 0

I like the U.S. President but he picked a real loser here and she needs to be replaced.


Mary
said
0 0

I agree with what you said and the other comments as well. This woman Napolitano or whatever her name is, is obviously trying to deflect attention off herself because she knows she said some stupid untrue things, so what better way to get negative attention off yourself than by changing the subject by saying "well its to Canada's benefits as well that the border be secure."

Canada has spent billions of dollars on border security because they were pushed to by the U.S. I am not saying U.S. security should not have been made stronger after 9/11. It should but to what extent? The border between Canada and the U.S. was not why 9/11 happened. And now we Canadians and Americans all need passports. How will that solve anything when all the 9/11 terrorists who piloted the planes ib 9/11 were all legally entitled to live in the U.S. Napolitano says we Canadians should get over her earlier comments, well maybe the comments lingered on because she never apologized for her wrong comments earlier.

That's another deflection to get attention off her for her gaffes. She has a lot to learn about tact and diplomacy.


Geffen
said
0 0

I like it.
Good for Canada, cause it means we can keep and spend more of our dollars in our own backyard.
Napolitano's bosses are starting to lose it.


Zircon
said
0 0

It's truly absurd that she or anyone else would even consider pointing the finger at Canada for the 9/11 events. EVEN IF the perpetrators entered the US from here, it isn't Canadian border policy/enforcement that let them in, IT WAS THE UNITED STATES CUSTOMS AT THEIR ENTRY POINTS.

It amazes me that people can attain positions of power/responsibility such as hers and have such a shallow or non-existent grasp of logic.


meerkat
said
0 0

This woman seems to think the Canadian border and the Mexican border are the same thing. This woman seems to think a lot of things that don't make very much sense.

We are already painfully aware in Canada that intelligence is not a prerequisite to an elected position in the United States. Why should it be a prerequisite to an appointed position in the president's cabinet? Maybe a geography lesson would be a good place to start.

And finally, just one question to Mrs Napolitano..

Why do so many different cultures and countries have such a hate on for your country that they are constantly trying to infiltrate your borders? If you can come up with the answer to that, maybe you can come up with the answer to your border concerns.


John
said
0 0

We should have borders as the European Union has. But than would Canada like to have Americans coming to our country with guns in their pockets if it were chewing gum??


Sheri
said
0 0

this is your typical American...ignorant of the world beyond their borders to a nauseating degree...she can't even admit she was wrong - it was Canada that was insensitive - well I'd rather be insensitive than the bully of the world the U.S. has become.


Gordon Phillips
said
0 0

Napalitano could not even control her homestate border. She was quite willing to allow illegals cross the border in AZ at will and provide them the same services that citizens recieve. How she ever landed this job is beyond me and counting on her to secure the entire US is very scary.


Stephen Strepsi Montreal
said
0 0

Trade, yes, but I don't know why so many Canadians vacation in the U.S. From Dawson City Yukon, to Jasper Alberta, to whale watching in Tadoussac Quebec, I have camped in some of the most amazing places on earth -- right here in Canada. Scr*w the border.... CANADIAN VACATIONS, Y'ALL!


Linda
said
0 0

What Napolitano calls a simple "misstatement" was/is a deeply disturbing accusation to Canadians. One that has been "misstated" before and sticks in the minds of Americans and Canadians alike. What I find even more disturbing is that she as an American has the bloody gall to lecture us about what we should find upsetting. Maybe we are just a bit sensitive to having a finger pointed at us for harbouring the terrorists that killed 1500 innocent people! Oh well.. pish, pish..let's just all forget the whole thing and move on so we can focus on her profound wisdom.
How quickly she has forgotten the many, many Canadians that were there digging through the rubble shoulder to shoulder with our American neighbours and we grieved with them as well.


Chris
said
0 0

In response to the above....
Homeland security will forever be scrutinized as it does impose a number things on citizens of the US and of all those entering the states....as for Canada we have to tug along and do as the states do...and here we are not. We can work together but must remain separate as much as possible. I agree that Nap should take her paranoia elsewhere. Where did the Pres find her anyways?


Robert Brise
said
0 0

Yes we Canadians tend to remember idiotic statements
uttered by people of importance. We also can tell the difference between deliberate misinformation that is used to try and bolster certain politicians popularity.

Katie
said
0 0

This woman is in a position so far over her head that its sad and frightening. If I were an American I would not feel very safe with this woman at the helm of Homeland Security.

MW in Thunder Bay
said
0 0

She knows that she is incompetent and that the American government is virtually impotent when it comes to properly securing its souther border. And, let's face it, Mexico is the real issue here.

But just like governments who favor gun control among law abiding citizens, it's simply easier for Mrs. Napolitano to hassle her neighbours to the north who have not done anything wrong and pose no security threat.


Peter1951
said
0 0

911 was a day the world will never forget, it was a very sad day and many people lost their lives that day including Canadians. But the Americans said that they will never let those terrorist put fear in the heart of Americans. But I regret to say, the Americans have been scared stiff ever since that day and you can tell by their voices and their policies.

The Terrorists are laughing, they have accomplished exactly what they set out to do, and that is to keep the American looking over their shoulders 24/7. But for the USA to give Canada the cold shoulder is the wrong message to send out to the world. This USA Canada border has been a model to the rest of the world how two peaceful and free countries can get along and the Americans are so paranoid they are destroying the great relationship we have always had. And Canada being the USA largest trading partner this is going to only hurt this world economic situation even more.


Goldens
said
0 0

Waiting in line to cross the boarder, having to get a passport is not a benefit. I don't care what she says.

JW
Btwn NS


Joel Bain
said
0 0

Why is anybody listening to her? She has already shot her mouth off about the 9/11 terrorists allegedly coming through Canada. Clearly she isn't well-informed about the facts to begin with.


DV88
said
0 0

Napolitano: First you need to PROPERLY train your own border patrols and customs officers before commenting on what other nations need to do with their securities. The problem lies within your borders and not outside of it.


Doug BC
said
0 0

I'm not fond of Obama's choice for this job.This woman is not well informed at all.
That said,it's time to move on.She screwed up by commenting on the 9/11 terrorists.Get over it.
Thinking Canadians know all to well how weak our immigration system is.Add to that the joke we call a justice system,and the fact that Canadians would rather have free day care than a well equipped military that can handle most of our own security issues,and it's easy to understand why the USA has reservations about it's northern cousins.
If "Steve" wants us to have new trading partners for our exports,I hope he supports lower taxes.If that doesn't happen,few of our businesses will be able to compete,or sell to any but the wealthiest nations on the planet.I actually agree with "Steve".But Canadians seem unwilling to make the sacrifices needed to get us from where we are now,to where we want to be in the future.Until we get our own house in order,we NEED the USA market a lot more than they need ours.
You want real sovereignty for your children? To do that we need lower taxes,a lot less debt,fewer people living on "free" handouts by government,and a military that is well enough equipped to work productively with our NATO partners.
As long as we don't take security seriously,the USA will continue to tighten up the border.They have no choice.This is one of the unintended consequences of Trudeau's neglect of our military.
I don"t like this woman.But we have orchestrated this mess ourselves by being to cheap to properly fund our share of North America's defense needs.


Brian In... well... they already know over there.
said
0 0

Contraband coming from Canada? Like what... pot? Thank goodness weapons, coke, heroine, spies, escaped convicts or uneducated american politicians don't enter our country from the U.S.


Colline
said
0 0

It has been almost 9 years since 911 and this woman still cannot get the facts straight. That is why we are not accepting of her supposed misstatement. Someone in her position should have a better knowledge of such facts. She needs to clearify this with the American people if she really means her appology.


Mike from Toronto
said
0 0

Economy is in ruins and were still debating whether we should spend more tax dollars to further slow down trade across the border.


Kevin
said
0 0

Let's stop dealing with the greedy USA. New trading parners needed! They are broke anyways.


Robert Buchanan
said
0 0

The terrorists have probably been using phony passports for years, so they're still laughing.

I just know that my US neighbours in Arizona (I'm a sometime snowbird) won't be heading to Canada anytime soon to visit their daughter who married a Canadian and moved to Ontario.

It's almost going to be a spectator sport in my neck of the woods on Monday. There are 2 "rural" border crossings nearby, and the US side just got the full construction treament of concrete and steel barriers designed to keep the "heathens" out.

I just wonder what the local US folk are going to do when they cross the border into Canada to enjoy their favoured exchange rate and then can't get back home without a passport.



Brian
said
0 0

I've had it with the Americans and their all sizzle and no steak "Obama". We should be the one's building a wall to keep out their guns, drugs and unfair trade practises. In some fairness to the US, they are right in that our drug,refugee and immigration laws are much more lax than theirs,hence their concern.


Tim ontario
said
0 0

I agree there are concerns with the borders but before we fix them perhaps we should consider turning off the oil pipe line from northern Alberta or the hydro switchs from Hudson Bay or New Brunswick I would think the US administration would seriously reconsider their border concepts


Bay
said
0 0

And just after the European Union had opened their borders for economic growth and prosperity. Fatherland Security is not the answer.


Prof. Pye Chartt
said
0 0

WHAT WAS THAT, JANET?!

"She also touched on differences between immigration in Canada and the U.S., but would not say whether she felt those differences exposed a risk to the U.S.

'I don't want to say it that way in part because I have discovered Canada is very sensitive to that kind of implication,' she said."
________________

Where did you get that impression? (From this forum?)


Murray W.
said
0 0

The US President has failed in every appointee. He can talk with a teleprompter but he hasn't got a clue as how to run a country. I'll take that back. He knows how to run a country, into the ground!


George Poole in Lunenburg
said
0 0

What a shame, at one time if you wanted to immigrate/visit the USA you just showed up at the border, told the customs agent you were a Canadian citizen and were visiting such and such or entering the US for such and such a reason, end of story, however I blame our terrorist/war criminal loving liberals for the current state of affairs, not going to blame the USA for that.


Dennis L. Krahn
said
0 0

Ms. Napolitano has admitted that she misspoke, so, give it up and listen to everything else she has to say.

Only idiots would say that here are no problems at the 49th parallel.

Given the immigration policies of both the US and Canada there is a good chance that undesireables abound in both countries.

We live close to the Americans, let us work together and get busy fixing the problems.




Denny in Sask
said
0 0

You would expect someone holding the top job for homeland security would be competent and well informed of border issues. Unfortunately she is neither. We can only hope Obama has realized his mistake and a replacement will be named when he's re-elected.

Americans and Canadians deserve better than this blundering woman.


Kerry
said
0 0

Get over it! I cross the border several times a year with our RV, have always carried a Passport and its not a big deal. Sometimes we sit for a few minutes going into the US and sometimes we sit just as long coming back into Canada. You are still treated way better than at any airport - I have never experienced anything but courtesy and professionalism.

The US has the right to protect its borders the way it sees fit, just as we do.


stevo
said
0 0

Why do you need to travel to the US? If you have relatives or do business there get used to the lineups. I used to go a few times a year prior to 2001 but I haven't been since before 911 and the sky in my world hasn't fallen. As for holiday travel check out Canada first if you haven't seen it all not to mention the fact that there's a world beyond North America that few Canadians ever see. So the border is tightening up and Canadians now need documentation like everyone else. Big Deal.


Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz