Canada -
News Sections
Canadians quarantined in China over H1N1 worries
CTV News Video
Watch: See all Videos in the Player
Font-size:
Share
Print
Comments(63)
CTV.ca News Staff
Date: Mon. May. 4 2009 5:54 PM ET
Two groups of Canadians in China are being held in quarantine in hotel rooms as a precaution against the H1N1 flu, Canada's Department of Foreign Affairs confirmed Monday.
One group consists of tourists, who are being placed under "preventative medical surveillance" at the Metro Park Hotel in the Wanchia district of Hong Kong.
Foreign Affairs spokesperson Alain Cacchione told The Canadian Press that, according to Chinese authorities, it was confirmed one of the guests tested positive for the H1N1 influenza virus.
"Consular officials have been assured by local authorities that all guests are being well cared for and have access to amenities including food and communications," Cacchione said from Ottawa.
"We have no indication at this time that any of them are showing flu-like symptoms."
Meanwhile, Sophie Langlois, director of media relations for the Universite de Montreal, confirmed to CTV.ca that students with the university's Centre for Studies in East Asia have also been quarantined.
Langlois said the professor leading the students on the trip said they are being held at a hotel in the northern city of Changchun.
The students are in China to study Mandarin and are taking part in a language exchange program.
On Saturday, they had flown from Beijing to Changchun, where they were met by health officials at the airport and taken to a room to have their temperatures taken.
Peter Kent, the minister responsible for overseas consular services, confirmed Monday that 22 students out of a class of 28 are currently in quarantine.
"They were originally quarantined in a university dorm, but after complaints, Chinese authorities moved them to a hotel," Kent told CTV's Power Play on Monday.
Kent noted that the students say they have been treated well and are free to move around the hotel.
"That said, we have asked Chinese authorities for an explanation of why this happened here," he said. "They passed through Beijing with no complications."
While no one in the group has a fever or is showing signs of illness, they were told they would have to be quarantined for seven days.
The group must have medical examinations in which their temperatures are taken, four times a day.
China has not reported any cases of H1N1 flu. The only person in east Asia to have been diagnosed with the virus is a Mexican traveller who was identified last week in Hong Kong.Dr. Keiji Fukuda, acting assistant director-general of for Health Security and Environment at the World Health Organization, was asked about such quarantines at Monday morning's daily news conference.
"I don't want to comment on the disease control actions of specific countries," Fukuda said.
"I do want to point out that quarantine, in certain situations, can be a quite reasonable action to take in specific situations. There are times when it would be reasonable and other times when it would not.
"But as we've mentioned over and over again, situations differ and countries' approaches to disease control measures are choices. There is no set recipe for how you approach disease control."
User Tools
Related Stories
CTV.ca News
Tips for Parents
How to spot swine flu in kids, when to treat it at home and when to call your doctor.
Health Blog
Infectious disease expert Dr. Neil Rau offer his thoughts on swine flu on the CTV MedNews Express blog.
Related Websites
User Tools
About the tools
Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.
-


Font-size
Print Article
Comments(63)-
Feedback
Share it with your network of friends
Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.
Most Viewed News Stories
Most Talked about Stories
I applaud the budget, even though Health Care and education may stay unscathed. Sadly this cannot last and I worry to later this year where cuts will become enviable. If anything, this provides the Wildrose Alliance plenty of ammo when an election is called.




Comments are now closed for this story
CC
said
Dave
said
Hey this this is going well...don't you think?
DANIEL H
said
Bob A
said
Treat others how you want to be treated
said
See their reaction!! I get it if they are sick but even then they are human and deserve to treated accordingly. Do they lock their people up when there is an outbreak of H5N1 Bird Flu which is far deadlier than this H1N1 flu going around now... not!!!
AndyL
said
Jan
said
Get a grip there China!
said
Katie
said
Anne
said
dolly the sheep
said
Jenn in Ottawa
said
If they're banning pork imports and all travel to our country, then we should assume they don't want people from our country traveling into theirs. Dido for the quarantine of Mexicans in China. China does not want their own people traveling to Mexico. It should be clear that they wouldn't want Mexicans traveling into their country.
Obviously there's a lot of fear out there. There's also a lot of skeptics. Nobody is RIGHT in this type of situation.
There will always be over reactors and under reactors. But even those definitions are relative and our opinions of various reactions are bound to change as time goes by and we learn more about this virus.
Mark -Vegreville, AB
said
This isn't just a China over reaction. People all over the world and the governments have gone off the deep end over this scare. As the saying goes "The road to Hell is paved with good intentions".
Maurice
said
China cannot afford an outbreak, they have to take extra precautions because they don't have the resources to manage another strain of flu virus spreading throughout China.
Here in canada in less then 24 hours its the cases of the flu virus doubled.
As the cases increase the higher the chances of this strain turning into something worse.
Kat - Ottawa, currently in China
said
Jackie Barrett
said
First step is to impose trade sanctions and embargoes against China for over-reacting and targeting Canadians though they test negative for H1N1.
China, food for thought, did we quarantine Chinese citizens during the SARS epidemic which originated in China? No we didn't.
Therefore, during the Swine Influenza epidemic, you have to right to quarantine Canadian citizens.
Stop over-reacting China.
We treated your citizens fairly during the SARS Epidemic, now its your turn to treat Canadian citizens in your country fairly. Remember, what goes around, comes around.
Greg from AT
said
Look at what these narrow mind people are talking about. These students are only quarantined for 7 days and not forever. Langlois says the students and their professor are being treated well, have Internet and email access and are being provided with meals.
Are you talking about right? freedome? lol. Do you fly to Mexica right now?
Roger T
said
If our Gov't had done a better job perhaps the cases wouldn't have jumped from 13 to over 100.....
China is taking the right steps and swift unlike many other countries who are dragging and spreading it around.
Rick in NB
said
How can you blame the Media. Just look at the fiction other posters are creating over the fact that some students are being treated well in a hotel in China. And i would imagine that they are still learning the Chinese language. Why protest a working vacation.
PS: Posters find something worthwhile to complain about.
Rob W. -Toronto
said
Also, China has a lot of pig-chicken-duck households that present a huge problem when it comes to a brand new strain of swine flu. I think they are simply taking no chances and applying a policy across the board to eliminate ANY possibility of error given the possible consequences. Every situation like this has 12 things that can go wrong you are able to predict and 50 you can't foresee. (eg. Pig herd infection in Alberta) That is really the reason for any and all precautions.
KJ in Kingston Ontario
said
John Savard
said
Cedric, Montreal
said
Outbreak
said
You're on your own!
said
Canadian in forgein countries - they are their own.
I think it is fair since our Harper Government didn't try to help some Canadian oversea in past.
Harper's government recently stated that Canadian should educated themselves that once they left Canada they are on their own.
So if your in China and flu outbreak so you are on your own and you must respect China communist's decision whether to quarantined you for time being.
At least it isn't bad as being stuck in Mexico prison.
Irony eh? Good luck to these Canadians.
reese
said
Dan
said
Tamz
said
Ted
said
Lisa
said
Payback for their own poisoning/recall nightmares from last year? Hard to believe they have no cases considering their population numbers...but then it took them a really really long time to report the emergence of SARS too.
Tony
said
Cyle Hagen
said
5th generation Canadian
said
yoshi
said
H.Ren
said
Sam
said
Andrew Chisholm
said
Mother shaking her head
said
talisker8888
said
Tom in Winnnipeg
said
Kat
said
The Canadian students that are being held in quarantine are not in prison, or a cramped hospital or any of the other horrifying images you'd think when you hear the word quarantine.
These students are being held as the only GUESTS in a great hotel where they are being fed and treated well.
This whole situation has been completely blown out of proportion. The worst thing these students have to deal with is a little bit of boredom.
annoyed with stupidity
said
Helen from Toronto
said
For those Canadian who never travel to Asia - especially China, there is a note to take in this case.
It might sound terrible for Chinese to "lock up" our Canadian students at the hotel.
But China has such a big population and crowded density plus the climate is getting hotter now, they just don't want to take a chance!
This is only a 7 days stay. Take the most out of it. Relax, enjoy! It will soon be over with!
Similiar situtation happened to me too
said
I truly feel for you. Back on 2003 when the SARS was breaking, I was in line at the check out of Dominion.
I started to cough and everybody turned their head towards me. I am Asian. I immediately had to tell them that "No, I did not go to China. My Canadian passport got expired! I was in Toronto for the whole time."
Yes, people are very over react nowsdays! Because we all only live ONCE! Nobody wants to get sick or even die! Can't blame them.
Be patient. It will be over with. Then something stronger will come out again! Never ends. Do your best to protect yourself and your family.
Anastasia
said
Pia Brown Calgary
said
they would loose their jobs. China most always look good, so if any other country has annything like the swine flue, they want to show the world that they are pro-acting. Shame on them for quaintine the Canadians- but not one bit suprised
Russ
said
Ken
said
The flu is not a big deal, then please go to Mexico for a week. Don't wash your hands, brace the children there. Try it out and see how strong your body is. Let's do it and prove it to the work H1N1 is not deadly at all.
Pre-cautionary is good. These students are treated well, Chinese gov't contact Canada embassy first for this. The students are allowed to call home, well fed, have the whole hotel to enjoy. They can play cards, read a book, watch TV (there is English channel in china's hotel). China is much better than before. Their action is excellent in terms of protecting their citizens.
MAL
said
Remember the next time China plays with the milk, or sells polluted wheat germ to kill our pets, or send families to Detroit and other cities to bulk buy homes or allows families to drown baby girls.
Remember this.
Next time ban all their third rate crap for good.
neednottoknow
said
1.All Chinese passengers from Beijing or Shanghai were quarantined in Vancouver for three days during SARS.
2.In Canada, the confirmed cases jumped from 13 to 101 in 5 days.
3.The action is done by a Chinese provincial government, not national wide
4.One passenger from Mexico was confirmed with H1N1 in Hong Kong. Two days later, all passengers who had boaded on that plane were put in quarantine. So they are not just do this to Canadians.
guppies
said
I just don't understand why some people post here say China is over doing it. If they take action, you guys complaint and if they don't you guys complaint.
You can ask Harper, see he will send a plane to pick up all Canadian under quarantine.
I bet you he will point at you and start laughing...lol
Good Job ! China
Jackson k.
said
Kate
said
Before I visited Hong Kong I was well aware that if I entered the airport with a fever, I would be quarantined.
If you are aware what actions the country you are vacationing practice than this would not be a big surprise.
This is not something new and the media is blowing this out of proportion.
Travel is not for the ignorant.
guppies
said
The top official from "WHO" she is from China.
And you think China will not 100% backing her up. Just in case something turn bad. Specially after "SAR"
And so what quarantines the Canadian students for 7 days will not kill them. And if they don't and if something wrong with the kids after.
What will you say...
If I am the student Dad, I will be very happy to see China take this action. At least to keep my kid save for now.
Doing something is better not to do anything.
When I see one fish was sick in my tank. I quanatine the whole tank for 2 weeks and
I raise the temp. too...lol
Am I too hard to my fishes ?
Nite Owl
said
Donny
said
1.All Chinese passengers from China were quarantined in Vancouver for three days during SARS.
2.The Mexican in Hongkong has be confirmed with H1N1 flu. What do you want the local authority to do? Let him shopping round the streets?
China did right action to deal with the flu. All the people in the hotel potentially will infect the public.
What the Mexico's reaction is definely overreact. Why there are other countries doing the same quarantine measures and Mexico just complain China? This is really interesting.
Victor King
said
And then there is the freedom of speech. During the Bush post 911 era, there may still be democracy but there is no freedom of speech. So please cut this nonsense out.
I also sense that some of those who disagree with the quarantine in China will be more than eager to quarantine the Mexican.
Only if we are more understandable.
K Xie
said
Reece
said
"Pre-cautionary is good. These students are treated well, Chinese gov't contact Canada embassy first for this. The students are allowed to call home, well fed, have the whole hotel to enjoy."
To be held in a stinky hotel for 7 days isn't being treated well. Why are they systematically taking these vacationers to a hotel and holding them there? Why not just bar travellers to China before they depart? A dozen Mexican were held as they got off their plane and although none are showing signs of this flu they nevertheless have to languish in a hotel in china. 7 days - $2500 for a flight to China only to sit in a hotel? Only a communist mouth piece would see nothing wrong with that. Cancel the flights to Mexico for gods sakes!!
Jimmy W,Toronto
said
The facts are:
The quarantine is a provincial measure and not part of a national plan by the Chinese government. The quarantine doesn't target Canadians.
Jilin Province has a large Korean population and has close economic ties with Korea.
South Korean has recently confirmed first H1N1 case.
The city of Changchun is very friendly to Canada. They even have a college named after Canadian Doctor Henry Norman Bethune.
Canadians shouldn't fan the flame of hate towards anyone.
Sharon Papequash Yorkton, SK
said
I think China is doing the right thing.
Gary in Toronto
said
1. Chines have more than 40 times population than Canada, Beijing is even more crowed. If the disease spread, that would be a disaster (both china and world)
2. China is still a developing country, who can not afford a outbreak.
3. Swine flu could spread even people without any symptoms.
4. Chinese suffered from 2003 SARS, they learned lesson from it and awared they should do whatever they could to prevent spread.
5. Student are in luxious hotel and treat well just in 7 days.
Please be nice, and take off your colorful glasses. Don't put any thing in the wrong categories just because done by Chinese government.
Paul Lefort
said
On the upside, with close to 20% of world population, the Chinese cannot be blamed for being a tad over-careful.