News Sections
Mexico City in lockdown as U.S. downplays flu
CTV News Video
Watch: See all Videos in the Player
Font-size:
Share
Print
Comments(64)
CTV.ca News Staff
Date: Fri. May. 1 2009 8:18 PM ET
As the U.S. appeared to downplay rising alarm about the global H1N1 flu outbreak Friday, residents in Mexico City were under a government-ordered lockdown which made the world's second-largest city look like a ghost town.
While the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention said the current illness is an "unusual" combination of human and swine flu genes, it lacks the genetic power of last century's pandemic, which was one of the worst in history.
The 1918 outbreak, an H1N1 strain which struck healthy young adults, killed up to 50 million worldwide.
"We do not see the markers for virulence that were seen in the 1918 virus," Dr. Nancy Cox, the CDC's flu chief, said in Atlanta on Friday.
Echoing that sentiment, U.S. President Barack Obama said scientists aren't yet sure if the current outbreak is actually worse than "ordinary flus," which strike the public every year.
While the new flu "is relatively mild on the front end, it could come back in a more virulent form during the actual flu season," Obama warned in Washington, following a cabinet meeting dominated by discussions about the illness.
However, in Mexico City, the danger remained very real.
The massive metropolis is considered ground zero for the outbreak, and so far, 15 people have died from the infection and another 343 have been infected.
While the city's streets are usually crowded and bustling this time of year with May Day revellers, the streets were nearly deserted Friday as millions obeyed an order to stay home for five days.
Only essential services like hospitals and supermarkets will remain open over the break, which is aimed at ending the spread of the illness.
Meanwhile, the World Health Organization said there is "no doubt" scientists can quickly develop a vaccine for the H1N1 flu virus as news broke Friday that the virus had spread to France.
Marie-Paule Kieny, director of the WHO's initiative for vaccine research, said samples needed to make a vaccine could be ready to send to manufacturers by mid-May.
However, he added that it would take four to six months for the first doses to be made public.
"We have no doubt that making a successful vaccine is possible in a relatively short period of time," Kieny said Friday in Geneva.
Kieny said it's unlikely the seasonal vaccine will be effective against the H1N1 virus.
Anne Schuchat, an interim deputy director at the CDC, said officials must plan for vaccines a long time in advance. She said officials are working on creating a vaccine as a precautionary measure.
"We haven't made the decision yet that we will manufacture large numbers of doses of vaccine and we haven't made the decision yet that we will use a vaccine if we produce a lot of it," Schuchat told reporters Friday.
"Those are decisions that need to be done in a deliberative, careful, thoughtful way... it's really scientific expertise that helps with those types of decisions."
The WHO said the H1N1 flu has been confirmed in 14 countries around the world.
Gregory Hartl, a spokesperson for the WHO, Officials in Hong Kong, Denmark and France also independently reported cases of H1N1 flu Friday.
In Mexico, there have been 15 confirmed deaths. In the U.S., there has been one death linked to the outbreak.
In total, here is the breakdown of confirmed cases worldwide from the WHO:
- Mexico: 343
- U.S.: 149
- Canada: 51 cases
- Spain: 13 cases
- United Kingdom: 11 cases
- Germany: 5 cases
- New Zealand: 3 cases
- France: 2 cases
- Israel: 2 cases
- Netherlands: 1 case
- Switzerland: 1 case
- Denmark: 1 case
- Hong Kong: 1 case
- Austria: 1 case
In Hong Kong, officials said the victim was a Mexican citizen who developed a fever Thursday after arriving in the Chinese territory via Shanghai.
The patient has reportedly been isolated in hospital and is in stable condition.
As a sign of increasing concern about the outbreak, a Washington-bound flight from Germany had to be diverted after a passenger complained of flu-like symptoms.
The plane, with 245 passengers and 14 crew, landed in Boston at the request of the CDC on Friday afternoon.
A 53-year-old female passenger was taken off the plane and taken to hospital and the flight continued onto Washington.
It isn't yet known if the woman has the H1N1 flu.
WHO on defensive
Meanwhile, the chief epidemiologist in Mexico, where H1N1 flu was first reported, said the WHO responded too slowly to warnings about the health crisis.
Dr. Miguel Angel Lezana is calling for an investigation of the WHO, saying his centre alerted the Pan American Health Organization about the problem as early as April 16.
Eight days later, the WHO said it was "very, very concerned" about the threat of a pandemic.
"It seems it should have been more immediate," Lezana, director of the National Epidemiology Center, told The Associated Press in a recent interview.
In response, the WHO said Friday that they learned of cases of "suspicious influenza" on April 9 from Mexico.
The WHO said it responded quickly on April 24 when U.S. and Canadian laboratories identified the virus as the H1N1 flu.
"We moved into operation within a matter of hours," WHO spokesman Thomas Abraham told reporters.
To stop the spread of the virus, Mexico has ordered a suspension of nonessential federal government and private business activity from May 1-5.
The WHO raised its alert level to Phase 5 Wednesday, meaning the probability of a pandemic is "high to certain," as the virus spreads around the planet.
However, Abraham said Friday that there were no meetings of the emergency committee scheduled for today.
The committee can recommend whether to raise the WHO's pandemic alert level.
With files from The Associated Press
User Tools
Related Stories
CTV.ca News
Tips for Parents
How to spot swine flu in kids, when to treat it at home and when to call your doctor.
Health Blog
Infectious disease expert Dr. Neil Rau offer his thoughts on swine flu on the CTV MedNews Express blog.
User Tools
About the tools
Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.
-


Font-size
Print Article
Comments(64)-
Feedback
Share it with your network of friends
Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.
Most Viewed News Stories
Most Talked about Stories
I applaud the budget, even though Health Care and education may stay unscathed. Sadly this cannot last and I worry to later this year where cuts will become enviable. If anything, this provides the Wildrose Alliance plenty of ammo when an election is called.




Comments are now closed for this story
ZZZ
said
Lynn in Hamilton
said
Sean H. in Ottawa
said
I'm about to be a first time father and it's hard to not be paranoid. I found myself ebaying hazmat suits yesterday for my wife... Free shipping if I buy 2.
Daveyboy
said
Mark
said
I don't think there is such a thing as overreaction and if there is it is better to over-react quickly and isolate a new virus than have business as normal with the possibility of allowing a pandemic to occur, which is only based on history a matter of time before a very serious one occurs. Along with Sars this helps all countries and health agencies in the decision making process on a go forward basis.
I would have preferred that Mexico had immediately shut its borders on April 16th and anyone vacationing have been quarantined in a hospital or their homes upon return to their home country until medically cleared. Thats how you lower the possibility of a Pandemic, not by taking a business as usual approach and watch the virus mutate and spread.
Seth
said
Dr. D. from Alberta
said
Bill in BC
said
Ordinary flu KILLS over 3500 Canadians yearly. This one....?
Health facilities in mexica, available to the public are not to our standards.
Hygene standards are much lower there than here....heard of hepatitis perhaps....
the airborne and water pollution in Mexico is far higher, making for a reduced immunity in the population.
So....
Is it a concern for public health?
Yes.
Is it cause to PANIC?
No.
This is NOT an airborne virus. This is NOT a NEW virus. This IS a varient of influenza that crosses over from animal to human and can still be transmitted between people. Really, not a huge deal. We get virus' from animals all the time, most are minor this one just happens to have the potential to make us sicker than most.
Simply take reasonable precautions that you should have been taking in your daily life all along:
Wash your hands regularly and don't cough and sit in your friends face.
Most important:
Don't panic.
If you think you are sick, see your doctor (which you should anyhow).
If you are are a member of a vulnerable group such as compromised immune system, get a prophylactic vaccine.
If you just got back from mexico, be aware.
Otherwise, stop - inhale - exhale - repeat as neccessary.
HT in SK
said
I want to point out that in 2007-2008 flu season there was a total of 88 Pediatric Deaths, and in the 2008-2009 season there was a reported 55 pediatric deaths associated to the common Influenza. This is according to the CDC records in which anyone can look at online!
With any cold/flu there will be associated deaths.
I dont think there is need to put people in Hazmat suits and totally freak out the world and cancel travel!
If that were the case then we would never leave our homes!
I think the travel advisorys are just a little much!
david sawkiw[saskatchewan farmer]
said
Can't blame anyone but the media for the hype,,, unless of course,, someone controls the media.
The economy seems to have taken the back seat lately..
Ann
said
Concerned Canadian
said
But what exactly should WHO have done? No one knows what will happen with this virus - it's simply impossible to predict the future course of the disease for either the next week or the next six months.
I'd rather WHO "overreacted" and got us ready for a very negative progress of the flu, than under respond and potentially risk the lives of millions.
And as for the claims that everyone is "panicking"- where exactly is that coming from? Prudent caution is certainly warranted, no matter how the disease progresses. "Panic" would mean people running amok in the streets. Has anyone done that yet?
Those claiming that WHO is causing panic don't actually have an argument unless they tremendously over exaggerate, do they?
But there are lots of people, for whatever reason, willing to do that. We see lots of them writing into these posts.
Where exactly is the evidence of mass panic? Have there been riots for Tamiflu in the streets of most American and Canadian cities? Have thousands committed suicide rather than face the uncertainty of the next few months? That's panic.
Or are people calmly going about their daily business, with some more caution as required, and showing the proper level of concern for what could be a very virulent outbreak?
Which is it really?
Responsibility
said
Kathleen
said
Blame game?
said
B. Kelley, Ontario
said
Sean H in Ottawa
said
J.F from Moose jaw
said
Arnaud
said
You scared people with your 150 deads in Mexico when you just couldn't look at any mexican newspaper to see there were only 15 confirmed deads of swine flu!
The worst desinformation transmissions are definitely newspapers and Tv!
"Swine flue is here"
"It's too late now"
"Swine flu in Canada NOW"
Come on! You enjoyed those titles!
Doug BC
said
Hype,over-reaction,very ridiculous expectations as to what should be done,and absurd panic in the face of a flu virus BEFORE anyone has a grip on the reality of the situation.
Sadly,this is all to often the way the "news" is presented.Or at least,the way it is interpreted.
Mexico is in no position to criticize anyone about being "slow to respond".I'm not casting a lot of blame on a country that doesn't have the capacity to respond themselves,but finger pointing on their part is hypocritical,to say the least.Especially when you consider that it's the USA that pays for most of their law enforcement,and is very tolerant towards those Mexican officials who offer excuses for those Mexicans that ignore American laws when they get to the USA.
I don't agree with "Mark" at all.His post assumes a rational public,able to differentiate between real knowledge,and preliminary speculation.I see little evidence that the majority of the general public will come to rational conclusions or even spend a little time sorting out fact from fiction before they start closing borders and banning travel.
Thousands of people in North America die EVERY YEAR from flu viruses.I doubt that will ever change.
Brian
said
Is this really a crisis?
Come on people, lets move on.
kenji
said
S. Wray
said
KH Victoria BC
said
Could someone confirm how many deaths occur each year based on non-specific flu's (The ones that occur annually and are not in the news)?
Let's put this story to rest...
KH
Victoria BC
Mar
said
Lisa
said
Andrea
said
WESTERNER
said
The other Lowell in BC
said
Calgary Researcher
said
WestofTheRockies
said
There are 331 confirmed cases, not deaths cases of this Flu in the world! 331 cases in what - SIX BILLION people?!
Now that's really something to light your hair on fire over.
This is nothing more than an opportunity for the WHO to try and justify their existence. In doing so they have completely shut down the Mexican economy & severely affected the US & Canadian economy.
1000's die every year from one flu strain or another.
God help us. What will we do when there is a real crisis?
jay
said
Those are the confirmed cases. It sounds there is a lot of cases waiting testing so we could very well be in the thousands by monday.
Ann
said
Adamwolf
said
Upon report of an outbreak, have the area effected quarantined, have the immediate suspension of all air travel, close all border crossings, flights and individuals already airborne are quarantined upon landing etc, etc, etc.
That is the only chance that we as a global community could have had a chance to have the virus contained and dealt with. But no can't cause a panic, global markets would crash, people would go over board, mass hysteria, etc, etc, etc...like something out of a science fiction movie.
Luckily this time the H1N1 has for the most part been a relatively mild contagion. I even bet there are those out there who may have had it, not known, over came what they thought was the regular flu and carried on like nothing happened. Maybe we as a global community/human race should take a lesson because the next time we may not be so lucky. Then again what are the odds....
Jim Leahy - Sunnyvale Trailer Park Supervisor
said
Dorothy
said
kent
said
Bess
said
Oh, but it will be too late to help most people. Well the thought was there, guess I'll still buy that neo-citran.
Dale - Edmonton
said
Harman from Montreal
said
And yeah, can people die with the H1N1 flu?
wanda
said
If the current outbreak turns out to follow a similar pattern, that would be "good and bad news," Simonsen said. It's bad news because a worse outbreak could conceivably follow.
Locked in my nuclear bunker...
said
Oh sorry, that was yesterday. Never mind.
Johnny05
said
Eyes Wide Open
said
Sensationalism is the norm now. Quite sickening. No pun intended.
WestofTheRockies
said
Well you can always count on some equally dumb comment to balance every stupid action.
"the vaccine killed way more people than the actual flu. This is actually pretty typical for vaccines though. I guess someone needed a way to push more drug sales"
Please tell me how many people you know of in the last 50 years who died of Polio, Malaria, Diphtheria, Tetanus, Whooping Cough, German Measles etc. etc. All common diseases millions of people contracted each year before vaccines were available and from which 10’s of thousands died.
Yes those big bad drug companies, murderers of testing rabbits and monkeys who are pillaging the sick and poor to fill their coffers.
Give us a break!! I’m kinda surprised you haven’t blamed this on the Canadian government yet.
angry hawk
said
Calm and Rational
said
As well, yes, there are only a small percentage of those suspected or confirmed to have this flu compared to the 'traditional' flu....but at the start of the flu season there is only a small number of sick and deceased as well. This is just starting - we do not have final numbers and probably won't for a few weeks or most likely months.
YKer from Ottawa
said
There are 30 million people in Canada, I think you have a better chance of catching West Nile now that spring is here. I bet more people got sick from West n=Nile last year that will get sick from H1N1.
Settle down for crying out loud!
Have faith in medical science-its pretty good
said
This is a fact that no educated person can dipute.
Also a fact, we understand contagion better than ever before and have the skills, infrastructure and technology to battle outbreaks.
So is "swine flu" a cause for concern?
Yes and we'll deal with it appropriattely using all the tools at our disposal.
Is is a cause for alarm and panic?
No because we'll deal with it appropriattely using all the tools at our disposal.
YKer in Ottawa
said
andyl
said
Calgary Researcher
said
I like how you didn't argue that the vaccine did indeed kill more people than the flu itself, because that is a fact. If you actually cared to find more facts you could also find that there is no correlation to the decrease in the diseases you mentioned versus the introduction of the vaccine.
Most diseases were on the decline before the introduction of the respective vaccine. As well, vaccine statistics have a strong record of using self-proving methods of showing 'proof' of them working. At any rate, there is hard science that shows how harmful they are, so why would anyone want to purposely harm themselves on the chance they 'may' get something later? Not very logical...
Oy Vey
said
I think I have the exact same odds of GROWING ANOTHER BELLY BUTTON.
davidovich
said
Pandemic? Let's get real.
Gail (Hamilton)
said
John in Ottawa
said
Until it reaches Level 6 it is very difficult to predict, so I would cut the WHO a bit of slack. So all you consiracy jockies need to grab a cold one and leave the predicting to the experts which you are not.
Munro - Brampton
said
Cheers to Jim:)
said
cam
said
Don't drink the KoolAid
said
Dunny from Manotick
said
schpid
said
By the way, the masks everyone is clamoring for; they do squat against viral infection. It's been stated by three different agencies.
GROW UP!!!!
said
I won't listen to the CDC or the WHO after this pointless scare. Post your worries on Youtube and stop cutting into the Family Guy to announce yet another dude with the sniffles. Seriously! Stop wasting our times and grow up!
Kerry
said