CTV News | U.S. security boss clarifies comments about border

Politics -   

U.S. security boss clarifies comments about border

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV Newsnet: Tom Clark on the diplomatic concerns

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(78)

CTV.ca News

Date: Wed. Apr. 22 2009 1:22 PM ET

The U.S. Homeland Security chief has clarified earlier remarks that suggested the 9-11 terrorists entered the U.S. through Canada.

Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano made the comments during a media interview earlier this week, much to the chagrin of Canadians on both sides of the border.

In a release Tuesday night following the interview, she called Canada a "close ally and an important partner" and said she was simply misunderstood.

"I know that the September 11th hijackers did not come through Canada to the United States," she said in the statement.

"There are other instances, however, when suspected terrorists have attempted to enter our country from Canada to the United States. Some of these are well-known to the public -- such as the Millennium Bomber -- while others are not due to security reasons."

Ottawa rushed to defend its border security on Tuesday amid the diplomatic scuffle that broke out over Napolitano's earlier remarks.

In recent years, Ottawa has invested a great deal of effort into dispelling perceptions among Americans that Canada's border is an easy entry point for terrorists planning attacks on U.S. soil.

"Unfortunately, misconceptions arise on something as fundamental as where the 9-11 terrorists came from," said Michael Wilson, Canada's ambassador in Washington.

"As the 9-11 commission reported in 2004, all of the 9-11 terrorists arrived in the United States from outside North America. They flew to major U.S. airports. They entered the U.S. with documents issued by the United States government and no 9-11 terrorists came from Canada."

Wilson, who was the keynote speaker at the Border Trade Alliance meeting in Washington on Tuesday, said Napolitano's staff attempted to tamp down the controversy by blaming the comments on a simple misunderstanding.

"Her comment from her people is that she misunderstood," Wilson said, adding that he was planning a personal meeting with Napolitano in the near future.

The furor began when Napolitano was asked to clarify statements she had made about equal treatment for the Mexican and Canadian borders, despite the fact that a flood of illegal immigrants and a massive drug war are two serious issues on the southern border.

"Yes, Canada is not Mexico, it doesn't have a drug war going on, it didn't have 6,000 homicides that were drug-related last year," she said.

"Nonetheless, to the extent that terrorists have come into our country or suspected or known terrorists have entered our country across a border, it's been across the Canadian border. There are real issues there."

When asked if she was referring to the 9-11 terrorists, Napolitano added: "Not just those but others as well."

However, Public Safety Minister Peter Van Loan downplayed the comments and said that Napolitano is well aware that Canada was not the source of the 9-11 terrorists.

"We spoke about it back in March, and we were sharing a chuckle at the fact that the urban myth does circulate," he told CTV's Power Play.

"Ms. Napolitano understood quite clearly, then and now, that none of the September 11 terrorists came through Canada, as the 9-11 Commission found."

Still, that positive outlook wasn't shared by other Canadian officials.

On Tuesday afternoon, RCMP Commissioner William Elliot expressed frustration with the comments during an interview on CTV's Power Play.

"I was somewhat surprised and disappointed," he said, adding he hopes the misconception has been cleared up.

"I understand and am happy to hear that she has issued a statement acknowledging that that didn't happen."

But Thomas d'Aquino, president of the Canadian Council of Chief Executives, decried Napolitano's comments on Tuesday.

"I am a longstanding friend and ally of the United States, but sometimes failures in our two-way dialogue cause me to shake my head in sadness and dismay," he said in a press release.

"The claim that some of the 9/11 terrorists entered the United States from Canada is, quite simply, a myth - an urban legend that began with a handful of erroneous media reports in the days following the terrorist strikes."

With files from The Canadian Press

Comments are now closed for this story

The Hammer
said
0 0

A real nice way to mend fences...I would like to know what Obama's views are on this and what his thoughts are reference to his Homeland Security secretary's comments. Will the U.S.A. ever admit thy've done wrong in some instances or are they that arrogant?


I suppose Canada is responsible for all their other mishaps over the past 7 years.


Of course Harper will agree with them no doubt.....



R/H Ontario
said
0 0

And these American 'educated' people really believe what they are saying! It's a good job that the ordinary American Citizen is more up to date on the Canada/American border. At least I think so!


Any terrorists entering US are using US visas.
said
0 0

Clean up your own mess, US.




Tono
said
0 0

You see what they're doing?

Today it's the Canada-U.S. border.
Tomorrow, it's the Northwest Passage.




Peter in Edmonton
said
0 0

Typical. Blame everyone and take no responsiblity themselves.


MF
said
0 0

How very typically American. Open mouth and with no knowledge whatsoever, change feet.

Where does Obama get people like this.

Making excuses for her just isn't going to cut it.




Heather in Ontario
said
0 0

Last time I checked, when you're crossing from Canada to the US, it's the US Border Guards who have the job of stopping you, not the Canadian ones! So if this situation does exist, how exactly is it our fault?


Joe O`Connor
said
0 0

If terrorists are getting into the U.S., it is U.S. Customs who are letting them in. They have only themselves to blame.



Clean up our act first Canada
said
0 0

The FACT is we have many terrorist cells operating within Canada... that's a fact.


Whether or not others have permeated the border isn't public knowledge.


I'm in favour of a clampdown on these cells and curtailing or making more stringent the entry of people from these regions where known terrorists immigrate from.




vj
said
0 0

typical. Blame others for your incompetence.

william
said
0 0

I watched this interview and I was outraged by Napolitano's comments, but more incredulous that how obtuse she seemed!

She was extremely rigid and she portrayed herself as not amenable to not accepting the truth, namely the myth about the 9/11 terrorists. I have questions about this woman's ability or willingness to comprehend
the complexities of The US
security issues. She was certainly ill-prepared and
severely lacking in knowledge during this interview! It seems paradoxical that on the one hand, Obama is making amends with Chavez and Castro, and
on the other, Canada is being treated as untrustworthy and suspect!

It seems that Obama and Napalitano are not on the same page. By the way, great job, Tom !





Ray Luft
said
0 0

With friends like Janet Napolitano, who needs enemies?


dawn
said
0 0

i am sick of canada being blamed for the shortcomings of the united states..Canada is not responsible for the 9/11 hijackers and for whatever reason the united states keeps pushing that lie.


A Former U.S. Citizen
said
0 0

Paranoia has been, for a long time, (anyone remember the McCarthy era?) such a crippling disease which will ultimately lead to the demise of a once great country.

You know they do have medications to treat such disorders....I suggest they all take a handful then work on their own problems.


Anne M
said
0 0

This sounds like shades of the days when Chretien and Martin were dissing the US. Now the lefties are in power in the US, they are dissing us.If you can't take it don't give it.


Regina Ron
said
0 0

Self-absorbed, self-centered, out of touch, misinformed. The Obama crew is no different than Bush's crew - they just smile more as they make fools of themselves.


Terrorist cells operating in Canada? Name one.
said
0 0

Where is it?

Liar!

US government has to tell paranoia lies to public.
said
0 0

It's how the US government herds the US population in the direction that the US boss class wants the herd to move.


And of course thirty percent of Canadian voters
said
0 0

will swallow the US paranoid fantasy hook, line and sinker.

Guess who that thirty percent voted for in the last election.




PROUD CANUCK
said
0 0

Pull your heads out of the sand USA. Before you open your mouths regarding anything about Canada, have your facts straight before hand. Very sad, during 9-11 we reached out to the YANKS and to this day, they do nothing but try to lay blame on us. Try getting a proper education folks, it may help you in the worlds eyes.


JW
said
0 0

It's comments like this that remind us the the United States of America is not our "friend". No country has friends - they have interests. And only so far as we serve their interests will they have any use for us. Those in the traditional conservative camp have never understood this fundamental fact of real politik. Past and present brands of conservatives have been so busy fawning over the Americans by trying to integrate our economies and foreign policy that we now have but a shadow of independent foreign policy and sovereignty for us to rely on and stand up for ourselves. In this regard we lack a Trudeau like figure in our political landscape to define ourselves as different and independent in the world's eyes. Sad.


Sue
said
0 0

Its unfortunate that she believes this story re 911 terrorists came from Canada. She must be a good friend of Hillary.
I know some Americans living in this Country that still believe the terrorists entered the US from Canada. I guess the borderguards were smoking some of the stuff they get from Mexico that day!!!
There are also many Americans that also still believe that statement. Its time to put some clozapine in their drinking water!!!!



BC Wet Coaster
said
0 0

This is why the Americans are heading towards being another developing country: arrogance, ignorance, and a lack of willingness to take responsibility.

Our only hope is to start building a large concrete wall before they start entering illegally like their neighbors to their south.


DW in Vancouver
said
0 0

It makes sense to me, Canada will let any one in the country if they claim political asylum or they say they are in danger of being executed in their own home. So don’t act so surprised people it is very possible.


Bob in Renfrew
said
0 0

Canada has a very real problem with this myopic new Homeland Security bureaucrat. This is not the first instance that she has shown an amazing lack of knowledge. Being from the Mexican border area she thinks that those problems are the same as exist along the Canadian border.


Well folks, I don't see too many Canadians crawling in the ditches and under the floodlights to get into the US. Do you?


I am a great admirer of the elephant in our refrigerator and thank goodness they are there while we build up our own Armed Forces and defenses that were killed by the Crétien and others of his ilk.


But let's stop infantile musings from a neophyte who has been promoted many levels above her abilities or intelligence.


Darlene in Halifax
said
0 0

How do people so obviously ignorant of the facts ever get in to public positions? Do they ever CHECK these facts before opening their mouths? I suppose she is still looking for weapons of mass destruction in Iraq, too.


Zhimmy
said
0 0

The U.S. has to realize they need our natural resources more than they we need them! We can always sell it to someone else. So they want to tighten up the border. FINE! Forget NAFTA and slap some duties on raw materials exspecially oil. Then we'll see how fast they wake up!


Rick in NB
said
0 0

Canada did play a roll in 9/11 we provided airports for all the stranded planes that couldn't land in US airspace. And i bet Napolitano doesn't know it.


Ronald in Toronto
said
0 0

Too many microphones - not much being said.

I'm still reeling from Ann Coulter's insistence that Canada put troops into Viet Nam!

Maybe, for a more "balanced" consideration, we could get Billy Bob Thornton's take on this.


ScottHfx.
said
0 0

The Liberal's were at their height of leftist bliss on 9-11, and the Canadian homeland was certainly not secure. Chretien and Martin did one hell of a job at making us look like wimpy weaklings to the rest of the world. Congrats! Now the same bunch want back in power. Give me a break!


Libra
said
0 0

Watching the interview it came across that this is another bureaucrat. Mexico's border gets the same emphasis as Canada's although the traffic is considerably different. Treat every 'foreigner' the same. Money is wasted on unnecessary procedures and Custom and Immigration officals have to fill out paperwork and follow unneeded protocols. I wish we could Fire Her and get someone competent.


Anne Bérubé
said
0 0

In a very short time, if not already, I would bet that at least 75% of Canadians will miss George W. Bush. And for all kinds of reasons, just wait.


Proud to be a Canadian
said
0 0

When a person enters the States it is through their customs. Therefore they are not defending their own border. It is a US Custom error not a Canadian Custom Error.



Judy McDonald, North Bay, ON
said
0 0

Why blame only Canada? It seems to me that it would be significantly easier for NUMEROUS terrorists just to enter the U.S. via Mexico.


Lee
said
0 0

Another person talking either without knowing the facts or just forgetting that tv coverage is no longer carried by rabbit ears!
Canada is an active member of the UN and NATO and this provides us with some important security facts. First of all, as a member of the UN, Canada is afforded the collective support of other nations which means that if anyone attacks Canada they have effectively attacked all members and will meet with the appropriate level of response. Secondly, as a member of NATO, Canada does not simply have to follow American policies and this is why Canada is known all over the world for our Peace Keeping efforts and are not a direct target of Terrorists as the US is.


Dan
said
0 0

Sounds about right. Remember the great blackout a few years back? The US blamed it on Canada right away. It actually originated in Ohio but they didn't highlight that fact. I bet they still think it was our fault.


Ian
said
0 0

How ironic that they blame Canada. Where did they get their pilot training done and how much of it was paid in cash. Hmmm. Smells funny to me. Perhaps the US needs to audit all of the training schools to see how many are truly legitimate before blaming their friends to the North.


Herb
said
0 0

And Homeland Security WILL be at the 2010 Olympics, armed, to augment Canadian Forces and police...... Impressive, eh??


Ray Jorritsma
said
0 0

Mr. Obama, I have great respect and admiration for you. That respect would increase ten-fold if you would do Canada a great favour and fire Ms. Napolitano. This lady is so incredibly out of touch she isn't even remotely capable of doing her job. The 9-11 terrorists did NOT come across the border from Canada and Heather and Joe are absolutely right--if any terrorists ever do get in via Canada, well the Americans have only their own border guards to blame. Geeeez....


RetunedMan
said
0 0

She's totally wrong about the "terrorists" coming through Canada, but give her a break. She's only been on the job for a bit more than a month.


BC Wet Coaster
said
0 0

We as Canadians can show our dissatisfaction and boycott American products and cancel any money spending trips to the US.

Do it for Canada folks!


Fed Up with USA
said
0 0

The USA needs to get over themselves and realize they are not the only country in the world and to take responsibility for their messes and clean them up!

My philosophy has always been: If everyone cleans up their own backyards, then soon we will have a lovely neighborhood.

As for the terrorists crossing the Canadian border, this was debunked shortly after 9/11. I think that they need to accept responsibility and look after their own actions.

I had thought that Obama could prove to be a different type of leader, but he is as bad or worse than Bush. At least we could see that Bush was an idiot! Obama's administration is just the same old, same old.


Mike from Toronto
said
0 0

If the US claims terrorists entered from Canada, that would mean that THEIR border guards were not doing their job. Canada to US = US guards. US to Canada = Canada guards.

L.A.
said
0 0

What about the US policy that was fast tracked to allow people from the Arab states in to the US, even visa free? and immediately prior to 9/11? Countries that live in glass houses should not throw stones.


USA
said
0 0

Well,what can we expect from a country that calls foreigners "illegal aliens?"

The US is too ignorant and arrogant to admit they make mistakes. Time to smarten up US.

Canada needs to toughen up our border to keep them out!


Dan
said
0 0

Michael Wilson 'chuckled' over this 'misunderstanding'? I think Frank McKenna did a more diligent job than Wilson did in correcting this misinformation. A new Minister to the US makes sense right now.


Doug BC
said
0 0

The woman is a politician and a moron.Hillary Clinton suggested the same thing.I think about the same time she told Americans that the great eastern blackout a few years ago was also Canada fault.Sadly,while I think Americans close to the border know more about Canada than either Clinton or Napolitano,both are in favour of relaxed border and immigration policies for Mexicans.Thus the "spin".

As to the "terrorists in Canada",we should be careful about being to smug.After all,the terrorists that brought down Air India are likely still here,living freely as "citizens" of Canada.

And finally,"Heather in Ontario" is right.It is up to American border guards to scrutinize people entering the USA.Our border people check out people entering Canada.However,once again,if Canada does not take the issue of national security here seriously,crossing the border will become much tougher for all of us.If the USA thinks getting into Canada is to easy for potential enemies of the USA,they will have no choice but to tighten up their northern border as well.

Napolitano's comments were out of line.But,at the same time,do point out legitimate concerns about how lax we are about who gets into this country,and how we pander to the rights of those who should not be here at all.

We do have work to do.But I think it goes without saying that the USA should clean up it's own act before they attack us.Somehow I doubt our "illegals" top the 20 million they have from Mexico alone.Not even on a per capita basis.


Jorja
said
0 0

How can someone like Napolitano get into such an important public service position and be so ignorant and uninformed. Even if the 9/11 terrorists entered the US through Canada, which they didn't, the US border service would have had to let them in. So it's pretty obvious who's at fault.


Dan in St. Catharines
said
0 0

Excuse me but before you get yourselves all worked up please consider 2 inconvenient truths:


1: Ahmed Rassam the "Millennium bomber" sentenced to 22 years in a US prison. He entered the US from Canada using a false Canadian passport. quoting from CTV: "He entered the country (Canada) using a false French passport, later making a refugee claim and receiving welfare benefits. He lived in Montreal and obtained a Canadian passport using a forged Quebec baptismal certificate."


2. Thousands of Tamil Canadians are on Parliament Hill today... "Protesters had been criticized for carrying the flag of the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE), the rebel group, which Canada has designated a terrorist organization."


So did the 9/11 terrorists come from Canada? NO.


Does Canada have terrorists? YES. Do they enter Canada illegally and get caught by our bunch? Gee... I dunno. Are there any walking around on Parliament Hill? I suppose the correct answer depends on which definition you want to use.


Does US customs catch terrorists at the Canadian border? ... Sometimes, YES and sometimes we even catch our own "Homegrown terrorists" in Toronto.


People who live in glass houses shouldn;t throw stones.


Steve G
said
0 0

It's good to know that public safety minister Peter Van Loan got a "chuckle" over speculation that the 9/11 terrorists entered the US from Canada.

Remind me...who voted for these clowns again?


Paul White Rock
said
0 0

The US is trying to be politically correct, but it is time Canadians voted with their pocket books and boycotted the US. Many of my friends already have and will no longer travel to U.S. Otherwise we will never get any respect or attention.




Dan
said
0 0

Now that is just too funny.
Just goes to show you how ignorant people are.



Mike from Canmore
said
0 0

Once again an ignorant American, unfortunately someone who truly should know better, sticks her foot in her mouth, chops down hard and blames Canada for the self-inflicted pain. Those morons let the terrorists into the states via their own airports. But not willing to admit that they screwed up, let's blame someone else.

Ron G.- Alberta
said
0 0

I agree with the U.S., we do let people from Canada to leave. I've done it many times when I lived in a border town. I found that I did have to stop at the American side and answer a bunch of questions before THEY would let me into their country. I'm sure it was has not changed much in the last 40 years.


Keith Fisher
said
0 0

All the self-righteous Canucks shouldn't forget about the terrorist cell in Mississauga that was arrested after running a boot camp and planning an attack on Parliament. Thanks to our mis-aligned justice system, MOST of those arrested have been freed without trial for the lamest of reasons, i.e. young offender, didn't know what he was doing, etc. They're now back out there pursuing the cause so don't be so sure that it can't happen here.


Eyes Wide Open
said
0 0

Welcome to Obamas cabinet. The Liberals in the US are no friend of Canada. Yet, the sheep in this country will still love the "geat saviour".


korie
said
0 0

so many of you have it spot on, we, as canadians, have been taking a lot of flack from the usa in the past months/years! i have a friend who lives in denver and she has brought up the subject of canada to her college classmates and most of them, according to her, don't give a hoot about canada! they see mexico as their most important neighbour (i guess it's about the sandy beaches and less about the water!)
the citizens of the usa are not force fed canada like canadians are force fed the usa! we know all about their president (she didn't know the name of our prime minister not did many of her class mates but some did!) and his dog's business!


should we really take stock in what the usa thinks about us right now or should we dam the rivers on our side of the border and stop the flow of oil & uranium & coal? fact is the usa is screwed with out canada's constant support yet our government tells us that we are so dependent on the usa? makes you wonder who has what thoughts in mind for our futures?


just my thoughts on the matter!


BC Bud
said
0 0

This outright falsehood is a common belief in the U.S. Part of the pervasive anti-Canadian attitude that exists there. The federal government needs to crawl out from the shadows and take a hard line on clarifying this. The usual asskissing by the spineless Harper and his lads will not suffice on this one.


Buba
said
0 0

I think it's kind of dangerous for senior U.S. pulic officials going around quoting urban myths.
The truth is much simpler.


kjo
said
0 0

Typical arrogant American comment. I can't believe that someone with the position she has, has no clue as to what happened on Sept 11. It is because of their lack of understanding of anything outside the US that Americans are hated around the world.


Remarkable
said
0 0

I hate to be honest, but after all I am Canadian and it's in my nature.

But the US allowed these people to come into the US, via their own borders, not ours.

These people lived among them for years, training as airline pilots, working as legal landed immigrants to that country.

I think more trash has come to Canada from south of the Border (guns, guns and more guns) then the other way around.


Michael from Toronto
said
0 0

I have good friends in the US and I support their right to defend themselves but...

WHY ARE AMERICANS SO BLOODY IGNORANT IN GENERAL?

And why can't Obama come up with better appointees? Is there also something inherently flawed with Democrats when it comes to isolationism? It certainly seems to be so.

First Obama bickers about NAFTA and now his people say we are the source of 9-11 terrorists. Well, they entered the US via Thailand, Germany/Czech Republic, Saudi Arabia, the UAE and Spain, Ms. Napolitano!


Wade Ens
said
0 0

Michael Ignatieff hurt Canada's image after Harper spoke about what good neigbours we are to each other and how we are a safe country and Ignatieff turns around and asks a Terrorist from Gitmo be released.
No wonder Obama left him sitting at the airport and went cookie shopping.


Bill
said
0 0

Careful. They invaded Iraq without reason, we may be next!


Nanook the Free
said
0 0

She's a huge South Park fan. You know, Blame Canada.....


Kim Davis
said
0 0

Every time I hear the American gov blame Canada for criminals that enter USA through Canada I seeth like crazy. It's so simple even a dummy can figure there's something wrong in their statements.
Here it is-one leaves Canada to enter the USA they face American Customs. One leaves the USA to enter Canada they face Canadian customs. That being said lay the blame at the feet it belongs - There


Lost in Translation
said
0 0

Forgive me for my "misunderstanding" of how the border security works... Yes terrorists alerts should pick them up if they enter Canada, but to get into the United States across the border, isn't it the American Customs they pass through ??? Can someone explain how if their own customs agency failed to recognize them it now becomes our fault by proxy that they got by the American customs???
Maybe just my "Misunderstanding"


kjo
said
0 0

Hey Bill, not to worry. They won't invade Canada. They don't know where it is.


Shadow
said
0 0

Yeah they blamed Canada for the blackout they caused as well. I think a formal appology should be made to the same media outlets that reported this.


tash
said
0 0

while irrelevant , it would be most interestying if they had entered the USD through Canada as that would have said quite clearly that the AMERICAN BORDR GAURDS LET THEM IN! Regardless the AMWERICANS let them in !


RL88
said
0 0

Well, the US have to blame on somebody. They can't take the blame that their own border control couldn't do a real man's job. It's easier to put it on someone else's shoulder than admit to the mess which their trillion dollar security systems couldn't handle.


B.
said
0 0

Napolitano is supposed to be in the know and obviously isn't. If she is head of Homeland security then likely all of her administration is thinking her way and setting policies in this way of thinking. Give her the boot. As usual she as a spokes person of the USA is treating its friends in its usual friend making ways.


Samual
said
0 0

Oh but Harper wants to be buddies with Obama, so now Harper will dig into our pockets again & through away billions to please Obama. So far is all Harper has done is follow the USA. We need a leader for our country, Harper is a follower not a leader.
At least the liberals have always stood up for Canada.


Paul in Leduc, AB
said
0 0

Do the Yanks forget that one or more of the 9-11 "pilots" were trained at American fight schools?


Todd ON
said
0 0

If they came through Canada, that means that US customs let them in.

So how is this Canada's fault?


Wendy
said
0 0

Where are all the conservative supporters!
Only days ago you were on here telling us how good it is Harper was in the USA trying to sell Canada to the USA.
We need a leader not someone who kisses their shoes!


Frank weber
said
0 0

Ya ok so they entered through Canada... But who let them into the USA??? not Canada!!


JB in Ontario
said
0 0

We as Canadians cannot live in fear. We need to stand up to the challenges post 9/11.

We need to speak our minds and have respect for people. We also need to be vigilant and suspicious of illegal activities and especially Terrorism.

Some people may not like the fact that Canada is multi-cultural. All I have to say to that is we have been a multi-cultural country for over a century already.

Terrorism does not discriminate and we cannot live in fear. My suggestion is to embrace our differneces and be wary of criminal activities by anybody. We all would like to live in a peaceful, democratic and safe country much like I knew Canada was back in the 70's and 80's and 90's.


Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

CTV News Video Player

Power Play

Power Play with Tom Clark

What do Napolitano's comments on border security say about eight years of diplomatic efforts?

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz