CTV News | N.L. signs historic deal to sell power to U.S.

Canada -   

N.L. signs historic deal to sell power to U.S.

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News: Michael Connors on the new deal
CTV Montreal: John Grant on the historic Newfoundland energy deal
NTV News: Michael Connors on the Churchill Falls project
Power Play: Newfoundland and Labrador Premier Danny Williams explains how the agreement works

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(20)

CTV.ca News Staff

Date: Thu. Apr. 2 2009 8:03 PM ET

Newfoundland and Labrador has signed a historic deal that allows it to route power through Quebec and sell electricity to the United States.

Quebec's regulators approved the deal to allow Nalcor Energy, Newfoundland's energy corporation, to send power from the Churchill Falls hydroelectric project through Quebec's power lines and sell it elsewhere.

As of April 1, the province began selling energy from the Churchill Falls project in Labrador to New York state, premier Danny Williams announced.

"This is a very important deal and a proud moment," Williams told CTV Newsnet's Power Play Thursday. "This is the first time that Newfoundland and Labrador have been able to wield power through Quebec to a distant market.

"So we are in a position now where we can sell our own power to either other Canadian jurisdictions or into the United States."

The much-maligned contract between Newfoundland and Labrador and Quebec on the Churchill Falls project was signed in 1969. It has been a continuous issue between the two provinces ever since.

The agreement between the two provinces doesn't end until 2041, and the N.L. government charges that Quebec has made $19 billion in profits, compared to only $1 billion for Newfoundland since 1971.

"It's a very lopsided, unconscionable deal," Williams said. "Obviously, there's huge benefits for Quebec . . . that's something Newfoundlanders and Labradoreans have had to live with for a long time."

In 1998, under then-Liberal premier Brian Tobin, Newfoundland and Labrador Hydro signed a deal with Hydro Quebec, giving it the right to recall 300 megawatts of power from Churchill Falls.

Most of that energy had been used in Labrador.

On Wednesday, the hydro company began selling 130 megawatts of power to Nova Scotia's Emera Energy Inc., which is selling it to New York, Williams said.

The province is able to sell 250 megawatts of energy to the North American grid, the premier said. That's enough to power 160,000 homes.

Not without controversy

But the Liberal opposition in Newfoundland charges that the deal is not as significant as to what Williams is touting.

"Obviously, what we got here today is another tweaking of a Liberal government initiative," Liberal Leader Yvonne Jones said. "The premier today talks about our first opportunity to sell power directly into the U.S. markets, but why didn't you do it before when you renewed the deal in 2004?"

The Churchill Falls hydroelectric station has a total generating capacity of almost 5,500 megawatts.

The five-year term of the new agreement, will net Nalcor Energy about $40 to $80 million annually at current energy prices.

"It's a small first step but a significant first step," Williams said Thursday at a news conference.

He says that a precedent has been set that his province can only build on.

"We've now broken that blockade at the border," Williams said on Power Play.

Comments are now closed for this story

Paul
said

I wonder what they have given to Quebec?




Ottawa32
said

2041 can't come soon enough!

Quebec rakes in $18 billion more than NL does from its own hydroelectric facility?!?

If today's announcement is good news financially for NL, imagine the business headlines 30 yrs from now!

At least NL now has Danny Boy to ensure there will be no more bad deals.


Ray In AB
said

Oh how I dislike Danny W.. But this is a great deal for the great people of N.L. Now if only we could find away to by pass quebec somehow so N.L can reap the full reward for the power it generates.. Keep up the good work DW..


Jimmy B - Perth Ontario.
said

Way to go Danny! Believe it or not I was very priveleged to spend a week at the project when it was about half finished in 1970. I was only 14 yrs old then but I have not and will not ever forget the experience. It's nice to finally see one of the have not provinces getting a better share of what they truly deserve. I have three words for the premier - SELL SELL SELL!!!


CC
said

Oh those Americans are gonna be sorry. They should have bought from Quebec or Manitoba. Working with Danny and the crew is a mistake from the onslaught. I wish them well.


Kurt
said

I wonder if that money gets included in the equalization calculations of Quebec and NL? If not how is it deferent than any other resource revenue? Maybe the formula is broken?


Kathleen
said

I wonder if they now realize that with this sale they are now bound under NAFTA to always sell a minimum quantity of energy to the USA or suffer serious fines!


Franky
said

The ignorance of some of these post are hilarious.... The power is being sold to Emera ...then they will sell to New York. Danny will not have dealings with the US.


DJ in Manitoba
said

(But it wasn't until Wednesday that it began selling about 130 megawatts of that excess hydroelectricity to Emera Energy Inc. (TSX:EMA), which in turn is selling it to New York, Williams said.)

It is no wonder everything costs so much. Too many middle men! Sounds like Alberta


Doug Ontario
said

I have been as critical as anyone of the Williams government's dealing with the federal government over off-shore resourses. However, today's announcement, of a deal to sell a renewable resources that is province owned and developed, is grest news for the province. On top of that, a deal for transmission through Quebec is a good sign for future development.


Mark M
said

If Newfoundland was dumb enough to sign a contract with Quebec until 2041, then they deserve to get have to live up to it...did they even read the thing before signing it?? Good for them on the new deal though...too bad they couldn't go around Quebec this time!


Keith in Brampton
said

To those slamming Danny: can't say I always approve of his methods, but that $19B / $1B split is all too typical of Nfld's treatment within Canada. With most resources residing offshore, the Feds decide what gets done with it - and they give most of the benefits to others.

You'd probably do more than just whine if the short end of the stick was being used to turn you into a pig on a spit.

NL just celebrated 60 years in Canada; while we're proud to be Canadian and, over all, have done better than had we gone it alone, proper resource management and fair treatment by the Feds would likely have seen NL reach "have" status a long time ago.


Was this the power Abitibi thought they were
said

going to steal?


Rob
said

Williams and Charest in the same bed... now that's a grotesque image isn't it? NL NEEDS a new Premier!! Nobody wants to work with this guy. They have a 5,500 MW facility and they're selling 250 to New York... BIG DEAL... that's only %4 of production and only has political significance. Time to TURF Williams


Lynn
said

Alot of people say they don't like Danny W. but he is doing alot for Nfld. I think more then any other Premier. I say go DANNY.....


albertan supporter
said

I Support N.L. since I made many friends from N.L. here in alberta when there was work for them here.

I think we should all band together and get rid of Harper ounce and for all! Canadians support all Canadians...

United we stand divided we fall!

Cheers to N.L.


Rob
said

Good for NF! Hopefully this project will expand in the coming years. Of course the Feds will be figuring out a way to take the Lion's share of profit.
19 billion to Quebec VS 1 billion to NF on a NF resource.....Does anybody in their right mind not see how NF was abused by the richer, "Central Canada" of the past....and the PM just let it continue with the last Federal Budget....It's hard to swim with a foot on your head! Harper, give NF a break!



Doug BC
said

I am happy for the people of N.L.& L.They really did get the dirty end of the stick on the hyrdo deal with Quebec.At least they can re-coup something.
That said,and maybe a bit off topic,but what ever happened to the idea of an east-west corridor for clean energy.Like a lot of people, I also welcome profits from exports.But I do continue to be concerned about to much "integration" of our systems.It seems to me that going to far down that road takes future Canadians to a position that makes if very difficult to get out of.
There's lots of money in energy,and we should all use renewable hyrdo electricity to build a cleaner supply of energy.I would have thought the tree huggers would be in favour of a plan that would close down dirty sources in favour of hydro.
It's the same energy situation here in BC.I guess it's just more profitable to sell it to the USA than it is to use it to get off of "dirty" energy at home.
I am NOT anti USA,and I do favour profits that can be used anywhere in Canada.I just get the sense that energy is going to be huge as time goes by.It seems to me that good planning and the resources we have in Canada could be used to give our own industries a huge competetive advantage if we used them properly.I am not sure "integrating" these projects with the USA meets our future needs as well as using Canadian resources for Canada first,and exporting ONLY what we don't need.
This is NOT a criticism of this deal.It's a question about the direction our energy policies should take. After all,there will be Canadians living here after we're gone.


Mel Blake
said

2041 will be a historic day for Newfoundland and Labrador. Everyone thinks Newfoundland got duped. In fact, every indication is that Joey knew it was a bad deal when it was signed, but didn't see any alternative because only a consortium with Quebec could get the international loans to build the project. When Ottawa refused to allow Newfoundland wheeling rights through Quebec on crown land, we were screwed. Canada will always side with Quebec over us. We only have 7 seats after all, so who cares what is fair and just. Quebec has been laughing holding Newfoundland's head in the toilet and flushing it ever since. They even print driver's licenses with Labrador as part of Quebec.

One chance Newfoundland has to win back something is if there is a global trade in carbon emissions. All that clean renewable energy has to be worth a lot for the carbon market.




albertan supporter
said

Oh yah and I forgot to mention.

I miss all my N.L. friends,


I'll See you Boyz/Girls in SASK and we can continue the struggle to feed our family's.

True Canadians support all Canadians!

Cheers my friends


Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz