CTV News | Michelle Obama gets Queen to break protocol

World -   

Michelle Obama gets Queen to break protocol

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News: Tom Kennedy on Michelle Obama's tour

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(50)

The Associated Press

Date: Thu. Apr. 2 2009 4:11 PM ET

LONDON — Michelle Obama's meeting with the Queen began with a handshake and ended in a hug.

U.S. President Barack Obama and his wife arrived Wednesday. After separate meetings on the eve of the G20 summit, the couple attended an evening reception for world leaders hosted by the Queen.

Michelle Obama clearly made an impression on the 82-year-old monarch -- so much that the smiling Queen briefly wrapped her arm around the president's wife in a rare public show of affection.

It was the first time Obama -- who is nearly a foot taller -- had met the Queen. She also wrapped her arm around the monarch's shoulder and back.

A Buckingham Palace spokesman who asked not to be identified because of palace policy said he could not remember the last time the Queen had displayed such affection with a visiting dignitary.

"It was a mutual and spontaneous display of affection," he said. "We don't issue instructions on not touching the Queen."

When the former Australian prime minister Paul Keating put his arm around the Queen in 1992, the tabloids dubbed him the "Lizard of Oz." When his successor, John Howard, was accused of doing the same, a spokesman insisted: "We firmly deny that there was any contact whatsoever." In 2007, U.S. President George W. Bush gave the Queen a sly wink during a visit she paid to the United States.

Canada had its own touching-the-Queen kerfuffle some 25 years ago when British tabloids reported Ontario Transportation Minister James Snow touched the Queen's back and elbow during a royal visit.

One tabloid, the racy News of The World, ran a front-page story with the headline "Hands Off Our Queen." Snow denied touching the Queen's back and said if he did touch her elbow, it was by accident.

Royal protocol apparently states those who meet the Queen should not touch her except when she offers her hand.

As for the Obama visit, the Daily Mail said the "two women clearly took to each other."

Wednesday's reception was followed by a dinner at Prime Minister Gordon Brown's Downing Street home, where the leaders' spouses were joined by notable British women, including "Harry Potter" author J.K. Rowling and Olympic gold medal-winning runner Kelly Holmes.

"Michelle walks in and she is as she seems," Holmes told reporters Thursday. "So warm, engaging, a beautiful, beautiful lady -- and I quickly got my photo in the middle of her and Sarah Brown," the prime minister's wife.

Obama also seemed to win over the often feral British press.

The last time a president's wife was such a hit in Britain was last year when French President Nicolas Sarkozy visited along with his wife, the former fashion model and songwriter Carla Bruni.

But on Thursday, London's Times newspaper had moved on, writing "Carla who?"

The BBC described Michelle Obama as her husband's co-star rather than supporting act, appropriate for a Harvard-educated lawyer.

Obama visited an all-girls school in north London on Thursday afternoon. She told the 240 girls about growing up on Chicago's south side, and urged them to think of education as "cool."

"I never cut class. I liked being smart. I liked getting A's," she said. "You have everything you need. Everything you need to succeed you already have right here."

At the end of her visit, Obama doled out hugs to the students, and was swarmed by them, to the extent that some Secret Service agents stepped nervously forward.

Earlier Thursday, Obama attended a performance at the Royal Opera House with the other leaders' spouses and guests. The program included music by Handel and a dance performance by Ballet Black, a troupe set up to give performing opportunities to black and Asian classical dancers.

Wearing a bright teal blue dress by Jason Wu -- who designed her inauguration gown -- and a sweater by Junya Watanabe, Obama posed for photographs with Sarah Brown, Therese Rein, wife of Australian Prime Minister Kevin Rudd, Japanese Prime Minister Taro Aso's wife Chikako Aso, and Laureen Harper, wife of Canadian Prime Minister Stephen Harper, on the stage of the opera house.


Comments are now closed for this story

Pat
said

Does Walter Assef count as affection?


Wishing Michelle was Canadian
said

Kudo's for Michelle Obama. She seems a very real very caring person who doesn't put on airs. He title of President's wife does not seem to faze her at all but gives off the impression to the public of an approachable down to earth person.
Being a military wife, it is quite impressive that her main cause is military families and her support that she shows them and her pledge of putting the focus on the spouses and children of members that are deployed. I could only wish that Mrs. Harper put as much support publicly behind our troops families that have a loved one deployed.
Bravo Mrs. Obama the world's leaders could learn alot from yourself and your husband!!


Regulus de Leo
said

What is this nonsensical puff piece for the Obamas? Michelle Obama violated protocol by touching the Queen. Being a royal she didnt' take offence; she was gracious to attempt to minimize the breach of protocal.

The media's love affair with Obama's is nauseating.


Greg - Signs and Wonders
said

M.O. was out of line and broke protocol. The Queen simply covered her [M.O's] ass. Don't forget the Queen has had 57 years as a monarch, vs. Obama's 90 days.


So Cute!
said

Awww...how cute! Now where's Laureen?


Scene
said

Gotta love this! Maybe republicans who still think having the Obamas representing their country is a bad idea will start to think differently. I don't recall any other first lady from the recent past that got that kind of affection fromt the Queen. All you Obama pesimists pay attention to what the world says about them. Some of our neighbours south of the border sometimes forget there is a great big world around them, maybe they shoudl pay attention to it!


MJB
said

It is a good thing that our head of state doesn't have any silly rules like not being able to be touched.... oops that is our head of state!

It is time for Canada to enter the 21st century - as a republic.


For her Next Trick, She's Going to Walk on Water
said

Yeah, right. Michelle Obama makes a royal protocol blunder with her well-toned arms and suddenly she's melted the 82-year-old heart of the emotional ice queen, but Steven Harper misses a photo shoot for whatever reason and he's a freakin' idiot. The news media certainly picks and chooses it's victims doesn't it?


What a nightmare it must have been to be touched!
said

Anyone who thinks the "Royal Protocol" has a place in modern society belongs in a room with rubber walls. Had the Queen or her staff made a scene over this situation it would have simply opened up the media attention to the fact that she is the pompous, uneducated, out-of-touch with the real world piece of work that she is.
It's nice to have traditions and have the monarchy as an afterthought to our heritage, but lets not pretend there is actually any critical reason for the longevity of the Royal tradition.


Rick in NB
said

@Regulus de leo:

If you would read before posting. You would have known that the Queen was first to embrace Michelle.











Dan from Northern Ont
said

The story states the Queen initiated. But in all honesty, people are people, not drones to policy, so meh.


I've had Enough
said

I have to agree with the comments from Regulus de Leo. The media coverage of the Obamas is nauseating. Trust me people, they are not as perfect as they seem to be. No one is.

And I couldn't disagree more with the comments from Wishing Michelle was Canadian. Wishing Michelle was Canadian, there are thousands of Canadian women who are role models to us Canadians.


Angela_Guelph
said

I am not sure if the article is in error, but it was clearly stated that the Queen made "first contact". If so, M.O. was only responding in kind.

I think it is a bit ridiculous that anyone should think of themselves above others and that it is somehow above them to be touched by someone else.

I am pretty sure the Queen puts her panty hose on the same way as I do..one leg at a time. Well....maybe she has someone to do that for her who knows.

Back to the point. M.O. strikes me a real person. Thanks for that, and please try not to change!




Canuck in Bellingham WA
said

Somehow this gets comments that:

1 - take a shot at Harper. Reaching aren't we.
2- says MO made a mistake. Apparently some people can't read. The queen touched MO first.

Yeah, a bit of a puff piece but so what?


Sad
said

I simply couldn't imagine living such an 'uptight' life as that of the Queen. It's 'news' that she put her arm around a woman and embraced her. Wow...how incredibly sad for her. What a lonely woman the Queen must be to not be free to express herself anytime because of 'protocol'.


lizzy
said

I cannot believe the fluff that you cover. Honestly, I like the Obamas, but we have people magazine on what she is wearing, and now CTV. I dont really care.I adore the queen.]God save the queen!


draven
said

Once again showing their lack of experience, and just how out of touch they are. This can go into the long list of faux pas' including the gift of the IPOD. What a total lack of class and ignorance. Kudos to the Queen though for not showing how poor protocol that was.


Matt in Fort McMurray
said

Michelle Obama broke protocol? Did you even bother to read the article? It was the Queen who embraced Mrs. Obama first, not the other way around.

"The U.S. first lady clearly made an impression on the 82-year-old monarch -- so much so that the smiling Queen strayed from protocol and put her arm around the president's wife in a rare public show of affection.

It was the first time Michelle Obama -- who is nearly a foot taller -- had met the Queen. The first lady also embraced her. "


Alicia
said

Apparently we have a bunch of those people on here who refuse to read yet again... The Queen INITIATED the embrace... get over yourselves... protocal BAH HUMBUG!!


Hi
said

I agree that the Queen was merely covering for M.O. I heard a story (not sure if it's true) that the Queen once drank finger bowl water because one of her guests did it by accident. Another example of the class of the Queen.


dave
said

This is a lovely story. Good for you Michelle Obama.

To bad we didn't have our own Obama's in Canada.



Jack Figge
said

Great emotions between two classy Ladies


Jack R
said

Regulus de Leo;

So is the obvious "hate on" that proforma republicans display. As well as juvenile, puerile, and outright ignorant attitudes. Bush is gone. He's not coming back. Get used to it.


Disgusted Canadian
said

This is a ridiculous article. The news is simply fawning over the Obamas foolishly. Instead of concentrating solely on Michelle Obama, why not pay attention to the Harpers? Stephen Harper is if I remember correctly the Prime minister of Canada and Laureen Harper is his wife. Other people besides the Obamas exist.

Oh, I forgot. . . the news did mention that Harper missed a photo op and looked really stupid. I wonder if the Obamas could do such a thing? Mostly likely not.


No More Hate!
said

Be a Lover, not a Hater.

It's a sad comment on our society when people are so disgusted by a simple humane act of affection - especially in this day and age. We all know the debate over "protocol" is a cheap mask. I bet those same people are for segregation...


Brian D
said

Think some of you missed the point. Just because the Queen broke her own protocal and embraced, hugged, high 5'd the 1st lady, doesnt mean you turn around and do the same thing. The Queen does as she sees fit. She makes sets the rules for herself. As for the 1st lady, she should have not returned the gesture especially in public. But hey folks, its THE USA, and here we go and Tar and Feather Harper, give me a break.


Fatman
said

This piece of fluff challenges the article on Mr. Harper's absence from the infamous G20 photo op as the most trivial of the day!

What are you guys in the media thinking and what are you going to serve up next? No, forget I asked that I don't want to know!


Chat
said

Queen showing affection? Give me a break. It is all politics. The Brits are sweating bullets that the US now has a non Anglo-Saxon president, and so they are desparate to suck up to the Obamas. Mrs. Elizebeth is just playing her part.


Michel Valois
said

The Queen touched Michelle Obama and thus reciprocated in kind. No harm done!


Mykey, The Lakehead
said

Pat

Thank you for mentioning the late Walter Assef, former Mayor of Thunder Bay. 'Jolly Wally' is well remembered.


Michelle Ain't All That
said

No More Hate!

I don't believe that people are disgusted by a simple act of affection. I believe the disgust comes from the idol-making machines which are at work here suggesting, as this headline does, that Michelle Obama, as if through some mystical force, had, in mere minutes, broken down a decades old barrier and gotten the Queen to break protocol. As if the Queen, given all the people she has met in her lifetime, has never met anyone like her before? Is that really what we are expected to believe? I think not and I can see where it does become tiresome to hear of how every little thing the Obamas do, even when it's wrong, deserves high praise. She broke protocol. So what if the Queen touched her first. That doesn't mean she gets to start grabbing the Queen. If the Queen asks her a question, she doesn't get to pepper the Queen with questions.


Dennis L. Krahn
said

It is mind boggling the kind of BS that makes the news especially when there are a lot more important issues to deal with.

Britons, Canadians, Americans; we all have our own style. Mrs. Obama meant no disrespsect to the Queen.

In closing, when push comes to shove the Queen is no more important than Michelle Obama, Stephen Harper or The King of Siam.


Daver
said

Whoopee doo!!! File this under who gives a crap...


ldiaznew@msn.com
said

You Canadians clearly are strange people. I am glad I am an American and that we have Michelle Obama as our first lady.


Ian
said

I'm an old Englishman and I assure you the Queen was simply being gracious to someone who is fumbling through their first foray onto the world stage.


Robert Edwards
said

Rob from Caledon

Wow, it looks like they had a very nice meeting!
Its good to see that they are both normal people just like everyone else.
Just with titles that is.






Matt in Fort McMurray
said

Brian D:

Let me get this straight: Mrs. Obama, instead of warmly returning the Queen's affectionate gesture, should instead have coldly ignored it and done nothing? Should she have just stood there and ignored the Queen, pretending the embrace wasn't happening? I think that would have been a slap in the face to the Queen. I guess you think insulting the Queen is more "protocol" than acknowledging a friendly gesture.


John in Vancouver
said

So maybe you should all look at the video of this so called "Break with Protocol" The Queen clearly is upset with the 1st lady touching her, and yet the media says she had no problem with it. Pictures are worth a thousand words. So perhaps the media should watch their own video and the body language of the Queen. It is very clear to me



Sigh
said

This woman and her husband have no respect. She breaks a longstanding protocol and then gives an ipod (not made in America btw) to the Queen...who already has an ipod.

She probably even thinks that she is more important than anyone in the world anyways. Like when she went to an elementary school where she said "do I really have to introduce myself?" and the kids said yes. Who does she think she is? God?

I dunno...either the Obamas don't get it or they just don't care. Either one is not good for any head of state.


Miranda
said

I am sick of all the fawning over the Obamas. Let's just take the crown off of Her Majesty and place it on Michelle's head and be done with it.


Robert in Calgary
said

No wonder Queen Elizabeth finds herself charmed by this Michelle Obama, who on her own has many social charms, but also, the US didn't send the typical Presidential team of Neanderthal corporate raider adolescent low-brows like they consistently have since the day Reagan took office.


Henry Wysmulek
said

So how does this help the economic mess her husband was elected to fix?




David #1
said

The embrace of the Queen makes the Queen look like a feeble old Granny she's visiting in a Nursing Home.

Why can't reporters just recognize Michelle Obama's philosophy and beliefs and report on her will to change the social system for America's youth..rather than get on that stupid rhetoric about comparing her to Jackie-O, Princess Di or Carla Bruni?

The media really reveals a different standard between men and women. Women are always measured on trivial crap like clothing, makeup and how they carry themselves. It's so pathetic and stereo-types women as being nothing more than a trophy parading around to make the hubby look like he's got good taste.

Pleeze!!!!! This kind of judgment insults women as "thinking" people that can influence the world and politics on the basis of their intelligence and not their look or style. I thought we had moved beyond that b.s.?!?




"CTV #1 FAN"
said

Personally I find that Michelle Obama should have respected Royal Protocol and not touched the Queen in this way. The Obama's "God bless them" are taking their celebrity too far and crossing too many lines chatting/cosying up to Hollywood nuts like Clooney, Pitt and Penn. They somehow seem to think that they can get away with anything and disrespectfully "change" the rules without regard to tradition.

Sorry but I'm not a fan of Michelle's stunt. Where will it end with them? I laugh when reporters hoot about her beauty and style and compare her to Diana. Sorry but she's "no" Princess Diana and her style is extremely "pedestrian" in comparison to either Diana's or Jackie Kennedy's.


Dave W. in Alberta
said

Good for her! Who cares about a "Royal Protocol" - Queen Betty's just a regular person like all the rest of us: she puts her knickers on one leg at a time too! If we all treated "royalty" and celebrities like the regular human beings they are, maybe the world would be a better place.


The media's love affair with White House occupants
said

is nauseating.

Report the real story: financial finagling by globalist scumbag elites.




Becky of Calgary
said

Honestly who really cares!!! We all get mellower as we age. Yes the Queen touched first.



Will
said

People who post like Regulus de Leo feigning outrage over a breach of protocol make me sick to my stomach. This is the 21st Century, such ridiculous rules of protocol are hoplessly outdated. Good for Michelle Obama for reaching out and connecting in a real and human way. Canada needs to become a Republic. Obama rules!


Mykey, The Lakehead
said

It's very touching.


rmbedfu
said

So, let me get this straight. Some folks have their knickers in a twist because Ms. Obama put her arm around the Queen and she reciprocated. The last time I looked at pictures of these ladies they looked like adults who could decide what to do all by themselves. You folks complaining about this need a new hobby. Get over it!!!


Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz