CTV News | Condoms not the answer in AIDS fight, Pope says

Top Stories -   

Condoms not the answer in AIDS fight, Pope says

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(48)

The Associated Press

Date: Tuesday Mar. 17, 2009 6:35 PM ET

YAOUNDE, Cameroon — Pope Benedict said on his way to Africa on Tuesday that condoms were not the answer in the continent's fight against HIV, his first explicit statement on an issue that has divided even clergy working with AIDS patients.

Benedict arrived in Yaounde, Cameroon's capital, Tuesday afternoon to a crowd of flag-waving faithful and snapping cameras. The visit is his first pilgrimage as pontiff to the continent.

Benedict had never directly addressed condom use, though his position is not new. His predecessor, pope John Paul, often said that sexual abstinence -- not condoms -- was the best way to prevent the spread of the disease.

Benedict said that the Roman Catholic Church is in the forefront of the battle against AIDS.

"You can't resolve it with the distribution of condoms," the Pope told reporters aboard the Alitalia plane headed to Yaounde. "On the contrary, it increases the problem."

The Pope said that a responsible and moral attitude toward sex would help fight the disease.

About 22 million people in sub-Saharan Africa are infected with HIV, according to UNAIDS. In 2007, three-quarters of all AIDS deaths worldwide were there, as well as two-thirds of all people living with HIV.

Rebecca Hodes with the Treatment Action Campaign in South Africa said if the Pope is serious about preventing new HIV infections, he will focus on promoting wide access to condoms and spreading information on how best to use them.

"Instead, his opposition to condoms conveys that religious dogma is more important to him than the lives of Africans," said Hodes, director of policy, communication and research for the action campaign.

While she said the Pope is correct that condoms are not the sole solution to Africa's AIDS epidemic, she said they are one of the very few HIV prevention mechanisms proven to work.

Even some priests and nuns working with those living with HIV/AIDS question the church's opposition to condoms amid the pandemic ravaging Africa.

The Roman Catholic Church rejects the use of condoms as part of its overall teaching against artificial contraception.

Senior Vatican officials have advocated fidelity in marriage and abstinence from premarital sex as key weapons in the fight against AIDS.

The late Alfonso Cardinal Lopez Trujillo made headlines in 2003 for saying that condoms may help spread AIDS through a false sense of security, claiming they weren't effective in blocking transmission of the virus. The cardinal, who died last year, headed the Vatican's Pontifical Council for the Family.

Benedict's African trip this week will also take him to Angola.

Benedict was met by a crowd of photographers and cameras as he stepped off the plane after ground crews struggled to place the aircraft's mobile staircase. Temperatures on the ground were 31 C with high humidity.

The Pope was greeted at the airport by Cameroon's President Paul Biya who has ruled since 1982, and whose government was accused in a recent Amnesty International report of a long list of abuses to crush political opponents.

The Pope made no specific reference to the situation in Cameroon, but he did say in general remarks on Africa that "a Christian can never remain silent" in the face of violence, poverty, hunger, corruption or abuse of power.

The pope also said Tuesday that he intends to make an appeal for "international solidarity" for Africa in the face of the global economic downturn.

He said that while the church does not propose specific economic solutions, it can give "spiritual and moral" suggestions.

The Pope's next stop in the seven-day African pilgrimage is Angola.

Comments are now closed for this story

Paul, MTL
said

More proof that the Vatican is irrelevant.


MDDM in London
said

All I can say is 'Oh lord'.

And I don't mean that in the religious way.

The Vatican has said this before -- many a times. He's wrong, and thankfully millions of people who do HIV/AIDS work everyday choose to ignore him. Imagine how bad the problem would be if we didn't.


Louie
said

Maybe the church should stop sermonizing and put its money where its mouth is. Talk is cheap.


Lin-Z NB
said

While I am not catholic or even religious, I do kind of see the Pope's point of view on this. However unrealistic abstinence may be, by handing out condoms to those with AIDS, it's like giving them the green light on spreading the disease rather than be more conciensious of it and trying to prevent it. Let's face it, if people weren't having sex it wouldn't be spread to those who don't have it and children would not be born with it.


sph
said

Just another blind statement illustrating the lack of reality that exists in the Catholic Church.


Steve in Ottawa
said

Come on now its the year 2009 AD not 2009 BC. Statements like these just go to show how out of touch these religous heriatics are!


Robin Brown
said

To expect the impoverished to be abstinent is ridiculous to demand it under religious guilt is murder. I wish I could take the "RC" off my birth certificate.


Phipps, Ottawa
said

Wow, how can someone so worldly be so detached from reality. The fact that he beleives so adamantly in this makes me question his overall judgement.


David, Woodbridge
said

As long as we treat sexually transmitted diseases as a moral issue rather than a public health issue (as we should be), we'll get nowhere against HIV-AIDS and other STDs.

The Catholic Church doesn't seem to get it. People have sex. They do it all the time, and they don't wait to get married and they don't do it with just one person for their entire lives. The sooner the Church realizes the reality of the world, the sooner we can get this disease under control.


Mike, Moncton
said

I agree with the Pope, abstinence is the best alternative. It's 100% effective. I would add that education plays an important role as well. Condoms promote promiscuity in that they give the person the false security that they are protected, hence; sexual activity increases. Anyone who thinks a thin piece of latex is the answer to this pandemic is someone who is comfortable with the idea of millions of people risking their lives and the lives of their loved ones including their children. The rampant spread of the Aids virus is through multiple contacts, if we focused on more monogamist relationships, Aids would disappear in a generation.


GREG TROLLEY
said

I totally agree with his highness. We should protect ourselves by avoiding temptations of the flesh. I know I have had some in my past but the good Lord gave me the strength to conquor in my time of weakness. We should also substain from self gratification as well.

Sam C
said

Phipps... I think this Pope is "worldly" only compared to other RC Clerics.

Unfortunately, the church's stance against birth control is at odds with the use of condoms for the prevention of disease.

This proclamation is not surprising, however irrelevant it may be.



Tom
said

Tom
Wow, how out-of-touch! But those truly involved in prevention knows that condoms are just one aspect of the preventive measures. Safe sex education is also a very important part of it. But to advocate sexual abstinence is pretty unrealistic in this modern day and age. Perhaps the Pope and the vatican should actually go out there and counsel one-on-one about abstinence, and they'll see how unrealistic this is. Sure it's easy enough to issue statements, but of no practical or clinical impact.


kenny g
said

does the pope live on the same planet as we do?????? i think not.


m@ - Canada
said

The point is, when condoms are distributed to people with AIDS it gives them a reason to go have sex.
Your comments are ridiculous at best. You all know the only solution is the solution the Pope is giving. And the reason AIDS is being passed around the way it is, is because of people like you and your ignorance. Should the Pop change his faith because YOU think he is out of date? Perhaps the people of this world are the ones who need a change.

Michelle
said

The Pope also teaches that women should view their monthly period as a gift from God because it is the only time of the month that a woman can say "no" to her husband without sinning. Extremely few Catholic's are on board with that one (much to the disappointment of Catholic men) and there are probably even fewer on board with the Pope's view of birth control and safe sex. I would not worry that this will have much of an impact on changing minds about condom use in Africa.


Russ
said

It is unfortunate to have such a powerful political (yes, not religious) organization that so ignorant.


Dan from Northern Ont
said

If you take the principle of what he says (monogamy), as opposed to his actual literal meaning (wait for marriage), it makes sense. The fewer partners you have, the less risk. That said, the condom is a great safety net.


Will
said

AIDS is the single most preventable disease there is in the world. If one is monogamous and true to their spouse, AIDS would die out in 1 generation. Yes, meaning that AIDS would be "cured" simply because no one would be passing it on.

The fact that AIDS is that preventable and yet takes up a disproportional amount of research funding is immoral in itself. The Pope is right in that condoms is not the answer. It's not a physical problem, it's a behavioral one.


Kris
said

The data from Uganda's "no grazing" policy (i.e. abstinence) versus the neighboring countries' approach of pushing condoms suggests that he is right, and has been all along.


Martin.NS.
said

It is naive to think that the pope has any sway in public oppinion in places where HIV/AIDS is growing. Places in Africa, South East Asia, HIV/AIDS is growing at an alarming rate. I don't understand how the pope can say that condoms increase the problem. HIV/AIDS is a world wide problem which people need to constant reminders/sex education to prevent spreading it, including the proper use of condoms!

This article just proves how irrelevant the Pope really is with todays issues....


Angela_Guelph
said

Wow...i long ago gave up believing in religon as anything more than an instrument of social control. Don't get me wrong, I am a spiritual person and believe in a higher power. I simply refuse to believe in man's interpretation of this higher power.

This ignorant and dangerous statement on the part of the leader of i think more than 1 billion people who DO believe him is shameful.

It does not matter that the statement "abstience is 100% effective" is true. The reality is that more people will die of this disease thinking that protecting themselves with a condom is morally and religiously wrong..

How can you seriously look yourself in the mirror Benedict?


Rob in toronto
said

If you saw a bunch of people running around shooting each other with handguns would you tell them to stop, or would you give them kevlar vests?

The Pope seems to dance around it. I'll come out and say it. Condoms do not prevent the transmission of HIV. And they certainly don't do any long term good in a region with AIDS numbers as high as Africa. They are a prophilactic step we in the west can use in pool of sexual partners where 1 in thousands or tens of thousands are infected. In Africa where the disease is more prevalent a more extreme measure is needed.

Set the religious beliefs of the Roman Catholics aside for a second and look at it from a purely scientific and secular point of view...in a room where half the people have a gun, your gonna get killed eventually, even if you are wearing kevlar.


KJ in Kingston Ontario
said

The sad part is in the 21st century the media is still printing what the Pope says -- and people still follow advice predicated on ignorance and delusion.


Erin
said

Wow this is one of the dumbest things I have heard in a while. Just another reason why more and more people choose not to go to church, they are so out of touch with reality.


Chris
said

The pope only said it isnt the answer.

He is not stopping its use.

Condoms have been around for more then 1000 years. IF they are the answer then why do we have this pandemic?

Condoms may have some effect but they are not the entire answer.

I know people who have broken one and contracted.

Abstinence if practiced works 100%. NO questions.

Ethics need to be taught.

Nothing is perfect but we can't deny the ethical ways either.

The church is not irrelevant.

There are more cahtolic missionaries in Africa then any other.

They are on the front lines and seeingit first hand.

GO there and see for yourself then judge.

God bless and may he keep everybody safe.


Nancy
said

Some argue that it gives those with HIV more reason to have sex, however many, many others are infected prior to the first individuals diagnosis.
It is really sad that something so incredibly inexpensive could prevent such a terribly devestating and expensive disease.


G in Ottawa
said

As someone who works in an HIV clinic on a daily basis, I can say that most of you (including the Pope) are grossly misinformed about HIV/AIDS and its transmission methods... Condoms are an extremely important prophylactic step in the transmission of AIDS, contrary to what many of you seem to believe.

As for your comment Will that "AIDS is the single most preventable disease there is in the world. If one is monogamous and true to their spouse, AIDS would die out in 1 generation. Yes, meaning that AIDS would be "cured" simply because no one would be passing it on.", this is the most ridiculous thing I have ever heard. AIDS is not only spread through sexual contact. It is spread through exposure to blood products as well. A needle stick can be all it takes to contract HIV. Your kids can contract HIV by playing in a sandbox and sticking their finger on a used syringe hidden in the sand. Sexual contact would have had nothing to do with it.


Ann
said

It never ceases to amaze me that a man who is supposed to remain celibate all his life, gives advice on marriage, sex and raising a family, all things he has no experience of. And to all of those who compared guns and Kevlar vests to condoms and aids, sex is a natural part of being a human, shooting at someone with a gun is not. It is ridiculous to suggest there is any comparison at all. Aids is a health issue, not a moral one.


Realist
said

Mike, Moncton: you're right, abstinence is 100% effective. It's just not 100% realistic. In the REAL world, not everyone has a spouse, not everyone is 100% monogamous. And whether or not you or the Pope thinks people SHOULD have a spouse and be monogamous doesn't make it reality. The fact is, people are having sex and will continue to have sex. And you have to treat the situation based on what the facts are, not what you wish the facts were. Providing access to condoms does not encourage people to go out and have more sex, any more than providing 3 toothbrushes would make someone suddenly want to start brushing their teeth 15 times a day. People are GOING to jump in the pool, so the only way to keep them from drowning is the combination of teaching them to swim and providing lifejackets.


Jackie
said

I find it interesting that the catholic church promotes abstenance while at the same time telling people to go out and have a large family.I've often wondered where that came from.
I do agree that it's all about education and not about morals. The minute you stick a morality in there is when you have problems, since everyones idea of morality is different. Sure he is trying to help but i would believe those statements much more if it were coming from someone who has had and still is having sex, and not a pious man who is sitting on a throne in Rome, not living in the real world.


Joshua J, AB
said

Abstinence before marriage is the only way to stop it. Condoms are like trying to put a band-aid on a severed artery. People can scoff all they like, but you can't dispute that abstinence will be more effective. If only people could learn to control themselves...


AmyK76
said

Abstinence is unrealistic, period! I get it that if people weren't doing it - the spread would stop...but people ARE doing it!
Condoms are the best defence against the spread of AIDS!

The church needs to pull it's head out of the sand and get REAL!


Mandi
said

Wow. The Roman Catholic Church never ceases to amaze, as do people who leave comments when they don't know what their talking about...
Condoms are extremely effective against preventing HIV when used correctly. If they were distributed and given out in Africa the HIV/AIDS Epidemic would gradually slow.
Abstinence does NOT work.


Emily
said

This is ridiculous. Lots of the AIDS cases in Africa are the result of rape. Do you think rapists will think to use condoms? No.

Maria
said

Some people seem to think the Pope's views are out of date for this day and age. Don't kid yourself. People aren't any better or worse today than 4000 ago. Other STDs also existed back then that people died of. Just read up on your world history - mistresses, homosexuality, prostitution, and orgies abound.

I agree with a previous comment that it's a behavioral problem. The only thing we know that is 100% effective is abstinence. At the time of creation, God's intention was that people would live in monogamous relationships. When we stray from His pattern, that's when the problems occur. Whether or not you're religious and believe in God, we all know that a monogamous lifestyle poses the least amount of risk.

The sad part is that innocent people like children suffer the consequences of the adults' irresponsible behaviour. It's worth fighting for a cure for them. To say the Pope is old fashioned and his views are unrealistic is just a cop-out. Realistically, people are not likely to change because the prevalent thinking is always "if it feels good, do it", regardless of the consequences. But that is no excuse. That kind of thinking only spreads it more. Adults need to take responsibility for their actions regardless of where they live, rich or poor.


B. Kelley, Ontario
said

Several studies have shown that the failure rate for condoms falls in the 10-20% range during vaginal sex and significantly higher during anal sex. On the positive side it can be argued that 80% protection is better than none. The problem lies with people who aren't aware of the potential failure rate and their ignorance provides a false sense of security that exposes them to the risk of death by AIDS. The Pope is right in that abstinence is the only totally effective defense. Realistically, however, that just is not going to be the choice of the majority. Until technology develops a better product, accurate and widespread education is the only practical strategy coupled with encouragement to avoid multiple sex partners and riskier activities such as anal sex.


Wade: When a Woman says NO it means NO
said

Men need to understand when a woman says NO it means NO.
The bible said Eve was taken from the rid so she she would not be higher or lower than man. The Bible taught us equal rights and this idea being spread by the church is also a powerful message in the fight against aids.


Mandi
said

and G in Ottawa..
You should know if you work in a Clinic--unless that syringe the child touched was just out of someone who was infected, the virus dies within seconds of oxygen exposure...maybe you were thinking Hepatitis which can hang around without a host for matters of weeks...


Sandie
said

What is the matter with all those men at the Vatican. Are they still living back in the iron age? Come on get into the new century, wake up and get down to the real earth. Sex has been going on since the beginning of time and very few may abstain but the majority do not and will not. Hand out the condoms. We shoud do whatever helps reduce this terrible plague.


Kevin, Calgary
said

I use condoms, But have had a few break on me. They are not a 100% solution.


Mary in Calgary
said

As a Catholic I am insulted by his comments. He is only diving the church even further. This shows us the unrealistic reality the church lives in.


A Galega en Dallas TX
said

I am a Roman Catholic, grew up going to church twice a week, went to a private roman catholic school, but I also am an inteligent human being, and my faith is my own believe in God, but not what I am going to do with my life. Pasing around the condoms is the BEST way to keep people safe from the transmission of the virus! People is not going to stop having sex, never done, and never will! it is instict! People don't think about abstinence, people what to live their lives, and besides that technology has been helping us to do so. Thanks to years of research condoms are hugely improved since first models, and today offers the option of live from death to many people. Besides that the way to get AIDS is not only by sexual transmission. As someone else mentioned, you can get it even on an emergency blood transfusion.
Please as a Roman Catholic I make a call: please use condoms!! pass them around, and don't mix a believe on God with being a good human being by protecting yourself to don't harm others or just simply to don't get harmed!



CFS
said

I completely agree with the Pope, AIDS would stop spreading if people stopped having sex. If you have sex, take whatever consequences(sp?) that it has, it is your own fault.


Stephanie
said

There is one instance that condoms won't work, and that is in the many, many, way too many cases of rape. Many tribes in Africa use rape as a weapon of war, spreading diseases from baby girls as young as a few months old, if they survive the sickening attack, or the surgeries to repair such damage, to elderly women. In South Africa, gang rape is used to try to "cure" lesbianism. These men must be educated properly and in many cases, punishments MUST be extreme.

Tiffany Reed, Philadelphia PA
said

The issue is not about "handing out condoms to people with AIDS" as some of you have stated. The problem is that so many people don't know they have HIV/AIDS and continue to have unprotected sex because of a lack of education, lack of health services and/or money, and/or the extreme stigma involved in going to a clinic to get an AIDS test. It's not like programs ONLY distribute condoms to people with AIDS... condoms get distributed to all adults in the hope of preventing the spread of AIDS and other STDs.


Will
said

The probability of contracting AIDS, if you don't participate in high-risk activities (multiple sexual partners, IV drug use) is for all intents and purposes, zero.




People like to throw out the syringe scenario, but the likelihood of such an event is statistically fantastic. You would have a better chance of winning 5 lotteries than contracting AIDS. The truth of the matter is that AIDS is a result a conscious decision of engaging in risky activites. If you do not engage in such activies, you are not going to get AIDS.


Shale
said

To those who agree with the Pope and say that all we need to do is teach abstinence are truly ignorant. Sex education is the key, Africa is not only a different country bur almost a different world in terms of mindset. This is the country where it is believed that if you have sex with a newborn then you will be cured of AIDS. Abstinence is not realistic.


Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz