CTV News | Protesters greet George Bush in Calgary

Top Stories -   

Protesters greet George Bush in Calgary

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News: Janet Dirks on Bush's image rehab
CTV Newsnet: Bernie Gauthier, image consultant, on Bush's new public persona
CTV Calgary: Reg Hampton on the huge crowd and protesters arrested
CTV Edmonton: Scott Roberts examines who will be protesting the former president's visit
CTV Newsnet: Reg Hampton explains why oil patch execs and expatriates are attending
CTV Calgary: Camilla DiGiuseppe with reaction from staff at a local restaurant where he dined

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(57)

The Canadian Press

Date: Tue. Mar. 17 2009 8:08 PM ET

CALGARY — George W. Bush wooed a packed crowd at a private luncheon in Calgary with his trademark folksy charm, while hundreds of protesters outside hurled insults and shoes at the former U.S. president's image.

Four demonstrators were arrested outside the downtown Calgary convention centre where Bush spoke for one of the first times since leaving office in January. At the time, he had a dismal approval rating and was blamed for his country's collapsing economy.

"There is a war criminal upstairs that has committed murder," screamed one man, who identified himself only as Splits the Sky. "If I try to get in there you will arrest me. What is wrong with you?"

Bush's affable public persona, subdued by widespread criticism of his administration near the end of his time as president, was front and centre as he explained his eight years in the Oval Office.

In his 35-minute speech, he drew ties between his childhood in rural Texas and life in rural Alberta, including the common binds of community and family.

Bush poked fun at himself, but also grew serious when talking about Canada's role in providing the U.S. with a secure source of energy.

He also admitted his administration spent its final days "bailing water" trying to deal with the financial crisis, and said while there's no easy answer going forward, more government involvement is not the solution.

The event was closed to the media, but many of the 1,500 people who paid $400 a ticket to hear Bush speak stopped to offer their impressions. Few seemed annoyed by the fact the event started an hour and a half late due to tight security screening.

"He was very, very candid. He was witty and witty in a way that you would have to be intelligent to be that witty," said Calgary Tory MP Lee Richardson.

"He seemed to have a remarkable grasp of events and issues that just didn't come through as president."

Brenda Kenny, president of the Canadian Energy Pipeline Association, said Bush emphasized the interconnected, open markets that tie Canada and the U.S. together.

Peter Yates, a lawyer who has dual citizenship and voted against Bush in 2004, admitted the former president is very personable and gave an entertaining speech.

"My feelings are still the same -- he's a folksy affable guy but I don't agree with his policies."

Most of the 400 protesters waiting outside showed their negative feelings for Bush.

Some of those opposed to Bush's visit have suggested he should be arrested as a war criminal because of alleged torture at military prisons in Iraq and Guantanamo Bay. Many yelled at police officers for not arresting Bush on the spot.

Signs read "No to U.S. Crimes Against Humanity," "Indict Bush For War Crimes" and "Canada Is Not Bush Country, as well as "Shoe Him The Door" -- a reference to the Iraqi journalist who threw his shoe at Bush during a news conference in Baghdad in December.

Two men showed up to support Bush, however. Their signs read "The World Is Safer Because of George W. Bush."

"Thank you, George Bush. Thank you, George Bush," they chanted.

The former president's speech almost exactly marks six years since the invasion of Iraq, said organizer Peggy Askin, and it's not OK to forget what happened in the ensuing years.

"He shouldn't be able to go anywhere in the world and just present himself as a private citizen," she said. "We do not have any use for bringing war criminals into this country. It's an affront."

One businessman in the audience said Bush implied he had some regrets from his time in office, although he didn't give specifics.

"He admitted that maybe there were some things he could have done differently, but overall he made some sense with the reasons for doing it," said George Fink, CEO of Bonterra Oil and Gas.

The 43rd president of the United States defended his reasons for military action in Iraq and Afghanistan, Fink said.

"He said if we were in his boots in 9-11, a short time after he got in, there was a big demand to do something, and he had to react and he reacted."

Kenny said Bush seemed eager to explain his views, and he said he plans to write a book to show what happened during eight very challenging years.

"I wouldn't say apologetic, I would say acknowledging that there was not always agreement and, frankly, just accepting that as a fact."

The Globe and Mail reported on its website that besides defending his decision to invade Iraq, Bush said "risk takers," not government, will solve the world recession and that he had positive things to say about current president Barack Obama.

"I love my country more than politics," Bush said.

"He deserves my silence and if he wants my help he can pick up the phone and call me."

On the economy, Bush even though he is a "free market guy," he had to step in with a bail-out package in the waning days of his administration.

But he said the government can't do it alone.

"It's the risk takers, not the government, that is going to pull us out of this recession," he said.

In a question and answer session, Bush defended the invasion of Iraq and the toppling of Saddam Hussein.

"The world is better off and the Iraqi people are better off without Saddam, no ifs, ands or buts," he said.

There were shoes everywhere during the protest. A young woman wearing a hood, orange jumpsuit and a name tag that said "Club Gitmo" was pulling a shoe cannon along with a target festooned with pictures of Bush.

Protesters flung projectile footwear from the device at the massive photo of a smiling Bush, while others jeered and tossed sandals and boots by hand.

One of the arrested protesters was ticketed and released, said police. Three others were charged with more serious offences -- one with breach of the peace and two with obstructing a police officer and resisting arrest.

Seventy-nine police officers were involved, but that included traffic members who closed off intersections for the president's motorcade.

Comments are now closed for this story

Red X
said

It figures Bush Jr. would visit Canada's Texas...

American's have switch from a "down home" kind of leader to someone intellectual. Could we do the same?


Gord in Regina Sask
said

These protesters really need to get a life. Bush is president no more!


Calgarian for peace
said

This just worsens Alberta and Calgary's reputation as lovers of environmental destruction and "religious" conservative wars.

Sorry Calgary I am embarrassed to live in Calgary today.


John in Calgary
said

Did they take away their shoes? Hehehe, careful you might get three years.


Steve the Pundit
said

These people need to get a life; he's not the president anymore, he can't get re-elected again, it's over.

What effect do they think protesting a private citizen will have on anything?


Ana, AB
said

I heard, in another report, that a lot of the protesters had shoes that they were planning a shoe-toss. Heh. I would have liked to see that.


SK Doctor
said

Like a dog with a bone - they can't leave it alone can they?


frenchman
said

Business must be slow in Calgary if they have time to listen to this guy. Someone lauch a pie!!!!


John
said

Why would anyone want to hear 'W' talk about business?
What was the topic?
How to run your business into bankruptcy in 5 easy steps?


Jeremy
said

My god, I would be asking officials with the Calgary Chamber of Commerce if they had a hundred thousand dollars to throw away inviting Bush jr to talk about his great successes during his 2 terms. Even if they got him for a 1/4 that price, not worth lining his pockets. My god, I am glad I am not a member in Calgary.


Peter Rapsey
said

The sentiment I agree with, but it is so nice not to have him as the most powerful man on earth that we should just smell the Obama hope and forget about idiots. You give him legitimacy by protesting him. He is just a nobody now.


beeman
said

The time for protesting G Dubya has passed. The damage is already done and there's nothing he can do about it now. Its time to focus attention on the future, not the past.


MuskyBuck
said

200 to 300 protesters showed up, 1500 came to listen.

I wasn't surprised that Bush scheduled an event in Calgary. If ever there was a city in Canada that exemplified the Republican/Conservative thorough ideology it is there.

However, based on the amount of talk given to the 8 year tenure of this administration and how maligned it has become on a number of different topics...

It's hard to make a case for genuine disagreement when there is more than three times more willing to listen and bask in an evening of this ideology vs. the amount that show up to show disapproval.


Keith Sipa, Cape Breton
said

I trust all associated costs for this debacle were born by the Calgary Chamber of Commerce, and I, as a taxpayer paid nothing Wait a minute! Did Dubya pay the chamber to appear?


RVH
said

Get real people, move on. Instead of protesting, do your part and work!


Devin - Guelph
said

As much as I don't like Bush or his policies, you can only beat the same drum for so long. He is no longer a president and doesn't affect any type of US policy. What is left to protest against? Seems like they are just protesting the fact that he was a bad president and even worse leader. I don't disagree it just gets old.


Julius, Hamilton
said

Note to protesters: Get a life, and get over it. He's gone. You can enjoy your lives again.


Alana
said

What's the point of protesting now? He is no longer in power! Seems like an exercise in futility to me!


Tim
said

Another attempt by certain left wing groups to gain media attention. Yawn...


John from AB
said

What a sad picture, protesters that do not understand that if it was not for Bush many terrorists would still be on the loose and killing innocent people around the world. Doesn't matter what else you might think of Bush, he has taken the criminals and terrorists off the streets. Give the man a little respect.


John
said

hopefully it's a speech on what not to do to your economy. His track record does not appear to be all that good considering the fix the U.S. is in now


Jeff S.
said

Get over it people. Bush is out of office and there's nothing you can do about the past. He's not a war criminal any more then Obama is for continuing on with the wars Bush got started.

Let's just move on.




Janice
said

As Obama increases US military presence in Afghanistan are these same protesters going to call him a war criminal?



Tarah
said

You call them "protesters", I call them - hippies. Why do these people protest instead of working or doing something useful? Get a Life!
I am glad George W. Bush visited our great country Canada.


L-P Markham
said

Thanks George for doing exactly what needed to be doing. Hope the world wakes up and learns that peace comes at a price we can't afford not to pay.


James
said

George W. Bush worked very hard as President of the most powerful country in the world and just because of his approval ratings being low while in office does not make him a not so good President. Being President is not a popularity contest.

Now that he is Calgary and in oil country, my hope is during his speeches he will talk about alternatives over the long term about our dependance on oil. As most of us know the oilsands are an environmental disaster. If I were still in Calgary, I would be attending that dinner and listening to what George W. has to say in his speech.




I.R. Milton
said

GWB will remain controversal for what some say he did when he shouldn't have and what others say he didn't do when he should have.

I guess history will reveal the real GWB when the proverbial dust has settled.

In balance how do you weigh the adult and children's lives lost due to military decsions versus the number of unborn childrens lives saved due to his faith-based initiatives, holding back on public embyonic stem-cell research money to holding back on overseas abortion financing?

I guess it depends when you consider life begins.

I have never met the guy but I would like to some day.


Jay in Stoon
said

Isnt' it wonderful that Calgary business men and women want to see and hear George Bush? Isn't it wonderful after 8 years of a pointless war, destruction of civil liberties, broken international accords, circumvention of the Geneva accord, and the legacy of de-regulation responsible for a global economic meltdown - they STILL want to see him? Doesn't this make you wonder why? Why does George Bush still have so much popularity among the wealthy?


Blake White
said

You've got to love the hatred from the far-left “tolerant and accepting” crowd. Maybe these protesters should try getting jobs.


Patrick
said

Who cares?

He's talking to business people. If they want to run their businesses into the ground the same way that GWB ran the US into the abyss, let them listen. I can't believe people are wasting their time to protest this. Shouldn't these people be supporting our economy by rolling up the rim?

It's not like he's addressing our distinguished Parliament.


MJ
said

It cracks me up to hear about Bush and the links they try to draw to the Conservatives. Fact of the matter is that the Democrats in the US are to the right of the Conservatives. Look at the platforms. Moron Liberals trying to take advantage of Obama's popularity and Bush bashing to pump their more left wing agenda. Get a life and read the platforms instead of just running on emotion!


Eric in Calgary
said

The damage the Bush regime did to the US and the world should never be forgotten. Inviting him to speak anywhere gives him legitimacy he doesn't deserve. Shame on Calgary.


DonnaThiel
said

George W. hopefully paid the bill for his speech and arena. The protesters: get a job. Start a legitimate company. Find some positive hobbies.


Nick
said

I like how the pro-Bush demonstrators were willing to give their real names, but the protestors hide behind pseudonyms. The courage of their convictions, I guess. It's too bad that such idiocy accompanies protests against Bush because it chases away any moderates. I dislike Bush intensely, but I won't align myself with people who's behavior is so outrageous they're afraid to give their real names!


Jared in Courtenay
said

Janice wrote:
"As Obama increases US military presence in Afghanistan are these same protesters going to call him a war criminal? "

*sigh* That's not why he's called a war criminal. It's because he commited war crimes. Increasing the millitary presence is not a crime - violating human rights and signed conventions on the treatment of prisoners etc is why W is called a war criminal. I'd love to see him on trial in the same seat Saddam sat in...

Jeez - do you even read the news that they post on this website?


The Liberal spinners can't help themselves
said

I wonder how many people in the world will be making under a dollar aday after Obama's administration, considering the amount of people working for under a dollar a day significantly reduced under Bush.
But I guess the MSNBC, looney left doesn't care much about anything but their own agenda and pocket books!!!


Doug BC
said

You kind of have to wonder if it's the protestors or Mr.Bush who is dilusional.
I certainly have issue with a lot of American policy,and,in fact with Mr.Bush himself.But the fact remains,he did kept borders open to Canadian products in ways the current government will not.And,he is no longer the president,so whatever it is people disagree with him about,it's irrelevant.
At the end of the day,I think it's people who are to busy shouting to actually hear anything.Personally,I like to hear people whether I agree with them or not.
How else could I understand what brought them to believe the things they believe,or convince them that perhaps they should take another approach??
I fear people who don't listen,or people who try to stop opposing views from being heard a lot more than I fear people I simply have differences of opinions with.I didn't care for a lot of Mr.Bush's policies.But I would be fascinated to hear what he has to say. Especially since he is no longer bound by the constraints of his office.
When this is no longer a free speech country,we all have something to fear.No one has ever been harmed by listening.
To me,it's the protestors who look ignorant.Like the kind of people who announce that a budget will be defeated,even before the budget is written.
Hear him out.THEN feel free to agree,or not.How stupid is it to not listen.


terri
said

I am with you Janice. It will be interesting to see what they think of Obama when he doesn't pull out of Iraq for a few years instead of the six months he campaigned on as well.Or all the other promises he has already broken.


Pete in Calgary
said

A lot of these protesters are just simply anti-american. I am sure many of them were also there with their anti-u.s. rant when we had a rally in Calgary after 9/11 to show solidarity with the u.s.


KMC (Markham, ON)
said

While George Bush certainly did his share of the damage to the U.S./World economy, a large portion of the blame lies with Bill Clinton. The handing out of mortgages to people who would never have qualified, began under Clinton. The Republicans would like to have ended the program, but they didn't dare.
The Clinton homeownership program was largely aimed at minorities, particularly blacks and it would have been political suicide for the Republicans to have terminated Clinton's policy. As it happens, they (the Republicans) didn't fare too well in any event.


Linda in Vancouver
said

I'm not one of Mr.Bush's fans,and I was certainly on the opposit side of many of his policies.And,I'm still trying to figure out how he became president.
BUT,I would love to hear what he has to say.The fact remains,if I can stomach my way through a speech by the likes of Taliban Jack,or some of his brothers in the other socialist party we call "NDP Lite",a speech from Mr.Bush would seem to be enlightening,by comparison.
I don't know about everyone else,but I've never been harmed by listening to ideas I don't agree with.
Although,I suppose there may be some truth to those who believe that "ignorance is bliss".


Calgal
said

Really? The "Texas" of Canada? Have you sunk that low?

Are you saying if he had chosen Toronto or Vancouver they would have turned him away but because we're the "Texas" we welcomed him? Yes I can just see any city giving up this media exposure like that based on moral principle.

Sort your life out. We pay the same taxes, love the same country as you and hate George Bush just as much.

We still have protesters out there making their mark so don't sit there and make us all out to be tyrant sympathizers just because we have a similar resource pool to Texas.

Trust me, most of us don't want him here either.

Leave Calgary out of this it's just a spot on the map he chose to stop at, it could have been anywhere.


Kris
said

Those two men who showed up to support him had a lot of guts. They're the ones I respect.


Rick
said

Bush ignored Canada all his time in Office and then we turn around and invite him here. Does not make any sense, but Alberta (Canada's Texas) does not make much sense anyway.


BobKnows
said

How extremely sad and shameful all you give no thought whatsoever to the tens of thousands of civilians who are dead because of this illegal war. You people are telling the protesters to get a life? Maybe all of you should get some morals. Shame on all of you. Bush IS a war criminal. To suggest he is no longer accountable is lunatic. Shame on Harper for letting him in.


jw calgary
said

It's easy to be an armchair quaterback and critize America and George Bush for taking care of the world's dirty work. As an American in Canada I appreciate Canada's participation with the war on terror in Afganistan.


Dunny from Manotick
said

Everyone should remember that Bill Clinton was so bad that the americans elected George Dubya twice. Let's move on and hope that Obama is a positive influence on Canada, the USA and the rest of the world.


Ron in the West
said

The left-wingers (or looney left) never cease to amaze me. They would be protesting regardless of Bush's performance while in office. And don't give me that Obama=Intellectual crap. He's no more intellectual than any other politician...he just orates better than most...which means he is a good orator, nothing more nothing less. His record still waits to be written, although he's not off to the best of starts (hello AIG bailout money which he and his administration approved)!
Lefties...get a life and do something constructive and productive with your lives instead of this constant "need" to protest. If you really need to protest...how about looking no further than your own completely incompetent dork leading your NDP Party in Ottawa...Jack Layton. No, you would rather protest someone who isn't even in office anymore. Just a further sign of your complete and utter ignorance and removal from reality.


Don
said

Protesters who threw shoes at a picture of Mr. Bush have the intelligence of kindergarten kids. Oh, sorry kindergarten kids have more smarts than that. If protesters want to make their views known, they have to demonstrate a level of minimal intelligence which they obviously need to work towards.


Jay
said

Well Tarah. Maybe it's because people care about justice being served on a criminal. Think of what would happen to you if you did half of what Bush did. Can you spell gulag? Not being President doesn't make him any less of a criminal. In fact, all the more reason to prosecute.


Ben, Edmonton
said

Fashionable Conservatism in Calgary gives the rest of Alberta a bad reputation. It's a shame.


John Albert Rowand
said

Calgarian for peace said: "Sorry Calgary I am embarrassed to live in Calgary today."

---

Then get out stay out. And how is this a "religious war"? You need to stop throwing cheap shots at religion and actually talk about the issue at hand.


TD in TO
said

protestors make me laugh! Is protesting a job? Because I have a feeling it is the same people over and over again who go out with the sole purpose to find something to plop a sign infront of and start inciting hatred against said person/place/thing. A Life... please get one... I may just see people on my front lawn within minutes of me posting... PS: Sorry to break it to you, GW Bush is no longer president (SHOCK!)


Mary
said

Listen to the piqued and juvenile snivelling about Calgary. It's a welcoming, white hatter City known internationally for its gracious and non-partisan hospitality, the Olympics included. It's also known for its can-do business acumen in varying political climates. Deregulation in the financial districts certainly didn't begin under George. He was speaking to the business community via The Calgary Chamber of Commerce, and the general public weren't included. Obama and the Dems won't be in office in perpetuity, and particularly not in light of what is transpiring currently financially. Calgary is objective and business savvy enough to realize that there are two sides to every fence. Canada characteristically and historically fares far better financially in all sectors when the Republicans are in power. The pendulum always swings the other way eventually. Let the man speak. You don't have to pay for a ticket to listen if you don't like his politics.


Don Smith
said

I was part of the group "protesting" outside of the Calgary convention centre today.

I was there because I think it is a disgrace that any group of people would pay $600,000 to hear him speak.

There's a big problem in our world and the fact that the well-to-do would spend that kind of money on that kind of "celebrity" is part of our problem.

Ashamed to love in Calgary.


CWS Saskatoon
said

Let's see what happens 4 or 8? years from now. Maybe they will be protesting Obama too.


bruno
said

Figures he would go to Texas north on his 1st out of country speaking engagement.


Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz