CTV News | 16 presumed dead as N.L. search ends

Top Stories -   

16 presumed dead as N.L. search ends

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV Newsnet: Greg Locke, N.L. News Agency
NTV News: Glen Carter with reaction to the decision to end the search
CTV Atlantic: Kelland Sundahl on the grim task of recovery
CTV Newsnet: Linda Swain, reporter with Voice of the Common Man Radio, with local reaction to the tragedy
NTV News: Mayor of Bay Bulls Don Drew responds to the crash
NTV News: Darrin Bent on the questions around the response time of the rescue efforts
CTV Newsnet: Officials in N.L. announce the search for the missing will end Friday night
CTV Newsnet: Mike Cunningham, TSB lead investigator, updates the rescue efforts

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(47)

CTV.ca News Staff

Date: Fri. Mar. 13 2009 9:46 PM ET

The search for 16 missing passengers of a helicopter which crashed off the coast of Newfoundland was called off Friday evening, because officials said "the likelihood of finding survivors is no longer there."

The announcement came more than 30 hours after a chopper heading to an oil platform crashed into frigid waters with 18 people on board.

One survivor was rescued from the water on Thursday and is being treated in hospital for his injuries. One death has also been confirmed, but 16 others are now presumed dead.

"It appears there are no survivors," said the Joint Rescue Co-ordination Centre's Maj. Denis McGuire, adding that rescue crews had repeatedly searched a massive area of open water but found no signs of life.

The search officially ended at 7:30 p.m. local time.

The operation has now been handed over to the Transportation Safety Board, who will probe what caused the crash, and the RCMP, who will conduct a missing persons investigation.

Meanwhile, questions have been raised over the Canadian military's response time, amid reports that provincial helicopters were busy on a training mission at the time of the crash.

Normally, two Cormorant search and rescue choppers are stationed in Gander, N.L., which is about 200 northwest of St. John's.

But on Thursday, as the Cougar 2-92 Sikorsky crash landed into the Atlantic, the two Cormorants were conducting an exercise several hundred kilometres away in Sydney, N.S.

However, officials said the training exercise didn't jeopardize the search and rescue mission and didn't result in delays.

"It would have taken one hour from Gander -- it took hours from Sydney," McGuire told The Canadian Press.

Premier Danny Williams echoed those sentiments.

"The rescue officials are not to blame," he told reporters Friday. "This is not intended to be a springboard for that debate."

Crash details

The helicopter was en route from St. John's to the Hibernia platform when the pilot reported mechanical troubles and turned back towards St. John's.

The chopper issued a distress call, and eight minutes later, went into the water.

"Mechanical problems were reported and we don't know of what nature," said Julie Leroux, spokesperson for the Transportation Safety Board.

It is believed that the pilot was "ditching" the aircraft, that is, making an attempt to intentionally crash-land the helicopter due to the mechanical problem.

The crew of a Provincial Airlines plane flew over the area within a few minutes of the crash and reported that the helicopter was floating upside down. The helicopter sunk shortly afterwards.

The chopper crashed and sank in 120 metres of water, and left a debris trail of about six kilometres, officials said.

The missing aircraft is operated by Cougar Helicopters in St. John's.

Communities "at a standstill"

As the search wound down Friday, people along Newfoundland's coastal shore were still holding out hope that more survivors would be found.

But a mood of optimism among community members was turning somber as hope faded, said Don Drew, Mayor of the coastal town Bay Bulls.

"The whole area is affected. Within our community here, people are still in shock that this happened," he said.

Drew added that seven of the 16 missing passengers are from Bay Bulls and other surrounding communities.

"There's a lot of feelings going through the community today," he said, adding that people's lives have ground to a "standstill" because of the tragedy.

"We all know of so many people that work in that industry and they fly back and forth," he said.

"Our hearts are going out to the families of all those involved ... we wish it was better."

With files from The Canadian Press


Comments are now closed for this story

Newfie Lover
said

My heart goes out to the families who are waiting on edge to learn of their loved ones' fate.


Fellownewfie
said

I am curious are the Cougar choppers equipt with the pontoon system that the Bell choppers have that fly personnel to the north sea oil fields? It is designed to be deployed just before hitting the water allowing the chopper to remain upright so the men can escape. If they don't maybe they should. So another tragedy can be avoided. My sympathies and prayers to the familes of the missing men. Hopefully all will be rescued.


vivian kelly-lambert
said

Our hearts and prayers go out to the families who are with such a tradgedy. From all the newfoundlanders in Fort Saskatchewan, Alberta


edwin bishop
said

I remember the morning of the sinking of the ocean Ranser .On that morning the first person that I met going to work was one of my neighbours and friend , I thought that he was out to the rig . I remember how glad i was when I saw him. He didn' know about the sinking at that time until I told him. I remember the fear in his voice when he ssid my God Wade is out . Later we learned that his brother in law , my friend Wade was one of the lost . I can only express my sorrow and prayers to the families and love ones of those who are missing now . God bless!!


Newfoundlander forever
said

FellowNewfie, yes the s-92's do have a float system that are deployed to help keep it boyant. Keep in mind that there are two engines and the helocopter head located on the top of the aircraft, thus making it top heavy. If they did make a controlled ditch, the aircraft would of been afloat right side up but many factors have to be considered, i.e waves, wind, how did it hit the water etc.

My thoughts and prayers are with the families and friends of the crew and passengers of this flight.


b brown
said

God bless the families . There is still hope. Good luck to the brave rescue workers..


Susan in Halifax
said

I am saddened by this news and am praying the outcome is better than we all expect.The Atlantic isn`t terribly forgiving.


Married to a Newfie
said

The problem ditching in high seas is tha tthe chopper likely tumbled down a wave after hitting the water ,rolling into the sea and ending up upside down.

It is virtually impossible in heavy seas to avoid this.


Brenda Keddy
said

My husband and I flew with Cougar and Rick Burt for years offshore, NS. As Radio Operator and Medic we worked closely with the pilots every day. First class does not say enough about their professionalism and courage. The oilfield workers fly in and out once, every few weeks. These pilots do this every day. It is the intensive training, maintenance and strict regulatory compliance that allowed Cougar Helicopter pilots to perform the rescue and recovery of the only two persons found, so far. The whole time understanding what the conditions were, what the risks were and what the odds were of finding the passengers and two of their own. God bless guys and we'd fly with you today.

Our thoughts and prayers are with all persons in peril, their families and co-workers still offshore trying to digest this information.


Karen
said

My prayer go out to the families and who wait for news from their loved ones. Nothing is worse then not hearing news when your so scared. Also my prayers go out to the company they are trying so hard to find anyone who may have surrived.


Karen
said

As a Newfoundlander living in St. John's, it is daily that your hear helicopters fly over head. You tend to look up at them as they fly above you, but you never imagine a tragedy such as this one. My thoughts and prayers are with all those involved.


jasper blanchard
said

i have a neighbour involved in that crash .i can feel their devestation, my prayers are with the famalies


Mona
said

My nephew would have been on this flight had he not accepted a request to return to work a week early.
Thank Heavens for his smart decision to change his plans & go back to work.
My heart goes out to all the lost (hope yet to be found) & their families.I can imagine the heartache / and still remember the Ocean Ranger when friends were lost.
For all the loved ones hanging on for the last bit of hope >>> May you find comfort in the memories that are yours to cherish always & the strength in the companionship of those who share your loss.. wishing you comfort & peace at this difficult time.God bless.



Bave Barton in Newington
said

As an immigrant to Canada the first bunch of people I worked with in Malton at a small factory were all off "the rock"
In the past 44 years I can only add that I have NEVER met a "Newfie" young,old,gal or guy I didn't instantly like.
Their humour,outlook on life and generosity should be an example to each and every one of us.

God Bless all those families involved in this terrible tragedy, my thoughts and prayers are with you all.


Michael
said

There is no hope now after this amount of time in the North Atlantic.

They have stepped into the other side of eternity. May God bring comfort to their families and loved ones.



Rose
said

It's very sad that this had happened. Unfortunately now it would probably be safe to say it's now a recovery mission and not a rescue mission. My heart goes out to the families in which this tragedy involves. God bless you all and may you find the strength to get through this terrible accident.


Patti
said

I am from Sault Ste. Marie, ON my heart goes out to all the families and rescue workers, I have been following this story, and I am praying as hard as I can. God be with you all.


Rob
said

It is now 11:28a.m. Lord, please guide the search and rescue team to these men and women. Do miracles! Please save them. In Jesus name, Amen


Ian
said

My hope and prayers go out to all the families of those missing and hope they are recovered Bluenoser now living in louisiana


Doug
said

This is a terrible tragedy. Prayers and condolences go out to all the families involved. May they all be found.


Linda in Vancouver
said

Prayers and best wishes to these men,and to their families from the west coast of Canada.
Time is not our friend right now,but no one should give up until all hope is lost.


Patricia
said

Hopefully, those in the helicopter were able to escape from the aircraft before it sank. Otherwise the chances of finding any of them alive are slim since they would have been trapped inside and drowned. What a horrible ordeal no matter what happened. The one survivor must be absolutely in shock and disbelief that he was able to be rescued. It would be a wonderful miracle if more survivors could be found!


James
said

With Survival suits on, there is always the possibility there may be someone alive in the ocean. Hopefully the Canadian Coast Guard and Canadian Forces Search and Rescue will find something before nightfall.

Remember the book "Down but not out?"


Tony in Trinity Bay
said

As this day goes on, the chances of finding survivors is greatly reduced, but not impossible.

Whatever the outcome, there are a lot of people who need a lot of love and prayers.

Again, my heart goes out to all involved, from those who are lost, to the at least one survivor, their families and the officials who are working on so many levels to get all hands through this, may GOD be your guide.

Obviously, many communities throughout our Province will be affected by such a tragedy. Hold on to the memories you have of loved ones and hold on to the loved ones you have with you right now.

We only have the past and the present, we are not guaranteed the future.

To those who are involved in this surreal earth shattering experience, don't go through this alone. Reach out to a friend, family, your church, or a professional.

God Bless You All


Barry Hennessey
said

As a Newfoundlander living in Northwestern Ontario, I am also greatly saddened by this latest tragedy back home. I just hope that (if no more survivors are found) at least those still missing will be recovered.

On behalf of my wife, our heartfelt condolences to all families, relatives, and friends of those involved.
Take care of one another and God bless...


missy
said

My heart is sadden by such a lost. My prayers are with all the families at this time.


Shelly
said

My prayers go out to the families that this is affecting. May God be with you all.


Judy and Chester
said

Out thoughts are with our fellow Newfoundlanders and hope they all return home safe.For those that may not return home may their families take comfort in prayer.


Wanda
said

The Atlantic Ocean means no harm with her unintential cold embrace.

Please God watch over the one survivor and lead the dedicated rescuers to his friends and transport buddies. God please give the family members the strength and courage to endure all that may come their way.

I'm still praying for a miracle.


Colin Olsen
said

To Fellownewfie - The helo MAY have been equipped with deployable inflatable pontoons, but there may not have been enough time to actually delpoy them properly before surface impact. Chances are that the helo had what is called a catastrophic gearbox failure and the crew didn't have any opportunity to deploy such devices.


ME
said

Is there any rational to spend so much time and money searching by air and sea while not searching the Helicopter to see if the men are in it. Could not both be done at the same time.

This prolonged uncertainty must be terrible for the families and my heart goes out to them. Very tragic


Morgan Burden St. Luniare(Saskatchewan Now)
said

May the Good Lord bless each and everyone involved in this tragic event....As a Newfie who as worked in the Oil industry for the past 10 yrs in Alberta I know how close People can get...It's like one big Family...No can take away the pain that your feeling right now...but I Hope and Pray you find Solice in the Fact that they were doin something they all loved. Has Newfie's it seems no matter what we do for a job we will forever be tied to the sea.May God Bless you From My Family to Yours...


Bobbie Leigh
said

My heart goes out to all the families of those who were on board.
Halifax, NS


eve beaulieu ori
said

please find my oncle in the ocean he means a lot to me and i have not sean him in 3 years.


eve beaulieu ori
said

please find my oncle in the ocean he means a lot to me and i have not sean him in 3 years.


Ann & Glen Castle
said

We are so sorry for the loss of your love ones, There is no words to make it better for you. Our hearts are with you.


Joyce ,Walter & Family
said

May god bless each and every family member of the lost crew. Our prayers are with each and everyone. May god also keep the man who survived strong.


chuckie
said

We are so sorry for the families of these people. Life is truly short, so live every minute as though it is your last. Tell your families you love them every time you part. You will never regret it.


Catherine British Columbia
said

Very Sad time for the Familys involved. The North Alantic is a very loving sea it takes and gives back so when we think about it we have them in our hearts for ever and ever we will never forget what happened. God Bless all involved. And the survivor can be at peace. reason for life we all live.


wife of a rigger alberta
said

our hearts and prayers go out to all the families that have lost their love ones may god be with you all


Doug BC
said

Finding people in the vast Atlantic Ocean is never an easy thing to do.But,given the debris they found,and the more time that goes by,I am beginning to think these men never got out of the chopper before it sank.
120 metres of water makes me think the helicopter could possbily be recovered so the families could eventually know for certain what happened to their loved ones.But I don't think it's ever a "waste of time" to carry on searching in cases where there is even one iota of a chance to find ewven one more survivor.
I'm a recreational diver on the western side of this beautiful country.I love the ocean,but it has always come with built in dangers.Since the beginning of recorded history,there have always been people brave enough to face those dangers.And,I suspect the same will be true hundreds of years from now.
Deepest sympathies to the friends and families of these people.We have been praying for a much better outcome.Your warmth and commitment to helping others in distress are well known in all parts of Canada.
Sadly,that doesn't seem to have been enough to help your own,this time.
You deserved a much better outcome.


Retired Soldier at Kingston, ON
said

Reference the tragic helicopter crash at Hibernia and the military Search And Rescue response:

Readers need to know that the courageous men and women of the Search and Rescue Sqn's, risk their life willingly on these hazardous missions. NO ONE can order them to risk their lives; they opt to do this willingly! Whats more, the military can't indulge in finger-pointing like the media. They're forbidden this luxury by their Code / Ethos! Reporters on site with dubious motives... take note!

The investigation should focus on the training provided to flight crews and passengers on these shuttle helicopters! Why did 16 people die in broad daylight while fitted out with "Helly Hansen" survival suits? Where were their flotation devices? Liferafts? Where was the helicopter company backup at Hibernia? Who was the on-scene commander at Hibernia and why did'nt they call the military in Dartmouth NS on the "hot-line" for back-up in a timely fashion? Etc, etc.

A nations condolences to the families of the deceased -
"Pro Patria" indeed!



Jamie
said

First of all let me send my condolences to the famlies of this horriable accident. My thoughts and prayers are with you at this time.
I wanted to comment about the people who are questioning the response time of the Canadian Forces after this accident. They are risking their lives to bring Newfoundland and our Country the best S.A.R in the world in my opinion. Don't sit there and think in your little mind that they didn't do everything possible in the search effort. In closing may the lost members of that flight Rest in peace.


cooch
said

To all the family and friends of those involved in this terrible tragedy our prayers and thoughts are with you.
No one can ever make sense of such a thing. Hopefully the help and love of friends and family can somehow ease your pain and sorrow. God Bless Ye All


Jamie/ Halifax
said

My thoughts and prayers are with all the famlies at this time. As a Newfoundlander and a member of the Canadian Forces (Navy), I know how unforgiving the sea can be. May God Bless you and be with you during this difficult time.


Lindsey Daine
said

Prayers going out the Families


annabelle
said

my thoughts and prayers are going out to the families of this terrible tragedy.God Bless each and everyone.


Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz