CTV News | Healthy food prices vary widely across Canada

Top Stories -   

Healthy food prices vary widely across Canada

Viewer

CTV News Video

Canada AM: Dr. Marco Di Buono, Heart and Stroke Foundation
CTV News: Avis Favaro reports on the discrepancies
CTV Newsnet: Stephen Samis, Heart and Stroke Foundation, on the report
CTV Atlantic: Jacqueline Foster on how prices vary from city to city in Atlantic Canada
CTV Newsnet: Dr. Beth Abramson, cardiologist, discusses the negative health implications of the higher prices
CTV Ottawa: Sally Brown, CEO of the Heart and Stroke Foundation, discusses the findings

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(55)

CTV.ca News Staff

Date: Mon. Feb. 9 2009 1:44 PM ET

Some Canadians are paying between double and nearly six times the average price for healthy foods, depending on where in the country they live, according to a report from the Heart and Stroke Foundation of Canada.

The report found price discrepancies across the country and within provinces. It also found many Canadians have difficulty accessing healthy foods at their local grocery store.

The report, entitled "Heart and Stroke Foundation's Annual Report on Canadians' Health," discovered:

  • A wide cost variation across the country for fruits and vegetables. For example, six apples cost $0.90 in Peterborough, Ont., but $7.64 in Rankin Inlet, Nunavut.
  • Whole-wheat pasta in Dawson City, Yukon, can cost between four and six times what it costs in Barrie, Ont. ($11.37 in Dawson City compared to $2 in Barrie).
  • Milk, cheese and meat costs twice in the communities with the highest prices than in the communities with the lowest (the average low price being between $4 and $6 and the highest price ranging from $8 to almost $14).

The high cost and low availability of a variety of healthy foodstuffs puts Canadians at risk of a number of health problems, according to Heart and Stroke Foundation CEO Sally Brown.

"Those risk factors will decrease dramatically if you eat a healthy diet," Brown told CTV Ottawa on Monday. "Because healthy foods do a number of things: you lose weight, it stabilizes your blood pressure, it lowers your cholesterol and it manages your blood sugar. So, we need people to eat healthier, and if we're going to price food in certain communities out of reach, Canadians aren't going to."

According to Brown, 25 per cent of cases of heart disease, stroke and other ailments could be prevented if Canadians were eating a diet rich in fruits, vegetables, grains and lean meats and dairy products.

For the study, Foundation staff recruited 66 volunteer shoppers across Canada who were asked to purchase a list of foods based on Health Canada's National Nutritious Food Basket. The basket was created to aid health officials in evaluating Canadians' accessibility to healthy foods.

The volunteers were asked to choose items from the list to feed a family of four for one week. They shopped at a national or regional grocery chain in their community and were given a list of national food brands to choose from.

Not all of the volunteers could find a wide array of healthy foods.

For example, the volunteers found that dried beans and frozen spinach were unavailable in one out of three grocery stores. One in five stores did not have unbreaded frozen fish, while only 10 per cent of stores carried fresh chicken legs.

In contrast, the prices of unhealthy snacks such as pop, chips and cookies varied little across the country, and were also widely available.

Not surprisingly, a survey of more than 1,400 Canadians contained in the report found that 42 per cent occasionally go without a particular type of food because of the cost.

The survey also found that:

  • Nearly one in five Canadians forgo at least one type of food almost every time they shop because of the cost.
  • Almost one-quarter of Canadians have to go without lean meat and poultry, while one in five Canadians have to forgo fruit and vegetables.

It is unclear why food prices and availability vary so widely across the country, Brown said.

"We don't know why it happens," she said. "That's why the Heart and Stroke Foundation is saying we really need governments, the food industry and others to research why these prices are so variable."

According to the survey's results, many Canadians feel the government has a role to play in making nutritious foods more accessible.

The survey found that 86 per cent of Canadians believe the government should regulate the price of nutritious foods to ensure that they are equally affordable across the country, while 84 per cent believe government should raise the income of lower-income Canadians.

The Heart and Stroke Foundation agrees, calling on the government to monitor and report on the cost of staple foods included in Health Canada's food basket, research price inconsistencies across the country and improve programs that deliver nutritious foods to isolated northern communities.

"If governments and provinces can regulate the cost of alcohol," the Foundation's Dr. Beth Abramson told CTV Newsnet, "surely we should be able to find some way to make sure Canadians have accessibility to healthy food choices."

Comments are now closed for this story

VH
said

I think it is a good idea to regulate the price of healthy food across the country. I don't generally agree with regulation, but there are some things, like food, that should not be subject to such price variations. A poor diet has implications for our health care system.


Prof. Pye Chartt
said

OH SO TYPICAL

"The survey found that 86 per cent of Canadians believe the government should regulate the price of nutritious foods to ensure that they are equally affordable across the country, while 84 per cent believe government should raise the income of lower-income Canadians."

It seems no "Canadian" survey would be complete without capturing our loving embrace of socialism, and the belief that government is our all-important caretaker.

Sad. Pathetic.


Michelle in Steinbach
said

Good Job for reporting on this. It's amazing though...we in more urban areas are feeling this pinch...but nothing like the northern communities. I believe milk is around $12 a jug there...fruits and vegetables are outrageously priced. We need to keep this in the news till the folks up there get some relief. And yet pop and chips are under a dollar. Could any of us afford to feed our families nutritiously at those prices?


Terri
said

Here's an idea.

Tax unhealthy food like we do tobacco. Soda pop and chip prices should go up and those taxes can then go into subsidizing healthy foods.

Why should unhealthy food producers get a free ride? Don't you think they affect our health care costs as much as tobacco?


Roger T
said

How is this new......we already know that and it's nothing new to anyone. Retailers try to take advantage of consumers where they can especially the bigger stores.

It doesn't matter where you live, retailers will impose their price fixing becuase if consumers have no other choice to shop.

Hopefully, with the recession dragging on ALL those who've took advantage of consumers will go bankrupt due to greed.


Vee
said

It's only my husband and I in our household and we make a point to eat healthy. It's been more and more difficult to do so in Calgary since the prices of produce and groceries in general have been raised. We've gone from paying $150-$200 every two weeks for two people, to $250-$300 every two weeks for two people. I can't even imagine how larger families are doing it.


Dave, Ottawa
said

Better yet, let's have government-operated stores sell everything. We could be a socialist paradise, just like Cuba, eh comrades?

Only two places were specifically mentioned in the article - Rankin Inlet, and Dawson City, both in the high north. Rankin, an Inuit community only accessible by air, is not known for it's abundance of apple trees, nor are apples a staple of the traditonal diet. And Dawson, also a little off the beaten path, does not have a pasta factory. Naturally, all imported goods are going to be more expensive, due to the difficulty in getting them there.

That junk food is consistantly priced is somewhat puzzling, but is likely due to the fact that the high demand for it makes it an "economy of scale" issue.

If there is money to be made by opening a fresh produce store with prices lower than "grocery chains" (remind me again of the name of the grocery chain in Rankin? Is that a Loblaws or a Sobeys? Perhaps it's a Wal-Mart SuperCentre) surely someone will open one.

And the comment about alcohol price regulation was quite amusing. The prices are regulated to make it MORE EXPENSIVE, not less so.


Eric
said

Good grief. Junk foods don't hurt people as much as tobacco and I really wish people would quit using that awful analogy. The vast majority of people eat a relatively small amount of "junk" food a few times a month. That is not "hurting" you. Smokers are by and large chronically addicted and an incredible drain on society resources. Even light smokers gravely increase the risk of cancers and diseases. All tax increases on food is going to do is negatively impact those most venerable in society.


BIG-Jim
said

To Terri!

Hello? Tobacco is not the only thing out there that raises health care costs but so many people like yourself point the finger in only ONE direction.
The grocery stores are full of greed like, Safeway, Save-on foods, IGA, etc.
They are upper management heavy and who gets the privilege of paying their greedy salaries? Us the shoppers trying to feed their families. Fuel went UP so did prices, fuel went down per barrel, not at the pumps and NOT at stores!!
So you need to rethink your logic I am thinking!!!


John Calgary
said

Regulate it? Shipping to northern locations is expensive. The cost of operating in those locations is more expensive. Blame the store owners/managers. Pop and chips always make it to the shelves. Who makes that decision? The profit margins are probably higher in the high fat, processed crap that is poured into the trough, cleverly disquised as "food". Shame on the store managers for not creating a better food source. Why not suit them all for perpetuating poor health?


Sara in Sask
said

Well said Prof. People still dont know that the banks and the big corporations OWN the government!


Kelly in Vancouver
said

I agree with Dave in Ottawa. Fresh food in isolated towns is more expensive because it is much more difficult to transport it there. I grew up in a small, northern town that was accessable only by air, rail, or an 8-hour long dirt road. I don't think I saw a green banana until I moved to Ontario. Even potatoes were half black by the time they made it to our supermarkets. Although we could buy fresh meat, poultry was often bruised and contained broken bones from the long trip over the road. Chips, pop, and other processed foods were probably cheaper because they were non-perishable and therefore didn't have as strict a time-limit.

I don't know how the government would regulate the costs of these foods, since no trucker is going to accept less money to transport these goods to isolated areas, especially these days.


Doug BC
said

OMG!!! A survery comes out that states the obvious,and we line up for more taxes and more regulations.It makes one think there really is no hope for Canada.It's filled with special interest groups,slef appointed do gooders,social engineers and people to dependent on someone else to make their choices for them.
EVERY place you might opt to live comes with a list of pluses and minuses.Some will have more jobs,some will have less crime.Some others will have higher prices,but less crime,and maybe more land.Some let you buy less because you can garden for yourself,or hunt and fish for a part of your diet.
Attempts to make us all the same,no matter where we live,is nothing short of social engineering.We will soon need to alter our national anthem to remove the "true north strong and FREE" part.
It won't be the USA,or bad economic policy,or even provincial differences that tear this country apart.It will be the nannies,the social engineers,the people who do polls,and those who follow them without looking into the context or the unintended consequences that come with them.
I have a novel idea.Live your own life,make your own choices,reap your own rewards for good decisions and take responsibility for the poor ones.
And,oh yea,stop reading self serving polls as though they are commandments for a higher power,and contain the solutions to all your troubles.
This "survey" looks like complete rubbish.Although I concede,it could help someone decide to move to a place where milk is cheaper,it won't tell that peson what they are giving up just to get cheap milk.
I "choose" to accept the higher northern prices in favour a lifestyle I love.I value my rural life a lot more than cheap food in Vancouver.


Jon in Burlington
said

Having been in the Food Industry for many years, toy will find most retail pricing is dictated by the chain distributing the products. Obviously fresh foods cost a lot more to ship because of the fragile nature and short shelf life of certain products. I f you are in the far far reaches of the north getting producrs [freah is nor aleays feasible do to weather also. It is great to do these studies but they should talk to people in the industry before the put their incorrect and not completly researched informatiom on the internet.


Dale - Edmonton
said

Summing up then - small stores have less selection and higher prices than large ones and food costs more in the North. Shocking.


M
said

To Terri... EXCELLENT idea! I'm with you 100%. Now it's time to pitch this to our MLAs and MPs.


vicky
said

I totally agree that the govt should step in. Healthy food should be cheap enough for everyone to afford. I wish salt water fish was cheap in toronto. Its just too expensive to have if you have a family of four


Kaye
said

I am in Calgary as well and I agree with Vee. My weekly grocery order was in the $150 range and now it is over $200. I buy fresh fruit and fresh vegetables, very little meat so eating healthy does cost substantially more in Calgary for my son and I. I am now spending around $800/month for food whereas it used to be in the $500/$600 range....for my small family. Glad I do not live in remote locations if it is this bad here ... having a hard time with everything just going up except for my income.


Mel from Calgary
said

If shipping cost is responsible for the higher prices in northern Canada then why is New Zealand lamb cheaper than Alberta lamb here in Calgary?

Something is skewing prices on everything, not just food. This needs to be the topic of CTV's next article.


Michelle
said

If you live in either of the "expensive" places mentioned in the article, you receive the northern living allowance precisely because the cost of living is higher, due to the remote location and harshness of the climate.
As far as the relative low cost and availability of "junk" food in those same locations, who is to say that retails haven't tried to stock healthier choices? Retailers carry the items that will sell, and if the consumers demand pop and chips, then that is what will be on the shelves. I live in an area where the cost and availability of healthy foods is quite good, yet if you examine the carts of the majority of shoppers, they are full of processed, prepackaged and junk foods; and they spend far more than I do on groceries even though my family eats a whole foods, natural and organic diet.
The problem with people's diets isn't a lack of price regulation; if anything the problem is that we expect the government to "fix" everything for us instead of taking personal responsibility for our lives.


Julie
said

Terry - in Quebec at least, junk food is considered 'luxury' and is taxed... no taxes on healthy food.

What I don't understand is having lived in Hull for a while, why 2L of milk is under 3$ in Hull and literally five minutes across a bridge it is over 4$ for 2L in Ottawa. Ridiculous!


Ara Hepburn
said

We've been unable to afford fruit and most veggies for a couple of years now.
Bread is at 4.95 and we live in the lower mainland.
Luckily we don't use butter, margarine, junk or processed foods but buying basic real food is becoming difficult.
Yes, the prices went up when the fuel did but didn't come down when fuel dropped.
We wish that could be looked into.


Faith
said

Healthy foods - try adding allergies to that and the cost goes up even more. Dairy free celiacs disease with reactions to MSG, soy and spices is not fun to shop for. Thank God he is not allergic to nuts too.



KJ in Kingston Ontario
said

The ironic twist of this is that as one educates and promotes the importance of selecting more of the healthier foods -- one might expect demand to grow -- and therefore the price to further increase. The idea of regulating prices is ridiculous, the government would have to buy these foods in a lower price zone and sell it at a loss to make that work.. No private supplier is going to remain in a unprofitable market for long... Anyone remember life under government price and wage controls…?


Laura
said

After living in Northern BC, I can now understand the huge price jumps between urban Ontario and the BC North. However, I did notice that most people there chose to grow their own food, fished and hunted for their meat and canned/froze enough to last the winter. So maybe prices are higher because demand is lower? Just a thought...


John Kent
said

Dear Sirs:
I was amazed at your report of the cost differences of food in different parts of Canada , it is obvious that you have no clue as to the fact that it costs a lot of money for trucking these items all the way to Nunavut as an example, or do you really expect these trucking companies to absorb these costs ?your naieve attitude was really surprizing to me.


Liz Sutherland
said

Definitely higher, and it went up when our gas prices went sky high. Now with lower gas prices, the cost of fruit and vegetables did not fluctuate, therefore the higher price.


Ed L
said

The gov't already regulates dairy, eggs, some meats and others. The result is higher prices. Older readers may remember when the Egg Marketing Board destroyed 3 million eggs in order to cut the supply and keep prices high. There are also political considerations: By law, 50% of Canada's cheese must be produced in Quebec. Ontario milk producers are forced to ship milk across the border instead of using their own excess cheese making capacity.

Does it really sound like more gov't is the solution here?


glen in edmonton
said

It's funny because when I lived in NFLD, healthy foods were even too expensive to look at yet junk food was way cheaper in NFLD than in AB even with high taxes so shipping costs have little to do with it.


rock doc
said

Hardly startling that food in Yukon, NWT, or Nunavut costs more than it does in Ontario...it has to be shipped alot farther. Even "unhealthy" food costs more.


How's That?
said

What blows my mind is that for about $40 a month I can pay a charity to regularily feed healthy food to a kid in Africa but we can't get cheap apples and whole grain products to remote regions of Canada where many live in poverty. What is up with that?


Mary Clarke
said

What this report fails to mention,is the liklihood,that "unhealthy" foods are just as overpriced as the healthy choices.
So,you can either choose expensive unhealthy choices,or expensive healthy ones.
If you choose to live in the middle of nowhere,you're going to pay a high price for it.


L in Peterborough
said

I live in Peterborough (mentioned in the survey) where we have seen food prices rise substantially in the past year (from 100 every two weeks to 150), although I understand that we are still in a better region than many when it comes to grocery prices. My husband and I are able to eat well by shopping smart... we buy lean cuts of meat that are onsale every week - and try to find meats marked down by 50% that we can eat right away or freeze. I buy the vegetables and fruit that are on sale and supplement with frozen. It can be done - it just takes a bit more effort than simply eating what you feel like and shopping without regard.


common sense
said

Did anyone look at which communities have the highest prices? They are in Nunavut and the Yukon. Now why would that be, I wonder!


Leonard Downey
said

WHO IS THE MIDDLE MAN

A few years back BSE hit the Canadian stage, Famers seen price's crumble to near 0.Government investigated into why pricing never dropped at the retail level, with no results,it was a puzzle.

Northern canada's higher prices are no puzzle their diet is no puzzle, but the difference in pricing in canada's largest city is somewhat puzzling.

If the last investigation is any benchmark, let't not waste anymore money in these rough economic times.


Michelle in Steinbach
said

I am so blown away by how many ignorant people there are posting on this page. If you choose to live there? If someone is born into a struggling community...with no resources...how are they supposed to move? How are they supposed to understand what choices there are if they have never been given any? It's ignorant to assume that these situations are black and white.


Laura Langstaff
said

Nobody speaks about the elephant in the room. These nameless northern and remote communities, are predominantly Aboriginal. Inuit folks are circum-polar, that is where they belong Mary. They also deserve to exist without the social engineering of the dominant cultures, such as outrageous consumer costs which means healthy foods are not easily accessible to the Inuit. Lets call it what it is, an historic attack on Aboriginal communities.


H Herman
said

The government should put more money into the hands of the poor. Some people can't work and are expected to survive on under 700 dollars a month. Subtract rent utilities and see what is left for food. you do the math


jayme
said

I would like to see a heavy junk food tax.

Exazmple
Bag of chips $2.00
Junk food tax $5.00

How many people would pay $7.00 ofor a bag of chips.


Ron
said

It only makes sense it is more expensive in remote areas because of transportation costs, proximity to market. When I worked in far northern B.C., the fresh produce was not so fresh and choice was limited.

However, isn't that the reason why some communities in northern area like the territories get a northern allowance and often a higher salary? I for one, do not believe Canadians in general through Government, should be subsidzing the cost of fresh produce or fruit. An absolute disater and as others have put it, too socialistic. Maybe a food ombusman to monitor the gouging if it indeed exists.


G. Gravelle, Ottawa, Ontario
said

I thought merchandise and food were more expensive up north in Canada because of the increased costs involved in delivering the foods up there. If that's not the case, the prices should be dropped.

The price of food should not be based on what city it's sold in but on its actual value.


Van
said

Terri's comment about raising taxes on unhealthy food, all the junk food, is a fabulous idea. The hard part would be determining the line between healthy and unhealthy but it sounds like a great idea and the funds raised could subsidize the cost of healthy food to bring it down. Government of Canada, are you listening?


jay
said

How's That?
I would love to see some solid proof that $40 feed a family for a month.I have its more like $200.


Wee Mikey in BC
said

I totally agree with Doug in BC, what's the matter with helping yourself? In Inuvik,NWT. some community members converted an old hockey rink into a huge greenhouse where folk can rent plots and grow healthy food or purchase starter plants for their own gardens (remember 24 hour daylight up there?). Here in Burns Lake we have a community garden. These things are not out-of-this-world, merely ordinary people finding, sometimes extra-, ordinary solutions. Even in Burns Lake apples will thrive and this is Zone 2b I believe.
Get your municipality to set aside some land for apartment dwellers to grow gardens, encourage your local school board to have an extra-mural gardening program for the students.....and on and on.


Leslie
said

Who pays the difference if the price of 'healthy food' is regulated? Does the price of apples increase in cheaper parts of the country (where apples are grown) to cover selling apples in the North for less than the cost of production and transportation? Or will the producers be expected to subsidize making food cheaper in the more inaccesible parts of the country? The grocery store chains certainly won't absorb the costs of selling apples for the same price in Rankin Inlet as in Niagara-on-the-Lake.


KM
said

To those of you who think that eating unhealthy food is not a strain on our health care system, please think again.
Our hospitals are full of people whose illnesses are a direct result of the food that they choose to eat.
A person who eats high fat foods is more likely to be overweight and is also more likely to develop heart disease, diabetes, respiratory problems, back pain, knee problems, etc.
Along with all these problems come endless tests, prescription medication, physiotherapy, surgery, etc.
Not a strain on our health care system? I think not.




matt miramichi
said

what a bunch of babies this country has become. you try getting foods up to nunavut and see how much the transport cost is, or better yet give Castro a call


Jason
said

"Prof. Pye Chartt
OH SO TYPICAL

I dunno what to make of people like yourself. Anything that encourages togetherness or fairness seems to so upsetting you decided to come here to blow up. Why do greedy, self serving drags on society feel it necessary to use a vehicle for discussion for such loathsome purposes?

How horrible. Altruism. Egad. I suppose you took or are planning to take your mother somewhere in the wilderness to let her fend for herself when she becomes a burden.

Like you said.

Sad, Pathetic


mike
said

that's so true healthy foods are so expensive even in the ontario sticks like pembroke where i am in case any of you people haven't heard of pembroke it's west of ottawa but when wal-mart here expands and adds a grocery section it's gonna knock down the prices in the other stores because they need to be knocked down a peg


vince in trenton
said

Nobody has stated the obvious here. They set the price were they want because you need to eat. What choice do you have, pay it or starve. Just like gas, pay it or walk.... If you don't like the price of something don't buy it. Don't expect the government to give you a handout everytime there is a story about something that costs more in one place than another. It is not always the governments fault....


Gail (Hamilton)
said

Prof. Pye Chartt exudes common sense. We don't need more government interference. Transportation costs put the price of food up. People should use coupons supplied by companies for their products, buy locally when you can, and learn to do more canning and preserves. Buy what you can afford and don't go overboard. Teaching people how to budget and home economics should be taught in the classroom.


jay
said

What a important thing to keep in mind is this is not just a poor person probleam.In fact you go into rich or middle class commuunites this is a very big probleam.People who work in high tech or evn the go or law firms have no time to cook.So what do they do yes that right they eat junk food.


Bonnie G.
said

Food costs should be regulated across the country. I left Alberta and came to PEI. The apples here are just about as much as the apples in the yukon. It is much cheaper to buy fresh food in Alberta, and apparently peterbourough Ontario, as compared to here. Even the electricity isat least four times the price out here as it is in Alberta. What Gives? One of the poorest provinces and yet the highest prices.


Greg from Down Under
said

Wow, research shows that food transported by air or thousands of Km over northern roads is costlier... that’s quite a revelation.

I've got an idea, let's give our friends who live in the north a tax break and an allowance to overcome the higher costs of fresh foods, perhaps call it the Northern Allowance or something...oh, wait a moment...

Better yet a Royal Commission to study the matter.



Brandon Calgary
said

"84 per cent believe government should raise the income of lower-income Canadians"

Let me do math if you raise the wage of all the staff who make "lower-incomes" then the store needs to make more money so they raise the cost of the merchandise. so lets look back at our poor worker who got a raise but is still poor because they cant afford anything as the prices went up and the not so poor workers become more poor because they don’t get a raise hmm 1+1=2

Lets be realistic people idealistically it would be great that everyone makes lots of money but if that were true then how are you going to expect any service when no one can afford to pay that employee

Oh and to tax junk food like cigarettes is dumb why not then tax watching tv, sitting on the couch, playing contact sports, beer, fights, internet blogging - i hear that carpal tunnel is the new black?

Taxing cigarettes was great got me to quit and probably saved my life - i dont eat junk food but i like to know that when im to lazy to cook a meal and to poor to eat at a restuarant i have option's


Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

Subscribe!

CTV MedNews Express

CTV MedNews Express

Sign up for our weekly medical newsletter, delivered for free to your inbox.

CTV.ca Blogs

Health Blog Avis Favaro Marla Shapiro

Health Blog

Check out what our guest medical experts and CTV health reporters are writing about.

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz