CTV News | 'Puffingate' to Couillard: Top political headlines of '08

Top Stories -   

'Puffingate' to Couillard: Top political headlines of '08

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV Newsnet: Bruce Hicks, University of Montreal

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(40)

Andy Johnson, CTV.ca News

Date: Wed. Dec. 31 2008 7:19 AM ET

From raven-haired beauties with links to bikers attending cabinet swearing-in ceremonies, to the so-called "Puffingate" scandal, this year has kept journalists busy and provided plenty of fodder for headlines.

The exciting year in Ottawa began with allegations of corruption against former prime minister Brian Mulroney, and ended with the near-fall of the government in December.

"This has been an unparalleled political year in terms of the direction it has taken and the events that occurred. It is seldom, if ever that there has been a year like this," said CTV's Chief Political Correspondent Craig Oliver told CTV.ca

With that in mind we felt it was time to look back on the stories that gripped the headlines this year, and compile a list of our favourite political stories from 2008.

The federal government's near collapse

We're actually still waiting to see how this one plays out at the end of January. But it's been an exciting few weeks with a rare game of high-stakes political chess playing out on Parliament Hill.

It all started with the Conservatives' fiscal update, which prompted the Liberals and NDP to form a coalition with the backing of the Bloc. The fired-up group pledged to topple the government when the bill came before Parliament a week later.

With few options open to him, Prime Minister Stephen Harper convinced Gov. Gen. Michaelle Jean to prorogue Parliament until the end of January, keeping his government alive until it delivers a budget on the 27th -- and possible saving his own political neck.

"No one's ever seen anything like it," Oliver said, noting that the political mood was "feverish and angry."

"Nobody has ever used prorogation to prevent a defeat, that was unprecedented and the Governor General could easily have said sorry, and called on the Opposition to form a government, or called for an election."

The federal election

Canadians went to the polls this year for the third time in four years, and the result was the third straight minority government.

When the election was first called, most observers, Oliver included, believed the Conservatives' strong support in the polls, the deep divisions in the Liberal party and the weak leadership of Stephane Dion, would all lead to a Conservative majority.

But Harper's handling of Quebec -- where he desperately needed to gain ground -- demonstrated a deep misunderstanding of the political climate in the province, and probably cost him the majority he sought.

"Many of us believed a majority was within his reach, and I think it was, but he made those remarks in Quebec which were a complete mystery to all of us," Oliver said.

Allan Tupper, a political scientist from the University of British Columbia, agreed, blaming "Harper's blunder on arts funding, reinforced by the Conservatives' profound misunderstanding about Quebeckers' opinions on the treatment of young offenders."

The election was so loaded with material we came up with three subheadings:

'Puffingate'

Shortly after the election was called, the Conservatives launched a website aimed at engaging young people in mocking the Liberals, and particularly then-leader Stephane Dion and deputy-leader Michael Ignatieff.

The main page featured a picture of a nerdy-looking Dion, with a puffin flying over his head, and, ahem, pooping, on Dion's shoulder. Outrage ensued and most elements of the site were quickly taken down.

Grieving father's remarks questioned

Jim Davis, the father of a soldier who was killed in Afghanistan, was interviewed on Canada AM during the election. He offered some criticism of the mission, and Harper's announcement of a firm 2011 exit date.

Ryan Sparrow, a Conservative Party spokesperson, quickly made calls to media to point out that Davis is a Liberal supporter, suggesting his heartbreaking claim that his son's death would be in vain if the mission were abandoned, was politically motivated.

Again, outrage ensued, and the Tories suffered another black eye.

Questionable listeria jokes

In one more election kerfuffle, Conservative Agriculture Minister Gerry Ritz made off-colour jokes about the listeria outbreak, while on a conference call.

The comments were released weeks later, at the height of the campaign, by someone who was in on the call.

In his remarks, Ritz called the deadly Maple Leaf Foods outbreak "The death of a thousand cuts, or should I say cold cuts." And when told there had been another death in P.E.I., he said "please tell me it's (Liberal agriculture critic) Wayne Easter."

The story gripped headlines and the Tories squirrelled Ritz away to a safe-house, avoiding the media until the storm had died down.

"I thought that was serious enough," Oliver said. "It should have cost him his job but Harper decided he was going to ride it out and he did."

Maxime Bernier falls from foreign affairs post over NATO documents and relationship with Julie Couillard

Ahh Maxime. What happened? Things were going so well for you, with your quick rise to a high-profile cabinet post.

Romantically, too, things seemed good, when you showed up at the cabinet swearing-in ceremony with that beautiful brunette on your arm, wearing that infamously revealing dress.

But easy come, easy go. And it went -- fast, starting with news that Couillard had links to Quebec bikers and eventually, with allegations Bernier had left top secret NATO documents at her house.

Bernier quickly resigned from his post and was relegated to the back benches where he has maintained a low profile ever since.

While it was certainly one of the more sexy scandals Canada has had in recent years, it also had political impact, Oliver said, hurting the reputation of the Foreign Affairs department and calling Harper's judgment into question.

"(Bernier) was so irresponsible it staggered diplomats and it shook their confidence in whether they could trust Canadians with important secrets," Oliver said.

"Furthermore the prime minister dismissed it as private business and we were all busybodies for caring about it, which showed tremendous misjudgment."

Obama campaign's NAFTA musings

During the U.S. primaries, the Barack Obama camp mused about renegotiating NAFTA, a move that could have serious repercussions for the Canadian economy, which relies heavily on cross-border trade.

The story probably would have ended there, but Harper's then-chief of staff Ian Brodie was accused of being involved with leaking a memo which claimed that a senior adviser to Obama reassured Canadian diplomats that the presidential candidate wasn't serious about renegotiating the NAFTA trade deal.

Observers said the leak harmed the campaign of U.S. presidential candidate Barack Obama, who eventually lost to Hillary Clinton in the Ohio and Texas primaries.

Not long afterwards, Brodie stepped down from the role.

Schreiber, Mulroney square off before Commons committee

A battle between Karlheinz Schreiber, a German-born arms dealer, and former prime minister Brian Mulroney gripped headlines for weeks.

In his rambling, colourful testimony before a Commons committee, Schreiber accused Mulroney of accepting cash from him in exchange for lobbying on his behalf for government contracts.

Schreiber, who was fighting extradition to his homeland where warrants were outstanding for his arrest, accused Mulroney of lying and offering "smoke and mirrors" testimony about their dealings.

Earlier, Mulroney admitted he took money from Schreiber, calling it a "colossal mistake."

"I think it was a pathetic wreck, the whole business," Oliver said bluntly. "Schreiber would say anything and was desperate not to be returned to Germany where he would be put on trial for fraud, and it ruined Brian Mulroney's reputation for all time ... it was a tawdry business, the whole thing."

Cadman accusations

In one of the weirdest stories of the year, the widow of deceased independent MP Chuck Cadman went public with allegations that her husband had been offered a lucrative life insurance policy in 2005, if he were to support the Conservatives.

Cadman, who had cancer and died two months later, allegedly told his wife and daughter he had been offered a $1 million policy that would take care of them after he passed away.

He rejected the offer, she said, and eventually sided with the Liberals in a tight vote that the government barely survived at the time.

Then a tape emerged in which Harper is heard saying he was aware Conservatives had discussed "financial considerations" with Cadman as they tried to coax him into voting against the Liberals during a confidence vote.

The Tories had the tape analyzed by experts who claimed it had been doctored.

Making the story even stranger, Dona Cadman was preparing to run as a Conservative candidate in her husband's riding, when the story broke.

Comments are now closed for this story

John
said

"Puffingate"? Please. That is not even news.


Baz
said

It can be easy to forget these incidents when they happen, then all move on. But, when these disturbing events are laid out here, point by point, I find the whole picture of Mr. Harper and his Conservatives shocking. Why on earth do we Canadians keep this Party as our Government??? This is so similar to the Bush Administration. It frightens me.


Cory - Toronto
said

The puffins are a top news story? How so very sad.

The biggest story, is how Dion lost more support than any other leader in Liberal history. The puffins will be long forgotten, but Dion will go down in history as the biggest Liberal LOSER ever. And we all know there are many of them.


Brantford Boy
said

Well, here's to another year of Professionalism on Parliament Hill and in the Meadia!


Mutt from Windsor
said

It appears from the summary that 2008 was the year that the Opposition did everything possible to disparage the government, rather than take a supportive role for the benefit of all Canadians. Most of the "scandals" were initiated by the Opposition, fueled by a predominately anti-Harper media. Depite all attempts by the Opposition and the Media, the Canadian people saw thru the rhetoric and gave Harper a strengthened mandate, despite all of his gaffs and poor advice from his inner circle. The bottom line is that the Canadian people want a cool headed, slow, methodical and sober approach to governance. I hope that the storm of the economy will cause everyone to tone it down a notch and work together for the benefit of all Canadians. Nobody saw this coming, this world-wide tsunami of economic woe. However, the economic policies of Harper have put us in a better position to weather this storm than most countries in the world. Enough of partisan bickering and phony scandal, enough of selfish buffoonery, get out there and do your job, not for yourselves, but for all Canadians. Best wishes for the greatest nation on earth in 2009.


woods
said

And the latest, Dreidelgate, seems like more of the same from the Harper Conservatives.

Also don't forget the talking oil blob and tax-on-everything that will scr*w everyone, which now many Republicans are pushing as being the sounder, more fiscal conservative choice compared to cap and trade. Who would have guessed.


Earl Robert
said

If it's not news worthy don't worry about it,the news media will make a story out of it. Puffingate? we haven't heard the last of that one. Will "Mediagate" be far behind?


Ron
said

As usual - its all about negative attacks and insults on Conservatives -- not a single comment on the Liberals performance or conduct or problems - try being the least bit fair. The Liberal party's abuse of power in the House by putting their partisan attacks and witch hunts above the real Parliamntary work was dispicable. Dion's performance was the worst performance ever by a leader of a party yet not a mention. Liberals were willing to inflict that man on Canada as PM yet one day later he wasn't even good enough to be Leader of their party - I don't have a problem pointing out Conservative mistakes but an article that does nothing by attack Conservatives primarily based on Liberal accusastions is unfair and so typical of Canadian journalism - grow up and do your jobs.

woods
said

When the Liberals are in power, scandals and criticisms focus on the Liberals. When the Conservatives are in power, scandals and criticisms focus on the Conservatives. The party in power is actually in a position to do things. One should expect more from the people that are running the country and spending our money.

So people should quite whining about the Conservatives being criticized.


CC
said

We are talking about headlines, woods. The Liberals have made the "headlines" just as much. Not about criticizing at this moment, woods. Iggy geting annoited is kind of a big headline. The Liberals kinda skipped the Democratic process and proclaimed a saviour. In my books, that is the worst. Who needs democracy, right Iggy???


Jason.
said

Still, I would love to see Julie Couillard in that famous dress one more time in 2008!!!


woods
said

CC, I just can't understand why so many Conservatives get worked up about Ignatieff being appointed the interim leader. He was appointed in accordance with the rules of the Liberal Party constitution. Both Rae and LeBlanc voluntarily stepped aside and Rae was the one to nominate Ignatieff for interim leader. Polls show that this doesn't bother most Liberals, but that Conservatives are really bothered by it. Well, if Liberals were polled on whether the CPC should dump Harper, the answer would be a resounding YES. So what?


Bridget
said

So many of these items reveal the true nature of the current manifestation of the Conservative Party of Canada - a mean spirited, ethically challenged and immature group of fierce partisans governing for their own good and not for the good of our nation.


CC
said

I have voted Liberal and Conservative. I, as a Canadian, not a Conservative worry of this. There is usually a non biased person in the interim, so that a leader can be voted on a a convention. Putting Iggy in there shows that there will not even be a choice for Liberals , come April or May.
All people should worry when democracy gets eroded..in any form!


woods
said

Okay, CC, I understand that is your view. I don't feel similarly because I take Rae and LeBlanc stepping aside and endorsing Ignatieff as their right and their choice. I am also influenced by the fact that leadership choices have been swayed by lots of backroom dealing. Rumours still swirl about past Conservative and Liberal leadership elections, where lots of money was involved (under old rules). Harper has always refused to reveal the names of his largest leadership donors (as is his right, because he came under old rules.) In fact, the Liberals are the only ones to have ever chosen a leader under the new, more transparent rules.


David H
said

My wish for Canadians in 2009 is that we get the Parliament we pay for and not the Parliament we're afflicted with.


Gail (Hamilton)
said

Baz, we keep Mr. Harper and the Conservatives because they're less likely to break the bank. When government spends money, it's our money and, we also need to understand government never grows an economy, private industry does. Government needs to create an industry friendly environment to encourage more business and more jobs. I'm tired of party hacks creating problems and diversion tactics to promote political partisanship and want to see every politician putting Canada first and foremost so we all benefit.


Cynthia J
said

I do not believe for one minute that LeBlanc and especially Rae stepped aside for Count Iggy of their own volition. The Liberal "old boys club" is at work again and simply dismissed the rank and file of the party as unnecessary. There will be no choice at the convention in May and the Count will become Czar with a rubber stamp. No Democracy Here!


CC
said

yes woods...but the thing is. It is the choice of the tens of thousands of members. Not the two of them. If that was the case, there would have been other people enter the race. Democracy, woods. Democracy. The Liberals at this time have proven they will bend, break, give up on almost anything they believe in...for power. That's the bottom line. They've showed it. And that is why , at this time in our history...the Conservatives will continue to govern.


Red X
said

The puffin was free advertising for the Cons... with the endless play and the image of Dion. Many missteps by Harper will lead to his future defeat. He should accept his fate instead of the American style attacks. Brodie's comments about Obama and NAFTA lead to his removal. Hopefully Barack will remember what the Cons did to prolong his primary race...


Dixie from Alberta
said

OK....can we now forget about the misadventures of all the politicians, forget about 2008 and get on with governing the country out of the financial mess the world is in. Forget about trying to take power in a coup, forget about 'ABC' (it didn't work), forget about the 'green shift', forget about 'the dress', forget about having your feeling hurt because the PM wants to cut expenditures...trust me its not personal Quebec..get over yourselves, can we forget about the sins of the long forgotten past...live in the now not the past, can we be civil to one another, be polite, have respect for yourself and one another, allow that driver to merge instead of trying to block his entrance onto the freeway, can we hold the door open for another person..old or young, can we just try to get along, get to know your neighbours, can we live within our means and not mortgage the country's future (are you listening Jack Layton)....profit is not a bad word. Can we just feel blessed we live in a peaceful country with freedom of speech, religion, to work, go to school, live where we want & free to prosper. Canada still is the best country in the world but each and every one of us who hold citizenship must work hard each and every day to hold onto that.

Happy new year Canada from coast to coast to coast.


Mark from Brampton
said

- Liberals stole millions of dollars from the Canadian Taxpayers.
- Conservatives aides posted a picture of a puffin pooping on Dion

- Liberals claimed the gun registry would cost a few million, and the costs are now over 1 billion dollars
- A Conservative MP made an off-colour joke while on a conference call making light of the listeria outbreak

- The head of Human Resources lost (unaccounted for) 1 billion dollars
- A conservative MP left classified material at his girlfriend's house

Anyone who equates these 'scandals' is crazy.


Thomas J. Martin - Ottawa
said

Let's review:
Stephen Harper, while in opposition, demanded that our banks be deregulated so they could be in the same league as their U.S. counterparts, which thankfully did not come to pass.
Stehpen Harper promised not to tax income trusts. Broke that promise.
Stephen Harper promised fixed election dates. Broken promise once again.
Stephen Harper promised an elected senate. Broken promise.
Stephen Harper promised to work with the other parties yet handed out pamphlets on how to stall and disrupt parliamentry committee processes.
Stephen Harper promised no deficit. Broken promise.
Stephen Harper's track record speaks for itself.


Chad from London
said

I guess only the ruling party made blunders eh? What about Dion's infamous "If you were Prime Minister today what would you do?" interview, or Jack Layton and his need to dismiss a bunch of candidates because of their involvement in the "MaryJane" party..Or Elizabeth May and her "all Canadians are stupid" comment...Let's spread the wealth a bit please...Happy New Year to everyone...


LET'S GET ON WITH THE ECONOMY!!!!! PLEASE
said

I too, have voted Liberal and Conservative, but never again will my family, friends and myself vote Liberal as long as the Coalition exists. Liberals should be ashamed of this. Iggy should get on with looking after us, the voters who put them in power. We never voted for the Coalition, this was just a power trip which Taliban Jack created and Iggy went along with it, he too is on a power trip! He has done nothing yet for us Canadians. Harper out does him as far as experience and an Economist, which he Masters in. Iggy being out of our Country for 30 years, tells me he lacks experience at the present, therefore he can not even be compared to Harper's experience. Harper has done a good job considering all of the Opposition ganging up on him just to gain power to spend our Taxpayer's dollars recklessly. At this point I don't want any of them looking after my Tax Dollar.
For now I say Iggy get rid of the Coalition and he and Harper get on with the Economy which Canadians want. NDP are known for supporting unions, this being the problem with the Automotive crisis, Union and Poor Management. Due to this why should our tax dollar be used to bail them out. The Union and Management should dig into their pockets to straightened this mess out, that they caused. Private Jets, etc., etc., in the time of our Global crisis. They all lived high in the past now they should pay and look after the workers and our Country, which still stands the best in the world, Thanks to Harper.


Trent
said

It's good to see CTV is fair in judegment...Lets what the liberails have done before this....As far as i'm concerend there has been no proof on somethings. The thing that pissed me off the most was Bernier case most people beleaived a women with questionables ties??? Why did she wait to bring this all up??? I wiulod say to get even.... thanks again to CTV for being fair ....


James - Winnipeg
said

These are some pretty lopsided headlines CTV. You’re not mad at the Tories for taking one of your finest are you? Let me add a few top headlines of 2008 to your list, you know, just to balance it out:

1) Liberal party falls into complete disarray and nearing bankruptcy.

2) Liberals steal millions from EI fund.

3) Liberals and NDP sell their souls to the bloc.

4) Liberals skip democratic process in favor of import leader.

... and this is only the tip of the iceberg.



James - Winnipeg
said

Well said Dixie from Alberta!

Cheers to a happy and safe New Year for every Canadian!


Wayne in Halifax
said

The big story I believe is the absolute hypocrisy of Harper and the Conservatives. They cannot even put forward a decent arguement without distorting the facts. They downplay their own screw ups and illegal behaviour and instead focus on others "supposed" misdeeds that they deem as so wrong. The country will see that respect and moderation can succeed in this vicious politic culture when Obama turns things around (hopefully) in the US. Then the tide will change and there will no longer be room for narrow minded Conservatives, only Progressives ones.


jay
said

The puffin was the most over rated story of all time! People who were outraged by this really need to examine their lives!


Andrea
said

Hopefully 2009 , will bring a year for change for governing our country. Make it count!


Al From Winnipeg
said

Canadian political stories are 100% fluff and of little substance. How about trying to raise the bar in the coming year by challenging our intellect and ability to focus.


WpgGal
said

Mark from Brampton:
These are top 2008 stories...I think all of the Liberal things you posted happened before 2008.

No matter what party is leading our country we are going to have pros and cons (no pun intended).

I personally think that the political story of the year is how Harper lost his majority government (thank goodness) because of political blunders!!


Craig Vokey
said

LOL Puffingate? Good to see that it is not only the politicians who are asleep at the wheel. As one already mentioned, here is to another year of professionalism in politics and journalism.
Craig
Sudbury ON


Mary Clarke
said

If Dona Cadman thought that her husband had mistreated by the Conservative Party,why would she run as a Conservative.
It was the Opposition and the media alone,that once again,tried to create scandal,where none existed.
Sooner or later,everyone will realise,no match could ever be found for the Liberal scandals and misuse of taxpayer money.Corrupt,arrogant,smug and completely self serving.
I'll never vote Liberal again.Their alliance with the Bloc ,to bring down the Govt,without even a vote,was the absolute last straw.
The "Coalition"vote,was never offered to any Cdn. to vote on.


Joyce
said

The story which broke only this year is the fact that the Liberals did run the EI fund for years without Parliaments approval, which should have been a top story. This was a Budgetary measure and they ran it as if they owned it.
Well seems to me there is something which fell through the cracks of the Columnists.
Also the sitting on hands of the lIBERALS, for the last Parliament, but with a smidgen of people to back to Conservatives was also a top story, but alas we see they got the fly by from the columnists again.
The Coalition Government was only enacted, because Layton had it all sewn up even before the Budgetary update, and Dion, eventhough he did loose big in the last election his desire to be PM was what he truly wanted and would get with the Coalition.
I would say it was more greed on the Opposition side to be in Government with the backing of the Bloc and their Veto on things, as the other two did not even have the full majority and had to rely on the Bloc, whom the Rest of Canada do not vote for, ruling the Coalition Government.



Ryan
said

Seriously Mutt? You didn't notice that when Harper was head of the opposition he brought the Martin government down with a scandal that Martin had nothing to do with? How is it that when a Conservative makes a crass and uncalled for joke demeaning the deaths of the listeria outbreak victims, has a childish website put together make fun of an opponent that it is somehow the opposition who are responsible for the public outrage?

How can you hope "that the storm of the economy will cause everyone to tone it down a notch and work together for the benefit of all Canadians." while simultaneously attributing all of the ill-will against the Conservatives to a conspiracy of opposition and media? "Nobody saw this coming"??? I knew about it in 2006 along with anyone else who paying the slightest bit of attention. Even as the world was calling emergency meetings and foregoing partisanship Harper continued to deny it was happening as proven by he and Flaherty's economic update.

If Canadians truly want the government to work together for the greater good then isn't the coalition the singular greatest representation of that will?


jo from albera
said

BAZ, do you think we would be any more impressed if the liberal media chose to outline all the liberal and NDP misteps during the year. open your eyes


mike
said

puffingate?

LOL

That constitutes "Top political headlines of '08" at CTV?

are they trying to out-wanker CBFC?


bettie
said

One of the most incidious events of 2008 was Jack Layton describing to his obviously appreciative caucus how he and the Bloc were planning their 'coup'. Honestly, you didn't find that significant?



Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz