CTV News | Top 10 best-selling cars: Cheaper in Canada or U.S.?

Top 10 best-selling cars: Cheaper in Canada or U.S.?

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV Toronto: Pat Foran on Canadian car deals

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(8)

Jeremy Cato, Autos.CTV.ca

Date: Fri. Nov. 28 2008 8:35 AM ET

What a difference a year makes.

Last year at this time, the loonie was flying high against the American greenback. That was good for anyone travelling to the U.S., but it also had many Canadians bemoaning new car pricing in Canada.

They complained of price gouging and demanded that auto makers lower their prices to match U.S. pricing on a strict exchange basis - one Canadian dollar for one U.S. dollar.

When that didn't happen right away, frustrated buyers by the tens of thousands went south in search of bargains. In fact, more than 160,000 Canadians imported a car from the U.S. last year.

Canadian manufacturers, though reluctant to cut prices quickly to match currency fluctuations, finally did react. They had to. The pressure was tremendous.

Hammered by bad publicity and seeing so many consumers import vehicles from the United States, auto manufacturers either lowered new car prices or slapped on generous incentives designed to level the pricing playing field between Canada and the U.S.

But since peaking at about $1.10 to the U.S. greenback, the loonie has swooned; it is now trading at about $.81 US. That's a 26 per cent drop in one year.

New car prices have not gone up 26 per cent in Canada, but many analysts are predicting price increases very soon. Among other things, the threat of cross-border shopping no longer exists as a force, as a counterweight, in pricing. According to the Consumers Association of Canada, cross-border shopping has come to a screeching halt.

"We've already seen a sharp decrease in Canadians shopping for new car bargains in the U.S.", adds Paul Timoteo, president of the online pricing service www.carcostcanada.com. "Last year at this time, we were flooded with inquiries from Canadians looking for U.S. new car bargains. Not anymore."

Timoteo and others suggest that if the current trend continues, prices for new vehicles in Canada will surely rise to keep pace with the latest currency swings. The price changes may not happen overnight, but they will happen if the loonie remains in the low-$.80 range, he insists.

"Canadian new car buyers should be worried," says Timoteo, adding that "if new car prices went down when the Canadian dollar went up, with the Canadian dollar now down significantly, new car prices have nowhere to go but up. It's just a matter of time."

To illustrate, Timoteo points to a 2009 Toyota Camry LE. At $22,370 in the U.S. (including freight), it is no longer a bargain for Canadians heading south to shop. The opposite is true, in fact.

Canadians shopping for a Camry in the U.S. are facing a price premium when the exchange rate is factored in. That is, with the loonie trading at $.80, that US$22,370 Camry has a U.S. equivalent price of $27,962. In Canada, the same car lists for $24,870.

In other words, the Canadian Camry costs $3,000 less than the U.S. version on a currency exchange basis. That surely cannot last.

Remember, when the loonie was strong, Toyota Canada reduced the price of the Camry from $27,370 for the 2008 model to today's 2009 price of $24,870. What goes down can and will surely go up again.

At Autos.CTV.ca we wanted to find out just how the slumping loonie has affected new car pricing on a currency exchange basis. So using the latest top 10 list of best-selling cars in Canada, we compared Canadian and U.S. pricing.

For U.S. pricing we used the respected www.edmonds.com website for vehicles listed in the Buffalo area just south of Toronto. We included freight charges. For Canadian pricing, we used figures from www.carcostcanada.com, as well as figures from the manufacturers themselves and other sources. Again, we included freight charges.

In each instance, we attempted to include the equivalent features for both the Canadian and U.S. vehicles. This is difficult and feature content does vary between U.S. and Canadian models, but we did our best.

The analysis may not be perfect; there may be some minor differences between Canadian and U.S. models. But the overall conclusion is very clear: With the loonie trading at $.81, cars in Canada are selling at relatively bargain prices.

Perhaps that's why new car sales in Canada are actually up 1.4 per cent on the year.

CANADA'S TOP 10 BEST-SELLING CAR - LOONIE VERSUS GREENBACK

1. 2009 Toyota Corolla LE (four-door compact sedan) with equivalent option content.

Corolla

US MSPR (manufacturer's suggested retail price): $18,604.00

Exchange rate premium (with loonie at $.81 US): $4,377.85

Canadian dollar price equivalent: $22,981.85

Canadian MSRP: $21,540.00

Canadian pricing advantage: $1,441.85

(Note: No available Canadian and U.S. incentives)

2. 2009 Honda Civic DX-A (four-door compact sedan) with equivalent option content.

Civic sedan

US MSPR (manufacturer's suggested retail price): $17,625.00

Exchange rate premium (with loonie at $.81 US): $4,406.25

Canadian dollar price equivalent: $22,031.25

Canadian MSRP: $20,900.00

Canadian pricing advantage: $1,131.25

3. 2009 Mazda3 GX (four-door compact sedan) with air conditioning and other equivalent options.

Mazda3

US MSPR (manufacturer's suggested retail price): $17,140.00

Exchange rate premium (with loonie at $.81 US): $4,285.00

Canadian dollar price equivalent: $21,425.00

Canadian MSRP: $18,390.00

Canadian pricing advantage: $3,035.00

4. 2009 Chevrolet Cobalt LT (four-door compact sedan) with equivalent options.

Cobalt

US MSPR (manufacturer's suggested retail price): $17,705.00

Exchange rate premium (with loonie at $.81 US): $4,163.53

Canadian dollar price equivalent: $21,868.53

Canadian MSRP: $19,420.00

Canadian pricing advantage: $2,448.53

5. 2009 Toyota Yaris (base model, four-door subcompact sedan) with equivalent options.

Yaris

US MSPR (manufacturer's suggested retail price): $13,895.00

Exchange rate premium (with loonie at $.81 US): $3,273.17

Canadian dollar price equivalent: $17,168.17

Canadian MSRP: $15,165.00

Canadian pricing advantage: $2,003.17

6. 2009 Toyota Matrix XR (four-door compact hatchback) with equivalent options.

Matrix

US MSPR (manufacturer's suggested retail price): $18,865.00

Exchange rate premium (with loonie at $.81 US): $4,434.92

Canadian dollar price equivalent: $23,299.92

Canadian MSRP: $20,720.00

Canadian pricing advantage: $2,579.92

7. 2009 Hyundai Accent GLS (four-door subcompact sedan) with equivalent options.

Accent

US MSPR (manufacturer's suggested retail price): $14,990.00

Exchange rate premium (with loonie at $.81 US): $3,546.76

Canadian dollar price equivalent: $18,536.76

Canadian MSRP: $17,090.00

Canadian pricing advantage: $1,446.76

8. 2009 Pontiac G5 (base two-door compact coupe) with equivalent options.

G5

US MSPR (manufacturer's suggested retail price): $16,335.00

Exchange rate premium (with loonie at $.81 US): $3,869.87

Canadian dollar price equivalent: $20,204.87

Canadian MSRP: $16,970.00

Canadian pricing advantage: $3,234.87

9. 2009 Volkswagen Jetta S (US)/Comfortline (Canada) (four-door compact sedan) with

2009 Volkswagen Jetta S

equivalent options.

US MSPR (manufacturer's suggested retail price): $17,640.00

Exchange rate premium (with loonie at $.81 US): $4,164.21

Canadian dollar price equivalent: $21,804.21

Canadian MSRP: $23,310.00

Canadian pricing advantage: -$1,505.79

10. 2009 Ford Focus SE (four-door compact sedan) with equivalent options.

Ford Focus

US MSPR (manufacturer's suggested retail price): $16,875.00

Exchange rate premium (with loonie at $.81 US): $3,987.38

Canadian dollar price equivalent: $20,862.38

Canadian MSRP: $17,699.00

Canadian pricing advantage: $3,163.38

Comments are now closed for this story

J. C.
said
0 0

Personally I think cars have been overpriced in the past and all auto manufacturers should keep the prices as low as possible if they want to have more sales.


Wes
said
0 0

Stick to Japanese and German cars and you will have way better reliabilty then North American cars. Because when you are going to sell your car someday, if it is Japanese or German car, you will have better deal and more for your money.


Pat_from_Mississauga
said
0 0

These Canadian pricing "advantage" are just co-incidental to the fact that the Canadian dollar has plummeted in value over the last few months. One year ago, there was a huge Canadian price "disadvantage".


bergy
said
0 0

With all the jobs cut because of issues with GM and other car companies, i don't think they should increase the price of the cars soon because we just won't buy any. they will be too expensive. And with the market so low presently, who wants to spend thousands of dollars on a car when you need it to feed your kids.


R. J.
said
0 0

I doubt many dealers would dare raise prices when people (myself included) have put off purchasing a new vehicle while the Canadian and American economies are shaking at it's foundations.


Matt Brulotte
said
0 0

Biased study. They should've taken a look at the best selling car in each class. Once you breach the $30,000 plateau we start getting royally hosed. Case in point the 54,000USD Audi RS4 that is 96,000 in Canada.


duck
said
0 0

take out the $2000 pension cost for CAW people and then we have a more realistically priced auto.


Vito Pirri
said
0 0

I absolutely, positively, love my 2007 Pontiac G5 SE. I downsized from a 2003 Buick Rendezvous which cost twice as much. My half-cost G5 SE came with all the same equipment as the Rendezvous, save for a sun roof, power driver seat and steering wheel audio/radio controls. The build quality it excellent. I get many, many compliments from passengers on it's comfort, interior design and quality.


Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

Autos.CTV.ca

Autos site

Latest news and columns

Get the latest news, insights and info from the auto industry.

Michael Vaughan

To the Arctic!

Michael Vaughan travels to the Arctic... in a smart car.

Ford

Mighty Ford

Ford's Neat Trick: Turnaround year in a difficult time.

Recall

Recall FAQ

My car has been recalled! Should I be worried?

Luxury hybrids

Green Driving

Save the planet with new options for driving.

World's Most Expensive Cars

World's Most Expensive

Check out the six-figure price tags on these street-legal, ultra-luxe cars.

In Pictures

Models pose next to a China's Chery QQ car at the Shanghai International Auto Show on its opening day, Monday, April 20, 2009 in Shanghai, China. (AP Photo / Eugene Hoshiko)

Foreign and fabulous

Ten cool cars that are popular with drivers outside of North America.

The new 2010 Lamborghini Murcielago LP 670-4 SuperVeloce leaves Santa Monica Beach on the way to an inaugural opening ceremony in Santa Monica, Calif. It's a two-door, two-seat supercar. (AP Photo/Damian Dovarganes

Fantasy Wheels

Check out these new luxury and concept cars.

Related Websites

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz