Canada -
News Sections
Fundraiser canned on claims disease affects only whites
Font-size:
Share
Print
Comments(58)
CTV.ca News Staff
Date: Tue. Nov. 25 2008 5:50 PM ET
Carleton University won't be holding a popular fundraiser to benefit cystic fibrosis, it was confirmed Tuesday, after the student council passed a motion falsely claiming the disease affects only white men.
In what journalism councillor Nick Bergamini calls an "incredibly divisive" move, the Council of Carleton University Students Association (CUSA) passed a motion at a meeting late Monday night that effectively cancelled the annual Shinerama fundraising campaign.
Shinerama events occur during the school's orientation week and proceeds go to the Canadian Cystic Fibrosis Foundation (CCFF).
The association raised the motion based on information it received from one of its former executive members that the disease affects only white people and mostly males, Bergamini told CTV.ca.
"I don't believe that you should be playing politics with a charity," Bergamini said during a phone interview from Ottawa. "It's the most un-political thing. It's something that's supposed to bring people together and now they've done something that's incredibly divisive."
It is correct to say that cystic fibrosis "does affect Caucasian populations primarily," according to Cathleen Morrison, CEO of the CCFF.
However, the term Caucasian includes people from South Asia, North Africa, the Persian Gulf and Israel, Morrison said.
"These are Caucasian populations," Morrison told CTV.ca. "These people do not have white skin. They have CF, it now seems, in the same ratios as other Caucasian people who do have white skin."
Cystic fibrosis, which is the most common genetic fatal disease in young people in Canada, affects just as many young girls as boys, Morrison added.
It is a chronic disease that primarily affects the lungs and digestive system. Only about half of patients live into their thirties and beyond.
According to Bergamini, the motion read that orientation week strives to be inclusive and volunteers should feel like their fundraising efforts are serving a diverse community.
However, the motion went on to say that "and whereas cystic fibrosis has been recently revealed to only affect white people and primarily men, be it resolved that: CUSA discontinue its support of this campaign."
CUSA president Brittany Smyth said the idea of changing next year's orientation fundraiser to focus on a different charity, perhaps a local cause, first came up about a year ago.
She said that the part of the motion that refers to why Shinerama has been cancelled is irrelevant, not part of the official meeting record and simply reflects the rationale of the councillor who raised the motion.
"It completely depends on the individual," Smyth told CTV.ca. "It's 100 per cent their opinion. Their opinion doesn't have to be fact or anything really. It's just how this individual felt."
Only the resolution is important, Smyth said, even though it appears councillors are endorsing the idea that support of cystic fibrosis be stopped because it is a white-man's disease.
"Speaking from the council perspective, the whereas motions weren't actually overly relevant when people were making a decision on what they wanted to do," Smyth said.
She also pointed out that the whereas clauses cannot be amended, and said if a resolution to drop Shinerama had been rejected, the issue could not have been raised again.
Calls to the Carleton University spokespeople have not been returned.
Shinerama began in 1964, and events are held at nearly 60 Canadian university and college campuses. Students shine shoes, wash cars and hold other fundraising events as part of the campaign. The program has raised nearly $19 million for the CCFF.
Carleton students have participated in Shinerama for 24 years and have raised nearly $1 million for the cause.
Morrison said the CCFF has valued past contributions from Carleton students and hopes to speak with members of the association about their decision.
"We're hoping that when the facts are before them that they will feel more comfortable," Morrison said.
Bergamini said he will try to raise a motion to reverse the decision at the CUSA's next meeting. However, the council is the highest decision-making body and is the primary organizer of orientation week events and so he, and even the university, have little recourse, he said.
"So unfortunately this appears to be a final decision."
User Tools
CTV Video Player
Mike Duffy Live
Tuesday, Nov. 25: A member of Carleton University's student council disputes the reported cause of the cancellation.
User Tools
About the tools
Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.
-


Font-size
Print Article
Comments(58)-
Feedback
Share it with your network of friends
Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.
Most Viewed News Stories
Most Talked about Stories
I applaud the budget, even though Health Care and education may stay unscathed. Sadly this cannot last and I worry to later this year where cuts will become enviable. If anything, this provides the Wildrose Alliance plenty of ammo when an election is called.


Comments are now closed for this story
J.C.
said
I find their decision rather discriminatory!! What's next? We don't worry about a disease like sickel cell anemia because it only mostly affects blacks!!!
Ridiculous!!
Lon
said
Matt
said
Janet
said
Just another white dude
said
Saying that a charity isn't worth supporting based on the claim that cystic fibrosis is a white mans disease isn't far off saying that it doesn't matter if a white man dies since there will always be another to take his place.
How heartless! If I was a student at Carleton University I would be ashamed of the actions of my student association.
Been There
said
I hope this does get overturned as it a very worthy cause, even though it seems that it is unlikely to happen.
John Doe
said
Biochemist in BC
said
Josh B, Ottawa
said
JC in Ottawa
said
I wonder which charity they will replace it with (Beer Drinking Rallies).
K D
said
Lee in Calgary
said
I'm sure your parents are very proud and happy with the education you're receiving.
Linda
said
White men certainly did have it far too good for far too long, but efforts to "balance the books" can NOT include reverse discrimination and bigotry.
Westner
said
Tim
said
Polly
said
What kind of no mind comes up with this stuff?
So 'Juvenile Diabetes' shouldn't be supported because ONLY kids suffer from it? (A misconception that only children suffer from it by the way) OR Breast Cancer because mostly women are afflicted (men have been diagnosed but it's rare) and conversely, prostate cancer sufferers are only men so they don't warrant the money required for research?????
Our society needs to stop being so hyper-sensitive to every darn thing - we are all different on the outside but we all bleed the same...internally we are designed relatively alike...
It's days like this I'm not convinced 'humans' are the superior/most intelligent creatures on the species list.
*sigh*
Ross Wilkie
said
CF needs all the help they can get. It seems strange a minority of students at one universiy is correct and all other students attending university are wrong supporting CF.
Radicals seem to rule even if they are ignorant of what they are talking about
Kevin
said
nc
said
It is sad to see that even illnesses have a colour of skin. I guess we have not learned much, since the famous speech of Martin Luther King. "... I have a dream that one day people will be judged by their character and not by the colour of their skin."
Dale Wilson - Edmonton
said
Laurier Student
said
When politics and racial issues interrupt people trying to donate to a cause, there is a major problem. A University located in the Capital of our country should be ashamed at this decision.
Randy from Ontario
said
This is crap. Can you imagine if a charity geared to help black men (sickle cell) was cancelled? Why are white men always getting the short end of the equality stick.
Steve - Montreal
said
J.B., Toronto
said
Toby
said
Mike in ON
said
However, the motion went on to say that "and whereas cystic fibrosis has been recently revealed to only affect white people and primarily men, be it resolved that: CUSA discontinue its support of this campaign."
So, CUSA strives to be inclusive - unless, of course, you're a caucasian male. I guess some animals ARE more equal than others, Mr. Orwell.
As other posters have already mentioned, not only is CUSA's position discriminatory, it is also ill-founded. Sounds to me like an organization that's about to lose its funding.
Lee In Ottawa
said
I wish that I could say that I am surprized by their actions but it is reflective of political correctness run amuck. I am deeply disappointed by this decision as it points to a lack of understanding on the parts of the students who sit on the coucil. I find their decision disrespectful and they should be ashamed of their thoughtless course of action.
For shame.
Rod
said
Kalyn
said
Mike in Ottawa
said
K Brown
said
Charities help those in need, free from prejudice. Don't open a pandora's box.
Frank
said
For years Carleton has been working to improve its image as a viable academic institution. With this decision, it has taken 5 steps back.
Biolgoist in Prince George, B.C.
said
Suzie
said
Ben
said
Acroyear
said
Is it too late to move to England?
This is so utter ridiculous that I'm left without words that I can use in a G-rated public forum.
Shame on every member of the CUSA who passed this.
And I say the remaining students of Carleton should get together and do their own fund raiser for CF and thumb their noses at their so called leadership.
Unbelievable!
Marsha
said
Angela in Ottawa
said
James
said
Chanel
said
woman with CF
said
Doug
said
Carl Kazmierczak
said
It makes me ashamed of my alma mater.
Cal in Ottawa
said
For Ms Smyth to say that the wording didn't matter is a convenient excuse, but one that does not hold up to scrutiny. On a radio interview she said it was a student of Haitian background that instigated this. Now, if there was a motion proposed that had racist implications against a visible minority, does anyone think that the wording would not matter? Give us some credit Ms Smyth. You push political correctness much too far.
At least there was one member who had some integrity and voted against the resolution.
I hope the students of this fine university will send Ms Smyth and her ilk a very loud and clear message.
Colin M
said
Enjoy the ride for the next few weeks...
It's going to be bumpy.
Nothing like a bold stance against a charity!
Ken
said
dcp
said
Ottawa KMH
said
Given that CUSA has displayed a remarkable capacity for public idiocy, I would like to think that other Carleton students would do their best to voice opposition to this decision before the value of their education is devalued by association.
Ryan P.
said
Ter Ry
said
A little research would have clarified the nature of CF and permitted a balanced discaussion and educated decision. Carleton may not have a Sciences program, but ever hear of the internet?
Jenna from Carleton
said
Get your facts straight before you make a decision CUSA.
Clay in Calgary
said
I am starting to wonder though... this is one of the strangest, most ridiculous things I have seen come from a university student government. Which says a lot since university student governments are a guaranteed source of the sublime and downright ridiculous.
Johnnie Oil
said
Political correctness is a façade constructed in opposition to reality and sold as “tolerance.” Because of this, its purveyors are given to moral relevance and all who reject it are branded as “intolerant.” When properly implemented, it stifles our ability to think clearly.
We must understand that a major tenet of political correctness is that there is nothing more wrong than the act of pointing out what is wrong. Political correctness is understandably hostile to facts and its followers quite intolerant of anyone who refuses to budge on the fact that absolutes exist; for the rejection of absolutes is a most convenient way to open discussions about "race based deseases" or “the non-existence of God” in university classrooms for example throughout the country.
This is not to insinuate that the problem is only in university classrooms. Political correctness reigns supreme throughout our educational system. “Facts are stubborn things, and whatever may your wishes, your inclinations, or the dictates of your passions, they cannot change the state of facts and evidence.” To this a misguided, politically correct university student board can make such a ridiculas statement and stop such a worthy cause based on intolerance thought.
This is the power of political correctness in the hands of those who know how to use it -- it literally silences opposition. And this brings us to a second point: political correctness is not just a façade sold as tolerance, but a way to heave guilt upon soft consciences, thereby stagnating courage and the free exchange of ideas. Anyone with their eyes halfway open saw this same tactic used again and again through the past election cycle.
Ze
said
Ian K
said
The one thing we Canadians cannot do is to simply let this go by. It could set a precedent we will soon regret.
E L
said
Sarah
said
Are any of you surprised by this? The same rot goes on all across the country. Councils elected with less than 5% of the vote seem to have time to organize for radical stands on every possible issue (paid for with student money) and yet can't ever seem to balance a budget.
Maybe the *real* adults should be running things.
jane
said
cusa and carleton framed the issue incorrectly, race did not need to be brought into this.