CTV News | Expert opinions divided on where meteor crash landed

Canada -   

Expert opinions divided on where meteor crash landed

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News: Mike Ciona with more on the meteor
CTV Calgary: Elissa Carpenter reports on the fireball that lit up the night sky in Western Canada on Thursday.
CTV Newsnet: Paul Delaney, astronomer, York University on what researchers hope to gain from finding the meteor
CTV Newsnet: David Dodge, retired astronomer, on the whereabouts of the meteor
CTV Newsnet: Alan Dyer, astronomer, on what the mysterious object could be
CTV Edmonton: Frank Florian, Telus World of Science on the fireball aftermath
CTV Newsnet: Mark Ciona from CTV Saskatoon describes what he saw in the sky northwest of Saskatoon
Canada AM: Randy Attwood, space educator, on the awesome but not so rare sight
CTV Saskatoon Extended: Eyewitnesses describe the fireball
CTV Edmonton Extended: A security camera at the station catches the meteor approaching
CTV Edmonton: Amateur astronomer captures a flash in the sky using a special camera

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(75)

CTV.ca News Staff

Date: Fri. Nov. 21 2008 9:19 PM ET

Researchers say the fireball that blazed across the Prairie sky Thursday evening was most likely a meteor, but expert's opinions about where - and if - the galactic object hit the Earth are divided.

Hundreds of residents of Alberta, Saskatchewan and Manitoba reported seeing the bright light, which was also captured on security cameras.

The stunning images show the sky light up as a bright point of light blazes into view, then disappears over the horizon.

Paul Delaney, an astronomer from York University, said the object was a meteor that was "cruising through the upper atmosphere, giving us a wonderful lightshow, telling us of course that you should always be outside looking up."

He said the meteor may have disintegrated prior to reaching the ground. But if it is found, it could offer a fascinating look into the history of the solar system.

"It's a wonderful laboratory," he told CTV Newsnet.

"This is a piece of our past. You're talking about an object that potentially is four-and-a-half billion years old, telling us all about the local environment in our solar system as the solar system was forming.

Even more fascinating, he said, is if the meteor turns out to be a piece of another planet, such as Mars.

"Meteors get blasted off the surfaces of old planets in our solar system, terrestrial planets, and they come to Earth," he said.

Randy Atwood, a space educator, told CTV's Canada AM the meteor was probably no bigger than a grapefruit, and may have broken into small pieces before hitting the ground, or it may have burned up entirely before touching down.

He agreed there may not be much of it left, saying it was travelling at incredible speeds when it was spotted.

"There's a very good chance it was what we call a bolide, which is a meteorite crossing the sky at extremely quick velocity -- very, very fast -- and as it hits the atmosphere at about 400,000 feet, travelling at about 60 kilometres per second, this is the incredible light show that it creates," said Atwood.

Still, not all experts agree.

Alan Hildebrand, a planetary scientist from the University of Calgary, said the meteorite likely smashed into the ground near Macklin, Sask., which is about 100 kilometres south of the Alberta border town of Lloydminster.

In fact, Hildebrand is so sure of his hypothesis that he plans to spend his weekend searching for rock remnants around in the area.

"Right now, the important thing is not searching because we don't know which field to search in. It's a big world," Hildebrand told The Canadian Press. "What's important now is finding proximal eyewitnesses, so you know where meteorites might have fallen."

Astronomers and universities across Western Canada have cameras recording activity in the sky, Atwood said. If the meteor was captured by more than one of the cameras, it may be possible over the next couple of days to triangulate exactly where it touched down -- if it did.

CTV's Mike Ciona, a Saskatoon reporter who saw the sky light up on his way home from work, said it appeared to be positioned to the west and north of the city.

"It looked like a lighting bolt, the most intense lighting bolt you've ever seen, and maybe the size of three," Ciona told Canada AM.

Phone lines at CTV began to light up just minutes after the event, with residents seeking more information on what happened.

CTV Saskatoon fielded roughly 60 calls, Ciona said.

"It seemed the most intense areas where it was being reported was in the west-central part of Saskatchewan and the east-central part of Alberta, with the most intense reports coming in from Melfort, Saskatchewan and Lloydminster...and right at Red Pheasant First Nation," Ciona said.

MyNews user Dan Charrois, who lives about 50 kilometres north of Edmonton, said security cameras set up at his home managed to capture some grainy footage showing a big flare in the night sky.

"It happened so fast I don't think anyone would have had the reaction time to get it," he told CTV.ca, adding that his computer software business has written programs that track meteors.

Though Charrois didn't see the fireball himself, he decided to check the security tapes after his friends and neighbours called him to find out where the light may have came from.

"I only had to rewind a couple of minutes and it was there," he said, noting the security time stamped the flash at 5:26 p.m. local time.

"You kind of see a flash, which lasts about two seconds or so," he said.


Comments are now closed for this story

Annette Barthel
said

Saw the ball oof fire 20 km west of Meadow Lake while travelling on highway # 304 west, seemed very close to the south of us , lit up the road like daytime, lasted only seconds!


RVH
said

Very cool indeed. I saw one over my house a few years back. Nothing near like the one out west but it is quite neat to see in person.


Pete
said

It is so exciting to be reminded of our place in space and experience such events to humble our presence here.


gwen barks
said

Gwen Barks "i saw the meteor and a huge flash it seemed very close by melfort saskatchewan"


Casz
said

This is the second time I've seen something like this. It's vary cool.

Imagine the energy released if something this size hit the earth in one piece!


Steve D.
said

I think it landed southwest of Battleford straight out from the shell gas station, it was the coolest thing I had ever seen


Gary
said

I found it, it was melted twisted metal in the shape of a wrench and you could just make out NASA encraved into it. The whole thing was encructed with what looked like a burned up tool bag


DB Schwartz
said

It lit up the sky over the Suffield military base just behind me - like extreme lightning - I looked back and saw a shower of orange sparks. Thought it was a military flare or exercise :)


Tiffany G From Queen City
said

Hi I am from Regina, Saskatchewan. I seen this perfect. It was green and it was huge, it lit up the whole sky!! it lasted about 5 seconds. It WAS THE FREASKIEST THING I EVER SAW IN MY LIFE!!




PrairieDog
said

I was driving on highway 41 NE of Saskatoon when it went by. Truly amazing. Never seen anything like it. It lit up like the sun was just about to set again...and then gone. Glad I was lucky enough to see it. I can tell you, that it looked a lot bigger than a grapefruit, as they say. But I am sure wasn't. Makes a person realize just how small we and this planet are.


Terry Laite
said

Two months ago while transiting the Indian ocean Just before getting to the Gulf Of Aden , My self and the captain were on the bridge when the Night sky lit up enough to illuminate the boat and the bridge like day time, we watched a meteor streak across the sky for about 5 seconds, Three days after it was repeated again with the same results, crossing oceans I often look to the night sky's to watch meters as it is so much darker and we get to see many more stars then at home.


Lorne
said

And just think, this was the size of a grapfruit. Holy crap! No wonder a large meteorite finished the dinos.



RBYUL
said

Gary
That is the funiest thing I've heard in a long time!


Cara B, Halifax
said

Gary - kudos, bud :)


beeman
said

Good one Gary


Carmen Weber
said

My husband was in Fernie BC last night and saw the fire ball fall out of the sky. He said it looked very close, which everyone seems to say, no matter where they saw it from, it must have been very large.



Miguel
said

We were driving to my 12 year old friends birthdayparty, and there was a big flash. then we went to his house for a sleepover, and in the mornning his mom told us it was a metear. We were supprised



JoeC
said

It may have been a Soyuz rocket body reentering Earth's atmosphere a day earlier than expected. The Soyuz rocket launched a Russian Defense Ministry reconnaissance satellite codenamed Kosmos-2445 on Nov. 14th



shane Prpich
said

I was in my car at the time in Saskatoon and saw what I thought was at the time lightning. The sky light up with a couple flashes. I was confused at the time wondering why there was lightning
I was facing south at the time and it looked to me as the flashes were at the south of the city


Todd R.
said

I was travelling home from Lloydminster to North Battleford and the sky lit up for about 3 - 4 seconds. It was night then all of a sudden it was day time, but at least twice as bright! I thought for a brief moment it was a nuclear explosion, it was so bright - just about drove into the ditch as I scanned the area around me looking for a mushroom cloud. Unbelievable! It was incredible!! What an awesome display of power of our universe...


I believe
said

Hmmmmm, and you still believe there is no Aliens? I guess it's time to have open-mind about the Univers that we live in. Where do you think all these informations that people use in Movies came from?


Craig Garrett
said

I was driving west on hiway 12 from Consort Alberta. It was incredible it went from night to daytime like someone turned on a switch never seen anything like it before.


Rose Simpson
said

I saw a fireball when I was a little girl. It scared me senseless. It was never found.


Key
said

The sight last evening was awesome. I was driving home in Saskatoon leaving downtown area and the fireball was stunning. It definitely had Saskatoon alight. I am amazed that it was the size of a grapefruit. Usually my kids are talking in the van but after that they were alot louder.


Jest Dempsey
said

very cool, glad i seen it. for those interested join the facebook group :I survived the Nov.20.2008 Western Canada Meteor strike!


Jennifer
said

I live in Cold Lake and we have a military base. I thought a plane had gone down. Amazine how it lit up the sky. Very cool!!


Tamara Courtney
said

We saw it about 1 hr North East of Melfort Saskatchewan.We thought for a quick second that we were having a retinal detachment..lol.


CC-western Canada
said

I was driving just north of Saskatoon, as well. An incredible thing to see. I was also looking for a mushroom cloud. I didn't think anything but a nuke could cause that degree of light and flash. It went from dark to day and back. If that was the size of a grapefruit, and the four western provinces seen it, I'd hate to see what one the size of a car could do. Glad to be apart of it. Probably won't another of that degree in our lives.


Joe Anglo
said

Isn't there a UFO landing pad in Alberta???

haha I guess it's working!!


Kathy Helms
said

Last night around 5:30 PM, I was driving on the way home on an old highway near Colinton Road. It was so fast when it was happening. At first I thought it was a lighting that was brighten up in the sky. It turned out it was a fireball. It was like a very very hot and huge red surface ball was fallen down to the earth from the sky. It is like 20-30 second that was falling straight down. It was so beautiful. I believed that was a fire ball. It probably have landed somewhere in the Colinton area, but I am not too sure.
It was on the east of Coliton where I spotted the fireball.

It was a very first hand experience to see like this.







Josh
said

Has anyone seen the movie Austin Powers: in goldmember?

This is finally "Midas 22" coming to crash down on the earth and cause a global flood.


chad
said

I believe that my wife and I saw a smaller event. After reviewing all the news and others comments, I believe that it did blow up and what we saw was a chunk falling to the earth. We were driving south towards Kindersley when we saw the the sky light up like day time. To the north of us we saw a medicine ball size fire ball crashing to the earth with a green luminicant glow around it. It was so close we could see chunks of smaller fire balls the size of baseballs falling off it before it burnt out about 40 feet before the ground. After seeing some other footage the one we saw was amazing but not nearly as amazing as what we have seen on the net or TV. We had to see falling debris from the larger meteor.


Casey
said

seen it on the 619 enroute to lloydminster, it looked rather close to our truck about 4-5 miles away, quite a sight to be seen thats forsure.


Shmang
said

Wellsir! Tell you what... I saw one o them thimajiggers when I was about...14....sept the one I saw was more defined. I coulda actually see the flames on the one I saw. Yessir...


Gary, are you sure the aliens didn't probe you?
said

Were they attempting a landing at Vulcan, Alberta?
...

Cor
said

Well - I love you Gary. Your wit made my day. I howled so hard the whole office came running in to see if I was dying!


Winston
said

It must have broken up or hit ground realatively close to Lloydminster, the ground was rumbling for a good thirty seconds soon after the sky lit up.


Angel Flett
said

I was driving home about ten minutes west of Dauphin,MB around 6:30 p.m. and I seen it it looked so big! I didn't know what to think of it, I've never seen anything like that in my life! it was amazing to see. All I seen was a big streak of like greenish-blue in the sky then it looked like it hit the ground! like you see in the movies! It was really neat!


Wes
said

$100,000 tool belt lost in space, I wonder if there is a connection.


pete26
said

At first I thought it was the US economy........., then I thought it was the auto industry...........then it I realized that it was a struggling Meteor Company on Mars drawing attention that it needs to be bailed out too!!!!


Andy
said

That was no meteor that was the economy going up in flames


Erin
said

I was driving from Vulcan on the highway i saw it come in and light up the sky with an explosion of orange color and then it was a straight line of orange to the ground. 2 trucks of us saw the whole thing right across the fields and to us we believe it must have hit the ground because of the orange ball of color heading downwards.


Lisa
said

CHAD - it sounds like you were real close, you should go back to the spot and see if you can find anything.
Once I was driving down the DVP in Toronto and I saw a blue flaming ball go overhead, it was wobbling so I think it was very close. Wish I had gone back to search.


James in Calgary
said

It was the Borg travelling back in time to cleanse the Earth...run...dont get assimilated! Resistance is futile!


Wary Mate
said

Two weeks ago while transiting Indian Avenue, just before getting to my destination in my Golf with Aden, myself, with cap-in-hand, were crossing a bridge when the Night sky lit up enough to illuminate a goat and the bridge we were on like day time. We watched a a guy with porcelain white skin streak across the road for about 5 seconds. Three days after it was repeated again with the same results! Now when crossing streets I often look left and right for streakers as it is so much fun. I'm just glad I don't see them at home.


Richie
said

Wouldn't be the first time the United States has invaded our airspace to test military weapons... They tend to do these kind of things, doesn't it make you glad they have the authority to control nukes.


Jake the Snake
said

It was not the Soyuz debris, that was discounted as it was still verified orbiting 10 hours after the meteor. Folks-let's get real, none of us were that close to it as everyone froM MB-AB says it lit up their kitchen and landed just over the hill. I think it was Optimus Prime and his entourage. They are taking over the auto sector and going to make some whoopa## machines. Wanna kickstart the economy? Who wouldn't want to buy a new V10 GMC duelly that turns into Ironhide - sign me up!!!
Snake in Drake,SK


tj
said

I live in teulon manitoba about 30 miles noth of winnipeg. i caught a glimpse of the meteor.


Michelle
said

We were driving on Hye 834 and looked East towards Ryley and saw the fireball which lit up the sky and then seemed to blow apart. It looked bigger than a grape forsure.


Sylvia
said

I saw it too here in Tisdale, Sask. The black night sky brightened to blue for just a brief couple of seconds. Pretty cool.


Scott Rogers
said

The sky lit up on my drive home from work in Saskatoon, SK. I wasn't sure what had happened because it was much brighter than a firework or anything like that. It looked like it was going to come down right on Saskatoon, but clearly it was just that bright that it was noticed for miles around. Where did it land???


Judy Probert
said

It passed right in front of us as we were driving into Martensville, SK at 6:30 pm. What an amazing thing to behold!!!


joe
said

It must have been going very fast as Ive seen guys going down the QE2 that fast and they didnt light up eh.
joe


Martin from Ottawa
said

Yeah, it was so bright, so awsome, it lit up the whole night sky.... but I didn't see it cause I live in Ottawa. lol


Amazed in Cornwall
said

I have a small still in my basement,and last year on the ninth day of my annual Vodka tasting try-out I was lying on the floor in the cellar and actually saw three meteorites flash past my house.....EVEN THOUGH THERE ARE NO WINDOWS AND THE WALLS ARE FIVE FEET THICK !


andrea
said

I thought of the Tool Bag that was dropped by one of the astronauts in outter space lol . Maybe that is the tool bag.


Merrie
said

The landing pad is in St. Paul - not that far from Lloydminster in the grand scheme of things . . .


Valerie Pranteau
said

Live in Grand Rapids, Manitoba caught a glimpse of what I thought was lightning in the western sky, a flash for 2 to 3 seconds would have liked to see more though!!


Mike
said

The earth is not billions of years old folks.... there is absolutely no evidentiary facts to support an age of billions of years. There is evidence to support possibly ten thousand years old using tried and proven techniques of age dating. Other methods are inaccurate and yet those numbers are used freely without factual support. So you're not as old as you look world!


Mo
said

that's amazing how such a small rock can do. Now imagine if a rock 10 times the size of that hit earth, there might be different results then.


Dayton
said

Bush and hills were to the right of me as I drove north slowly pulling a grainauger down a dark backroad last night around 6:30 p.m. There was no traffic and the nearest farm house was about 3 miles away. Then the sky and surroundings started to light up. It was so intense I could have read a newspaper inside the cab of my truck. I stopped my trucking thinking I was going to get hit by a jet. The rumbling sort of stopped and as I looked out my drivers window facing west I saw the back end of a huge yellow ball of light with a distinct red center and a long tail. I've seen lots of falling stars but this one looked like a comet even though it only lasted a few seconds and ended with a drop similar to a falling star only with a sunset glow and a few sparks. I could have drawn a line in the horizon as the trail of smoke seemed to linger for almost half an hour. It was about 5 degrees north of were I was and headed to the south East of North Battleford towards Provost A.B.


Roy
said

I feel bad. My 6 year old son insisted he saw lightning last night here in Saskatoon and I told him he was seeing things. I guess he has the last laugh now...My sister in Neilberg near Lloydminster saw it and moments later heard the sonic boom so I expect the reports it was near the border are true....Roy


Sahib Reginawale
said

Paul Delaney, an astronomer from York University, said "...giving us a wonderful lightshow, telling us of course that you should always be outside looking up."
-----------
This advice is very much different from what my mama and papa gave me. They said, "You shouldn't be looking up but looking where you are going."


Kevin
said

You would think that there would have been a jet or plane close to where the meteor struck and with all the devices they have on board, pretty well determine the exact location of where it went down.


Janice Grabler
said

My 17yr old daughter seen it throgh my bedroom window just before 5:30, we said maybe it was a flare from a hunter her comment was thats the biggest freeken flare Iv ever seen! Then late I saw it no the news, she was happy to know she was'nt the only one to see it! Sangudo Ab


Just happen to have one
said

So, something that is 4 1/2 billion years old, should be worth a fair amount of money. I'd sell my meteorite to an interested party for the right price


Janet Paskemin
said

I was driving on hi-way 40 travelling east from Cut Knife, when the sky lit up for more than 5 seconds. I looked north and the meteor looked like it was at least 5 kms away. I saw it fizzle out before it hit the ground. I didn't feel any kind of crash. It did leave behind a long trail of smoke. I would have to guess that it may have landed somewhere between hi-way 16 and hi-way 40 and not as far west as Lloydminister.


Amanda Deschner
said

We were on a hwy just east of Coronation AB when all of a sudden this fireball shoots from the sky. We suddenly slammed on our brakes because it felt like it was going to land right in front of us. I felt like I was in the movie Armagedon....It was scary and very unexpected but an incredible sight to see....


J. Hanson
said

I saw this fireball with my mom driving home last night. We were just passing Harris on highway 7 when we saw it almost directly North of us. It was so amazing and overwhelming that I started to cry just a little bit. :) Hope this was some help!


Russell Roberts
said

I am a long haul truck driver and I was proceeding eastbound on Highway No. 7 about a kilometer and a half before Brock, Saskatchewan. The sky ablsolutely lit up in a bright orange-reddish-white fashion. I turned my head and looked out my driver's door window and saw an object in flames with a wispy white smoke trail behind it hit the ground. It hit on the north side of the Trans Canada in a field. According to the news reports, they do not know where it is located. I believe I could walk in and find the exact spot where it landed. Afterwards I thought, "Man, that thing nearly took me out!!!"


Chels
said

It was really cool! I actually was driving on the highway between Rosetown and Kindersly and seen a fireball hit the ground just outside of the town of Brock right after the flash of light in the sky. It was only a couple of hundred yards away.


stephanie mike
said

we were driving and we saw something flash right in front of us and landed in a field by duck lake,sask. it is an half hour west of beardy's reserve. we thought it look like a fallen star and then it blow bright light up and fell to the ground.


MDK
said

I was putting up Christmas lights south of Medicine Hat, when I saw this fire ball getting larger and larger, everyone seems to be thinking it was in the North but it looked like to me it came from the South heading North, the entire house lit up and went right over the city heading North East, then about 5 to 10 seconds later there was a massive flash. This is the second one I have seen, about 20 years ago we saw one working on the farm, lit up the entire farm it came from west to east and hit somewhere in Sask. Again with a huge tail of fire and then a massive flash. You never forget those things.


Sandi Daniels
said

Hi my name is Sandi Daniels and I am from Cumberland House Saskatchewan. My family and I were driving around the community last night and had stopped at a stop sign when one of my family members saw something in the sky. I looked and we saw a very bright light that lit up half of the sky for a few seconds. We caught the very end tail of it. It looked like the burning of an ember just before it flcikers out, it was just above the trees and then it was gone. We notified the local R.C.M.P as it really did look like something had hit very close. Was there only one meteor or were there more? It's just that it seemed so close to us, but yet again isn't that what everyone is saying. If anyone is looking for it? do you think they will find anything, because I saw the video that Andy Bartlett had posted and it looks like it burnt up before touching ground. Either way that is the most amazing thing I have ever seen and probably ever will in my life time.


Dale Wilson - Edmonton
said

Lets get a comment here by a reputable scientist...these events clearly aren't meteors, they're folks from other worlds coming to visit. Just because we perceive their presence as a "streak of light" doesn't mean they're not real.


Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

CTV Video Player

Fireball

CTV Edmonton Extended

(Warning strong language) Dramatic video of the fireball shooting across downtown Edmonton.

CTV Edmonton security cameras caught the meteor approach and then create a massive flash in the skyline on Thursday evening, Nov. 20, 2008.

CTV Edmonton Extended

CTV security cameras captured a spectacular flash in the sky right after the meteor approaches.

A MyNews user Dan Charrois captured a bright flash in the sky on security cameras at his home.

MyNews

MyNews user Dan Charrois captured a bright flash in the sky on security cameras at his home.

MyNews.CTV.ca

My News

Send us your video and photos

Did you see the meteor? Send us your videos and pictures.

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz