CTV News | Canadian journalist safe after Afghan abduction

Top Stories -   

Canadian journalist safe after Afghan abduction

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV Newsnet: Mellissa Fung speaks about her ordeal
CTV News: Rosemary Thompson on Fung's ordeal
CTV Newsnet: Nasir Islam, Afghanistan expert, on the details surrounding the release of Mellissa Fung
CTV Newsnet: Ret'd Col. Michel Drapeau, former dir. general of DND
CTV Newsnet: Omar Samad, Afghanistan's Ambassador to Canada, on the kidnapped journalist's release
CTV Toronto: Matet Nebres on Fung's release
CTV Newsnet: John Cruickshank, CBC News Publisher, comments on Fung's safe release
CTV Newsnet: Lisa LaFlamme on the dangers female journalists face in conflict zones
CTV Newsnet: Harper on the release of Melissa Fung
CTV Newsnet: Scott Taylor, Esprit de Corps on the experience he shares with Mellissa Fung
CTV Newsnet: Graeme Smith, Globe and Mail, in Afghanistan
CTV Newsnet: Ret'd. Maj. Gen. Lewis Mackenzie, military analyst
CTV Newsnet: Craig Oliver on the safety of reporters in Afghanistan
CTV Newsnet: Craig Oliver on the behind-the-scenes efforts to secure Fung's release
CTV Newsnet: Craig Oliver on Prime Minister Stephen Harper's statement

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(22)

CTV.ca News Staff

Date: Sat. Nov. 8 2008 8:20 PM ET

After a 28-day kidnapping ordeal kept secret by Canadian officials and media, a CBC television reporter was released from her Afghan captors on Saturday in good health.

Mellissa Fung was kidnapped by gunmen on Oct. 12 after interviewing refugees at a United Nations camp in the western slums of Kabul, the Afghan capital.

For almost a month, CBC staff along with Canadian and Afghan officials worked to secure her release while international media kept the story under wraps.

CBC publisher John Cruickshank said that the network had requested the media blackout so negotiators could work for her release without mounting public pressure.

"We must put the safety of the victim ahead of our instinct for full transparency," Cruickshank said at a press conference in Toronto Saturday.

"If there's a question of harm coming to a victim of crime, it's not our role to intensify that harm," he said, adding that "hundreds" of people had been working toward Fung's release.

"If there's a compelling reason to protect the victims of crime, we will do that."

It's believed Fung's captors were criminals, not Taliban insurgents.

Cruickshank said the 35-year-old reporter had already spoken to her parents and Prime Minister Stephen Harper.

"She sounded terrific," said Cruickshank. "She said she hadn't been harmed in any way, and she said to us she was sorry for all the trouble she caused."

Currently, Fung is staying at the Canadian embassy in Kabul, however, Cruickshank said that "plans are being made to reunite Mellissa with her family as soon as possible."

While the circumstances surrounding the reporter's release remained shrouded in mystery, Harper was clear that clear that "no ransom was paid by anyone in this case."

Harper added that the media blackout may have been crucial to Fung's survival.

"I would like to thank members of the press who, understanding the grave risk to Ms. Fung's life, have deferred publishing this story," he said.

Harper added that he spoke to Fung by phone and said she seemed to be in "remarkably good spirits.

"A short while ago I was pleased to speak with Mellissa myself to convey our great joy and best wishes on behalf of all Canadians," he said.

Fung, who is normally based out of Regina, was on her second reporting assignment to Afghanistan when she was captured.

"Ms. Fung was preparing to report on the plight of Afghan refugees and displaced persons when she was seized," said Harper.

"I commended her for her commitment as a journalist to deepening Canadians' understanding of the challenges and hardships faced by our Afghan friends and partners."

Adam Khan Serat, spokesperson for the provincial governor in Afghanistan's Wardak province, told The Associated Press tribal elders and local council members helped secure her freedom.

Serat also said there was no ransom involved.

Despite the dire circumstances, Mellissa's mother Joyce held out hope during the entire 28-day captivity.

Joyce Fung told The Canadian Press that in her "heart of hearts" she always believed her daughter would be set free.

"She's a very calm and collected person. She can handle stressful situations much better than her parents, actually," she said.

On Friday, another female journalist was set free near Kabul a week after she was kidnapped. The Dutch reporter was also unharmed during her captivity.

Comments are now closed for this story

Sammy
said

Thank god she's safe. And good on the Canadian media on the blackout, it was better for her safety and for her family.

All in all, I'm glad she's okay!

Anne
said

Thank God she is o.k.
And thanks to all involved in her safe return!

FuturePM
said

Hmmm... I wonder why when the average citizen is abducted in the Middle East that there is no blackout for their safety. Maybey for the press to have a story to tell?

Mark
said

Thankfully the reporter is safe and sound.

One question-how much did it cost me (the taxpayer) for the non-disclosed ransom paid by CBC?


Carlo Dimarco
said

Why media Blackout? But same media goes to court when there is media blackout?

Why don't they have media blackout when somebody in Toronto is killed and harass the family members for interview?

Shame on media for this blackout?

Mike Tenszen
said

I accept that the basic safety of any one of us might be more important than a news story.
But that would seem to be the case only if the reporting of the kidnapping of that CBC reporter can now, in retrospect and for the information of the inquiring public, be clearly shown by Mr. Oliver of CTV, and by the CBC brass, to have actually threatened the life of that unfortunate reporter.
The duty, obligation of the CBC, CTV, and all of the media, it seems to me, is to show the public now why this story was covered up when so many stories of similar kidnappings in these brutal and uncivilized lands are NOT covered up.
This abject cover-up of a kidnapping by the media of a member of the media---when we all know that had this poor woman been a diplomat, a secretary in an embassy, a soldier, would NOT have been covered up by CTV, the CBC, and all other members of the media who appear, quite frankly, to be conspirators in hiding important news when it is "one of their own."

David in Trenton, On.
said

Thank God.... And God bless Melissa. She is an outstanding reporter and I am so happy that she is safe. Everybody did it perfectly and correct. Keep your lips shut. I have more than five dozen landings in that region and it is not a place to dick around, and diplomacy doesn't often work. Mark, the main thing is that she is safe, and if you want I will pay the few cents of tax on your behalf for CBC's transfer payment.

Tony
said

Media coverage of captured journalists becomes a bargain chip in favour of the abductors.

Victor King
said

This goes to tell you that negotiation is necessary to secure peace and safety of Canadians and locals alike. I strongly urge the present government to initiate negotiation with the Taliban to find a peaceful resolution to the current foreign conflict. This is the only way to enable ever lasting peace in the region.

Prof. Pye Chartt
said

Glad she's safe and sound.

I may be entirely alone on this one, but, I've never fully understood and valued the role of journalists who get plopped into foreign countries ravaged by war and untold political and religious issues.

Frankly, I rarely get to see fruits of labour that outweigh the risks. My sense is that, usually, reporters are so constrained and influenced by the opposing forces at play (and the overriding need to remain alive) that their "reporting" is often biased, shallow, somewhat hollow, sensational, and devoid of genuine impact on the viewers/readers at home.

Oh, I know, they represent our eyes and ears and, therefore, are critically important (theoretically) to our knowledge and understanding. I get the whole Journalism 101 thing.

I'm merely yapping out loud as, over the years, I've read and watched more worthless "reports" from hunching journalists in danger zones than I can shake a stick at. Often it seems as though they're just there to represent their media company's interest in being there (ie. news prestige).

Anyway. No disrespect to the profession. It's a tough job.


Happy Outcome....
said

Tony said it all....
In circustances such as this you do everything possible for the subjects safe return, and I am certain the fact that the kidnappers saw nothing in the news media about their crime just showed them that the person they had kidnapped was of no real importance,making any negotiations that much simpler.
Pity Mark, FuturePM and a few others were deprived of a juicy abduction story of a young lady in war torn Afghanistan, but the rest of us realise that in these circumstances you do what ever you have to.
Thank you "media" for passing up on a chance to satisfy the minority named above and helping get this young lady home safe.

DougB
said

I totally agree with many of the comments here. There is good and bad side to this black out. Since it worked and the Canadian media were all in agreement for this, I hope I dont hear the media in the courts trying to lift a black out on a court case in the future as they will have alot to answer for it. Glad this girl is safe, but do not all canadians have the same rights? apparently not unless you work for the media.

OttawaJames
said

mark... if you read the article carefully there was no ransom paid. so the cost to you is nil. even if there had been a ransom paid wouldnt you rather have paid it that have the video of her beheading all over the internet? i mean you shouldnt put dollar amounts on a persons life. have a little respect.


buffalojump
said

Thank goodness Ms. Fung is safe.

But I see double standards and double speak from CBC and media when one of theirs is in a position of danger. They have no respect for victims in other situations and question vigourously and crticize gov. and others for transparency when this doesn't affect them.

Media and CBC, learn from this and respect other victims and situations. Understand and respect others like you do your own.

Move up the credibility ladder by being credible.

Veteran
said

In any conflict journalists are a prime target for snipers,conventional attack, or abduction (their plight serves as the perfect propaganda tool). As a veteran of many military missions over the years,I can say that a camera or microphone was perfect bait for drawing the radicals out of the woodwork.
Regardless of this, in a democracy, the press is obliged to tell the story to the best of their ability.

Golf Company Grunt
said

>>>Victor King
This goes to tell you that negotiation is necessary to secure peace and safety of Canadians and locals alike. I strongly urge the present government to initiate negotiation with the Taliban to find a peaceful resolution to the current foreign conflict. This is the only way to enable ever lasting peace in the region.
>>

You are so naive. The Taliban do their negotiating through the barrel of an AK-47 and I.E.D.'s. They have no desire to see a peaceful resolution. Their only objective is total control of the country through whatever means gets them there.

'Pro Patria'


Norm
said

I think this situation is a win win for everyone. First - Melissa whose safety in my view, comes first - and as a result, I have no problem with a news blackout, given the dire circumstances. I personally believe, this strategy is effective and in the interest of those who may unfortunately suffer a similar experience, let's hope our media conducts itself accordingly.

I also think it's win win for Prime Minister Harper and what I hope we will see more of in the future - his willingness to work with the media when it is in everyone's best interest and to demonstrate trust and a willingness to collaborate and be less divisive than in the past. It works both ways - a reaching out by Prime Minister Harper and a reciprical gesture by the Media when it makes perfect sense to do so.


brad in fernie
said

i'm glad she's safe.i'm also very glad to hear no ransom was paid.i hope this is the truth.i feel its the paying of ransoms and bribes that help cause these people to become targets for abduction.

Simon Shaw
said

My initial reaction was feeling great thanks for her safe return.

Within a second after having read the article, I became enraged that a media blackout had occured. I ask myself, had it been my life or someone else who was not one of their own, would the media have appreciated the dire need for a blackout to safeguard that life. The only answer I have is a resounding NO.

If the media as an entire entity, band together in this conspiracy of silence, what else are they capable of? To what depths have they lied to us before?


Lost Cause
said

Hey Golf Company Grunt - how do you think this woman's release was secured? It was almost 99% probable that her release was secured through negotiation.

If it was a rescue via a firefight against the bad guys over there the politicians and higher ranking soldiers who think like yourself would be out here having a press conference and bragging about it. Of course. Like they always do.

Your attitude is nothing more than a self-fulfiling prophecy. Treat the Taliban like the way you describe them and they have no choice except to fight back - you are leaving them no other option whatsoever. If you "negotiate" with them solely through firefights and air strikes and bombs and missiles, of course they'll "negotiate" back with AK-47's and IED's. And if in the process of these battles a lot of civilians die, you'll strengthen Taliban ranks because over time the increasingly disillusioned people in Afghanistan will weary of your "help".

Negotiation with ALL parties in the region is the only plausible way to maybe get a peaceful resolution out of this. Even Karzai (the guy you're fighting to prop up) has said it, but I suppose you, like so many other foreign occupiers throughout history, know what's better for the Afghans than the native Afghans do...


Timmy
said

Why was their a media blackout for this situation, but with the pretty reporter kidnapped in Somalia - Amanda Lindhout - her face splashed across all newspapers? I'm just glad the situation for Miss Fung turned out okay.


tinkerbell
said

No ransom? I guess the Taliban decided she was OK because she was a Canadian.
Amazing what good Canadian logic can do in negotiations.Good thing we didn't cave and give them money to buy weapons to use against our troops.Thank goodness.

Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz