News Sections
NAFTA in jeopardy if Obama wins, Cellucci says
Font-size:
Share
Print
Comments(56)
CTV.ca News Staff
Date: Mon. Nov. 3 2008 5:12 PM ET
A former U.S. ambassador to Canada issued a stern warning Monday that the possibility of Barack Obama in the White House presents a "danger" to Canada by threatening the fundamentals of Canada-U.S. trade relations.
Most polls show Obama leading heading into Tuesday's U.S. presidential election.
Former Massachusetts governor Paul Cellucci, who was the ambassador under Republican U.S. President George Bush for four years, told CTV's Canada AM that free trade is under threat with a Democratic win.
"There's a danger for Canada in that Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton during the primary campaign were just about in a race to see who could take us out of NAFTA the quickest," Cellucci said.
"They made some pretty strong statements about the North America Free Trade Agreement, and if Barack Obama is elected with a strong Democratic majority in the House and the Senate, there's going to be a lot of pressure on him to do what he said he would do ... I don't think that would be good for the United States, I don't think that would be good for Canada."
Republican candidate John McCain, however, believes in the cross-border trade agreement and "how important this trade back-and-forth is to both of our countries and to the millions of people whose jobs are dependent on it," Cellucci said.
Spirit of co-operation
However, the former ambassador put partisanship aside to say that no matter who is elected to the White House, he believes there will be a spirit of co-operation and communication between the two nations that are each other's largest trading partners.
"Whoever is the leader of Canada, whoever is the leader of the United States, it's in each of our national interests to work together," Cellucci said.
"We're interconnected, we're dependent on each other, we have a lot of common interests and common values and I think they will work together no matter who it is."
Cellucci dismissed reports that the election is firmly in Democratic hands and Obama will walk away with the victory on Tuesday. He said McCain is still within five percentage points in most national polls, which is a surprising, given the unpopularity of the Iraq war, the current economic downturn and Obama's huge campaign budget.
McCain victory unlikely
Graham Dodds, a professor at Concordia University who specializes in U.S. domestic politics, agreed with Cellucci that regardless of who wins the election, the relationship between the two countries will in all likelihood remain strong.
But he conceded that in some ways, Canada would likely be better off with a McCain victory.
"An Obama presidency might mean a little more tension in a couple of areas," Dodds told CTV Newsnet.
He said Obama's comments about renegotiating NAFTA were most likely nothing more than campaign rhetoric, and he doubts such a change will actually happen.
However, he said Obama's stance on international trade is clearly more protectionist than McCain's, which could negatively impact trade relations.
Dodds also said Congress is likely to have a much stronger Democratic presence after the election if voting goes the way polls have suggested -- another factor that could affect Canada, he said.
"Democrats tend to favour protectionism as opposed to free trade and also burdensome environmental restrictions which both have heavy implications for the relationship with Canada in the future," Dodds said.
Fixing economy will be top priority
U.S. political commentator Mark Plotkin said the overriding issue in this election is the economy -- and Americans have traditionally sided with the Democrats in times of financial uncertainty, he said.
If, as Plotkin and Dodds predict, Obama wins the Tuesday election, his first order of business won't be to dismantle an important cross-border trade mechanism, but to try to fix the fractured U.S. economy, he suggested.
"People are worried about whether they can stay in their homes, whether they can afford a car loan, whether they can they meet their weekly and monthly bills. So that has overwhelmed everything else," Plotkin said.
User Tools
Related Stories
User Tools
About the tools
Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.
-


Font-size
Print Article
Comments(56)-
Feedback
Share it with your network of friends
Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.
Most Viewed News Stories
Most Talked about Stories
I applaud the budget, even though Health Care and education may stay unscathed. Sadly this cannot last and I worry to later this year where cuts will become enviable. If anything, this provides the Wildrose Alliance plenty of ammo when an election is called.


Comments are now closed for this story
Allan Eizinas
said
The USA has strong armed us in the softwood lumber dispute, shut down our beef industry with their Mad Cow sanctions, created all kinds of cross border access problems with their “security” restrictions and ignoring most of their promises through the NAFTA agreement.
They continue to subsidize their export products at will.
I do not understand why we are not looking at Chinese, Asian and European markets.
Yoyoma
said
Robin the Hood
said
kate
said
Scott
said
John from Fredericton
said
Should we wait and see what will happen with NAFTA if Obama gets in?
If NAFTA is in jeopardy, I know Ontario wouldn't mind.
Erin
said
Niagara George
said
KLS
said
Partisanship scare tactics
said
Jim-Surrey
said
I wish all these speculators would just button up and sit back and wait for what the American voters want.
It really has nothing to do with what us Canadians want or think it is NOT our country and maybe it is time we started as a country to take care of ourselves instead of worrying about other countries politics!
Matthew from Ottawa
said
Kris
said
Mark, Victoria, BC
said
No one is going to cancel a free trade agreement at a time when the American economy is tanking! This guy has his head in the Republican clouds plain and simple.
Go Obama! Save us from the war-mongering right wing fanatics in the Republican Party!!
J. Smith
said
RobO
said
They can only close there borders for so long...then they will reopen them. Lets hope the Government of the day hold the flame to them and doesn't bend...over
Ki-Som Victoria BC
said
roy cotton
said
Roger T
said
The Widowmaker
said
Doug Rutherford
said
So what?
A. Bica
said
Get your facts straight instead of misleading forum participants
GC
said
Do you really think the Americans will renegotiate NAFTA for our benefit???
Yes, Mr. Hope and Change will definitely put Canadians ahead of Americans.
Gail in NS
said
Please don't believe all the smoke and mirrors of big business that is raking in the increased profits and paying out higher dividends to their shareholders. The top 10% richest are the ones benefiting (greatly!) from free trade - the lower 90% are actually losing.
Alberta Believer
said
Because Asian and European markets are far weaker and less stable than American ones Allan!
Europe's banking ballout crisis is now worse than Americans and it wasn't the Europeans who had a bad lending policy. The Asian markets are wildly unstabele because unlike ours their market is still dominated by short term traders and speculators as opposed to long term holders like pension funds and the like.
Allan when it comes to peoples' money you'll find there's little apetite for anti-Americanism or other crazy political view points which don't measure up to fiscal reality.
Ry (from the Hammer)
said
"The sky is falling, the sky is falling."
Yet still, 2,000 some years later, the sky is still there. Thankfully, I'm not losing too much sleep over either.
Nostradamn
said
Jim in Edmonton
said
By the way, I feel the same way about goods being shipped into Canada from China, India etc. We are only hurting ourselves by not insisting on similar wage and environmental laws. The rush to the bottom line has hurt everyone, even those who invited in this rush through the stock market. If anything comes of the Harper / Obama elections it should be and must be fair trade on both sides and keep foreign producers out unless they compete on similar grounds - after all we can't sell very much to them.
Ps. i'm no liberal or union loving, green socialist. I just want more made in Canada thank you.
opinion
said
Wont be long, Canada copies the USA in everything, a more liberal government south means we are not far behind, thank goodness.
Harper, when is the next election?
bryan
said
Anne Ottawa
said
Denise
said
Dave in Newington
said
OIL
They sacrifice their young men in wars for it and we have it in spades....
Yup....we will start renegotating NAFTA when we see all those US gas stations with "closed" signs on them.....
This is all the more reason that we start refining our own oil now,this being our Achilles Heel,relying on the US refineries for all our gas,diesel and heating oil
Glynn in Saint John
said
I'd love to agree Mark; sadly though, some of the recent conservative campaign ads took a page right out of the Cheney/Rove book of politics.
Leo
said
What did you think that Cellucci should've said, the opposite?
He's afraid of his own job...
The quicker he leaves Canada the better we'll be...
The soft wood deal we won several times in Court but Them Republicans don't comply with the World Court just their own...
NAFTA was started by Conservatives and Republicans
But they don't like to follow the rules when it's in favor of Canada.
Carolyn Macdonald
said
Mel from Calgary
said
NAFTA's chapter 11 is designed to thwart the will of democratically elected governments.
In NAFTA we guaranttee the oil and gas supply to the U.S. even if we have to go without.
Die NAFTA die!
Mike
said
Nick in Gatineau
said
NAFTA is a good deal. The problem is that we let the USA dictate what the terms would be rather than let a foreign body determine when and to which sector subsidies are actually determined as subsidies. They also know they can refuse to abide by judicial councils because Canada will bend over backwards. We win 9 (6 Major rounds and 3 minor ones)out of 10 judicial rounds and they do nothing. They win 1 round (Minor one)and we have to bend over backwards...
Take the simple commodity, yet the most important of all: Water. When used by farmers, it is an agricultural subsidy. When used by Firefighters, it is a subsidy for our wood industry. When used by the oil industry - silence. So what does Canada do ? We let Farmers go through droughts (the US provides them with water), we let our forests burn down (2 US states provide tax exemptions to all wood industry-related losses caused by fires), and we provide all the water that the oil industry needs.
If they want to fix Nafta, a) Remove the barriers that are pro- American isolationist,b), Force all parties to abide by the judicial rulings, and c)ban all subsidies or allow all subsidies for all sales within the member countries.
Colin, from Québec
said
ed
said
Eme
said
Ed Leaf
said
Mr Chillz
said
Doug BC
said
I support the idea posted by "Allan Eizinas" about other markest.The problem right now,is that our products are to expensive for most Asian markets.If we want to sell more than natural resources,we have to find ways to reduce the cost of production here so we can sell affordable goods that actually make profits.
This is the biggest reason that paying down debt,and lower taxes are vital.As are pipelines from Alberta to BC ports.Right now,BC needs revenue,so we sell raw logs to American mills.ALberta needs revenue,so it sells oil to the USA.
Our future sovereignty depends on our ability to manage our economy in ways that benefit people here.And we cannot do that as long as we are burdened with debt and totally reliant on the export of unprocessed natural resources.
Those resources give us some leverage to access the American markets.But not if we have no other options or markets that can afford our products.
In fact,on CNN last week,one American Senator actually pointed out that an angry Canada could easily sell it's oil to China.He was quite concerned that we might now bow meekly to US demands.And in fact,might begin the process of quietly developing other markets.
Our problem may well be getting all the premiers to present a united front.And to develope a long term strategy that does not unduly punish one region of Canada.
Both Canada and the US are better off as allies.We both have to do well if North America is to do well.
G
said
John Chow
said
During the last 8 yrs, we went nowhere on softwood, beef and other issues...
US ignored Int'l trade rulings..
Setting our own prices on oil will allow us pay down the national debt. Remember, China & India are ready to buy resources all over the world. Having resources next to Americans is a dream comes true for them.
Shall we bring Brian Tobin to negotiate for us?
Jenn in Halifax
said
Edmonton John
said
Excuse me, but since when has the US ever honoured an agreement that it was not the unambiguous and ONLY beneficiary of?
I love the US, and I love Americans, but the politics and economics of our relationship are fair game for any anti-American rants.
This soon-to-be-unemployed ambassador is toe-ing the party line. There's nothing new here.
If Obama wants to reopen NAFTA it's not like we're going to lose something that works all that well for us. We need something better, anyway.
Darcy
said
gundi
said
Layton B in Moncton NB
said
Andrew Steeves
said
Canuck in bellingham WA
said
And just what does he dislike about Canada. It has national health care, is more unionized and takes care of its people better. These are all the things he espouses for America. I suspect if he wants to renegotiate NAFTA, it would be Mexico etc that are going to take the hit.
Canada's right wing and the US's left wing are not far apart in their stances.
Gwillimbury
said
I dont' think that the US can afford to cut Canada as it's closest trading partner.
They need us and we need them, its' that simple.
They need us because Canada has the 2nd largest oil reserve in the world.
We are an energy rich country that the US cannot simply brush off.
If they want to reopen NAFTA and renegotiate it, it could be beneficial to Canada.
So, if Mr. Obama wishes to do this, be my guest. I know of many other nations out there, such as China, India, Europe, need resources and are willing to purchase them from us as well.
Matt
said
The long and short is we can't be caught in the myopic sights of the US as it begins to close its borders. Let then do it and let us continue to expand relationships. I for one am positive of the outcome for the US...and it isn't pretty