CTV News | Harper offers arts tax credit to woo Que. voters

Top Stories -   

Harper offers arts tax credit to woo Que. voters

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV Newsnet: Harper delivers campaign speech
CTV Newsnet: Stephen Harper takes questions following his announcement regarding the RESP
CTV Newsnet: Graham Richardson on the looming importance of Quebec
CTV Newsnet: John McCallum and Michael Ignatieff discuss the Liberals' economic record
CTV Newsnet: Roger Smith on Ignatieff's comments and the stronger tone being taken by the Liberals

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(192)

CTV.ca News

Date: Mon. Sep. 29 2008 12:02 PM ET

In an apparent attempt to win back vital ground in Quebec, Conservative Leader Stephen Harper announced Monday he would provide a $150-million tax credit to help get kids interested in the arts.

Speaking in Ottawa, Harper said the credit would be designed to help defray the costs for parents who want to enroll their kids in arts programs that could inspire them to pursue a career in the field.

"The credit will apply on up to $500 of eligible fees for children under 16 who participate in eligible arts activities. This tax cut will encourage and make it easier for parents to give their children the benefits of activities such as music classes, drama or arts classes, and the parents will save money on their taxes," Harper said.

"For some children participating in arts, dance and drama classes these will be a fun and enjoyable activity. For others it could be the beginning of much more -- a life long interest or career."

He said the new program would also be extended for lower-income families. An already existing children's fitness tax credit would also be extended, Harper said.

The Conservatives poll results were strong in Quebec early in the campaign, but appeared to slip last week after Harper suggested ordinary working Canadians didn't relate to elitist, tax-subsidized artists when they see them at gala events on television.

Strategic Counsel polling for CTV and The Globe and Mail on Friday showed the Tories had stalled in Quebec's key battlegrounds while the Bloc Quebecois had seen a rise in support.

Liberals target Harper

Meanwhile Monday, the Liberals stepped up their attacks against the Conservatives.

Deputy Liberal leader Michael Ignatieff warned business leaders in Toronto on Monday that Stephen Harper would lead the country into an "economic crisis" if he returns to government.

Ignatieff, appearing with Liberal finance critic John McCallum, said Harper's plan won't help Canada navigate the turbulent global economy.

He said a Conservative government would make cuts to health care and pensions, would "devastate" the middle class and make Canada unrecognizable.

The Liberal plan, meanwhile, would provide "sound money, balanced budgets, low taxes and personal responsibility."

Ignatieff also said Harper is trying to deceive Canadians into thinking he occupies the centre of the political spectrum.

"Harper's trying to push us off the centre because he's a right-wing conservative. He's got to persuade Canadians of what is not true -- namely that he's a centrist. He's not a centrist, he's a right wing politician and we have been in the centre since Laurier for heaven's sake," Ignatieff said.

"He puts on the blue sweater, he does the 'you are getting drowsy stuff', and it's not going to work with Canadians. Canadians are not fooled."

Ignatieff downplayed a seat projection released Friday by the Strategic Counsel showed the Conservatives poised to double their seat count from 16 to 32 in the 45 key battleground ridings in Ontario, Quebec and B.C.

Ignatieff said he is confident that Canadians will vote Liberal when they go to the polls.

"They know there's a party at the centre, at the centre of Canadian life, it's called the Liberal Party of Canada. And when they see that party occupying the centre, pushing them off from the right, pushing them off from the left, they vote for us."

Comments are now closed for this story

Jaid in Toronto
said

No matter what party side you look at. Blast a side and say yours is better.

Now, who ever said the election campaign of all parties is clean?

Harper was right about this one, it's going to be nasty.

Vote for what you believe is best. Unless you wish to scratch out all the names and vote yourself in.


Henry Wysmulek
said

The liberals still believe they are the center of the universe and Canada'a natural governing body.

These continuing delusions could be the heart of the liberal problem, since most Canadians see them as nothing more than a bunch of crooks ripping off taxpayers.




PVT
said

Cuts to health care? I guess the Liberals would be experts on that....


Dennis - Sudbury, Ontario
said

Shouldn't Dion, you know, the LEADER, be seen going on the offensive like this before his Lieutenants, his FORMER leadership rivals?

It is obvious what is going on here. The wheels are coming off the Liberal camapaign because they are hitting the latest bump in the road; the person they threw under the bus - Dion.


Exiled Canadian
said

The Liberals are in panic mode. That is why they are now using "economy collapsing" and "right-wing" scare tactics, and using Ignatief as their mouthpiece instead of Dion.

Liberals are imploding but Ignatief did get one thing right: Canadians will not be fooled.


Andy
said

Liberals are centrist?? Please..anyone who is considering a coalition with the NDP and colludes with the Greens not to run a candidate in Peter MacKay's riding is definitely thinking from the left! Fortunately it seems most Canadians know better.


Red X
said

When the Conservatives came to power in 2006. The GDP - Economic growth was healthy. In April & May, Canada ran deficits.
The PM was smart to call an early election because things are going to get worse in North America in general...


Not Again
said

Ignatieff is out of his league. His bluster and "for heaven's sake" appeal is too little, too late. The attack on Harper as some demonic right wing thinker with no morals, is akin to the huffing and puffing - I will blow your house down if you don't let me in. Sorry, I don't buy it.


Darcy Lindzon, Halifax
said

Who is the Liberal leader?


CC-western Canada
said

Panic is now setting in. They are at 25% in the polls. Turner won 40 seats at 28% in the polls. Dion will not be able to debate to the level of Harper or Layton and in effect, will get lost in the shuffle. Yes, ..panic had embraced the Liberal Party.


BW
said

Let me get this straight, the Liberals have been promising to spend Billions on just about everything yet they are the prudent ones. Absolutely priceless!!


bill
said

the liberals are getting desparate now. how can they question what harper has done up til now? i'd say compared to the u.s. canada is more than holding its own right now and we'll be far better off with a conservitive majority


proud conservative
said

And so it begins.He would know as he lived in the states long enough. I guess that is why he bailed and came back to Canada.


JP in North Saanich, BC
said

Being a Liberal- i am trying to decide who to vote for.
The Liberal party made a mistake at the Leadership Convention and elected a good man BUT not a Leader.
UnderDION they cannot win - so for the first tiem in my life i may not vote Liberal. Having said that I urge the votes to sedn a MINORITY governmnet to Ottawa- that way they can be controled if they step out of line
A Majority Conserative governmnet will be a disaster.
Think Back - Malroney,Clark.
Side Note- Under Harper - my home town, Dalhousie, NB went from a pulp and paper mill employing 2,000 to a closure of mill and 2000 on UI- Thanaks Stevie


GFT from NB
said

How is the "Green Shift" doing these days?


Robin the Hood
said

They need to keep hammering at the fact that Harper is in with Bush and that it is under their policies and right wing agenda of enriching the wealthiest 1% that the market crisis occurred. Even though Harper is not really part of the Bush disaster they both share the same economic and social ideology and goals. Remind people of that fact and using their increasing economic insecurities and you would think the more left leaning parties would be a shoe-in come voting day.



Ted
said

Wishful thinking, I'd say.


K. Johnston
said

The Liberals use to be in the middle but they are really on the left this election. Has anyone ever notice when the Libs are loosing they come up with the most outrageous statements - and for a party that has been whining all election about personal attacks - they sure have been saying a lot of mean stuff about PM Harper. Really personal attacks. The Conservatives are the only party that can run this country properly.


Wake up igi
said

Ignatieff downplayed poll numbers and is confident Canadians will vote Liberal.

What planet is he from?


max
said

I think the liberals are getting nervous.


bob
said

There is crisis coming. A world crisis cause by the US. Mr. Harper will have to deal with it. It was not caused by Canada, but the Liberals would have you believe it is. They are hoping for a crisis so they can say ‘I told you so’. An empty party with petty people.


Tom Kaberle
said

It is always entertaining to listen to politicians move their lips. Like when Layton says "what we are hearing as we door knock is that people want the NDP" What a hoot....... he must be hearing this 18% of the time but somehow this translates to support for him..... Ignatieff and the liberals are the same....... they always say things like "Harper and the conservatives do not represent Canadian Values"..... I guess those who vote conservative are not Canadians then.... what a hoot..... The Conservative politicians are not any better when it comes to Political Smack.... The whole thing is a hoot..... My suggestion to everyone is this.... forget what politicians are saying to you.... look at their written policies, look at their history and then choose the party that best fits what you believe.... and then when they don't live up to your high standards don't be disappointed... they are politicians after all.


Bill from Whitby
said

Who is Iggy trying to kid...he's the one that thinks Canadians are fools...just like every other Liberal has for years......and yes they treated us that way also.


Glenn in Winnipeg
said

This is an interesting plan. Clearly stating the mantra that "the Liberal party is in the middle of the political spectrum" and repeating the mantra. But their policies are closer to and may be more left of enter than the NDP who are clearly left of center.

It will be interesting to see if the Liberals shift (again) to a listen to what I say today, will work.
Personally I believe this is stale. It won't work.


Roger
said

Liberal party is Centre??? my goodness the past 2 years they are left of the NDP for crying out loud... talk about who is trying to decieve Canadians.. sorry, we won't be fooled this time.


Bluenose
said

How on earth can these people call themselves "Centre" They are far left, out in left field so far, you need binoculars to see them. Oh, I guess they have some unfound magic, that the rest of the world doesn't know about that can protect Canada against global economic meltdown. I think these guys are having a medication breakdown or something? Canadians know, the only centre party is the Conservative party.


Jess D
said

Ignatieff's and McCallum`s comments smack of desperation. Harper is a trained economist and the economy is producing a surplus. In turbulent times why should we risk switching to the Liberals and their untested leader?


darren
said

if you mean "economic crisis" as in tax cuts and a stable government for a change. I think most people are smart enough to realize the liberal party is a pathetic excuse for a bunch of people who want to spend our money any way THEY see fit. They have proven themselves completly irresposible in the past.


Peter
said

Here comes the Liberal fear mongering. Not this time Iggy. Maybe Jack will have a job for you in the opposition after the 14th. Putting the Liberals back in power would be like making the local arsonist the fire chief.


Kisr
said

The fact that Mr. Dion is not making this statement is a clear indication of the Liberals lack of true leadership. If the Liberals do win then we are really in for an economic disaster.


Socialism is killing us
said

This line got me:

"The Liberal plan, meanwhile, would provide "sound money, balanced budgets, low taxes and personal responsibility."

Uh yeah. Sound money going into Liberal pockets. Balanced budgets with $13 billion surpluses. Low taxes, yeah sure what a joke. Personal responsibility only if you're putting money into a Liberals pocket right?


Niagara George
said

Way to go Michael! It's time to call their bluff. The cons have no plan... they haven't even announdced a platform.

If they ever get in, our heads will be spinning with the announcements they make about the things Canadians voted for. Too much of it will be ideas that were never even presented in their campaign.

The arts announcements should be enough to turn everyone against them. They follow the exact pattern of the Mike Harris neocons in Ontario.

Mike's polls told him that teachers and welfare recipients were the ones to pick on. That's what he did and school children are still suffering the consequences.

Now Harper's polls tell him people don't understand the arts or the young offenders act, so they become the target.

What he doesn't bother to say is that his wife is the head of one of the arts councils that had the black tie gala with limos at the door. He was there and certainly seemed to enjoy every moment of it. Besides that, the gala was a fundraiser not an event that used taxed dollars, with no return.


Mike in BC
said

This is just scaremongering.

It was the Liberals that cut transfer payments to the provinces for healthcare and put healthcare into the terrible state that it is in today. We're still in catch-up mode.

I'd much rather give Stehen Harper the keys to the vault than Stephan Dion.


Trent
said

Of course we should beleavie the liberals??? They must think all of us are dumb? Show me some prof? All I see are liberals throwing more money then the conservites and he says they are going to cut costs? Lets get real they are fish out of water trying to save there part and there jobs nothing more.. Playing it up sorry Dion Ignatieff and Rae are out for your job....


Doug BC
said

Well Mr.Ignatieff,I can agree that Mr.Harper's party probably a little more right of centre than most of us care to be.A lot of us are hoping the maturing a party goes through as it occupies office will eventually move the Coservatives a half step closer to the political centre.
But sir,this life long Liberal supporter has left your party because you have become simply another branch of the left wing socialists in the NDP.Your vote bribing socialist policies have taken the Liberals so far left that you haven't seen the political centre since Lester Pearson.You really should re-name your party "NDP Lite".
Attacking the Conservative party will not alter the fact that the Liberals are now socialists.If you want my support back,you have to fix your party.Kick out the socialists and return to the centre.
I'm no fan of Mr.Harper or Conservative ideology.I'm not sure how a Conservative government will do.But so far I'm OK with what they've done.And I know one thing for sure.I fear a Liberal majority a lot more than I fear the Conservatives.
And hey,there's always another election coming if they don't do a decent job.


Ignatieff fear mongering again
said

Canadians see thorugh this crap by Ignatieff. Where has Michael Ignatieff been hiding during this election? It appears he's trying not to be seen to much so as not to destroy his chances in the next Liberal leadership convention. What a political hypocrite!

It's the Liberals who Canadians need to be concerned about.

They don't have a great record - a few reminders of their "accomplishments"

- Sponsorship Scandal (stolen money)
- 14 RCMP Shawinigate Investigations
- The wasteful gun registry debacle
- The "lost" $1BILLION HRDC boondoggle
- The gutting of our military
- "Strippers" & Immigration Department
- 13 years & NO child care program
- Liberals NOTHING on Kyoto (except name a dog Kyoto)

...to name a few




Jasper
said

So...Ignatieff is saying is it will be Harper's fault if there is a recession. How convenient. Recessions are a normal part of the economic cycle. Always have been...always will be.


truenorth
said

Boy, the Liberals are sure running scared now! Don't know what Iggie is smoking, but to suggest that the Liberals are centrist! Give us a break! They are as left wing as the NDP and Green. The Liberal line of "the scary Harper with the hidden conservative agenda" was never true. The Canadian voters bought that lie the first time around, found it suspicious the second time, and will totally reject it for the Liberal fantasy and scare tactic that it is, this time. You can fool all of the people some of the time..... Consedvative majority here we come!


Transparent Liberal hypesters
said

The "Glibs" are hauling out their "names" just prior to the debates in hopes of stirring up some interest in their dying electoral campaign.

I don't want these turkeys anywhere near government.




Raymond
said

Where is your hapless leader, Iggy?

Harper kept over 50% (125+) of his 2006 election promises, and made strides toward fulfilling many more.

He did this in a little over two years, with a minority parliament, and WHILE fighting an unpopular war.

Lose the fear mongering, Iggy...I'll go with Mr. Harper, thanks.


Anthony, Lindsay
said

The truth is that nobody can do much about coming recession. But having comrade Ignatieff calling shots will most likely make things worse. After all the economy reaction to whatever government does comes with a delay and the liberals in the 90s enjoyed what was sown by the previous governments and today we face the consequences of the liberal policies.


VagnF
said

Economic turmoil? The unemployment is still the lowest it has been in 30 years! The conservatives are posting a surplus this year... where is the scary agenda Dion? If it wasn't for Toronto's blind support for the Liberals they would be looking at a wipe this election.


R/H Ontario
said

Actually Mr Ignatieff, Canadians must be fooled by Mr Harper! Look at the polls! Does that indicate that the Liberals are going to form a Government? I don't think so and neither do a LOT of other Canadians. Sorry but your adopted party needs a good shake up and you could start by getting rid of all the Old School lot from years gone by. That way maybe, just maybe the Liberals will rise again to some sort of party that people can support.


Laurie from Mosse Jaw
said

Lowering taxes and paying 40 Billion off the National Debt seems to be against the fiberal ethos. It is not only dion that is a joke, the whole fiberal party is dangerous. The only thing keeping Canada off the skids like the American economy is the sound Conservative fiscal responsibility shown by Prime Minister Harper.


Max
said

I firnly believe that Mr Harper will win this election. The Billions that the Liberals and NDP are promising is unthinkable at a time when the global economy is tanking.
Dion behaves like a bobble head who can't make up his mind on anything and Canadians are to smart for his scare tatics.
His Carbon Tax will Break alot of people. Don't get sucked in by this man,
Vote Harper and lets be proud of Canada.


Rick in Calgary
said

What in the world is the Liberal party smoking? In the last 13 years, none of their policies have been economical. They were just very fortunate to be in power while there was an economic up swing and they were able to spend their way to election wins.

I keep hearing that tough economical times are when the Conservatives are in power. Exactly, we do not want power drunken socialites running the country spending our money, like they won the lottery. We rather have smart, reasonable and a somewhat frugal person managing our funds during tough times.

I also know why the Liberals are afraid of Harper.....He says "NO" to things that conservatives feels are a waste of money and will not benefit the greater majority of people, and this is scary when you make your money from grants (even if it is only $20,000) drawing stick men or making a documentary about the merits of being a drug addict.

One last thing on this story……Liberals are always saying that Harper is Bush’s puppet, well Michael Ignatieff is already in the lime light more than Dion, what does that tell you about your leader. NOT A LEADER……JUST A PUPPET for the Liberal party elites……pretty sure they offered up Dion as a lamb because they have no money to run their party and needed a few years to restructure. The Liberals where so arrogant that they thought the Conservatives could never do a good job and Canadians would never give them a majority.

Whoops……enjoy being out of power for the next decade.




Edb
said

Crash the economy, a handgun for every man, women, child, dog, cat, privatize health care, force everyone to go to church, repeal the law giving women the vote. Have I left anything out?
Now you're really becoming a comedy act Ignatieff. Go back to your little fantasy bubble on some US college campus.


Rob
said

Ignatieff is a pompous, self centered and arrogant jerk that keeps on giving the same fear mongering message. It is this attitude, the attitude that "We are the Natural Governing Party of Canada" that is killing the Liberals. Canadian cannot be fooled again.


James Eh!
said

GFT from NB
How is the "Green Shift" doing these days?

At least the Liberal $40/Tonne with tax cuts platform is there for all to see.

What about the Conservative $65/tonne "Turning the Corner" plan? Its on the Environment Canada website, but the CPC haven't exactly been giving it the push. At $65/tonne, I wonder why? Could it be that they know prices will increase even more under their plan?


Shamaro
said

Of course they are going to say that Canada is doomed if the Conservatives get in.

Has anyone seen what is happening to the Liberals under Stephan Dion?

I'm sure he is a smart man, but he's way too left for me and as far as the Liberals are concerned, they had their chance in power to do all the things Harper is doing, but they chose not to do them.

I always use to vote for Liberal, but Harper has a Plan (not a hidden agenda)that is out in the open and for everyone to see.

If you want big government, big taxes, little economic growth during these very trying times, then vote for Dion or Layton. But if you want the best guy in there for when the economy needs a strong leader and who isn't afraid to make decisions, then Harper is our best choice.


bunny
said

could barely write this comment because I was laughing too hard at the ridiculous things coming our of Mr Ignatieff's mouth. He says Mr. Harper cannot manage our economy while his party cheated and lied themselves out of power the last time....and all the spending promised in this election makes no sense when considered in our present economic climate. Don't vote Liberal if you want a future.


Paul Chilliwack.
said

One thing I can say, as a firearms owner, I will not forget the LIBERALS. They stepped on my rights and have done nothing to stop the criminals.

I will not forget the LIBERALS on voting day, the conservatives have the right idea, punish the criminals not honest citizens.

As for the scaremongering, typical LIBERAL lies.


PM
said

For the first time, in many years Canadians are faced with a tough decision. Elect a liberal who cares about Canada or a conservative whom has repeatedly lies to Canadians and tries to pull the wool over our eyes.



Bill
said

Halloween is coming.

More scare tactics and lies from the Liberals. Middle? With all those spending promises and brand new carbon tax so we can't afford to drive to work? Not even close.

People are starting to realize...the Conservatives aren't the scary ones.

People are starting to realize...the Conservatives show all their plans and keep their promises...but the Liberals are the ones with the masks.


Glenn - Cochrane Ab.
said

I guess the only way the Liberals can get any attention is to yell 'Fire'. If it wasn't so serious it would be laughable.
In tough times we need doers not sayers. Now look who's scarey, and Jack you're really scarey.


alan
said

cut taxes....dion wants to raise taxes.....interesting....what page are you on mr ignatieff


Rick W
said

It does not matter who gets in, there is always problems and there will always be backstabbing and because of that I chose Harper because he knows what is REALLY happening in the world and is not afraid to tackle it head on and as I said I am for him and I will watch his back because I know he is watching MINE!!!!!


K D
said

Everyone, keep in mind that the liberals aren't running an election campaign for this Oct. 14. They are setting themselves up for winning a majority in 4 years time with Ignatieff or Rae as leader. They are going to forecast doom and gloom because of the worldwide economic downturn then point to their published forecast as proof that they should have been leaders.


Steve in Fredericton
said

It does my heart good to see that most of the responders to this story cleary recognize the Liberals for what they truely are; an impediment to good governance and fiscal responsibility.

My crystal ball is telling me there will a host of Liberal floor-crossers on 15 Oct as they bail off their sinking party. Iggy will likely be leading the way once he realizes that Bob Rae is the hier apparant.


Shawn Bull
said

It's over for the Liberals. The only question now is how big will the Conservative majority be after the English debates.

I am thinking
CPC 180
Liberal: 60
NDP 35
Bloc:35


George in Winnipeg
said

Mr. Harper and his government are cut from the same cloth as those who created the economic crisis in the U.S. They are not going to be good managers of
our economy.


Jesse James9764
said

LOL LOL!! I wonder why the talking heads of iggy and the former minister of nothing haven't tried their vaudeville show somewhere like Calgary or Vancouver? Probably because they'd be thrown in the stocks and get rotten tomatoes thrown at them. A center party phttt! they're so far out in left field they've forgotten where home plate is!


David Dunlop
said

A surplus is nothing more than too much tax. After two years of Conservative government we have set the tax free day back by 11 days, paid off 40 Billion of our national debt and yes, the surplus has been reduced by about 10 billion, thank goodness it has. We all know what John McCallum did for the Canadian military, do we really want him in control of the country's finances while standing beside Bob Rae?


Brian S
said

I used to vote Liberal. These type of over-the-top shrill comments by Iggy and McCallum is why I am proud to be voting for Mr. Harper this time. The Liberals are no longer the party I used to vote for. They have become an extreme left-wing party that cannot be trusted.


Bob,Alberta
said

I don't know how it will turn out in the end but it is a beautiful sight watching the Liberals squirm. This bunch of self absorbed individuals who care very little about Canada or Canadians is slowly being pushed into irrelevance. The Liberals have held Canada back for many,many years with their tax and spend policies, their social engineering and playing off provinces against each other.It is amazing that they still think they have some unalienable right to rule the country. In times of economic turmoil they still believe they can spend their way out.Tough times are ahead and we need a Prime Minister who is capable, prudent and can make decisions. With the Liberals we get some intelltual who whines and cries if he is questioned. With the NDP we get a bunch of leftist loonies who would destroy Canadian businesses by taxing them out of existence. If their is any reluctance on the part of Canadians to vote Conservative I can't really see why. Harper deserves a majority so he can get on with the business of running the country properly.


Johnnie Oil (Alberta)
said

ha ha ha , give me a break! What a Joke!!
he should remember it was his liberal party that cut $25billion in health care transfers to the provinces, then made EI harder to get and when you got it was for less time and for less money, then they raised the cost of EI to both employees and employers and just dumped the extra revenue into the general pot! The liberal money pilosophy is still the same and would be the absolute worst gov't to have now! Wait let's add the green shaft tax and then increase the GST - then it will be the perfect liberal storm that would lead us to very hard economic times!!


Hanley
said

Harper studied Economy in university...that doesn't necessarily mean he is an expert economist...even the economists scratch their heads on his decisions.

Wake up people....if you're middle class now, you won't be if Harper gets in!


Keith
said

I just love these comments folks !Nice to see that nobody is buying into this... :)Mr Harper has my vote as well.


Gid'day
said

Iggy's rant and you callum's mental wanderings should show the Liberals they have problems. Unfortunately, so do Canadians.

Scenerio: Con = 180-200 seats, NDP = 60 seats, Lib = 50 seats, others = balance.

Jack is opp leader under this, and Liberals are almost? financially bankrupt. NDP will then almost certainly form the government within a dozen years. Here comes another Rae's Ontario!!

As a senior, maybe I won't see it, but I am sorry for the younger people who will suffer as England did in the mid 40's!


Will
said

All you Liberal bashers out there seem to forget one thing...Mr.Harper might fly the Conservative flag but he is a tried and true Reformist.It seems you people have a very short memory. You also seem to have forgotten about the "wonderful" Mr,Mulroney and what his Conservative party did to Canada. Wake up people!!!1


Barry in Saskabush
said

Any body else notice how the Liberals are now so ready to talk about anything BUT their green shaft? Lots of promises about other stuff, but what had been the main plank in their platform is now almost obliterated from their talk... unless someone else asks them about it. If they themselves don't have enough confidence in their main platform plank so as to be out there honking a horn in its favor - why should we vote for them and let them have a chance at inplimenting their nonesense? I dare you Liberals... go out and honk your horn in favor of your main policy initiative - I so much like seeing the red line on the political standings graph take a nosedive. I dare you! I bet you won't do it - but then again... maybe Liberals really intend to stay locked into suicide mode these days. Amazing how ANYBODY would waste a perfectly good vote on them.


Vancouver Girl
said

If I have to hear about Harper's sweater one more time, I might scream! Is that the best the liberals can do?


Mark in NB
said

I've met Ignatieff and he seemed to be so full of himself it was oozing out of the room.

I've met Dion. Like someone said a great person but not leadership material.

When (I say when as it is certain at this point) the Liberals do not win a minority or a majority government if Ignatieff becomes the leader I will not vote Liberal. (I'd rather have McCallum as leader. At least he doesn't sound like he's full of himself.)

At this point I am thinking of voting Green as they get some funding to see if they are really worth it and the conservatives don't get anymore than they already have.


Paul R. Martin
said

Our unemployment rate has remained stable while the Us unemployment rate has risen sharply.Manufacturing employment has declined due to productivity improvemrnts and a decline in US demand for cars. Do Dion and Ignatief realize that there is nothing that a Canadian government can do to stimulate US consumer demand? They kind of remind me of King Canute.


Mutt
said

Desperation! Cling to power at what ever cost, even it's second place. Thank God that most Canadians can see through this fear mongering. Ignatieff should be ashamed of himself. After Dion crashes and burns, Mr. Ignatieff (nutty Enough) better choose his words more carefully. This is not leadership. Crying fire in a crowded theatre is offensive, however it pales in comparison to his remarks. Leadership on all accounts, thats why Mr. Harper is getting my vote.


James
said

Politicians are like diapers. They both need changing regularly and for the same reason.


Brian from Winnipeg
said

The fact that the Liberal party thinks Canadians are dumb enough to blame Harper for the economic problems of the World, shows that they are willing to say anything to try and win. Canada's economic woes are a result of a failing World economy. We depend on other economies as they buy our goods.


nc in alberta
said

In my opinion Harper's only real enemy in this election is his own past and the people that he chooses to surround himself with in the present.

It is only because the opposition is very weak that his numbers are as high as they are.

Many true centrists like myself (both "red tories" and "blue liberals" if you recall the terminology of day gone by) just don't believe that he has changed his ideas to the extent he is attempting to portray.

This is not hysterical screaming about "hidden agendas" it is just that I and many others don't yet believe Harper truly embraces centrist values.

He is an intelligent person and so knows what he can and cannot say in order to convince Canadians but many of us are suspicious that this does not mean he will continue to support centrist ideas in the long run especially if he achieves a majority.

If this lack of trust was not so prevalent, the weakness of the opposition would have him easily in majority territory.

This failing is his own doing since you can't take back either your actions or words of the past no matter how hard you try.

It is even more difficult to shake a past impression if you continue to embrace collegues that have not renounced a more extreme ideology.


Jeff
said

Will you wrote:

All you Liberal bashers out there seem to forget one thing...Mr.Harper might fly the Conservative flag but he is a tried and true Reformist.It seems you people have a very short memory. You also seem to have forgotten about the "wonderful" Mr,Mulroney and what his Conservative party did to Canada. Wake up people!!!1

Look what BOB RAE did to Ontario when he was premier.



Grant Stoddard
said

For some reason, people are always quick to blame liberals for attacking opponents in desperate times. Seems they forget that conservative's run attack ads from the very beginning of the campaign... To be honest, nobody is worth voting for, they all care about slandering the other guy. If I wanna know the liberal platform, I just have to watch a conservative ad. It's nice having a multi-party system, but this isn't working. I say they all need to change before they get my vote.


Fayclis
said

This is the same guy who said a couple of years ago he would move into the Etobicoke-Lakeshore riding in which he was parachuted (and he writes a book about democracy?) I heard him say he would move here myself at a candidates meeting. Imagine my HUGE disappointment when shortly AFTER I heard he bought a condo in D/T Toronto. Well, he either lied to us or dosen't even know where his own riding is. How can he now expect me to believe anything he says.


Prof. Pye Chartt
said

Talk about desperation. Unable to speak for himself (even though he's Leader), Dion employs the elitist and alarmist rhetoric of the same guy (Ignatieff) who's gunning for his fleeting job.

When your sense of political entitlement is as pompous and arrogant as the Liberals, and your election platform is built out of cardboard, I guess you don't have a lot of choice.


bill in Halifax
said

I cannot see a Liberal Dion leader run parliment. How may times since Dion did the Liberals abstain when it came to voting on issues in the house?
He may be a nice guy but I think it takes great leadership to run a country and Dion just don't cut it.


Optimistic and Canadian
said

Talk about a bunch of paranoid Liberals. Are they ever optimistic about anything? I don't think I could stand the doom and gloom if they are ever elected to power.

They make it sound like Harper doesn't hold a primary Canadian citizenship.


Logan
said

Will...

No disrespect man, but if you think the Conservatives are bad, I think you should take a look at the dismal performance the Liberals put on.

The liberals kept our tax rate at 15% (8% GST - 7% PST ) . This was supposed to only be to balance the deficit back in the 80's. The deficit was cleared in the 90's, but the Liberals still kept it at 15% because it meant more money in their pockets.

The Conservatives of today have been slowly decreasing it. Wiping it out altogether would be a double-edged sword, because it would mean a huge fallout in the budget, which means cuts to much needed programs instantly. This way, by slowly reducing it, the companies have time to adjust as well as the budget plans.

The Liberals went out and spent huge sums of money on broken, ancient submarines that haven't been put into service to THIS DAY. They are still sitting as scrap in the shipyards.

The Conservatives have been balancing the military budget to include up-to-date equipment.

Remember when the Liberals were in power, and we sent soldiers to Afghanistan? Our military was wearing equipment suited for a jungle, not a desert. Even foreign military were laughing at us. It was embarassing.


Anyway, this is just to name a couple of things. I can go on and on.


Bob
said

Why is it that Michael Ignatieff is giving this speech?


Catherine
said

Liberals are desperate, outright lies and scare tactics about Harper is making Dion less wimpy, or the carbon tax shaft more acceptable.

The 30 years Ignatieff lived in the US must have affected his brain if he thinks he's anymore believable.


DRH
said

To Will:
Your joking right? I really like your sarcasm...........I mean you have to be joking. You can't tell me with a straight face that your still playing those old "Reformist/Hiden Agenda/Alliance" cards? Oh, I forgot the Mulroney one? You go right ahead and vote Liberal there sunshine but when the PC Majority hits on Oct 14, You will fade away like your Left of NDP leader. If you read the article, look at the polls and actually listen to Dion, Iggy, Rae etc.....and still want to vote Liberal, you have more problems than you think.


Joyce
said

Liberals are still the fearmongers, looks like they are getting desperate. Seems to me they were the ones who cut and cut when they regained power 1993.
Weren't they the ones who promised one thing and did all the drastic cuts not only did the taxpayers get shafted by large CPP payments and UI Payments and more taxes added, but also the Provinces transfer and Health Payments were drastrically reduced and more, and in turn it was also the Municipalities which got the brunt. The Liberals did us no favours.
Do we have one Liberal Leader or not.
Looks like they are praying hard, but once bit twice shy.


Tom
said

With a 30% support nationally in the last election, yet the party is in heavy debt. Do you want to trust the country's economy with the Liberals?


MR from Mississauga
said

"Economic crisis"? That's it, it's officially, the beginning of the end of the election. The Liberals are desperate and we're now moving into silly season. I'm sure if the Liberals can rub together a couple of nickels after paying their campaign jet repair bills, we'll see some similarly desperate and negative ads soon. Say good night Stephane.


Andrew
said

Didn't the Liberals also tell us if the Conservatives won the last election we would have armed soilers in our streets? Gun. In. Our. Streets? Guns.

Who's doing the fear mongering?


Diggy (Vancouver)
said

The Liberals are so pathetic and these remarks are, frankly, quite insulting. They have such a sense of entitlement that its pathetic. People, remember the sponsorship scandel and the stripper visa program scandel that were started by the Liberals. These people are a disgrace!


Geof
said

To Will,

We conservatives, and a good portion of the country, have woken up and smelled the coffee, but from your comments, it appears you're very groggy, perhaps you need to have a rest--perhaps a good four years.


Davey boy
said

You want to see 2 crooked politicians which pretty much know nothing about everything. Look no further than McCallum and Ignatieff.


Anthony
said

Liberal party arrogrance is truly over the top in this election. Liberal values are NOT Canadian values. Canadian values are Canadian values. People of different political stripes and backgrounds helped form what is today's Canada. The gross hyperbole from the Liberals is why I have left them permanently and for the foreseeable future, I will NOT vote Liberal


Gail in Halifax
said

I have voted Liberal in every election since I turned 18. When Stephane Dion announced his Green Tax plan my reaction was "my God, he's a sleeper agent for the Conservatives - he's just guaranteed that Harper will win the next election." From the comments here, that is exactly what will come to pass. And I can't say I blame any of you. For the first time in my life I have no idea whatsoever who to vote for. I disagree with Harper/Conservative ideology yet I cannot bring myself to vote for someone who has gotten into bed with the NDP & Green Party, and whose Green Plan is the equivalent of a political gun to his own head. I truly believe a minority Conservative government is the way to go, but I can't imagine that enough Canadians will vote Liberal for that to happen. Think carefully Canada.


Keri in GTA
said

PLEASE sir, if the Liberals represent the 'centre' then please explain to me how Buzz Hargrove can be quoted in the Toronto Star this month as saying something to the effect of how he is a socialist without a home but he believes the Liberals are now as socialist as the NDP. I couldn't agree more!


George
said

People are you wearing blinders or are your comments more Conservative scare tactics.

Neither Dion nor Ignatieff has ever said that Harper is the cause of the global financial crisis. What they have said, very clearly, is that Harper is not the man to take us through this difficult time. He already took Canada into deficit during the spring.

Why do you think he took a chance and called the election, after promising to wait? He knew the direction we were heading.

And do not forget the Conservative plan calls for carbon at $65 per ton. If the Liberal plan for $40 is going to bring the economy down, I wonder what effect $65 will have.

They haven't bothered to say anything about that. Of course they haven't even announced a full platform.

Call it Liberal scare tactics if you want, but at least show us the full deck before we let you play the game.


hollinm
said

No where does Iggy say what the Liberals would do differently than the Conservatives, what the impact of the carbon tax would be on the economy as a whole, no where does he say where the $12 billion in reallocations is going to come from i.e. higher taxes, cut programs or deficit. No where does he say the Liberals have a dud leader who cannot communicate effectively with the majority of the population. Remember it is the leader who makes the ultimate decisions. Dion knows nothing about economics and so electing the Liberals would put Canada into a significant economic crisis to borrw Iggy's over the top rhetoric.


Bob McGrath
said

While I don't disagree that the Arts DO need stimulation, far, far better to put $15 Million into Health Care and/or Seniors Care.


Ed Lenarcic, Toronto
said

When Iggy first ran (in my riding) I was appalled when I heard him on a CITY-TV talk show. He actually answered questions! Didn't he know politicians are supposed to avoid questions, or at least feign interest while promising to make a high priority study? Then he put his foot in his mouth a few times during his leadership run.

Well, he's now obviously had some serious coaching, as he sounds just like any other politician reading nonsense from a predictable and unoriginal script.

He may do well after all.


TrangQuynh
said

Such a good idea. Why the Fiberals could not think of something like during their 13 years? Please stop giving away our tax money to those left-wing CBC gangs.


Vince M
said

Don't know if I'd believe the Fiberals on anything - this is what Sheila Copps said on Question Period yesterday - and she kept a straight face...

"Obviously we have the strongest environmental record of any of the political parties.."


Gail (Hamilton)
said

Please spare us from all these ridiculous rants. A natural governing party with complete control from Ottawa sounds eerily familiar.

The Conservatives have at least allowed the provinces their own control and responsibility. The premiers deserve to be treated like adults and not paternally governed by a so-called higher authority. I can't wait for a Conservative majority. A democratic government sets the rules/regulations and lets the energy technology companies do the innovation necessary to take us off our dependence on oil, with oversight.

At least the Conservatives aren't manipulated by special interest groups.


Andrew Koornstra
said

I believe that Harper has shown that he is a leader and a man that truly can be trusted. The liberals should have given Harper more credit with they elected Dion to be their leader. I personally believe Dion loves the nation of Canada but does not have the leadership skill to be prime minister.


Karen J Cao
said

the difference here is that Dion is working, i.e. compromising and working together with other parities, i.e. a leader's courtesy to the green leader (how else did you think Harper got elected? LEADERS' COURTESY FROM ALL OTHER PARTIES),

except all the current other political parties see it as wrong.. why? they've been in politics too long, too partisan, and forgot that minorities have to work together -- Harper has the guts to frame Dion as a nutty professor when he himself has been either a politican or a lecturer @ U of Calgary for his ENTIRE ADULT LIFE... so NO, he is NOT the middle class dad he portrays himself to be, when he is running for a position that that comes with a tax-funded mansion and an entire domestic staff... stop the negative politics, vote for their policies

and Harper's own government-commissioned report proves that a carbon tax of $50 will NOT CAUSE A RECESSION, so STOP LYING - outright lying to Canadians, if we truly lived in a market economy, then pollution should be priced to reflect the real cost of products... then again, Harper once called Canada a socialist backwater... hmm guess its okay to spend billions on the military and jails, but not on education, health and the environment... it goes both ways --- why do Conservatives always run deficits despite cutting spending? Spending on social programs btw are now at its lowest since 1950s, so again, NO we're NOT "SPENDING TOO MUCH" -- don't trivialize real arguments to left and right, can we not be adults and look at the real facts here?


Rob
said

ABC, ABC, that is all I hear in Atlantic Canada, and I even hear from Tory insiders working on campaigns they are told they will gain 1 Quebec seat, so wake up Ont and BC don't give this guy a majority, the planet and my RRSP and our economy can not afford it.


matchuk
said

It's obvious the CONS know nothing of leadership. At least Dion is allowing his people to speak for themselves. THIS is team work (at least in theory) unlike the dic (sorry Steve) who wants to muzzle his members. This is leadership? I guess Ritz (the cracker) and Jackson didn't get the memo.Or is Steve afraid to find out what his members really think of him?

As for those CONS who haven't read the principles about the Green Shift, read the article in Saturday's Star about carbon tax. Sorry talking to CONS again. Have someone read it for you. Not many pictures either and some of the words maybe difficult to understand.


Carl99
said

Wow.... this Liberal is a Genius or he has a crystal ball that he borrowed from the the Geniuses of Wall Street that put all there money on sub-prime mortgages.I guess that he has never heard the saying of "When the U.S sneezes Canada catches a cold".If the U.S Goes into deep recession there is no Party or Canadian that can stop Canada from being dragged down with them.

What's the definition for a Politician.

POLECAT- small brownish-black mammal of the weasel family.




Nick in Gatineau
said

Smart government saves for a rainy day. The Harper government blew those savings on the bright sunny days while the darkest clouds were rolling in - and they saw it coming way before any of us did.

Harper is banking on the fact that Canadians are not informed and for the majority, he's right, they are not. Most Canadians don't know how government works; Harper still has alot to learn and he's the PM.

Just go the your local hockey rink and ask any regular joe how this mortgage stuff affects him. Odds are he'll say he doesn't know or doesn't care. Canadians just want to know if their taxes are going up or down so it doesn't matter what the politicians throw in between.

If these guys are serious about fixing this economy:

1. Remove the taxes from Income trusts.
2. Limit private credit cards (Canadian Tire, Home Depot, Citifinancial, etc...)to 15 % instead of 28 %
3. Limit registered credit cards (Visa, MC, Amex, etc...) to Prime + 5%.
4. Establish a national database which automatically decline any credit request for people who have 3 or 4 maxed-out credit cards. 5.Set Mortgage rates at Prime + 2 % with a 0.5 cushion, 2nd tier mortgage established at same rates are Registered Credit cards and 3rd tier mortgages at 15 %.
6. Lower Usury laws from 60 to 50 %, 40 if you can. (Makes corporations more accountable)
6. Create jails for CEOs and CFOs who take part in naked shorting, insider trading and stock manipulation. No more of these $ 1 million fines and they still get to keep the $ 100 million they stole.
7. Stop the banking fees to 1 fee a year. All other fees would be for additional products purchases.
8. All stock dividends tax-free : except for Corporate-owned stocks (re-invest those in company).


mikey
said

Great!! Kids will be getting into arts... but with all the other cuts to the arts programs from the conservatives... where will they be practicing this in the future??? America??? BAND-AID!!! watch the mask pulled over your head!!


Ian- Alberta
said

I see alot of people are still saying the Green party is a left wing party. They must be forgetting that Elizabeth May was the environmental advisor for Brian Mulroney. I guess Brian Mulroney is a liberal now... too bad history will prove those wrong who think this.. but oh well. Hey far right Harper supporters hows your economic philosophies doing south of the border?? Americans doing well under a conservative far right government??? Why in the creator's name anyone would want to vote Reform is beyond me... do you not want to have a job? Vote true tory.. Vote Green


M
said

Ok??? So cut the funds for the professionals who the kids look up to??? and give it back to the kids?? Thats like having a fantastic Hockey system in Canada but yet no professional league for the kids to aspire too?? Remember the cart trails behind the horse!! Silly conservative!


Mike S.
said

To get kids interested in arts that have been slashed in funding... That makes perfect sense. Good job Harper.


Ray
said

I will most likely vote liberal this election because I am scare of having a conservative party with a majority... WE ARE 3 WEEKS INTO THIS CAMPAIGN AND THE CONSERVATIVES HAVE NO AND I REPEAT NO PLATFORM TO SHOW! What do the CONSERVATIVES have to hide? I cannot believe the people who would vote for them and follow them blindly!


Bill
said

WOW something for kids from the harper Conservatives ! Will wonders never cease?
This is more promises to buy Quebec votes. Instead of a real platform (which the Conservatives are way overdue to release) we get these piecemeal promises that come out knee jerk style depending on Harper's whim of the day. This is not leadership.
I like the NDP platform particularly the idea of NOT giving huge tax breaks to large companies that just ship Canadian jobs out of the country so that Canadians are not given the work. Mr. Layton's idea of rewarding companies that keep the jobs for Canadians who work here in Canada makes much more sense.
Overall there is much in the NDP platform that makes a lot of sense.
Now the question is is Harper even going to release a platform???
Or do the Conservatives expect Canadians to just trust Harper with a blank cheque ?
The Conservatives since they are incumbents are way overdue to release a full and transparent platform and come clean with Canadians.
Or will this unrevealed agenda of the Harper Conservatives become another Tory "secret" ? The time for Harper and the Conservatives to reveal their real intentions in a real Platform that is costed, is NOW.


obscured_reality
said

HAHAHAHA

Harper and his "principled" leadership. What happened to people not liking gala's?


connie
said

Harper has so much turned into a Liberal. So much so I don't know why his servants criticize them.


JPC
said

The Conservatives are no more responsible for this down turn than the Liberals were for years of a good economy. World economies flucuate, the important thing is to manage properly when those hills and valleys arrive. The Liberals managed huge financial windfalls by burning the money on themselves and un needed programs. Even in a global downturn the Canadian economy is in relatively good shape thanks to the Conservatives. Blue Team all the way!!


Lorne.
said

Atta boy P.M. Harper..Another tax break for my family.I saved 1000 bucks last year with my tax break for my 2 kids in sports.Another opportunity awaits if they want to get into some arts program.My parents are both pensioners and love your income splitting policy.Dad mentioned he saved 1200 dollars.P.M. Harper is truly a guy who thinks about the average canadian.


It`s an illuuuuuuusion!
said

Mr. Ignatieff is showing up very frequently, this illusion of "teamwork" and "2 heads are better than 1" approach is nothing more than the liberals phasing in a new leader before Dion gets slammed in the polls, we`ll being seeing much more of him.


gertrude
said

Stephane Dion is right. With a Harper government we'll end up praying that nothing bad happens. With a Liberal government, there will promotion, incentive, action, and hope. With a Harper government, we'll have a legacy of broken promises. Stephane Dion has integrity, has an intelligent and strong team, has a caring nature and the smarts to integrate social, environmental and economic concerns productively. We need smarts and inspiration to get through hard times, not bullying and selfish investing (the oil conglomerates.)for only some sectors of society as Harper would have it.


Nick in Gatineau
said

Has anyone ever thought of handing out incentives to people who don't have kids rather than to hand out benefits to those who already have kids ? Might get people to start having kids again ?






matchuk
said

Steve the hypocrite. Giving a credit for those in the arts. Talk about trying to buy votes. I know the Quebec voters are smarter than HE thinks they are. Shame. Isn't he the one who believes artists are elitists? Maybe we can ALL use tax payers money to become elitists and attend galas. Hold it a minute he plays the piano doesn't he? Maybe a credit for him too? Think about it.


Maya -- Montreal
said

I applaud Michael Ignatieff’s call for an “all hands on deck” approach to the Canadian economy. Addressing the challenges faced by us as Canadians through the present economic situation demands a strong government that works as a team to uphold the interests of all Canadians, not one with a penchant to cutting costs left, right, and centre, as Harper’s government has clearly demonstrated its willingness to do.


HARPER HATER
said

He's using kids now that he feels bad.


harrrrpooorrr
said

Is anyone else sick of seeing harper contradict himself....one minute he's anti-arts , next minute he's photo op'in a boy n cello..

FAAAKKEEEE

Wait maybe he'll pull a mccain and bring out his vanna white out of a magic hat trick!



constance
said

You just never end, since you first came into power your methods are always about buying people, promoting hatred, and breaking promises. You are spiritually flat, ethically microscopic...Steve.


Suzanne
said

Arts Tax Cut!! Another example of improvised, last minute, super great treat announced to lure Canadian votes.

When will all politicians stop belittling the intelligence of all Canadian citizens? Give us substance, not lies to chose a real leader that wishes to govern. Stop this nonsense, show us your plans in a concise and clear manner so that we chose with knowledge and trust in what you say you will do. Stop improvising just to change things to fit the polls.


Shawn
said

Harper's tax credit idea for children in the arts makes far more sense than the cancelled program.


Ed
said

To all you lefties and hate Harper ones - I was a CCF/NDP for 45 years till I heard Preston Manning speak - yes a REFORMER who made sense after living with 3 national tired out old parties going nowhere. Shake your heads and see the facts as they are not as you want them to be. Hate mongers get a life.


Dennis - Sudbury, Ontario
said

One party gives millions of dollars to arts organizations and groups, the other has a proposal that lowers tax costs for parents of children that partiipate in the arts. Now tell me which party is which, what policy makes more sense, and who benifits the most from either policy.

Affordable, prudent, and responsible. That is what I'm voting for.


Don from Ottawa
said

Please, Iggy, we all know you're just posturing for the next Liberal leadership race. If you really want to be Prime Minister some day, stop using "right wing" as a dirty word, in fact stop using labels in general. Try intelligent debate instead. Stephen Harper does this very well, which is why he gets my vote and you do not.


Chuck M
said

Is there anyone besides me who believes Gerrard Kennedy is an NDP operative who has infiltrated the Liberal Party?

Ignatieff should keep Dion on as a policy writer. Dion is exceptionally talented. Rae can take on the type of role Peter Van Loan & Jason Kenney play for the cons -- someone has to do it and Goodale has insufficient restraint.

In the meantime, I welcome the emergency organization of a 4-party coalition to:
1) paralyze Harper's plans for healthcare deregulation.
2) force the issue of poverty/homelessness to the fore.

I've seen ENOUGH protesting. I want to see calculated & unified action from the centre-&-left before Canada becomes unrecognizable. I really don't care who the leader is or which party leads the emergency coalition. We can't afford to keep "leaders" who only succeed in protesting.

I've been saying this for months: The left-&-centre will need to be more cold & calculated to defeat Harper. This is not a contradiction of small-L liberal values; rather, it is a paradox we need to embrace.


Lowell
said

First Harper insults Canadians by telling them that any interest they might have in the arts is a total waste of time and money. Then when he finds out that Quebecers are indeed very appreciative of the arts, he does an about aface and tries to buy votes from them. Is this the kind of man you want as a prime minister. Does the word sleazy come to mind? Lets vote for anyone but Harper.


cosmo
said

Wow! You know the NDP-Lite Party is running scared when the party leader shuts up and lets Ignatieff spout absolute nonsense (I am assuming that the average voter knows he is lying thru his teeth). I agree with the post that noted the Liberals have become another wing of the NDP. In fact, concerning the TV debates, it seems as though the Conservatives are having to debate 3 left-wing socialist parties: The Liberals (who I will vote against for the first time in my life), the NDP (does ANYONE believe their ads' messages - maybe if you live in a vacuum and believe everything you hear), and the nuttiest of them all - the wing-nut party AKA the Green Party. If the Green party wants any credibility with reasonable Canadian voters, they will need a leader who doesn't sink the party's chances every time she opens her mouth.


Socialism is killing us
said

Can you feel the love, the tolerance, the inclusiveness of the Liberal supporters? What a bunch of hate filled, spitefull people. Pathetic really. Why should we support the arts? If the arts can't support itself, too bad. As Dalton Lying McGuinty stated last week, the arts is a $20 billion part of the Ontario economy. If the arts can't live off that, it's a sad state of affairs.


geebee
said

It's a vast improvement over
the gravy train that has been plying the Ont. Quebec corridor
for decades with huge bags of cash tossed to lackluster artists at every whistle stop.


M.B.M./Ontario
said

What Ignatief knows about Canada, Candian Economy & Policies, When he just came back to Canada? He have been out of the country for 25 years. I believe he doesn't have a clue.


Karen
said

Mr. Backtrack... Mr. Do What the Polls Say... does it again.

When the Green Shift was announced, Dion clearly said there would be some changes. Harper never mentioned changes when he presented his arts cuts. But he is desperate in Quebec, so he will do anything to get the vote.

Did you read the article about Harper being a no-show on the poverty video? I suppose, if you don't have a plan, there's no sense showing up to discuss the problem.

Harper doesn't care about the poor in Canada or anywhere else.

You noticed the big announcement in the last election about more international aid. Hopefully, you know our aid went down.

One more sign of what is to come if these neocons should get a majority. Money for guns, but not food.


Les
said

A tax credit encourages low to middle income families to get their kids involved in the arts. This is much better than giving handouts to special interest groups, especially during these tough economic times.


George Booth
said

Despite being a majority government,Harper has kept his promises.
Dions plan to put in a carbon tax, would literlly wipe the funds of of all fixed income families trying to survive, who already face a hard choice between lodging, food or heat, which includes the senoirs and the disabled like myself and we don't get a cost of living allowance to compensate with high costs. Layton has had some good ideas, but his tarck record for family values is also untrustorthy. The Bloc, has done nothing to ensure billinqual signs when travelling through Quebec.

Lets face the facts, all liberal goverments both federal and provincial has had proven, money sponserships scandals, some NDP have endorsed Liberal ways, and the conservatives have done there best to fight for family values, but they need a majority to go further.
The ball is in Mr.Harper's court.
All that I ask ius that you continue to fight for us, and to also help us al who are low income, to have more funding and some sort of drug programme.
Also,do something to keeps outsiders from coming in, and shutting down Canadian companies after a take over.
And the worker needs to have their money before the creditors, if a company does shut down, as they are the back bone, of the company.
My first vote at fifty was for the conservatives, and I will continue, so come to ur aid.
s

Jaid in Toronto
said

Looking over the comments, it's the same text being spewed out.

This $150 million incentive is actually part of Chretien's playbook.

It's called the mini-budget. If the tricks works, guess what. That's another nail in the Liberal coffin.

Harper has been playing his cards correctly compared to many others. You talk to people and not depend on the polls and votes and Harper is emerging more often.

One can say, he broke so many promises. So what? At least you get to know what's broken rather than hearing the "good news" report of other parties when there is in fact a lot more underground stuff happening.

Remember the "I will get rid of the GST"?

I sure did, it was simply kept quiet hoping nobody ever knew what happened and things went along "happily ever after."

While you may not have access to each party's playbook, you can review their plays.


Mike S
said

If the liberals are expert on cutting health care, how come there was more money received by the hostpitals when the liberals where in power then Harper has been given in the last 3 years?


Roger T
said

tax credits or any type of credits are a form of delays to tax payers/consumers. If you are going to give credits, give it upfront. There is no point of postoning the refund while you can get it upfront.

The other point of tax credits is to make it seem like you're getting back something but in reality you are really not because you've already paid into it.




Mark - Fort Erie Ont.
said

My son is taking piano , and my daughter is taking dance classes. This is fantastic! I can now get tax breaks for culturing my children the way I want. No more of my tax dollars for smut and soft porn.


Phil in Ontario
said

I read these posts every day and All here are liberals are bad liberals are to blame Harpers is the best..People of the arts get out of my pocket. here is Mr Harper now changing is tune and is willing to give credit to art programs in Quebec. When are people going to see that he will say and do everything to get re elected. Mr REFORM party who blasted the liberals for giving into Quebec is doing the samething. Where is the the rest of the Conservative party members. Oh yes out of sight out of mind. Because Mr harper like to control everything and everyone. I never trusted Mr Harper when he was leading the Reform party and I still don;t trust him leading the conservative (REFORM) party


Outrageous and mean statements by the Liberals
said

"The Liberals use to be in the middle but they are really on the left this election. Has anyone ever notice when the Libs are loosing they come up with the most outrageous statements - and for a party that has been whining all this election about personal attacks - they sure have been saying a lot of mean stuff about PM Harper. Really personal attacks. The Conservatives are the only party that can run this country properly."

I agree 100% and the only thing I would add is this Liberal sponsored Harper bashing is ethically and morally wrong because along with the improper character assinations ate intentionally misleading statements and they know it.
THAT IS WRONG and if we as Canadians want a better government then we had better raise the standards to what we will accept from our political representatives as well as ourselves.

Please get out and vote October 14th and vote your conscience, the policies and not the spin.




Chris in Halifax
said

Whose the leader of the Liberal party this week? Is it Ignatieff's turn? Is it Rae's turn next week? It won't matter what the rotation is after the election when the Liberals lose their status as the official opposition to the NDP. They can all take turns being the leader of the week as they will have a long time to ponder on the back benches.


Bill
said

Harper seems to be releasing his platform by his whim of the day. Instead of having the courage to relaese a real comprehensive and costed platform for Canadians to examine Harper prefers to say what ever he thinks will BUY VOTES on any particular day-this time he's trying to buy back Quebec votes he lost when he cut grants to the arts and culture community manof whom work in Quebec.
I appreciate Jack Layton's NDP releasing their clear, comprehensive, and costed platform for all Canadians to read and ask about. This shows Layton's courage and integrity instead of Harper's style of hiding his agenda and providing no "substance" for us to examine (just expensive "flash").
I like the NDP idea of NOT giving huge tax breaks to large companies that just ship Canadian jobs out of the country so that Canadians are not given the work. Mr. Layton's idea of rewarding companies that keep the jobs for Canadians who work here in Canada makes much more sense.
Overall there is much in this NDP platform that makes alot of sense.

Now is Harper even going to release a platform??? Or do the Conservatives expect Canadians to just trust Harper with a blank cheque ?
The Conservatives since they are incumbents are way overdue to release a full and transparent platform and come clean with Canadians.
Or will this unrevealed agenda of the Harper Conservatives become another Tory "secret" ? The time for Harper and the Conservatives to reveal their real intentions in a real Platform that is costed, is NOW.


Larry
said

$150 million. What a perfect opportunity to introduce children to the arts. One of the better promises of the whole campaign. The conservatives have shown promise in this direction before with support of sports for children.
When children are given opportunities like these, they have a better chance later on in life.
Great idea Mr. Harper.


Lorne was MISLED by the Conservatives
said


..."Another tax break for my family.I saved 1000 bucks last year with my tax break for my 2 kids in sports."

I'm sorry to say you were fooled/misled/lied to by Harper and Flaherty into thinking that you saved $1000 for the fitness tax credit. The most you would have saved is $77.50 per child.

Kids hockey costs pretty close to $1000/child so $77.50 won't exactly help someone who can barely afford to feed their own kids to put them into hockey (soccer maybe)!




RolandGodin
said

En français le parlement sonne comme parle et ment. Translation parle et ment, speak and lying...


Tom Hawley
said

Wake up igi:
You ask,what planet is he from ?
I am going out on a limb and saying earth.And I would hope for many generations to come others will be too.All we need to do is do our part.
It is laughable that most ignore the headline.
"Harper offers tax credits to woo Que.voters".
...All of a sudden Harper is losing Que. partly because of the arts and culture and then bang, here is a bag of money. Speak on the facts or don't speak at all.


Kate in Gatineau
said

Hmmmmmmm...this really doesn't help anyone out there on a low-income and can't afford to send their children to an arts program already unless its subsidized. Has Mr Harper been drinking some of the milk from China??



Dan in Oromocto
said

No more tax breaks for Quebec PORN and more tax breaks for my kids learn culture. Me thinks that the Cons are starting to walk on water!


Pat
said

cuts to pensions..maybe time to ask Mr. Harper if seniors are included in his family value plan... Harper majority getting scarier every day.


Jaid in Toronto
said

@Bill

This isn't a race of who releases their platform the earliest becomes the most courageous leader with LOTS and LOTS of integrity.

As long as you see the platform you can make a choice yourself. As weak as one could think that Harper will simply release his platform before the debate, if opposition tries to blast those during the debate, then everything plays into Harper's hands.

The whiners say how he wants to control everything, those that support say that it's by design.

You choose how to play your cards in politics. Just because you have a full house early doesn't mean that your opponent can get 4 of a kind or better full house.


calgarian
said

Crazy… Canadians are planning to elect the NeoCONS???? These people are mini-republicans! Has anyone paid attention to the mess 8 years of Republicans did to the world economy. NOT ONE RIGHT MOVE, EVER!!!! Harper will be leading us into a downward spiral into a bleak future for my kids. This is scary folks… scary indeed. Better get inline for the soup kitchens.


MM
said

Harper's really gonna screw everyone up.


joe
said

i just do the same as i have done since i was 18. i officially refuse my ballot at the polling station. politicians are nothing but lying thieves all of them. none are trust worthy and none would know the meaning of good morals if it slapped them upside the head. so in closing i hate all political parties.


Sandy
said

Maybe it's the PM getting desperate since he has o platform or plan for that matter and they are now only five pints ahead of the liberals in today's CPAC polls!

The liberals are the only ones wit long term plans that will help the environment and put money in our pockets. They are not defeated yet.


Joel
said

...the first 15 comments only contain 2 liberal posters and the rest are clearly conservatives. How about posting comments with substance from people that criticize the actual article.


Sanguine
said

Piecemeal again, taxes targeted to special niche groups, GST taxes cut when income tax would have been better across the board, funding cuts to food health and safety-19 dead and counting, more food and safety funding cuts to follow. Recall upon recall, now samonella, meat recalls in Atlantic Canada, Conservatives are fiscally irresponsible and dangerous to your health. Doesn't matter who, but as Danny Williams says, ABC, anyone but the Conservatives. They are scary


Vince
said

Oh wow that's great! harper is giving kids a tax credit to study the arts. What a nice guy eh? Oh wait, he's cut funding to the entire sector and he thinks that we're all elitest! Hmmmm that doesn't sound right! Another neo-con idea from the neo-con leader.


Wally
said

Okay, so legitimate and professional artists get cuts to the arts programs, so families can have tax credits for their children. Another example of Harper pandering only to the nuclear family he holds so dear. Not one thing this man has done has offered any help to the millions of Canadians with grown children or without children at all. This is insulting to the highest degree.


Stephen
said

I love how the commenters here howl and complain about tax dollars going to artists (when you also get $4 back into the economy for every dollar spent on arts funding), but you seem to have no trouble about ME paying for YOUR children, who are in no way contributing to the economy. What is the per centage of children who take piano lessons going into it professionally? 1%? Less? Yet I should pay for your children's lessons, like I already pay for your children's education, like I already pay for your maternity leave, for your child tax benefits, etc. You have children, something that ANYONE can do - talent or not, and you think I should pay for it, but not one red cent of yours goes to the arts. Turn off your television. Take the art off your walls. Take the colour out of your house. Tell the landscaper to go home, don't wear anything knit, c'mon, tell me you don't use ANYTHING the arts community produces. Hypocritical beyond belief!


Nick J Boragina
said

Why the hell is he doing this? I dont want my government funding useless "arts". How about funding health care or maybe building a highway or two. You know, things that are actually of some practical use.


Sid in Toronto
said

Harper is backtracking since he has seen the reaction of ordinary Canadians to his comments on the arts last week. Thank you Mr. Ignatieff for reminding us that there is a credible alternative to Steve Harper. Ignatieff is strong, intelligent and credible speaker and can only help Dion in his efforts. It takes a strong team to lead a country - let's not forget the public gaffes committed by current Conservative MPs in recent weeks.


Willy
said

I see the Conservative war-room is having a field day with this. Too bad Ignatieff actually made sense talking about how Harper has run the economy out of his political office. Conservatives haven't the slightest idea about the economy and Harper is just following in the ridiculous tradition.


Ken - Calgary
said

What a hypocrite!!!! Last week, he is denouncing arts funding, and now, in a move of desperation, now he's decided to fund it. More reasons why Harper cannot be trusted. He can't even stick to his own platform if he thinks that doing a flip flop will win him his precious dictatorship.


ABC
said

It's amazing how the number of comments on these stories goes up during the week. I guess it is all those cons. staffers with nothing constructive to do with their time at work!

How about some constructive discussion on the current election rather than rehashing everything that previous governments have done. It's not what have you done but what will you do for us that is important.


Dan
said

Four BIG mistakes made by the Liberals:

1. They elected Dion as leader.
2. May/Dion agreement
3. The Green Shift
4. NDP/Liberal alliance.

These four mistakes shows just how far left the Liberals have gone. They are so far left now that even the center looks right wing.


my take on this
said

Definition of Stephen Harper: a person exercising absolute power, a ruler who has absolute, unrestricted control in a government.

Canada, it will be four long miserable years with a conservative majority.




Currency Arrangement TRIPLED to $30 BILLION
said

"The Bank of Canada said Monday that it and the Federal Reserve have agreed to expand their reciprocal currency arrangement to US$30 billion, up from the US$10 billion announced Sept. 18."

Yup - Economy's in GREAT shape Stevie. I have complete faith in the Economic Dynamic Duo of Harper and Flaherty.

Andrew....Guelph
said

For those who do not watch world events and keep their heads burried in the sand the country south of us is imploding from the same kind of crap Harper wants to give Canadians. Feed the war machine, get tough on crime, build bigger and more jails, give tax breaks to the already very prosperous large corportation, Deja vu, Bush did this and look how well the US doing. Wake up people, turf Harper and his right wing agenda. We do not need a wing winged religious fanatic running Canada, a sexist, racist, God fearing, Bible beleiving do gooder who is on a major power trip.


marbou
said

What a two faced measure! No wonder the Bloc is gaining votes in Quebec.


Jesse
said

Harper (being an economist or ex professor of economics) is the best man for the job at this tough time. There isn't another leader right now who could weather this upcoming storm better than he can. Give the man some credit, we don't have nearly enough trouble that our southern neighbors have. Harper kept spending to a minimum the past couple budgets because he saw a recession coming. Keep him in power and we'll get through this unscathed.


gaye facer, washington
said

Why encourage careers in the arts - the very sector you have abandoned?


Nathan in Calgary
said

To: Andrew....Guelph

It's Obvious to me that your self and others will buy anything anyone tells you as long as it supports your point of view. These comments are void of any REAL credibility. I hope others see past this garbage.

I'm quite sure I've made my decision on who to vote for, But I'll wait until after the debates and NPD/Conservative Platforms have been released.


Harper, the cynical player of political games
said

He cancels funding for arts just before the election, in order to get approval... then promises more arts funding, in order to win back favor of people injured by the previous cancellation. It's no wonder the Conservative government has been on a spending spree, depleting the carefully accumulated surplus that should have been kept for dealing with the upcoming recession.

Canada needs financially responsible government, not this Clownservative Harper.





Tony
said

Let me get this straight: lets pay off a prosperous province in hopes that they will not seperate in the future; meanwhile lets screw over the least wealthy of the Canadian provinces that need to be in Canada.


gerald allard
said

hi,what do you call a candidate who bad mouths arts&culture then promises tax credit to quebecers arts???who could this be,he's been doing it all campaign.
gerald from nb.


al from calgary
said

To Stephen
I don't expect you to pay for my kids I'm willing to pay for them myself but I do pay for my tv, I did pay for the art hanging on my walls, I paid for the paint for my house, I did my own landscaping and I pay for my own clothes, I buy cds and don't download them. He cut parts of the arts that were a waste of taxpayers money but increased it overall so quit your whining, if your work is good enough people will buy it if not find another occupation, because if I open a business and produce things people don't buy, I close it or produce something consumers want not whine to the government to support me because I like to produce things nobody wants.


Dan in Halifax
said

Harper=hypocrite

The handouts are coming at a feverish pace.

I don't trust this guy for one minute.


Marg, Richmond
said

So Mr Ignatieff says the Liberals are in "the center".
Then why is it that they would form a coalition with the NDP & the Green party to stop Harper & the Conservatives??

The next question is, stop Harper from what exactly?

Making the rest of his promises. Did anyone read that he actually fulfilled 50% of his promises, and probably would have fulfilled the rest if it hadn't been for the Liberals & NDP voting against them or "cutting & running" when there was a vote.
Or do they want to stop him from keeping our economy on track when there is a world wide economic crisis???

It seems that the Liberals & the NDP are the scary ones.


Ian C (Calgary)
said

I think the idea of Art credits is wonderful. It is good for families who send their kids for music lessons and it encourages them to continue to do so. I also does not break the bank of the government. If sports can get credits then it is about time we add a bit of music/Arts.This is what I like about the Stephen Harper, he can think.


Layton B in Moncton NB
said

Listen Canada. For the love of God, listen. Harper is a wolf in sheeps clothing. I was a Liberal but doubt I'll vote that way this time around. Dion is not a leader, BUT a Reform Party majority government is a nightmare scenario for Canada. Say goodbye medicare, say goodbye environmental policies, say goodbye jobs. That's right say goodbye jobs. What Harper isn't saying between the paltry tax cuts that the unthinking masses are gobbling up with gusto, and the scare tactics over the Liberal Party is this, they are the Reform Party. Stockwell Day? Does that ring a bell? These are Alberta Reformers who think that as long as there's oil everything will be alright. Oil does not provide for a middle class, manufacturing and JOBS do, not the latest profit reports from Exxon or Shell. Stop and think, please, just stop and think. Don't drink the Kool-aid.


small c in ottawa
said

Artists are like small businesses. They don't have the capital etc to go abroad to expand their business. They don't have the income to waste. So when previous programs helped them sell to the world I gladly payed my part (3$) in taxes. But now Harper wants me to pay $10 instead for what? Finger paint? Forget it!

This is the most anti-business Conservative governments on record. They don't support hi-tech. They do not lift a finger for the film and TV industry, They sign bad deals for the forest industry. They wait until the layoffs have already happened in the auto industry. They ignore the wishes of the majority of grain farmers. And they shy away from helping manufacturers get global contracts (while pissing off one of our three largest customers). And then they keep adding page after page to the monstrosity known as the tax code!.
But Hey. Harper has never owned a real business nor even worked in the real world for what 20+Years?


Larry
said

It seems to me that the CONS are doing whatever they can to buy the votes of Quecbers. I really fail to see why any one would vote Conservative after the leader has lied, (remember the Investment Funds?) broke the law (remember the law that the Conservatives brought in about election set dates? Just so that you know, there was other intention in that bill other then to keep the CONS in power for four years), giving art credits that critics say won't do any thing at all for the average family, and finally giving to the people in Quebec $ 2,000 per household to help with the electric bill. Sounds like a party that I would support. I just would like to know where my share of the money is and when I can expect it to arrive? NEVER!


Ron Jefkins Niagara Falls
said

Shades if McCain !
are he and Harper really twins or is the same person running both campaigns. Now Mr. Harper has discovered that ordinary Quebecers are indeed interested in the arts . My Lord, but he really thinks people are so stupid ! What a joke !


Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

CTV.ca Specials

Election 2008

Election 2008: Full Coverage

Extensive and exclusive coverage of the federal election campaign.

Election Blog

CTV Election Blog

Notes from Craig Oliver, Robert Fife and the CTV News election team.

My vote: Arthur A. Leach School

My Vote

What issues are important to you? Send a video and let us know.

CTV Broadband

CTV Video Player

Watch breaking news, features and exclusive specials on Election 2008.

Battleground 2008

The Strategic Counsel surveys 45 swing ridings.

Poll Tracker

Poll tracker

Strategic Counsel's latest numbers from 'Battleground 2008.'

Mobile Updates

Mobile Updates

Sign up for campaign alerts and election night results.

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz