CTV News | ADHD drugs should be last resort: new guidelines

Health -   

ADHD drugs should be last resort: new guidelines

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV Newsnet: Denise Difede, Attention Deficit Resource Network

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(19)

CTV.ca News Staff

Date: Wed. Sep. 24 2008 1:49 PM ET

Drugs such as Ritalin should be a last resort for treating children with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder and should never be prescribed to kids of preschool age, new guidelines suggest.

The new guidelines, issued by the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence in the United Kingdom, recommend that parents and other caregivers receive training in the care and management of the disease as a first line of treatment.

If parental management proves ineffective for ADHD patients between the ages of 11 and 18, group or individual counselling should be the next option considered for treatment, the guidelines suggest.

"Drug treatment is not indicated as the first-line treatment for all school-age children and young people with ADHD," the guidelines say.

Treatment with Ritalin or other drugs, "should be reserved for those with severe symptoms and impairment," or for those who have refused or not responded to parent training or psychological treatment.

For children with severe ADHD, medication is still recommended as a first-line treatment, with parent management as a supplementary treatment.

ADHD is a behavioural syndrome that leads to symptoms such as hyperactivity, impulsiveness and an inability to pay attention. It affects anywhere from five to 12 per cent of Canadian children.

Symptoms can range from mild to severe and can overlap with other behavioural or mood disorders.

"With this guideline we are providing the most comprehensive approach to diagnosing and managing children with ADHD right across the spectrum of care," Dr. Tim Kendall, psychiatrist and a joint director of the National Collaborating Centre for Mental Health in the U.K., said in a statement.

The new guidelines fall into step with widespread concerns that too many children are given medication to manage hyperactive behaviours.

Ritalin can cause a variety of side effects, such as nausea, fatigue and mood swings, and the long-term effects of the drug are not yet known.

When children do need drug treatment, physicians should start them on very low doses and closely monitor side effects as they determine the correct dose for each child, the guidelines suggest.

Doctors should also conduct an annual review of children on medications to determine if they should continue with drug therapy or otherwise have their treatment altered.

Comments are now closed for this story

Clint
said

As parents of two ADHD children, we thank the lord for Concerta and in the past Ritalin.
these children would have either done damage to themselves or others if not on medication.
the people that do these studies either have not spent 24 hours per day with these type of children or if they have they were boarderline cases.
With the help of the childrens Therapist and our family GP we have been able to find the right mix of therapy and medication to give these children as close to normal life as can be expected.

Michelle
said

And good luck to parents in trying to find a doctor who really understands ADHD and treatment options and isn't eager just to write a prescription to get you out of the office. You need even better luck finding a school who won't twist a parent's arm into putting an ADHD child on drugs because teachers are not interested in the extra work involved with providing behaviour therapy.
Sometimes parents try hard to stay away from drugs but receive very little support using behaviour modification techniques.




Pat
said

Well, if nothing else, it is nice to see that a few people have thought to stop popping pills as a first action for dealing with life, or worse yet, forcing them into children as a 'solution.' If more doctors would say something about this, maybe people would begin to solve more of our problems without needing to feel better first. Emotions, even though they may be unpleasant, are often just the things that motivate human beings to change for the better.


j55
said

My daughter has been medication free now for 2 years and 4 months. She had been medicated for 4 yrs prior to that. We did behavior therapy and changed the diet somewhat. We did everything at home that we could do. Schools and teachers need more resources and understanding in working with adhd children and it doesn`t always require medication. Now that my daughter is in a designated school for children with learning disabilities,in grade 11, she is thriving. Her passion for life and learning has come back becuase teachers who care take the time to teach her the way she needs to learn. Positive Reinforcement goes a long way, improving self-esteem and grades.


Against drugging kids
said

If children spent more time playing outside than sitting doing nothing there would be less children on drugs.

Schools need to put recess and gym back into the daily schedule.

Parents need to either take their kids outside or send them out to play.

Kids need manners and patience not drugs.


Jay
said

I couldn't agree more with the statement that doctors should try living with these kids 24 hours a day . most people have no knowledge of ADHD and will never understand what it is like . We have people looking at us at the mall as we we are horrible parents when our son gets out of hand , but we have always been told , be understanding but firm , yet the number of times strangers have overheard us trying to control our son , and look at us like we are child abusers is not comfortable . I wish more people were educated about ADHD and then you might understand...just myabe ???


trish
said

After much prompting the teacher insisted that I put my child on Ritalin. The side affects 3 years later, was air vaced to Children's Hosp in heart failure. He was diagnosed with heart arrhythmia as well as an enlarged heart. He clung to life for weeks, had 2 ablations ( that never worked) and a heart transplant was close by!!
Thanks to BC CHildren's Hospital and our faith in God he is slowly recovering.Principals brag that teachers can adapt to all types of children in a classroom. Not so, teachers do what is easiest for them and us as parents have to pick up the pieces. I suggest to any parent with their child on these drugs to have regular checkups, especially to monitor their heart, as it is one of the side effects. I live with guilt thinking I gave in too easy to teachers and doctors. With lots of patience and understanding these children WILL do well. They need extra support, teachers should be trying to make more of a difference and doctors not so quick to prescribe drugs.


Nadine
said

As parents of a child whose teacher says was ADHD, as well as the doctors, I am glad we didn't go to medication first. We researched eveything possible and worked with a homeopathy doctor to find that the source of the issue was diet (in particular food colouring) and not ADHD. Too many people jump to medication right away and don't take the time to find other solutions or the underlying reason for the behaviour. I believe there are children that do do need medication, I just don't think it should be the first step taken in the path of treatment.


Paul
said

My child went from getting B's, under an IAP, to getting A's without an IAP. His teacher noticed the difference in one day, with meds.

For myself, I can't function at work without it.


Alan
said

By stating this you are assuming that the poor parents are strong enough, in a situation of duress when they are struggling to figure out what is wrong with their child and how to help, to take it to the powerfully teachers and school systems in Ontario;

I was called more then one, siting on a side of a table and on the other side, the principal, the vice-principal, two teachers (French and English), the resource teacher and the psychologist from the school; They made it clear to me that unless i medicated my child, I have no other alternative; they dismissed my counter proposals and bullied us; the tagged me as an irresponsible parent and, at the end, it is with heart broken that we cooperated and drugged my child;

fortunately, we abandoned the medication after few months and my daughter is doing well today; but how many other parents were cornered like us and drugged their children to cripple; till today, it boils my blood when i think on how these people wanted a quiet and aseptic classroom and how they will not deal with any child little bit out of the ordinary;


Alistair McLaughlin
said

As an adult who has been on Ritalin, or some form of it, for 11 years, I can attest to the effectiveness of drug therapy for ADHD. All the behavioural modification in the world won't make a difference for some. That does not mean I believe Ritalin should be the first thing tried on an ADD kid. Likely it is worth it to explore other options first.

For pre-schoolers, I personally wouldn't even consider it. But that's my own personal opinion, and I'm not condemning parents who felt that they had no choice but to try it with their pre-schooler.

As a final note, those who cry about the "drugging of our children" are just peddling empty slogans with little or no knowledge backing them up. Try being a teacher or a parent managing an ADHD kid, and perhaps you'll have a different perspective.


Michelle
said

ADHD is a neurobehavioural disorder caused by an imbalance in brain chemistry and damaged anatomy.

IT IS NOT A DISCIPLINE PROBLEM CAUSED BY A LACK OF DISCIPLINE AND PYHSICAL EXERCISE!!!!!






Since95
said

Though ADHD may be caused by a neurobehavioural disorder caused by an imbalance in brain chemistry, the medical field does not have the ability to measure the imbalances. By giving medication to correct this imbalance is a flawed theory, as there is no possible way to measure if the imbalance is being corrected.


Miguel
said

I think we are way too quick to diagnose these kids as having ADHD. If I recall, they thought I had ADHD. Could it be that I was bored in school, strict parents that didn't let me be a kid, teachers that did not make lessons interesting...
I agree with those suggesting that kids should have more physical activity. It helped me when I started track and x-country. Studies later showed that runners performed better because of the brain stimulus. When I went to high school and College, I scored better because I was starting to focus on things that interested me both academically and physically.
Teachers are taught to blame it on ADHD and drugs that seem to make their jobs easier. Where is the study that shows the kids grades before and after they are put on drugs? Are they in sports? How do they interact with other kids? People skills are just as important as grades and so is physical fitness. We have to work on the whole package here, not just focus on one thing.
While this may be off subject, I think it still applies, schools should stop focusing on memorization tests and focus more on projects that involve research. Skills learned in the process will be used for the rest of their lives and it may make school a little more interesting.


Andrea
said

My 17 year old son had ADHD and has been medicated since the age of 5. He, too, would not have survived without medication. He is a B honour student and lifeguard. I am also a former teacher (K-12) and see the struggles teachers/parents face. However, I am in full agreement that one has to LIVE with an ADHD child to fully comprehend the struggle for the child, the parents and the family. He himself acknowledged recently that even with his Concerta, he doesn't think he can ever drive a car. Walk a mile in his moccasins before you judge....


Renee
said

The problem doesn't only lie with doctors prescribing medication for ADHD to young children who may benefit from other methods of treatment if given the chance. The problem is doctors prescribing medication too quickly in all situations, many of which can be treated without immediate medications.

What's going to happen to us in another 20-30 years wehn our bodies are so used to being pumped full of unnecessary drugs? Think of how powerful flues will become when the bacteria become immume to antibiotics.

Something needs to be done on all levels when it comes to prescription medication.


UR
said

I think a better reason to avoid drugs as a first treatment option for the kids who are misdiagnosed. My aunt and uncle put all three of their kids on Ritalin...they were not out of control kids. But they "had" ADHD because it was easier for my aunt & uncle to pop them full of pills than to establish rules. Oh, and my uncle also has ADHD...which is why he's never been able to hold down a job...not because he's a deadbeat.

I know there are real cases of ADHD, but those drugs are scary. Isn't better to try drugs last? Alternative therapies first would certainly help weed the parents who are too lazy to actually parent.


Rachel, Blenheim, ON
said

My husband has ADD and has accomplished much without meds. He worked really hard at his schooling & social interactions, much harder than the average kid. He wasnt even diagnosed until he was older.
Two of our kids have ADHD & ADD and one has been on meds since preschool - we took her off and she actually DEPENDS on the meds. CAS & the school system screwed her up - they are the ones that said she had to be on meds. Now she goes through withdrawal, she has physical & mental side effects, and she doesnt work hard at all - she just coasts through the school system. Thanks CAS & School Board! It's about time these guidelines were in place - it's just too bad they took so long!


Mike From Calgary
said

I have 2 children diagnosed with Autism, a little more severe than ADHD even though its on the Autism spectrum as well.

Doctors are WAY too quick to prescribe a cover up or symptom silencer like Ritalin than come up with fix for the root cause. 99% of Autistic or ADHD symptoms can be positively affected by change in Diet and cleansing of heavy metals and toxins that kids affected with the spectrum disorders don't seem to be able to get rid of naturally. Of course this along with behavioral therapies is the most effective because they can't learn if they can't think. Clear out the body of foreign toxins and it clears the mind to create new pathways needed to get the most out of behavioral therapies.

Giving a child Ritalin in my opinion, may dampen symptoms but it also dampens their abilities in EVERY way. I not only think it should be a last resort, I think it should be abolished and abandoned as a treatment for ADHD and or Autism.


Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

Subscribe!

CTV MedNews Express

CTV MedNews Express

Sign up for our weekly medical newsletter, delivered for free to your inbox.

CTV.ca Blogs

Health Blog Avis Favaro Marla Shapiro

Health Blog

Check out what our guest medical experts and CTV health reporters are writing about.

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz