Canada -
News Sections
Ritz sorry for 'tasteless' Listeria comments
CTV News Video
Watch: See all Videos in the Player
Font-size:
Share
Print
Comments(80)
CTV.ca News Staff
Date: Wed. Sep. 17 2008 11:17 PM ET
Agriculture Minister Gerry Ritz has apologized for making "tasteless" remarks about the listeriosis crisis that killed 17 people, but the NDP and Liberals say he should resign.
"My comments were inappropriate and callous," Ritz told reporters late Wednesday night. "I take responsibility and I apologize without reservation."
During a conference call with scientists, bureaucrats and political staff on Aug. 30, Ritz made several off-colour jokes about the outbreak.
After fretting about the political dangers of the Listeria scare, Ritz quipped: "This is like a death by a thousand cuts. Or should I say cold cuts."
Then when told of a death in Prince Edward Island, Ritz said, "Please tell me it's (Liberal MP) Wayne Easter."
Easter is the Liberal agriculture critic and has called for Ritz's resignation over his handling of the outbreak, which was linked to a Maple Leaf Foods meat processing plant north of Toronto.
"I phoned Mr. Easter earlier today and apologized," Ritz said late Wednesday. "He accepted my apology and I thank him for that. Most importantly, I want to offer my most humble and heartfelt regrets to the families of those affected by this tragedy. I did not intend to add to their suffering and I very deeply apologize for that."
Kory Teneycke, a spokesperson for the Prime Minister's Office, said Ritz expressed regret over his remarks to Stephen Harper but there was no suggestion of resigning.
"A resignation was not offered, nor was one asked for," he said.
Karen Clark's mother, Frances Clark, was the first identified Listeria victim in Canada and passed away Aug. 25, five days before Ritz's comments.
Clark told CTV Newsnet Wednesday evening that she found Ritz's comments "hurtful ... to any family that has lost a loved one due to the (outbreak)."
Easter said that he didn't take the comments personally but slammed Ritz's "insensitivity" to those who lost family to listeriosis. He said the comments were just one more reason Ritz needs to be dismissed.
"I spoke with Minister Ritz earlier this evening ... and he did apologize to me for the comments," Easter told CTV News.
Ritz had apologized for the comments earlier Wednesday in front of a handful of reporters, but left before camera crews arrived.
NDP Leader Jack Layton spoke out about Ritz's comments on CTV's Mike Duffy Live.
"Canadians are dying because of the mismanagement of our government . . . there should absolutely never be that kind of humour," he said.
"It illustrates the government is not taking this matter as seriously as they should."
A spokesperson for Conservative leader Stephen Harper released a statement saying the Ritz comments were tasteless and completely inappropriate.
With files from The Canadian Press
User Tools
Related Stories
CTV.ca Specials
User Tools
About the tools
Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.
-


Font-size
Print Article
Comments(80)-
Feedback
Share it with your network of friends
Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.
Most Viewed News Stories
Most Talked about Stories
I applaud the budget, even though Health Care and education may stay unscathed. Sadly this cannot last and I worry to later this year where cuts will become enviable. If anything, this provides the Wildrose Alliance plenty of ammo when an election is called.








Comments are now closed for this story
Al
said
What an absolute insult to the families of all those people who died from listeriosis! I think these families should all get together for a class action lawsuit against Gerry Ritz and the Conservative government.
Any lawyers out there??!!
beachdude
said
William Zebedee
said
mike
said
Bob
said
BCL
said
mefromhere
said
By the way, he showed great character by not punching that reporter in the airport and stomping on his recorder!
mike
said
Scott Ash
said
He didn't say it to any of the victims or their families directly. He made a bad/tasteless joke to some scientists on the phone probably when he was stressed out.
Let's not hang him over this. He's only human. Also funny how this comes out during an election? hmmm something sneaky going on?
Den
said
Kevin
said
Dallas in Winnipeg
said
Law suit? Give me a break! He said something stupid but that shouldn't translate into a cash grab. Typical socialist! What I find unfortunate is people like you think that people should change their vote because of somthing like this. I guess that's all the left have to hold on to because God knows their party has nothing to offer.
Ken - Calgary
said
Shane Prpich
said
VOTE HIM AND HIS PARTY OUT PEOPLE!
Jennifer
said
Matt from Ottawa
said
reality man
said
Jarod
said
Peter
said
Kelly Rae
said
Robin
said
THE CONS HAVE NO SHAME...
justwow
said
I'm not big on firing people over quips, but this speaks to broader ignorance...this was a tragedy not open mic night.
Adios, Gerry!
FreakAlert
said
Annette
said
M. Cameron
said
KJ
said
Marcel
said
DR42
said
Why would any youth want to get involved in politics right now?
mike
said
Kevin
said
You couldnt sue the party, perhaps the Government of Canada, but the political party itself really wouldnt have any liability here. As far as a personal suit against an individual politician... id have to say that there would more than likely be some liability exemptions in place to protect governing officials from that type of thing. Nothing stopping a class-action against Maple-Leaf though, and as I understand there is allready one underway.
Jay From Out West
said
Remember, many Ontario MP's were in the Harris government during the Walkerton crisis. So in my mind the Conservative party has no credibility on this issue. I don't expect my government to be the do all and end all, but public health and safety is one area I expect the government to go the extra mile.
V. Barr
said
phauser
said
I can't believe someone could say something so stupide but I a dying to know the context it was spoken it.
It is hard to imagine it in any other context than an idiot putting his foot in his mouth and putting his party's (my party) chances to secure a strong mandate down a rung.
I like the idea that the constituents should decide his fate but I think firing him immediately as agriculture minister must be considered.
I don't know how this one comes out good for conservatives. I do think Wayne Easter did a good job of being gracious.
As reported these are very tasteless comments. Sad he didn't take them back 2 weeks ago when he said them.
Joen Hadfield
said
The Liberals, NDP, Bloq should 'run' with this crude remark and all Canadiens should vote his sorry person out of any position of responsibility.
david
said
chris
said
What's next- the Minister of Transportation making jokes about losing your head on a greyhound bus!
I would have said the same in his position !!
said
Political hypocrisy runs wild during an election and this is one more example by those clamoring for his resignation.
CTV said it was a joke and anyone who is objective knows it was intended as a joke and to say otherwise is taking it out of context to suit their bent political aims.
If you have to use this as a "story" to bolster your political fortunes then you are in dire straights.
End of story.
Grant
said
Bill
said
I welcome and encourage all of Mr. Harper's Conservative buddies, from his Cabinet Ministers to his election "war room" Spin Doctors, to keep on telling us what is exactly on their minds.
It just makes the decision for Canadians that much clearer to vote for ABC; ANYBODY BUT Mr.Harper and his Conservative cronies come the October vote.
craig
said
Andre Lacroix
said
Is this the bunch of clowns we want to form the next government and represent our great country on the world scene.
The Conservative ( reformed politicians ) party is a scary thought. Harper is not a leader. Get them out!!! You have three other choices to choose from, unless you live in Québec. There you have four choices.
Save Canada. Vote them out of office.
Peter
said
Zircon
said
Ritz should resign. Period. There's no room for this sort of insensitivity from government officials. But so should Layton et al who use the very same incident in an attempt to gain points from it.
Hey Jack, people died not because of the government. They died because other people, at Maple Leaf Foods, didn't do what they were supposed to do. But that doesn't matter when we all care about is rhetoric and partisanship.
Brad
said
Jean Travis
said
Newfoundland saved the nation during the Meech Lake fiasco and saving the day another time.
Danny Williams for PM
Enough with the Cons
said
Jack Layton's audition for drama TV
said
No Jack, some Canadians died as a result of a virus that got through the cleaning processes in Maple Leaf Foods and maybe others we have yet to learn about.
That is not the governments fault, Jack.
Some Canadian
said
What this story is missing and other news services are reporting is the aggresive nature in which the 'Honourable' Minister tried to evade questions at the airport. If this guy wanted to show how responsible he was and if the Conservatives wanted to show what great leaders they are, Litz would have apologized in the scrum rather than push his way through and then have the war room issue a press release later.
It was bad enough we had a health minister that was out of the country at a political convention during a health emergency, now we have the minister responsible for the failed food safety inspection system making light of the mistakes his department made?!?! Strong leadership indeed.
Gord C.
said
Ritz's comment was bad, it was tasteless.
Nonetheless, when Harper is sworn in again as PM, I wouldn't expect to see Ritz in any portfolio much less the agriculture portfolio.
Good luck Gerry. Hope you enjoyed your time as ag minister.
DD
said
Certainly an indication that they were more concerned on how this would impact the election than on how it impacted on those sickened by the meat.
Disgraceful.
ABC
Cara
said
Linda from Hamilton
said
Brian H. +
said
The comments were indeed insensitive and showed a particularly odd skewed character on the part of the minister.
But above all, it is the pure stupidity shown that is amazing.
If nothing else, the minister showed be dismissed for being a dolt.
Josh
said
Jason from Templeton
said
Mike (kitchener)
said
peter
said
Leave the man alone. There will be a lot of very stressed people trying overall to help.
Leave the blame game to the NDP, they are SO good at it and certainly aren't above trying to campaign on the backs' of a families' grief.
Richard
said
However, I'll bet the Liberal posters will take a shot and say; "Hidden Agenda - Told you so!".
Ritz, who has worked hard, will resign. It's Harper's way = It's the right way, It's Leadership!
Go Neo-Cons/Reform/Alliance/Conservative Party of Canada Go!
Bill
said
I welcome and encourage all of Mr. Harper's Conservative buddies, from his Cabinet Ministers to his election "war room" Spin Doctors, to keep on telling us what is exactly on their minds.
It just makes the decision for Canadians that much clearer to vote for ABC; ANYBODY BUT Mr.Harper and his Conservative cronies come the October vote.
Don
said
h
said
Nicole
said
The Public Service is full of LIBERAL supporters
said
Mr. B.
said
However, the guy apologized & I'm pretty sure he didn't mean to offend or hurt anybody. Just a dumb move on his part.
Lawsuits? Give me a break. Only the lawyers benefit when that happens.
I'm pretty sure he will be very careful in the future.
We all make mistakes. I've made a few myself a lot worse than his "jokes".
Time to worry about other things.
A conserned conservative voter!
said
Second of all, if you are a minister of some sort, a person of authority and joke about this ... you are showing very, very poor judgement and I would, as the PM, question myself about such a person holding such a position of power.
Being a conservative I have to say that Gerry Ritz should resign as Agriculture Minister with out hesitation. There are no excuses for a man in his position to show so much poor judgement. It worries me and makes me wonder where else he is erring with such bad judgement?
Gerry Ritz ... do the honorable thing! You may still run, but please resign you are reflecting very badly on your Leader.
Typical
said
Marg
said
Justin - So What
said
The media seems to think they have to show Harper is not perfect.
Calgary guy
said
Lorne
said
This is just an extension of Harper's arrogance by one of his MP's.
We all make some "off the cuff" remarks, but when you are in a position where these remarks are recorded, you better watch what you say.
This has left the impression that the Government does not care about the deaths of the individuals from Listeria.
It shows there sympathy lies with big business.
Scott R in BC
said
Mr. Harper, if this minister stays and is supported by you my support for you and your party is gone.
If this man is defended in his comments your judgement is drastically compromised.
Gail (Hamilton)
said
Jorja
said
anotherone
said
I'm sure if this were a Liberal screw up, Harper would be calling for calm and understanding...ha. It's politics, if you don't like the rules, don't play the game. Admit he's ignorant and quit whining that things aren't fair.
Steve
said
This is Harper's handpicked Minister
said
... yet another stellar example of Harper's handpicked choices.
All the former Progressive Conservatives out there really need to ask yourselves who you think you're really voting for if you're thinking of backing Harper...
Prof. Pye Chartt
said
Good gracious. Take a pill, people. They were not comments generated for "public" consumption...and now are being used by political pumpkins for bogus partisan advantage. What a pathetic non-story.
More aggravating, is that the wheels in the PC Party election machinery felt compelled to tell Ritz to go public with a goofy apology, to appease all the disingenuous whiners scattered here and across the land.
No wonder why only intellectually sterile robots seek public office: we've all made it so that REAL people with genuine character traits get driven into the ground. The electorate is its own worst enemy.
Ken in WPG
said
Todd
said
All those frothing at the mouth over this will likely continue to do so, whether it makes any sense or not. All of the ranting about hidden conservative agendas, neocon insensitivity etc will likely continue unabated, but luckily, will have no effect on the actual outcome of the election. The majority of Canadians, regardless of how they plan to vote, will see this issue for what it is - absolutely nothing - and base their decision on real issues.
And for the minority which will continue to lash out with their various conspiracy theories and inflated indignation - please continue to do so. It does makes for some comical reading.
brenda
said
Who ever gets fired for saying something stupid. I guess we should all be fired! The whole human race.