News Sections
Hearn cautions EU over ban on seal products
Font-size:
Share
Print
Comments(96)
CTV.ca News Staff
Date: Wed. Jul. 23 2008 5:11 PM ET
Canada's fisheries minister has issued a stern reproach to European lawmakers over a proposed ban on seal products from countries that "practice cruel hunting methods."
The European Union's environment commissioner Stavros Dimas put forward the legislation Wednesday with the goal of leveraging seal-hunting countries to improve practices that he said are often "gruesome" and unacceptable.
Fisheries Minister Loyola Hearn reacted swiftly, vowing to stand up for Canadian hunters and warning the EU members they were on thin ice.
"Once again, we would like to caution European decision-makers: adopting broad regulations to ban products from a responsible, sustainable and well-regulated hunt is a slippery slope," Hearn said in a statement.
"To bow to misinformation and emotional rhetoric in restricting the trade of humanely harvested animals would set a dangerous precedent for all wild hunts."
The 27-members of the EU and the European Parliament would have to back the proposal for it to take effect.
Rebecca Aldworth, a spokesperson for the U.S. Humane Society, said the animal rights group was pleased with the proposal.
"It's a very strong step at this stage in the process and we are absolutely thrilled this has come out of the commission," she told NTV News.
"This is just a first step and now it goes to parliament. But given that, I believe, 425 members of the European parliament signed the original written declaration, which called for a total ban on sealing products, I believe this proposal will only be strengthened."
Proposal review
Hearn said the government, provinces and stakeholders will be reviewing in coming months how the proposed regulations, and any possible exemptions, would affect Canada.
Canadian hunters and exporters maintain their practices are humane and that the hunt is sustainable and vital to many isolated communities in Atlantic Canada. If it is brought into law, the legislation could virtually eliminate a key market for Canadian hunters.
Mike Hearn, veteran sealer in Newfoundland, said Canada should counter any potential ban with trade barriers of its own.
"We may need things they have. But they certainly need a lot of things that we have in this country," said Hearn. :I think we have to step up to the plate and make them answer for what they're doing."
In recent years the Canadian hunt has become tense as animal rights activists from around the world come to observe, document and protest the hunt.
This spring, tensions were highest when members of the Sea Shepherd Society clashed with the Canadian Coast Guard as it tried to impose a limit on how close the activists could come to sealing vessels.
Ban 'cautiously welcomed'
The International Fund for Animal Welfare "cautiously welcomed" the EU's proposed move.
"It's a very positive step. Closing the European markets to Canadian seal products should give our government a serious wake-up call," Sheryl Fink, researcher with the IFAW said in a news release.
"This proposal shows that the European Commission is concerned about the cruelty inherent in commercial seal hunts, and understands the importance of animal welfare for European citizens. It's too bad our politicians don't pay the same attention to Canadian concerns."
With a report from NTV News
User Tools
Related Stories
User Tools
About the tools
Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.
-


Font-size
Print Article
Comments(96)-
Feedback
Share it with your network of friends
Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.
Most Viewed News Stories
Most Talked about Stories
I applaud the budget, even though Health Care and education may stay unscathed. Sadly this cannot last and I worry to later this year where cuts will become enviable. If anything, this provides the Wildrose Alliance plenty of ammo when an election is called.


Comments are now closed for this story
Dalia
said
Lance E Taylor
said
S Jupp
said
DD
said
Are you still relying on the lies of the animal rights groups for your information? They use decades old information and videos to tug at your heart strings.
Despite what they STILL say, whitecoats are NO LONGER hunted. The vast majority use a rifle (you know, the same way people hunt deer and moose etc). The only ones that still club are in the Magdalen Islands where there are too many hunters to safely use rifles.
Numerous vet reports have declared the hunt both sustainable AND humane. Who are you to doubt their findings?
Educate yourselves. There are almost 7 million seals. At the peak of the hunt, the herd averaged 1 million seals.
In the end, it doesn't matter what the EU does. All it means is that the hunt will become a cull to keep the population down (you know, like they do with caribou, horses and wolves).
Oh wait...a caribou isn't cute...so it's okay to kill it.
Give me a break.
Mich
said
I don't understand how anyone can judge or make remarks if you don't know the whole picture.
George
said
M Setterfield
said
Ever see a child starve to death? I think opponents of the seal hunt could better spend their time and resources saving the human race.
R D
said
Rob
said
Andrew
said
Chris
said
arnie williamson
said
Next why not a a ban on all leather products from farm animals inhumanley slaughtered and skinned alive in French and German slaughter houses
We harvest and kill animals for food and resources. Where did everyone think that meat in the supermarket or seal coat in the store came from anyway.
Daryl
said
Rita Wilson
said
Brian from Barrie
said
Nancy
said
The day the seal hunt ends permanently, my family will end our boycott of tourism to Newfoundland and Labrador and we will plan a nice trip to see the seals!
John Kik
said
Dustin
said
beeman
said
Jason
said
The government has to spend more than this atrocity is worth just to maintian it while destroying our reputation abroad.
Only in Canada.
Newfoundland Wolf
said
-Sealers hurt Canada
-The seal hunt loses money for the nation.
-It's an economic loss.
-Costs more than it makes.
-Seal meat contains Mercury, no good to eat.
-Eating it causes stunted mental development.
-It took the lives of 4 people this year.
-Sealers already make money as fishermen.
-This is merely a 2nd job, and disgusting.
-Sealers continue to shame Canada and stain the Good Canadian people.
The Seal hunt shall go into Canada's history and rejected the same as horrible "traditions" like cannibalism or slavery.
james
said
The arrogance of Europeans!
Lets hope our government will retaliate by baning lets say wine from the EU. I wonder how arrogant they will be when they loose a major North American market.
Trent
said
But I doubt a ban of Canadian seal products would occur as we are the most open book country inrelation to the hunt.
AnimalLover
said
Pro Seal Hunt
said
Will
said
Jim McB
said
beeman
said
Larry L
said
I can count only a dozen or so things that in modern society only, or best, can be done through collective effort including national security, creation and maintenance of an effective and efficient infrastructure, health care, education, social/economic safety nets, a minimal body of law to protect the inividual and property, police and fire services, economic controls, public sanitation in all its forms, and a few more that don't immediately come to mind.
When governing bodies - from the national on down to the municipal - can do all these things efficiently and consistently then, and only then, should they even think of doing more.
As individuals, we are quite capable of deciding for ourselves whether to purchase a seal coat, or even whether or not to build a tree house for our kids.
Nancy
said
By the way, this is not a total ban. The sealers have always claimed they kill seals "humanely", so what is the whining about?
Po
said
FYI Beef is killed in a very similar manner as these seals, a cuncussive blow to the head... I don't see the big difference other than the cuteness of teh seals.
CamD
said
Even Grean Peace has concluded that the sealhunt methods are human.
Do you thing a bunch of fisherman really want to walk out on rolling ice in the Atlantic to help them through the year and then screwup their livelyhood by getting caught performing inhumane methods?
Next time you're have your bacon and eggs, think about how easy your hypocritical life is.
James in Calgary
said
If you eat beef especially veal you must know that the baby cows are killed in the same way the adult seals are, with a hammer blow to the head. The job in the abattoir is called a Knocker because he knocks the animals on their heads.
My point is, if it is OK to kill cows this way why not seals?
Newfoundland Patriot
said
The hunt costs upwards of 50 million dollars to conduct, and it only earns 5 million. So the seal hunt is a HUGE economic and financial loss to the nation.
And the good Canadians with real jobs end up paying for a small handful of extremist lobbyist sealers.
Economic. Nothing to do with anyone's diet. So all comment posts mentioning veganism or vegetarianism as a prerequisite for being against anything are now debunked.
You may no longer use that. Move on to your next attempt.
Ed
said
Let the Europeans and PETA put their money wher etheir mouth is : financailly support sealers so they dont HAVE to go out and earn a living this way.
PUT YOUR MONEY WHERE YOUR MOUTH IS EUROPE OTHERWISE SHUTUP AND CLEAN UP YOUR OWN BACKYARD FIRST.
A Real IT Manager From Calgary
said
Seriously EU better look at themselves first before attacking Canada.
Bill
said
Mike
said
Stupid hypocrites
Something else i've heard is if we don't restrict the popualtion of seals, that all the fish will be eaten to near extinction and really mess up the environment. Does anyone know if that's the case?
annoyed
said
Canadian Seal Hunter
said
I mean, Seal Hunters have dogs. And cats. And they could skin them. And eat cat meat pie. (yummy!) And there is a very good market in China for dog skin.
There's probably at least 6 million dogs & cats in Newfoundland!@ They are not going extinct!
But no, these bleeding heart Seal Killers don't care about seals because they are gray and fat and ugly.
All they care about is little puppies and kittens...Because they're cute!
These bleeding-heart Seal killers being against taking advantage of skinning & eating a great Canadian renewable resource of Canadian cats & Newfoundland dogs is sickening. It could put food on the table for poor desperate rural children!
Fish Minister
said
Wonderful!
Now the Seals can get back to saving the Cod fish.
Seals increase COD. Because seals eat cod's predators. Seals eat less than 2% cod, and it turned out Seals eat the things that FED on the cod, and the cod's eggs.
Seals were taking care of the squids, skates, sculpins, and other things that humans don't eat. 98% of seals diet.
Seals protected the cod, but seal hunters killed the seals, then cod's predators increased and destroyed huge amounts of cod. Seal killers danaged it for the whole planet.
Previously the DFO thought seals depleted the cod, but that was just an old wives tale by Newfoundland fisherman, the DFO did a study, and found that Seals did not ruin the cod. After seeing the results from their own DFO scientists. The DFO has now pulled that statement off of their website. It's gone.
Now even the Dept of Fisheries & Oceans acknowledges that what the sealers & fishermen said wasn't true.
And so Finally now seals can be allowed to protect the codfish again! Wonderful!
Thank you E. U. !
mike r
said
This isn't about sustainability or economic viability, it's about our continued support and participation in a hunt that most of the civilized world finds disgusting and is determined to put a stop to.
N T
said
Just my 2 pennies...
Dan from Surrey
said
I believe they do not kill baby seals with white fur anymore but many are still clubbed and some are shot.
Personally i think it should be banned. But many would disagree but I think the seal hunt is in its twilight and when the ban comes in from the EU the death nail will be imminent unless the seal hunters can find another market. Would or could Russia , China and Norway pick up the slack?
People get wound up when it comes to animals these days, whether it is seals, the rabbits in various places in BC, The beavers in Surrey or the 10 kg Lobster named Dee Dee. People do not like to see animals hurt and with the seal hunt video is beamed all over the world so many can see....
I hate to see people losing jobs but with oil isn't there going to be more jobs and even better paying ones? I also know NFLD is sort of off the 'beaten path' but Williams and Harper should try to 'encourage' more investment in NFLD which would bring more jobs, hopefully.
This barbaric so called 'hunt' should be ended. It is not hunting but akin to shooting fish in a barrel. Hell shooting grouse takes more skill than this.
Nunavik
said
The newfoundland seal hunt is not a Native hunt. it's an industrial hunt operated by caucasian newfoundland Sealers.
There are no indigenous newfoundland natives in Newfoundland today. Because some of the forefathers of current Newfoundland Seal hunters killed them.
The Beothuk indians were the native people of Newfoundland. They were here before any caucasians. Foreign Sailors came to Canada and took the native's fish, killed the walrus, killed the whales, and killed the newfoundland wolf. They are all extinct.
The ancestors of today's Canadian seal clubbers made the Beothuk into slaves, and when they revolted, they killed them. The last newfoundland native Beothuk died in 1829. Her name was Nancy Shanawhdit.
Sealers & Fishermen killed animals, plus, an entire race of native people. The original native Beothuk people of newfoundland are completely gone.
Today they continue to do it. The sealers & fisherment did it to the cod. And were working on the seals.
Now native people can get back to their own for food, not for cash, wealthy ladies fashion accessories, and sealer greed.
Great that Newfoundland sealers have been stopped!
Bob
said
buffalojump
said
Rational thinking at it's best.
The Donald
said
Saint John
said
The price of a seal pelt right now, from Carino is barely only 33 dollars. Actually it's less because that's only for the perfect ones, nothings perfect.
So the Total Allowable Catch of seals is 275,000. So 33 dollars times 275 thousand equals only 9 million dollars, but wait...thats not income, there's fuel costs, diesel, provisions, the 50 to 100,000 dollar sealing boat, safety vests, epirbs, food, guns, ammunition, the pelt chemicals, hmm. Expenses are a lot.. 50%. So the Seal hunt actually only brings in 5 million in 2008.
But that needs divided over 6,000 people, there are 6 thousand sealers confirmed by the DFO.
Ok, so each sealer for all of this long voyages, icy wind, life threatening work, ice bergs, boat damage, etc earns...5 mil divided across 6000 sealers earns an Annual Salary of...: 833 bucks (avg).
Hmm. 833 bucks annual salary? If we looked at what that would be like if it were a regular job, over a year, that'd be 69 bucks a month. 17 bucks a week, or in other words, if it were a real job, over a year, Seal Hunting would make 43 cents an hour.
Wow! Even as a janitor one could make 10 dollars an hour.
No wonder sealers want to fight so hard to keep doing this, they will be rich some day! Hey! maybe after another 500 years! John Cabot will be proud.
Oh, and this seal hunt earns only that 5 million for Canada, but it costs 24 million just for the Coast Guard to break the ice so they can get to where the seals are.
Excellent! 0.43 cents an hour, and a financial loss to everyone in Canada as well!
No wonder Canadian sealers want to fight so hard to keep it going!
CWS
said
Jim
said
Wow, what culture do you come from that Cannibalism was a tradition?
Marc
said
Jim
said
While I agree with your basic premis, you really got some facts wrong:
"the British chase foxes and deer with hounds until the animal is exhausted, followed by the ceremony of "blooding" the hunters. This is the ultimate in hypocrisy!"
First, the UK is not EU. Second, the fox hunt was outlawed as being cruel.
Paul on Vancouver Island
said
We have to get off our pedestals and come down to earth. HUMANS ARE JUST ANOTHER ANIMAL SPECIES.
All species are unique, as is the human animal, and we all feel pain. We are not unique in feeling pain. We must stop this cruelty upon other species.
It's not easy to change our ways, but it can be done. I've moved to being a vegetarian and use products not tested on other animal species.
david
said
Al Ottawa
said
Many in the media, and most environmentalist, keep showing the baby seals/the white coat seals being killed, but that doesn't happen anymore. They keep showing old videos falsely implying that is what's happening nowdays. So all the ignorant people watching TV suck it all in - after all, if it's on TV it must be true, right?!
Roger T
said
Perhaps, our political leaders should learn from this and other situations in the future "THINK BEFORE YOU SPEAK" about other countries rights and abuses!
RRO
said
The seal hunt is a part of our history as much as fox hunting, bull fighting or many other sports in Europe.
Perfect example of these fringe animal rights groups pushing their agenda on everyone else and not thinking of their impact on people.
John Timmermans
said
DD
said
Seal meat DOES NOT contain mercury. That's one of the advantages of getting Omega 3 oil from seals. They are too young to have absorbed enough and are not inland mammals to start with. The hunt is economically viable. It brings in tens of millions every year to those that really need it. And no...not all fisherman "make good money" or use the hunt as a "second job."
What's shameful is the complete lack of knowledge some of you armchair quarterbacks exhibit. The hunt is humane, sustainable and viable.
Animal rights groups love to hit hard on the hunt because (they have admitted) it is a cash cow for them. These organizations make more off the hunt than they put into protesting it. And they lie.
They lie. They lie. They lie. Even today, they use the whitecoat on their websites when the whitecoat hasn't been hunted in over TWENTY YEARS!!!!!
Stop drinking the animal rights groups' Kool-aid and educate yourselves.
Oh...and unless you are vegans, you have NO RIGHT to whine about the hunt. Go visit a slaughterhouse and learn that compared to that, the seal hunt is humane.
Shawn
said
Mr. Dimas started his crusade against seal products based on an unverified and non-peer-reviewed study that an anti-sealing group claimed showed "42% of seals" were being skinned alive. They looked at a total of 76 animals for that study.
The EU's own agency - the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) - wrote in its December 2007 report that "it is incorrect to conclude that 42% of the seals in the sample were skinned alive."
EFSA also added that "it is not appropriate to
extrapolate from a small sample of 76 skulls collected in the Gulf of St. Lawrence over two days to all the animals killed during the entire hunt,
which is conducted over several weeks,
both in the Gulf and on the Front off Newfoundland and Labrador."
That means that the EU shouldn't even be considering a ban right now and that Mr. Dimas' personal biases are guiding the EU's process - not science or the truth.
While folks may not like the seal hunt, policy and trade decisions should be based on verifiable science and not emotional nonesense.
Besides, I don't see Mr. Dimas going after EU countries' hunts for a million deer, or the UK fox hunt, or the millions of other animals he doesn't seem to have a problem killing.
Rob
said
If these losers want work, move to Alberta, there is plenty of work there. People have to migrate sometimes according to their needs.
Ban the Seal hunt altogether!
Jim
said
Andre
said
Remind me again why the Europeans or anyone should compensate the sealers now that their product is no longer in demand? Are you helping out the poor people who used to manufacture horse-drawn buggies and are now out of business? I didn't think so.
Maybe Newfoudland should start sharing its oil revenue with other Canadians, just like Canada has financially supported Newfoundland since 1949.
If not, then let this dying industry of seal hunting disappear. Canada's image in the world will be better for it.
Gary
said
Kevin Aubie
said
To DD
You don't have to be a vegan to oppose animal cruelty. To imply you do is downright ridiculous.
Mike vdB
said
The seal hunt dwindles but will not totally end because the EU only makes up 1/3 of the market. Many of these communities that rely on these hunts are full of proud people that want to support their families on something other then govt assistance. Most are also fishermen but not all. Besides, if the seals eat all your fish what is the point of being a fisherman? So that industry goes down the tubes.
What is next? Support the migration of whole communities to larger centers? That creates a whole bunch of problems in itself and in a time we are trying to assert our soveriengty (sp?) in the North..do you think that is feaseable?
I think before people pick and choose the things they want to believe, they should spend time in these communities and talk to the people at the center of it all. Maybe even live there for a year.
Oh wait...how feaseable is that? It is just easier to condemn and think you are doing the world a favour.
Timber
said
Keith, Halifax
said
The industry is not even close to being sustainable as the processing plants, marketing and the inflated price of the pelts all add up to huge subsidies. Throw in the cost of policing, search and rescue and this puny industry is costing Canada dearly. It is total idiocy we allow it go on.
There were are lot more seals and fish before Europeans settled the continent so you can’t blame the seals for the decline in fish stocks but even if that were the case it would be better to let the fishing industry die then allow such inhumanity to continue.
MartinofNS
said
By the way, seals are nasty little critters, they bite, Paul McCartney knows this first hand...
Me
said
I think everyone should jump on this boat
Robin the Hood
said
Joe from Ottawa
said
If, and when this is dealt with at a WTO Dispute Settlement, Canada has a solid case against the EU. The way in which seals are killed is no more repugnant than what happens daily at a slaughter house. Furthermore, with the exception of a widely criticized and suspect study by IFAW, most studies have indicated that the method of killing a seal (using a hakapik) is humane, killing the seal with seconds. Many trade experts agree that, with the above being the case, seal furs will likely be considered by the WTO to be a "like product" (WTO terms) and given the same opportunities as any animal product killed in a humane manner. Whether the EU will follow the ruling is another story.
Finally, if the seal hunt is so repugnant to European consumers that their government must step in, why is it that seal fur pelts are a highly sought after product, selling in record numbers and at a record price in the EU. If Europeans are so disgusted with the hunt, let them protest by refusing to purchase the product. Until then, the government should stay out.
Mo
said
FishyDon
said
RRO
said
Further, you may be correct about the fox hunt but that does not address the bull fighting or other extremely cruel practices in Europe.
The Europeans love to preach but rarely live up to there end of the bargan.
erleen
said
JPC
said
Ally
said
Joe - Vancouver
said
As for the seals depleting the fish stocks...wait a minute....didn't we do that with over fishing???
John D in Sask.
said
More importantly, however, why is everyone so worried over a proposed ban on seal products from countries that "practice cruel hunting methods." If Canadian seal hunters and exporters are practicing the humane methods that they and Mr. Hearn so vehemently insist they practice, then there should be nothing to worry about.
Rob
said
Tony
said
The seal hunt is more humane than most other animal slaughter, difference is they are done behind closed doors and chickens and cows aren't as cute. At least the seal got some time in the wild.
Seal hunt rhetoric is just an easy fundraiser for animal rights groups.
Chris
said
George
said
Gael Maxwell
said
Skinner
said
Mike Webster
said
The seal hunt isn't cruel or barbaric and it in no way endangers the seal population. Human beings, whether some people want to admit it or not, are part of nature. We're not apart from nature and out of the food chain, we're right at the top of it. Human beings are, as someone else observed, omnivoirs. We eat meat. We hunt. We keep and slaughter cattle. We fish. Sealing is no different. If we didn't keep the seal population in check, it would explode. Just look what they did to the Atlantic fishery last time we stopped the hunt. The population exploded and they devoured every fish they could get.
Ian from N.B.
said
We have to get off our pedestals and come down to earth. HUMANS ARE JUST ANOTHER ANIMAL SPECIES."
I don't go around killing crocodiles, but if I got near one it would probably try and kill me. So by your logic I should kill the Crocodile first. It treat's me as it's next meal so I should return the favour. Same goes with lions, bears, sharks, pirahana, etc.
The hunt is sustainable, in all probability there will be even more seals come next years hunt than there were this year. At this rate the only way to start turning the seal population the other way is if we raised the hunt cap to 2 Million or something. I'm no expert, but it's common sense, if the seal population is greater than their food source, then starvation will begin. Is that what you want?
You activists need to choose, fast or slow?
JD in Alberta
said
It’s time Canadians started standing up and defending each other, regardless of what region of the country we are from. Why should a foreign government dictate to us what is right and what is wrong? If we let them pressure to do this what will be next???? Maybe the next time they will want us to stop the brutal slaughter of harvesting sap from maple trees.
Tammy
said
BTW, if anyone's thinking about harping on me, don't...I am a V and I do help human causes as well, so let's not judge one another for writing comments and having opinions. Have a nice day!
Todd
said
Linda in Vancouver
said
Cows,chickens,pigs,and every other animal we humans consume will be next on the hit list of aimals in need of our protection.They are, after all,cute to someone,or at least to each other.
Of course,if the EU has no problem with us imposing tariffs on the products they sell to Canada to pay the incomes lost by the sealers,it might get them a place at the discussion table when future harvests are discussed.
Yes.They are cute.But so are a lot of other creatures consumed by humans.And seals,in no way are and endangered species Maybe these bleeding hearts in the EU should quit their whining,get off their asses,and go do their share of the work in Afghanistan.They would be more credible if they cared as much about our men and women there as they do about an increasing population of seals.
Nancy
said
Most Canadians want the seal hunt to stop, however politicians here do what will buy them a seat at the next election. Harper can't afford to lose any seats and Hearn can't commit political suicide by stopping the seal hunt.
History is repeating itself: the only reason Canada stopped ripping nursing whitecoats from their mothers and bludgeoning them to death in the '80s was because of an international outcry, not out of the goodness of our own hearts. We haven't learned anything- we still need other people to tell us to stop our barbaric ways. Shame!
Doug
said
Videos you watch are probably from many years ago. Do you know how a cow is slaughtered, a large spike on a machine is driven through its brain. Ever had veal? Thats even worse. Sealers are picked on as they are not a huge industry such as the beef industry, which has the money, and political backing to move forward without complication.
Back to you
said