CTV News | Truscott receives $6.5M for wrongful conviction

Canada -   

Truscott receives $6.5M for wrongful conviction

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News: Scott Laurie with Truscott's reaction
CTV Toronto: Paul Bliss on repairing a reputation
CTV Newsnet: Author and journalist Julian Sher on the debt of gratitude owed to Steven Truscott
CTV Newsnet: Ontario Attorney General Chris Bentley discusses the compensation and what it means for Truscott
CTV Newsnet: Ontario Attorney General Chris Bentley answers questions from the media

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(70)

CTV.ca News Staff

Date: Mon. Jul. 7 2008 10:40 PM ET

Steven Truscott is calling the Ontario government's $6.5 million compensation package for his wrongful murder conviction "bittersweet."

But Truscott says money will never truly pay back the years of his life lost while in prison.

Ontario Attorney General Chris Bentley announced the package on Monday. It also includes $100,000 to be paid to Truscott's wife Marlene.

"This is the final and long-awaited step in recognizing Steve's innocence," said the couple in a statement released Monday from Guelph, Ont.

"We are also painfully aware that no amount of money could ever truly compensate Steven for the terror of being sentenced to hang at the age of 14, the loss of his youth, or the stigma of living for almost 50 years as a convicted murderer."

They said they plan to use the money to live the rest of their lives in "peace and tranquility."

In August, the Ontario Court of Appeal found Truscott not guilty in the rape and murder of 12-year-old Lynne Harper in 1959.

"It is our hope that Mr. Truscott and his family will be able to spend their time on the rest of life's journey," Bentley told members of the press assembled for the announcement at the legislature.

Harper was killed near Clinton, Ont. A court convicted Truscott, 14 years old at the time, of her murder.

He was initially sentenced to death by hanging -- the youngest Canadian to be dealt capital punishment -- but after four months on death row the sentence was commuted to life in prison.

Truscott spent almost 10 years in jail followed by nearly 40 years on parole and has always maintained his innocence.

Marlys Edwardh, one of Truscott's lawyers, said the money can never undo the harm done.

"Could it ever fix it, erase it or change it in any way? The answer, of course, is no," she said. "It's just money."

Justice tasked with compensation report

Immediately after the August verdict, former attorney general Michael Bryant asked retired Appeal Court Justice Sydney Robins to create a report analyzing whether Truscott should be compensated by the province. The package announced Monday acts on recommendations from Robins' report.

In April, the Ontario legislature approved a motion seeking compensation with all-party support. The vote came well in advance of Robins' report, leading some MPs to suggest it was held prematurely.

Bentley said Harper's family was told of the government's decision to award Truscott $6.5 million.

Harper's family opposed compensation for Truscott because the appeal verdict did not explicitly clear him of responsibility for the girl's murder. While Truscott was acquitted of the 1959 crime, the Ontario Court of Appeal stopped short of declaring him innocent due to a lack of physical evidence.

Harper's brother told the Globe and Mail newspaper on Monday that the family considers the compensation "a real travesty."

Barry Harper told the Globe he would be meeting with his lawyers to discuss blocking the award.

"I don't think there's many options open," Harper told the Globe from Ohio.

Bentley said his thoughts are also with the Harper family, which will continue to live with the tragedy of the loss of Lynne Harper forever.

"Our government will do whatever it can to ensure... miscarriages of justice do not occur in the future," he said.

With a reports from CTV Toronto's Paul Bliss

Comments are now closed for this story

Julie from Corner Brook, NL
said

I am very happy to see that Mr. Truscott is being compensating for the miscarriage of justice. Nothing can give him or his family back all the years of normal family life but this certainly will help. Mr. Truscott, I have a great deal of respect for you and your quiet yet persistence in your innocence.



Annie
said

I am glad I lived to see this day! Have a happy healthy life with your family and friends, Mr. Truscott.


Bonnie
said

About time!

Have fun, Mr. Truscott...for the first time.


Allan Eizinas
said

Unlike previous similar payouts, Truscott was never declared “innocent”. I suggest that that should be the criteria for the awarding of compensation.

I do wonder what method is used to calculate the amount of the compensation.



Cheryl
said

Congrats to the Truscott family. This was an incredible miscarriage of justice. Unfortunately it still happens. Reaffirms my opposition to capital punishment. Despite DNA, humans still make mistakes.

C. Anderson
said

Good for him! While it won't erase the many years Mr. Truscott has endured under the black cloud of this issue, nor the time robbed of him in prison, it may make his and his family's remaining time more comfortable. I wish him peace.
C. Anderson


JET
said

All the money in the world will not give him back the 10 years he spent behind bars, nor the time up to his acquittal. But it's a start.
Enjoy your life Steven! And if you're thinking of starting a charity/foundation with some of the money, I suggest supporting DNA labs or assistance for other wrongfully accused persons


Sandra Belleville Ontario
said

All the money in the world will not give the man his life back. All the best to Mr Truscott and his family.


Richard
said

Arar got 10 mil. for ten months. The government owes Truscott a lot more for 50 years of agony!!


Lindsay Morgan
said

I for one remember when this tragedy occured and how shocked Toronto was that a young girl would be murdered in our city. I do not believe our society and city have been the same since.
I am all for Mr. Truscott receiving this compensation and wish him all the best.
He was truly badly treated by our system and is after all one of our own.


Sandra
said

Ontario Government.
Put your mouth were your money is.
Clear his name once and for all.
It is the tax payers money not yours.
It is very easy to give away someone elses money.



Frank Buchan
said

So now we don't even need to find innocence to pay out cash. Wonderful precedent. His guilt or innocence is irrelevant to that comment, just as it was to the payout.


larry
said

6.5 Million sounds nice. But you can't give Mr. Truscott back the almost 50 years of his life that was taken away. He just can't relive those years.
Judges and lawyers who wrongfully convict a person should be held accountable for what they have done. Even judges today are making grave errors in their judgments.
They are letting the obvious criminals off easy and those they are not sure of are handed heavy penalties.


Wise Wajid
said

Now THIS man was wrongly convicted and deserves FAR more than 6.5 million dollars! And I'm sure this is the LAST we will hear of Mr. Truscott because he has always shown grace and class and will continue to do so. God Bless you Sir. I have followed your journey for years and your conduct has always been exemplary!


Mike
said

I'm getting a bit tired as a taxpayer having to compensate all those found wrongfully convicted. Could we not hold the "witnesses" to account as well considering that it is often by their statements that that convict these men? In other cases victims are swearing up and down a stack of bibles that the police have the right man in custody but it turns out to be so wrong 2 decades later from DNA evidence. I don't want to further victimize these victims but they should not be allowed a license to become criminally negligent. Neither should the prosecutors. I think after too much time in the courts they have lost their objectivity and turn these trials in to a game they must win at any cost.


Shamaro
said

Good for you Mr. Truscott. This countries judicial system wrongly convicted you and had taken away your best years of your life.

Now I know that the 6.5million isn't going to bring those years back, but you can invest in your childrens and grandchildrens future.

Our judicial system needs to be overhauled. It seems that there are many people convicted of crimes who are innocent and many more who are guilty that get to go free.




Roadrobber
said

For those proponents of the death penalty, this is yet another example of someone wrongly convicted of murder. Truscott, and many others like him, would not be around right now if Canada had not abolished the death penalty. Let's ensure it's never brought back. It is a true miscarriage of justice that Truscott was convicted, it would be the ultimate miscarriage of justice had he been put to death by the state and a mistake that could not be undone.


Ben McLaurin
said

"Arar got 10 mil. for ten months. The government owes Truscott a lot more for 50 years of agony!!"

It was not just 10 months. It was 10 months of brutal torture.



Denny
said

Nothing personal against the Harper family, but no matter who would have been found guilty and subsequently cleared, you would blame them for life regardless. That is understandable, since at the time they provide you with convincing, albeit very wrong information. I read the entire Appeal sumassion and suggest you get a copy and read it word for word. Mr Truscott was framed, period.

As for compensation, i agree there is no magic formula to determine how much or how little is acceptable. Nothing brings back what has been done, both for the Truscott and Harper families. I would even suggest some compensation be paid to the Harper's as well for their own personal suffering all these years. Neither party will probably ever get closure.


Paul on Vancouver Island
said

This is one of many criminal cases that justifies not having capital punishment as an option in Canada, or elsewhere for that matter.

The justice system in Canada for the most part works well; however, there are times when it does not, and this case is one of those times.

The Ontario Government was correct to compensate Mr. Truscott for his wrongful conviction.


sarah
said

I agree with Richard.He is owed a lot more than 6.5 million.


Sonya Van Kruistum
said

Due to the litigious nature of our culture I am usually quite cynical of these settlements. However the travesty of justice this man experienced makes me say, "Congratulations Mr. Truscott!! I wish we had given you justice instead."
Sonya-Toronto


Where is the Justice
said

There are 2 victims here.
Mr. Truscott, for having his life wasted away in prison.

The Harper family for never recieving justice in the murder of their daughter.

I feel equally bad for both


Karen & Ron
said

We are so pleased to hear Steven has received some restitution for the horror he has lived thru. If not already done, our wish is that Lynns family recognize what I believe most Canadians believe, that Steven did not kill their daughter. There is still a lot of healing to be done. Perhaps in time, there can be communication between the families to grieve together.


Sandi
said

Amen to that!!

This man lost his childhood and it likely changed who he would become. Not to mention what his parents and family went through.

Steven, enjoy!


Darrin
said

Just imagine, at the age of 14, that you were going to die by hanging, he was just a boy, put yourself in those shoes, think of what his parents were going through. He deserves the 6.5 million and much more!!!


George
said

Miscarriages of justice will always occur.

Mike said:
"I'm getting a bit tired as a taxpayer having to compensate all those found wrongfully convicted."

Comments like this underscore my point.


KC
said

Blessing to you & your family Steven
It has been a long road.

I have folllowed this miscarriage of justice for the entire time& I am happy for Steven & his family , My hat goes off to his wife Marlene for her devotion & non stop endevour to prove this stupid justice system wrong .
May you & your family enjoy your well deserved paeace & happinness

God Bless


Marian
said

This is a note to "Ben McLaurin" for his comment "It was not just 10 months. It was 10 months of brutal torture.", this is so incorrect and as well alleged torture and spending 10 years in prison is what to you ?? Steven Truscott shoud have much more money then just 6.5mil. Question should be how in the world they have calculated that ??



Mike Barton
said

I am very happy for the Truscott family, this is truly deserving. Although it is my personal belief that it is not enough, I do also beleive Steven when he was quoted in saying it is not about money but more about finally being free.

Sadly this case has torn 2 familes up as the Harpers have not got the justice their daughter deserved.

I wish Steven all the happiness life can bring his family in the years to come… they deserve it.

Sincerly,

Mike Barton - Guelph




Q
said

The compensation should have been MUCH GREATER!!!! Enjoy just the same Mr. & Mrs. Truscott :o)


andrea
said

OMG how awful Mr. Truscott. I'm sure you lived a miserable life in prison. I dont' know you but I am so happy to see that you have a huge smile on your face and are finally set free. Live life to the fullest my dear. May you be blessed with many many more to spend with your family. I feel so sorry for you having to be jailed for so long. May God Bless you and your Family.


B.B.
said

No it is not enough but finally Mr. Truscot will have some peace. It was a long time ago and I think at the time he was a scapegoat as they had to charge someone just to keep the community quiet.


Rob
said

I feel for this man and anybody wrongfully convicted of a crime. Why is the taxpayer the one suffering though. The government can give out unlimited amounts of money to others for wrongdoings and it is the tex payer that suffers the consequences. How about holding the ones that were involved in the wrongdoing pay the consequences, being allowed to be sued by the victim, this keeps our society stronger and makes individuals responsible for their actions instead of the society.


Daniel H
said

And what becomes of the people who screwed this up in the first place? Where are the police officers who investigated this and came up with the wrong answers? Where is the prosecutor who had all the evidence to get a conviction? Maybe they should be putting out $ for not getting it right! Make the right people pay the $ and guilt for doing it wrong.


tazzy
said

I am happy for Mr Truscott but what about the Harper family? Due to the negligence of the Justice system we as taxpayers have to pay twice for one murder case


Eric
said

3 Questions?

Will these large payouts make it even MORE difficult for others in Mr. Trescott's position to finally find justice?

How long will it be, or is it already happening, before governments make it nearly impossible for these people to get a fair shake because the governments involved just do not want to make the payouts?

How much cover up is going on now?

I say increase the number of investigators currently working on these cases and get those wrongfully convicted OUT of jail.




B
said

The money will never compensate him for the years lost, he deserves much more. Mr. Truscott and family enjoy your new found wealth, I hope it brings you some degree of peace and satisfaction.


lulu
said

50 years of crap from the federal justice system and that's the best they can do????????
Give the man a medal, a huge apology and a LOT more than 6.5 million.
No, it won't give him back what he lost, but it could sure help the rest of his life (and that of his family) be a better experience.


Don
said

Makes me ashamed of how slow our justice system works, and then drags its heals when it is found to be in error of a decision. Compensation for Mr Truscott should be far more than this amount.
14 years old and sentanced to hang....there is no amount of money can buy back the horror he and his family must have felt.
25 million would be more like it...and even that is cheap!
Impossible for me to comprhend what he must have gone through for all those years!
I hope the rest of his life is happy and full of promise.


Krystal
said

I have been studying Mr. Truscott's case as well as many other wrongful convictions in Canada. Believe me, there have been a lot and that's only the ones we can/or have detected. There needs to be a change to the Canadian criminal justice system and this is proof. I am glad to see Mr. Truscott has finally received some sort of reparation for this (not that it could possibly make up for what has happened). I am also pleased to see so many people supporting his reparation.

We need to make some serious changes.


Murray LaRocque
said

Way to good Steven.....



I am so pleased for you and your family.

Please enjoy what life has to offer and may it be nothing but happiness.


Ross (Kelowna)
said

Long overdue and not enough!! One of the greatest injustices that this country has done. I can remember "the steven truscott story" being removed from our school because it tarished the reputation of police in our country. Mr. Truscott I hope you and yours can now spent the remaining days in peace, but NO you shouldn't forget. The people have Canada has not forgotten you.


Jayme
said

1)I feel for him big-time that he lost many years. Now with that said, no amount of money will bring that back.

2)The taxpayers are they ones that are hit hard. To those saying he should be paid more, that's all good, but it's the taxpayers who are paying.

Yes it would be nice from him to get more cash but not from the taxpayers.


Roadrobber
said

Rob, I can answer your question quite quickly as to why the taxpayer is the one suffering. It's because it was the taxpayer (the state itself who represents us all) who put him in jail in the first place.


Ken
said

The Ontario government shortchanged Mr. Truscott and with the paltry $6.5 million for 50 years of hell, it continues to shortchange him. The $100,000 for his wife is an insult. Justice has not been served in this case.


glen gaffney
said

Throughout all those years, Steve Truscott has acted with class and diginity. He deserves this and more. Enjoy the money but nothing can bring the young life you missed out on.


Phil
said

Finally a recognition by the Government that he was wronged. They should make it complete and declare him innocent of the crime. To those who complain that the taxpayer is on the hook for the cash. It is our system and we are ultimately responsible. Any suggestion to go after the people who caused all this grief is pointless. They are all dead.


dave
said

To Lindsay Morgan;
Your memory is not that good. It happened in Clinton, not Toronto


Jeffery
said

No matter how much the compnsation is, Mr.Truscott has got it now. But I wonder who should be responsible for the miscarriage of justice,the judge,the lawyers,or who else? I don't know how my country's judicial system runs, but I know they have already been proven wrong once again. Shamaro,I agree with you.Our judicial system needs to be overhauled.
In addition, who is the real murderer of that little girl?
Anyhow, Mr.Truscott,enjoy the rest of your own life,please. God bless you and your family.


Con Noble
said

No amount of money can atone for the grief Mr. Truscott and his family have beenput through.


S Embree
said

I'm not sure which is worse, to observe wrongfully convicted because of a miscarriage of justice or watching a killer go free because of a miscarriage of justice.(I have know the latter personally)

To the Harper family:
I am so sorry for you loss and the unending questions this will lead to.

To Steven Truscott:
I don't know if you are innocent or guilty it is not my place to judge. I hope the rest of your journey is in peace if you are truly innocent as you say you are.


Jason Daniel Baker
said

It is about time but in my view the settlement is not enough. Nothing can be enough for what this man and others like him have gone through.

I want to remind advocates of capital punishment that we could have executed this man for no other reason than he was in the wrong place at the wrong time.


margaret swindells
said

I am so happy for Steven. I never believed he was guilty. My heart goes out to the Harpers as there has been no closure for them. As a christian I will be praying for them. I believe the killer can still be caught.
God bless both families.


Mike
said

There is no doubt that Mr. Truscott deserves much more for a life lost in our prison system. Mr. Truscott’s example and all of the other wrongful convictions that have come to light over the past few years beg the question, "what is wrong with our police?” They are the ones who investigate and bring forth the “evidence” that has sent the innocent to prison. Mistakes such as these cannot be excused for they clearly show that we are all at risk in the hands of a system that cannot distinguish between fact and fiction.


ricardo
said

everyone in canada always seems to be in favour of someone receiving compensation for something...


Ed
said

It is important to remember that virtually none of the witnesses, nor any of the forensic evidence was available second time around.

Was the first trial a gong-show? Absolutely, however his accquital (which I can never spell) was based on the lack of useable evidence more than anything else. Read the case - more likely than not he did it.

However, more likely than not doesn't cut it in our justice system which is as it should be. Best to think of this case as the price we pay for being free.


Michael
said

I agree with some of the other posters......those who testified....investigated...(?) and prosecuted this case are responsible for Mr Truscott's wrongful conviction...and are also responsible for the Harper family's ongoing grief and suffering. They should bear some of the cost ...not just the taxpayers


jayme
said

How about this they set up a bank account where people who want can give more money to the fund. As it stands now if we keep going on this pace in 10 years our taxes will be very very high. I would like the turcotts to get more cash but i don't think via gov funds is the way.


John KW
said

I am glad that Mr. Truscott is finally being given compensation for the injustice that was brought upon him and his family. Of course, $6.5 million hardly seems enough to make up for such a vast amount of lost time with family and friends.

I am sick of people complaining about the "tax burden" such compensation has upon the taxpayers. I for one am more than willing to pay 59 cents (assuming it is the approx. 11 million Ontario citizens flipping the bill)to help reverse a great injustice.
Mistakes happen - thankfully MUCH LESS often here in Canada than in many other countries around the world. I am fine with the small amount of "tax" it takes to help compensate those who are unfortunate enough to be victims.

That being said, I am also willing to pay a greater tax bill to ensure that the victims of crime are also compensated for their experiences.



Ian
said

To anyone saying "50 years of hell", please note Mr. Truscott was released on parole in 1969, so he was in prison for 10 years, from the ages of 14-24.

That said.. Six-point-five million bucks? With some people here saying it's not enough? I thought the idea of compensation was to put someone back where they would have been if the wrong done to them had not occurred. Not to finance a worry-free luxury retirement at the expense of the rest of us. Would this guy have really made a multimillionaire out of himself had he not been in prison? Just how was this number arrived at?


SARAH
said

Steven derserves must more than 6.5 million.He has had to live through this his entire life.Being told you were going to be hanged at 14 years old, knowing this was a crime you didn't commit.None of us can know what that feels like. Knowing Steven and his family as I do he is the most honest, kind,hard working man I have ever met.He has handled this incredibly well.For those of you who say you don't know if hes guilty or innocent he has fought for the past 50 years of his life to have his name cleared.If he was guilty he wouldn't have gone through all of this. Congrats Steven,to you and your family.You deserve this and MUCH more!!!


Max
said

While I wholly support the Death Penalty in principle, this is just another example of why it should remain ditched: the justice system doesn't always work.

As for the $6.5M, I think a person in his shoes deserves more. We should be prepared to heavily compensate those people who have an entire chunk of their life forfeited while we muck around indefinitely, trying to get a certain end-result.

I can appreciate those comments suggesting it's dangerous to compensate someone not formally determined "innocent," but I'm comfortable that Mr. Truscott isn't a threat to our safety. If someone can't be proven guilty, then they're innocent. That's it.

Let the man enjoy his remaining years.


ab
said

I remember reading Steven Trucott's case very well,I was only approx 12 years of age, and have always followed his cases. Steven I remember your family on a few of the bases here in Canada,hope I can be the first to tell you that 90% ofthe people in Canada, plus the Canadian Forces that were deployed in station's such as France and Germany during that time,always beleived in your innocence. Maybe we should elect the Officers and Gentlemen into Office, instead of the High priced lawyers. If the forces would have been allowed to investigate this miscarriage of justice( I use the term "justice" loosely. All could have and would have been Strict,Swift and effective, also it would have been over 45 years ago with the evidence, or the lack of.

I am happy to have been around to see you get to the end of this story, and start anew. I have read in several comments today that he deserves the Order of Canada. Congratulations.


Doug Jones
said

I am now 57 years old and I have heard Mr. Truscott's name for many many years. I can't thank the medical community enough for developing some newer falesafe systems so people like Steven can be proven innocent. Going forward in our history, we hopefully will never see this type of false imprisonment again!!

I hope you can have a happy life Steven, I will pray for that!!

Doug


Thomas C
said

$6,500,000 will provide $100,000 for each of 50 years plus $1.5 million in damages. That number does not sound patently unreasonable to me.




dee
said

Very happy to see a justice here but, what does this say about "who believed he did the crime". Our courts (sometimes) are to eager to convict and case in point a young boy sentenced to hang! Justice was not on his side then and now, should receive a lot more.


G DeWolf Shaw CFA
said

I was born in 1950 and watched my federal government try a 14 year old as an adult and sentence him to death -- just like Alabama, my Mother said at the time.

Thank God we stopped killing the innocent in time for Truscott who joins a terribly short list of a few who were saved; imagine how many we killed before 1962; as America does now in 38 states. God Bless Our Canadian Nation.


Alex Nelson
said

I think the wrongful conviction of anybody by our systems of justice is a real tradgedy above all cost.


Pat
said

He should have received more, a lot more.


Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz