CTV News | Canada falling behind on innovation: report

Top Stories -   

Canada falling behind on innovation: report

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV Newsnet: Glen Hodgson, The Conference Board

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(29)

CTV.ca News Staff

Date: Mon. Jun. 30 2008 10:14 AM ET

The Conference Board of Canada has tabled a blunt assessment of Canada's place in the world. In a new report, it argues Canada is falling behind its industrialized peers when it comes to innovation and its "mediocre performance" in six key areas is a recipe for future problems.

The Conference Board's report -- entitled "How Canada Performs: A Report Card on Canada" -- graded Canada's performance against 16 other industrialized nations in categories such as the economy, the environment, education, health, society and innovation.

While Canada performed well in four of the categories with grades of "B" or better, the Conference Board gave it a "D" in both innovation and the environment.

And relative to other countries, Canada placed in the bottom half in a majority of the categories. When it comes to the economy, for example, Canada was listed 11th, and on the environment it placed a dismal 15th place.

The authors state Canada's performance in the innovation category is especially worrying because of its impact on the other categories.

"Our performance in innovation is stunningly poor," the authors write in the report.

"This poor showing is a serious weakness in Canada's overall performance and an alarming portent for the future."

Here is Canada's ranking a number of other key categories:

  • Economy: B
  • Education: B
  • Health: B
  • Social Environment: B
  • Environment: C
  • Innovation: D

Out of the 17 countries included in the study, here's where Canada fell:

  • Economy: 11
  • Education: 2
  • Health: 9
  • Social environment: 10
  • Environment: 15
  • Innovation: 13

The report states that Canada may actually be handicapped by abundant natural resources, which are masking potential problems in the overall economy.

"Canada's reliance on natural resource products partially explains why Canada derives less of its revenues from innovative products," according to the report.

The authors note, European firms are deriving more than 25 per cent of their revenue from innovative products and services -- a significantly higher proportion than their Canadian counterparts.

The report states Canada isn't just competing against industrialized countries. The global economy means it can't take solace for long in being ahead of the developing world.

"China, India and Brazil, among others, are knocking on our door," said the report.

To improve innovation and the economy, the report recommends:

  • increase product and investment
  • improve domestic investment in machinery, equipment, and infrastructure
  • improve tax system for investors

The Conference Board's report did have some good news. Canada placed only behind Finland in the education category. But even here, the report states it could do better by producing more doctoral graduates, and more graduates with math, science, and engineering degrees.

Comments are now closed for this story

Mrs A
said

Doesn't surprise me. Most of our larger corporations eventually get purchased by bigger conglomerates that find cheaper manufacturing methods such as running to China or whatever is better for the bottomline. I can't remember the last time I read in the business pages about corporations or government offering grants for research and development. Does that even exist in this country?


Layton in Moncton
said

I once spoke to a politician about introducing solar powered street lighting to remove current exterior lighting from the grid. The extra power generated could feed into the grid when the lights batteries were charged. This politician seemed more interested in the welfare of the company that provides fuel to the utility than the savings in both dollars and carbon. Its our current cadre of politicians who are joined at the hip not only to the status quo but to their FINANCIAL task masters, big business, that inhibit true innovation. I think Canada needs a cleaning fire to go through our elected ranks, and that will only happen when big business is OUT of the business of political contributions. When the voting populace becomes sickened by "our" representatives, they may kick them out and replace them with someone who will stop pandering to the corporate world, whose only interest in innovation is when it makes them money. But before any of that can happen, first the populace HAS TO VOTE. I have voted in every election I have been of age for and I'm 36 now. If Canada wants innovation, we'll have to VOTE it in.


francesco
said

How can Canada innovate for the future of the country? The present government is draining the cupboard for their own furtherance making " at home investment " practically impossible. Also, look at the past history, since WW2, and you will find many technilogical marvels not accepted by our idiot politicians, and/or the ideas shunted aside to protect the interests of other countries.We need some damned politicians who will stand up for Canada come hell or high water.


Lis
said

Please note that the story previous to this one on the top stories list is all about a group out of Calgary is set to launch a miniature asteroid tracker. Sounds pretty innovative to me.


Doug BC
said

Whoa!!Why so negative.This is actually a fairly good report for Canada.A decade ago our currency was 63 cents US,and our debt was spiraling out of control.Canada was often referred to as Canuckistan,and thought to be heading toward collapse.
Now,while we haven't finished solving that problem,we get good marks on our economy,our debt is going down and we have surpluse or balanced budgets.
And,while making huge strides this way,we still are ranking very well in social issues like health,education and social environment,which most of us claim to be our most important values.
We have challenges to improve productivity and a better climate for manufacturers to build in Canada.While I have some concerns about a lack of a unified strategy that involves ALL regions,I am not pulling my hair out.
Frankly,with lower debt,declining taxes,and a country full of natural resources,I think Canada is well positioned to keep making forward strides.
Innovation wil come when we have a stable and competetive business environment.Our glass is more than half full.


Melanie
said

I think "francescos" post shows how out of the real world many Canadians are.
Innovations really don't need to be accepted by "idiot politicians".They need to be accepted by the market place that finds them useful.Government needs to create a good environment for the really smart people to be able to invent,and market their inventions.
And,I also question his assertion that the current government is "draining the cupboard".I would have to wonder,for exaple,in the last budget,paying of $10 billion dollars of our nation debt,and returning billions of dollars of overtaxation to taxpayers,can be considered anything but moving in the right direction.
I don't care very much for Mr.Harper or his arrogant style.But really,the direction we are going on economic issues is far superior to anything we've had since the 1960's.


Michael in MTL
said

"This politician seemed more interested in the welfare of the company that provides fuel to the utility than the savings in both dollars and carbon. Its our current cadre of politicians who are joined at the hip not only to the status quo but to their FINANCIAL task masters, big business, that inhibit true innovation. I think Canada needs a cleaning fire to go through our elected ranks"

Right on, I think Canada needs some new younger blood with a good vision for the future of Canada in parliament that involves sustainability at all levels. The current group of idiots representing Canada at the moment needs to go. I'm at the point where I don't even have any interest in voting for a federal election anymore because I like neither leader for any political party in Canada. Canada needs a change! Canada needs a Barack Obama! Out with the old in with the new


A nation of Blah
said

This is not shocking, this is a country where only mediocrity and conformity thrive.

Anything or anyone who has new, innovative ideas is battered into submission.

"Who do you think you are?" is what the innovative people tend to hear by the mediocre masses.

The people of this country are so terrified of anything new or different that they turn ugly and threatening in the fact of challenge in every facet of life: technology, culture, race, media ... all of it.

Everyone must look the same, sound the same, act the same and have the same ideologies about everything.

I guarantee you a bunch of conversvatives will swarm this board with the following inanity: If you dont like it here, leave!

Blah.



WELFARE STATE
said

Liberal governments have historically always created cushy government jobs. When you have a population in which 70% of the workforce are directly or indirectly working for the government, innovation will suffer. People have no reason to invent or be creative.
We don't have much driving force in this country - people are not hungry enough to be innovative. The people are just slow now. The only innovation we have is when a special interest group gets into the media wanting something extra to recognize their insignificance, taxes go up. The situation will just get worse when creating a welfare state.


ET
said

Layton in Moncton...that is a very interesting idea. As I have recently been in contact with MY local MPP's office, here in Ontario, I have relayed your suggestion. The thing about projects is that you just need a successful pilot project going somewhere. Once you see it work in one case, someone else will usually pick it up and use it.

This news does not surprise me in the slightest. We are going NOWHERE with President Harper at the helm. If you wanna get something done, you better go to your provincial government or city. The only thing the CONServatives care about is the oilsands, and Oilberta's economy. This all fits right in with Mr. Flaherty's hate of his home province, Ontario. There's a reason he got voted out of provincial parliament here...hope the rest of the country can see it now.


nowonder
said

Example: instead of investing on and exporting green technology, we are defending and investing on the tar sands!! Bad move. We will pay for this mistake for years to come...


WELFARE STATE
said

I forgot, money should invested and made available for real ideas - not for producing adult entertainment.


Wake Up Call
said

Buy products made in Canada.
It is getting harder and harder to find products made in Canada, let alone even just assembled in Canada. We need to revisit our trading policies, and ensure that more products required by Canadians are completely made in Canada from Canadian Resources when available.
People wonder why their is less R&D in Canada, I think it is because we do not support Canadian businesses and opt for cheaper products made in China for American Companies.


DG
said

Tax cut for investors is better than government financing. Investors combined financing is larger than government financing.


Mickey
said

What I don't get is that we ranked second in education but ranked poorly in almost all else. If we are producing a bunch of unimaginative grads who can't steer our economy in the right direction and effectively manage our environment and social programs, then how great can our education system be?


Phil
said

What sort of innovation are we talking about here? Innovation in manufacturing or in the realm of ideas and services.

If the former, then it is the fault of every Canadian who prefers cheap goods made in Asia to those produced at home; who prefers to do nothing and say nothing as even more manufacturers give up on Canada; who prefer their high-paying union job and will do anything to keep working on products that do not match the market. Also, we have to blame corporations who simply feed the bottom line for investors - institutions really, not real people - who are only interested in taking profit from a company, not ensuring its future profitablity through R&D.

If it is for lack or original ideas in ALL fields, then we need to put more money into research, so that what may be deemd "useless" may be seized upon by someone with imagination and developed into something that benefits all.

Don't blame politicians; after all, regardless of party, they are only interested in being re-elected, and doing those things that will get them elected. This holds true for Conservatives, NDP, Bloc, and especially Liberals: after all, they successfully did the right things to maintain control of Canada for nearly a century! After all, they are entitles to their entitlements, one of which is their entitlement to rule Canada.

A character in Henry IV part 2 wants to get rid of all the lawyers. Perhaps we should just get rid of all the politicians and start over!


Linda in Vancouver
said

We've spent too much time building the so called "nanny state" that innovation is not necessary. After all, it's true that "necessity is the mother of invention".
The idea of using government grants and subsidies is one that has failed.Even if they lead to successful inventions,the high cost of doing business in Canada almost always sees those inventions being manufactured somewhere else.After taxpayers funded the research.
I kind of agree with Doug.This is not all that bad.And no one country will get good grades in all categories.
We were moving towards a welfare sate for a long time.I think we have changed direction,although have to admit we have a long ways to go.
In my opinion,the next challenge is to make Canada competetive enough that businesses will want to manufacture here,and to make sure the huge profits we see from selling resources are invested wisely so future Canadians can build on our successes.
I do think,if energy is the future,ALL the premiers and federal governments need to get together and develope a long term plan that ensures Canada has a goal of self sufficiency in energy.I think,given all of our natural resources,we should be able to do that,and still have very reasonably priced energy.That would surely attract companies that manufacture things to do so here.


gtiguy27
said

Innovation in Canada died in the late fifties when the Avro Arrow was chopped up and massacred. Our spirit and national identity in technology and Development died that dark day.
Heck, Canada makes an Electric car that was developed and built in quebec...where is it not allowed to be sold? IN CANADA!! (soon to be a dissolved company once bought out)


Glen Quayle
said

Could the lack of innovation have anything to do with the lack of political leadership?


Albert
said

Innovation does not come from politicians, it comes from scientists and engineers with ideas that are supported. Sadly, Canada has very little to offer new scientists, including those with advanced degrees. Most of the graduating PhDs I know have left for post-doctoral positions in the US and abroad, and will not return. There is nothing here for them. Canadian universities can barely find new graduate students, and rely largely on foreign students who leave when they finish. Many universities have hiring freezes for new faculty, which hastens the brain drain. Gov't funding for science and technology research has declined for years, although Harper increased it a tiny bit lately. We get a D in Canada because science investment is a very low priority.


tony
said

Canada has tremendous potential but so few people who can wield power in the Global Market. Our talents go south of the border or is bought out by American corporations. We need people with a bold strategy to move our country forward. For example, if we lose a factory to China why not own one in China? USA and England have been doing it for decades, gaining outstanding profits. Or are we too busy drinking Starbuck Lattes while listening to itunes?


Jeffery
said

It doesn't matter that Canada's performance on innovation is stunning poor.Under the globalized circumstance,every country should concentrate on the issues that it is skilled at with low cost.The others like innovation should be done in other country instead of in Canada because we are not good at it.Just imagine,even though we have invent something,but the cost is much higher than we expected.What can we get from it?


Jacquie
said

To everyone who is saying that buying more made-in-Canada goods is the way to improve innovation, is not understanding basic incentive structures in place here in Canada. Buying only Canadian made goods is like putting the bench warmer on the starting line: the people who weren't good enough to compete at the top levels aren't somehow going to get to that level if it's just handed to them-they're still going to suck once they get out on the floor. It's harsh, I know, but if Canadian goods are going to be contenders on the international level, they had better be as innovative as the others. Buying goods from elsewhere doesn't drive away domestic innovation - it should stimulate innovation at home so that they can be players on the international markets, too.


Socialism is killing us
said

The only innovation Canada has is how to create a bigger welfare state by getting more Canadians on the poggie along with "new" Canadians. Canada also taxes innovation to death. Why are companies going to the U.S or Asia or Scotland? Lower taxes and help for companies that create.


craig
said

"Example: instead of investing on and exporting green technology, we are defending and investing on the tar sands!! Bad move. We will pay for this mistake for years to come..."

Nowonder: The oil sands are one of the biggest areas of innovation in Canada. Alberta has strict caps limiting emissions from the industry and the oil companies are currently designing and implementing new technologies to lessen the emissions generated by the oilsand drilling.

Also, millions of dollars are being put into research to start up carbon sequestering so that CO2 doesn't even make it into the atmosphere.


Jeff Robillard
said

The city of Ottawa used to be a hot-bed of technology innovation, and is now suffering a high-tech meltdown. Lack of innovation can be partly attributed to venture capital investors that cause a move of the technology and the innovators (the brainiacs) to the United States because of American buyers and their desire for a short term exit strategy. Canadian Banks invest and lose a lot of money in foreign countries; they should consider doing the same for Canadian technology entrepreneurs.


PS
said


I somewhat agree with Phil... It’s really dumb to always see folks turn everything into a Liberal vs Conservative issue... How idiotic… Politics has got nothing to do with it in a democratic society... Conservatives were ellected by Canadians, and will be removed if/when Canadians choose, that's it...

We’re falling behind in innovation because we’re a developed, natural resource biased economy (hum funny Australia has the exact same problem according to this and many other studies). We need to counter that ‘blessing’ by ensuring we don’t allow private enterprise (the only long-term creators of wealth) to simply get complacent and chase the easy, readily available pickings (i.e. raw natural resources). We need to ‘punish’ companies (national and foreign) that don’t invest in R&D (something Canada clearly lags in), that don’t invest in new technology, that don’t actively participate and shape our higher education programs through grants and other vehicles. And we MUST reward those that do! We do this by tweaking the corporate tax system, by giving significant tax breaks to companies that invest in education, R&D, work-force training, and by making the others that don’t pay dearly. We need to tell the world, we’re open for business but you better be ready to innovate in Canada, and if you do you’ll be rewarded with a transparent, stable, low taxed, business friendly environment. I think in such an environment we’d see more R&D and the associated high-paid jobs that go with it, we’d see more innovation, and increased productivity… You’d see Canada export more value added goods the world must absolutely have but can’t necessarily produce itself (at least not as economically)… Forcing Canadian consumers to buy Canadian made goods even though better/cheaper is available from elsewhere will never work and must never be allowed to happen as it will just reduce the purchasing power of consumers and reward Canadian industry for being inefficient and allow it to survive in a bubble (which will burst sooner or later with tragic consequences). Isn’t this what’s happening to companies that didn’t innovate and instead decided to take advantage of a falling Canadian dollar in order to remain competitive?

What do we need government for (federal AND provincial)? To seed the proper business environment through taxation schemes thus making it compelling for the right private enterprise to set up shop in Canada AND innovate in Canada… Other then that all we need government to do is stay the darn out of the way…



Trudy
said

Enough with the innovations. Innovations have us up to our ears in global warming and too many people on the planet.


Mickey
said

Innovation doesn't come from politicians? It sure doesn't but imagine what a country we would be with highly innovative leaders directing policy. Quite frankly I believe our system stymies innovation and we need to get innovative and change the system.


Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz