CTV News | Harper condemns 'stolen' Zimbabwe election

Top Stories -   

Harper condemns 'stolen' Zimbabwe election

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News: Tom Kennedy covers global response
CTV Newsnet: Gretchen Wilson from Johannesburg
Canada AM: Reuters' MacDonald Dzirutwe in Harare
Canada AM: Heidi Holland, author of 'Dinner With Mugabe,' on the leader's strategy of intimidation
Canada AM: Peter Godwin, author of 'When a Crocodile Eats the Sun,' discusses the political intimidation

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(62)

CTV.ca News Staff

Date: Fri. Jun. 27 2008 9:23 PM ET

Prime Minister Stephen Harper added his name to the growing number of world leaders who have condemned Friday's presidential election in Zimbabwe as corrupt.

Harper said that he may be prepared to announce sanctions against the African nation and encouraged other nations to pressure Robert Mugabe's regime.

"Our government has condemned the corrupt vote in the strongest possible terms," he said in a speech for B'nai Brith International on Friday. "We are working with the international community to bring in strong measures to pressure the Mugabe regime which has illegitimately stolen the election."

Harper called Friday's runoff election "an ugly perversion of democracy."

"Because no opposition candidate was fully engaged in the runoff election, Canada refuses to accept that the results are an indication of the will of the Zimbabwean people. This 'election' was stolen," Harper said in a statement released Friday night.

"We call on the Government of Zimbabwe and the Movement for Democratic Change to work with each other and with regional and international mediators toward a negotiated political settlement to end this crisis, which continues to damage peace, security and stability in Zimbabwe and the wider region.

Voters intimidated

Reports from Zimbabwe have indicated widespread voter intimidation Friday.

Some residents said they were forced to vote, others feared violent retribution, and some were threatened with arson.

"What is happening today is not an election. It is an exercise in mass intimidation," Opposition leader Morgan Tsvangirai said at a news conference.

Despite reports of intimidation, it appears the national election had a low voter turnout. The one-candidate runoff vote follows a presidential election in March, during which Tsvangirai seemed to pose a legitimate challenge to the longtime rule of President Robert Mugabe.

Tsvangirai pulled out of the race last Sunday over allegations of state-sponsored violence. As a result, Mugabe, who has ruled the country since 1980, is the only candidate in the unusual runoff vote.

Mugabe has faced mounting international criticism and analysts said reports of voting-day intimidation are not surprising.

In the capital city Harare, armed paramilitary police and pro-ruling party militants patrolled the streets while marshals escorted voters to the polls.

"I've got no option but to go and vote so that I can be safe," said one young voter.

Tsvangirai, whom many looked to as the face of change for Zimbabwe, has been hiding out on-and-off in the Dutch embassy in the days leading up to the election.

He said the results from the Friday vote would "reflect only the fear of the people of Zimbabwe," The Associated Press reported.

Tsvangirai has made it clear to his supporters they should vote for Mugabe if they feel threatened or at risk.

"God knows what is in your heart. Don't risk your lives," he wrote.

The opposition leader's name remains on the ballot, with organizers saying he dropped out too late to print new ones. But Tsvangirai has asked his supporters not to vote for him in order to prevent further violence.

"Quite a few of them are likely to be worried about their personal safety because there have been these mobs of Mugabe supporters going around saying people have to vote," Peter Godwin, author of "When a Crocodile Eats the Sun," told CTV's Canada AM.

"When you vote in Zimbabwe your finger is dyed with an indelible dye and the worry is these mobs will go around after the election checking to see that everybody has this dye and if they don't they'll be beaten up or worse."

Godwin said Tsvangirai had little choice to pull out, and if he had remained in the race, he had little chance of winning.

"I think even if he had stayed in, the playing field was so unlevel -- he wasn't being allowed to campaign, he wasn't being allowed to hold rallies, he wasn't being able to advertise -- the whole thing was a farce. It already wasn't an election," Godwin said.

International criticism

Roy Bennett, the opposition party's treasurer, who is in exile in neighbouring South Africa, called on the world to acknowledge that Mugabe's rule is illegitimate.

"The whole election is a farce," he told Associated Press Television News. "Nobody should endorse that election" and "all pressure that is possible ... should be brought to bear" on Mugabe by African leaders.

U.S. Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice said the U.S. would bring the matter before the UN Security Council.

"Those operating in Zimbabwe should know that there are those ... who believe that the Security Council should consider sanctions," she said. "We intend to bring up the issue of Zimbabwe in the council. We will see what the council decides to do."

The spokesperson for the EU said the election's result will be "hollow and meaningless."

Earlier this week, Nelson Mandela broke his silence on the crisis, calling Mugabe's actions a "tragic failure of leadership."

Heidi Holland, author of "Dinner with Mugabe," said she believed election turnout will be higher in rural areas, where voters are more vulnerable to intimidation.

"I also feel that Mugabe is doing more -- I hope I'm wrong -- than winning a deeply flawed presidential runoff," she said.

"I think he's also getting revenge against his own people, possibly even attempting to wipe out the opposition once and for all in the rural areas, because he has gone back to very much a war footing in the rural areas."

Election observers from The African Union, the main regional Southern African Development Community and African parliamentarians were struggling to monitor the election, with too few authorized monitors to make a difference.

With files from The Canadian Press

Comments are now closed for this story

kevin P
said

Another fine example of United Nations irrelevance. This is utterly disgraceful that nothing has been done to force Mugabe's resignation. Countless people are being murdered every day, and the legitimate government is hiding.

Way to go U.N.! How much money does Canada waste on this obsolete dinosaur?


James
said

This is not the UN's fault. It much more simple than that. This is the fault of men, who allow other men to run roughshod over basic human rights. They fear that if they intervene they may become a target themselves. It is very much "what a man does in his home is none of my business."


yves
said

What a SAD day for that country. Thak god for CANADA. Remember that on Canada day.


FCS
said

If the world cared, all it would take is about 2000 western troops to overthrow this despot. The UN could then take over running the country and actually stage free elections. But this won't happen of course. Relying on other African "nations" to put pressure on Mugabe is a waste of time. Zim. is soon to be a failed state like Somalia if action is not taken soon.


Carol in NB
said

Mugabe is nothing but a coward...he has to use violence and intimidation to ensure he stays in power, and have his goons stand by the voters with guns to their heads. I'm glad the Queen stripped him of his knighthood. What did he do so special to deserve it in the first place?
So much for the UN.


Earl Robert
said

re: kevin P. You said it all. The UN has to step up and do it's job.
re: James. It's not that simple, I wish it were.


Kevin D
said

only 2000 forces? the military in Zimbabwe there is not the threat, it's the local police and the unemployed war veterans and the unemployed MDC youth party. It would be another Afghanistan where the UN forces wouldn't know who the actual enemy is.


James
said

To Robert Earl: It is that "simple"! It's just not "easy" to make any changes. Tell me how it is any more complicated that a greedy man or bunch of greedy men terrorizing a group of people for their own gain.


norsky
said

The UN must send in peace keepers immediately.


Merle Terlesky
said

I find it interesting that the left wing rails against President Bush anytime they can and call him a tyrant.
At least Bush was elected failrly.
Yet they are silent regarding Mugabe, Castro or Kim-Jong-Il.
Yes very silent indeed.
Can anyone call what happens in Cuba a fair election?



Greg
said

How ironic! They were fighting for freedom of black people
from colonial oppression! They got it! White colonial oppressors are
out, replaced by even worse, their own black oppressors, murderers. Where are
those who called for boycotting South Africa? Why they do not follow
the same steps now, when millions of other black people are oppressed?
The black people in Zimbabwe do not have the same value as the people
of South Africa? This ignorance is shameful politic mainly by the leaders of
Africa. For them is more important power, corruption and crying for “help money”
(then deposited to private accounts in foreign banks) from developed countries, then well-being of the people. Shame!

Greg




Dean
said

What a sham. however, I'm sure if there were any oil there, some power hungry nation would be there to "help" those people. Looking to the UN to do anything is a joke. Does any despotic country or anyone , for that matter do what the UN tells them to do? It should be disbanded since it has become a dinosaur.


Lily
said

1) Send in peace keepers!

2) I'm thankful for Canada, despite of all of the 'overexaggerated' scandals, we still get to vote.


Scott
said

If the UN were anything more than a cheerleader for peace, they would have already sent in peacekeepers... but cheerleading is all this failing organization is capable of nowadays. Gone are the short days when a UN intervention actually meant something.


Max
said

It's sad, indeed, that this part of the world is still such a backward mess.

After decades, the U.N. remains stumped as to how it can demonstrate to the rest of the world, especially those who needs its help, that it has any substantive purpose of existence.

Is the U.N. a global chamber of self-important political windbags, or not?!

"Peacekeeping"...yeah; whatever.



James in Calgary
said

Africa is a complicated place where even the simplest 'problem' by our standards is complicated.

What is happening in Zim. is horrid no matter how you measure it.

One major political problem is that there is no term limit on the president.

The time for the international community to have intervened was when Mugabe started his program of seizing land from white owners who were productive farmers and turning it over to his friends who let the land go fallow. The corruption was shown to the world and we did nothing. Now that things are really bad the unwashed herd is bleating in unison...but still we do nothing.



Sherry - Ottawa
said

I agree that Mugabe needs taking out - but not with PeaceKEEPERS - as a Peacekeeper you do not carry weapons and must use "diplomacy" and talking - I know, I was one of them. THAT would put our Peacekeepers absolutely in harms-way -in fact would probably get many of them killed. You, see, the world has let Mugabe get away with the murdering etc for so long that he actually believes he's untouchable. He and those scumbag followers of his would end up also hunting the Peacekeepers - and that would be a very big mistake - please people, realize that you need a form of Peace first before "the keepers" can go in.


jj
said

What is especially sad is that if the thug Mugabe were to die today, nothing would change. His army backers will appoint one of their own as President and continue the subjugation of Zimbabweans.

Rhodesia's Ian Smith was a hero compared to these murderers.


Earl Robert
said

To James: Survival is a basic instinct. I will give you an example. A man falls into a fast flowing river. There is a branch hanging down from a tree. The man grabs the branch and is dragged under the water. Since the man is afraid to let go because he can't swim, he drowns. The UN had an opportunity to save that man and didn't.


Steve
said

The UN is only as strong as the efforts put forth by the member nations. If the world doesn't care about Zimbabwe then the UN is powerless. Taking a "what have you done for us lately" approach to the UN without funding and supporting the UN properly is cowardly and selfish. It's always easy to find a scapegoat.


Chris
said

As a Canadian Soldier, I don't want to go there to peacekeep. Our role as peacekeepers is over. We have a more important job to do. The UN is a failed organisation. So stop calling on it.


Andrew in Hamilton, Ontario
said

Yet one more example of how useless the UN is. And no, UN peacekeeper's being brought in will not do anything, except for create an even bigger mess. The UN allows for one of Mugabe's goons to sit on council and does NOTHING to overthrow this murderer. Nevermind "kind-diplomacy," this joker needs to be assassinated, just as he as done to so many of his own people. What a disgrace.


Let's invade Zimbabwe
said

Hey! Maybe we should attack and occupy Zimbabwe because they hate our freedom... uh, no, er... we should be there to help the oppressed women go to school... uh, no wait.. because of 9/11... no, maybe we can go there to help a US appointed puppet government. Actually, scratch that.

We need a reason to go there with our army. Someone please help because none of the reasons above are working any more!

Are there any resources and political gains our government can tap into by sending the military there? Maybe that'll work!

If we all put our heads together I'm sure we can come up with some kind of justification to send Canada's army to Zimbabwe.


Tim
said

One big problem I see with the UN dealing with these matters are the 5 countries with veto powers on UN security resolutions. So even if most of the world's countries and all members of the UN Security council wanted do something about it (sanctions/send in troops), all it takes is one of the 5 veto wielding countries to say no. It this case, China is the one blocking most resolutions dealing with Africa, since it's very heavily invested in buying natural resources from these countries (especially oil).


Mike C
said

In the end ...who really cares.
This has been going on in Africa for years,
And in the end nothing will change.




RRO
said

Kevin, the UN system relies on cooperation between nations. Unfortunatly many nations are not willing to back action that would be necessary to rectify this situation. It is a failure by world leaders.

Mugabe has supporters in China and Russia which insures their protections. The UN is an important part of the international system, and is very successful in a number of areas.


RRO
said

All of you saying the UN needs to step in, that action needs to be taken. I hope you all support the mission in Afganistan, because the action needed would be troops on the ground escourting Mugabe out of the Presidential Palace.

Think that through to the next stage, because Mugabe does have supporters and they will scream imperialism all over again. Our troops will be targets. And soon afterwords all of you calling for intervention will be demanding we leave because of the death toll for our troops.

Its easy to say take action but Canadians seem to buckle at paying the price. Africa is not a place where intervention by the western world is welcome. Look at Somalia and Chad and every other UN intervention in Africa and see where it ended.

Many people in many African nations will scream for our help, but will not lift a finger to help us. If a leader gets up and starts denouncing the colonial powers they will cheer and in short order they will turn against us, the very people who invited us in.

African leaders need to clean up this mess. To many of them used anti-white propoganda and nationalist rhetoric to get into power. Now they have made it impossible for us to help. Let them attack Mugabe, and fix this problem maybve than they will be willing to truly accept our help.


RRO
said

Good point Sherry,

I think to many Canadians are confused about what peacekeeping really is.


Doug BC
said

As "Chris" said,the UN is a failure.Even at it's best it is only as effective as it's members allow.And member countries are rarely going to agree on much of anythng.
What I find odd,it the same people who oppose the UN mandated mission in Afghanistan are more than willing to suggest we send troops to Africa.Would those be the same NATO troops the UN assigned the Afghanistan mission to? And would that be in addition to the UN's declaration that the west should take responsibility for poverty in Africa as well??
This is a tragic waste of huma lives.But even if Mugabewas ousted,,there would be another tyrant ready to take his place.And,if the west did intervene we would be accused if illegally occupation of a sovereign nation.
There is no "win" available.Even a 2nd world country like Mexico can't control violence and build a justice system.Given that,it will be decades before 3rd world countries will be able to manage their affairs.
The best we could possibly hope for is that the issues will eventually be decided by locals,and neither side supported by outsiders looking to create even wider areas of disruption.
Politics in Canada is an annoying disaster these days.But we still have a lot to be grateful for.
Canada day might be a good time to remember those before us who made our liberties possible.Our freedoms were not "free".They were paid for by our ancestors.Often,with their lives.
God bless all those that not only "talk the talk",but step up and "walk the walk" when things get tough.


Henry Wysmulek
said

This is what happens when the NATURAL GOVERNING PARTY of a country refuses to step done after losing an election.

Remember that on Canada and Election day.



Yuri
said

I can't imagine the UN sending in a force. Hell, even Nato can't muster the forces they need for Afghanistan. What alot of people don't understand is that most countries are reluctant to send their troops when it is not them being hacked and shot up. Now if there were some oil there that might be a different story. One could almost bet if there were anything of real value to the west we would most certainly be involved up to our eyeballs.


Charlene C.
said

I feel sorry for the people who live here. I talk to 2 families there and I am frightened for them. Now they have had to rush to get passports to make a quick getaway. Hope someone can get some order back there and people can feel safe. Please Canada help these people.


Fake Democracy?
said

To Henry, who said

"This is what happens when the NATURAL GOVERNING PARTY of a country refuses to step done after losing an election."


Are you talking about USA with regards to Florida and Diebold? I agree 100%. Canada has no business warming up to fake democracies!


Lily R.
said

Ian Smith himself would never have given up power had he not been forced to. Mugabe and his military junta have inherited the Colonial legacy of greed and exploitation through brutality and military force. Every Post Colonial govt has to go through its growing pains. Here in North America we haven't even reached a Post Colonial govt where indigenous people could rule the country. So much for world progress and all our Western self-righteousness.


as long as there is conflict
said

The U.N. wears Prada, this is what I call socialist mishandling of world affairs, If all you do is talk and no action you can justify wasting billions in order to maintain an elitist lifestyle.
This an awful time for the poor of the world, raped and murdered by both the left and the right. If we keep doing what we are doing the Third World War will make the last great war to end all wars look like a small war.
Sad sad times indeed


glen gaffney
said

why doesnt the UN do something about this disgusting man called mugabe. he has run down the country which was once the breadbasket of africa. not one african country has the heart to take on this thug and his cronies. he should be charged with crimes against humanity at the very least


Vince M
said

The UN isn't going to do anything, and frankly, I'm sick and tired of trying to help out poor countries when it is so unappreciated and so very little ever changes.

The people of Zimbabwe need to fix these problems themselves.

Starting in Poland the whole of the Soviet Union collapsed when people finally said "Enough". When are the people of Zimbabwe going to do the same? Is the government of Zimbabwe more intimidating or powerful than the whole aparatus of the Soviet Communist system?



Mamad
said

UN is pointless. just because Zimbabwa doesn't have oil, West doesn't care at all. INstead, they start sanctions on democraticly elected governments like Iran or Venezuela. Just because they don't follow US's rules on oil.


Ian K
said

Mamad - the democratically elected government of Iran???

You mean the Iran where all reformist candidates are prevented from running in elections? Where all final decisions are made by an unelected Supreme Leader and his coterie of mullahs?

The same 'democratic' Iran where they literally have fashion police in the streets and persecute Baha'is for their religious beliefs, i.e. won't let them attend schools or university?

The 'democratic' Iran where almost all youth despise the government of the mullahs because of the rigged elections and the rubber-stamp parliament.

(Don't tell me this is all American propaganda: my sources on this are inside Iran or have been there recently.)

Iranian 'democracy' is as much a farce as Zimbabwean 'democracy.'




Greg in the Hammer
said

I have to comment on the cynicism and ignorance of those writing that the only reason the we (meaning the West) have not intervened in Zimbabwe is because it has no oil. What sad and ignorant position from typically left leaning thinkers. Zimbabwe (also know as Rhodesia) was a jewel of Africa and full of promise before Mugabe gained power and began purging white people from their lands and plantations. It is a country teaming with natural resources and its people should be enjoying one of the highest standards of living on that continent. However under Mugabe, infrastructure, development, business investment , education investment, have virtually ceased and virtually all of the country's resources have gone towards keeping one despot in power.

We have not intervened for a number of reasons. The fact that Zimbabwe has no oil or other valuable commodoties isn't one of them.


Eric
said

quick question ?? who are the five major member of the UN. Hummm let's see US,UK,France,China and Russia. Now who's the five bigest arms dealers in the world hummm US,UK,France ,China and Russia. what did the UN do in Croatia, Somalia,Darfour and now soon ???? My point is that reality is not alway's what you read or see on tv. control information(this probably won't be publish)


Marc
said

Canada should just throw more money there way. That is the way we handle situations at home with healthcare, education etc. just throw more money their way and the problems will be solved.


tony
said

The West can denounce Zimbabwe's democracy any way they want. It won't matter. Whether it's benign or malevolent, power comes from who reaches it first.


James from Vancouver
said

Wow, Harper's new media relations team is working overtime. First to announce that he might do something (to get press) then announce that he has done it (to get 2x's the press per event).



somesoldierswife
said

It is easy to say "Someone should do something."
"Something", but what?
**If the United Nations mandates a mission there, and we sent soldiers in, as someone already said here, there would be hoards of people calling us "imperialists"...and what happens when our casualties start mounting...what happens when the perception is that of white soldiers killing poor Africans?
**People say "Do something", but quite often those same people are quite unprepared to accept the consequences of "doing something".



JP
said

For all those blaming the United Nations -
you dont knwo what your talking about-
Its the World Leaders who sit back and watch this and wait till its too later before they say anything- are to BLAME. As A true Canadian and a Peacekeeping Veterans - I am proud of the U.N.
Our PM will sit back and wait for the US to lead thenn Harper will follow like a puppy on lease.


Gary
said

Hes got the army & police under his armpit & Mugabe is going to do whatever he wants. He could care less what the rest of the world thinks of him. He wants power & will do anything to keep it.
Other than lame diplomacy, I really don't think the U.N. is going to get too involved. Are there any countries out there willing to send in troops to get rid of this guy & all his cohorts? I doubt it. Economic sanctions might work but who suffers the most? The people.
I think down the road, a nasty, lengthy civil war could erupt & where all that ends is anybodys guess.


SA
said

What about Bush's idelogy of spreading freedom and liberty to the rest of the world. Why is he not doing so in Zimbabwe? Is it because Zimbabwe does not have oil? Or maybe because it is not an attractive place like Middle East? or it does not have much strategic significance?


Sylvain
said

You can only lead the horse to the water, you can't make him drink....


Michael
said

UN-Troops wont do any good and change nothing. Freeze all bank accounts of Mugabe and all other ZANU-PF officials. This will hurt more than sanctions. Sanctions will not only hurt the people that always suffer. Then give back our land and let us together become africas bread basket one day.


Larry not in Calgary
said

James in Calgary: Those White farmers stole the land from black ownership when they colonized Africa. They deserved to be tossed out of a nation they were parasitcally using for their own benefit. I have no sympathy for white racists and imperialists in Africa.

Mugabe is corrupt ... so is George Bush, Dick Cheney and Codi Rice, lets invade the USa first and remove those war criminals from power first and then we might have the credibility to start stomping around Africa.


Rex
said

It makes my blood boil when you consider he was given a Knighthood in UK and an Honorary doctorate from the University of Massachusetts at the time he was butchering 20000 innocent civilians-kind of puts a value on these 'esteemed awards' doesn't it?


Bernard Romanycia
said

May announce? Hopefully he's got more guts than that and can actually take a stand against corruption. Oooops.


Roger T
said

Like it's gonna make a huge dent on the world stage! Our country is so irrevelant and all the bigger global players blink with Harper's announcement. Means little to anyone as we (Canadian Gov't) listen and follows the world on everything, as we are known to be puppets controlled by it's masters!




KD
said

Where do people get this notion that the UN is a global ethics comittee? Of the origional security council members Russia (Stalin)and China(Mao)were(are) totalitiarian dictatorships themselves. The UN's sole purpose is the protection of established borders and soveriegnty!


Dave
said

Harper criticizing another country for deplorable election practices? Isn't that funny, given Harper's own election scandal...


David fm NS
said

It would be a no win situation for any Western Nation to intervene in Zimbabwe. Western Nations would be accused of returning to Colonialism, being racist etc etc. The African Union has to take action in Zimbabwe, Sudan and Somalia. It's time for Africa to fix itself from within, this is the only way it will stick.


Don in NS
said

Too bad CTV and most other news organizations would not recognize why PM Harper Harper was making a speech atB'nai Brith. Mr Harper was making a speech at the 'B'nai Brith gathering after being awarded its highest honour, the Presidential Gold Medallion for Humanitarianism."

"We have only presented (the medallion) to a handful of outstanding exemplary and distinguished recipients," said Moishe Smith, the Ottawa-based president of B'nai Brith International.

"This highest of honours is reserved for only those individuals who have demonstrated inspired international leadership and service to society well beyond the call of duty."

Past recipients of the award include David Ben Gurion, Israel's founding prime minister, and former U.S. presidents Harry S. Truman and John F. Kennedy."
I guess contrary to belief, not all believe that the Conservative government is devoid of Foreign Affairs quality.











gilles
said

Mr. Harper, as head of the government of Canada, should have asked the GG, head of State, to support the condemnation.

Does it make sense, no?



Stan
said

Hit 'em with Canada's soft power!
Remember that fantasy of the idiot liberals?


MHB
said

I fully agree with Mr. Harper's stand. I could not help though asking why did not Mr. Harper condemned the Egyptian president Mubarak when all elections in Egypt were "stolen" over 27 years?. The fact is that Western leaders condemn only dictators who do not play according to Western rules!.


Layton in Moncton
said

The United Nations needs teeth, but sadly, there's no oil there. Mugabe doesn't have nukes, all he has is a nation of near serfs. Oppressed, terrorized into 'voting for him'. Its time the UN gets a mandate to enter failing states and govern until true democratic elections can be held. Maybe then some sanity and order can be brought into the developing world. Justice and employment could return to these lands. I'll be remembering this on Canada Day.


Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz