CTV News | Harper apologizes for residential school abuse

Top Stories -   

Harper apologizes for residential school abuse

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News: Craig Oliver on an emotional day
CTV National News: Craig Oliver discusses the first step in the long road to reconciliation between natives and Canadians
CTV National News: Roger Smith with details on an emotional day for one residential school survivor
CTV Edmonton: Sonia Sunger with one group that doesn't feel the apology was sincere enough
CTV Winnipeg: Joe Olafson on how students, who have never witnessed the abuse, feel about the apology
CTV Ottawa: Joanne Schurr on why many native people feel there is still a long way to go
CTV Newsnet: Prime Minister Stephen Harper apologizes to survivors of residential school abuse
CTV Newsnet: Liberal Leader Stephane Dion apologizes to survivors of residential schools
CTV Newsnet: Bloc Leader Gilles Duceppe apologizes for the residential school abuse
CTV Newsnet: NDP Leader Jack Layton offers his apology to residential school survivors
CTV Newsnet: Phil Fontaine, National Chief of the Assembly of First Nations, responds to the apology
CTV Newsnet: Patrick Brazeau, National Chief of the Congress of Aboriginal Peoples, and Mary Simon, President of Tapiriit Kanatami respond to the apology
CTV Newsnet: Clement Chartier, President of the Metis National Council responds to the apology
CTV Newsnet: Beverly Jacobs, President of Native Women's Association of Canada responds to the apology
CTV Newsnet: Richard Kistabish, residential school survivor
CTV Newsnet: Erna Paris, author, 'Long Shadows'
CTV Newsnet: Mike DeGagne, Aboriginal Healing Foundation

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(112)

CTV.ca News Staff

Date: Wed. Jun. 11 2008 10:46 PM ET

By saying "we are sorry," Prime Minister Stephen Harper acknowledged the Canadian government's role in a century of isolating native children from their homes, families and cultures.

"The treatment of children in Indian residential schools is a sad chapter of our history," he said Wednesday in the House of Commons. "Some sought, as was infamously said, to kill the Indian in the child. This policy was wrong, caused great harm and has no place in our country."

Residential school survivors from across Canada -- many wearing traditional clothing -- filled the House of Commons. Parliament postponed other business for the day, to hear the Government of Canada's official apology.

More than 1,000 watched from outside, where big screen televisions were mounted outside the Commons and on the Parliament lawn. And more than 30 events were organized in communities across the country.

Harper began his long-awaited speech after leading a procession of native leaders including Phil Fontaine, the Grand Chief of the Assembly of First Nations, into the House of Commons.

Harper took responsibility on behalf of the federal government for cultural loss and patterns of abuse that resulted from the schools' policy.

"The Government of Canada now recognizes it was wrong to forcibly remove children from their homes... to separate children from rich and vibrant traditions," he said. "We apologize for having done this.

"We undermined the ability of many to adequately parent their children."

The prime minister's 15-minute address also included a surprising nod to NDP Leader Jack Layton for constantly pushing the issue as a government priority.

About 150,000 native children went through the programs, which were an extension of religious missionary work designed to assimilate them into Christian society. An estimated 80,000 are still alive.

The apology comes as part of a $4 billion compensation and healing package for residential school abuse survivors.

Aboriginal leaders speak in House

In a last-minute twist, the government allowed native leaders to reply to the apology in the House of Commons, rather than be shuffled off to a reception room after the apology.

Fontaine led the leaders' delegation by inviting all Canadians to continue to struggle for racial equality.

"Brave survivors, through telling their stories, have stripped white supremacy of its legitimacy," he said. "Never again will this house consider us 'the Indian problem' just for being who we are.

"What happened today signifies a new dawn on the relationship between us and the rest of Canada... We are all part of one garment of destiny. The ties that bind us are deeper than those that separate us. We still have to struggle, but now we are in this together."

Inuit leader Mary Simon used her speech to look the prime minister in the eyes and thank him for his "courage."

"I have to face you to say this because it comes from the bottom of my heart," she said. "The generosity in the words chosen to convey this apology will help us end this dark period."

Party leaders say sorry

The prime minister's opening speech was followed by Opposition Leader Stephane Dion, who recounted stories told to him by numerous survivors and acknowledged past Liberal governments' role in residential school policy.

"As leader of the party that formed the government for more than 70 years of the 20th century, I acknowledge our role. I am deeply sorry," he said. "We apologize to those who died waiting for these words to be spoken."

Dion lauded the Truth and Reconciliation Commission, the panel launched earlier this month to hear testimony from survivors about the impact of the policy on their lives.

Layton fought back tears as he recalled the suffering of students, and said it's time to address the problems plaguing native people and communities across the country.

Despite Harper's advice earlier this week to avoid playing politics with such a serious issue, Bloc Quebecois Leader Gilles Duceppe used much of his time at the microphone to blast the Conservative government for failing to back up its apology with concrete action.

"This apology is necessary but insufficient," he said, noting Canada's position as one of only four countries that failed to sign the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. "Apologies, once given, are only meaningful for the action that follows."

Duceppe pressed the government to better fund native communities or risk repeating the actions of the past by further damaging aboriginal culture. He ended his speech to thunderous applause in the House, from his own party and the survivors who packed the observation gallery.

After the apology, the leaders who had been sitting in a circle in front of the prime minister ushered several aging survivors onto the House floor, where they were met with a standing ovation.

Abuse survivor Charlie Thompson watched the apology from the House gallery and said he felt relieved to hear the prime minister acknowledge the horrible legacy.

"(My brothers and I) were all sexually abused by the people who were supposed to look after us," he told CTV's Mike Duffy Live on Wednesday. "All across the country people didn't believe us that we were being abused.

"Today I feel relief. I feel good. For me, this is a historical day."

Comments are now closed for this story

Rocket
said

It's about time. How many governments have come and gone, and how many politicians have paid this lip service yet have done nothing. This is a mark of shame on the history of our country and while Stephen Harper will finally address this and issue a long-overdue apology, I can't help but feel it's too late for it to have the impact it needs. All previous governments, Liberal or Conservative, should be ashamed for keeping their heads in the sand.


wc
said

Long overdue and appropriate. What was done in those places was shameful.


Judi Halfe-Phillips
said

I don't believe there will be any sincerity behind this apology.
Unfortunately, the general public may not realize the devastation Residential Schools have caused. The damage is irreparable and the root of the problems many natives have faced over the years.
My mother was in a Residential School, so I know what she went through and more.


MHR
said

Apology is nice but it is not enough. Punish those who are responsible even if they are still 90 year old. Just like we did with Nazis - we still punish whoever are still alive today.





Terri
said

Really, it won't matter. I think it is about time it happened. I think it was wrong but we (as white people) will never be forgiven because we are still here. I would sure like to see a native person say that they knew it was wrong, they have apologized, now let's move on. It will not happen.I am pretty tired of feeling guilty about things that I had no control over.


Roger T
said

I think the Aboriginal people need more than apology and a small amount of compensation. They need seats in Parliament and so they can be a part of this country as this is THEIR LAND which was taken away by force.

I hope the Aboriginal leaders don't get fooled by this foolish speech, it's a tactic to avoid any protest becuase our current Gov't fear that it might happen.

Small talk to divert a big diaster for the Harper Gov't.

Aboriginal people need to Govern themselves as our Govt have failed them for many many years, it's time the Aboriginal people demand and be granted seats in Parliment and make choices that really reflect their needs and NOT dictated by anyone on their soil.


J.
said

An apology is very nice but what would have real meaning is to finally do something tangible. Make native issues a priority. There was a deal agreed to between the natives and different levels of government before the conservatives took over. That deal had substance and was not just words. Mr.Harper saw to it that that deal was dead in the water. Many of the reserves in this country are in a shocking state. No one could view these and come away with anything other than that these are third world conditions. Afghanistan is important of course but we need to take care of our native population before we are so quick to hand out billions in other parts of the world. To tell native children that they will not be getting a proper school but then to brag about the schools they are building on foreign soil says a great deal about this government. Give our First Nations people clean water, health care, schools etc., the very important basics of life. Give them the tools to deal with alcohol and drug abuse which are caused by the residential school system that we forced them into. Step up and make this not just an apology of words but an apology that truly has depth and significance.


James
said

Why stop at residential schools. Why not apologize for the way Native Canadians have been treated since the French and English first landed in the "New World." Treaties were signed and brokened. Bounties were placed on various tribes, leading, in part, to the extinction of the Beothuks tribe of Newfoundland. The fact that Native Canadian land was stolen is still the source of tension today. Why not give a full and complete apology, and compensation for what our forefathers stole and what we currently refuse to share? As decendents of Europeans, that is what we would demand had we been treated in a similar fashion. Canada is a large enough country to properly share the land and resources with Native Canadians. Why do land claims negotiations take so long? This is not fair for Native Canadians. Share the land!


Gil McGillivary
said

I'm a Residential School surviver. The "cultural genocide" was a success because I've lost my language, I don't live on reserve which is across the Saskatchewan River, I'm a stranger to my own relatives. No amount of money will ever bring back my relationship to my physically, emotional, mental, and sexual abuse I suffered for 5 years at Prince Albert Indian Residential School. It will never bring back the relationship I should entitled for "life, liberty and happiness" with my dysfunctional family because of "Residential School". Having the Prime Minister of Canada apologize for the past "Cultural Genocide" will be accepted with great drepidation.


Chris
said

You know what... an apology is sometimes all it takes to heal wounds. That's humanity. We'll see if the greed kicks in afterwards.


Rob
said

Give the apology then we need to move on, although many did suffer at these schools, the first nations people need to try to move beyond the victim mentality that is destroying their people, yes the schools were wrong, and shameful, no one argues that, but the first nations can not be the victims forever, for the very sake of their future, stand up and stop being the victim, be proud of who you are and lets turn a page hopefully for the positive.


B. Belobrajdic
said

Do not blame the citizens of this country who came from Europe with nothing, raised families and gave everything to help build this great country. The shame lies on the shoulders of the guilty and ends there. Canada is a great country but there will always be a few rotten apples.


Andrea
said

While I agree with Michele that the churches should also apologize, it should be noted that the Catholic church only operated 60% of the schools. Other churches involved in the running of residential schools were the United, Anglican, Presbyterian,Congregationalist Churches.


Tony
said

Yes it was shameful and horrible what happened there. But at the same time there has to be a point where we realize it is in our past and however much we want to change it we can't. There are so many other horrible things that have happened in our history with no grand apologies or compensations of any kind. I think that there needs to be a point where we all just start to lay down our grudges and past offenses and realize that the things done were in a different time by different people. We don't believe in doing it now and it won't happen again. We can learn from the situation but shouldn't drag it on. This doesn't mean that I am against this apology cause I'm not but I think we need to take the apology and accept it.


HMJL
said

I agree that an apology is long overdue, and I am sure it compares to what the Christian Brothers did in Newfoundland to the children at Mount Cashel Orphanage. I think that those teachers should be exposed and punished for what they did at these native schools; and compensation should be paid to these people for their suffering. Tina Keeper is a keeper. Keep up the good work Tina.


M.
said

Dear Michelle,

Please be aware that the greater majority of these institutions were not run by the Catholic Church. Several denominational institutions were involved. As such, all should tender an apology.




NDN Wonder Woman
said

Well it's about time...We don't know if it will be a sincere apology (which I highly doubt), however, the Canadian Government needs to be accountable for the actions taken on trying to assimilate our people. I'd like to see if the Catholic Church will take the government's lead and make an apology for trying to "civilize" us...


Susan
said

"Terri's" comments are a fine example of the ignorance of non-aboriginal people that still exist today. The fact is an apology is long overdue and necessary, however, we (today's society) need to acknowledge that the current generation of aboriginal people and the future generations of aboriginal people are still affected and will continue to be affected. This cannot just be acknowledged and forgotten! The journey to healing will be slow and long. The government took an entire generation and destroyed them physically, mentally, emotionally, and culturally. Now, do we not understand that this has impacted thier children and grandchildren, etc??? Not only are the survivors victims but so are their ancestors!


Ian Yellowknife
said

Judi Halfe-Phillips is right out to lunch. How dare she say it probably won't be sincere. PM Harper is doing something "Again" that the Liberals would not do. There were success stories also in Residential Schools. The Commissioner of the NWT Anthony Whitford and yes I do know more. Yes there was problems with the way it was done and in the "past" it was frustrating and wrong, but we have to look forward and learn from the mistakes not dwell on them for generations. We are all Canadians now.



Rob from North Bay, ON
said

My family suffers from my mother's experience in the residential schools.
My mother went from singing native songs at pow wows to losing her language,culture and they even forced her to be right handed.
I was lucky to have my parents who guided me, but even so I am totally disconnected from my culture even today.
People of my culture do not see me as one of them nor does mainstream culture have an understanding of what happened.

Heres hoping some understanding and growth will come and the history books will now contain this dark part of Canadian History.


mugsy
said

Life is 5% circumstances and 95% what you make of those circumstances. I agree that an apology is forthcoming but what always gets me is how the children of those in the residential schools carry on the grudges of their parents. Someone made a great point in that there comes a time when we should forgive and move on and stop blaming all of our social and other problems on something that happened in the past to other people by other people. We definitely must learn from what happened but let's learn and move on.


Lila
said

My mother was almost taken to a residential school when she was about six or seven years old. It scares me to think these places even existed and I feel priveledged to live in a time when it is not expected of me. Now, being Iroquois but also being Catholic, in a way, is sort of an oxymoron. I think this apology is the first step in settling the many problems and disagreements between natives and whites.


Ted
said

Healing is a big part of forgetting. The people responsible for the abuse should be taken to task and made to pay. We as Canadians are paying and it's time to go after the assets of those responsible. Someone very close to me endured all kinds of abuse during her youth, in foster homes. She has never been redeemed at all. Same abuse but just not native.

Pacifica
said

The Anglican Church has already apologized -- several yeas ago, in fact -- and to those who say that peple who have been victimized by abuse should "move on," it is clear that you have no idea how totally devastating childhood abuse can be -- one doesn't just "move on" when one's whole person, body, mind, and spirit, has been broken and treated like trash.


Chief Ross
said

This apology is very important to us aboriginals because it was us that felt this pain for the past 100 years since the 1800's, and for a white person to say this is nothing then im just offended by those comments, but then again we are natives i forgot, i see that we dont have respect amoung canadians because are are protray as lazy welfare indians, on the other hand, thats why residential school made us this way, if you get my draft, plus these are my own thoughts as a aboriginal person(so im not offending anyone)sorry if i am.

and thanks for reading.


jm
said

I have read a lot of these comments and some just say "move on or get over it". Although many agree that what First Nations people went through was wrong and painful but there is more to it than that. What about the forced elimination of who we are; our culture, our values, our beliefs, our languages, etc. All that no one can replace! Because of the residential schools, it's shameful to say, that there is only a minority or First Nations people that speak their traditional language.


David fm NS
said

Long overdue, Native Canadians have been asking for compensation and an apology on these matters for decades. Typical of this Government to take action where others have only used words and I commend them for it. I hope that this is a giant step for healing between the native and non-native communities. We are all Canadians and every Canadian should be proud of their heritage.


PBW
said

This apology is long overdue. Hopefully, the victims of this cultural genocide will be able to accept it.

It was - and still is - arrogant of any group to consider itself better than any other, and to demand that members not of its group conform to its ways. That applies to race, religion and politics. Most of all, it applies to people who think anyone who holds a different opinion should not be allowed to express it.

For many years, our aboriginal peoples were denied the right to their own cultures, and were punished for speaking their own languages. Happily, that period is in the past. Now, all that remains is the healing, if that is, ideed, possible.


Rona from Canmore
said

Let's not forget that the Natives also received an education in "those places" as well as health care and food. And not every missionary was a depraved abuser. The First Nations were apologized to in 1998 by the Liberal gov't and by the Catholic Church in 2005.


A. L.
said

I do remain positive that the healing will happen and each apology helps heal the wounds that are many. As a 3 year old Metis child chased down a back alley, taken from my family,though not placed in a school but foster care, when I hear people say to "forget it for it is past" . One has to ask, how past is past when the last school closed in 1996 and foster care is no better than before.
The present day attitude of many are the same as decades ago, perpetuating the same hurts and wondering why they should apologize for the past.
It happened for me forty years ago , yes, most of my young life has been "forgotten" ,unfortunately it was most of the good things that many take for granted, such as a mothers hug.





Coddy
said

To all those who say Native people should forgive and forget and move on. Would you tell Jews to forget about the holocaust and move on? It's funny how it seems like some people matter more than others. Unfortunately white people will get away with this one and they will never be brought to justice and all this apology is not going to change lives.



Tori
said

Being this was so traumatic, why is it First Nations is only "providing support this week for residential school survivors who may need to talk"

Has First Nations not acknowledged this problem in the past? Why would they not have provided councelling and support previously?




Chris
said

This apology is long, long overdue and i believe this is one of the most shamefull things in our countries short history. Look around the world though, it's been happening since man stepped on this earth. It continues in Africa today. Look at what happened in Bosnia while the UN watches. Nothing ever changes in our sad world because we humans are evil greedy people. What can we do to accept responsibility, offer real hope. First Nations Leaders need to step up and say OK this happened, it was horrible but we need to heal for the sake of future generations. How many billions of dollars goes into that ministry every year and nothing ever changes. The entire situation is crying out for a true statesman to rise up but they don't exist any more. Only self interest and what is it it for me.

Charlene
said

The residential school system was a tragedy! My father and his 12 siblings went to the residential school in Alberta. The years of abuse at the residential school enabled him to become an alcoholic. He lost his wife and children as a result. NO amount of restitution could bring back his innocence or his childhood lost in the residential school. No amount of money could bring back his loss of language, culture and tradition. You cannot put a dollar value on family, culture, tradition or language. You cannot put a dollar value on shame. The years and years of shame that he has to live with everyday. What are the cumulative impacts of the survivor's offspring? The cumulative impact is huge! My brothers, sisters, daughters, nieces, nephews have all suffered a cumulative impact. Through the loss of our language, culture, tradition. An apology is great, but it leaves a bitter taste in the mouths of the survivor's and their offspring. The first step to healing is the acknowledgement that a wrong was done, next comes the apology. The final step of the healing process is the ability to forgive! Perhaps one day the survivors will be able to forgive and what a glorious day that will be!


Doug BC
said

I am generally not a big fan of this raft of apologies we've been seeing lately. However I do agree this one is overdue, and warranted. I hope it is done well.
However,it may be quite useless. Apologies are only useful if they hep heal wounds,and make it easier for people to reconcile their differences in ways that make brighter futures. No matter what happens today,there will be many First Nations people who won't accept an apology, and many non First Nations people who don't know why one is necessary.
This is the 21st century. Even if land claims take a long time to resolve,there is much that can be done to improve living standards for First Nations people. We have to build the paths they need to access better health care and the higher levels of education it will take to reduce the levels of poverty that a disproportionate number of them live in.
Then,of course,it will be up to individual First Nations people to choose their own paths.
Any kind of apology is only one step.No matter how it goes down it will still take a lot of work to create better opportunities for the next generation of First Nations people.And I think that's the most important part of a reconciliation process.



Al
said

Yes, any party who has committed these abuses should apologize for these actions.

But to those of you commenting that all the land should return to the aboriginal people, ENOUGH is enough! The aboriginal people lost the land, period. All over the world wars are fought, and lands are conquered or lost. This has been happening since the beginning of history. Only in Canada the political correctness has gone so far as to suggest that they are "owed" for the land they lost.

Let's all try to be PRODUCTIVE members of society, and earn the possessions and land that we acquire.



Chris
said

to JM:

Although I somewhat agree with your statement, you're not being stripped of your culture now. Their are many schools teaching various Aboriginal languages, cultures, and ethics. The Aboriginal community celebrates its peoples with many awards, like the one coming up in Winnipeg with the Aboriginal People's Music Awards. Power to that, I think that's great.

Oh and I'm a White Male that grew up in a predominante Aboriginal Community in Regina.


Jason in Calgary
said

Ms. Keeper, You are RIGHT! God Bless you for asking the tough question, and Shame on Harper for his Useless, Politicing answer to a VERY important question.

If Harper is as Serious as he is about saying Sorry, Invite those who lead the Native communities and show you mean your apology and stand behind it.

Veronica
said

I am glad to hear that there will be a formal apology. Both my parents and most of my older siblings attended residential schools. I was fortunate to attend public schools. Today, my children are fortunate to attend their community school. I don't think what happened should be forgotten so that we can ensure this does not happen again. Too many of our people are still dealing with the hurt they experienced in residential schools. I love my children deeply, and when I am away from them for a few days, it is quite difficult. Imagine your child/ren being away from you for 10 months straight? That's only the beginning. To me, having a child being separated from their parents is more than enough abuse already. I am going to watch with my children as this is an important event in the history of native people in Canada. I hope the apology helps those that attended or had family attend residential schools.


Dave Hayward
said

An apology is extremely important. However, if Canada sincerely wants promote healing and ensure cultural sustainability for our Aboriginal peoples... we should consider the following pledge.

______________________________________________________________

We, The Descendants...


We, the descendants of Canada’s Aboriginal, French and English founders, and of all others who later arrived to help build this nation, stand in unity as witness to this pledge.


Remembering that Canada’s provinces and territories have been settled by peoples whose mother tongues, heritage and values differed, we pledge to one another:



To recognize, to respect, and to celebrate Canada’s diversity, lest a loss of identity suffers unto our descendants;

To embrace tolerance, equality, sharing and compassion as the moral cornerstones of our great nation;

To bond together as one in the pursuit of dignity, health, prosperity and happiness for all Canadians;

To forever preserve and promote this mission that we so proudly share.



Darryl
said

While i believe that the apology is warranted and they deserve compensation, BUT when is it all going to stop? What else is this govt going to have to apologize for? Sure the natives have legitimate issues that need to be resolved. But how is blaming the current generation of non natives helping anything? All that will lead to is more resentment and more ill will between both natives and non natives.

Until BOTH SIDES learn to treat each other with dignity and respect, then all we can expect is more violence, more blockades, days of action and a further gulf dividing this great country of ours.


roman wolskyj
said

mind you that this apology is long overdue lets hope that out of the spirit of humanity that we dont have to contnually apologize and leaders dont milk this at every given oppotunity to platform themselves. after all "we" are all to blame for the lack of leadership for an event that happened long ago and we can take resolve to heal the present and future.


Patrick
said

I agree that our government needs to be more accountable to everyone. How ever often when the government takes accountability it costs the tax payers greatly. I don't see why an apology should come with a monetary value. I bumped into someone at the store yesterday and apologised. How much should I compensate them for that?


Liz D.
said

I am so pleased that Margeurite Wabano is there for her generation of survivors. My mom is a bit younger and is watching today too. It is indeed a moment in history for all of us.


Mel
said

I look at my 4 year old daughter and imagine her being taken away from me, as this happened to my Grandmother. I wonder if my grandmother was consoled when she hurt herself. Who took care of her when she was sick? Was she shown any love and affection? Growing up, we never received much love and affection. I do not blame my mother, as I understand now, she probably did not receive that herself. How could she? My grandmother did not know how to be nurturing and loving. As my grandmother has now passed away, we are not entitled to any benefits. I do not care about any benefits! I do believe that there should be more active counselling and activities for families and survivors. I believe that cash payments are a short term solution. We need long term solutions.


James from NB
said

For all the white people who post here and say that aboriginals just need to let it forgive and work together. Well that would be ideal, but the fact is Natives are STILL being persecuted everyday.

We as white people like to acknowledge alot of positive things about our past, as if we were responsible. Well if you take credit for positive things, we MUST take credit for the negative things.

To all hurt aboriginals out there. I'm sorry :(


Tula
said

Maybe now the current Native leaders (most) should apologize to their own people for all the misuse, fraud, nepotism, and other violations of their own people. They should listen to that chief from B.C. who tells it like it is.


Jen
said

I sit here and listened to what was said, and I read some, I myself was bought up with parents who both gone to residential school. It breaks my heart to know what has happened, people wonder why native people are so messed up, just like what they say....do not judge, you have not walked in my moccasins, I just feel so emotional knowing this apology has come.


We ask your forgiveness...
said

TO all aboriginal peoples of Canada.. we the people of Canada ask your forgiveness for what we have done. We are ashamed for our actions, for looking the other way, for being silent, for the grave hurt inflicted we inflicted on your people, your culture and your individual lives.

We ask your forgiveness.





Camera Guy
said

I may not like the Conservative Party, nor Stephen Harper's policies in general. Today however our Prime Minister displayed candor and leadership worthy of the title "Right Honorable." Thank you Prime Minister for opening the door for healing between Canada's Government and Frist Nations peoples across Canada.


Martin from Sask
said

It is good to here that Metis are included in this "apology" its too bad that most of the public, government and our FN cousins like to forget us as often as possible. As with most Aboriginal initiatives many Metis now are being barred from the reconsiliations as they didn't go to a real bad school. It is amazing the abuse gets heard about but the truth about the cultural assimilation is still swept under the carpet. The Metis suffered not only from Government assimilation techniques but from racism of our fellow Canadians and FN cousins. We are aboriginals too, remember that. How bout an apology for Batoche, Red River, Seven Oaks, Road Allowance, Scrip systems, disassociation and removal from the census in the 1900's era, ongoing non-recognition and etc. etc.?


DNB
said

I am extremely hopeful that this apology will now be the end of this issue. What happened to the residents of these schools is unforgettable, however these acts we not performed by us, the average canadian. I am so tired of being blamed and having to accept responsibility for every injustice and wrong doing against the first nations people. Those that committed the act should be punsihed and subject to punishment by the law of the land. If the individual or individuals responsible are no longer living than I am sorry but that is it. At some point you need to focus forward and quit letting the past dictate your future.
Enough!!!!


bunny
said

I listened and I cried. PM Harper was really moving
This is long overdue, and so well said. Of course, I now see CBC is saying who has the best speech. Do they have to do that on a day like this.( sigh)


Dale Wilson
said

A group of 20 of us are sitting here at work and some had tears running down their cheeks. All of us were moved and appreciative of what was said by the Prime Minister of Canada on behalf of all of us.

Why the other party leaders thought it was appropriate to speak for longer than the Prime Minister of Canada is completely beyond us all. Most of us feel it was very inappropriate.


Mitch Baker
said

I applaud the Prime Minister's speech. Now people can begin to move on.


Yvonne
said

As a spouse of a survivor of residential school, we've been together for 28 years, he has never spoke about his experience in detail; I uderstand of not wanting to open old wounds, so I never initiated the topic unless he did. It is very painful,now I can understand why he is the way he is. Listening to the apology live, really tugged at my heart. ...

25 year old member of the Okanagan Indian Band
said

For all you tossing out ever so casually, "move on"...

I would love to, just point me in the direction that will teach me my own peoples language and give back my cultural pride and heritage.....I'll go running!


Steven
said

He said what we needed to hear. I am the grandchild of a residential school survivor. my grandmother and father almost drank themselves to death because of this. I thank Mr. Harper for apologizing and asking for our forgiveness. now we can start to heal the wounds.


Bret
said

I am so ashamed of this dark time in canadian history. We need to step up to the plate and fix the poverty that exists on reserves.


a hopeful indian
said

i think this is a great symbol of taking responsibilty for the actions and its a noble sentament. also the oppertunity to start healing from the various abuse can start and there affects of drug use and alcoholism can be worked on. i think a true and more effective testment to feeling guilty is giving back power to govern our selfs to us. For those non natives that see a part of the problem we dont need money we need the right many Non natives take for granted and that is the power to be Indian to choose our leaders without correption from non native thing. we need freedom form the residential school lagecy where we can be indian instead of us being ruled e the dollar. if we had a true democracy for the reserves i think we can open a new peaceful life with our white, yellow, and black brothers.


Carolyn Hesseltine
said

I too am a Canadian whose ancesters came from Scotland to make a new life in this magnificant country in the 1800's.
They did not come to conquer.
As their families flourished and settled across this country some of my ancestors were responsible for carrying out the Government's mandate for First Nations people on the West Coast.
On behalf of my ancestors I apologize and offer my humble and sincere apology for their part in the attempted assimilation of our First Nations people.
Let us not forget this dark part of our history but move forward together taking strength in one another.
Good bless
How'aa


Cantesutawin
said

I am an intergenerational survivor of residential schools. I have read with interest the comments of non-Aboriginals on this site. Some are saying that we must get over our "victim" mentality. As an Aboriginal woman, I can assure you that I have never felt like a victim, my attitude has always been that we must learn to heal from this dark chapter in our history. However, having said that the reality is that until the past is recognized, only after that is done can we move forward with dignity.

I do not totally trust that this marks a turning point in our relationship with the larger society. It is not until the attitudes of non-aboriginal Canadians change to see my people as equal will we ever be able to fully move forward.

I found it interestng that after Chief Fontaine made his remarks, the only politicians to come forward and shake his hand was the leaders of the opposition parties. Methinks that perhaps PM Harper needs to be better versed in the protocols of Aboriginal people. If anything shook my confidence in the sincerity of this apoligies this was it. Many have said that what counts is how things will move forward from this point on and his actions did shake my confidence.

All we can do is wait and see what will change.


Ben
said

I'm sure I'm not the only one who saw this coming. An apology is never enough and it seems most of the comments saying so are written from indulgent self-satisfying non-natives who seem to think they represent what natives think and feel. I am truly sorry that these people endured such treatment within our country. At some though it seems like we are left in limbo regardless of what we say or do now. We will always carry the guilt and never be rid of it, but I believe with a sincere apology should be sincere acceptance. Native Canadians, please accept this apology and we can all move on.


RRO
said

Hopefully this can begin the healing for these people, and close this terribly sad part of Canadian history. It is unfortunate that it has taken so long for this appogliy to be given.

Prime Minister Harper has demonstrated a strong sense of leadership today. Admitting the wrongs our country has committed in the past, and offering a honest appogliy.

An entire nation remembers this tragedy today, and offers its sorrow to the survivors, and hopefully a pledge to never allow anything like it to happen again.

Now we must move forward to address the issues facing our first nations people in a sincer effort, only then will we truly be united and put this sad chapter behind us.




Jormiester25
said

I think that this is long overdue, and though i hardly agree with Mr. Deceppe's policies, i put my pride aside and totally support him in this. Actions NEED to be taken by this. As a Mohawk myself I have witnessed the hardships first hand by our elders. I think it's time for the U.S. to follow suit!


PAULG
said

Apology on these shameful incidents should have been tendered long time ago. I fail to understand why the previous Governments remained indifferent.


Standing Moon
said

Admitting falut is only the first step in making amends. The government and the churches must show they are sorry, by working to undo the damage they did. The church must be ready to leave all together if that is what is wanted on some reserves. The churches should make financial restitution to the point that the community is sufficienty appeased. They must show they are serious about purging the curch of sexual abuse, by attaining a new name that doesnt appear over and over again in the headlines for these horrid acts. The government must establish and fund schools to teach native language and culture to the natives, and whoever wants to learn and live their ways. I assume this is being done to some degree already. Let's make it public.


D
said

The Catholic Church did apologize - many years ago, it is also part of the 5 year Truth and Reconciliation Commission traveling across Canada.


Residential School Survivor
said

Our Own Land

When I was six my daddy died,
I saw how my mommy cried.
The Indian Agent would not relent,
To residential school we went.
Our daddy and mommy we did miss,
What wrong did we do to deserve this?
Our only language was Ojibway,
But on school grounds, No Way!
The Ojibway language, not at allowed to speak,
We were humbled and made meek.
A raw potato I did steal,
I was made to miss a meal.
My sister sick, vomited in her plate,
At this tender age I learned to hate.
From morning 'til evening she stood behind the door,
Silently my tears began to pour.
The work, today we call had labour,
The food, oh what an awful flavour.
To mass, we went every single day,
To the dear Lord I always did pray,
To please help get us out of this hell,
To the world, someday, I vowed I would tell,
Of the anguish, oppression we were made to suffer,
I tell you true, I am no bluffer.
I'll never, never forget the tears,
We suffered, for five lonely years.
Today, my people are still fighting to stand,
In this Canada, our very own land.
The whole planet we do not want,
For we are content with our own country to haunt.
On this planet we start no fights,
We merely ask our Native rights.

Residential School Survivor



Peter
said

I must add my comments and say I do agree with the apology. Long over due and we as a nation should learn from it. However the assimilation process is still in progress so to speak and without the help of residential schools or other government run organizations; at least not directly.

I wonder how many aboriginal young people these days wear designer jeans, play video games on their XBoxes, drive large trucks or even the odd snow machine? I wonder if any or all of these items are in fact manufactured by non-aboriginal companies and how many represent a non-aboriginal way of life (maybe I should throw in cell phones here and the ability to text message?)? Now these items do not take children away from their parents, granted and they do not submit the children to a regimented life style (hmmm I wonder on that one?). But the bottom line is that they are being influenced by non-traditional aboringinal ways and yes it is changing their culture. Different but maybe the same?

For the one writer the Beothuk of Newfoundland were in fact "hunted" but by other aboringinal groups mainly from Labrador. But yes plenty were killed by non-aboriginals but most in fact probably from diease then tracking down and killing.

If we are all Canadians then saving so many seats in Parliament for aboriginals sounds good and yes it would be good to have more present in the House but I am of the opinion that they should be voted in under the current system instead of some "guarantee". I have a feeling that most aboriginals would rather have it that way as well. Elected by merit not acclamation. I think that one writer stated that this could mean an equal system for all visible minority groups and could open flood gates that would ruin our system. More thought required on that idea.


dani
said

Hooray! Finally someone will stand up and say we are sorry for the abuse that you suffered. We admit that it was wrong what happened. However, the people who just want the victims to quietly accpet and move on will never understand what it is to be an "indian" We are still frowned upon or considered a lesser status of society. Rednecks will never change their way of thinking. I know that we did not cede our lands due to wars and that we did not voluntarily ask for the Department of Indian Affairs to govern how we manage the dollars we receive towards education, health and so forth. The administration alone of such a department funnels a majority of that funding towards them. It ends up like a dog chasing his tail, we go round and round and no wonder we have difficutly getting anywhere. I believe if we could manage our own affairs we would be that much better off. Think about all the jobs that are in INAC plus management and the few token indians that are on staff probably make up a small minority. I can ramble on and on but i better quit. I was disappointed in the Prime Ministers speach actually. The media blitz made it sound like he was going to make everything all clear and everything will be okay.
I had family that went through that system thank goodness none were abused in the ways that others were, but reflecting back on growing up, I missed out on a lot, culturally speaking, cannot speak our native language, had no clue on the big house rules and how the potlatch system works and family rankings and learning from traditional healers.
Thank you for your time.


John R. Sutherland
said

I appreciated the sincerity of the Prime Minister's remarks and those of M. Dion and Mr. Layton. I very much regret, on the other hand, the over-the-top partisanship of M. Duceppe. Now it's the turn of the churches. In fact, they should have been way out in front of the government in seeking reconciliation. As for what follows, the Conservatives have already taken a few useful initiatives, but many more must follow before we can judge the genuineness of their apology. "By your fruits they shall know you."


Annie Cheekie, Sayisi Dene First Nation
said

A very historic day for Canada and it's people. Musi-cho to Prime Minister Steven Harper for his heartfelt apology. Musi-cho to elders and representatives of the Aboriginal community who attended on my behalf.
I just hope and pray that this will indeed put an end to the disparaging discrepencies that are used when providing say shelter to residence and non-residence of northern communities. The little home for a single family should be as strongly and adequetley built as the little home they build for the visiting doctors and nurses or any other diginitaries they see fit. If we are all indeed going to be treated the same on equal grounds, then the homes should all be the same. Until I start to see that along with open accountability from the Band Offices through it's elected leaders, I for one shall continue to pray.




Desiree
said

This apology is a big step and the first and hoping there will be more changes in the future. I am a first nation student still in high school and trying my hardest to finish school for those who never did. I am the only aboriginal student in my grade 11 classes and its difficult at times.


Ian
said

I find it sad that people are using this forum to take partisan shots at the present government. We as a nation collectively have to feel bad for the treatment of the aboriginal people over our history. The apology was a good thing and I just hope that those naysayers out there will remember that our nation was founded on many principals, one of them being forgiveness. People can complain that this apology is too late, but it can never be too late. I hope that this apology will help start the healing process for those whose lives have been ruined by the ordeal.




D.R.
said

I am a white mid thirties male and think that this is long overdue. I have many native friends and they are still wondering why the Liberal government didn't act for so many years...even when they had the opportunity. To watch Dion stand up and say the Liberals stand by this, when they had decades to do something but didn't...made me and my native friends sick. Another grab for political gain. I admire the Conservatives for standing up and finally doing the right thing.
I just hope that all those effected can start to heal.


Xia
said

"To forgive does not mean to forget"

I concur with what Robin and Mike - NWO
have stated. What more can there be done? An apology was given. We tax payers have been paying substantial amount for something that the government has done a long time ago. Native youths also have the option of free post-secondary education. I, for one, am not white, I am Chinese and I have to work hard to get money to fund for my education and to pay my taxes. Us citizens of Canada have acknowledged that residential schools have been an extremely unnecessary requirements for the Aboriginal people. It was a terrible mistake and should have not even existed.
But why is it that us citizens have to pay back for what the government did and more demands are made from the abused for funding and money? Where will they get the money? From the government yes, but where will the government get the money from? Us.
All I am trying to say is although the Aboriginal people have been treated the way they should not have been treated, there are other racial minorities that had it bad as well. For instance, the Chinese were treated like trash as we built the Canadian rail way and it was because of a large portion of the Chinese immigrants, Canada was joined and connected via rail way. My ancestors died during the process and what do the goverment give us? Nothing. And what's even interesting is the fact that Chinese people, whom are also hardworking citizens of Canada do not get any compensation. Do you see alot of us demanding an apology and asking for tuition funds and social assistance? Do you see a lot of us still reliving the past. No.
Lest we forgive and not forget.

We all have to acknowledge that a formal apology was given and the residential school atrocities have been acknowledged. We cannot change what is in the past and White people cannot keep owing for future generations to come. Our forefathers are not us. The ones to apologize and be bashed on are the ones who were directly involved, which were the churches and the government, mainly the Liberal government. And the Conservative government has done something that has never be done.

Why can't we just forgive and move on and live a better and happier life and look forward into the future and build a stronger Native community instead of bringing up hatred? The more hatred we bring up and suppress, the more this feeling of betrayal will prolong. This will only seperate this country and nation more and more and no unity will ever exist!

Of course the victims will not "move on" just like that, but perhaps the motivation to live a better life and to show the government that you can be better than what they view the Native people to be will show to them, a strong and resilient culture. And I know that the Aboriginal culture is very resilient and a rich culture. Let this shine through!...

Betty
said

It's great to hear an apology, however people have to realize that the apology is just the beginning of the healing process. The past traumas from Residential School has affected our First Nation's People for Generations. People will never fully understand what had taken place unless they have lived/experienced it for themselves. I have heard ,oh hurry with the healing now from Non Native Society. I wish life were that simple. It's time we support one another as Canadians.


Steve D
said

A nice politically motivated gesture but essentially meaningless. It's like me apologizing to Jews for the Holocaust or Mulroney apologizing for the internment of Japanese-Canadians during World War II. It's easy to apologize for something you didn't do.

Besides, apologies don't put food on the table, a roof over your head, restore culture, or return land that was swiped.

It's obviously a quiet week politically because this is not a story that really changes the reality of the native experience in Canada. It's like giving a cancer patient chicken soup: it won't hurt but it won't help either.


bunny
said

It was a wonderful speech. I had to change the channel, because a certain media outlet was starting to pit one leader against the other. Thank you CTV, for a) not doing this. b) Mike Duffy is really a gent


Still Standing.
said

My mom and two older brothers went to residential school. My brothers are 40 and 41 and I am 37. This means they were in the residential school in the late 1970s. I was fortunate enough not to have gone, but I may has well have with all the abuse and neglect that I grew with because my mother had no idea on how to raise or protect me.

I forgave my mom and all my abusers for what they did to me growing up. I had to or I would never be able to move forward. I did a lot of work in therapy, counselling, and treatment programs to get and stay on my path of a healthy way of being.

Apology or not, as a residential school intergenerational survivor, I think dwelling on the past will only continue to keep people stuck. If my First Nations brothers and sisters want to move forward they really must forgive, keep their heads up and take the steps forward that they need to to heal and be happy and healthy. Being a victim doesn't work, I tried it and it almost killed me...

I work on a reserve as a nurse today and can only hope and pray these things happen.


John Steeves
said

There was no need for an apology. Those responsible are dead. People have to stop living in, and harping about the past.

Time to move on.


Breezey
said

I think it was due, I believe it does have some sincerity as it what an awful disgusting policy, with no excuse but to be wrong. I do now think its time to move forward as a canada and not two separate people. Put the money into programs and centres to help those affected and to help break those cycles of abuse and for those who turned to substances, to help substance abuse. All let keep striving to be the country EVRYONE would be proud to call home.


Stephanie
said

Talk is cheap - actions speak louder than words. Are Aboriginal peoples living on reservations going to see an improvement to their quality of life? Will the Canadian government finally put an end to the "Fourth World" that exists in Canada? The Indian Act is still an assimilation act - in a few more generations there won't be anymore "Indians" and assimilation will be complete - will this be changed?

As a white Canadian, I don't have to be satisfied by today's events, and nothing will, or for that matter, should, absolve me of my cultural legacy. It is what it is, and my "people" should wear it forever. I thought today's events were nothing more than performance and empty words, but if it provided some comfort and at least formal recognition, I think that is an important, but small and long overdue, first step. I want to know what the Canadian government intends to do now - was this apology a beginning or an end? Time will tell, and considering the Canadian state's legacy as far as its dealings with Aboriginal peoples are concerned, I think on-going cynicism is the most realistic and legitimate perspective to have on all of these events.


angela
said

I am an Algonquin/Metis. I have no language. I have no culture or traditions. I am the end result of decades of attempted assimilation.... through residential schools, through racism and ignorance...

I say attempted however, because I refuse to give up my identity. I have light skin, blonde hair but I refuse to lose my native identity. I don't have a status card, I'm not tax exempt, I don't get free schooling... that's not what this is about.

Assimilation happens when you roll over and say, "You win."

I'm 30 years old. I'm reclaiming my past and in my lifetime, I will learn my aboriginal language again. I will incorporate aboriginal traditions into my life again. When I have children, they will learn these as well. They will embrace their backgrounds from their mother's side and their father's side. You must honour all of your ancestors...

Unfortunately with apologies no one wins. Someone admits a fault. Someone was wrong. No one is ahead in the end.

By the way... Anglican and United (and other churches as well) have reached some settlements and churches have (including my own) been paying into a large fund to pay these settlements. I applaud these churches for taking the responsibility... even if we did not directly do it... the legacy remains. By chosing to associate with those who have wrong in the past, it is our inheriate duty to accept the responsibilities of the past.

Some of the settlement monies are "supposed" to go into legacy funds to assist the children, grand-children, great-grandchildren of those who have been wronged. They are affected too.

Allow all of them -- at the very least -- to have the opportunity to reclaim their past.


Alex
said

To Roger T: If you want Aboriginals to get Parliament seats, perhaps you should encourage them to register as a candidate, run a good campaign, and get elected? That's how it works in a democracy. I hope that there will never be a time in Canada (or, eventually, anywhere) when people can just "demand and be granted seats" like you say Aboriginals should, because that would be anti-democratic. Unless you're talking about the Senate?

About the actual apology, it was much-needed and overdue, so good job to the Harper government for doing it. Shame on Trudeau, Mulroney, Chretien, etc. for not.


Norwegian
said

Go Canada. It's great to see such an apology in the western world. My own government in Norway should do the same for their similar actions against Saapmi and Romani people banning their language, shattering their familys and sterilising their women up to the mid 70s, it's about time. Lovely Canada, you're an inspiration :-)


Anishinaabe Youth
said

As a young lady growing up in a community full of residential school survivors, many in my immediate family, I have realized at a very young age the impact it has had on the surivors and their families. An apology is an expression with words that many people may not comprehend or simply understand. I understand the importance of forgiveness and the feeling of self gratitude of offering an apology, but to put myself in any suriviors shoes I will probably still be carrying a great amount of hate and anger within. Our generation with many soon to come will never see world peace. War is not only an Aboriginal fight, "White People" will never get over the fact that they are being discriminated against because of their ancestors actions. The cycle will continue and continue...Never-ending. I am sincerely grateful for Mr. Harpers apology and am proud to say that my father is a survivor who has overcame many tough obstacles in his lifetime. He has raised 4 successful children since then with grate dignity and pride, I know he is extremely proud of himself and on behalf of my family I am thankful. As for the Non-Aboriginal races who do not wish to acknowledge this great history, I am as well deeply sorry for the attitude and selfishness that I know and have seen frist hand directed towards you. What can I say, it may be a means of dealing with a deep, internal issue most people will never have to deal with!


Garry in NS
said

This appology is but the first step in a very long healing process. However well intentioned, no words can erase the hurt and tragedy experienced by so many in those schools. The treatment of our original Canadians was based on the colonial concept of superiority. This concept was also evident in the USA, Africa, and a host of other nations. I now wonder if those former Eurpean colonial powers will appologize for what they have done in the past. Canada has taken the first step of many.


Tony
said

I think these comments are really split. But I feel that each side is misinterpreting the other. No one is saying JUST move on JUST forget cause well that's not possible. However there are people all over who suffer similar injustices and receive no apology and no compensation of any kind. They still manage to continue on. The problem with internet forum is you don't hear tone of voice instead you assume (and usually the most negative way). You don't see body language which is important.

I think this apology was a great thing. That being said there has to be a point where we can stop apologizing and compensating for the mistakes of our ancestors. I did not start residential schools, I did not work at one, I did not abuse anyone. We should not forget this happened because remembering the past is the only way to not repeat it.

I don't believe it is fair to blame all the social problems on residential schooling. I think that if you really want to learn about your heritage you can, and that goes for anyone. There are all kinds of language courses out there all kinds of appreciation courses for many different backgrounds. So don't let anything stop you try it out. Go learn.

We need to take past as past and that's not saying to forget. But just take it for what it is.


Wayne
said

Why is it that there are people posting saying yes an apology is due and then comes the kicker : HOWEVER : when you apologize for something if you ever put a BUT or HOWEVER in the staemnet you are basically not apologizing!


Raigen D'Angelo
said

I believe the apology made today is very beneficial to the healing of both the First Nations peoples and the general public. It is important because it helps to establish a public dialogue regarding the horrific nature of the Residential Schools and how it tried to wipe out the native people. As a First Nations woman, it made me proud to be aboriginal and not hide in the shame of the past. I wish my mother and grandparents were alive to witness this day.


Change Now
said

I am just so tearful here. This apology should have come when our parents were still here.

I am not surprized at the denial and ignorance people like Terry and Mugsy represent. They fail to see that is exactly what the problem is, and where it originated from. That mindset. It will never go away.


James Murdock
said

We have a Dream (National Unity)

Perhaps in fitting with and in future rememberance of this Wednesdays historic apology and expression of national unity with our aboriginal brothers and sisters - perhaps if agreed June 11th
could be First Nations People Day in Canada.

Let there be aborginal seats in the House of Commons
not just for this one day. But let us truly join hands at our nations table of brotherhood/sisterhood everyday.

Sorry is the first step. May God bless the Aboriginal - Canadian peoples.


RRR
said

On a day that should have been a great solemn, united day in the House of Commons, Gilles Duceppe has to display his true colors of separatism, and criticize the Gov't. and ruin the spirit that was there. Obviously, his only goal is to break up the Country which enforces even more the frequently asked question: "Why is a political party whose only goal is separation from Canada, allowed a place in the House of Commons?


Natasha Saganash
said

Okay now. Apology is accepted by some people and some of us will not forget the trauma that they have caused. But we must forgive and yes we must punish those that have committed crimes against my people.

My late mother was a survior of the residentials school. I am not sure if she was a survior cause she killed herself a couple of years ago. I know she had suffered a great deal and never wanted to talk about it. I heared many of the screams at night from her nightmares that she has suffered. Our mother was unaffectionate towards her children and grand-children. She didn't liked to be touched.

She left behind seven children all grown. We are waiting for our settlement for two months now. We know that it won't be enough. Imagine dividing 27 thousand dollars in seven? How much is that gonna help us.

Her children have broken families. Still living unheathy relationships.

We have seen and heard a lot of this during our childhood like myself I don't want to pass on that abuse to my children but is very hard to break that cycle.

Anyhow, my late mother told me that an apology would do her some good and she was looking foward to the compensation but she couldn't take it any longer.
I was anxious looking at this special broadcast on television with my children and later released some tears for my late mom. She wanted to see this day.


Daniel Tessier
said

It is a shame that many of the comments posted here are politicized - this should be a day of reflection for all Canadians.

Please set the partisanship aside as a courtesy to those who suffered most and in honour of Canada's First Nations.


Pam aka native_poison_ivy
said

I would like to say today that I am a strong proud Anishinabe woman. After my experience in the residential school I couldn't say that till I was 30 years old, which was just 9 years ago. I am also a Canadian who's First Nation. Many uneducated people can make rash statements about what they know nothing about thats just plain ignorant human nature. To these people I send you prayers so that you may one day walk the good path. I am very grateful that my sons did not have to endure what I went through. I am trying to break this cycle, I wonder if the same can be said about other Canadians. Unfortunately with the racism and discrimination still rampant in our society that cycle will still continue. To my sisters and brothers I send you love and one day may you find peace. Miigwetch


Tara Sawyer
said

I am a Metis child of a residential school survivor as well as the many surviving relatives who also made an impact on my and my siblings' life. I agree this is long overdue; however, I also have a hard time believing in its complete sincerity. They are only words without promise.

Regardless of my belief and whether or not it was sincere...it has made a large enough impact across our land to elicit such emotion from so many Canadians, both aboriginal and non-aboriginal. The comments on this board are a testament to that.

Maybe the Catholic Church did make an apology in past...maybe the government did also. I was not aware of these apologies as I am sure many other Canadians were also not aware of them. Why?? Was it because of who they were addressed to? When the Government closes their doors from regular business for a day to make a formal aplogy to many aboriginal leaders, people are going to listen!!

So for me, the apology was not to heart, but the means in which it was delivered was monumental in starting the healing process. I think there are too many ignorant people out there who haven't a clue what happened and this can really start to open their eyes to it.

And, Yes, Tori, First Nations & Metis have adknowledged these issues in past and, yes there has been support and counselling...it obviously goes deeper (multi-generational) than a lot of people would care to believe.

I will accept the aplogy, for I too have felt the wrath of the cultural genocide. Only now, can I believe the healing will begin.


Leesa
said

It was what my Grandparents would wanted too....Thankfully my Mother heard it and she was fine with it.


ingrid francois
said

As a young female aboriginal, i have recently attended university which is how i came to understand the devestation that i grew up seeing in my home in northern manitoba. I am eternally gratful that i have been privliged to see such a historic event which has occured today. I understand some people may be very upset and think that an apology is not enough, but it is a big step toward healing and rejuvination for our people. Thank You Prime Minister Stephen Harper for the sincerity of your apology for the past injustices that have occured to my people. Ekosani.


Bob Racine
said

I believe this is a step in the right direction - and yes not only the Conservatives will have to follow through but the opposition parties (those in opposition now and those in the future) will have to see this to the end.

For all those naysayers out there, do you really think that the government, after signing a declaration, and the good will that was so apparent would NOT come through with whatever it takes to heal the wounds - such skepticism.

As for Gilles Duceppe's comments I expected nothing less - criticize the very country that will provides him with medical coverage for himself and his family, and a hefty pension to boot, as well as the pretty good salary he has been receiving as the leader of the BLOC, simply to be negative.

Mr. Duceppe who is so proud arrogant saying that the Province of Quebec had already started the healing process with the Aboriginal people's, maybe he should think of what the Duplessis government, with the backing and financing of the Catholic Church, did to Jehovah's Witnesses and how their children were also traumatized when parents were put in prison for being something other than Catholic (as a former JW who left many years, ago I still believe that this was an injustice done in the name of religion and government - maybe the PQ / BLOC should set a precedent and provide the JWs with an apology - then the PQ / BLOC can take full credit and not have to share the stage with the Federal Government for the apology; it only occurred in Quebec.




Steve in the Maritimes
said

I too believe that it has taken too long for the gov't to offer its apology.... and contrary to others, it is just a first step on a long journey. I am a mid thirty white male who knows that culturally there is responsibility that I must take for the past. Not easy steps for anyone to take, and there are costs -- not just financial, but a real analysis of what has happened and is still happening in our society. The next steps will be as important as this first step.
For those commenting about the churches taking responsibility, as a member of the United Church of Canada, unfortunately a supporter of the residential school process, we have issued two formal apologies --1986 to the general mistreatment of First Nations people, and then in 1998 specifically to the Residential Schools. These words having been shared have only been first steps in our work at healing relationship with First Nations Communities across this country.
Though not at all a supporter of Stephen Harper, I thank him for offering those words today, and hope that action follows.... I too offer my apology for actions that go beyond words.


Barb Gardey
said

I'm very releived that this has finally happened. I'm proud that our Prime Minister had the courage to finally apologize for the Federal Gov't and for the people of Canada. The only damper would be the fact that Gilles Duceppe spoke. It's really easy for someone who has no responsibilities to anyone to speak out against the Gov't and tell them what they should be doing. All he really cares about is breaking up Canada, and he couldn't care less what happens to our First Nations people.
I hope this is the beginning of the healing that needs to take place.

Jaquiline
said

it's about time that the government did something about this.

Frank Buchan
said

The apology was well made, and I think it was sincerely intended. That the aboriginal leaders were given a chance to speak suggests maybe the apology sparked an understanding that to be strong people need a forum for their voice. It was nice to see the majority of the folks who were there today were embracing an opportunity for positive change.

I, for one, look forward to the day when native culture takes on a greater role in our general culture. I would love to learn about that past through the eyes of the people whose culture it is, and today may mark a chance to begin to focus on the strength of that culture, rather than the inappropriate attempt past leaders made to erase it.

To all the survivors, never forget that you are survivors. No matter what was done to you, it is what you have done for yourselves that sets you above and apart from the actions of those who caused your pain.


Deboran
said

Now, let's
1.build a memorial to the victims to show our Canadian nation's grief
2. build a museum to record the history so others know what happen & so it never happens again,
3. have writers record the stories/pain/loss & healing so all Canadians can know more details, & thus have more understanding
4. do whatever it takes to give something to our incredible First Nation people to assist them thrive again in their incredible rich & deep culture



lynne
said

to all who are in this column, and i am sure this wont get posted, but my son inlaw was one of those put through this residental school stuff, he receive compensation for his pain and suffering back in 2003, no it likely wasnt enought for him, but i will tell you that he did some good with his settlement, he used it to help himself and my granddaughter improve their lives, he also used a small amount of it to help me get a permanent residence card for my husband, who has turned out to be the best grandpa my granddaughter ever had, my son inlaw was grateful for the help and acknowledgement that was done for his pain and suffering. but i am so thankful for stephen harper to say that in public and the way he did it, your a great pm sir, and you will do canada much good, thank you so much for all you have done, and good luck in the next election, may our creator watch over you and bless you and yours.


Grace
said

I'm so happy that they finally said that their sorry...I'm soo happy

Roadrobber
said

I don't understand how someone can be against this action by Mr. Harper and criticize his motives. This apology is long overdue. It hurts nobody to apologize for something and can only make those affected the most feel better. What exactly is wrong with that?


David
said

kookum's(grandmothers) goomshoom's(grandfathers)my aunts and uncles and parents, I felt the pain you felt growing up and the wounds still hurt but today I feel relief from the burdens of our collective past. I forgive and will bring my future children into a better place free from these burdens!

meegwetch and chaceedin (love)


Diane Lloyd
said

I was so pleased to see the heartfelt sympathy expressed by our Members of Parliament on behalf of Canadians; it was so overdue and so necessary. I felt pride that at last we were doing the right thing.

I was then so very discouraged by the comments of Pierre Poilievre who wasn't compassionate enough to give our first nations people one day of peace before he started the abuse again.

He should be so ashamed of himself and it would be a positive move on his part to resign.

Diane Lloyd
Lakefield, Ont

Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

In Pictures

First Nations people depart the site of the former Shubenacadie Residential School, and walk through a finish line ribbon, during an Honour Walk march on Wednesday, June 11, 2008 in Shubenacadie, N.S. (Mike Dembeck / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Day of Apology

Scenes from across Canada as the PM apologizes for abuse at residential schools.

CTV Video Player

Aboriginal

Response from Leaders

Watch the powerful and emotional response to the apology, made by leaders in the Aboriginal community.

CTV Video Player

duffy promo; play button; Mike Duffy Live

Mike Duffy Live

Aboriginal members explain what the government's apology for residential school abuse means to them.

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz