CTV News | How did 'Sex and the City' score on STIs?

Top Stories -   

How did 'Sex and the City' score on STIs?

Sex and the City

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(23)

By: Andrea Janus, CTV.ca News

Date: Fri. May. 30 2008 10:09 AM ET

If Samantha Jones, the sexy and sex-obsessed character on the hit television show Sex and the City, was a real woman, sexually transmitted disease counsellors might have to sit her down and explain the tenets of safe sex.

As Samantha once famously said in an episode: "I'm a tri-sexual. I'll try anything once."

This Friday, the fab four that made up one of television's most famous group of friends are making their eagerly anticipated big-screen debut in the Sex and the City movie.

But don't expect any frank talk about safe sex amidst the outrageous personal and professional escapades that are sure to be a big part of the movie's plot.

Over the show's six-season run on HBO in the United States and The Movie Network in Canada, only three episodes dealt with sexually transmitted infections (STI). Miranda was diagnosed with chlamydia, Charlotte got crabs after cavorting with a younger man and Samantha finally got an AIDS test.

But with the parade of sexual partners each character had, the issue might have come up more if these were real women.

"The women don't talk a lot about practising safe sex, even though they are very sexually active," Dr. Gina Ogilvie, associate director of the division of STI/HIV prevention and control at the B.C. Centre for Disease Control, told CTV.ca.

"And you would think when they have their lunches and they sit in the diner that it would come up more. But it doesn't. And I think that's a disappointment and, from my vantage point, a lost opportunity."

During the show's run, the characters had multiple sexual partners:

  • Carrie: 14
  • Charlotte: 17
  • Miranda: 18
  • Samantha: 40 (including a short-lived relationship with a woman named Maria)

But according to Ogilvie, it's a person's behaviour, not how many partners they have, which dictates STI risk.

"Individuals can have more sexual partners, but if they've been very careful with their sexual partners, then their risk may be lower than the person who just has one or two risk encounters but chooses not to use condoms and practise safe sex."

However, regular condom use would not have fully eliminated the women's risk of contracting an STI, Ogilvie said.

"For instance, the story with Charlotte who got pubic lice. Well, condom use is not going to prevent pubic lice," Ogilvie said.

"So if you have more encounters, even if you're using condoms but you're not getting regularly screened for STIs, you could acquire one and not know it."

Advice for the four friends

But if Ogilvie were to offer counselling to each character on safe-sex practices, she said she would give the women the same advice, despite their different sexual history (and Samantha's drastically higher number of partners).

"When you look at the numbers, you would think that I might tone down my advice to Carrie versus someone like Samantha. But first of all, it's not just about what you do, it's also about your partner's history," Ogilvie said.

"So for each of them, I would certainly advise routine STI screening, particularly when they've moved to a new sexual partner or are planning to have a new sexual partner."

The show's loyal viewers may not have been watching a safe sex public service announcement. But that's not to be expected from a prime-time, cable network dramedy aimed at modern, urban women.

What fans should have taken from the show, and particularly from an empowered character like Samantha, according to Ogilvie, is more confidence to ask questions about different areas of sex and sexuality.

"I think one of the appealing things about Samantha is that she is very confident in her sexuality," Ogilvie said.

"I think what that permits women to do is potentially feel empowered to ask questions and seek knowledge and that this is not knowledge that they should feel ashamed about asking for or pursuing."

The Sex and the City movie opens in theatres on Friday.

Share with your social Network:

Comments are now closed for this story

mac
said

I hope this movie is a hit.

I have no interest in seeing it (although it seems to have some funny lines in it).

But it is an R-rated movie aimed at a specific adult audience. If it performs well at the box office, then there could be R-rated action movies . . . which I do want to see.

PG-rated action movies are too childish.

You go, girls!





Karl Marx
said

I hate Sex and the City. I hope it fails miserably at the box office. I believe that there are few shows that have messed up women more in the head, as far as encouraging them that risky, lewd and unsafe sexuality is perfectly safe and that they need not worry about it.
Films that encourage exaggerated male sexuality are also a target for my disfavour, such as the American Pie series, or any of the other films like it.


Alex Sz
said

What a bunch of rubbish. While "Adults" can laugh at the comedity of the show, young adults; those 16 to 25, seem to think this is normal. Just look at the statistics of young adult sexual activity and see what they now consider normal sexual activity. When 18 year old young men have to take the blue pill for their girl friends, that is troubling.


ARJAY
said

Isn't America a paradoxical society? Here we have a TV show and a movie that celebrate female sexuality, yet just a few years ago the female surgeon general of the United States, Jocelyn Brothers, was fired for suggesting that teenage girls be taught to masturbate to help them avoid pregnancy by lowering their sexual need. What made this even more ridiculous was the idea that teenage girls needed to be taught to masturbate, as if this weren't a completely natural and normal function that they discovered for themselves. American society seems to enjoy fantasizing about sex openly, yet whenever someone suggests something that might be beneficial, like teaching birth control in school, or raising the uncomfortable specter of female teenage masturbation, suddenly Americans become incredibly prudish and quite frankly naive.


Dan Dan
said

Must be a slow news day if we have to resort to talking about some loose women from a lame TV series...


Wendy
said

While I have never been a fan of this tv series nor will I go to the movie or even watch it when it comes out on DVD, I am shocked by Dr. Ogilvie's thinking. I thought movies released in theatres were for entertainment not education. Who cares if they don't talk about safe sex on the show or movie. If people don't have it in their heads by now to practice safe sex, then the millions of advertising dollars that has been spent getting that message across has been wasted. What is being taught in Sex Ed classes in schools. Oh yes, I am sure budget cuts have cut those classes out!

If I want to be educated when watching a movie, I will watch one that the Canadian Film Board has put out like the ones we watched in school.

I watch movies to be entertained not to be preached at.


Lindsay Morgan
said

Much ado about absolutely nothing.
What will this teach young girls/women, are things not bad enough already?
Ridiculous and too bad it is receiving so much attention/publicity.
Shame, shame.


G-Dog
said

I turned the show on once. I thought it was about three hookers and their mother.


Adam
said

Its a tv show designed to be a comedy. There is nothing funny about STI's. Despite what the morons on Family guy have you believe


Chris
said

Karl Marx apparently doesn't know the difference between fantasy and reality. Who knew?

Just because I saw the movie 300 didn't mean I wanted to go out and slaughter all persians...

Movies are entertainment, they aren't trying to teach you a life lesson.


THISMOVIEISABOUTNOTHING
said

NEWS FLASH, four cougars seen prowling the streets of NEW YORK.



Old Fogie
said

Although I have never seen "Sex & the City", I certainly don't feel I have missed anything. High morale standard are a thing of the pas, and this movie is not going to help bring them back. All this movie is going to do is promote more sexual activity amoung those who don't need it. When are tax payer going to learn that it is we, the people paying for the produvt of teenage pregnancies....All the illegitimate babies who are never going to have a chance in life, because their parents were completely void of morals.


Chris
said

I saw SATC last night at an Advanced Screening and it was absolutely enjoyable. I'm a fan of the show and the actresses. They looked amazing. The story-line was great too!!


Guido Sarducci
said

Slatterns in the city.


Katherine
said

I absolutely am IN LOVE with Sex and the City. I have been waiting quite a long time to see the movie, and last night I finally did. It was amazing, except for the mistakes- buffer mics were left in some sceens and for a whole fifteen minutes or so, there was a black strip missing across the top of the screen. I had heard that was coming, but i wasn't prepared for how awful it was. I'm truely disappointed in the director or editor of the film for not catching that gigantic mistake. The movie itself though, was great; I loved seeing my "girls" on the screen again making me laugh.


ROSIE
said

Most of the people who left comments haven't even seen an episode. What dweebs!! Best show ever, totally love it! Such a fun show to watch, made me laugh so much. News flash, never made me want to go out & have multiple sexual partners or unsafe sex. Hellooo wake up, it's a show, a movie, not reality. I think people know the difference.


Lesley
said

I am a big Sex and the City fan and I think the show is amazing. While the characters do encounter a number of sexual partners over the course of the six seasons, if you look at the direction the show takes and its overall message, the main purpose isn't to educate people about safe sex or suggest women go on unsafe sex rampages.
I am a 25-year-old female and when I get together with my girlfriends, we don't often discuss the importance of safe sex- we ask questions about the men in our lives and relationships. I think too much sex education would have taken away from the authenticity of the show. If one has to learn safe sex practices form an HBO series, I think we are all in trouble!
I completely disagree with the show being nothing more than four women 'encouraging risky, lewd and unsafe sexuality.' I dare you to watch a season and take a closer look. I think it’s a fabulous display of wmoen's relationships and their sexuality, complete with a character that pushes the boundaries of what has been deemed 'appropriate' behavior for a women. I love Kim Cattrall’s character, Samantha. Does that mean I run out and have unsafe sexual relations with as many men as possible because I can? No. It encourages me to take a look at my own life and sexual experiences and know that it’s ok to feel empowered, strong, sexy and confident as women!
They've done a fabulous job and I can't wait to see the movie!



Wendy
said

To Adam: The show isn't about STI's it is about 4 women. They are not unlike most single women at that age. No there is nothing funny about STI's but that is not what it's about.


Gerry
said

Better yet, how many cases of STDs has resulted from
this series and another glorified chick flick?


Trudy
said

We all go through phases in life. Before fifty it's about hormones and after fifty it's about brains. The young seem brainless sometimes but it is a kind of rights of passage. Most of us dressed or behaved too provocatively in some way when we were young, according to the older generation. I'm sure this can be said for as far back generationally as a person wants to go. Young people are driven to break rules, define themselves as separate from the older generation. This ends up on tv, in movies as entertainment. Those of us, who are older, think it's stupid. Just wait, the young right now will be the older generation one day, and saying the same thing about their kids. I saw a few episodes of Sex & The City on tv. I couldn't relate. I live in the country, work hard in stables and it's kind of difficult to look sexy at the best of times at such work. I remember when I was young, though I had hormones too, good parenting kept me from sleeping around. I always had more pride, dignity and sense. I see my children, my nieces and newphews not sleeping around either. Good parenting is the key to much. If the kids are sleeping around, look at the parents. So, I guess these girls had parents who slept around or were too busy to take the time help their kids develop some plain old good sense. There are many ways to learn, but learning the hard way is still the best way. My son once emulated Michael Jackson but now he is embarrassed to be reminded.


Alana
said

It's a TV show and a movie - not real life! The show is meant to make you laugh not change the world.


Gary
said

Plzzzzzz..I'd rather talk about Brenda Martin for heavens sake and that story made me gag.


Secure Man and Husband
said

I hope it's so good my wife and her friends go see it a few times, it makes them happy and excited so I like it. Now they know how I feel when a new Star Wars movie comes out.


 

Advertisement

Contest
Movie Review

Movie Review

The clothes! The shoes! 'Sex and the City' hits the silver screen with much fanfare.

'Sex' Talk

'Sex' Talk

These spicy 'SATC' classics will surely liven up your office chitchat.

Sex in the City

CTV Video Player

A look at the show, and the movie's pop culture impact.

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz