CTV News | Kids traded sex for food from aid workers: report

World -   

Kids traded sex for food from aid workers: report

Viewer

CTV News Video

Canada AM: Problem said to be under-reported

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(47)

CTV.ca News Staff

Date: Tue. May. 27 2008 1:30 PM ET

Some of the world's most vulnerable children are being victimized by the very people sent to help them, according to a new report from a major humanitarian aid organization.

"No One To Turn To," a report from the U.K.-based aid organization Save The Children, says sexual exploitation against children as young as six by aid workers and peace keepers, is becoming a major crisis.

Almost as shocking as the abuse itself, says a news release from the group, is the general silence surrounding the violations of trust.

"Children and their families are not speaking out because of fear and powerlessness. And international organizations are failing to respond effectively to allegations of abuse levelled against them," the release says.

Save The Children convened 38 discussion groups that consisted of 341 people living in chronic emergencies in Cote d'Ivoire, Haiti and southern Sudan.

More than 30 per cent of the participants reported incidents of forced sex

  • 55 per cent reported coerced sex
  • 40 per cent said they were aware of incidents of kissing
  • 55 per cent reported incidents of touching
  • 65 per cent had witnessed incidents of verbal abuse from aid workers or peacekeepers.

"Participants identified coerced sex as more common than forced sex," the report states.

"Children as young as six are trading sex with aid workers and peacekeepers in exchange for food, money, soap and, in a very few cases, luxury items such as mobile phones."

Troops with the United Nations Department of Peacekeeping Operations were identified as a particular source of abuse, particularly in Haiti and Côte d'Ivoire, the report states.

Of the four UN agencies that reported allegations of sex with minors in 2005, DPKO staff were implicated in the vast majority of cases.

  • UN Department of Peacekeeping Operations: 60
  • UN High Commission for Refugees: 2
  • UN World Food Program: 1
  • United Nations Volunteers: 4

"While this may be a true indication of conduct associated with military actors, it may also reflect the particular efforts invested by DPKO to monitor and report on abuses associated with its own staff. Indeed, Save the Children welcomes the managerial courage and transparency DPKO has shown in making these allegations publicly available," the report states.

The data was reinforced with a number of anecdotal reports of abuse from people living in crisis zones -- including verbatim accounts of sexual abuse from the victims themselves.

"A broad spectrum of different types of aid workers and peacekeepers were implicated in the abuse," the report states.

"For example, staff at every level, from guards and drivers to senior managers, were identified as having been involved.

Participants also implicated a mix of local, national and international personnel, including staff described as 'black,' 'white,' 'foreign' and 'local' people."

In addition to meeting with aid recipients, Save The Children met with 30 humanitarian, peace and security professionals working at national, regional and international levels and conducted a broad spectrum of research.

The report acknowledges that Save The Children itself is not immune to the problem.

In 2007, 15 allegations of misconduct towards children were made against Save The Children staff and its partners organizations.

Seven of the allegations were made against partners, while eight were made against staff.

Three of the allegations against staff were proven and led to dismissals. The three men were all fired for having had sex with girls aged 17, which is not illegal but contravenes the organization's policy.

In 2006, four allegations were made against partners and seven were made against staff.

"Save the Children does not claim to have all the answers, or to be immune to this problem. Indeed, awareness of the difficulty of stamping this out in our own organization is a driving force behind this report," the document states.

"We do believe, however, that eliminating this abuse is a key responsibility of every international actor."

The report identifies three areas where key problems exist:

  • Community members, especially children and young people, are not receiving the support they need to speak out about abuse against them.
  • Strong leadership is lacking to ensure good practices and procedures are adopted up and implemented.
  • A lack of investment in tackling the root causes of sexual exploitation and abuse.

It sets out the following recommendations to deal with the shortfalls:

  • The establishment of effective local complaints mechanisms to allow people to report abuses.
  • The establishment of a global watchdog to monitor and evaluate international agencies and their track record on sexual abuse.
  • Governments and donors should put more emphasis on tackling the root causes of sexual abuse.

Comments are now closed for this story

DWB
said

That's what you get along with corruption and other abuses when there's no accountability.

Governments and donors need to think twice before forking over vast amounts of resources.




Ron
said

It is the catholic church all over again. Power corrupts. Absolute power corrupts absolutely. If we cannot protect our children, what are we as a society?


Ian Yellowknife
said

Unacceptable. These people are where Capital Punishment should exist. Our children of the world should, and have to be protected and anything less is wrong. This type of event went on in the churches and was allowed by cowards. Lets send a message to these pedophiles that the world doesn't want them.


Kevin
said

I'm beyond disgusted and totally speechless.


Lou
said

We, as a society, are worse than animals...they don't abuse their children!


Alana
said

What is happening to this world? This story makes me so sad. How do we protect the children in this world from these animals?


Sonny
said

To much trust is given to those in power. Much of the money donated goes to "Developed World" administration rather than providing for the basic needs of the people that they are supposedly helping.

When the relationship is that the worker can withhold food etc. the chance for abuse increases.


Debbie in Langley
said

What can one say? We read about these crimes, invasions upon our most vulnerable. We shed a tear. We donate money and trust. I feel helpless sometimes in this world. A world run by power and money. I can't even imagine how these children must feel. I am sometimes ashamed to be a part of the human race.


D.R. - Toronto
said

Yet another example of HUGE social programs that are run without any accountability. These children are looking to us for the most basic of needs to simply survive, and this is what they must do to get it??? Sickening!! This is the exact reason I donate locally. As sad as it is, the human race has evolved very very little. We only like to think we have. We have to get away from these massive social programs that help only the ones running them. The private sector for profit would be a better option. At least we know where the goods are going. Probably fair to say that the profits would be less than all the lining of pockets along the road through the "social net".


Sara
said

Lou - AGREED


LMM
said

It is more than hard to believe !!! How much more can these people endure, just to try and live .
God must be crying !


Trai
said

This is disheartening to hear but not shocking. Anywhere you have the human element there is room for the profane, the inhumane, and injustice. Just as there is room for a large amount of genuine good that can be done. It is very uplifting to see the organization doing something about the acts of the individuals and holding them accountable.


beeman
said

Debbie in Langely - I'm with you.


Roger T
said

The most disguisting and disturbing news yet to surface from Humanitarian workers. Why, because these organizations are mainly runned by the West and turn a blind eye by calling the Mission Human Rights just to be close to the oil rich countries.

Sounds more like Human Abuse Mission.


Kerri
said

Pedaphiles are not dumb! They are predators who get jobs that give them these opportunities! If you have a 30 year old person that wants to be around children all the time that should sound alarms everywhere! Then we give them the power to do this, all the while giving them praise for being so helpful and caring! SICK!


bobby
said

Similar reports were leveled against UN troops and aid workers in Africa years ago - nothing has changed in that organization.

And to the poster linking this to the Catholic Church - SHAME ON YOU! There are many more cases of teacher-student abuse than priest-child abuse.
All are horrendous.


Tori
said

Just because a person volunteers obviously does not make them a good person.

Organizations are going to have to begin screenings and drug testing like major corporations do. Of course looking for a pedophile is often like looking for a needle in a haystack unless they are already a registered sex offender.

This story makes me sick. Humanitarian aid not a realistic name any more now is it?


Wendy
said

Oh my god... like these poor kids and their families don't have enough to worry about. What the heck is wrong with this world? Do these people sign up so they can abuse children? Who can they trust? Who can we trust? We give our hard earned money to try and help and it ends up being used for raping kids? I guess they do it because they can. Shame on whoever is in charge... Make the punishments worse and have people monitor donations more carefully - unless everyone is corrupt? God Bless those poor victims. The world needs to speak up and say "no more". Email all the organizations to say you won't tolerate it any longer or donations will stop. Do something ... don't just say "too bad" - what if it were your kids?




Soph
said

Sex offenders will always find a way to exploit the helpless children and with this disaster they just found an all pass access to young desperate children. This is totally sickening to me. Essentially, it seems to me that the organization, should have better screening tools before hiring these predators!!
Get to the root of the problem. That would be a much better solution. Once on site, how do you propose that any leader control theses animals?? Really??


Murray
said

Such a shame that we are supposed to be the civilized country and other countries look toward us for help in anyway we can provide and we send such animals like this !!!If these people were in the same position how would they feel if it were thier children or how would they wanted to be treated..It always seem that some kind of kindness has a price..And unfortunately the price for these people is to be subjected to inhumane selfish perverts..I think it destroys the belief in humanity and goodwill..I hope these people are caught and it be made public to who they are...



Helen Lovejoy
said

Will Somebody, PLEASE! Think of the Children!


SG
said

The saddest thing is the fact that we hear of these attrocities, we suffer for these children maybe even shed a tear, but guess what nothing is going to be done. When is someone going to stand up to these people, give the deserved punishment.


Tami
said

It happens continuously because the penalties are not harsh enough. The victim pays the price of the abuse for the rest of his/her life, while the guilty pays, if caught a couple years if that. where they continue ruin the lives of many innocent children.


Shelley Haggard
said

The abusers are sneaky and will use any 'in' they can. It is time for us to take the blinders off and start protecting the innocent.
I suggest aid workers be put through rigorous testing, including lie detector tests. People with good intentions would not protest evaluation. We can't afford to be naive when faced with these issues.


Jean
said

Shame on the aid workers and peace keepers who would take such terrible advantage of the children and families that need the assistance. For these workers to demand sex from these people is just sick. The aid workers and peace keepers need their heads examined and like someone else said the capital punishment.


Skye
said

it is a sad day anyday in the world when there are corrupt people out there taking advantage of those in need of help and the vunarable. Aid workers, priests, ministers, teachers, doctors, care workers --- the list goes on. I makes me ashamed of a large portion of the human race. These people are not dumb but must be held accountable for their actions and the reporting system must change so the victim in not victimized twice or more for coming forward and reporting these abuses. Tougher sentences must be handed out and more accountablity must be done by the agencies who are reporting to be helping the down trodden. God wants us to love each other but love in the good sense and to take care of each other NOT to abuse and take advantage of each other. I agree God must be crying. I pray each day that an answer will be found and now I pray for these who have had to endure much more than need be -- how much more can they take. We need workers to help look after them but the governments must also stand up and come up with ways for these people to have a chance at be self sustaining and where they can enjoy life not endure life.


Sarah
said

Absolutely and utterly apalling. I can't even fathom understanding what goes on in these sicko's heads. I, like Kevin above, am totally speechless and beyond disgusted.


IAN
said

I agree with 'Bobby' in as much as this is not new to the U.N and nothing has changed. What irks me is how Canadians so solidly support this corrupt, abusive organization and hide behind it to avoid helping friends, as happened with Iraq for instance. And please, if we can ridicule the entire Catholic church for the acts of some priests then we can hold the U.N. to the same standards.


Elly
said

Wow this is utterly unbelievable and disgusting!!
It a sad day when aid workers start victimizing little children for their own sick desires so the little kids can eat.You have to wonder about the governments of the world and mankind in general!!



Joyce Jenkins
said

Oh, that is unspeakable...to betray and prey on the weak and those in no position to fight back. There will be a special place in hell for those vermin. Meanwhile we need to all speak up and be appalled and force those in high places to put a stop to this no matter how or what they have to do.


Isabel
said

This deeply saddens me,as I'm sure it does everyone. I can't imagine how these children must feel. How can we see that this won't happen again? Is there a way to screen people for pedifelia? Can we help these children heal from their ordeal and can they learn to trust again? How do we do that? What can we do to help?


SSN
said

My heart goes out to these people and what they have to endure and I know they need help. However, in light of this story we will just have to stop donating. If those incharge have no money to pay themselves - what then? Maybe they will be forced to clean up their acts - money talks and the lack of it even louder


Bill - Kitchener
said

You have to wonder why it's always the same people who want to go over and help these poor unfortunates. If it is necessary to take a means test (background check)in the country of origin to take on the responsibility of caring for the less fortunate, why in Hell is it not necessary for those who travel to assist desperate people in desperate situations?


Dixie from Alberta
said

Humans are a hideous species. Look at what we do to each other. No other species on this earth is as cruel to their own or to others. Nothing surprises me anymore.


Mario
said

I'm afraid this is it, we appear to have reached the end of our road as a human race. I think that if at least 50% of the worlds leaders were women, this sort of thing wouldn't happen!


GR
said

I am really sick of reading this type of story.

Which person in there right mind would ever do this type of nonsense to these type of poor children.




DD
said

Now that we've all agreed that these are terribly destructive acts, why not get together and DO something, like write write letters, make phone calls to people in charge (government, leaders of the organizations... I don't know who exactly) and ensure that laws and procedures are put in place to protect the children. Maybe instead of repeating the same message of shame, the following posters could develop ideas on actions to take against these crimes.


Wes
said

This is a horrible and real problem. Governments that are donors need to take a more active role in monitoring what is done with relief items/money. Also the organizations that recieve donations must come under intense scrutiny to ensure that we have supported the right people to help those less fortunate. As for the three recomendations from this report they should be more realistic. I do think that complaint mechanisms should be clearly defined and simple to use. However a global watch dog will in time become as corrupt and bureacratically hand cuffed as the UN. And the last one "Governments and donors should put more emphasis on tackling the root causes of sexual abuse." This sounds good however it will only have an impact with regards to this problem if these NGO's submit themselves to government regulation. If we sent a couple of RCMP officers or a detachment from the international police task force on these missions perhaps crimes and abuses would be less frequent. And of course complete trasparency from these NGO's. Full disclosure about allegations and detailed records of workers and resources will go much further. This information will reach the media, bring government and lobby presure but most importantly it will affect donations. (This will force NGO's to keep better track of thier house holds) And of course in reality we simply need these organizations to supervise and stay informed of what is actually going on. This probably will take government intervantion.



B
said

I am so afraid of what our grandchildren are going to endure in this awful world. We need something major to happen to this planet to bring everybody back to reality. Does nobody value a human life anymore? These poor innocent children, how do we sleep at night when we know there are so many atrocities taking place. God, please watch over your children!


Lee-Anne in London, ON
said

This makes me feel so angry and sad...I continue to lose faith humanity...


monique
said

My heart goes to these children I wish I could change this world we live in . Everything is about money money and power . We need to change our ways if we want to survive on this planet


A Montrealer
said

It is truly heartbreaking that human beings have aspired to such a low moral standard and hide behind the premise of doing good unto others by joining up with a humanitarian organization. Totally and utterly disgusting. This is a horrible example displayed by these people who are supposed to be adults. Please!! ... Children are our future and they deserve a fighting chance to succeed. Humankind makes me deeply ashamed when the world turns a blind eye and continues to let these poor and helpless children suffer so much!


CYL
said

I am disgusted at hearing this. Is there a harsher word for disgusting ? These disgusting people who call themselves peacekeepers, humanitarians or aid workers or whatever, are to be caught jailed and the key thrown away or literally thrown to the sharks. I hope these abusers, sex crazed idiots will have their photos and addresses posted all over the newspapers. What goes round will come round.


Steph
said

I think the real question is now..... what the bloody hell are we going to do anout it???


Robin the Hood
said

It sort of brings to mind what the "agent Smith" told Morpheus (Laurence Fishburne) in the movie "The Matrix" about humanity behaving like a virus upon everything around it.. I see these people, who use humanitarian causes as a means to gain access to these children, as a good example of what he was referring to. I can give some other examples as well.
Also I fail to see why the word "human is used in "humanitarian"?.. A true oxymoron.



Mark
said

It doesn't surprise me that the peacekeepers are the majority. Most are from the African Union. People are always trying to take advantage of each other in those 2nd and 3rd world countries. It is completely normal over there where the masses live in absolute poverty. It is sad. The NGOs need to conduct better screening. In addition, there needs to be more over watch.


ance
said

These sick individuals look for situations of chaos, turmoil or limited oversight in which their potential victims are at their most vulnerable...

they seek these opportunities with deliberation and intent...

hence the term "sexual predator"...



Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

Related Websites

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz