CTV News | Bush launches political rocket from Israel

Politics -   

Bush launches political rocket from Israel

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News: Joy Malbon on Bush's bold statement
CTV Newsnet: Brian Katulis, American Progress
CTV Newsnet: Justin Logan, CATO Institute

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(29)

CTV.ca News Staff

Date: Thu. May. 15 2008 9:15 PM ET

U.S. President George Bush has set off a political furor back home following a speech in Israel where he suggested that some politicians are ready to "negotiate with terrorists."

Marking the 60th anniversary of Israel's founding, Bush told members of Israel's legislative body at the Knesset that he condemned "the false comfort of appeasement ... that we should negotiate with the terrorists and radicals, as if some ingenious argument will persuade them they have been wrong all along."

He then compared such a strategy to speaking with Hitler and the Nazis in the lead up to Germany's takeover of Poland and the start of the Second World War.

While he did not mention Barack Obama by name, Democrats accused Bush of cheap political posturing.

Obama, the likely Democratic presidential nominee, has suggested that, as president, he would be willing to negotiate with countries considered to be enemies of the U.S., including Syria, North Korea and Iran.

Obama issued a statement saying that Bush had launched a "false political attack" against him.

"George Bush knows that I have never supported engagement with terrorists, and the president's extraordinary politicization of foreign policy and the politics of fear do nothing to secure the American people or our stalwart ally Israel," Obama said in the statement.

The White House denied Bush's comments were aimed at Obama.

But Democrats lashed out at what they perceived as an attack on their presumptive leader. Delaware Senator Joe Biden didn't mince any words.

"This is outrageous, for the president of the United States to go to a foreign country, to sit in the Knesset . . . and make this kind of ridiculous statement."

Obama's Democratic opponent, Hillary Clinton, called Bush's original comments "offensive and outrageous, especially in light of his failures in foreign policy."

There is an unwritten rule in American politics that foreign trips should not be used to criticize domestic political opponents.

Meanwhile, other aspects of Bush's speech before the Knesset left many Israeli politicians disappointed. Some said that Bush had dropped an opportunity to push Israel and its neighbors into taking substantive steps towards a peace deal.

In his speech Bush said that Palestinians would have a homeland and people in the Middle East will live in "free and independent societies."

Bush added, "a desire for peace (will be) reinforced by ties of diplomacy and tourism and trade."

But he didn't mention any specific steps that would need to be taken to achieve the broad aspirations he described.

"It was an embarrassing speech, a collection of slogans that somebody wrote for him in order to be nice to Israel, or what he thinks is Israel, and to steer well clear of anything concrete," said Israeli lawmaker Yossi Beilin, a key architect of the Oslo peace accords.

"It's a shame and a scandal, in my opinion."


Comments are now closed for this story

joe
said

George Bush's idea of a terrorist is anyone who doesn't agree with him


bobby
said

Some one finally tells the truth and the opposition gets angry.

Neville Chamberlain has been forgotten by this generation. He held a worthless piece of paper in his hand and declared "Peace in our time" - soon followed by World War II and 50 million dead.

So much for peaceful negotiations with mass murderers and terrorists!


Tom
said

What do you expect from the world's biggest moron and biggest embarassment for the poor old US of A!? Bush just go crawl under a rock and let intelligent people take care of the real issues.


Straussian Steve
said

Mr. Bush's solutions all involve weapons as do those of Israel. Regrettably the USA and Israel are probably some of the worst terrorists on the planet. Israel has nukes but has not signed on to non- proliferation but they will tell you how much danger they live in while shooting innocents.


JoeNorthAmerican
said

Whether you agree with the policies of George Bush or not the fact is that what he said in Israel is entirely correct.

Democratic countries should no more negotiate with terrorists and rogue nations than townspeople should with a child molester who just moved into the neighbourhood.


Tony
said

Everyone is a terrorist according to Bush - at least those who don't toe his party line. How many more days until he's out? He's really wearing thin already.


David
said

"And there is distrust in Washington. I am surprised, frankly, at the amount of distrust that exists in this town. And I'm sorry it's the case, and I'll work hard to try to elevate it." --George W. Bush, interview on National Public Radio, Jan. 29, 2007



Chris
said

Classic Canadian reaction. Bush called it exactly right, too bad many Canadians see the world like they want it to be, as opposed to what it is. They share much with a certain British Prime Minister of the past - Neville Chamberlin


zac
said

US does half the military spending in the world . . . but Bush is still whining like a whipped dog. Maybe he should have mustered enough courage to go to Nam instead of looking for the Viet Cong air force in Texas.




Peter
said

Just be thankful Bush is on his way out, FINALLY!!!! No more stupid Bushisms.


Toby
said

George Bush has been a moron his entire life.

We can only expect stupid comments from him. The only ones more stupid then him are the moron's that elected him for a second term.

American's just don't understand why they are so disliked worldwide. They may be nice people but their governments have had disatrous foreign policies.

They have a history of meddling and selling arms to countries who turn around and bite them in the ass.


RRO
said

I question the forum he used to make these comments, I question in choice of example.

The problem in my view, is that Obama has said he is willing to talk to these groups open endedly, he has placed no prerequesits, and because of his inexperianced he has not layed out a clear vision of what he plans to do. Is Obama the right guy to handle foreign policy? I don't know


Hans
said

'Bama. = chuckle =

'Bama has promised to withdraw, retreat, er, withdraw.

No terrorist is afraid of 'Bama.

Yup, I stand by my prediction of $2/liter by November.


Jason Daniel Baker
said

Barack Obama is an idiot who does not even know that Canada has a Prime Minister, not a President.

The only reason he might win the Democratic nomination is because his competition is even less qualified than he is.

I don't see much controversy in saying Obama doesn't know enough about foreign policy pertaining to Israel. Quite frankly he does not know enough about anything to be a head of state.


Andrew in BC
said

I haven't agreed with a lot of the things that President Bush has done during his long tenure, not to be forgotten the housing/credit crisis which his party brought into law, saving his father face by attacking Iraq, Cheney, etc; but his speech did have a lot of truth, for once, attached to it. What I see about all of the hub-bub commencing in the aftermath of the speech is Obama's lack of experience in assuming that the speech was strictly about him. I like Obama, but I believe that Senator Clinton would do a much better job, even with her anti-Canadian remarks in the past, as the President of the United States. If Obama keeps shooting himself in the foot every other day the world will have to live with John McCain as the President...most likely with Cheney as the Vice-president (a.k.a. Putin's way)in charge of the most important country, at this time, in our world.


mac
said

Bush's own Secretary of Defense wants talk with Iran. Bush is not just an idiot; he's ridiculous.

From the Washington Post:
"The United States should construct a combination of incentives and pressure to engage Iran, and may have missed earlier opportunities to begin a useful dialogue with Tehran, Defense Secretary Robert M. Gates said yesterday."




gosha
said

Bush wanted all Americans to know that he cared for Israel more then USA, he proved it by given billion dollars and american lives to Israel.
Americans are selling their homes becouse of his wrong policies, and he didn't care and he prove that today in the knesset. He is a dangerous men for a world peace


Behshad Hastibakhsh
said

I agree with George W Bush who has bravely led the worldwide struggle against Islamic fundamentalism. It would be wrong for Obama or anyone else to negotiate with the theocratic regime in Iranian and/or any other terrorist entity. Any negotiation with Islamic fundamentalists amounts to appeasement and an act of treason against freedom loving people around the world. Obama is making the historic same mistake as British and French governments between 1933 and 1939 who first entered negotiations with Hitler and paved the way for Nazi invasion in Europe. Obama and the political elite do not recognize the fact that one cannot negotiate with ....

Roger
said

The truth hurts. We will always see war in the Middle East. Iran wants power in the region. They want Israel gone. If Israel was destroyed, all you would see is poverty and war from the different
tribes of the area.
Bush and Harper are correct in not negotiating with these organizations.


yell
said

We will not publish comments that are profane, libellous, racist, contain personal attacks or are deemed inappropriate. Well, it looks like some personal attacks have been made against Bush here already. Name calling and judging will not solve this country's problems. Never judge something you haven't done yourself.The Democrats say they are for change. I am a Democrat. I want change too. All I hear and read is the same old democrat statements over and over every year. None of them are talking real change. I want the tax system changed. I want to see the Fair Tax passed.I want to see the two parties work together. I would like to see one of them take a running mate from the opposite party. Then I would believe they want change.


Geoff
said

As a Canadian I respect the President of the United States. The people of the United State decided that he was a better choice in two elections.As a Canadian I am embarrassed by the name calling of their President. It has almost become a fashion statement in some circles to say stuff like "he is a moron" or "a war criminal". Somehow it implies that you are well informed, well I beg to differ. I totally agree with what Mr Bush said and I know a lot of people like to use Neville Chamberlin as an example, but I think Churchill is a better example. Much of the same things were being said about Churchill before WWII as are being said about George Bush by the same social circle.


Bruno Baseotto
said

Regardless of whether Bush is an idiot or not or the US are bullies or not, one cannot turn a blind eye to the armageddon viewpoint of the Iranian government who not only is looking to persecute the Jewish people, but continue to persecute their own people in their own country every single day! If Iran achieves Nuclear weaponry, every country in the world will wish the US/UN/Israel had done something sooner. Amejinidad will unleash a holocaust that will make Hilter look like a pansy. Come on people wake up before it's too late!!!!!!!!

KBOB


sb
said

Stop the foolishness: Bush's own secretary of state and secretary of defence Gates have declared it important to negotiate with terrorist states; Gates supports neogitation with North Korea, as does Condi Rice. The kicker, of course, is that Bush has already sat down and negoitated with a terrorist: Khadafi. He cut a deal with him. So For Bush to call those who negoitate with terrorists "appeasers" is laughable and patently false. At some pont, people should grown up and face reality like adults rather than children: The US (and plenty of others) have always- and will continue to- negotiate with enemies.


Dee Sturber
said

If only those who comment and criticize could come up with a teeny tiny solution to one itsy bitsy problem, maybe people would give them some credibility. These people are the morons that pay attention to each other and don't have an original thought in their head.



Ki-Som
said

It is sad that the US can't have them run for only one term.


Reuben
said

I agree with Geoff. It seems like slagging Bush is the new fad. It's quite sad... especially when you have people like Toby calling Bush a moron and the people who voted for him stupid when he clearly doesn't know the difference between "then" and "than." Nice.

It seems it's almost impossible to find objective people these days. I don't agree with everything Bush has done, but I agree with his statements in this article.


Kris
said

Well we all know Bush is an expert at foreign policy, just look at what he has accomplished. The world has never been more unstable.

And for the record, Bush IS an idiot...

Jon
said

"Great moments in presidential speeches" is going to be sorely missed on Letterman when Bush is gone - that's for sure.

Although he may go down as the worst president in history - it's a wonder anyone takes him seriously anymore.


gar
said

For those of us who have seen war this may be the first time Bush has made a factual statement. Obama looks like he more interested in being loved. For those who have not read or experienced history. Neville Chamberlin was cheered by the British people by appeasing Hitler one year before WW2


Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz