Top Stories -   

Canada's housing market expected to cool off

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News: Lisa LaFlamme on the cooling market
Canada AM: Adrienne Warren, Scotiabank

Font-size: Bigger  Smaller  Share Share Print Print Comments Comments(37)

CTV.ca News Staff

Date: Thu. May. 15 2008 9:32 PM ET

Canada's housing market is expected to continue to cool off throughout this year and into 2009, a Scotiabank report says, bringing balance to the market for the first time in a decade.

However, the report says that a major drop in housing prices, as seen in the U.S. following the sub-prime mortgage crisis, is unlikely.

While home sales in Canada are down about 15 per cent off last year's record highs, prices have yet to dip -- in fact, they are up five per cent.

But the report will be seen as a relief to many first-time buyers. With energy prices on the rise, student loan debt at record levels and stagnant wage growth, many Canadians have been priced out of starter homes.

"All booms eventually come to an end . . . but at the same time it's good news for buyers who didn't get into the market the first time around," Adrienne Warren of Scotia Capital told CTV News.

Most of the country is already feeling the housing slowdowns.

Even Calgary's hot real estate market has cooled dramatically, down almost 40 per cent off last year. Homebuilders have taken to desperate measures to attract buyers, everything from free coffee to free cars.

Alberta is now officially a buyer's market.

"It seems to be levelling out, which I think is honestly good news for everybody," realtor Doug Hayden said. "A level market is a more balanced market."

In Ontario, home sellers are warned to tone down expectations of bidding wars over their properties.

However, the market remains strong in both Saskatchewan and Newfoundland and Labrador.

"We've seen a doubling of prices," Dale Ripplinger of the Canadian Real Estate Association said of the Regina housing market.

In Newfoundland, particularly St. John's, the strong economy has led many of those working in Western Canada to take their money back home, and buy into the housing market.

Housing starts dropping

The report says the average annual home price appreciation has also eased back into the mid-single digits after several years of double-digit growth.

The bank says cracks are also appearing on the new home front in Canada.

While housing starts in early 2008 are similar to last year, demand for new residential building permits has fallen sharply.

The demand has fallen for both single-family and multiple-unit projects.

Meanwhile, price increases for new homes are moderating while inventories of unsold new homes continue to rise, says the report.

Low risk of major correction

The report says a return to more historical norms for home price appreciation is a "welcome development."

Between 2002 and 2007, home prices in Canada appreciated at a rate of 10 per cent annually -- increases that the report calls "unsustainable."

"The faster and longer home prices climb, the greater the risk of an eventual price correction," says the report.

Economists say current market conditions show less of a downside risk than previous down-cycles in Canada over the past few decades.

"It appears to be built on a stronger economic foundation than those of the 1970s and 1980s," says the report.

Economists list five reasons why there is a low risk of a major correction:

  • Home prices in Canada are not substantially overvalued
  • There is still little evidence of widespread speculative home buying that often accompanies the late stages of a housing boom.
  • Canada's real estate market is not overbuilt.
  • Households, for their part, are not overleveraged.
  • Overall mortgage quality is still sound.

"At the end of the day, we predict a soft landing for the Canadian housing market, with somewhat lower sales and construction, and a period of relatively flat inflation-adjusted home prices."

With a report from CTV's Lisa LaFlamme

Comments are now closed for this story

Dale Wilson
said

Let's hope the steep rise in housing prices is over. I'd like my kids to be able to afford their own house someday without having to wait for us to die so they can use the inheritance as a downpayment.


Mortgaged for Life
said

Let's hope this keeps up. As an educated new graduate making better than $50,000 a year - I was worried I'd never find something suitable for less than $180,000 in Halifax. Even half of a semi, 30 minutes by car out of town is going for more than that right now. Just the other day I thought, something's gotta give. I hope this is it.


NB Tom
said

I'm currently in the market for my first house.....but now im wondering if i should wait a year or two so i don't get burned.


bd in sk
said

Dale,

Or you could plan to give your kids a "living inheritance" before you die. My in-laws have done this over the years which helped us be able to buy a house. There is much more joy when parents can share with their kids financially prior to death rather than after.


brenda W
said

I'm sorry. I must apologize. We put our house on the market last October in Saskatoon (the hottest selling market) yeah right. We're still waiting for a sale. We've never sold a house in a sellers market in over 50 years, therefore I just assume it's our fault the market has turned around.Cest la Vie!


Pat
said

In the long term, the house market is still going up. One generation after another will find a way out in the new market. This has already been happening in many countries. Canada is no acception, now heading this direction.


Wanting a raise.
said

Moderation in the market isn't a bad thing, but those of us who already own homes and are considering moving in the next few years have to be seriously concerned about declines.

A house has been an excellent financial investment over the past few years, I personally made a small fortune (by my standards) on the market in Calgary a couple of years ago. If those days are over then Canadians will need to look at moving their money elsewhere for more stability and security.

Hopefully wages across the country start to increase to match the high energy costs, and the fairly high housing prices. I know that over the past few years I've seen as much as a 50% increase in housing price, and 100% increase in energy prices, yet my salary has only increased by about 10%. If I didn't already own a house, I'd be hard pressed to get into the market now.


antony
said

It's about time prices come down to a realistic price. I'm just waiting my turn to buy see if intrest rates fall again in june then I will be in a far better position :)


Michele
said

I agree, Dale. Housing prices have far outpaced pay increases; therefore more % of income is spent on housing then any other time. We could not have afforded a new home without building it ourselves.


Maria-Julia
said

I agree with Dale's comment.


Socialism is killing us
said

This is great news. My soon to be wife and I want to buy a house right after we get married. But we don't own an oil company to pay for it and my parents are gonna be around for a bit. So no inheritance yet.


Shamaro
said

I do believe that the sharp rise in housing prices will flatten out and allow for some sort of adjusting, especially in artifically, over inflated markets like
Western Canada. Houses will stabalize in prices right across the country, however in Toronto, I believe that is one market that is going to suffer the most, due to the two different Land Transfer taxes one has to pay in order to opurchase a home. Mayor Miller of that fine City ahs imposed his new powers by making those buyin ga new home within the city of Toronto, to pay now up to twice the amount of Land transfer taxes as they were before. This is forcing purchases of new homes to be moved outside of the City into places like York Region.


Jean
said

Great news. I am a CDN living in the U.K. and have seen what over-valued house prices can do to the economy. Over here some banks are giving mortgages of up to 7 times a person's annual salary. It's nice to see the Canada, and Canadian's are still smart home shoppers/buyers. It makes me think of coming back!
Cheers,
J.


Nevada gal
said

NB TOM I would be waiting for at least one year and follow the Market Very Carefully, as I predict that your Market will get bad, not as Bad as Las Vegas, but it will also suffer because of this Sub Prime Mortgage and the fact that Canadian Banks got involved in them, Look at the Royal Banks Loss, it was like $855 Million the last Quarter??


Bizznitch
said

Yeah, the Scotiabank doesn't know what it's talking about. Housing in Vancouver is so overvalued that it's not funny. They're due for a *major* correction there. Bring on the 30%-50% drops...I'm waiting to pick up a house!


GP
said

I think there is a misconception here. The smart money is not saying housing will drop in real dollars, at least not in desirable places.

They are talking about house prices rising but not as fast as the rate of inflation. So a house will rise in value say 1.5%, but inflation will rise 2.5%.

This means after being adjusted for inflation the house value has dropped, although not in real terms.

For those that are waiting to buy, don't. This is what a soft "landing" or correction looks like.

That said if you live in places that are going to really feel the economic downturn that is coming, like Ontario, you may see real drop in values, but its very unlikely here on the west coast.


Frank Buchan
said

Instead of blaming the market, folks should wonder about their motives.

First, if you think of a house as an investment you're buying one for that reason, so expect to pay. Think of it as a home, and the price you pay will be what you accept. I bought two houses in 9 years (moved once), and both times I bought a home to live in, not an investment vehicle.

Second, for all "first time" buyers, take a few minutes to ask yourself why your first house has to be a 250K+ mansion. Both mine cost me less than 60K, the most recent in the relatively hot Alberta market. Both were true fix-up type homes, BUT neither mortgage stressed my income at all. Basically, I bought well below my potential range (the bank said 2 to 3 times higher was preapproved). And by doing that I have a place to live, something to fix up as I see fit, and almost certainly a small profit when I next sell, because the carrying costs of this mortgage are so low. My third home will probably be the 250K+ home of my dreams, of course, but by then I'll probably realise something half that pricey will suit me just fine.

Point is, people, the reason many today cannot afford a home is because they are looking for an investment, and investments have always been the domain of wealthier people. A home is easier to buy, because it matters more in the short-term.


Albert
said

House prices continue to rise because of creative financing like 40-year mortgages promoted by banks, and a greedy real estate industry who gain vastly from high prices. They are the only ones feeling good about this. The cost to homeowners is very deep personal debt. This is unfortunate, but people are evidently willing to risk this because they are optimistic about long-term prosperity, and real estate speculation that historically pays well. House prices will theoretically keep rising until everyone in the market reaches their maximum tolerable debt. I believe this is still far away, and prices will still go much higher in most markets. Prices will certainly not fall. Speculation will not be quite as profitable in the short-term, but if you need a home for the long-term, buy now.


Arlene
said

The housing market is still very good and lets hope it stays. The costs are high in some places, but in others you can get a super buy like in Oshawa.Great place to live for all ages and some really nice homes for the cost.You double what you would pay in Toronto.


Evan in Athabasca
said

Laugh Out Loud!!!


$180,000 for a mortgage on a house, I wish I could do that where I live Mortgaged for Life!!!

I cannot even afford a 200,000 dollar mortgage, if I could all it would buy is a 20` wide modular home, with out the land....


Larry Williams
said

As a home owner of many years, I would have to give some credit to the banks in this whole process of home ownership. For one, they're all still solvent today. we would have to conclude that:
a) Not having our mortgages as a tax deductible expense is definitely a good thing, because that way we focus on getting rid of the debt faster. And
b)The banks have done a fine job of promoting and explainng the benefits of being mortgage free sooner, rather than later. And finally,
c) Having to come up with a 25% down pmt. is an excellent thing because it doesn't only protect them in case of foreclosures, but it protects us (the investor as well), which forces us to become long term home-owners. This is what has helped the Canadian housing industry to remain strong, more so than anything else, in my opinion


Broke in B. C. (Bring Cash)
said

People seem to think that a hot housing market will go on forever (banks and current homeowners upgrading their postal code) however with all things economic there is a cycle to it. I believe we are now heading into the next cycle - a cooling off period but that will all seem for not if wages don't keep pace with current market conditions. Meaning banks won't make money, governments won't make money and so on. A 40 year mortgage with a zero downpayment means nothing if your paycheque can't make the payments and allow you to feed your family.


KMD
said

Dale I totally agree with you..

Mortgaged for Life..Consider yourself lucky. You know what I can buy in Victoria, or for that matter 1 hour outside of Victoria, a condo at the most.I also make well over $50,000 and my significant other makes more than me, we can not break into the market here. We also have debt, mine from university, but we should not be unable to afford a house with our salaries!

As for a $60,000 purchase. My family and I would be more than willing to buy a fixer upper, we would love that..NOT possible in British Columbia.My landlords 1/8th of an acre (not the house, just the land) is valued at something ridicules like $190,000



Sierra
said

Respectfully Frank B, you were not buying in the Calgary or Edmonton market for 60K...

$250K will not buy a mansion in Calgary or Edmonton... it MIGHT get you a 1000 SQ ft condo in the suburbs...

Starter homes in those markets are IN the $300+ range...

Pesonally I've jumped ship for the US where there are still jobs and housing in markets I can afford... I might return when all those babyboomers have to start cashing out thier "investment".
hopefully that will move housing prices to a level I can afford in a market where I can get a job.


Lawrence
said

If I had real estate to sell in the next couple of years, it would be on the market now. We don't know how bad the U.S. problem is going to be and we sell 85% of what we produce to them.Values are down by 40% and even more in FL and CA. Look out, high oil and gas, no money for mortgages,no construction. The U.S. market is overbuilt by 2million units and an ordinairy year uptakes 1.5 million. My guess is 5 years till a turn around, if we're lucky.Americans have overspent, period.George Bush has been blowing up billions for years with no return except dead soldiers.We are not immune to their economic woes.The last r.e. slowdown here lasted 7 years..vancouver realtor since 84


Homeowner Will
said

Remember it can pay off renting rather than owning, in a financial standpoint goes. In highly-priced markets like Vancouver, a condo at Cole Harbour start at $500k, yet rent is about $1500-$1800 a month. An equivalent mortgage payment with 20% down would be $2500 a month, and that's not including condo fees, etc.

I personally think that the West Coast, especially Vancouver/Victoria, will stagnate soon since spending over 75% of your net-pay on housing can't be sustained on "potential" market growth.


Dale Wilson
said

The only ones who benefit from housing costs rising faster than inflation investors/speculators. Once you're actually in the market, prices are irrelevant unless you're moving to an area where prices haven't gone up - not really a normal scenario. As your family grows, if you want to trade up to a larger house it went up as much or more than your smaller house. All the recent rises have done is to keep first time buyers out of the market, forced them to pay a very high percentage of their net income or (shudder) take out a mortgage whose length exceeds their working career.


Vahan
said

Housing is simply shelter. We have to stop thinking of it as an investment. We never truly make our money back on it after paying down the mortgage, and the upkeep.Plus selling a house costs so much also, with Realtor fees, bank fees and whatever could be added on as a fee.


Chris
said

Having to come up with a 25% down pmt. is an excellent thing

If you make $100k a year it's an excellent thing...coming up with a 25% down payment just isn't realistic for most working class folks. By the time my Fiancee and I save up enough for a 25% down payment the market will have gone through the downswing and will be on the upswing again, and our 25% will be 5%.


Overvalued
said

Houses are over valued because interest rates are too low and credit is too easy to get.

When I bought my first house in the early 80's interest rates where around 12% and one had to have at least 15% cash down. But the prices were realistic.

For this, houses should not be an investment. All I see now in new subdivisions in Ontario are oversized brick houses with twin garages sitting on silly little lots so small in some cases you can touch both yours and the neibhors house by stretching your arms. What's the purpose? May as well live in a townhouse or condo.

Investment should be a monatery one in banks or markets where a 10 to 12% interst rate would be ideal across the board: For home buyers and investors.

I predict many many foreclosures to come of huge homes built with easy credit to the max as the economy continues to sour.


Between the liones
said

When Banks suggests "Low risk of major correction " that means tsunami on horizon. Bank produce reports to make sure that they do not get burned by major meltdown.

I my belief housing market is set for correction at least 30-40% total, starting 15% this year and other depends on US economy. If US economy gets into further trouble, all the export will have to stay at home(including lumber/wood products) which means better prodcut will be available at much reduced cost.


Trudy
said

I know this millionaire fella, a real estate broker. He has a big horse stable outside Ontario and a big stable in Nova Scotia. He put the stable in Ontario up for sale, moved to his stable property in N.S. and is bugging the heck out of stable help save on pennies where ever he can. Yeah, I'd say we will be facing a decline in real estate sales. I'd say, as he is being so aggressive about little details like turning lights off, not using the gator for more than a couple of trips a day and much more that I feel comfortable with the thought, this decline is going to last for awhile. Trudy


Ned
said

I make $80000/yr (debt free) and will be buying my first home next month. How sad it is to think that all I can get is a tiny starter home and that I will be mortgaged until I turn 67 in order to do it. My mandatory retirement age is 60...Houston, we have a problem.


Waiting to buy a home
said

I live in Winnipeg, and don't own a home yet. Rent here is a lot cheaper than home ownership. I am saving as much as possible while renting with hopes of buying a home in a few years once the market has cooled. Right now, it is still not uncommon for there to be bidding wars for houses - houses are selling for way more than they are worth and that is just crazy.


Mike
said

It's about freakin time! Maybe soon I'll enter the market.


Kellie
said

Brenda W- Saskatoon

You can't be serious!

If you are still waiting to sell your home 6 months after listing it, then you have something drastically wrong with your house, or you are asking an astronomical price compared to the value of your house!!!

Check Saskhouses.ca. Most have sold within 2 weeks of listing. Some have even sold within 2 days.

Saskatoon's housing supply is extremely low, plus our vacancy rate is less than 1%.

How can your house NOT sell in the hottest market?










KEM
said

I have been patient for 3+ years for a house.
My household has a 100,000+ income and are finding it difficult to break into the housing market in Sudbury, Northern Ontario. Fixer uppers in the area of the city that I avoid range from 100,000 to 180,000. Tiny condos are 345,000.
Off topic, the price of bread used to be 0.99 and is currently 3.09 a loaf.
My salary has not changed...something has to "cool off."


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Facebook

Share this article with Facebook

DIGG

Share this article with Digg

Newsvine

Share this article with Newsvine

Delicious

Share this article with delicious

Email

Share this article.
Send Email

Twitter

Share this article with Twitter

StumbleUpon

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Reddit

Share this article with Reddit

Yahoo! Buzz

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz

Most Talked about Stories

Naturally coming on the heels of the Gulf event, this will be jumped on by all involved with both feet and there will be no lack of criticism regardless of who does what. If they had of had it cleaned up within 24 hours, the governor would complain that nobody consulted her on how to do it. A no win situation. I seriously doubt that anyone is deliberately dragging their heels on this, it's too high profile.

Pugfire

Michigan governor criticizes oil spill clean-up effort