CTV News | Chinese troops dig for survivors near epicentre

Top Stories -   

Chinese troops dig for survivors near epicentre

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News: Steve Chao on the ongoing rescue effort
CTV News: Steve Chao on the frantic rescue efforts
CTV Newsnet: Steve Chao on the efforts to plug a damaged dam

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(72)

CTV.ca News Staff

Date: Wed. May. 14 2008 10:42 PM ET

Thousands of Chinese soldiers arrived at the epicentre of a deadly earthquake Wednesday, in a desperate attempt to save thousands still buried under rubble. But with few tools available, troops were forced to dig through debris by hand.

Families were desperate to find trapped relatives, with time running out for those stuck under collapsed buildings.

"Yesterday my husband was calling for help, but today I don't hear anything," one woman told CTV's Steve Chao in Chengdu, the capital of Sichuan province.

"I think it's too late."

Soldiers also had to fix the Zipingpu Dam, located upriver from the city of Dujiangyan, because the earthquake had left it with "extremely dangerous" cracks.

There are also concerns closer to the epicentre in Sichuan province.

He Biao, director of the Aba Disaster Relief headquarters in northern Sichuan province, said the most dangerous problems are several reservoirs near Wenchuan.

"There are already serious problems with the Tulong Reservoir on the Min River. It may collapse. If that happens, it would affect several power plants below and be extremely dangerous,'' he said.

China's top economic planning body said Monday's 7.9-magnitude earthquake damaged 391 dams, most of which are small.

Watch dramatic amateur video of the quake

Death toll jumps

The official death toll rose Wednesday to 14,866, said state-run news agency Xinhua.

Xinhua also said nearly 26,000 people remain buried in debris and another 14,000 are missing.

CTV's Steve Chao said the death toll will no doubt rise.

"In some of the hardest hit areas... rescue crews have yet to reach them," said Chao. "Those places have populations of tens of thousands so people just don't know at this point how many people are trapped under the debris."

Chao said officials finally reached the town of Yingxiu Wednesday and found 80 per cent of the population -- more than 7,000 people -- dead.

At least eight schools near Chengdu also collapsed following the quake, killing thousands of children, said Chao.

"Many parents have been camped out at these schools, waiting for days, just for a glimmer of hope that their children will be pulled out alive," he said.

Chao said there have been some "miracle stories," including that of a three-year-old girl who survived after being protected by the bodies of her parents.

In another rescue, a father managed to pull his daughter out of the rubble at her school after hearing her voice.

Fifty-thousand police officers and soldiers have been mobilized to sift through piles of concrete.

But even when survivors are found, crews have had to make heartbreaking choices.

Rescuers had to amputate the legs of one little boy who was found in the rubble.

The powerful earthquake struck at 2:28 p.m. local time Monday, when office buildings, factories and schools were full.

With a report by CTV's Steve Chao in Chengdu and files from The Associated Press

Comments are now closed for this story

Felix
said

I think at this point out Canadian government ought to supply aid to the people as they have committed to for the people of Burma. Let's hope the government of Canada acts quickly on this matter


Eric in China
said

There is no point to supply one of the richest countries the world aid. China is a strong country and can take care of this themselves. Anyhow, even if we wanted to help, the communist nation's laws regulations would prohibit outside help and influence.


Don
said

My heart goes out to these people. If only the Burmese & Chinese gov't could get over themselves and allow aid to flow freely. The Chinese are better equipped to deal but the Burmese will be responsible for countless deaths simply so they can hide whatever it is they think they should hide.


Holly
said

China has the fastest developing progress, but with that huge population, it is still far from being a rich country. Let's not being so sarcastic on the tragedy. Pray for them and try to help if you can!


Not so harsh words from Chris today
said

I agree Eric. Over the past 11 years in Canada, we were able to handle natural disasters on our own as well. The BC fires, the Manitoba Flood, the Ice Storm, and most recently, the New Brunswick floods and the floods in Northern Ontario. Granted we didn't have the death toll as China has, but China can easily take care of its own.


Chris
said

Oh and I apologize to all those who misunderstood my comments yesterday. They were not intended to be hateful. Just merely pointing out the population ratios. That is all.


Willy (Nova Scotia)
said

Hey Chris (above)
Dont' apologize. It seems anytime someone in these comments doesn't show oooozzing compassion they are branded as idiots or heartless or un-Canadian.

China doesn't need our money or resources, they might need Canadian brain-power. Send over the water-experts, the disaster managers, etc. The request by Chinese groups here in Canada for money is a joke. This is a time for China to step up and take care of these people with their vast resources. Of course it is a tradegdy, but providing aid just to make us feel better doesn't work - remember Katrina?

They have a million man Army, send them in, and tonnes of aid, use that.

And to those calling this heartless - please, think with your head first.






Gong
said

Eric in China:
Are you really living in China?... Could you open my eyes to point out which laws or regulations prohibit outside help. Do you know what the opening policy means?


Micheal
said

Yes, No matter you help or not, China will overcome the difficulties by themself, whatever it is caused by the earth quake or by human . Their people, their government are best organized in the world. Chinese will firmly stand behind their government after all happened recently. This is a nation that nothing could knock them down, This is a nation that is full of future because they have the best people and best government. Tomorrow is better that today,


Monty
said

I've just been really impressed with the way their government has handled the rescue operations despite the conditions.

Whether you think with your head or your heart, that's totally not the point when we hear this news from halfway across the globe. As a human being, I can't help but feel for those who are suffering from this.


Glenn for Canadian Humanity
said

If it was up to me, the money being spent for aid in China would remain in Canada to be as aid here. Why is it, that it's always donations from the people to help others in our own country. Yet Canada will pledge 1 million just like that to another country for aid. It is my belief that we should ensure our own country is well looked after then see to others. We have families in our own country starving, needing shelter (and not on a part time basis)yet we are acustomed to this because we see it everyday and turn a blind eye.

Our quality of life is good here in Canada for most of us, so why can't it be good for everyone. There should be kids without winter jackets, or go without christmas, but there is. People die on the streets everyday in Canada, alone and without aid. Let's look out for ourselves first, see that our own people are safe, and not starving, and to save people from having to commit crimes inorder to feed themselves and there families. Some of you may look to me as the bad guy, that is your opinion. And this is mine.


Jean
said

In 2005 when Hurricane Katrina destroyed the whole New Orleans area, the U.S. government received millions millions dollars from all over the world. If you say China is richer than the states, you must be kidding!!

The epicenter area is a mountainous area which is very isolated from the rest of the country even in normal days. This disaster, the Chinese government reacted so fast, sending troops, rescuers. They are doing their best to save their people. The paratroops had to land in thunderstorm weather, several of them have reported dead during the landing. Every time when a Canadian solder die in Afghanistan, it touched all of the Canadians. What about Chinese soldiers?! They are sons and daughters too.

Do not be cold blooded! If you do not want to send money to help the Chinese people who are in need, it is ok. Please pray for them, for their families. No matter what, they are human beings too.

PLEASE PRAY FOR THEM!!





Marie Vallay
said

To Michael above:

Pleasee.... don't spout out how great the Chinese gov't is....this is the same gov't that just razed homes of poor people over miles and miles of land just to build Olympic venues -kicking them out on the street with NO where to go - they don't have shelters like here in the West. You want to say they will overcome and help....great, blanket rhetoric leave at the door. I am not impressed with their response so far with all the resources they have. You'll see they will be defined by their actions.


leigh
said

I am so sad to see here many heartless so-called Canadians, they are just spoiled.


Kate
said

To those who believe we should not supply to one of the "richest" countries in the world-
Let us not forget that when the US suffered Katrina, Canada and many other countries stepped up to the plate to help out. The US is the most powerful country in the world as well as one of the wealthiest. Clearly in times of need we could all use a little support


Edward
said

Fellow Canadians, please show compassion. Please help those in need!


Neil
said

China is the mother land to 1.3 millon Canadians. Think back to the 1920s when England was the motherland to the majority of Canadians we didn't only send money but men to die.

Chinese Canadians have a strong desire to help their former country and often sending money is the only method available.

Yes China is a rich country with means to help it's own, but so is Canada and I remember donating money a few year ago for the Red river floods in Manitoba.


Canada disappoints the world !!!
said

Canada, don't be too hard on yourself. Save those taxes for your own. China does not need them because they have aid from USA,Europe,Japan etc.. Unlike Canada,those are the countries who are humane. Canada is a country who wants the world to know it's humanity spirit, but actually it does not have it at all. Harper has not even expressed any condolence yet. And you are still saying one of Canada's spirits is humanity? Joke!


claire
said

I can not believe how cruel some people here! they have no feelings to other people! I hope these people do not seek any help when they are in trouble!


Joanne
said

It entirely depends on how far your heart goes out.

At the compassionate moment, just take an action if you care; but never show your cold-blood or heartlessness that can kill humanity.


D
said

I will save all your good comments and suggestions that will sure be useful for me to apply back in here. From now on, I WONfT support any charity donation to hospitals, etcc since you strongly believe the lost of 10,000 plus life in China are nothing, and think that the Winter storm, NB flooding are gigantic natural disaster than the Sichuan earthquake. That is fine with me. For sure, without my donation, the world is still turning. I hope, people back home can overcome this difficult time and move forward.


Chris
said

Tell me what is so "cold-blooded" and "uncompassionate" in saying that China can take care of its own? It's a fact and a compliment, not an insult.... WAKE UP!!!


Magician
said

How many of those "human rights" activists, who were all in an uproar recently,
portraying themselves as the true guardians of Chinese people's human rights, where are they now?
Have these groups done anything substantive to help the Chinese people in this time of need?
All the protesters in London , Paris during the Olympic torch relay, shouting slogans about human rights, have each of them done anything to help the Chinese people now?
Why do I sense the answer is rather depressing?
The same people who say we shouldn't give a cent in aid would be the first to harp about human rights and their supposed "care" and support for people's rights.



Peter
said

Who says Canadian doesn't care? See how we spent thousands to bring back Brenda Martin frome Mexico. We care our fellow Canadians, a criminal or not.


Eric
said

Harper is really heartless without a single word of sympathy to those Chinese who had died in the earthquake. I'll not vote for him in the next election.


Glenn for Canadian Humanity
said

Everyone here states how Canada is heartless and cruel. It's only a few people expressing their opinion. I can't see how this equates to all of Canada. You know what is cruel and heartless, when men and women will help people from another country that they will never meet or even see before helping Canadians. Whether those Canadians be Chinese, Russian. For one thing I don't trust any of the organizations that distribute funds received for these disasters. And by giving does not mean that the funds will make there way to the people that need it the most.

tired of dishing out
said

well today the tunes have changed ..yesterday..I said the same as most today..they are a strong country...but got bad mouthed for speaking the truth..they have the resources to help themselves..it did not mean I had no compassion..


Feel for the children
said

Glen well done. You took the words right out of my mouth. I totally agree with you, but the only devastating thing about these events is that the children will suffer regardless of help or not. For these suffering children all over the world they don't have a voice and its a shame everyone around the world is too stoked on greed until it happens to their own. So even though I agree with your comment, realize the children haven't a choice regardless, and they never should have to experience anything like this, shame on the Rich Powers of the World.


Peter
said

Chris

Thanks for the apology. I understand you apologize for hurting others feeling even they misunderstood yours comments because of how you wrote it.I now feel better to be a Canadian.


Mercy
said

So sad to see some so-called canadians are sooo heartless and thank God that most canadians show their compasssion at this monent.

I know that China gov did many things that disappointed the world and his own people. but chinese people can not choose their born country, like child can not choose their parent. If the child's father is a killer, does the child is a killer too? Now the child is in deadly danger, the father is doing his best to rescue the child. If you don't want to give a hand, or even show a little compassion, please shut up!! any harsh words from you in front of this human tragedy just make yourself even worse 100 times than the father.

My heart goes to those chinese people who are suffering pain.

And for those heartless candians, you are in my pray list too.


Jasper
said

I am sure China would gladly accept foreign aid money. Whether the money would reach the intended recipients is questionable.

I doubt a communist country like China would let foreign aid workers roam freely around the country. They would be under constant supervision and would not be allowed to do their work effectively. I doubt if China would allow a western military transport aircraft into their airspace.


Richard
said

If anyone wants help they can ask for it. I'm sure we are smart enough to recognize to be ready.

Let's let them, or anybody else for that matter, make up their own minds if they require assistance first before jumping to conclusions.


Jufeng
said

I am just shocked by some of the cruel comments here. I am a Chinese Canadian and I have always made donations to Canadians in need and to all kinds of institutions that help people in need. Now that the quake Chinese victims are in need and people you say the hell with them because they are citizens of China?

You got to be ashamed of yourselves.


Steve in Aylmer
said

Where does it say in this report that China is looking for your financial help?

They don't need our brain-power, they don't our money, they don't need anything from Canada. Seriously, does it hurt your ego that they're not calling for our assistance.

What you do in a situation like this is act with some class, offer a hand even if they don't ask.

If they refuse, offer prayers and compassion- its free.













brenda W
said

If our help is NOT required, such as China with millons more people & army, supplies, etc, then our going over could actually be more detrimental and slow up their progress...

People must reason first and foremost. Our prayers of strength for these people are often much more important for them.


Help China now for the future.
said

This is a horrible event. But China has hundreds of thousands of soldiers that they could mobilize. They could also dip into their two hundred billion dollar investment budget to cover all costs associated with this tragedy. Where our help could come in would be in helping to apply lessons learned from current disaster research. As well it may be in the best interests of the people whom live in the affected area to institute a more robust building code after the response phase is over. Sustainable development is what China needs most.


Geoff
said

Any action will have a reaction. As a proud Canadian, I am willing to help anyone who needs it, be it in my back yard to around the world.

I say, send help and one day they will help us when we need. But regardless as human beings, we must respect each other and help each other. The Chinese, Canadian and every other person will remember what we do today.

The Chinese Government remembers Norman Bethune, a Canadian, who help soldiers and citizens alike.


Barry
said

My heart goes out to all Chinese Canadians who worry about family and friends. It's apparent this is a divisive issue. I don't think money is the issue the Govt of China needs (at least for now).
They do likely need specialised manpower, search and rescue personel, engineers and perhaps others. I hope we do provide what we can based on requests made by goverment officials. Money raised should go to induvidual chinese families(in the form of cash) to help them get on their feet, I'm not convinced giving it to the goverment makes any sense. God bless all affected.


Riley T.
said

After reading all the comments we can all agree on something....

1. No one disputes this is a tradegy. It is hands down.

2. No one denies China can help themselves and has the means.

3. Everyone is entitled to their opinion, weather really compassionate or really logical or anywhere in between.

The said part is the people who claim to be so compassionate and so Canadian tell others to "shutup" (see post by Mercy) which is most hypocritical and why people like that get a bad name; and then this poster Jufeng, who considers himself a Chinese Canadian but believes giving money to "Canadians in need" (which presumably he is not Canadian and somehow excludes him) now expects Canadians to do support "citizens of China". If you don't give from your heart, don't give. Some don't trust the Chinese gov't, not the people.

Finally, the US during Katrina received 76% of aid in forms other than money, so send our expertise and that should do.




Brian
said

why doesn't the Chinese government re-allocate the funds it uses to oppress the Tibetan people? If we aid China with this disaster, while China continues to pour resources into murdering and oppressing the people of Tibet, aren't we in effect oppressing and murdering the people of Tibet? I pray for the families affected that their government will show compassion and take care of all people.


Ilona
said

As Chinese Canadian, I am very moved by Canadiansf sympathy towards people in need around world. I believe most Canadians are caring and worm-hearted.
Donft feel obligated to donate to China if some people donft have such abilities or donft feel like, but your prayer and caring will be appreciated by all Chinese people around world.




gtg
said

Compare the authoritarian Chinese government's response - the Premier, Wen Jiabao, was at the disaster area within 90 minutes of the earthquake, with the ineptitude displayed by George W, the leader of the "free world" during the Katrina hurricane and you will see a stark contrast.



Rieesa
said

Just because we don't give money doesn't mean we don't care ok!!!!

We care but some of us can't afford it right now. I hope the Chinese people have strenght to get through this,


Gong
said

Jasper:
The first aircraft carrying supplies from Russia has already landed in Chengdu. In another report on Globe and mail, Chinese PM Wen Jiabao thanked several volunteers from US when he met them on ground. Wen said everykind of aids were welcomed. NYtimes reported foreign journalists do not feel any restrictions in reporting.


Dharma
said

We should always offer and send help - unconditionally - because it is the right thing to do. Golden Rule and all that. What would you want done to/for you if the tables were turned? To all of you who are being callous, it is obvious that nothing bad of any significant proportion has ever happened to you, but one day it might. Karma, baby. What goes 'round, comes 'round.


Colin S
said

Wow!! Who knew that everytime people die in all parts of the world, that the Canadian Prime Minister is required to speak internationally and say "Sorry for your tragic loss" lest he fear a loss of votes come next election. When thousands were forced from their homes due to fires, flooding and whatever else, did Canadians get a "So Sorry" from China, or the US or anyone? Not bloody likely.

I'm all for helping when and where we can, but to criticize the PM for not saying sorry, or other people for not rushing to the airport for the first flight to Bangkok is simply ridiculous


David
said

Is that funny?

If China takes the aid, someone like Jasper says: I am sure China would gladly accept foreign aid money. Whether the money would reach the intended recipients is questionable.

If China doesnft take the aid, someone like Richard says: If anyone wants help they can ask for it. I'm sure we are smart enough to recognize to be ready.

Whether you would help or not, is NOT important for us. Ifm sure we will get over it.

But whether you want to help or not, is important to you, when you facing question from your kids gWhy didnft you even show sympathy and WANT to help when 10,000 people dying?h I guess thatfs an important line to distinguish a human being from animals. Letfs not say that, probably thatfs going to piss some animals off.

I certainly believe these are just a small part of Canadian who only show sympathy when their sense of superiority is satisfied.

When thousands still buried in darkness, horribly counting seconds and waiting for being chosen by either rescue or death, your sympathy without bias will be appreciated by us. We will take that; we will remember that, in our mind, and in our heart.

A Canadian Chinese



Marty
said

All I can say is: all those children! And all those grieving parents. As a mother myself I can't imagine sitting outside my daughter's school clinging to a mere glimmer of a hope that she is still alive. My prayers and thoughts are with those families. And everyone here is arguing money. No one is thinking of the people. Money will not bring these innocent little lives back.


robbie montgomery
said

I have just read some of the comments made by my fellow "Canadians' regarding the recent earthquake in China. I am shocked, embarassed, and ashamed to be a Canadian right now. My friend and I have been teaching in China for the past 9 months, and I know she would agree that Chinese people are proud, caring, and compassionate. We are talking about human lives here, aren't we? Children buried alive? What the hell is wrong with you? And you, Harper, are a disgrace to your country. All this comes down to people helping people, that's it. Forget money...forget politics...forget your self-righteous, self-centered attitude and do something!!The Chinese have been nothing but kind, generous, and patient with us "foreigners", and considering the large population, are doing a tremendous job keeping this country on a upward track. A Chinese teacher asked me today "Why won't Canada help us?" It was so, so sad. All I could do was shake my head. The least you could have done was offer. Yes, I'm embarassed and ashamed,but my eyes have been opened.


Thomas Miller
said

How very sad! But look for many more natural disasters as the earth's growing population settles into more and more remote and dangerous areas. This is also why so many more people are affected by hurricanes in the USA. A hundred years ago Florida was barely populated.


richie
said

Why do we have to supply aid for these countries? Honestly? In this state of inflation, how can we be expected to do this? All our jobs go out of this country and now you want any money the government pockets from us to go too? Oh wait, sorry, there are jobs being created in all fairness... $10 an hour telemarketing jobs that you need a car and $1.25 /litre gas to get to.


To Steve in Aylmer
said

It doesn't say in this report that China would welcome foreign aid, but it does in many other reports. Just Google "china welcome aid" and you will find plenty of articles. You should do a little more leg-work before assuming you have even a fraction of the story straight.....




Bob
said

The Harper's gov't hasn't expressed any a single word of sympathy to those victims. What a such heartless government is. Harper may not like the Chinese gov't, but he should not ignore the victims who are sufferring from such huge unexpected nature disaster.

For those who commented "Canada should not support China", you may have your own choice, you may have your own decision, but today the support we are talking about is not for the Chinese gov't, but the victims in China who are facing the death, who are injured, who has lost their family, lovers, etc. I am not sure whether you would have same feeling if you or your family were in the same situation.






Chris
said

I sympathize with the families of the victims of this terrible earthquake. Though I personally do not approve of the Chinese dictatorship government, I nevertheless feel Canada should show goodwill and humaneness to the people of China by offering to send assistance and a message of understanding to this very important nation and trading partner.


Gong
said

Brian:
Did you have any idea what you were talking about? In fact, a few towns there majority are Tibetan ethnics. Chinese soldiers hiked more than 60 miles to reached there.



Doug BC
said

China should request the things it needs if it wants help. This has nothing to do with being humane,or not being humane. Obviously China has more than enough people to do the labour part of the rescue.And,I suggest that any country that can afford a military of the size of theirs,and a space program on top of that,should be able to help citizens in distress.If not,why not.
Absolutely. If we can offer expertise or some equipment,or whatever,I am on board. But sending buckets of money just to make a good impression should be out of the question.
We should offer our best wishes,and I'm sure we all feel for people anywhere who get caught up in this kind of a disaster. But the question remains,"what is it that we have,that would help,or that they don't have plenty of already"??
And hellooo. The USA has nowhere near the people resources of China. And believe me,they got a lot less help then,than they have delivered around the world.So again,I ask, what is it they need that they don't have?
If the 1.3 million Chinese in Canada think they can help,have at it.Organize some work parties and start collection charities for money and goods to send "back home". I think real "charity" is about giving freely and voluntarily.Not having it taxed from the hands of people who may,or may not have anything left to give.Those taxes are scarce. I agree we should use them to help,but in cases where they will make difference,as opposed to just pandering for political correctness.
If we have extra,lets help our First Nations people first. They were here before any of us.


reply to robbie montgomery
said

reply to robbie montgomery

I have to say Robbie, you are exactly like the typical Canadian I used to think--kind, generous, warm-hearted, just like the doctor Norman Bethune who came to China to save lives during world war two. But I have to say Canadians' image has changed in my mind now, simply because some heartless and inhumane words I have read here and the fact that Harper as the leader of the country has not yet expressed any condolence to China's disaster. I used to like Canadians more that Americans, because Americans are so arrogant. But now, having seen that USA are sparing no efforts to help China, I know what a true friend is like.


JPC
said

The only thing China needs is a free and open election...


Mark
said

What Canadian can do to our First Nations people is to get out of here and return the land to them because they were here before any of us.



Don
said

It is all about power and politics. The Americans have spent huge amount in elections; Harper has kept his mouth shut about earthquake in China; Liberals are asking for huge donation to help China ...........

I am just wondering what our country is heading to now. We are use to be respected because we were helpful to others in need disregard thier political view. But now?


dee
said

It is Chinese culture that we "rarely" ask for help or support. Not to mention the Chinese government are with very traditional minds.

China's rich or not, donating is just a sign to show that you care. Before we even start debating sending aid or not, I heard from the radio that Hong Kong alone has already donated nearly HKD $200m (CAD$26mil)... the first day after the incident.

However, we have too many budget problems in Canada. I guess we aren't in a good position.

- my heart goes to the victims and their families in the disaster.


Heartless Canadian -- OUCH!
said

I'm confused. Did China ask for any kind of assistance? Why is it heartless to express an opinion? If a person feel inclined to start a "relief fund", than by all means, go ahead. I think it's up to the individual which charities or organizations they would like to contribute to. Just because I don't wish to donate money doesn't mean I don't care. I don't think it's appropriate to tell others to "shut up" for expressing a different opinion.
Call me a "heartless" Canadian if you wish, but at lease in this country we have the freedom to express opinions and ideas.


Gong
said

Just for your infomation, China donated 5 million US$ in Katrina relief in addition to supplies.

Money or not is not important in this circumstance. Have you ever seen a chinese sleeping on street out of 1.3 million in this country? Chinese people can eat bitterness what many canadian cannot.

Haper has a attitude as some of the canadian here. He, again, let the opportunity slip away to restore the damaged friendship with China.




CG
said

Canada should help China. Burma DOES NOT WANT ANYONE'S HELP -- so let Burma survive on their own. China would apprecitate the help and yes they would be the first to help Canada long before the US that is for sure and Burma? forget it they won't help anyone for that matter


wuregan
said

Does not matter about the governments anywhere, the low wage earners, the poor, and financial disadvantaged, take the brunt of terrible tragedy. Poor living conditions, inadequate housing, remote locations, make life hard for people with the least resources to cope and recover. It's despair in those places, I hope our goverment can help where ever possible.


robert form Alberta
said

My heart goes out to the Chinese people who have suffered through yet another natural disaster. I think the people who are questioning sending money are simply stating we (Canada) and other well meaning nations have offered money before and discovered after the dust settles the money never made it to the intended victims. Has China been one of these nations in the past?? I don't know the answer to that, however, my question is, do we trust the Chinese gov't to get the money to where it is needed most?? Again, I don't know the answer, but, as a westerner born and bred I have a natural tendency to question a communist government that I have been taught not to trust all my life.
Again. My heart goes out to the people affected by this horrible tragedy.


Lydia
said

As a Canadian Chinese, my heart is full of bitter sorrow and loads of sympathy when I heard another disaster hit China after the snowstorm paralyzed my home Hunan province in Jan this year. I am impressed with how fast and organized the Chinese government responded and how their people appreciated for the help. When there is disaster, we should not link it with politics. Let's show our bright side as human beings and pray for those affected, wounded and dead.

miracle stories
said

" there have been some "miracle stories," including that of a three-year-old girl who survived after being protected by the bodies of her parents."...

I wish I could post here a picture of a trapped a little boy from Beichuan middle school waits for rescuers in the earthquake-hit region of Beichuan County...he is so quiet and calm...just hang in there and wait for someone can come to rescue him...

This three year old girl who just lost her parents or this little boy is still buried underneath the building and whose parents might have already died...they have nothing to do with Tibet issues or cheap labor jobs transferring to China...Thousands of people like them just lost their family and many of them are facing death in every single second...It is due to a natural disaster which can happen anytime anywhere on earth...

It is not one's obligation to donate money or give out a hand at time like this....it is the choice made by our heart....We shall not judge other people...but we will be judged by our own soul...

Robin da Hood
said

If I were one of those people buried under tonnes of concrete, with busted ribs, in agony, bleeding, thirsty, cold and dying in complete darkness I would appreciate ANYONE willing to dig me out be they Canadian, Chinese or whatever.
Thank God for the Olympics anyway (even though I will likely still boycott watching them anyway)... it probably added incentive to the Chinese dictators to act more quickly and with more resources - however marginally or not - as the eyes of the World are "watching".

World Vision "dad"
said

WOW!

I really don't know where to start.....
The logic behind so many of the comments on this and earlier columns make me give my head a shake.....
When a tragedy such as Katrina,Burma or recently China occur the amount or type of aid should never depend on politics or even the personal opinions of the people that are contributing.
You are assisting fellow humans in their hour of most dire need. A dozen sacks of rice or a few tents with our Maple Leaf on the side tell these people that somewhere the other side of the world people are thinking about them and are attempting to help, even a little.
Although the thought of sending money conjures ideas that it could easily be used for other purposes than what it was intended, it is many times the most effective way of getting help to the suffering, as World Vision says it is not cost effective to send supplies from Canada where they cost more and then add the cost of air frieght across the globe when the same can be purchased locally for far less and sent to the disaster area a lot faster.

olebigblue
said

we may never know the full scope of this terrible ordeal

puzzled
said

Unbelievable some of these comments. THINK ABOUT IT!!!!!. These are human beings suffering like we have never imangined in our consumer driven western culture. Not one person who has posted here has faced starvation and yet I am reading ridiculous comments/debates about who deserves our help. If you're too cheap to shell out a couple of dollars cos our taxes are too high don't bother but I don't care about your petty complaints when there is real suffering going on.

Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

CTV Video Player

Amateur video

Amateur Video

Watch dramatic amateur video shot moments after the quake hit.

In Pictures

Search for Survivors

Search for Survivors

A frantic search is underway after the massive quake in China's Sichuan province.

Quake Chaos

Quake Chaos

A closer look at the chaotic scene in the hours following the 7.9 magnitude earthquake which hit China.

CTV.ca Map

Earthquake Epicentre

Earthquake Epicentre

Highlighted areas of the epicentre and where the tremors were felt in China's Sichuan province.

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz