CTV News | Thousands of Chinese soldiers hike to quake zone

Top Stories -   

Thousands of Chinese soldiers hike to quake zone

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News: Steve Chao covers the rescue efforts
CTV Toronto: Austin Delaney on how the city is helping earthquake victims
Canada AM: Francis Markus, International Red Cross, explains what international aid agencies are doing in the region
Canada AM: Doug Silver, planning manager for Canada Task Force 3, discusses how to best deliver disaster relief
Canada AM: Sam Katz, mayor of Winnipeg, discusses how his city is helping aid their Chinese 'sister city' of Chengdu

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(90)

CTV.ca News Staff

Date: Tue. May. 13 2008 10:03 PM ET

Chinese soldiers are hiking across washed-out roads and mud-blocked passageways in a desperate effort to get to survivors in the worst hit areas of this week's earthquake.

In areas of Sichuan province where help has already arrived, rescue crews continued to rummage through piles of debris looking for signs of survivors.

In the largest city near the epicenter, Chengdu, a teacher described how the quake sent rocks crashing down onto her school, crushing students.

"The whole mountain seemed to come down on us," she told CTV's Steve Chao. "We were buried underneath."

At the city's Juyuan Middle School, where 900 of the area's brightest children studied, only one child has been pulled out alive.

The death toll following the worst earthquake to hit China in three decades has passed 12,000 -- but rescue teams were searching for thousands more still buried under crushed buildings.

Fifty-thousand police officers and soldiers have been mobilized to sift through piles of concrete.

The powerful 7.9-magnitude earthquake struck central China Monday at 2:28 p.m. local time, when office buildings, factories and schools were full.

In Mianyang, another city near the earthquake's epicentre, 18,645 people remain buried in debris, the official news agency Xinhua reported.

According to the Sichuan Daily newspaper, more than 26,000 people were injured in Mianyang.

On Tuesday, rescue workers continued to dig through flattened schools and homes, searching for survivors.

"Survivors can hold on for some time. Now it's not time to give up,'' said Wang Zhenyao, disaster relief division director at the Ministry of Civil Affairs.

Wang said rescue efforts could take a week.

But even when survivors are found, crews have had to make heartbreaking choices. Rescuers had to amputate the legs of one little boy who was found in the rubble.

Even those who survived the quake are struggling to survive as they run out of food and try to build makeshift shelters.

Bad weather is hindering help from arriving at the worst hit areas and heavy rain is slowing down relief efforts.

Red Cross delivering aid

Francis Markus, with the International Committee of the Red Cross in Beijing, said Tuesday his organization has been trying to get relief supplies into the devastated areas.

"Clearly, the situation is going to get even more serious, the numbers are likely to rise even further," Markus told CTV's Canada AM from Beijing.

So far, only 58 people have been extricated from demolished buildings across the quake area, China Seismological Bureau spokesman Zhang Hongwei told Xinhua Tuesday.

East of the epicentre, about 1,000 students and teachers were killed or missing in Beichuan county after a high school collapsed Monday.

Another 900 students are feared dead in Juyuan, which is in Dujiangyan city, after their school collapsed.

Aftershocks also rattled the region Tuesday, creating a panic in the city of Chengdu. The U.S. Geological Survey measured the shocks between magnitude four and six.

A spokesperson for Canada's Foreign Affairs said no Canadian casualties have been reported. A B.C. professor and his students were on a study trip to China when they were caught in the earthquake zone. They say they feel lucky to have survived without injuries.

"The overriding sort of emotional sentiment amongst us now is just the feeling that we are really like lucky -- considering what we are hearing now about what is happening in areas that are really close to here," Chris Bertram, a professor at the University of the Fraser Valley, told CTV News.

The number of Canadians registered as living in China is 6,449.

In 1976, 240,000 people were killed in the city of Tangshan following an earthquake.

With a report by CTV's Steve Chao in Chengdu and files from The Associated Press

Comments are now closed for this story

Chris
said

China doesn't need any help. They are the most populous nation in the world. They have the largest, most powerful military in the world. They are arguably the most richest nation in the world. 10000 people in China lost in a natural disaster is like an average Joe being struck by a car in downtown Brandon, MB. They have the means to take care of this. And Myanmar's Gov't is just stupid to deny the aid. The US sent blankets, bugnets, and water... ooooooh... big help there!!!


Tired of Dishing Out
said

China does ot need our tax dollars..they are one of the richest nations, military strong and a well organized nation. No need to send DART or funds! We are strapped as it is.


Helen
said

They are human too, and hurt just as much as any of us when we loose a loved one. Maybe they don't need the financial help, but prayers are always needed.


Sue
said

My heart goes out to these people, as well as those suffering in Burma. We complain about our harsh winters here, but I'm so grateful to live in an area of the world where we don't often have to deal with natural disasters.


Lin
said

No matter how big China is, losing 10,000 people there is no different as losing 10,000 people here in China. have a heart.

My prayers go out to their family and friends.


Lin
said

Sorry, correction to the above. Fatalities in China, is no different than fatalities here in Canada.




wang
said

Shame on those people who say that they don't want to help China. China provides cheaper, higher quality products to all the world, which helps people around the world. Don't be mean to other people who are suffering pain. More than ten thousands people lost their life and thousands family loose their loved one. They are human too, just like each of us. How could you be so cold so mean to them? Shame on you!!


Lin
said

Nobody will say Chinese people don't need help when looking at the above picture of hand-touching. My tears burst out and hope my hand can touch that stranded student,too.
Let's pray...


L.
said

Chris...."China doesn't need any help". Where is your compassion. What if a natural disaster happened in your city? Would you like others to say that about Canada? For your sake, if anything does happen, I think you will realize quickly how important blankets are (imagine losing all electricity for days in winter) and bug nets (skeeters and black flies in summer) truly are.


Abdul
said

Tired of Dishing Out
noted that "China does ot need our tax dollars..they are one of the richest nations, military strong and a well organized nation. No need to send DART or funds! We are strapped as it is."

This is nonsense, no country is prepared for a disaster of this magnitude and where did you get the myth that we are " strapped as it is." THe conservatives may have depleted our surpluses but we are not strapped. This is like saying Bill Gates is facing hard times because the IT sector is slipping.


Robin da Hood
said

Considering the population affected, it's amazing not more people were killed. Had this happened 50 or 100 years ago when rescue efforts beyond the locals were virtually non-existent the death toll would have been 10 times as high.

Talking about a death rate 10 times as high has anyone heard about how the Burmese are doing lately? Or has that disaster been forgotten already esp. considering that relief was not getting through due to the criminal dictatorship there blocking aid as well as the Chinese govt's - who so quickly mobilized for their own disaster - apathy to intervene? Just wondering??



Nick
said

This is nothing new to China, they get quakes all the time and will be able to deal with it. Yes huge loss of life, but don't forget that in Canada, we don't have cities of 10 million plus people. Lin's analogy is flawed.


Xin
said

We Canadians have our value to give our love to each and every person in need. The comment above by Chris "China doesn't need any help..." and by : "China does not need our tax dollars..." are clearly against our Canadian values. I, as a Chinese Canadian, believe that my tax dollors need to be used wherever needed, here in Canada, or helping the people who suffered tsunami a few years ago, or people who suffer the earthquake. We come to Canada and become Canadians because we are proud of and believe such Canadian values.


Ray VanderLinden
said

Chris... China may be the most populous nation in the world but it is not the richest and as in any situation in any country the human thing to do is to offer and supply help when disaster strikes. It is not just the materials that are important but the human caring that comes with the goods we send. No matter where or when disaster strikes mankind needs to reach out just as bystanders in Brandon would run to the aid of an average Joe struck by a car. To turn away would be a denial or our humanity.


gregg
said

They are human too. Let us pray for the souls of those who died and for the surivors as well.


Chris
said

Oh please allow me to retort:

That's all we need to do is help out a country who has more money than we do. Help a country that robs the world of its manufacturing jobs (toys, cars, clothes, etc.). Sure, we can help, but then we get rewarded with cheaper goods that will cause even more job losses at home. I have a heart. It goes out to all those who lost love ones. But my heart also lies in THIS country and if we suffer from disaster, I will be the first one to help them. So don't harp on me for simply telling the truth about a country that has ALL the money, people, and power in the world to help its own!!!


Peter
said

"10000 people in China lost in a natural disaster is like an average Joe being struck by a car in downtown Brandon, MB"
If this is what an average Canadian thinks, then I cannot hold up my head as a Canadian.


CYL
said

I hope the world is taking note that all it takes is 'the powers above' to do the cleaning up as opposed to the war(s) and unnecessary killings around the globe.
China is very resourceful and since everything is "made in China", they have everything they need at their doorstep. Hopefully, those who are in need will receive in time.


Jean
said

Do not be cold blooded. It is a natural disaster, not a political game. No one had prepared for this kind of major disaster. Back in 2005 when hurricane Katrina happened, the U.S. did not get international crew to help either. What is wrong to not to get help, as long as they can help themselves. The least we can do is to send out prayers, and donate some money. God bless everyone!




Send what they need most.
said

China has sent 50,000 of their own soldiers to the affected area. There is no need for us to fly at the most 100 or 200 more to China. China has a huge military and in reality, only sending 50,000 for them is holding back. As well China has a trillion dollar investment fund. I am not saying that we should not help, but if we are to make a meaningfull contribution it would be by way of emergency managers and advisors. We could send professionals that given access to China's 100,000's of troops and billions of dollars, could positivley impact this horrible situation. The DART is full of exceptional members of the CF but in this case China could utilize the support of literally hundreds of thousands of their own troops much faster. I am sure that as Canadians our hearts and minds are with them. That being said we need to focus on sending people with the skill sets that may not be readily available in the affected area.


Steve in Aylmer
said

Where in this report does it say China is looking for help or assistance?

This is not a China tragedy, this is a human tragedy. The picture in the report shows a mother holding her child (we don`t know whether that child is alive or dead).

For Christ`s sake people, show some compassion. If that is something you lack, then do us all a favor and shut up.

To the people who lost loved ones in Burma and China...the majority of Canada wishes you all the strength in the world.




Martin
said

Good on the Chinese leadership showing up in Chengdu within hours. You should not doubt the PLA's abilities in this realm; they specialize in disaster relief, and I'm sure that they will show their most laudable side in their most laudable role.


Taska
said

Human lives are lost and are at risk. With each passing day, the death toll will rise. But lives can be saved if speedy rescue efforts are deployed. The hardship of the hard stricken will be alleviated with massive relief work. This is humanity against a natural catastrophe, so let us all unite our efforts in helping the victims. Humanity is one race when confronted with nature!


Micky from NS
said

Chris - There is always need for help regardless of the resources you have..."Why should we send a fire truck to that part of the city, they have one already?"...doesn't make much sense either, does it? We are looked at as a premiere nation in the world because we are a nation that helps where and when it is needed.

XIN - Don't give up on our Canadian values just because of a few people with poor judgement.


3221308
said

"Hurricane Katrina " right?
People's Republic of China On September 2, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs said that it will offer $5 million along with emergency supplies, including 1,000 tents, 600 generators, bed sheets, immediately for disaster relief. China also offered to send medical care and rescue workers if they were needed. This aid package consisting of 104 tons of supplies later arrived in Little Rock, Arkansas. A chartered plane carrying the supplies arrived on September 7.


Frank G.
said

I simply cannot believe the cold-hearted comments here in the face of this immense tragedy... surely it is the Canadian way to reach out a helping hand?!? If I really thought these comments represented the bulk of Canada I would hang my head in shame. This has nothing to do with economics or politics... these are fellow-human beings who need our thoughts prayers and yes our aid. Canada has one of the best rapid response disaster teams and willing volunteers... we should be proud that we can help.

I really wonder who actually reads these CTV news and comments. There was recent poll asking if the flag should still be lowered for every fallen Canadian soldier (our sons and daughters fighting overseas on our behalf)... at first I was shocked that the question was even being asked and then I was saddened to see how close the poll was.

Maybe some people come on here just for effect.
I won't believe that we are really turning into such a selfish nation. Shame on you!


Jeanne
said

Dear Jesus - please help these people, and their children and animals survive this terrible catastrophe. I think we should do whatever we can for them. Let's all say a prayer for them, and wish them well.


John
said

Three gorges dam is built on a seismic fault. and is between the epicenter and beijing where the quake was also felt...could any of this be related?


Amanda
said

Wow that's cold. I wonder if you would be so flippant if 1,000 children in canada lost their lives? Think about it. That is 10,000.00 PEOPLE. Not cars or buildings or dollars but parents, childen, husbands, wives. It shouldn't matter what country their from. If you think what nationality someone is should matter when it comes to caring if they died, or doing something to ease their pain, then you need help.


Compassionate Canadian
said

Wow, some of you people complete lack compassion. I wonder how you'd feel if the tables were turned? SICKENING!!!!! Typical Canadians, don't like the policy of the US or Chinese governments, so they paint their entire population as bad people, undeserving of our support. In case you're wondering, yes, I'm Canadian. My heart goes out to the victims of this tragedy.


Jennifer
said

just a quick comment about "the U.S didn't get any outside help either". Yes, the states did get some outside help. Members of our Navy assisted with the clean-up in, I believe, Biloxi.
While I do feel for the mass tragedy in China, our current DART team is already madated for Burma where 10X the amount of people require assistance. Second, do you really think China would accept military aid? Assistance - yes, military "intervention" - problably not


JD in Alberta
said

Why is it, no matter what is in the news, backward thinking narrow minded people find a way to blame the US. The US didn't need to send anything to Myanmar.They do and they are critisized. if they didn't they would be critisized. Chris, how much have you sent to help with the relief effort? Did you send anything to the Hurricane Katrina victims? How much did China and Myanmar send to the US after Hurricane Katrina??

And to Wang, China does provide cheaper products, but the quality is lousy, becuase they are made from what I consider to be from slave labor, enforced by a government that brutalizes the population every chance they get.
And finally to Xin, I agree let's give our tax dollars to everyone who needs it. But why not start with all the CANADIANS, that suffer right here at home. Just because people are fortunate enough to call Canada home, doesn't mean that every one of us live in the lap of luxury. I know lots of single moms, and single dads, that barely make do because of the high taxes, out of control gas prices, sky high rents, insurance etc. Let's take care of out own first for a change, then worry about the rest of the world.


Ivy
said

I am a Chinese and I pray for the people in SiChuan. It is an unexpected natural disaster that has literally taken lives within seconds, what a tragedy. I agree that China produces the most manufacture goods than other countries. However, I don't think losing a job compares to losing a life. Shame on the people who value money over human life, especially over Chinese people's lives. My heart goes out to the people in Sichuan, and to anyone of any colour that is in need. I hope that China can rescue as many people as possible. All my blessings!!!


Jessie
said

God bless those people and family who are suffered in the earthquake!


Jim Jagoola
said

It's interesting to see how borders and countries and ideologies become excuses of the mind at times like this. People of the world are all brothers and sisters, that's my experience anyway. It's possible increasing natural disasters around the world will serve to open up our hearts and feelings to see this.


Xiaozhu
said

The epicenter is Wengshan county, an Tibetan and Qiang ethenic autonomous county of Sichuan provence, China. As all roads to that county have been twisted by the earthquake, so it's very difficult to get there even on foot. Thousands solders from Chinese elite airborne force have got there by parachute yesterday under thunder storm whether, other few solders got there on foot. But heavy equipments couldn't be put into the epicenter so far, so those Chinese soldiers have to save lives by their bare hands.


Richard
said

It does not matter how many lives are affected. One or a million lives, it is still sad to lose people due to a natural disaster. I'm pretty sure that the people from China are not asking for financial aid. They would rather have your moral support during a difficult time like this. My heart goes out for you people from China.


Ivan
said

I agree that we should help in this situation. However, sending money at this time isn't going to deal with the immediate need. China may not need soldiers, but they do need medical, shelter, food and water supplies. Just because a country has financial means, does not translate in their ability to provide in a situation like this. Any country has a finite reserve of emergency supplies available for disasters, and other countries should help out to fill the gap.


Eleanor
said

Whatever happened to just caring about our fellow man!
you know... its called compassion.
why do we always have to judge one another and
place blame.
The chinese people are in my prayers
We all share this beautiful planet.
lets share it in love and peace and compassion for each other.What a refreshing change that would be!!


Joanne
said

If you are a average person, please be passionate, peacefully pray for all the people in need or suffer, whoever in the world, not to mention where rich of disasters. We are just so lucky living in a piece of tranqill land.

God bless everyone!!!


MJ
said

TWO THINGS NEED TO CLEARED:
1. PRODUCTS WHICH ARE MADE IN CHINA ARE BROUGHT HERE BY AMERICAN OR CANADIAN COMPANIES,NOT CHINESE COMPANIES.
2. GM OR OTHER COMPANY WANT TO CLOSE PLANT,NOT CHINESE COMPANY.


rocky
said

People write nagative comments here to grab more attentions. I get. But, listen to yourself, you always rise human issues on to a political level and criticize the country. They are people buried alive down there, and yet you are sitting in your confort sofa accusing the country and saying "Too bad for you". I came to Canada and chose to live in, because Canadians have such a great reputation for humanity and generosity. But you guys are puting shame on the Maple leave flag.


ha
said

You guys want to help? Funny, they don't want your help. It is your money they want.

Why?
(1) China has a rocket station in Sichuan. Mind you, a very good one.

(2) Sichuan is right beside Tibet.


Natalie
said

"10000 people in China lost in a natural disaster is like an average Joe being struck by a car in downtown Brandon, MB"

is saying an average ''Joe'' in Brandon, MB is equivalent to 10 000 dead Chinese people.

Just how racist is that?


monsword
said

Thanks, Steve in Aylmer

As a Chinese immigrant and the one who has family members in shocked region, I really appreciate your words which warms up my heart....I believe 90% of Canadian are as nice as you are...

Yes, as someone said, China has plenty of resource and manpower for the rescue and re-construction, but any aid, even only 10k dollars from Canada, would greatly cheer up Chinese people at this hard moment...

To Chris...lost 10000 is NOT same as an average Joe being struck by a car. I could share my tear for a great Canadian boy killed last week in Afghan, why could you not show some compassion to thousands Chinese school kids buried alive in earthquake..


Dixie from Alberta
said

If China can fork out billions to host the Olympics, why would they need our financial help?


Lin
said

Nick
This is nothing new to China, they get quakes all the time and will be able to deal with it. Yes huge loss of life, but don't forget that in Canada, we don't have cities of 10 million plus people. Lin's analogy is flawed.


My analogy is flawed?
How is it any different? If they quake were to happen in Ottawa, that would be disasterous.

The earthquake occured in an area where the popoulation was only 110,000 people. If the earthquake were to take place here, it would also be a disaster. I do not see how fatalities differ from one country to another.


sane
said

Let's stop "blessing everyone" and "praying". How about we commend the relief workers and emergency personnel who are actually doing something about the situation on the ground.


Concerned
said

'A person is a person, no matter how small'. They may be wealthier, they may have more citizens, but I only hope that when Canada has a disaster or we are in need of help that their citizens do not read the headlines and say things like 'Well they have enough wealth and ressources.' Everyone needs help at some point or another and this is no different.


X. Zhu
said

My tax dollars go to all those who face natural disasters of this magnitude, whichever their nationality may be! Shame on those who put politics ahead of humanity.


Susan Z.
said

Oh, I'm tearing... seeing how Wen Jiabao, premier of the government of China, is organizing and monitoring the rescue, how the military sodiers are approaching the sites under horrible weather.

Raining on and on after the disaster, lots of mudslides blocked roads connected with the epicentre.

even in this situation, the military is taking all possible solutions such as landing by parachute while roads inavailable and visibility extremely poor.


CB
said

Wow, some of you people are heartless. If that were your children under the rubble...would you respond differently?
I think it's a terrible time all over the world. I feel for the people of China and Burma. I hope all goes well. My thoughts are with all of the suffering people.



Edith
said

How can anyone get political at a time like this? Whether or not there are any reasons to disagree with the politics in China, we in Canada, are a compassionate nation. I am a Chinese Canadian but above all I am human. Like the Cyclone in Burma, my heart goes out to the families affected by this tragedy...all the families there and anyone here with families in those countries. There is too much cynicism in this world. Please show your compassion and support the victims of these tragedies. A natural disaster can strike anyone, whatever your nationality. Please donate to help make this world a more livable and humane place!

To support emergency relief efforts: Contact the Canadian Red Cross by calling calling 1-800-418-1111 or visit http://www.redcross.ca/article.asp?id=27283&tid=001


Stephen NY
said

The US sent what the Burmese government allowed us to send. There are very strict limitations on whatt hey allowed us to send. No food, bottled water meeting certain measurments, blankets or clotheing. Bugnets, and cots. Chris, you obviouls have never been in a disaster zone, so you would not know, what kind of blessing, blankets bugnets and water are. Do me a favor, get up and do something positive for society instead of sitting in you chair.


kate
said

"Help a country that robs the world of its manufacturing jobs"

News flash for you honey, it's not China that stole the jobs, it's the greedy North American WASP CEO's and shareholders who shipped your jobs over there so they could line their pockets with more profits. Seriously, get a clue or let me buy one for you.

Apologies to all the Chinese Canadians who are being insulted by Canadian red necks - they don't speak for all of us. The chinese have been an integral part of Canada and it's development and their loss is our loss. I can't even imagine knowing my child was trapped in a building and having to helplessly stand by and not be able to do anything. I'm happy and willing to send my tax dollars to China to help.


Sean
said

@Chris
I hope you are not one of those that point fingers at China every once in a while for "human rights abuse". Because if you are, I'm seriously going to fall out my chair laughing.

Oh and one more thing, shame on you.


Deeanne
said

I truly hope that comments that equate one Canadian life to 10,000 Chinese lives are designed to antagonize other readers, and are not truly reflective of someone's opinion. A human life is a human life, whether it be in Canada, China, Burma, Afganistan etc. To suggest anything otherwise is pure ignorance.


lieut
said

I thought that Canada was a friendly, responsible country before, but it astonishes me there actually exist a good number of cold-blooded people with parochial mentality, who are even rejoicing in the calamity of others, throughout this country. No wonder Canada's influence on this world is still very limited nowadays. Shame on those people! I'm seriously telling you both Chinese people and the Chinese government will stretch out a helping hand without the least hesitation if Canada faces a catastrophe or difficulties one day. I guess this is the result of the two countries' different education levels.


Susan Z.
said

What's wrong with Made-in-China? That is persued by western companies for lower cost and higer profit!

Why don't you blame them and not China?

China is a victim! We Chinese people are complaining why we are depleted so much! Go elsewhere beyond China!

Only idiots pour hatred on Made-in-China.


Cas
said

Some people are just so heartless. What if it was your loved ones that were living over there? Shame on you. My friend's son is missing from this earthquake. They deserve all the possible help that they can receive. Everyone needs help and support while going through a disaster such as this. My heart goes out to all of those people.


Doug BC
said

Well,I'm neither cold blooded or racist.But I agree with those who say we have no obligation to spend tax dollars foolisly.This is not an impoverished nation. Their military population alone is nearly 10 times the entire population. So they obviously don't need more people in there. And,if they can explore space and support a massive military, surely they can afford anything we could supply from here.
I feel for the losses any family feels under these circumstances.But this is a regime with its priorities way out of whack. Political correctness or feelings of compassion should not motivate us to spend foolishly on a country which will never be the slightest bit grateful.
We should wait for them to tell us what they can't do for themselves,and evaluate whether or not our help can be useful,and not just an exercise in political correctness.
Our limited resources should be used to aid people who don't have the ability to help themselves.I do not believe China lacks either the manpower, or the resources.


Praying for the peaceful world
said

As a human being, when any people is suffering from the natural disaster regardless if they are American or Canadian or Chinese, the first thing we should do is to try my best to help them. The people are suffering - they need help to be alive! That is it.


dcfdhr
said

Even though Chinese Government is trying the best to rescue people, I still believe more lives could be saved if the CCP government handle everything properly. I would never forget SARS in 2003.

Chris mentioned “…They are arguably the most richest nation in the world…” maybe true, but the majority of Chinese people don’t actually get the benefit of the economical gain. They are still suffering poverty, un-education, no freedom of religions, especially people like those from Wenchuan County, a poor mountainous region in Sichuan province.
“Made in China” means cheap labors, why cheap labors? Because many products and goods are made by people in Jail - they are forced to work day and night without pay. Another recourse of cheap labors is that people (most from farmer’s family) who lost their land and since they don’t have much education, they end up being cheap labors.

No matter what kind of disaster, it is always the same group of people who really suffering.
I am Chinese Canadian, my heart’s broken. God bless everyone in the world!



AlexN
said

It always shocks me how heartless people are at times like these. 10 000 people died. Not 10 000 Chinese, 10 000 people. No matter what nationality they are, how populous their country is, how rich or poor they are... They are PEOPLE!
Wouldn't we want their help and compassion if something horrible happened here?
Those people who died don't control China's actions they are just living and they were and are loved.


celine
said

These people are still human, whether or not they are still one of the richest countries, they need help, all the help they can get finding the missing people and the same with relief. And in return if Canada ever gets in trouble they may show the same kindness.


Joe
said

I'm disgusted in some of these comments. As someone above noted there is no mention of China looking for help. This article is informing us of the tragedy happening and the first thing people think of is don't touch our money. Have a heart, thousands of people died.
My prayers go out to their family and friends.


Joe North-American
said

If CommunistChina can afford to host Olympics, explore space and have a massive military then they can afford to pay for their own relief and crisis. Get over the political correct babble. Do you think they'd honestly lift a finger for Canada if we'd be in that situation?

And yes..they are part and parcel of our job losses because they keep their dollar the yuan artificially low to attract our companies to their shores. So yes it is their fault for manipulating business to leave North America because of their 'artificially' low yuan dollar. Grow up you pathetic 'do-gooders", shell out your own money to a charity if you want but I'm keeping mine thank-you very much!


sin_ical
said

It's not about SHAME and who's human and yakyakyak...it's about any aid and/or funds being picked over by "Aid Societies" so very little actually makes it through, and always far too late.

Cases in Point:

Live Aid
Tsunami
Katrina
Insert disaster here




Robin da Hood
said

Will you whiners give me a break already!.. one clown's comments does NOT make it the view of the majority of Canadians... rather than knocking Canada and Canadians - which granted so many a home to live here ... and who are much more compassionate than the majority of humanity - try taking a pill and then go out and make a $ contribution to the relief efforts instead! And hope they don't confiscate the good will like the China supported Burmese dictators did. And please stop making me waste my time commenting on such silly comments!. Thank you!



Glenn Alexander
said

I have lived in Beijing since 2003. I say upfront that China is not utopia, it is far from perfect and yet, it is not the horrible villain many seem hell-bent on painting it to be.

2 hours post-quake rescue workers were en route. 12 hours post-quake literally hundreds were on the ground and digging with bare hands. 24 hours post-quake the Chinese PM was on site, comforting parents who had to watch helplessly as their children were pulled dead from a collapsed school.

Tell me what happened within the first 24 hours post-Katrina again please?

I have spent today answering text messages from Chinese friends from across the country who know that my work causes me to often travel to where the quake hit. They are concerned to know that I am ok.

As a Canadian I have been so very warmly welcomed by the Chinese people. Every school child has learned of Dr. Bethune and told of the long history of friendship between China and Canada.

I have been received into Chinese people's homes too many times to count, been given gifts and made to feel like family.

People are not their governments and natural disasters are not political forums.

I promise you here and now that if a disaster of this magnitude struck Canada (and for Vancouver, my home, it just might) you would find the Chinese people standing ready to help in any way possible. They would consider it to be the height of ignorance and deplorable manners to heap criticism on you during such a disaster.

And before you jump on any further bandwagons to espouse our wonderful western values and human rights, pause a moment and consider what I learned growing up in Canada - for every mile of railway track connecting Canada from coast to coast is a dead Chinese person who lost their lives while building it.

This is not the time to punish innocent people suffering unfathomable loss because of differing political views.

I am deeply ashamed of any Canadian (or human) who thinks and speaks otherwise. Where are the Canadian values I grew up with now? Where are your manners? Where is your dignity?


Al
said

This is a sad and tragic event. Anything that results in loss of life (even 1 person), it's a tragic event.
However, i think China is well capable of handling this. One of the richest (if not THE), most powerful army and well organized system, this is easy for them, i would assume.
People can send prayers or whatever they want but i haven't heard China come asking for help. People don't confuse realistic with harshness.
China is much diff than Burma though!


Michael
said

When it comes to natural disasters China is obviously better prepared and organized than the USA was for the hurricanes.


Susan Z.
said

The Chairman, Hu Jingtao, of Chinese Gov. was talking with Bush regarding the rescue and restoration.

Unlike Burma, China is looking forward to help extended by kind hearted nations.

Many donation lines or internet accesses have been set up in addition to convenient locations including commercial malls, associations and embassy/consulates in Canada.


JimP
said

Canada will help the Chinese in any way we can, in any way they need. This is what we do! And proudly!


Matt
said

I am really shocked at the responses from Canadian on the site. They are not Canadians I know who have been considered Peaceful, generous and compassionate people.

Yes, China needs our help as just we do when we have our shares of natural disasters.

Chris, you do not have to give your money, but please do not say those hateful words to hurt the earthquake victims.


bernie
said

When I read that 10,000 deaths is not a big deal, I realize that the human race has declined to a new low.

Shame!


Embarassed by the comments on here!
said

What kind of sick individual comes on here saying "Don't help China... they have a big military... they have lots of money" Say a rich person gets hit by a car here... everyone should look the other way and say "not me". Thats horrible! For those of you that don't want to help... remember that someday you may need help from another. Hopefully they won't look at you and say... sorry... you're Canadian... you're rich... I'm not helping you!" your Morons! Send Dart ASAP and help our Chinese friends! It's not the money... it's letting them know we care!


Henry
said


After reading the posts, we are so shocked that previous warm-hearted Canadian now seems to becoming heartless. Canadian was overwhelming seen to be so friendly to Chinese just due to ONE PEOPLE --- Dr. Norman Bethune (REMEBER, ALMOST EVERY CHINESE KNOWS Dr. Norman Bethune), BUT NOW THERE ARE SO MANY CANADIANS BECOMING SO COLD-BLOODED. (Some people in the foolish comments say that Chinese is not thankful to Canadian help, PLEASE note how Chinese people thanks Dr. Norman Bethune so years later).
If Canadian has such a 7.8 earthquake, I wonder how will Canadian will feel about such stupid comments (NO neccessary to help). IF YOU ARE A HUMAN BEING, you should not say such words in natural disaster. ALSO those stupid Canadian politician will only make their way longer and longer to restore their damaged images in normal Chinese people. TAKE CARE...


Gong
said

It is appalling to see some Canadian being so out of touch with the reality of China.

Yes, China will survive no matter you help or not. But China will definitely appreciate your help even it is just a prayer and console. For your information, Chinese goverment donated 5 million US$ in 2005 Katrina. Do you know how much US offer to help this time? 500 thousand dollars.



Sarah Dello
said

Wow, some of you people are heartless. If that were your children under the rubble...would you respond differently?
I think it's a terrible time all over the world. I feel for the people of China and Burma. I hope all goes well. My thoughts are with all of the suffering people.



Jhislaine
said

I recently taught in China and I would like to remind people that yes, China has a decent army and the people to deal with this, but they are still a developing nation that does not have the infrastructure to deal with this kind of disaster.
Trust me they need our help, especially some leadership in how to go about the search and rescue.
Another point I want to make it, is that we are a global community and if we needed help China would give it.


Peter
said

This is what Mao Zedong wrote about Doctor Bethune :
"We must all learn the spirit of absolute selflessness from him. With this spirit everyone can be very helpful to each other. A man's ability may be great or small, but if he has this spirit, he is already noble-minded and pure, a man of moral integrity and above vulgar interests, a man who is of value to the people."
Can we still keep up with this Canadian value?


Joanne
said

I was not supposed to come and see so much pointing-figurer at China at this moment when it's suffering the natural disaster.

Why couldn't we be more tender and sympathy under such a circumastance? It's common sense that is I believe widely seen even in so-called suppressed nations.


Tony
said


"Hurricane Katrina " right?
People's Republic of China On September 2, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs said that it will offer $5 million along with emergency supplies, including 1,000 tents, 600 generators, bed sheets, immediately for disaster relief. China also offered to send medical care and rescue workers if they were needed. This aid package consisting of 104 tons of supplies later arrived in Little Rock, Arkansas. A chartered plane carrying the supplies arrived on September 7.



Ashley
said

Omg, I feel so sorry for thoes people who got hurt. I also feel so sorry for the people who died. I wonder how much people cried....Probably lots. :'(


jo
said

China is extremely wealthy and had more emergency systems in place than anywhere else in the world.
Why would we bring them here? It can be reconstructed and yes, with international aid..IF they need it. We are not a wealthy country. I am sorry for these people but facts are facts.


Teaching in Shaowu
said

As a Canadian living and working in a small city in Fujian Province, I have seen and experienced the living conditions of the Chinese people for almost a year. Their work ethic and determination is admirable, their generosity unfailing. Although most live in conditions we as Canadians could not tolerate for a week, they are willing to share what little they have with a Canadian who does not understand or speak more than 50 words of Mandarin, and who will be leaving in less than two months. Yes, the Chinese economy is growing at an exponential rate. Yes, the numbers of troops in their military are staggering. But the average citizen is like you and I - working to support their families, aspiring for a better life (here it means affording a small water heater, a refrigerator and a motorcycle), and the opportunity to take one day off each week. Let's remember our similarities as human beings and support them in whatever small way we can in dealing with this tragedy. Their heartache is real.


Glenn
said

Someone wrote earlier that it was 10,000 human beings that lost their lives and not 10,000 chinese. My question is: of the 10,000 human beings that lost their lives, how many are chinese? And one more thing, if you think by adding god bless and saying a prayer for lives lost is going to do any good then you might as well throw your money away too! God can't and won't do anything, if he could why did he let this happen. "God bless you poor souls", oh by the way it was gods will that put you in harms way. If you truly want to help these people show them how build better buildings to withstand something like this. Like it or not people, earthquakes were here long before we were, so it's not like it was a surprise that an earthquake happened. It's the same with floods, hurricane's tsunami's', tornado's, etc., people choose to live where they live despite the dangers. And when something like this happens, the world is shocked. 9/11 was shocking and preventable.


Trevor Davies
said

To say that China hasn't asked for aid from other countries is completely false. They have asked the global community for help. To hear some people say that the Chinese don't deserve it, for whatever reason, is not only shameful, but deplorable. If my helping could save one life, or help someone in their time of need, wouldn't it be worth it? I was born and raised in Canada, and these are the values that we, as Canadians have always held, regardless of the comments made here by the odd bad apple. My heart goes out to China.


Wai
said

Let us not waste time to debate with those who has no heart for people who are suffering, dying and need help immediately.
Pick up your phone to call your MP, send them e-mail or fax them to express your urge to them to ask the Canadian Government to send help IMMEDIATELY. It is a humanity cause.
My heart go out to all those who suffer and/or loss love ones in this disaster.
I will pray for those 'cold-hearted' and hopefully they will regain their sense of a human being and react more humanly.


Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

CTV.ca Map

Earthquake Epicentre

Earthquake Epicentre

Highlighted areas of the epicentre and where the tremors were felt in China's Sichuan province.

In Pictures

China earthquake

Quake Chaos

A closer look at the chaotic scene in the hours following the 7.9 magnitude earthquake which hit China.

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz