CTV News | Israel stages 60th birthday bash amid uncertainty

Top Stories -   

Israel stages 60th birthday bash amid uncertainty

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV Newsnet: Alain-Michel Ayache, Mid East expert
Canada AM: Janis Mackey Frayer in Tel Aviv, Israel
CTV Newsnet: David DeWitt, York University
Canada AM: Two Canadian volunteers in the Israeli Army share stories from the past

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(33)

CTV.ca News Staff

Date: Thu. May. 8 2008 10:19 AM ET

Israel has closed its borders with the West Bank and Gaza and set up extra security checkpoints as the nation celebrates its 60th anniversary.

Fireworks, an air show and nation-wide picnics were all part of the festivities as Israelis looked back with pride on the past, despite looming uncertainty about the future, said CTV's Middle East Bureau Chief Janis Mackey Frayer.

"This is almost a patriotic sigh of relief for people," she told Canada AM.

"They attach importance to milestones. Sixty years, they say, is not a long time to build what they see as a successful country -- though they acknowledge it still has its flaws. But people feel good they've come this far in 60 years, though they still have some uncertainty about what the next years will hold."

Israel experiences near-daily militant rocket attacks, militant threats from inside and outside its borders, tensions over Hamas-run Gaza and controversy over settlements in the Palestinian territories.

As well, a new criminal investigation into corruption allegations against Prime Minister Ehud Olmert, who is pushing for a peace agreement with moderate Palestinian leadership in the West Bank, may mean his job is in jeopardy.

"While this is being seen as a happy time, Israelis are also feeling a deep uncertainty, and it's not helped at all by the fact that the political leaders are constantly mired in scandal," Mackey Frayer said.

There is also little progress on peace talks brokered by U.S. President George Bush, who has set a goal of reaching a deal by the end of the year.

On Thursday, Palestinian Prime Minister Salam Fayyad said "the peace process is facing difficulties when compared with its declared goals."

Meanwhile, demonstrations in Gaza and the West Bank on Thursday served as a reminder that many Palestinians are still profoundly opposed to the Jewish state, the creation of which saw hundreds of thousands of Palestinians displaced in 1948.

In Bethlehem, The Associated Press reports roughly 500 marchers paraded behind a giant key symbolizing refugees' hope that they will one day return to their villages in what is now Israel. Most of those communities no longer exist.

The deep-rooted tension and disagreements in the region, Mackey Frayer said, suggest the objectives set out by Bush seem increasingly out of reach.

And if demographic trends continue, Arabs, who now make up one-fifth of Israel's population could become a majority -- another concern for Israelis looking for a more secure future, she said, reporting from a beach where thousands of Israelis had gathered to celebrate.

"People feel a lot better about looking at the past -- looking at the success of the past 60 years than looking ahead to the future because it is so uncertain," Mackey Frayer said.

With files from The Associated Press

Comments are now closed for this story

Ian - Milton
said

HAPPY 60th BIRTHDAY to the State of Israel! - real peace comes when we embrace our similarities and discard our differences.


Cindy Gidge..."Israeli supporter"
said

Great news hearing about happier times in Israel!They are a country to be commended NOT condemmed;being a democracy compared to some "others" and their achievements which are impressive.


Greg from Kitchener
said

Happy Birthday Israel!
you are a proud people, a country which is attacked daily, but yet you carry on.
I support you 100% in what you do, and so do most other Canadians.


Leslie
said

The Light to All Nations. A Nation so Admired and so Envied. A nation who is so hated with so many enemies against Her. Without Israel No nation on earth is safe or free.


Will
said

Happy Birthday Israel! Be sure to reflect on your successes and failures, and learn and grow from them. You have done much right, but do know that wrongs have been done throughout the years also. To sweep them under the rug only makes you seem weaker. Learn from them, and know that the world respects a country that has clarity in its past, present and future.


JP
said

The problem of Israel should be solved by the people who live around it. That is all I will say so that my note doesn't get censured. But please read into it the consequences intended.


How can this be?
said

When Israel celebrates the birth of their nation, the Palestinians mourn the death of theirs... at the hand of the Israelis.

It's a sad day for all people, whether or not they realize it.


Prairie suppporter.
said

Well done, Israel!. Enjoy your celebrations and the years to come. Godspeed!


Shalom Israel !!
said

HAPPY BIRTHDAY ISRAEL!!
You will always be the apple of God's eye, His promised land and His special people.

True followers of Christ everywhere appreciate your unique place in the affairs of God and welcome this opportunity to wish you a Happy Birthday!

Israel is God's land and will forever be God's land. Looking forward to the New Jerusalem.

SHALOM !



Rona from Canmore
said

A sad day for Palestinians who had their land taken from them 60 yrs ago. Walls dividing them from each other, students from their schools, patients from hospitals, farmers from their crops. All so that Israel can celebrate? Israel bends and breaks humanitarian laws every day while the world looks away.


Q from London, Ontario
said

60 years of Occupation is no reason to celebrate.
60 years ago Palestine was occupied.
60 years ago the largest refugee population in the world was born.
60 years ago the world turned a blind eye to one of the most henious crimes.
The world still seems to think Israel is a victim.. a victim with means to occupy, destroy and kill innocent civilians.
What a shame...



Ian - MIiton
said

To 'how can it be' - there never was a state or nation or country called Palestine. It was an geographic area that included parts of what is now Jordan (was called TransJordan)and parts of Syria and Lebanon and more.

Palestinians are a wonderful people group - and like Jews who are Jews no matter where they live, Palestinians are Palestinians no matter where they live.

The region called Palestine came about after the destruction of the original Jewish lands in the first place.


merlet@shaw.ca
said

There is no occupation, there is only disputed land and lots of terrorists that want to kill Jews. Israel must must fight off this threat with all its power and might.


Noa
said

I'm disgusted to see Canada and other states embrace "Israel", an illegitimate apartheid state that was founded on the expense of the indigenous people of Palestine, who are still refugees today, and whose calamity is denied by Zionists and their supporters.


Norman
said

What's the big deal here? 60 is not a significant number for a country. 50 or 100 is, but 60 is not. Have a happy 60th birthday anyway Israel.


raj
said

Happy Birthday - I rejoice with you.All that israel and it's people have been through, you humble me.I say Happy Bithday over & over


PJR
said

to Ian-Milton: real peace comes when we embrace our differences and not only our similarities.

Have a good one Israel but use this time to reflect on the past 60 years and to think about ways to make the next 60 better, for all people and peoples on your territory and in your region.


GW
said

Happy Birthday Israel

God promised the Jews he would bring this nation back together one day and this seems to have been fulfilled 60 years ago. This doesn’t mean they won’t experience a great deal of trouble however.

I believe the bible suggests a group of countries which includes Persia will invade Israel one day but will be thoroughly defeated never to be heard from again. After this there is supposed to be a short period of piece as a new world order is established. Interesting times ahead and all eyes will be on Israel.



Joe
said

Israel is an example of what human imagintion and creativity is capable if. It is an oasis of freedom, democracy amid a sea of Middle East stagnation.

Eor the naysayers, if Israel ceased to exist do you really think anything would improve in the Mid East? the violence against Arabs, especially women and the vulnerable, is lower in Israel than any other Mid East country. I did two tours of duty with Canadian UN forces in Egypt and the Golan Heights. A few R&R spent in Israel was like getting back in touch with positive in mankind.


Jack
said

Most disturbing to me is the systemic re-writing of history.

Ask the Irish if Ireland still existed while the British tyranny of occupation was forced on them.

American, Polish, Russian, German, French, African, Indian & Chinese Jews are not originally from Palestine.

This madness that God made a real estate deal with the Jews of some 'Promised Land' and then forcing this religious irrationality on the world to deal with must be stopped.


Zionism is a European creation of imperialism and it's modern out post in the Middle East is Israel.



A Jew
said

What are we as Jews, celebrating? We went from being persecuted in Europe to using the tool of the enemy to destroy a people who did nothing to us: the Palestinians.

We are now guilty of intentional mass slaughter: Quana,Sabra & Shatilla, Deir Yessan massacres, just to name a few.

We've become blinded by our own demands, most self-evident in our alliance with the Christian Zionists who would see us all dead or converted; we've befriended our enemies and crippled our friends.

As a Jew, I feel sorrow not celebration.


Tim Seguin
said

To Joe:
It seems you visited the Bubble`s part of isreal
I did tours with UN too, I did it in the palestinian parts but all I saw was violence against children, women & un armed men.. I hope you deliver true statements


Mike
said

That's interesting that everyones bible predicts that Persia will invade Israel because the facts are as following: Israel is the one that began threatening Iran two years ago and Israel is the one that has maintained an unrelenting propaganda campaign to paint Iran as the new Hitler/Germany garbage to build its lies upon to invade Iran.

Am I the only one who finds using the bible for nation creation and foreign policy to be, well, nutty?

I'm not celebrating.


Jim
said

Happy Birthday.

In the future, I would like to see middle eastern problems stay in the middle east, rather than pull us into this centuries old conflict (ie 9/11).


RRO
said

With age comes Wisdom and hopefully a desire for peace.
Everyone who is condemning the Israelies or the Palestinians are being foolish.
The reality is both have committed horrible crimes. The history has been scewed by all sides. Israel and Palestine are working towards frinding a peaceful solution. Israel has been at its least aggressive in 60 years, and on both sides their are leaders who genuinely want peace.
All the extremists condemning Israel, if you do truly care about the Palestinians, you should be encouraging them on the path of peace. hate begets hate, vegence begets vengence, blood begets blood.
Or to put it simpler, as Ghandi put it " an eye for an eye makes the whole world blind."
We must let the evils of the past go, with the hope of building a better tommorrow.


Chistian from Egypt
said

RE: "Shalom Isreal..Israel is God's land and will forever be God's land. Looking forward to the New Jerusalem"

I am a Coptic Christian Egyptian, and I like to say that Israel WAS God's chosen -as per God's promise to Abraham- until the birth of Christ. After the birth of Christ we ALL became God's chosen to heavenly Jerusalem"


How can this be?
said

To Ian - MIiton

Since my previous message was not posted... I'll keep this one simple:

1. Haganah -> Jewish militia (do your research)
2. British Mandate of Palestine -> Palestine
3. Israel -> created as a result of terroristic actions of Haganah


James
said

Happy 60th Israel!!!

I hope to visit your beautiful nation someday!




Trent
said

For those who say the death of Palestine was at the hands of the Israeli's do yourself a favour and pick up a history book to see how Israel was created, your blame belongs elsewhere including right here at home.
Let's hope that someday soon the two sides will be able to live alongside one another in peace.


Mark S.
said

I'm in Montreal and saw so many Israeli flags in cars today I just had to know what I was missing.
Nor from a completely outside perspective.. I must admit I am still torn between being happy for the Israelis and their celebration.. and feeling bad for the refugees who lost their homes long ago. But either way.. I'm glad there can be a little bit of joy in that tortured part of the world today. Happy 60th!
Mark S.
Montreal


bobby
said

Happy Diamond anniversary, Israel!

1948 - UN partition plan - Israel & Palestinian state side by side. Jews accepted - Arabs attacked.

1964 - PLO founded by Arafat. Attacks on civilians begin in force. There are no occupied "territories" in 1964.

1967 - Egypt, Syria & Jordan attack Israel. Results? Territories from which the aggression commenced were lost.

1998 - Arafat was offered 96% of the land in return for a peace of piece of paper. Response? Intifada hostilities.


Ian K.
said

Shalom and happy Birthday Israel! The only democracy in a sea of dictatorships!

As for the Palestinians, here's a viewpoint from a refugee from Eastern Europe.

Millions of people in Eastern Europe lost land unjustly before, during and after WW 2, my family included. They did not waste 3 generations whining, screaming or engaging in terrorism - they accepted that bad things happen in history and moved on to build better lives elsewhere.

It's time the Palestinians faced the hard facts - we all had to do that after WW 2 - and got over it. Move on: those lands are lost forever. Do something productive with your lives instead of wasting generations of youth on a fight that only makes yourselves more miserable.



mARY
said

Happy Birthday, Israel.
Shalome.


Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz