CTV News | Aid starting to trickle into Burma: agencies

World -   

Aid starting to trickle into Burma: agencies

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News: Steve Chao on the vast damage
CTV Newsnet: World Vision's Pam Sitko in Bangkok
CTV Ottawa: Charlie Musoka, Canadian Red Cross
Canada AM: A discussion on Canadian aid to Burma
Canada AM: World Vision's Pam Sitko in Bangkok
Canada AM: A discussion on the dire situation in Burma
CTV News: Robert Fife on the staggering death toll

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(28)

CTV.ca News Staff

Date: Tue. May. 6 2008 11:02 PM ET

While obstacles hamper delivery, international aid is starting to trickle into Burma to help the survivors of a cyclone that has killed at least 22,400 people.

"This assistance is on its way," United Nations relief spokesperson Elisabeth Byrs said Tuesday in Geneva.

However, aid workers are facing travel and visa problems. Some countries are complaining that Burma's rulers are reluctant to accept direct aid.

"We're prepared to move U.S. navy assets to help find those who have lost their lives, to help find the missing, to help stabilize the situation. But in order to do so, the military junta must allow our disaster assessment teams into the country," U.S. President George Bush said.

The White House has pledged US$3.25 million in aid.

Bernard Kouchner, France's foreign minister, said his country would provide 25 per cent of a $3.1-million European Union pledge.

However, Burmese officials want an additional US$300,000 to distribute themselves, something he described as "not a good way of doing things.

"It's not a lot but we don't really trust the way the Burmese ministry would use the money," said Kouchner, who helped found the aid group Doctors Without Borders.

Foreign Affairs Minister Maxime Bernier has said that Canada wants "Burmese authorities to provide full and unhindered access to humanitarian organizations to allow them to assist with the relief efforts."

Canada has agreed to provide up to $2 million in emergency relief.

Here are some other nations' contributions and pledges to date:

  • China: US$1 million in aid and relief materials;
  • Norway: Up to US$1.96 million;
  • Spain: US$775,000 donation to World Food Programme;
  • Switzerland: US$475,000 (initial);
  • Czech Republic: US$154,000
  • Denmark: US$103,600
  • Sweden: Logistical support and water cleaning systems

Widespread destruction

Cyclone Nardis struck Burma on Saturday, tearing a swath through the low-lying Irrawady Delta, a critical rice-growing region located on a peninsula between the Bay of Bengal and the Gulf of Mottama. The cyclone moved northeast to pass over Rangoon, the country's largest city.

Besides the 22,400 dead, another 41,000 people have been reported missing. The number of people left homeless is estimated to be one million. Burma has population of about 49 million.

Of the Irrawady delta, EU humanitarian office spokesperson Simon Horner said, "The reports that are coming back from some of our partner organizations ... is that there are some communities where the destruction is close to 100 per cent."

Anne-Francoise Moffroid, another EU official, said it's still difficult to know how many people need aid, given the destruction and the isolation of many affected areas.

"Many volunteers from the local Red Cross have died in the disaster," she said. "I think it will be a major challenge to bring assistance to these areas."

The International Red Cross said its first shipment arrived Tuesday.

It is working with the local Red Cross to distribute plastic sheets, drinking water, insecticide-treated bed nets and clothing.

World Vision's Pam Sitko said the group is working with the national government to distribute clothing, blankets, food, emergency shelter and clean water to those hardest hit by the disaster.

Speaking from Thailand, Sitko said the most pressing need is to provide clean drinking water and clear the roads so that aid can be delivered to those who need it most.

"It's not just water systems. That's just a start," she told CTV Newsnet. Disease prevention and medical care for the injured are other top priorities, she said.

A vote on the country's draft constitution had been set for Saturday, but state radio was reporting that the vote would be held over until May 24 in 40 townships around Yangon and seven in the Irawaddy delta. However, balloting will proceed as scheduled in less hard-hit areas.

Some critics say the new constitution is designed to cement military control over Burma. The military has governed since 1962.

With files from The Associated Press

Comments are now closed for this story

NSredneck
said

Hey Canada, isn't this why we have a dart team, lets send the help, they need it....


WW
said

Like I said yesterday, it is time for the DART to go over there and provide humanitirian assistance immediatedly.
The C-17's should be rolling right now.


Andrew in BC
said

Brutal...absolutely brutal to what has happened to the poor of this country over decades and this storm is only the icing on the cake. I only know what the media has told me about Burma but from what I have learned I can almost see the smiles on the dictator's face as he sees the unprecedented amounts of money that will be flowing into his lands from outside the borders.

How are we going to help and ensure that the help goes to the millions that are in need and not into the coffers of the ruling family? Good luck to all of the well meaning governments in this time of need...and I mean that sincerly, but please only send manpower and food, lots of food, and water, lots of water. Keep the money out of the country.


dave
said

For those of you calling for the DART, you should realize it is a military organization and I'm pretty sure that the military dictatorship in Burma will not allow another country's soldiers within their borders.


DART?
said

They had the police and military resources to crack down on the general population some months back, I'm sure they can cope with the situation.


bobby
said

In the long term, this may be the catalyst needed to embolden the Burmese people to overthrow the military dictatorship - when they see the total disregard for the nation's population in this, their time of great need.

Sadly, in the short term, many will suffer.


mnm
said

This is a perfect situation for Dart. We need to act now to prevent any more deaths!


MB
said

Send Food and Medical Supplies Do Not Send Money--------------


Wes
said

This country is a closed military dictatorship. They want nothing to do with the outside world. They don't allow the press or aid workers in. If we send them two million dollars, it will not go to aid but will line the pockets of the corrupt government. We should only be sending aid to places where we can be assured that it will be used to help the desparate, not get stolen by government officials.


WB
said

While reading the news story and the amounts of money being sent to help in this time of need, the first thing that came to mind was that it would go into the coffers of the military dictator and never be used for the purpose it was sent...I agree with the above post...send clothing food and water and personel to help the people, use the money to buy equipment to cleanse the water and rebuild the villages but buy it and have it sent there.


Yves
said

For DART to respond to the emrgency, they have to have the permission from the gov.of the requesting country. I don't think they EVER get that one.


A. T.
said

The Burmese Military will not spend any effort on recovery than the bare minimum needed to keep them in power.

If anything, their paranoid nature will probably not allow relief teams such as DART in the country.

Any AID sent to Burma through military channels will NEVER reach the people.

As long as the political situation is Burma is as it has been for the past few decades, there is nothing you can do for the Burmese people.


Act then talk
said

World Vision has been in this area for over 40 years. They are already on the ground, making assessments and handing out supplies. This would be an organization to send money to at this time.

Sean Calder
said

NSredneck and WW, sending DART would be fantastic I agree. This is what they train for.

This can only happen IF the Burmese government will allow foreign agencies to enter the country. They never have before, and refused any help after the Tsunami. This time they're saying they will accept help, but they haven't stated what they will allow. Until that answer is provided, DART stays where it is and the C-17's stay on the ground.


Paul In Barrie
said

Ladies and Gentleman

The DART unit based at 8 Wing, CFB Trenton can only be mobilized and dispatched under two conditions. The following is a direct quotation from CF Joint Headquarters DART webpage:

URL: http://www.cfjhq.forces.gc.ca/dart/main_e.asp

"In the case of an international mission, the DART can be activated either by a request from an individual country or by the United Nations (UN)

Regardless of who initiates the request, the final decision rests with the GoC based on advice from the Department of Foreign Affairs and International Trade, the Department of National Defence, and the Canadian International Development Agency.

In a UN operation, the DART would be required to coordinate its work with the UN-appointed humanitarian coordinator. The DART would collaborate with international agencies on site to achieve the maximum positive impact."

Since DART was formed the only exception to these conditions was Hurricane Katrina when General Hillier contacted his counterparts in the US military directly and started the process. This was done because of the common military command structure between our two countries as well as the unique relationship we have with the US in general.

It's quite probable DART has issued movement orders to bring the Team together at CFB Trenton in anticipation of a deployment to Burma/Myammar.

Paul
CF Veteran


michael
said

Any and all aid should be expedited to relieve an already stressed effort to sustain the health of these impoverished people. Readers should be reminded that Myanmar is a fictitious nation fabricated by those pretenders claiming Burma is no longer a sovereign British territory as it is correctly addressed in Australia, Canada and other loyal colonies.


Shamaro
said

Yes it would be nice to have our C-17's rolling down the runway, packed up with all the food and equipment, along with the DART personel we need for this mission in former Burma. However, you can't just send your military to any country you want, if you haven't been formerly asked by the other government. Sure, we could go in there without permission and try to help, however the Burmese government could look at that as a violation on their sovereignty by a foreign military and use military force to remove them if they so choose. Canada is doing the right thing and they are waiting to be asked to send their DART team over there as we speak, but they cannot act until a formal request has been given to them in writing by either the UN or by the Burmese government itself. I know the circumstances appear that we should just be able to go right in, however with the nature of the military government that's now in place and Canada's current relationship with them, it's highly unlikely at the moment that we can do anything


Alex
said

The Burmese government MUST request the DART before it is able to go. That is unlikely to happen, given they are a secretive military dictatorship and most likely do not want foreign troops of any kind on their land. There is nothing the Canadian government can do.

Our best bet is to contribute to organizations like The Red Cross or MSF. They are experienced in situations like this, and your funding will end up getting to those who need it most. Most countries (such as Canada) would never give cash as a means of assistance anyways. Aid is rarely that direct, it usually takes the form of projects, supplies, and services.


M.
said

Send your money to NGOs.
World Vision, UNICEF, World Food Program, Red Cross, Save the Children. They are on the ground already.

Forget about administartion fees, overthrowing the government etc. Those agencies are the only way to provide water and food. I think most of the aids are going to NGOs and not to the government (I hope they are that smart).


Al
said

As a retired serviceman I'm not aware of any
C-17's in our arsenal, but I've been retired for nearly 10 years. Our C-130's are busy locally and in Afghanistan.


Aris Scott
said

Well if DART can't go then there is another national team in Ottawa and the Province of Ontario's EMAT Team that should go.


WW
said

I understand that Burma is a military Junta, but I didn't say that the DART should be in the country. Maybe the DART could be inside of a country that it is close to burma, example Thailand, and give our supplies to those who are going to the country.


m
said

Send DART...do you people really know what DART is? Canada needs our tired military to finish in Afganistan not to go to Burma and get caught up in a military dictatorship country. Yes the people need help but there are humanitarian resources readily available if and when their country calls. For now 2 million in aid is a great gesture. Give from your own hearts and support through Unicef and World Vision...they are there!!!


DOUGB
said

OH just pack a plane with supplies and our DART Team who I may add goes in un armed. If they went in armed, in uniform to a country like this who is run by a military dictatorship, we would be paying more than $3500 fine to get them all out of jail like we did for Mrs. MARTIN.
If there is any group of people that deserve our help right now is all of our own in New Brunswick. Send our Dart Team there, there is places with no clean water, their homes are floating away, which also makes it hard cooking dinner. No problem sending aid over to Burma as along as its in food not cash, but our military, give your heads a shake. Burma has close ties to China and dont see their army moving in.


DC Dave
said

it seems to me that the Burmese government is being extreme... they already control nearly every other aspect of the country, and now they want to control whether their citizens get help or not... it's not as if the officials got caught in the storm.

I don't think that the people deserve to suffer because the government wills it... it almost sounds as if the country is one big concentration camp...

DJM
said

Canada has mobilized the DART team and they are ready to roll. However, they cannot go to Burma without the Burmese Government's permission - permission that (as of last night at least) HAS NOT been received.

From a CTV article last night:

"We have a DART team that is standing by and ready to go into Burma to help try to assess needs there," deputy spokesman Tom Casey said.

"As of this moment, the Burmese government has not given them permission, however, to go into the country. So, that is a barrier to us being able to move forward."


We cannot help if they don't let us.


Jim Sanderson
said

The shot of Burmese soldiers unloading is just a p.r. picture, why the heck are they smiling and away from the rear of the plane where the water is coming from.
The people in this country need help, pictures of the citizens should be plastered all over the net to get world interest and outrage going so help is allowed in.

gilles lebrun
said

Only a foolish country (Canada???) would hand over the US$300,000 that the military junta wants to "distribute itself".

Even in the face of adversity the Generals want to fatten, either, their pockets or, to buy more weapons to subjugate the population.

Go for it, idiot governments. Take the bait!

Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

In Pictures

Cyclone strikes Burma

Cyclone strikes Burma

Take a closer look at the chaos caused by Cyclone Nargis, which tore through Burma.

CTV.ca Map

Burma flooding

Burma flooding

This detailed map shows the path of cyclone Nargis' and subsequent flooding.

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz