CTV News | Burma death toll could be at least 15,000: report

Top Stories -   

Burma death toll could be at least 15,000: report

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News: Robert Fife on the staggering death toll
CTV Newsnet: Charlie Musoka, Canadian Red Cross
CTV Newsnet: World Vision's James East in Bangkok
CTV Newsnet: Sein Win, prime minister of Burma's government-in-exile
Canada AM: Andy McElroy, International Red Cross
Canada AM: Tin Maung, Canadian Friends of Burma
Canada AM: Elliot Tepper, Asian Studies, Carleton University
Canada AM: Robert Yallot, CARE Australia
CTV News: Steve Chao reports on the aftermath

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(31)

CTV.ca News Staff

Date: Mon. May. 5 2008 11:13 PM ET

Officials say a massive cyclone that devastated Burma this weekend may have killed more than 15,000 people, eclipsing earlier estimates and making it the worst natural disaster to hit the country in modern history.

Burmese officials gave the latest death toll number to the Chinese news agency Xinhua. Initial reports had suggested anywhere between 4,000 and 10,000 people had died.

The official death toll has steadily climbed as officials reach isolated areas where Cyclone Nargis struck the hardest.

CNN reports that the last record-breaking natural disaster to devastate Burma came in 1926, when a wind storm killed 2,700 people.

On Monday, criticism is beginning to emerge about the government's reaction to the latest catastrophe.

"The government misled people. They could have warned us about the severity of the coming cyclone so we could be better prepared," said grocery store owner Thin Thin.

UN officials say hundreds of thousands of people in the affected areas need food, clean water and emergency shelter.

On Monday, residents of Yangon, the country's commercial capital, were using candles instead of electricity and lining up to purchase emergency supplies of water.

The country's secretive military junta, which spurned international aid after the 2004 tsunami disaster, told the UN it would accept help this time.

Canadian aid

Canada says it will offer up to $2 million in humanitarian assistance. In a press release, foreign affairs said it would provide cash contributions to Canadian International Development Agency (CIDA) partners in Burma.

The UN said earlier it is prepared to move quickly.

"It is a question of identifying stockpiles of plastic sheeting, of water purification tablets and other items, either within the country or in the region and ensuring they arrive as quickly as possible," Richard Horsey of the UN Office for the Co-ordination of Humanitarian Affairs said Monday in Bangkok, Thailand.

Thai officials announced that their country, which shares a border with Burma, would fly in a planeload of emergency assistance on Tuesday.

But the country appears to be slow to accept an offer of assistance from the U.S. State Department's Disaster Assistance Response Team.

"We have a DART team that is standing by and ready to go into Burma to help try to assess needs there," deputy spokesman Tom Casey said.

"As of this moment, the Burmese government has not given them permission, however, to go into the country. So, that is a barrier to us being able to move forward."

In a media release, Foreign Affairs Minister Maxime Bernier called on Burma's government to "provide full and unhindered access to humanitarian organizations to allow them to assist with the relief efforts."

'Torn to shreds'

"They've never seen a storm like this," World Vision official James East told Newsnet on Monday from Bangkok about the impact of the cyclone on Burma.

"We know the full force has really struck in an area where people are living in homes with thatched roofs and bamboo walls. So we expect the damage to be worse than in Yangon," where the storm toppled huge trees, he said.

"Likely the homes will have been torn to shreds, they would have lost all their dry food, and they likely have injured family members. So they've likely lost everything," East said.

World Vision has been distributing rice and water on the outskirts of Yangon, he said.

Government officials have asked for help such as chainsaw, roofing, medicines, and tarpaulins, he said.

In addition to the damage in the capital, five states -- Yangon, Irrawaddy, Bago, Karen and Mon -- have been declared disaster areas, reported Myaddy television, which is operated by the military.

The military has controlled Myanmar since 1962 and has been blamed for wide-spread human rights abuses and violent crackdowns on pro-democracy activists. Nobel Peace Prize laureate Aung San Suu Kyi has been under house arrest for nearly 12 of the past 18 years.

Former Swedish cabinet minister Jens Orback told reporters in Bangkok that what struck him was the absence of police or soldiers on the streets after the cyclone ended.

"It was private people cleaning up, it was monks out with machetes but no military, no police," he said.

East said in Pakistan, the military played an important role in helping aid efforts after a devastating 2005 earthquake in Kashmir.

"We would be looking to the military in terms of providing assistance and aid (in Burma)," he said.

With files from The Associated Press

Comments are now closed for this story

ken
said

Note to Mr. Harper,
Send relief $$$ to Burma...now!!




skhlgsa
said

The area the cyclone passed through is a rather poor area where many people are farmers and many of those people live in what could be describe as rather fragile structures

The information we have suggests many of these rather fragile structures have been destroyed and more solid structures also have been badly damaged


Janice
said

Pls call your local MP & Red Cross to pressure them to send help to the People of Burma! It is as devastating as Katrina in New Orleans!


Ann
said

For all the human rights abuses of the government of Myanmar. Do you really think for one second any money is going to be helping the people who really need it? I have no problem with food and other supplies being sent but lets face it most countries spend any money they get of foreign aid on guns and everything but relief for the citizens in need.


katie
said

My father is an american teacher at YIEC in Yangoon. His family has no way to get in touch with him beacause the government has still done nothing to restore power. Please encourage our red cross and communities to send relief to the Burmese people. The devastation is as bad as Katrina if not worse.


Kelly Harker
said

My heart is breaking for the people of Myanmar. I've been a strong advocate for a FREE BURMA for a long time now, and upon hearing about the devestation that the cyclone has caused, my hope is that the Junta will allow aid to be distrubted to the people. ALL of these people need our help. We have the resources, and I hope that our governments are compassionate enough to share. I hope the Junta are compassionate enough to let us. I'm urging anyone reading this, please.. please donate to the RED CROSS or AMNESTY INTERNATION, and help make a difference to the disaster relief effort in Myanmar. Open your heart to them, and help.


bernse
said

Remember, Myanmar is an autocratic dictatorship. The federal government can't send any money for the disaster unless they ask for it and even then we need to be sure it is going to where it is needed, not buying arms for the military.


Roger T
said

It is up to the will of the citizens of that country to change the political system NOT up to outside Gov'ts to press for change. The situation will be more dire if our Gov't or other Gov'ts gets involved.

Changes comes internally NOT externally from pressure! Besides, monkey see monkey do and sometimes our Gov't is not doing or behaving at it's best which makes a mockery of themselves to the world.


Tahdah-BC
said

It is not up to Harper or anyone else in our govt to send $$$ - the military junta in Burma must open itself up to aid first. I am sure as soon as things get moving, Canada will certainly help. Thats what we do. But of course there will always be someone to blame it on Harper. Yeeiisshh.


bobby
said

The Red Cross and Amnesia International are notorious for withholding donations meant for the destitute. Just look at what the RC did after 911!

The army in Burma will appropriate much of the cash. If you must donate, give to the Salvation Army. They have an excellent record of distribution to the suffering populace.

And Katrina? Don't make me laugh. Mayor "School bus" Nagin was totally inept, failing to use 500 school buses to evacuate the city when he had the chance - and the Louisiana Governor did not dare run for re-election because she too was helpless in acting BEFORE and during the catastrophe.

Somehow, Mississippi is back to normal after also being devastated by Katrina. Their state government took charge and acted responsibly.


wor
said

At the moment we're still building a full picture but I can certainly say this is a very significant disaster and we are estimating that hundreds of thousands of people have been affected.

worrying.


WW
said

I think it is time that we think about sending the DART (Disaster Assistance Response Team) from the CF. Canada will answer.


ken
said

If the Junta won't accept relief directly from the Canadian government, maybe Canadian aid could be funneled into Burma via organizarions like the UN, Amnesty, Red Cross, etc. This is a humanitarian crisis!


Lart from Above
said

Natural disasters aren't the time to punish people for their country's politics. We can save lives by providing immediate short-term relief through governments and through effective non-governmental organizations.


Linda
said

Everyone is so money generous but is it coming from your pocket or our pockets ? and, is it going to the people who really need it or is it mostly so called administration fees ?
The only thing that those poor people in 'whatever country' gets is promise.


Overthrow the Junta
said

Sending money or the DART team, while noble intentions, are completely useless.

The military junta which controls Burma would not provide any of the relief money to the people who need it. They would also not allow foreign troops into their country.

In 2006, the leader of the junta spent over $50 Million dollars on his daughter's wedding. That is more than 3 times the national health budget.

Last year, the junta outlawed gatherings of more than 5 people when the monks tried to organize peaceful protests against inflation.

Near the border with Thailand, slave labour is used to clear land mines and build roads through the jungles. Countless innocents are killed or maimed to improve the army's ability to slaughter the ethnic groups hiding in the area.

I've spent time in the Karen Free State sharing my knowledge with the Karen who are wishing for the freedoms we take for granted. I learned a lot from them while I was there too.

Unfortunately, the junta is backed by China (which will block any UN actions), and Burma isn't strategic enough to cause the western world to do anything.

It is a tragic situation, but sending money to the junta is the last thing we should do.


M.
said

I understand the administration fees from agencies like UN, but this is the only way to send money for help. We don't have direct access to people on the ground.
Go through World Vision, World Food Program etc.
People are helping each other; sharing food and water but they can't last very long. And those clearing the trees are regular people and monks. I saw one picture of military personel and another with police.
So, where is the military when people need them? I bet they will send in the troops only after the riots/lootings start; emphasizing only the military can stabilize the country.


Paul R
said

Do not send Canadian Taxpayer dollars to Burma, it will just disappear into the hands of the Dictator's who are running that country.
Send material that can not easily be sold by the dictator's and let it be distributed by outside agencies.


Simon
said

For those worried about misuse of funds, The Red Cross is a very reliable and trusted organization. Giving money to them will make sure the aid gets to those who need it most.


Farm Boy
said

You know, this is a terrible tragedy. It's not a case of us just sending money there, we need to send our Canadian Forces Emergence Response Task Force, that specializes in these types of disasters. They can help bring relief of every kind to this grieving part of the world. If we just send money and give it to this dictatorship, they'll use it to fatten themselves and their hold on power, ruthlessly. I already see that there are people on this blog, who are holding Stephen Harper and the conservatives responsible for this disaster. Phalease people, come back to reality would you. Get your head out of politics for just one second and try to be constructive, not destructive.


DC
said

has there been any word on whether or not Canadian Forces will send the "DART" team over there?


Roger T
said

Farm Boy
You know, this is a terrible tragedy. It's not a case of us just sending money there, we need to send our Canadian Forces Emergence Response Task Force.....

No, we need to send more than that....send our foreign reserves, send our own food supplies, send our surplus, send everything we have in store because we our Gov't needs to save face to show the world that we are there for the sake of "KEEPING UP WITH APPEARANCES" WITH TAX PAYERS MONEY!


DMO
said

While I wish Canada and other countries could treat this as they would a disaster in other countries (ie dispatch DART, send aid $$$ etc.), the political realities make that impossible. I've spent time in Myanmar, and the control of the military is even more pervasive than the media suggests. I seriously doubt the junta would use any aid funding the way we intend it.


bobby
said

Meanwhile, Israel will send medical assistance and water sanitation supplies to Myanmar in the coming days to help them cope with the devastating effects of the cyclone.

The list of rich Middle-eastern and South American oil-producing nations is not immediately available for publication.


John Tracey
said

I have been to two Canadian charity websites and neither list Burma in their direction of donations. Is there a Canadian based charity that is accepting donations for this specific crisis?


Farm Boy
said

I'm sure that within the coming days, Canada will send the Canadian Forces DART team to assist in medical, building and to help provide sanitary drinking water. I just wish people would stop being so political about this whole thing and get off of their political high horses and help the people who are in need there. Stop trying to point fingers at Harper or this or that person, just start donating whatever you can, to a reputable organization that will be supplying aid that goes directly to those who are affected. Play the political game all you want, once we've helped these people.


GLENN
said

Hey Ken, they don't need money they need help and supplies, especially for a country that is run by the military after a military coup.


Manzo
said

I know we should send aid, but aid is needed at home with the homeless.
The old saying is help your own before others.


DW
said

Note to Ken

Burma has not yet asked for help. Second you do not give money to a military dictatorship, they will just spend it on weapons to use on there own people.



Mike R
said

If we can send food and supplies with the Canadian Military to protect them, then we should. It's horrible to see people suffering, but giving aid and comfort to a military dictatorship that will confiscate aid to feed and supply their supporters is a fools errand.


Mrs Akela
said

To John Tracey...World Vision Canada is specifically asking for money for Myanmar on their web site.

Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

In Pictures

Burma

Cyclone strikes Burma

Take a closer look at the chaos caused by Cyclone Nargis, which tore through Burma.

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz