CTV News | Special needs kids may be forced into foster care

Health -   

Special needs kids may be forced into foster care

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News: Murray Oliver on a clash over home care
CTV Winnipeg: Caroline Barghout at Norway House

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(21)

ctvwinnipeg.ca

Date: Fri. May. 2 2008 9:26 AM ET

Government infighting has families in a northern Manitoba community in anguish about how to best care for their children.

The Norway House Cree Nation has told the families of children with special needs that they may be forced to give up their children because the First Nation can no longer pay for their care, and federal and provincial governments can't agree on who should pay.

For mother Crystal Hart, it means she may have to say good-bye to her daughter, Priscilla.

"I want her to get the services that she can get," she said while wiping tears from her eyes.

Priscilla Hart has Ritscher-Schinzel Syndrome. She can't speak or eat and needs to be fed through a tube. She requires constant care from a respite worker who looks after Priscilla when her parents go to work.

The Norway House Cree Nation has been paying for those services, which are required by 37 children on the reserve.

However, the band said the money has run out and the services will end May 31.

"Bureaucracy is what you call a nightmare, I guess," said band councillor Mike Muswagon. "Trying to get what you can for your community and for your people."

Muswagon said the First Nation has been fighting for funding from the province and the federal government for years. He said each side argues the other should pay for Status Indian children.

Jordan River Anderson

It's a familiar story. In 2005, the community rallied around another sick child named Jordan River Anderson.

Jordan spent the first part of his life hooked up to machines in a Winnipeg hospital. When he was two years old, doctors were ready to send him to a medical foster home, but for two years provincial and federal government officials argued over who should pay for it. They couldn't even decide who would cover the cost of a special showerhead he needed.

Jordan never left the hospital and eventually died in February, 2005. He was five years old.

In December, Members of Parliament in Ottawa vowed never to let that happen again. They unanimously voted in favour of a private members motion called Jordan's Principle; children should come first when it comes to funding disputes.

On December 12, 2007, Minister of Health Tony Clement wrote this letter of support:

"Indian and Northern Affairs Canada is working closely with Health Canada as well as provincial and First Nations partners to ensure that jurisdictional issues do not impact a child's quality of care. Governments need to work together to see that First Nations and Inuit children have access to the same services available to other children."

Native children 'short-changed'

Charlene Ducharme works with the Kinosao Sipi Minisowin Agency, a social agency on the reserve, and said she has yet to see Jordan's Principle in action. She said the children of Norway House deserve the same care that other Manitoba children get.

"Our premier said Manitoba would be the first one to implement Jordan's Principle... we're still waiting."

In an interview with CTV News, Manitoba Health Minister Keri Irvin Ross said the provincial government is not required to pay for the children's care. "These issues are a federal responsibility," she said. "We need to make sure the federal government is held accountable for it, but we are committed to supporting this community and these children."

But not with any funding. Irvin Ross said the provincial government is offering its support by working with the Norway House Cree Nation in its negotiations with Ottawa. Irvin Ross said the fact that the provincial government is at the negotiating table is "new ground", and is a signal of its support for Jordan's Principle. She said the federal government has yet to respond to numerous letters requesting its involvement in finding a solution.

CTV News contacted Indian and Northern Affairs Canada. In an email, Senior Communications Advisor Patricia Valladao said "I was informed that we've recently met with our partners including the province on this matter, and we're working diligently to respond on an urgent basis. We will be meeting with the First Nation very soon."

Neither the federal or provincial response is very reassuring for the Harts. Little Priscilla's parents said they may quit their jobs to care for her. They said they'll find a way to make it work and keep their family together.

With a report from CTV's Caroline Barghout

Comments are now closed for this story

Christie
said

This is disgusting - the federal and provincial governments are basically breaking up a family rather than acting responsibly, sitting down, and giving these people some answers. This probably wouldn't be happening if this wasn't an Aboriginal family.

Macy
said

The federal and provincial governments need to come together on this!!!!! Each pay half the cost permanently. Simple.

It's high time we stopped treating natives as 2nd class people.

I wonder how well a story like this would go over if it were little white disabled kids being taken away to foster homes. Can you imagine the uproar? (I am white by the way)


Marcy
said

The media needs to bombard the airwaves with this story. Canadians need to know and be constantly reminded. This story needs full coverage and not just ONE blurb in the news for one day.

I have to say one thing about our Government though....when the people in the country get into an uproar the gov't usually fixes whatever it is and then we're happy (Brenda Martin is a good example).

We need to start shouting about this now.



Stephanie
said

The situation with this community is not the first instance of provincial and federal governments abandoning their responsibility to care for citizens in need. Due to privatization and cut backs on social spending, white, middle class families in Ontario, for example, who have children with autism, have been forced to give their children up in order to to secure necessary care. So, this situation is not particular to Aboriginal communities, but is perhaps felt more severely, mainly because these communities are already mistreated by the government and forced to live in Fourth World conditions on reservations. Families are being broken up, parents and children, indeed, entire communities, are being hurt beyond repair. But at least corporate taxes are lower, and the national debt is consistently being reduced. And thank goodness penalties for auto theft have been increased! It would be nice if we could call Canada a nation that puts the health and welfare of its people before the almighty dollar. With a nation as wealthy as ours, we can and need to do so much better. Just add this morally reprehensible and completely preventable crisis to the ever-expanding list of things we need to be ashamed of as a nation.


Pat
said

Natives receive 12 Billion a year from the federal gov't...where does this money go. Natives have received many millions in land claim settlements. Where has all that money gone?? Natives have built many casinos...raking in more millions. Where does that money go. Maybe it's time Natives started looking after themselves...sharing all that wealth with each other...or someone should look into where these billions have gone.


Speak- Up
said

This IS disgusting. Our Federal Government can give meg $$$$ to third world countries but nothing to our own first nations which in many case are living worse then third world countries. Shouldn't we be looking after our own before we open our door ( money bank) to others.


Louise LaBillois
said

Native reserves need special care homes. I know native people who have taken courses and are able to manage homes like these. All they need is the financing to do so.


Evan in Athabasca
said

This has got to stop. I was born into this world with a hard of hearing disability. I have to say that as a child growing up in the 80's I received 'Ok' treatment. My parents struggled to make ends meet when it comes to the major cost of having 2 children that have hearing aids.

This will continue to be a cost out of my own pocket for the rest of my life. It is far more expensive than eye glasses, even if you choose to buy designer frames once a year to keep you 'hip' and looking good. I have heard that people think eyeglasses should get, and do currently get more coverage with private health plans and government assistance than hearing aids. I do not wear hearing aids to look good.

I wish the government would treat those who are born into this world with a disability, with a little more compassion, and help out financially where ever possible.


emv
said

you know no parent should have to feel like this no matter your cree or colour or where in this country we live. I am disgusted with all aspects of the government, they should just keep paying and sort this out without this mother and child suffering more than needed! I think we as a country should rally behind this woman and other families like her. If a country can rally and a government can move to bring someone home from a mexican prision surely we can help a child in Canada!


Bernice
said

I agree with Pat on this one. Millions after millions have been given to Natives and where has this money gone? Why do they live in so called "fourth world conditions" after being given millions every year? Natives wanted their own system of government and that is what they have gotten isn't it? They have special rights that other Canadians do not have. That is the way they wanted it isn't it? Now, again, money has been mismanaged and the Native Community turns to the Federal Government for assistance. The same Government they wanted to be free from it's restrictions, but WILL accept it's financial support. It's just a shame these poor children have to be the unfortunate victims in middle of this centuries' old dispute.


Devon K.
said

"These issues are a federal responsibility, ... We need to make sure the federal government is held accountable for it, but we are committed to supporting this community and these children." - Manitoba Health Minister Keri Irvin Ross

Once again the inmates are running the asylum. The constitution clearly states that these kinds of social services are the responsiblity of the Province not the Federal Government. This is just another example of a cheap provincial government looking to skip out on its constitutionally mandated responsibilities and blame Ottawa for every thing.

Pathetic.


Byron Louis
said

In 1986 my eldest daughter was born with Spina Bifida that required years of surgery and extensive care. Since our daughter was raised on a reserve she wasn't entitled to a host of benefits such as therapy,specialized care and respite that was available off reserve. Since my wife and I were both employed, we were subject to a means test or an income test that said we received over a certain level and weren't entitled to assistance. Yet another child with exactly the health problems as my daughter, with two parents, one a Professional with a PhD and a wife with a Master degree didn't have to write a income test and received all benefits available for their child. One date my wife and I were asked to meet with health care workers from the federal gov't and our own health workers and informed that if we would give our daughter up for foster care off reserve she would be entitled to receive the assistance. All for the sake of conveniencing federal and provincial authorities who were inconvienced by my daughter. You guess our response, but don't take my word demand your own answers you'll be all surprised by the truth and the fabricated lies you've be feed over the years concerning the "Indian Problem.

Byron Louis


Lynn in Hamilton
said

Don't you think it is about time to abolish the reserves and treat everyone as and equal in this country? That way they can attend the same schools that the rest of us attend. Which where I come from in Nova Scotia, they do anyhow. They would then not be labeled the way that they are now and we can live together as one instead of apart. I am all for remembering the past but not living in it. Who would have footed the bill if they did not live in a reserve? Would there even be a question then? Get rid of the reserves and everyone live together as one.




Lorne
said

I would bet that people would be surprised to know that lack of money for services to children with disabilities is not just a Northern Issue but a provincial wide issue. In Northern, Manitoba the problems are compounded by jurisdiction, lack of experienced home care workers, nurses, and medical equipment. A complete overhaul of the Services to children with disabilities is needed because believe it or , this is not mandated in Manitoba so parents with children with disabilities are often left with no choice but to quit there jobs in order to care for their children.


Julia
said

This is like putting a price on a child's life...all those children's lives...is depraved and sick! What is wrong with them people?!


Ali
said

This is a national shame!

Children are thrown into foster care at the drop of a hat rather than spend the time and energy necessary to assist families. Foster care is a catastrophe and should be the LAST resort;children need their parents and siblings not some strangers.

I am so furious at the treatment our Native Peoples receive from government, just because some live in isolated communities doesnt meant they're not entitled to all the rights and priveleges of being Canadian!

My heart goes out to those families and their children. We are all part of this nation!


Sean Calder
said

Devon K. has it right. The main problem is a conflict in jurisdictions as laid out in the constitution. Native Affiars are technically a Federal Responsibility. Health/Social care is technically a Provincial Responsibility.

Take a look through the laws there and tell me who's responsible. I'll bet you can't. It's a mess and subject to "passing the buck" back and forth endlessly.

It's time we re-opened the constitution and made the necessary corrections/ammendments to avoid situations like this in the future.

And, if I remember correctly, there is other legislation that the Federal Government tried to bring though that would have helped in this situation, but was resisted by both the Opposition Parties and the First Nations people.


another mom
said

My son has a medical disability which took 2 years to get in to the clinic which specializes in this, why, because our provincial government (and I live in Alberta) only provides enough funding for these highly trained specialists to work 3 days per week. Now he is on an abundance of "waiting lists". To the province of Manitoba, if the only way these parents can get their children help is to put them in foster care, then they will become a provincial responsibility, then you will be paying. Enough already, I am tired of politicians making issues out of so called "scandals" and demanding inquiries at tax payer expense. I WANT YOU TO PUT THE MONEY WHERE IT WILL ACTUALLY HELP PEOPLES. The so called politicians just paid to bring a woman back from another country and even loaned her the money to pay her fine...yet they can't get off their butts and do whats in the best interests of Canadians??? the more we hear about children's needs being used as a political weapons, the more the people are going to start to revolt. It doesn't matter the political party...they are all the same. How about a government who will do what is right....just because it's the right thing to do?????


Canadian-mom
said

this is awful...Canada just promised $50 million in food help elsewhere, when this is going on here? $50 million could cover the cost of a number of respite care workers, and programmes in the North. Our Government really needs to sort out whats important. The average Canadian Household can manage to put health and education first, why cant the Government? This is one reason why i think we need more women in government. You cant disagree that it is the Mother who tends to a sick child first, gets the kids to school, manage the finances, and keep the place clean. Imagine, if the Country ran as well as the average Canadian Household!


Speak-Up
said

To Pat
Yes some have settled land claims and those nations are doing well. Just like all societies there are those who thrive and those who are forgotten... look at Hazelton and the suicide rate , the frozen children in Saskatchewan these are the forgotten nations; these are the nations that need our help



Carol in NB
said

Utterly despicable...why can't our government put the needs of children and Canadians first. All we get are politicians arguing like 5 year olds in Question Period. And I agree with Canadian Mom...this country would be much better served being run by a woman. Instead of promising $50 million to third world countries, take care of our own first, THEN commit to other countries. Children should not be pawns in anybody's political agenda. And why CAN'T both governments split the bill...50/50...makes complete sense...but then again...we're dealing with politicians.


Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz