CTV News | City mulls over deeming TTC an essential service

Canada -   

City mulls over deeming TTC an essential service

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV Toronto: Naomi Parness with the riders
CTV Toronto: Austin Delaney at the TTC Yard
CTV Toronto: Alicia Kay-Markson on the city's next move

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(19)

ctvtoronto.ca

Date: Mon. Apr. 28 2008 6:28 PM ET

Toronto city council is mulling over declaring the city's public transit system an essential service.

Councillors are reacting to the public's outrage over the weekend when workers with the TTC abruptly walked off the job Friday night, leaving people stranded.

The striking staff was mandated back to work Sunday afternoon after the Ontario legislature sat down in a rare Sunday session to pass the back-to-work legislation.

On Tuesday, a motion will be tabled at Toronto's City Council asking for the TTC to be declared an essential service. The move would effectively end the union's right to strike.

Toronto Mayor David Miller is expected to recommend the matter be discussed by the executive committee before returning to city council for debate.

Critics are concerned that the designation could end up costing the city millions of dollars. Traditionally, essential service workers receive a richer contract than non-essential workers.

"Until Ottawa and Queen's Park come back and offer an operating subsidy an essential service status would bankrupt the city," said city councillor Adam Vaughan. "I'm prepared to look at it but Ottawa and Queen's Park have to respond to the understanding that it's an essential service."

TTC Chair and city councillor Adam Giambrone said he is weighing the pros and cons.

"I have not supported this in the past because of the costs," he said. "Clearly people feel very strongly about this and I have an obligation as the chair of the TTC to get my head around the issue to understand the pros and cons and that's what I'll be doing over the next couple of weeks."

Miller was incensed because the union had indicated it would give 48 hours notice before any strike. The public was given a little more than an hour's notice before workers walked off the job at midnight Friday. 

The union said the abrupt notice was to shield workers from irate commuters.

Bob Kinnear, head of the Amalgamated Transit Union Local 113, did not speak to the media throughout the weekend but on Monday morning he told CTV Toronto that he would not apologize for keeping his members safe.

"I'm not going to apologize for ensuring members had a safe withdrawal of service and I'm not going to apologize for making sure members were not verbally abused or worse, beaten," he said in a telephone interview.

Kinnear said he does sympathize with the people who found themselves without a way home.

"My own daughter was stranded," he said. "She didn't know what was going on so I do sympathize with the public and I regret it happened."

About 1.5 million people ride the TTC each day.

The rejected deal

On April 20, the union and city announced a deal. One day earlier Kinnear had warned Torontonians to prepare for a strike.

The TTC ratified the three-year deal, and the union's leadership recommended the membership vote in favour of accepting the offer.

But late Friday night, the union voted 65 per cent against accepting the deal. The union -- which represents operators, mechanics and maintenance workers -- has 8,900 members. It isn't clear how many voted.

The rejection fuelled speculation of infighting among the union's members. Kinnear said there are some issues that need to be dealt with by union members but Kinnear said he's confident he has the support of his colleagues and won't be resigning.

"Absolutely not," he said.

Kinnear spent Monday in meetings with legal counsel preparing for upcoming negotiations. An arbitrator has been chosen and now the two sides have 90 days to reach an agreement.

Miller said Sunday that negotiations now go back to square one. The two sides have agreed on an arbitrator.

Here is some of what the parties agreed to in the now-dead agreement:

  • Term: three years, expiring March 31, 2011 Wages: April 1, 2008 -- 3 per cent; April 1, 2009 -- 3 per cent; April 1, 2010 -- 3 per cent
  • Vision Care: $300 every two years; plus $50 for exams
  • Dental Care: major restorative, including implants up to $2,500
  • Orthodontic: up to $4,000 (50 per cent TTC coverage)
  • Physio & Chiro: $1,000 max ($35 per visit)
  • Long-term Disability: $2,550 max, per month

Some conservatives on city council attacked the original deal for being too rich, although Miller insisted it was affordable. The Progressive Conservatives insisted the back-to-work bill include language that said any arbitrated settlement reflect the city's ability to pay.

Calm commuters

Toronto's public transit system ran smoothly throughout Monday, much to the relief of commuters.

When passing the legislation on Sunday, Ontario Premier Dalton McGuinty urged Torontonians to show TTC workers courtesy and respect when they returned on the job.

Commuters riding the TTC Monday said they're remaining calm but it's hard to forgive the weekend's events.

"Notice would have been nice for the people who were stranded on the weekend," said one woman.

"I understand there was a danger to the employees and there is no reason for the public to be rude to employees but they put a lot of people in danger," one man said.

"I'm just glad it's over," he said.

TTC drivers for their part said they were happy to be back on the job.

"People are good people and Torontonians are the best....just like the TTC," said one bus driver breaking into a smile.

With reports from CTV Toronto correspondents Naomi Parness, Galit Solomon and Alicia Kay-Markson

Please Add Comments( )

rgjk
said
0 0

We're hearing the drivers were fairly satisfied


Roger T
said
0 0

The transit commission should fork out repayments for ALL the people who paid for their metropasses. They can't just stop working and expect riders to tolerate paid miss trips on the travellers expense. The TTC workers as for more money yet thinking that when they disrupt services somehow they will get what they want when infact they owe travellers the pre-paid money on the metro pass. For those TTC workers who don't think it's fair, if you are not happy with your job with the TTC, find a new one will the limited skills you have and stop complaining. If you wish to strike and disrupt service - which is fine - but you need to reimburst travellers who pre-paid for their metropass.


Sunny
said
0 0

The TTC Union did not give the 48 hours as promised. It was more like 1.5 hours...

Given that the vote was 65% against based on rumours of contracting out. The mechanincs and maintenance workers will have to clarify what they fear given that their work entails less interaction with customers compared to vehicle operators.

The ATU 113 will pay for their actions when the TTC and the general transit system is declared essential as it has been in Montreal and New York...


Donald
said
0 0

It's time to privatize the TTC.

And, even if that doesn't happen right away, methinks Bob Kinnear is looking for a new job.


Jared
said
0 0

Which governmet department should I send my taxi receipts too, for Saturday's TTC strike? I pay my taxes I want my money back.


Roch
said
0 0

The union members voted down the lucrative offer, since they wanted more.

Unionists greed is directly related to the amount of damage they can inflict upon others.


Shamaro
said
0 0

I am tired of these unions who are funded by the taxpayers and their riders always holding us hostage to their demands. These unions are a major cause why cities like Toronto are in a financial mess. It's time that these unions begin to realize that the taxpayer is not a bottomless pit of cash and that public transit is an essential service. Millions of people depend on this service to get them to and from work every single day, many more, this is their only means of transportation and if the TTC would of continue to have been on strike, the city roads would of been so congested, that emergency services would not have been able to get to their calls. It is time that Mayor Miller and the city council deem Toronto's public transportation a essential service. In regards to all of this, maybe Toronto should start hiring people on Contract like many other municipalites like Viva in York Region.


consumer
said
0 0

It is nice to know that the TTC is up and runnng, but when it comes to high gas prices, How is the Government going to help us in the North where there is no Transit system?


MP.
said
0 0

Federal Government and Toronto Ridership: 1, TTC Union: 0.


Markus
said
0 0

Any sympathy the TTC Union would have garnered from the public has, I feel, been irrevocably lost. If they had given 48 hours notice, yes, we would still have been inconvenienced but alternative travel plans could have been made, but it's not possibly for many to do this at such short notice.

I do feel a little sympathy for the drivers, who are open, literally, to possibility attacks by angered members of the public due to the strike. One could argue that their safety has been compromised by the strike, and someone needs to be held accountable for that.


E. Gardiner
said
0 0

An open letter to Bob Kinnear,
Mr. Kinnear, I would like to congratulate on a great job. You single handedly made OUR employees look like greedy cry babies. I ride the TTC everyday and most of the interaction that I have had with OUR employees have been very positive. TTC employee's do occasionally encounter abuse by riders and that is wrong. Your decision Friday evening, put thousands of Toronto citizen's safety in jeopardy. The citizens of Toronto employ you and the members of your union. I would like to take this opportunity to denounce any abuse that TTC employees endure. Having said that I would also like to congratulate you on making your hard working employee's look like spoiled brats, which they are not. Being someone that depends on the TTC daily I have watched carefully the contract negotiations over the last two weeks. Hang your tail between your legs Mr. Kinnear. You have made yourself look like a self gratifying, blithering idiot who does not deserve to represent OUR employees. Not only did your actions threaten the safety of our citizens but it also compromised the environment and our economy. Shame on you. I would appreciate a reply and a public apology for this arbitrary decision to hold an entire city hostage.
Sincerely,
-E. Gardiner



Political hyppocrisy VS the right to negotiate?
said
0 0

I have a problem with this scenario. Do you think the McGuinty 'Clothesline Banditos' would step in if Ottawa Transpo was on strike? I highly doubt it which suggests that Toronto gets the grease and to hell with CBA's. All politics to stay in power at any cost. Sickening.


James
said
0 0

"Oh look more money for transit/TTC at budget hearings from past. Let's get as much of that money into our salary and benfits and little into repairs/upgrades in systems and complain later why buses break down cause no $$ from goverments".

When TTC gets increase, teachers get increase(teachers pension fund) and municiapal workers get increase our taxes go through the roof.

Meanwhile us whitecollar workers lose pay and jobs but still have to pay those tax increases

Unions are putting manufacturing out of buisness in North America and gonna put cities bankrupt.


Where has common sense gone?
said
0 0

Roch: "Unionists greed is directly related to the amount of damage they can inflict upon others".


Is that "greed" any different than what speculators are doing to the price of oil and how governments go along with it because they too enrich their coffers all at the expense of we the taxpayers. If we had any guts in Canada we would revolt and hold our politicians accountable which we don't (ie last Ontario election, putting #1 promise breaker back in power).


Leadership needed
said
0 0

Shamaro: "These unions are a major cause why cities like Toronto are in a financial mess".

No, Shamaro, the unions arent the cause it is politicians who will not say NO to them. If we had leaders for politicians we would solve our problems quickly but unfortunately we have wimps who have one eye on the polls and one eye on the problems instead of both eyes straight ahead dealing forthrightly with the issues in an intelligent manner. Instead political compromise screws it up every time. Not the unions.


Gerald Skowronski
said
0 0

Union leaders and their sheep knuckled under to the pressure of back-to-work legislation. If they truly believed in their position they would have stayed on strike, stood up for what they believe and stayed home. So much for showing just how strong and right the union mentality is.


Madashell
said
0 0

"Donald
It's time to privatize the TTC."
I agree entirely! In the UK they did just that, Sure there were problems at first but now the Transit system is awesome and VERY reliable.
PRIVATIZE!!!!!! NOW!


Rob
said
0 0

Anytime a Union votes against a deal it often is a vote against the Head of the Union as well, is it not? The head of the Union accepted the agreement and the Union members voted it down as far as I can see. Please correct me if I am wrong. Maybe we will see a change in management at the Union.
Just my though. Cheers


Lynn
said
0 0

ok everyone, lets do the math on this one.Metropass is $109 a month divided by 30 days is $3.63 a day. Divide that again by 24 would be $0.15 per hour. They were off the job for approx 36 hours. That would make the refund $5.45. Come on, and you say that the TTC workers are greedy.


Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz

Most Talked about Stories

The chance of the destruction of our planet is very very small with this collider, but who are these people to decide what risks are acceptable for all of mankind? It puts me at unease and adds to my anxiety. CERN acknowledges that there are miniscule risks -- they admit to it so please spare the convoluted retorts.

kc-bby

Hadron Collider back in action after year of repairs