CTV News | Re-opening NAFTA would benefit Canada: Harper

Top Stories -   

Re-opening NAFTA would benefit Canada: Harper

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News: Robert Fife covers Harper's trump card
CTV Newsnet: Charles Doran, Johns Hopkins Univ.
CTV Newsnet: U.S. President Bush speaks during the press conference in New Orleans
CTV Newsnet: Calderon and Harper speak during the press conference in New Orleans

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(25)

CTV.ca News Staff

Date: Tue. Apr. 22 2008 9:46 PM ET

Prime Minister Stephen Harper said Tuesday that re-opening NAFTA would actually help the Canadian economy, because Canada is the biggest supplier of oil and gas to the United States.

"That is of critical importance to the future of the United States, and if we had to look at this kind of option I think that would put us in an even stronger position than we were 20 years ago," Harper said at the North American Leaders' Summit in New Orleans.

But he added that his preference "is not to renegotiate what we discussed in the past, and to talk about the future."

The North American Free Trade Agreement helps generate roughly $1 trillion in annual trade between Canada, the United States and Mexico.

Harper, at a joint press conference with U.S. President George Bush and Mexican President Felipe Calderon, said that NAFTA was a major issue at the summit.

"We discussed the importance of co-operation on security and trade and the benefits that NAFTA has produced for each of our three countries over the last 14 years," he told reporters.

"We agreed that continuing to improve and expand trade is the key to greater prosperity for our peoples and we are putting special emphasis on the Detroit-Windsor crossing."

Both Bush and Calderon also expressed a preference for not re-negotiating NAFTA.

Bush also addressed criticisms of NAFTA from Democratic presidential candidates Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama.

"Now is not the time to renegotiate NAFTA or walk away from NAFTA," he said.

Harper said "North American co-operation" is the "best option to create jobs and to compete effectively with emerging trading blocks elsewhere in the world."

However, he said he was concerned about the "thickening of the Canada-U.S. border" that hinders the movement of people and goods.

The North American Leaders' Summit is the fourth such meeting between North America's most prominent leaders.

The Security and Prosperity Partnership between the three countries was specifically designed to increase efficiencies within NAFTA.

Comments are now closed for this story

Scott
said

Way to go Steve! Good show for Canada. Very professional and patriotic way to look at things. Excellent representation.


Shamaro
said

I agree, NAFTA is good for all three countries....to a degree. I think that somewhere down the road, we are going to have to renegotiate this agreement, however it is also my opinion that if this is to happen, that our water supply should be kept out of the agreement, and our oil should remain ours and the US should pay us what the each barrel of oil acutally sells for. Also, for continental security, I think it is important if Canada and the US want to keep the border open and allow the free movement of products and people, then the two of us are going to have to work out some sort of arrangement where it'snot just our own seperate borders we are operating, but the continent as a whole. A joint operation where our immigration and security policies see eye to eye, but that maynot happen for sometime, however it is something that I'm sure is being seriously looked at right now. As for Ontario, I don't think that with Manfucturing leaving in such large numbers to Mexico is anything we should be proud of when it comes to free trade. Ontario seriously needs to start looking into industry in which we can actually compete in on a global level. We can't manufacture goods with the labour costs the way they are.


Tony
said

It's seems very nice but Canada must realize the inevitable truth so it can compete within this trilateral trading block: "He who controls the water controls the world!"


GM
said

Since the trade agreements have been signed, trade with the US has doubled and trade with Mexico has increased five times.

There will be individual winners and losers in trade agreements but collectively Canada will be stronger.

We simply cannot bury our heads in the sand and ignore the globalization of trade.

Nationalism and isolationism applied to trade policy is a fool's paradise.

James
said

Well, I hope Steve enjoyed this last meeting with George because it is going to get very interesting when he meets with either Hilary or Barack after Jan/09. The course that both of the Democratic challengers are taking will put them on a collision course with Steve on a number of issues, namely NAFTA. I believe what we will see is a contraction away from more open trading and more protectionist policies from a Democratic president. After all, the president must be elected and then re-elected. He/she cannot do this if the economy of the United States is in trouble and well paying jobs have and are disappearing. Where will that leave Steve and Felipe. Worried to death that a Democratic president will want to renogiate NAFTA to the detriment of Canada and Mexico. Better bask in the glow of George as long as you can Steve cause a liberal Democratic shadow is about to block out your sun.


Mike
said

Steve better protect our sovereignty. I fear the indroduction of the Amero.

Kevin Aubie
said

Sorry Tony, but I have a feeling we'll end up controlling our water about as much as we control our oil. As long as there are crooked short-sighted people like Harper and Stelmach in power, we'll simply be a storehouse for America. They'll probably get all the water just like they get all the oil. As for Scott's comment, I can't imagine anyone being so enthusiastic about such a non-leader as Stephen Harper. You must love Bush too.

Jim in the West
said

Tony:

Take a quick step back and listen for the pop...

Controling the water is a double-edged sword. If we exert too much control, we may motivate those with more muscle to come and take it. Same with the oil.

I, for one, am more worried about protecting the water than trying to control it.

I AM CANADIAN :-)
said

I like the way Harper will speak in both English and French at these functions and subtly remind everyone of Canada's unique identity.

Michele
said

Security plans for Canada should include NOT following US foreign policy. That would be a major step for a more secure Canada.

What kind of jobs is this "North American co-operation" supposed to create? Call centers?

I don't see how NAFTA can protect against "emerging trading blocks elsewhere in the world"
when our NAFTA partners are having trade blocks elsewhere.

I for one don't think a "put all your eggs in one basket" mentality is good. Look at the concerns floating around regarding a US recession and the effect it will have on Canada.
By having more trade with them would only exasperate the problem, I would think.

I am very uneasy with the military integration happening under the SPP agreement.

Jill
said

With the billions we do in trade, Nafta isn't going anywhere.Despite what Obama and Hillary are saying to get elected.Once they are in, they won't care where apples come from.

Doug BC
said

This conference is about political optics.I doubt there were many serious discussions at all.Maybe a chat about direction,but not much more.
The USA's border issue with Mexico has almost no chance of being resolved any time soon.And the border with Canada,while a bit more difficult,is still manageable.
I tend to lean towards a favourable view of NATFA.But there are still concerns.I see and exporting of good paying jobs from both Canada,and the USA to cheap labour countries.If Americans and Canadians are to reverse the decline in living standards here,we are going to have to find ways to deal with that.Either that,or find political leaders with the courage to tell us the truth.
I have plenty of issues with the USA,but have to concede,that I have more trust in them than I do in Mexico.
I expect the Canada and the USA are either going to swim together or sink together.North American values,living standards,and cultures are under attack.In the USA,mostly by Mexico.In Canada,more by Asia.
Agreements like these are going to have to recognize that.At this time,I don't think they do that very well.


Jim
said

This Prime Minister makes us proud!

Allan Eizinas
said

When things are really getting hot at home and there are no answers that would satisfy the latest scandal then the best thing to do is to get out of town and get a few positive photo shots.

This discussion of NAFTA and photo op of Stephen Harper with the lame duck President Bush and the insignificant Calderon is supposed to take the focus off the current RCMP supported Elections Canada investigation, the Cadman affair, the Mulroney fiasco, the Afghanistan quagmire, the Hillier resignation, the Bernier bonehead bonanza, the Income Trust turnaround, the ...

I really do not think that it will work to get the serious Canadian taxpayer to focus off the important issues!



Sean
said

Of course Steve is perfectly fine with not revisiting NAFTA to protect Canada's water and other natural resources.

He'll do/say whatever makes Bush happy, and because the Dem candidates are talking about it right now, Bush demanded Steve and the Mexican Prez praise it.


truthseeker
said

PM Harper,
Please ensure Canada doesn't join a North American Union. Like many have said please protect our sovereignty, and ensure our future generations will continue to have a great country to live. Quality of life in Canada went down substantially while the Liberals were in power and it will take a while to fix their mistakes. Canada needs loyalty and integrity more then ever.


Little Caesar
said

I am not worried at all about the development of empire. While Roman soldiers were out conquering everyone and killing anyone who got in the way, Jesus Christ was walking on water. He could have broken Caesar into tiny little pieces if He had wanted to but didn't do anything wrong or hurtful to him or anyone else. Mighty Rome could not stop the Gospel and neither can the E.U. or the North American Union.


OwenT
said

I am 62 years old and have never been prouder of a Canadian Prime Minister. He speaks clearly, intelligently, diplomatically and backs up from no one, including George Bush. I believe that Canada must be firm but cooperative in the event the U.S. wants to re-negotiate NAFTA, especially concerning our natural resources. I too see Asia as a major issue for Canada's economy


The Green Hero
said

Yes, but did anyone else listen as Bush chuckled out loud when the PM mentioned Canada's energy position over the U.S. vis-a-vis NAFTA and how this country will be in an even stronger position in the coming years?


JP
said

Yeah YEah - dont forget its the Conseratives who force NAFTA on use to start with- The Conservatives alwasy do what they are told by the US - a Puppet


Tyler
said

Prime Minister Harper continues to impress on the world stage. His sincerity and statesmaship have placed him as a well respected world leader and that's good for Canada.


Joanna Mitchell
said

NAFTA benefits big business more than any one government, group or person. Chapter 11 outlines corporate investment rights and protections that are unprecedented in scope and power. Its caused a great deal of issues for countries where environmental protections have to be undertaken at the risk of damaging foreign investment firms. This has led to litigation between companies in all three countries and the environmental protection branches of their governments. In some cases, the governments lose to the companies' vast legal resources and the companies can continue to poison foreign soil against the will of the people that live there in addition to being awarded large sums of their taxpayer dollars for damages. NAFTA has made it easier than ever for us to dump our trash in Mexico and guess what? We can even sue them when they try to stop us. Hey, we're just trying to protect our investments. Its good for our economy.


Carolynn
said

Obama was caught lying about reopening NAFTA, after he said one thing in public and another to our embassy in Washington.
The question is should the beaurcrats their kept quiet and helped Obama perpatrate a lie to win power. Is it ok to lie depending if you support the Candidate. Then again Hillary Clinton was caught lying about landing under sniper fire and she got caught and was also exposed. Thats a lot of lies for one party to deal with and it is only helping th other party.


Brent
said

It's freaky. They are just too close.

Harper plays tough in the Arctic but it is just a show. At the end of the day, we have lost so much of our international independence since the Conservatives took power. We may appear to have more political might but we certainly bend to our U.S. masters. The pride that Pearson and Trudeau built for free-thinking Canadians is certainly evaporating quickly.


Mike
said

Hey Hillary and Barack, bring on the NAFTA renegotiations. Canada will happily renegotiate (and by that I mean "eliminate") the Chapter of NAFTA that forces us to perpetually export a constant percentage of our oil and gas to America. There are plenty of other countries who will pay a hefty price for our oil (China, India) and we'll happily sell to the highest bidder. Careful what you wish for, you liberal socialist Democrats. You might just get it. :)


Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz

Most Talked about Stories

The chance of the destruction of our planet is very very small with this collider, but who are these people to decide what risks are acceptable for all of mankind? It puts me at unease and adds to my anxiety. CERN acknowledges that there are miniscule risks -- they admit to it so please spare the convoluted retorts.

kc-bby

Hadron Collider back in action after year of repairs