News Sections
Hillier to step down as Canada's top general
CTV News Video
Watch: See all Videos in the Player
Font-size:
Share
Print
Comments(184)
CTV.ca News Staff
Date: Tue. Apr. 15 2008 9:25 PM ET
Gen. Rick Hillier says support for the Canadian Forces "has never been higher," as the popular -- and controversial -- chief of defence staff prepares to resign on July 1.
"I really did focus a lot on ensuring the men and women who wear our nation's uniform, and their families, had the support of Canadians from coast to coast to coast, in all the missions they choose to do," Hillier said at a press conference Tuesday.
In a letter to the Canadian Forces, Hillier wrote that he had set himself the task of creating the right conditions for soldiers to succeed "in defence of Canada, Canadians, and Canadian interests and values.
"We have achieved those key objectives, and reached the critical milestones I originally set out for us to reach by the end of my time as CDS. We have moulded our culture to one which recognizes that operations are our raison d'être; that our efforts, all of them, must concentrate on achieving the missions and tasks given to us by the Government of Canada, on behalf of all Canadians."
CTV's Ottawa Bureau Chief Robert Fife told Newsnet that Hillier's resignation is not related to any policy disagreement or other troubles with the government.
"After three years in one of the most intense jobs in the country in the middle of a conflict in Afghanistan, (people) would probably appreciate that he wants to get his life back," retired Col. Mike Capstick told Newsnet about Hillier.
There appear to be four possible contenders to replace Hiller after his resignation:
- Lt.-Gen. Andrew Leslie, head of the army;
- Vice-Admiral Drew Robertson, head of the navy;
- Lt.-Gen. Walter Natynczyk, vice-chief of defence staff; and,
- Lt.-Gen. Michel Gauthier, chief of the Forces overseas deployments.
In the House of Commons during question period, Prime Minister Stephen Harper praised Hillier.
"He is a great Canadian and we are very proud to have worked with him,'' Harper said.
NDP Leader Jack Layton, who strongly opposes the current mission in Afghanistan, said: "Here's someone who has given many years of service to our country.
"We always have to be thankful that people are willing to do these kinds of difficult jobs and when they decide to move on and take their retirement, I think all Canadians would want to wish the general well and certainly I would add my name to that list of Canadians.''
CTV News reported in October 2007 that Hillier, who has been in the military for 36 years, would be replaced when his three-year term expired in February.
Chiefs of defence staff normally serve a three-year term, but that isn't fixed. Defence commentators said at the time that they thought Hillier would welcome an extension or renewal.
The Liberal government of then-prime minister Paul Martin appointed Hillier, born in Newfoundland in 1955, as chief of defence staff in January 2005.
In his inaugural speech, Hillier called for more money for the Forces, which carried a significant burden of spending cutbacks as the federal government tried to bring chronic deficit spending under control in the 1990s.
Hillier also envisioned a new role for the Canadian military in the 21st century, a more nimble force capable of responding to the emerging threats of terrorism and natural disasters.
A strategic thinker with field experience -- he served as the senior NATO officer in Afghanistan before being named CDS) -- Hillier is also revered by the troops, particularly the army.
"I've been in Afghanistan twice with (Hillier), and it's just overwhelming to see how these young men and women admire this general," Fife said.
"We haven't seen a general like this, at least in my lifetime, who has inspired so much from his troops and is so popular with the Canadian public."
One reason for that is when Hillier is on a visit, he would rather talk to his soldiers than be seen with the prime minister or other top politicians, he said.
Under both the Liberals and Conservatives, the Armed Forces have seen an increase in its budget, so Hillier will leave a solid base for his successor, Fife said.
Surprising
Scott Taylor, publisher of Esprit de Corps magazine, told CTV.ca that he found Hillier's departure at this time surprising.
"He's in the middle of a massive transformation of the Armed Forces, and their own internal reports say it's being held together basically by the personality of the CDS himself. It's his idea, his plan."
The Afghan mission has been extended to 2011 and many of the many procurement projects meant to upgrade the Forces are in their infancy, Taylor said.
Any successor would be coming in at a very challenging time, he said.
Most generals retire at 55, but Hillier is only 52. He also spends 75 to 90 minutes per day working out in the gym, Taylor said. "I saw that as an indicator he was planning to stick around."
There are usually plenty of people with daggers out for leaders, but people around Hillier were loyal to him, he said.
Hillier did cross swords with former defence minister Gordon O'Connor, who was eventually replaced by Peter MacKay in an August 2007 cabinet shuffle.
And last fall, Hillier appeared to contradict Prime Minister Stephen Harper. The general said Canadian troops could be in Afghanistan for 10 years -- after Harper said the mission could be accomplished by 2011.
That triggered rumours Hillier would be fired. Hillier then said he was on the "same sheet of paper" as the prime minister about the mission.
Fife said there were elements in the Prime Minister's Office who didn't like Hillier, but he didn't know if that extended to Harper.
In terms of replacing Hillier, Taylor suggested Lt.-Gen. Michel Gauthier, the commander of the Canadian Expeditionary Force Command, would be the least disruptive pick.
If the government names someone from the air force or navy, there's a chance some of the transformation could be rolled back as those services have diminished in importance, he said.
Capstick said the current heads of the army, navy and air force could all be considered candidates along with a few others.
"Nobody can replicate Gen. Hillier's personality, but they're all good, solid operators," he said.
User Tools
Related Stories
CTV.ca Special
User Tools
About the tools
Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.
-


Font-size
Print Article
Comments(184)-
Feedback
Share it with your network of friends
Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.
Most Viewed News Stories
Most Talked about Stories
This is a moral test for voters in the municipal election. Electing him will be a stamp of approval for his actions. I strongly believe that the first thoughts should be for the person he has publicly humiliated, his partner. By his conduct he has made of himself, merely, a footnote in the election.



Comments are now closed for this story
Dave
said
Say it ain't so, Rick!
David BC
said
Robert C. Cross
said
David in Petawawa
said
19 year serving member
said
JABC
said
IAN
said
John
said
Craig
said
James
said
a Canadian Soldier
said
It has been a pleasure to serve in the Canadian Forces that General Hillier has transformed.
Thank you for your leadership and guidance - all the best, Sir!
MDT
said
Chris
said
Soldier
said
Hate to see you go Sir.
Lorne
said
YEB
said
A C Simmons
said
Jackie from Ottawa
said
Andrew McFarlane
said
Andrew McFarlane
A Soldiers Dad
Bill
said
someonewhocares
said
David
said
Sailor
said
BCM
said
Marty Mack
said
Asif
said
Continued success to you sir :)
Jackie and proud to serve
said
Kara Stewart
said
PK
said
Shamaro
said
Rob
said
DW
said
He will be missed, thank you sir for a great job
A Soldier's Wife
said
Jerry Elliott
said
Bill Newcombe
said
In Kingston
said
Ed. Anderson
said
Ricky Hurley
said
Military wife in Edmonton
said
Ernie
said
D Smith
said
Still Serving in Spite of Him
said
Good - he's going. Bad - not till July.
Maybe now the Gov't & DND can get out of this single-minded Afghanistan racket and get out from under the guiding hand of the WWW - (George) W's Washington Warmongers.
An LCIS MCpl
said
I hope the next CDS will be as strong and encouraging to us as you have been. I hope the next CDS has the passion and care for us as you have demonstrated on so many levels during your term of service. Thank you, Sir from the bottom of my heart.
Lesley
said
From someone who respects the work of the mission, but not the war!!!!
Nick Starr
said
Sheldon in NS
said
JohnT
said
ance
said
I think Rick Hillier was one of the only people that was telling us the truth... that's why he was not always popular with his political masters.
GJ Miller
said
wounded guy
said
I'd put my uniform back on and go back into combat if he stayed on!
Strathcona's wife
said
FoolMeOnce
said
Thank you
Bob R.
said
General in what ever you choose to do now good luck and good hunting.
Gary
said
I am totally flabbergasted by the support this gentlemen enjoyed from the rank and file.
But then again for reasons never clearly understood even Mulroney enjoyed unprecedented
support at one time.
His quitting is none too soon. With all due respect to his fan club this gentleman was promoted
beyond his competence. His less than cerebral description and understanding of the enemy and
his swallowing all the Bush and Cheney pretexts for the illegal occupation as very disturbing.
Saddened soldier
said
A. Duchemin
said
This is a very sad news for all military members, especially for soldiers in Afghanistan. We are losing the best leader ever!
You'll be missed!
Miriam
said
Serving CF
said
indy
said
kj
said
A true leader. A true soldier and protector of our Canadian rights.
I know you will be missed.
Ez
said
I know this because I have had the pleasure of serving with Rick on one of his many visits to Afghanistan.
It is sad to see you go Rick and may God bless you as per normal.
Colonel Blimp
said
Wes
said
Corrine
said
Marc Chenier
said
Cheryl
said
You came
You saw
left everyone and everything snafu'd
and then you left.
Must be a proud feeling.
Good riddance.
Hopefully we'll get a competent General next time.
(bet this won't make the comments list)
Greg
said
Kev
said
Wayne
said
Kevin D. Arey
said
Lance Usher
said
Farewell Sir, and godspeed
Sapper
said
Krista Byne
said
37 years & counting
said
C10
said
He is my boss,the CF's boss, he doesn't report to the Country, but only to the Defence Minister.
Sir, thank you for your excellent leadership and determination to fix the CF and make it what it is today. Airaghardt, sir and good luck.
Fixhist, Toronto
said
In simple solder motto,you jut step aside if you are overpassed in your ability or jurisdiction.
There is fine line of balance between interests of State and Political government.
Gen. Rick Hillier is a true statesman time will tell.
Allan
said
Tori
said
When he speaks people listen, not because he commands it but because his troops are drawn to him. He is trusted and loved. He is respected because he has earned it. Hillier is a soldier's soldier and one that leads by doing.
I would not want to be the PM or Defence Minister now, having to find a replacement is going to be difficult. We don't need a puppet, we need a CDS like Hillier who believes in the uniform, believes in his troops and believes he has the best job in the world and does it amazingly well.
Kudos Gen Hillier, you will be missed by not only the soldiers but the families who have come to respect your drive to improve our lives.
Stephan
said
I agree with other comments - expect to see this man involved in politics. Or should I say CONTINUE to see him involved in politics?
Airman
said
Gary
said
Gil
said
James
said
Respect aside, I am tremendously disappointed to see him leave at this time. His military reforms are finished yet, and while the tide is turning in Afganistan, it hasn't turned yet. I would like to have seen see those through.
T Boyle
said
Lart from Above
said
He would be obliged to step down if he felt that he could serve his country better in Parliament. Wonder which party he'd stand with? If he had a good relationship with his current chain of command, he'd have no need to quit now.
VRI
said
Sir, you have given us every chance to do what had to be done and honoured your promise to put your men above yourself. Thank you.
RCR Soldier
said
Best of luck.
PRO PATRIA
Steve Daly C.D.
said
Good Luck in your future endeavours Sir. I'm sure we haven't seen the last of "The Big Cod".
To the naysayers: Your ignorance and lack of understanding are overwhelming. General Hillier is the least political CDS in modern memory. Why else do you think that you heard so little about any of the others? They were so busy covering their own backsides politically instead of being the strong advocate for the CF that the job demands.
Mrs. Young
said
Gary Ridgewell
said
Sir, you were an inspiration to many. Best wishes to you and your family.
Joe MacPherson
said
David fm NS
said
Good luck in all your future endeavours Sir, you will be missed.
CDN SOLDIER
said
AUDAX ET CELER
BOLD AND SWTIFT)
Bev Andersen
said
D.S.
said
JJ
said
A. Norton, WO, CD (ret'd)
said
I had the benefit of attending a “red rally” at CFB Gagetown for those troops that were preparing for a tour of Afghanistan. Gen Hillier was there and received two standing ovations – one as he was introduced and a second as he finished his speech. Although on a tight schedule Gen Hillier not only took the time to talk to the troops and their families but he ensured that those who wanted to have their pictures with him got the opportunity to do so.
I salute you Gen Hillier!
A. Norton, WO, CD (ret'd)
Still Serving
said
merl
said
Adrian Telizyn
said
We had raincoats that would not keep out the water, and horrid plastic magazines that would not hold bullets and feed them into our C7 rifles.
Our leadership was composed of spineless bureaucratic generals who would not stand up for us. Lewis Mackenzie and Romeo Dallaire were shining exceptions to this rule, however.
I wish I could have served under Gen Hillier today. This will be Canada's loss.
Sir, I would STILL follow you over the top into battle any day. Just issue the warning order.
Pro Patria
ex 4RCR MCpl.
FCS
said
You came
You saw
left everyone and everything snafu'd
and then you left."
Nice to hear from the admin. clerks.
I was in the forces through the 90's ands I'm just wondering what excatly this guy snafu'd? The forces were a shambles under the Liberals and previous CDS' so what excatly is that opinion based on , other than ignorance?
Retired Corporal
said
To all the Naysayers, most of you have only been armchair soldiers at best. I wish that most of you would have served your country under a such a Great Officer that served his country faithfully and Honourably. He truly is a remarkable Canadian.
the Padre
said
bunny
said
Dale
said
Chuk
said
Its been a pleasure serving with you, from Petawawa, Bosnia, and, Afghanistan. Hate to see you go.
Best of Luck Sir
jamie broderick
said
Doug BC
said
Good luck General.A great big thanks for a job well done.You did a great job of taking care of the men and women in our military.I guess someone will succeed you,but you won't be replaced.Hopefully your successor will be someone that the public,and the troops will learn to trust and respect as well.
London
said
Steve
said
Serving Air Force Officer
said
He will definitely be remembered as a true leader, a CDS who made a real difference. Thank you and happy retirement Sir
Utsav S.
said
Steve Rtd
said
Sean
said
You've affected real change in the Canadian Military with honesty and integrity and I would like to presume that you will continue to do so in whatever role you decide to assume next. I can't imagine a man such as yourself retiring at such a young age and with the solid military background that you have I know you will continue to be a great leader. I hope to see you as Prime Minister of Canada some day. Good health to you.
honeybear55
said
james
said
The army loves him. But our country is surrounded by air and water. A navy and air force is essential for the most fundamental reason of self defence. While Afghanistan may or may not be important, devoting 100% of this country's merge military forces is folly.
Lets hope the government has the wisdom not to appoint a Hiller clone to continue this devastating course. Lets hope we have an air force or navy CDS who will get our defence posture back on track.
Good riddance General Hillier.
ArmyWife
said
Sam Jackson
said
Godspeed!
AirForceBrat
said
Mtr Cpl Benjamin (Ret.)
said
RRO
said
Though if it is Andrew Leslie I would feel that Hilliers legacy is safe.
Andrea
said
Robin da Hood
said
Give it a while, the truth will come out as part of the next Govt. scandal. ;-)
Steve in Ottawa
said
Dave
said
Thank you sir
Good Riddence
said
Mike in B.C.
said
Steven Leblanc
said
Canadian Latitude
said
S in Quebec
said
Lee-Ex Army
said
If the military wants to continue down the path Gen Hillier began down then they best bring on Gen Leslie who is a like minded brilliant leader.
Ray O'Brien
said
Margaret
said
Cpl Grosleau
said
Best of luck in your future endeavour Sir. You shall be missed.
//Salute//
Cpl G
VELOX VERSUTUS VIGILANS
Canadian Naval Officer
said
Hatchet
said
A retired soldier
said
Ex Troop
said
Sad to see him go
said
This is great news. Canadian forces are better off without a general trying to play politics all the time. I just hope that his replacement is not cut from the same cloth.
Whoever wrote this probably isnt a member of the forces!
lost one
said
Sir, i salute you.
To the naysayers, if you don't want to stand behind our troops, please feel free to stand in front of them.(if you've got he guts.I think not)
20 year serving member
said
WO K Berry
said
WO Berry 1 FD AMB EDM.
DA
said
The mess he made will not be fully realized till about five years from now when we wonder why have so few trained soldiers left, and why the young soldiers in the marketable fields are all leaving in droves.
As for his conduct: if anyone of his subordinates did what he did to his commander they would have been court martialed.
Anonymous
said
RMC 08
chris reid
said
retired solider
said
Maybe they should try stepping up to the plate and see how they fare.
It will be a sad day for the CF when General Hillier retires. It was my pleasure to serve in the CF under his guidance and widsom.
Joyce Evans
said
Yes, you must go , but you are a breath of fresh air for us.
Telling like it is is good for all Canadians and I hold you in great respect.
K. Wright
said
R. Barker WO (retired)
said
All the best in your future endeavors.
WO (retired)32 years
Air Element and
Cdn Airborne Regiment
"ex coelus"
R
said
Good luck to the man trying to fill those shoes....
PS, Navy also loved this CDS.
David H
said
To the Media: sometimes a cigar is just a cigar boys and girls
DJ
said
It is so refreshing to see our military elevated and our pride restored, we can still espouse the liberal values from underneath this umbrella. I just hope that military leaders in the wings and Canadians from all walks of life realize that you don't need to be politically correct and ass kissers to be respected and to do the right thing, you don't need to be France. Hiller has helped restore some respect and pride in being a Canadian and not being ashamed of it ,like a defacto France.
More importantly, Hillier has inspired and shown other Canadians how to lead and how to have passion about your country and your men and how many wonderful attributes are not mutually exclusive.
Canadian Soldier
said
Thank you Sir, for helping remind Canadians that our Army is for war-fighting and not the Liberal myth of Peace-Keeping.
We are an Army re-born and re-focussed, thanks to your leadership.
You have inspired many a generation of officer, including the undersigned.
All the best to you and your family.
Pro Patria
Sarah
said
Petawawa Military Wife
said
Jim
said
While he inspired awe in all of us youngsters, he also came across as a real person, something I can say I have seen repeatedly of him in the media since then. ANytime he said something, I knew I could take it at face value. While he definately carried the pride of his uniform, he was extremely approachable and to this day I am glad I got to shake his hand all those years ago.
Bob h fr Petawawa
said
Jim
said
Borden Soldier
said
1. If you're not a member of the CF, then you don't have a clue all the good the CDS has done for us and don't have the right to speak garbage.
2. If you ARE a serving member and speak garbage about him, you're obviously blind and can't see that we're on our way BACK to the top with him in the lead.
Sir, you'll be missed.
Cheryl
said
Well, FCS, as Mark Twain said, "It is better to be thought a fool, than to open your mouth and remove all doubt"
Speaking of ignorance, do you assume that all females that served were admin clerks?
What did he snafu....
-views based on politics not military strategy.
-no help for soldiers with PTSD
-promising to keep troops in afghanistan longer, then bailing out of the military....
Am I to assume (like you did) that anyone who can't think for themselves nor can they spell must be a grunt?
(please print my rebuttle, I take umbrage at someone who attacks me and uses my words)
A soldier
said
Old Soldier
said
has done. From personal knowledge, only LGen Leslie is in the same league (no offense to the others eligible).
Any major corporation would be wise to recruit him as a CEO.
Mike Webster
said
Merv
said
Ron
said
You will be missed Rick. I wish you would stay, we needed your changes long before you came along...lets hope the forces stay on the course you have laid out for them.
To the naysayers out there...any job like this can never please us all...but this man did better then any other in my lifetime. Great work, and good luck.
Jamie
said
Rick for PM...
JDF
said
Morgan B
said
A fellow Newfoundlander
said
Sandy
said
F. J. Lord
said
Scarlett
said
"he played politics";
"he's siding with the US in Afghanistan"; he's 'cutting and running'. What do you have to possibly back up that garbage?
You have no idea of what this man has accomplished!
For those of you who honestly think that we're getting the whole story about his departure - think again. Do you seriously think that Gen Hillier would bail now? Before the job is done? Before his term is over? The Gov't has had 'issues' with Gen Hillier BECAUSE he wouldn't play politics; because he always had the best interests of the Military and its troops at heart.
There's more to this story folks. Gen Hillier will go quietly, (because he's a soldier and has the best interest of the military at the forefront) and we may never know the whole story. To his fellow supporters, we know we all love him dearly and he'll be missed. To those who are glad to see him go, spend a little less time spewing lines about stuff you don't understand; educate yourselves - and get the whole story; rather than relying on what you've heard or seen on TV before you make a decision.
Richard M.
said
Wade - Let there be Light
said
Let there be light and there was light,
Thank you General Hillier you helpoed rebuild our forces and upgrade our rusted out equipment.
Katie McLaughlin
said
Robert
said
HD in TO
said
GunSgt
said
As a serving member who has served under you on several occasions, it is with tremendous sorrow that I say goodbye. You have evolved the way we do business, the equipment we do the mission with, and erased the image that the CF is just a peacekeeping force. THIS army has always shouldered the responsibility of defending our borders whether here or abroad which means ready to fight a WAR. You have embodied the fighting spirit and truly remade soldiering in Canada's Army an honor and a distinction. Thank you! UBIQUE
Schpid
said
Thank you Sir. We'll carry on from here.
Jim Rose
said
Sir, My family and I want to wish you a Happy and Well Deserved Retirement.
Hold your head high, sir, for those "boots" of yours will never be filled in my time.
I have had the previldge to have served for you in while you commanded the Regiment, 2 CMBG.
You are a man of the utmost integerity.
My I use a quote from the late King George V when he spoke to the Royal Newfoundland Regiment "Newfoundlander's,I salute you, you are better than the best"
Sir, if I may, I would like to "Salute you, for you better than the best"
God Bless and Sleep Warm
MCpl J.M.ROSE
Former DRAGOON
Rose
said
norm shanahan
said
Shankar_Mississauga
said
As a Canadian I like to thank you for you service.
Good Luck.
current serving soldier
said
Now, to those retired complaining of being dropped off of the earth by him and saying he messed up: He can't fix everything in 3 years. The tresurary board still fiddles with military financial policy (which affects medical) and there still are a few throwbacks to the early 90's left in the system who haven't retired yet. They can still screw up the system. Not his fault.