CTV News | Arrested anti-seal hunt sailors granted bail

Canada -   

Arrested anti-seal hunt sailors granted bail

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News: Denelle Balfour with the crew's reaction
CTV's Question Period: Minister Loyola Hearn reacts
CTV Newsnet: Jim Winter, Canadian Sealers' Association

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(81)

CTV.ca News Staff

Date: Sun. Apr. 13 2008 11:07 PM ET

The captain and first officer of the anti-sealing ship seized by the Canadian government Saturday were granted bail Sunday following a court appearance in Sydney, Cape Breton.

Captain Alexander Cornelissen -- who is a Dutch citizen -- and First Officer Peter Hammarstedt of the Sea Sheppard Conservation Society vessel, Farley Mowat, are alleged to have broken rules that prohibit anyone from coming within 900 metres of the hunt unless they have an observer's permit.

The two men were granted $5,000 bail each and are to return to court on May 1. It was unsure if they were released or if they were to stay in jail Sunday night.

Cornelissen has also been charged under the Fisheries Act with obstruction or hindrance of a Fishery Officer or inspector.

If convicted, the two men could be jailed for up to one year, fined up to $100,000 -- or both.

Eleven members of the 17-person crew have been released after being taken off their vessel Saturday and transported to Sydney.

The remaining six members remain in custody, although they have not been charged, because they have refused to sign immigration papers. They have also started a hunger strike to protest what they call their unlawful detainment.

Crew member Daniel Bishop said the officials who boarded the vessel during the arrest had their guns drawn in a strong show of force.

"They put a couple of people on the floor and put guns in their faces," Bishop told CTV Atlantic.

The 17 crew members are foreign nationals, coming from countries such as the United States, Australia, the Netherlands and France.

The Sea Sheppard Society claims that the storming of their vessel by RCMP officers brandishing submachine guns was in violation of international law.

David Nickarz, the ship's engineer, said Canada had no right to board the ship because the Dutch-registered vessel was in international waters, where Canadian rules don't apply.

"But I guess the people with the guns had a different opinion,'' he said in an interview with The Canadian Press.

"We've been marooned here in Sydney by the Canadian government.''

The 54-metre Farley Mowat was towed into Sydney today by the Canadian Coast Guard as a few on-lookers watched and snapped pictures.

War of words

On Saturday, Sea Sheppard head Paul Watson said the storming of the vessel was an "act of war" by the Canadian government and said anti-seal hunt activists had been handed a win in the court of public opinion.

But Canada's fisheries minister denied he handed anti-sealing forces a win with the storming.

"No, we haven't handed them a gift at all," Loyola Hearn told CTV's Question Period on Sunday.

The Canadian government has shown fellow governments such as Japan, Norway and Iceland -- that have also faced direct actions by the Sea Shepherd Conservation Society -- that "we're not putting up with it any more," he said.

"And if he (Paul Watson) can go to other places and get away with it, well, welcome to Canada, Mr. Watson."

Watson said of the seizure of the Farley Mowat and arrests: "I think Mr. Hearn has just handed us a gift.

"He's handed us the ability to put this right over the top and get Europe to pass this bill (banning the import of seal products). We're seeing the end of days for the seal hunt."

Watson, who was in New York Saturday, was making his way to Cape Breton by car Sunday night.

His group even took a swipe at Hearn on its website.

"In his zeal to kiss the bottoms of the seal-killing crowd, he has thrown reason out the window ... Loyola Hearn is certainly the latest Nufie (sic) joke and the joke is about to backfire in his face.'"

Watson has argued that his vessel, registered in the Netherlands, was in international waters and that Europe will be angered by Canada's actions.

Hearn said the vessel was in "Canadian territorial waters" but didn't say if it was within 12 nautical miles (22 kilometres) of the coastline. The minister has also said the Fisheries Act gave him the leeway to act outside the 12-nautical mile limit.

The arrests were necessary to prevent future danger to sealers, fisheries officers and observers, he said.

The incident for which they are charged occurred on March 30 and happened about 60 kilometres north of Cape Breton.

This year's hunt began on March 28 in the southern Gulf of St. Lawrence. The main hunt, in an area north of Newfoundland known as the Front, began Saturday.

The seal quota this season is 275,000 harp seals, but prices are low and fuel prices are high. As a result, some observers say hunters might not reach their quota.

With files from CTV Atlantic's Dan MacIntosh and The Canadian Press

Comments are now closed for this story

hugh
said

Good for Mr. Hearn. Sell the boat and keep the profit. Deport all the crew out of the country as fast as possible. Fine the owner and Captain.


RTP
said

"Conservationist" group? Maybe he should go to Iraq where human lives are in need of conserving, or maybe he should put his efforts towards animals that are actually endangered and in need of conservation which these seals are most definitely not.

I hate these ignorant tools with their misguided mission. There are some seriously misplaced priorities here.


Roadrobber
said

No, I don't think this is a win for the seal-hunt protestors at all. Paul Watson is prone to hyperbole and exaggeration. The more publicity he gets, the more money his organization takes in. I am proud that the Government of Canada has taken action against those who would break Canadian law. The Japanese should learn from this.


ance
said

This kind of "police state" overreaction signals to the world that our Government KNOWS we are hiding something shameful and is complicit in trying to keep it out of the public eye.

Trust the Conservatives to escalate the situation and bully the participants with whom they don't agree.

Sorry Mr. Hearn... this will be a stain on the Canadian government's reputation as a fair player and won't go over well in Europe.

The anti-seal campaigners are right, this makes you look worse than them.

If there is a true ecological requirement for a seal cull, support it with some scientific evidence that your opponents can't refute.

Then change the hunt so that consevation officers are on site to enforce some humane killing standards and fine anyone who is not in compliance.



Outdoorswoman
said

Paul Watson let everyone know what his agenda is when he told sealers he thought that killing seals was worse than human beings (sealers) dying. Sorry, but I have no sympathy for those who "think" they are conservationists. Thank you Minister Hearn!


bob c
said

Bravo to the government for acting against these self-righteous do-gooders. Before they complain about seals, start cleaning up the slaughter houses. I hope none of these protesters ever eats any form of meat. they're a bunch of hypocrites.


DD
said

It's time for the government to ban the protesters from the front altogether. The US, Norway and Russia don't allow protesters near their hunts...why do we????

The protesters are putting sealer's lives in jeopardy and lying to scam those who don't know better out of millions upon millions of dollars!!!

This is a hunt!! It is no different than going out to shoot a moose or a deer. Problem is, they're not cute. If the seal wasn't cute, no one would give a damn.

Yet the protesters lie and tug on the heart strings in order to get you to line THEIR pockets while they destroy what is a humane and sustainable HUNT.

And no one that consumes an ounce of meat has a right to call this hunt barbaric or unnecessary. If you eat meat, try going into the local slaughterhouse and see how far they let you in. What...they don't??? So why do we?????


Andrew in BC
said

Good for Canada in not bending over for these self-proclaimed environmental warriors. I believe that there is a place for environmentalists in policing the wrongs in the world (BC logging in the '80s, Boreal forest today, fish farming on the West Coast, etc;) but when fishermen are harvesting 275k seals when they number in the millions and devastate the cod fisheries, well, 275k just is not enough and it should be more. Killing anything is brutal from whatever point of view but from what I see it is done as humanely as possible and the workers have to be protected from foreigners who have no idea. Funny, I was walking in Vancouver the other day and I saw one of their posters which saw a baby seal and the words "right now, 250 000 baby seals are being slaughtered, get mad at the right things" or something to that affect. We all know that this is a lie (illegal to kill the young)and to me it goes to show that if you lie once so openly, why should we trust what you have to say at any other time.


Stan
said

Well done Mr Hearn...Finally a Goverment Minister that will stand up for whats right...




Helaine Petelka
said

Is this seizure to perhaps take the emphasis off the real , original issue of why are we not longer talking about the Canadian Coast Guard and why they are not being charged for not transferring the crew of the seal boat to their ship and why no one was paying any attention to the tow?? What's the real issue here?? as long as there are seals there will always be protesters.!!!!!


OnrNewf
said

"Go Harper GO" ,,Finaly!!There a man with courage at the helm of the good ship Canada


Old sailor
said

This organisation started out with a valid point, but now shows all the signs of having mutated into a cult.

Its a short step from "I am the saviour of the seals" to "I am the saviour and all who disagree with me should die".


Drake
said

If we made clothes out of jellyfish -- would anyone care?


Greg
said

Hugh, agreed about sell the boat. But I think Paul Watson should have to pay fist class tickets on a Canadian airline, though, to ship the crew members home... the long way... and that that should become policy for all disrupters who come here to protest anything. No free ticket out. The organization that sends them ought to have to pay for that, along with their jail or food and lodging, their court costs, etc. And they should be permanently banned from ever entering Canada.

For our part, however, we ought to make better use of what's left of the seals than leaving them to rot on the ice. That's simply wasteful, and disrespectful to creatures everywhere.


Mamad
said

Good job Europeans. Stop the seal hunt by these monsters. Ban Canada's seal hunt and see what they'll do then. It's discusting these things happen in a democratic country.


Bob
said

Congradulations Mr. Hearn. You finally got it right. Confiscate the boat and treat the proceeds as a fine for bumping the coast guard vessel. Then Deport the whole darned lot of them with a warning that they will face jail time the next time they teurn up in Canadian waters to act in an illegal manner.


Brad
said

Good for the Canadian givernment and Mr.Hearn, now sell the ship and use the profits to help the needy, This should have been done long ago. These so called conservationists, should stay in their own countries or go somewhere where really needed where lives can be saved. there are millions and millions of seals and they have already ruined the cod population and put many people out of work...


David #1
said

Smashing the skulls and beating the brains out of young seals be it young seals or pups is disgusting. Canada looks like a huge hypocrite when it chastises other countries for their records on animal or human rights but makes an "exception" for their own "brand" of brutality towards a living species.

The seal hunt is archaic and should be stopped "permanently". I hear so many of you lecture Ontario (Canada's economic engine) about diversifying its economy on not rely on "manufacturing" to sustain its economy. Maybe Newfoundland should get more creative as well.


George
said

Why didn't the Minister order the Coast Guard to seize the boats of foreign fishermen illegally fishing in Canadian waters? The reason is because it's easier to bully a small group than it is an entire country.

I am so grateful Hearn crossed the line. Now countries will really wonder why the DFO does not allow observers or cameras, and put an end to a national disgrace once and for all.


KPR
said

Mr. Hearn is my MP, and he usually does a bad job of representing his constituents, but I think he's done the right thing here. We need to stop trating eco-terrorists like normal protestors and take action to protect honest Canadian hunters who are trying to feed their families.


jesse
said

We should start up a "Save the ugly animals" campaign. Nobody ever gives a damn about ugly animals.


Jason Toronto
said

Conservation Group YEAH RIGHT!Why dont the crew of the Fartley Mowat tell the world how much marine diesel that decrepid ship uses!!!Or do they think it is the good ship lollipop and runs on warm feelings!!


Marc
said

Government mis-management is responsible for the cod fishery collapse, not seals. I find it offensive that CTV describes SS as a militant conservationist group. All they did was roll a camera to submit to European parliament for their rightful review. The censorship attempts will not help Canada, people want the truth, and the truth is that cruelty is hard to swallow.


James
said

Pathetic government & pathetic minister. As a Canadian who is horrified by the seal hunt, I hope this act will "seal" the end of this Conservative government. The soon the better!


Nancy
said

The Conservative Government has really become the Canadian Government for all.

I say save the fish not the seals.

The seals have eaten us out of the cod industry.


DD
said

Hey Mamad...if you find the seal hunt "discusting" then I assume you don't eat meat.

After all, the practices in slaughterhouses are no less "discusting" in that animals are killed. In slaughterhouses, they are electrocuted or have a bolt driven through their skulls (not unlike the older practice of clubbing seals which is rarely done now). Chickens are hung upsidedown on a conveyor, have their throat slashed and are permitted to move along the conveyor as they bleed to death.

Imagine...that happens in a democratic country.

Get your priorities right. The seal hunt is a HUNT. No different than hunting moose or deer. Stop listening to the animal rights groups that only want to scam you out of dollars they use to line their own pockets.

Educate yourself.


David #1
said

Smashing the skulls and beating the brains out of young seals be it young seals or pups is disgusting. Canada looks like a huge hypocrite when it chastises other countries for their records on animal or human rights but makes an "exception" for their own "brand" of brutality towards a living species.

The seal hunt is archaic and should be stopped "permanently". I hear so many of you lecture Ontario (Canada's economic engine) about diversifying its economy on not rely on "manufacturing" to sustain its economy. Maybe Newfoundland should get more creative as well.


Larry Brehmer
said

The accusations fly against Sea Shepherd.
Canadian fishermen endorse Canadian government using armed extreme measures for protection from camera wielding volunteers. I had no idea the East Coast Sealers were so weak and vulnerable as to require the full armed support of the Canadian government to prevent being observed.


JDSK
said

You'd think that in this day and age, the government or the protesters could provide positive proof whether the boat was in International waters, or even within the 12 nautical mile limit. I mean, get real - if we can track the locations of our kids within ten feet using their cell phones, something tells me that the 'Farely Mowat' would have similar technology - not to mention the Goverment of Canada.

If the protesters were, in fact, inside Canadian waters and too close to the sealers, then put them all in seal suits and let the sealers have at them. If they weren't, however, then the Honourable Mr. Hearn should be given the same fate (not to mention being charged for breaking international law).



Don
said

So the name of the game is, if you are a big business you don’t have to put up with annoying protesters anymore. I think maybe the oil companies are going to be learning from these tactics. Pretty sad day when CTV is trying to sell me that some people who protest seal hunts are "militant". GET REAL. Maybe all you people who support the seal hunt would like these protesters to stand somewhere where no one can see them. Life would be so much easier if everyone would just comply with big business wouldn’t it? (sarcasm)


Robert Pratt
said

Good job. There is some justice in going after a group that has committed acts of sabotage (throwing acid, ramming other ships) and essentially declared war on anything with which they don't agree.

They act like pirates. Sadly, they will be treated as civilized human beings in our judicial system.


Allan Eizinas
said

Animal and environmental activists are accepted and tolerated by the majority because it is assumed that their hearts are in the right place. When they go too far then the majority can and do easily turn on them.

When Watson et al equated the deaths of the sealers with the deaths of the seals and showed complete insensitivity to this tragic death of these fishermen and simple workers then they crossed the line.

I believe that Watson and his ilk have lost the sympathy of the majority and will pay for their statements. There are also those who feel that the farmer who is killed when he is crushed by his tractor overturning while he is harvesting his crop deserves to die because of all of the plants that he is killing.

I do not. I believe my views represent the vast majority of the Canadian population.

Watson and his group may have sealed their own fate.


Dave Kelly
said

Seals can often be classed as "vermin of the sea", and could be viewed in the same context as rats on land. Rats can be cute, and some keep them as pets. I have not seem protests against the use of rat traps or poisons to prevent rat populations from getting out of hand. Seals have maintained a population abundance out of step with their impact on a portion of the marine food chain on which we place a higher food value. Congratulations to those hardy individuals who can get some value out of this cull, and return the carcasses to the ocean to feed the lobster, crab and other scavengers which we welcome on our dinner table.


Marc
said

There is absolutely no evidence that AR groups are in it for the money.


JoeNorthAmerican
said

To "DD" specifically. Assuming CTV will even bother to post this because I might make you think in someone else's shoes...namely the seals.

If someday the tables should turn and human beings become a hunted species and human babies are on their menu, would that be okay with you? As well as the barbaric ways in which they are harvested?

Lets remember that man to is an animal. Therefore should another species "out-smart" us at our domination of the planet (and all living things on it)and decide we can be used for food and profit then I guess we should just suck it up and accept that fact and cheer on the guys using the clubs on us. Right???


Thomas
said

The seal industry is no different than any other industry involving the use of animals for mankind. As long as we manage it well, I'm OK with it.


Fog of Life
said

This barbaric practice of killing innocent creatures only hurts Canada's credibility on the world stage. How are we supposed to stop other countries from whale or dolphin hunting when we continue such crazy practices. Save me the speech that seals are not endangered. Barbaric is as barbaric does....Its time for the government to find these hunters other jobs so we can regain our credibility...


dave
said

I sometimes wonder how many would be on the ice protesting if a seal pup looked like a 40 pound cockroach
And I wonder how much people would contribute to save the aforementioned cockroaches ?


DebraMarie
said

Hip Hip Hooray!!! CPW is a HERO!!!


Percy Griffin
said

Hearn's comment about showing Iceland, Japan and Norway how to act has now put Canada in league with the whaling nations. This comment will go round the world and cause a boycott of Canadian seafood. What an idiot, he's just destroyed the Canadian fisheries industry.

Bruce
said

Seal 'Hunt'? Running through the wild with a club chasing a creature running away is definitely a hunt. Sneaking up camouflaged on an animal with a high powered rifle is arguably a hunt. Standing in a circle and herding creatures and beating them over the head isn't a hunt.

The real question is whether the ship was 12 nm offshore or not. If we violated international law, it'll be embarrassing for us. If we didn't, then it'll be embarrassing for the animal rights people.

Scott H.
said

Ahh yes of course... lets blame the Conservatives for a "police state" mentality, but praise Jean Chretien for going after Spanish fishing boats in coastal waters...

Pot... meet kettle?

erleen
said

Paul Watson got all of you where he wanted. Top story and now everyone's talking. Take out the commercialization of the hunt and it would satisfy most. Killing 250,000 seals for pelts isn't right. It's time to do something positive and use the International stage to find the sealers new employment. If they want to continue to hunt a few like the aboriginals let them. But the make work program the government has set up is failing miserably for the sealers and for the Canadian public. Do we want to go through the drama every year?


Balgonie Bob
said

I wonder how much money Paul Watson makes by sucking in all those foolish enough to donate to his organization. I'd bet it's enough to keep him supplied with all the best vegan food in his Manhattan digs.

catsrulz
said

I love all of you that think that they are killing the pups, well they arnt killing them.They are only allowed to kill the adult ones. Like Paul McCartney last year getting his pic taken with a pup. To bad he didnt tell people these arnt the ones they kill, cause that wouldnt make for good press to have a pic taken with an adult one cause they arnt cute.

Jim McB
said

We keep forgetting that Elizabeth May the leader of the Green Party is still a member of this fringe group, just not on the board of directors.

How come CTV has not had her on the tube explaining her sympathies for these folks that we have arrested?

Trou
said

SHAME ON CANADA!
Too much liars, hypocrits and disgusting people...

Watson is a hero! Time 'll give the antis their reward.

Mrs. Brown
said

Thank you for the gift Mr. Hearn. Europe will surely ban seal products now.

Someone who was there!
said

I was there when the takedown happened! These so-called environmentalists have no regard for due-process and use tactics that warrant force. I am proud of our gov't to finally take a stand. On a separate note, just try to envisage what will happen when these high fuel prices coupled with low cost returns for seals causes bigger problems in the future. Do you know how much fish one seal eats in a day? If the culling stops, there will be a total depletion of the fish stocks....also hit by foreign overfishing. Then what???? Fish being sold at $30 a pound in the grocery store? I suppose everyone will blame the gov't for that as well, won't they. (~sarcasm~)

Mike
said

What kind of ship is it? Maybe we could add it to our Navy

CAG
said

"The Canadian government has shown fellow governments such as Japan, Norway and Iceland -- that have also faced direct actions by the Sea Shepherd Conservation Society -- that "we're not putting up with it any more," he said."

How DARE we associate ourselves with countries that defy the international ban on whaling! Canada should be standing against such activities, not encouraging them. Are we going to start killing whales next? Loyola Hearn should be removed from office for destroying our country's good reputation.

I have never been so ashamed to be Canadian in my life. Shut the hunt down; it's a national embarrassment.

Fishy N.S.
said

I salute the good people of the Sea Shepherd Conservation Group. I support your actions 100%. Keep up the great work!

truthseeker
said

Stand your guard Mr. Hearn, Canada needs more patriotic leaders like yourself! There are lots of small communities on the East coast that depend on this type of revenue to survive. The government should do more to diversify the East coasts employment though, with decent wages, and without changing the unique culture.

roscoe
said

Hearn is a hero to all his fellow Newfies, but is a complete Buffoon in the eyes of the world, and the majority of Canadians.
Paul Watson is a more true Canadian than Hearn.
Bravo, Sir Paul Watson!
Hearn just signed the death knell (finally), on the seal 'hunt' (what hunt?).
West Coasters find the seal hunt abhorable.

Wes
said

The reaction by the Canadian government was justified and I am glad that they finally took some action. But for me this is about this particular group raming a Canadian coast guard ship and disregarding our governments authority. These people can protest but attacking the coast guard is going way to far. This should have been done days ago. The Canadian coast guard should be armed.

Tm Olheiser
said

The loss of salmon population indicates that seal populations are getting larger. They eat salmon, cod and herring, and the loss of these habitats indicates to me, seal hunting must be done to control the population of seals.

Seals maybe cute, but their elders can and are eating away other industries.

The sealers must be let to harvest, just like hunters are let to lower deer populations. Ecosystems have limits to their carrying capacities.
The byproduct of the seal harvest is pelts, and food for some. The importance of lowering seal population has been seen.

Take that back to europe, and explain that the price of Salmon will be $70 plus dollars a pound, and there will be no salmon eggs for the rich.


Richard
said

I think it is right that these guys have been penalized here. They don't have any business being there in the first place interrupting what is lawfully farming of these animals.

It is no different that cows going to the slaughter house. I wonder if any of these yahoos have been to one? And by the way, hamburgers taste damn good so there. I like my steak medium rare. I especially like veal too. Quite good.

Moe
said

Mmmmmmmmmmmmm, seal meat. There are too many seals and to leave them alone would be too destroy the fishery even futher and then the seals would starve horribly or sucumb massively to disease. We are the seals predators and keep them in balance.

Paul
said

Although I like Canada and most Canadians I have to say you are giving yourselves the same image as the Koreans, Chinese and Japanese in terms of your cruel methods, and also your not allowing non-biased news teams to broadcast events. You are giving yourselves a black eye and I can only see it getting worse. The seal hunt isn't done for food, it is for fur and there is an alternative which us Europeans are turning to. At least ENSURE seals do not endure pain please, but there are too many "accidents" where they are not humanely killed. I say "accidents" because they aren't accidents at all, it is arrogant uncaring hunters who do not club carefully. I'm against clubbing period. Can't you at least make sure the animal has no suffering if you are going to take it's life for profit? I also intensely dislike how many hunters gloat about it, as if it is some macho thing. Its hardly macho beating a defenseless young creature over the head, its actually pretty cowardley.

The fact is the markets are disappearing, the prices of pelts have halved and when the EU ban comes into force the hunt will be worthless, with any luck. Then we will see whther the excuse of "controlling fish stocks" or "restoring balance" is so important after all, somehow I doubt it.

But thanks for allowing me to have my say and for reading it.

David
said

God, how many people in this world still think they smash or kill white baby seals! They still show videos back when that was done and people still believe it is done today! Before you make a comment, could you educate yourself on how this hunt is done in 2008. Don't believe all you hear and see as AR just want your money. There are poor people in this world but you don't see Watson running to protect them. If he took the money he got from those seal pictures and gave them to the poor there would be no poor people. Movie and singer who eat meat and then protest the seals fishery. One reason I don't go to movies or buy cds as it in turns sends money to protester. Sad day when even Canadians don't understand the seal hunt and they likely live next door to a slaughter house...I'm proud to be an Canadian and proud to be a Newfoundlander. If you don't like Canada then just leave..


Shawn
said

Ask yourself this, if a cow was as pretty to look at as a seal would you care that when it arrives at the slaughter house that a bolt is driven into its’ head to kill it. If the slaughter house had to kill the cow without the use of hooks and troughs to keep the blood in one area would people be more bothered by all the blood that would be evident.

I decided to research into the seal hunt to find the truth and I discovered some facts that I will share.

Canada is one of five other countries that are currently engaged in seal hunting. Greenland, Russia, Norway and Namibia are the other four.

“The seals hunted today must be independent, self-reliant animals. Although gruesome images of nursing seal pup hunting continue to be circulated around the world, in fact, the commercial hunt of nursing seal pups is banned in Canada.” – DFO website

Canada is allowing up to 275 000 seals to be harvested from an estimated 9.5 million.

“Canada has researched the methods used - guns and hakapiks, which originated in the traditions of First Nations and Inuit peoples - to ensure that methods used compare favourably with those used to kill any other wild or domestic animal.” – DFO website

The hakapiks is a tool that has been used by hunters for thousands of years and if used properly, while it looks nasty, can deliver a fatal blow causing immediate death. The issue seems to be, and supported by researchers, is that hunters are not always using the tool properly. Let's get some experts out there to show them then. A gun can also be used but as any land hunter can tell you, it does not guarantee an immediate kill and can allow the animal to slip away and die slowly.

Bottom line, killing anything in today’s world is an ugly thing but when defined and accepted hunting practises are put in place, enforced and people are properly education, what more can you ask for.

Whether you put money on the counter for your burger or ‘pull the trigger’, you are involved in this ugliness just the same. Think about it.

Research this more to be informed.

Irate
said

Loyola Hearn....what a piece of work! The Department of Fisheries has done such a masterful job at screwing up every aspect of it's portfolio; East coast cod, West coast salmon, recent Coast Guard blunders.... and we continue to allow them to operate!!! What a joke! With performance levels like that in the private sector you'd be out of business in 3 months. Hearn talks of all those crazy people filling the coffers of the Sea Shepard Society; well how do you think I feel about paying this knuckle-dragger's salary as a canadian taxpayer. Canada is looking more and more like a banana republic every day.

We complain about China and the limitations it imposes on any press opposing the State's position but it is not too unlike what's happening here within our own country!! Every year the DFO imposes and expands the "safe" viewing distance for anyone interested in reporting on the gross acts of cruelty. Another joke!! Now, Hearn, acting like a raging spoiled child changes the rules again and has his goons do the dirty work in arresting the Sea Shepherd's crew members. Doing so in international waters will also create a situation that will have huge repercussions.

The last point of concern is the sheer cost of defending Canada's position on the seal hunt. They seem hell bent on deflecting how economically unfeasible the whole situation is. The hourly costs of having a Coast Guard presence, (ie. helicopters, vessels, manpower, rescue missions, etc..).

We have been offering handouts to these sealing barbarians for my whole life. This whole hunt has been a poorly veiled attempt at social welfare, I would suggest we should just give these whining babies a check every year just to get them to stay off the floes. We could save a whole lot of bad blood and maybe get back an ounce of the world's respect.

DFO what a farce!


byllie
said

Since we can believe very little of what governments tell us these days,and since they so often shape events to suit their political purposes, perhaps we should withold judgment until the facts are in.

D
said

I hope that these so-called conservationists are given the harshest of consequences for their actions. They care little about humans, or seals for that matter.
Seals do not need "conserving"-their numbers suggest otherwise.
As for all the hue and cry about baby seals....I don't hear any protests about slaughterhouses, force feeding of geese and ducks (people gotta have ther foie gras), and the killing of lambs and small calves. I am assuming that all those who bash the sealers don't eat meat or wear any type of leather? Enough hypocrisy already.

Greg in the Hammer
said

Good for Mr Hearn.

I laugh at the "activists" that cry in shrill tones about the poor seals while they sip their lattes at Starbucks or the Europeans who think that Canadians are barbarians for continuing a hunt that has been a way of life for the people of that area for hundreds of years. The seal hunt is vital for those that participate to provide for their families. The seals are not endangered, all of the seal is used not just the pelts. Yes it is brutal, it is bloody. Welcome to life in Maritime Canada. If you don't like it, have another latte.

Tammy
said

The seal hunt is a national disgrace and embarassment.I hope they boycott Canada on a huge scale.I for one will never buy fish or any product from eastern Canada.The only thing decimating cod stocks is over fishing.How can we say anything about Japan and Chinas barbaric treatment of animals,especially the dolphin hunt,if were doing the same stupid ignorant thing.
For those whining about vegetarianism.I only buy organic meat that HAS been killed humanely.I dont support mega farms or fast food places.If the sealers have nothing to hide they wouldnt have a problem with being filmed.Simple as that.

Peter
said

I really don't understand this way of killing seals. Why don't we "hunt" the seals the proper way and kill them with a gun rather than using this barbaric way? Would one bullet per seal be too much of a price to pay for a "clean" killing that would silence most if not all of the protests? Why use a barbaric way when a decent way of doing it is easily available? Anyone killing another type of animal this way would be accused of cruelty to animals, fined and possibly jailed under our own Canadian law!


Lee, BC
said

Hooray for Hearn and Harper! They are showing the world that we are a great civilized nation! Now, let's get back to whaling and let's kill all those Dolphins that are eating our fish supply as well! Great message to the world Canada! Gee, I am so proud to be a Canadian :(

Richard McAdam
said

The unfortunate thing I feel is that people, (Government officials and Conservation activists alike) are going to do what they want unless addressed by an interest group that confronts their intentions.
Always it's the innocents that suffer.
'Oh, the humanity?
Rather, 'Oh the lack of humility of the human race.'
RPM - Toronto.

bev. huff
said

Thank goodness, a voice of reason. Thank you Mr.Hearn for standing up ot a bunch of bullys who up until now have managed to scare others with the threat of boycotts and the like. It's about time we as a nation stood up for our rights. Thanks again.

ME
said

Irate--You are one of those people who know nothing and yet have so much to say--The sealers don't get a handout --that's why they seal. Just like those who support this cause, you have not looked into what you so vehemently condemn. You just open your mouth and hot air comes out.
FIND OUT THE FACTS

Stephen Lambert, Brampton
said

Watson is my hero! Way to go!
The reason we see this issue in the first place is the unbalanced overfishing of the humans that has taken place for decades.

Louis Boutet
said

I will accept anyone's objection to the seal hunt who first follows me through a local slaughter house and swears solemly never to eat meat again.

Otherwise bug off. You don't know what you are talking about!

Brian
said

I don't know if this is the voice of reason but this debate will likely not happen in the future.

European countries will likely put a ban on seal products at some point in the not too distant future and hunters will be able to "hunt" as many pups as they want, they won't be able to sell them anymore.

Look at what happened with the European asbestos ban... history tends to repeat itself.

Happy Meat Eater
said

DD I personally find hunting of any animal disgusting and therfore do not hunt though I come from a long line of hunters. I however understand the need for hunts and the place it serves in the food chain, and believe that if it must be done then it should be done in the most humane way possible i.e. as quick and painlessly as possible for the animal . And eventhough I find hunting a disgusting practice I love to eat meat. Doesn't make me a hypocrite, just somebody who understands where the meat on my plate is coming from and how it got there.

bill jones
said

What I can't come to terms with is how anti-seal protestors have boats that must be worth over half a million dollars while seal hunters can barely make a living.

Mike Horner
said

Fisheries ministers past and present are directly responsible for failure of the cod stocks by allowing bottom trawlers to destroy the habitat.

The seal hunt does nothing but destroy Canada's reputation on the world stage it makes me ashamed to be
Canadian

Scott
said

Helaine Petelka has obviously never towed a ship, not to mention ever been to sea. Accidents do happen, and unfortunately people do die in the maritime environment, and I pray for their families. Seizing the Farley Mowat is not a distraction by any means.

As for Paul Watson, it is nice to see that he can sit comfortably in New York why his flunkies have to sit in jail tonight for blatantly breaking Canadian law. 12nm limit or not, he obviously doesn't understand law of the sea and exclusive economic zones. And who are we declaring war against? The Dutch, give me a break.

Kay
said

This is absolutely atrocious - I wasn't aware that we lived in a country were militant action can be taken against peaceful protesters. According to the story, at no point in time did these protesters approach, harm or threaten ANY of the seal hunters, so may I ask why these people needed to be arrested a gun point???

I find it interesting that so many people are so quick so say 'raw raw Canadian government for squashing these protesters' yet in the current situation in Tibet, we all seem appalled that the Chinese government is taking forceful action against peaceful Tibetan protesters. How interesting that when seen through the lens of 'our good strong Canadian government' we seem to agree with militant action, and yet when seen through the lens of 'the Chinese communist regime', we are outright against it.

The real issue here is that at what point did Canadians stop being allowed to peacefully protest activities that the government endorses? I was under the impression that Canada stood for freedom of speech, not repression of activists the government doesn't want the media to see.

I can only hope that this spurs the international community to take a long look at the seal hunt, and whether Canada is truly sticking by human and animal rights sanctions, and indeed for Canadian to take a long hard look at whether we still value freedom of speech and freedom to peacefully protest.

ps. I would also like to say thank you to Don, JoeNorthAmerican, and dave, I agree 100% with your comments.

Shawn
said

Peter, this is why guns are not the best choice:

"According to recent studies done by the Canadian Veterinary Medical Association (CVMA), the hakapik, when used properly, kills the animal quickly and painlessly. Several American studies carried out from 1969-1972 in the Pribilof Islands of Alaska came to the same conclusion.[64] The Royal Commission on Seals and Sealing in Canada, also known as the Malouf Commission, claims that properly performed clubbing is at least as humane as the methods used in commercial slaughterhouses, and according to the Department of Fisheries and Oceans Canada (DFO), these studies "have consistently proven that the club or hakapik is an efficient tool designed to kill the animal quickly and humanely." – Wikipedia under seal hunt.

Also see "In 2005, the World Wildlife Fund (WWF) commissioned the Independent Veterinarians Working Group Report. With reference to video evidence, the report states: "Perception of the seal hunt seems to be based largely on emotion, and on visual images that are often difficult even for experienced observers to interpret with certainty. While a hakapik strike on the skull of a seal appears brutal, it is humane if it achieves rapid, irreversible loss of consciousness leading to death."[68] – also from Wikipedia under seal hunt

While the hakapik doesn’t guarantee a clean kill, neither does the gun. Any deer hunter who has shot and lost a deer can tell you. The bullet may only wound allowing the seal to escape to a painful and slow death.

A bullet can also tear through the animal and ruin whatever value their was in the meat our hide. Why not just shoot it in the head? I have observed a large dog take 00 buck to the head and not go down. (Police take down of a dangerous dog).

Until a better nethod is developed this is what we have to work with. Canadians should demand no less then the most professional and humane use of the tools available to sealers, as should be the case with anyone who hunts.


George
said

As someone who eagerly anticipates the annual seal hunt, as it has helped support our Canadian fishers here in the Atlantic. It is simply a harvest of an animal which obviously needs no protection.

Mr. Watson and his supporters, with good intentions, are misguided. Certainly there are many species of animals which need help. It would have been better to be focused on a real problem, instead of trying to create one for publicity.

As a Canadian tax payer, I'll be proud of the proceeds of the sale of the Farley Mowat be used to help Canadians, be it for health care, paying down the debt, or used to save an actual endangered species.

For those Conservationists who come over here from elsewhere, who don't like this thought, perhaps it would be better to get proper information, not propoganda. Then make an informed decision about Canadians and the seal hunt.


Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz