CTV News | Anti-cellphone driving laws in effect in N.S., Que.

Top Stories -   

Anti-cellphone driving laws in effect in N.S., Que.

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News: Genevieve Beauchemin on the bad habit
CTV Atlantic: Jonathan MacInnis with driver reaction
CTV Montreal: Tania Krywiak on what will happen if you get caught
Canada AM: Dr. Don Redelmeier, U of T

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(30)

CTV.ca News Staff

Date: Tue. Apr. 1 2008 11:34 PM ET

Nova Scotia and Quebec have become the latest provinces in Canada to ban drivers from using hand-held cellphones.

The new laws, which came into effect on Tuesday in both provinces, will still allow drivers to use hands-free devices.

But the two provinces part paths when it comes to grace periods for drivers caught on the road with handheld phones, which will now be illegal to use when behind the wheel.

In Quebec, police will give lawbreakers a three-month grace period. Instead of a fine, police will hand out warnings. Not so in Nova Scotia, where the Mounties say the full impact of the law begins on April 1.

Penalized drivers will also face heftier fines in Nova Scotia, where police will hand out $165 tickets for a first offence. Second and third offences will cost gabbing drivers $220 and $335 respectively. In Quebec, fines will be about $100.

Driver reactions

One Quebec resident says he's paying for a new hands-free phone now so he won't have to pay fines later.

"Whether or not it makes a difference is one thing ... but when it comes down to it, I don't want to get a ticket for $100 and lose demerit points on my licence," he said.

Another motorist was on his cellphone and reacted with surprise when CTV Montreal informed him of the phone ban.

"Really?" he asked, before snapping his phone shut.

In Nova Scotia, where the government also banned smoking in cars with minors in them, some people wondering if the government had gone too far. But others thought the moves were necessary.

"Common sense isn't used a lot these days," Linda Norman said. "Sometimes the government has to step in and make people do what they should be doing."

Experts say strict laws against handheld cellphone use while driving are necessary to save lives. Studies suggest that using a cellphone while driving can be as dangerous as drinking and driving.

"Distracted drivers aren't just a danger to themselves, but to other people on the road," says the University of Toronto's Dr. Don Redelmeier.

Redelmeier studied the cellphone records of nearly 700 Toronto drivers who had been in car crashes and found that they were four times more likely to get into an accident while on their phones.

Experts say that even using a hands-free cellphone has its dangers, but they note that Quebec and Nova Scotia have moved in the right direction.

"Hands-free is just as dangerous. (But) by forbidding the hand-held it does send a signal that there is a problem with the cellphone, there's a problem with concentration. With education, hopefully no one will use a cell phone when they drive," road safety advocate Jean-Marie De Koninck told CTV Montreal.

With their new laws, Nova Scotia and Quebec join Newfoundland and Labrador as the only jurisdictions in Canada to ban handheld devices while behind the wheel.

With files from CTV Montreal and CTV Atlantic

Comments are now closed for this story

LRW
said
0 0

Well duh. There are enough idiot drivers out there, they sure don't need a cell phone distracting them. Good law and its about time. Only a horrible person would put someones life at risk because they are so important they have to use a cell phone when driving. Rememeber the good old days when the only place you had to use your phone was at home or a pay phone? I do and I'm only 37!!!



Calll Me
said
0 0

Come on McGuinty, you can do it, come on now, Family Day was a nice bit of legislation, now it's time for some tuff love. If Que. can ban cell phones while driving, you can do it too.

martin from ottawa
said
0 0

It's a good thing, handheld phones while driving should be banned across country.


Nick T
said
0 0

Having almost been in an accident this past weekend because a young lady had her phone glued to her ear, I hope Ontario goes the same way. It would easily get my vote to pass.


Katie
said
0 0

I think this law is a good idea. Though I would like to see even blue-tooth and non-handheld devices (except GPS obviously) in the near future. They should be allowed if your vehicle is off the road and parked but not while you are driving. There is too much dangerous driving out there and 75% of the time people talking on cell phones are the cause. Let's drive safe! Put the cell phones down for a few minutes.


EJ
said
0 0

It is about time. When is Ontario going hands free. I dislike the use of the cell phone while driving. Just the other day, I saw a huge transport truck carrying a large load travelling over 110 km and the driver has one hand to his ear and other on the wheel. Who has control of that truck?


Nathan
said
0 0

First thing about this article, how can you single out "holding a cell phone to your ear". It is still just talking, whether you are talking with a person in the seat next to you and actually concentrating on a conversation while driving, or on a cell phone there is very little difference. I disagree with this law for many reasons:

-If you cannot concentrate enough to be able to use a cell phone while driving then there is a serious issue with your driving ability in the first place.

-How will this be enforced? you could see a cell phone on someone's ear, so why not just send a text message, its out of view from any oncoming traffic.

I would like to be clear that talking by intense driving can be a distraction, but how can you prove that talking on a cell phone is more distracting that talking to the person in the seat next to you. Conversations in person usually generate hand gestures which in my unbiased opinion would require more concentration than listening to a voice on a phone.

Before implementation of this kind of thing, make sure that it is well proven, I do not feel this is the case.


Only cellphones?
said
0 0

martin from ottawa said:
"...handheld phones while driving should be banned across country."

I agree, but so should lighting a cigarette, combing your hair, applying lipstick, drinking coffee (or other beverages), checking a map or your GPS device, writing a quick note, using a hands-free cellphone, using a CB, disciplining the kids in the back seat, using any two-way radio, and all the other things you can think of.
Driving is a full-time job, but few of us do it that way all the time.

What's the answer?



plabo
said
0 0

We are being denied from using cell phones while driving since it may distract us from driving cautiously and may cause accidents.

Have you looked through the window of a police car lately. I most often see only one police officer in the vehicle who must drive, use the two way radio as well as type away on their computer. They are a higher risk don't you think.


Steve in the WEST!
said
0 0

It's a good law and I support it...BUT...What about all the other things that people do while driving??? They are just as bad. Listening to music so loud you can have a conversation, or eating and drinking while driving? Trying to set your IPOD, GPS or Sat Radio? I could go on and on. Will this stop people from using their cell phones??? Maybe a few, but I am sure people will still go on using them. It's like speeding and drinking and driving. We have laws for them too, but we still have people that speed and drink and drive!


darrell
said
0 0

This should've been put in about 5 years ago...but better late than never I guess. Good job NS for not wasting any time to put fines in place.


L-P Comire
said
0 0

What's next? Ban conversations with passengers? How about DVD players and even the radio?

I am not in favour of talking on the cell phones while driving, but people do immensily dumb things while driving anyhow.

Besides, I do believe there are laws on the books for driving without care. why target cell phones only? Go after people who fail to follow not only the rules of the road but also those who fail to be courteous or even those who fail to move at a proper pace (ie doing 80 in the left lane of a highway).

We already have the proper laws to deal with it, let's just make sure it is done.




liz morrison
said
0 0

Cell phones should be banned in the car period, not just hand held. how many pple have to die before someone gets it!!!! you can't pay attention if your talking on the phone!!!!!!


frank c
said
0 0

to whom it concerns, try and stop me from using my cellphone while I drive. just another money grab for our commanding government. hat other law is next, not allowed to talk to your passengers, or listen to music, or drink a cup of coffee. ask yourself this, are we now living behind the wall. why is it, the government can do what ever they want and get away with it, but we get away with nothing. are the government officials going to stop using their cellphones, ?? i don't think so.


richie
said
0 0

Yea I'm sick of the crawling pace of traffic... This is quite frankly something that should've been done long ago!!!


Steve G
said
0 0

Sometimes governments have to legislate what should be common sense. Good on the governments of N.S. and Que.
Realistically speaking, this legislation will likely save more lives than the legislation banning smoking in cars.


Joann
said
0 0

It should be banned across Canada!


jj
said
0 0

"Hands-free is just as dangerous"

False, hence why I hate alarmists groups.


Bob H
said
0 0

Will this apply to Cops as well ????????


JFJ
said
0 0

I'd love to comment but I'm on my cell.


Lou Mann
said
0 0

I live on a street where each block has a 4 way stopsign. I can't count how many times people are talking on the phone and roll right through them. MAKE IT LAW IN ONTARIO TOO...NOW....
I am tired of the government making me where a seatbelt for my safety but let these simpletons...use cell phones.


Walter L
said
0 0

It's all about money grabbing and sugar coating with pious expecatations that it will save lives! How about limiting car speeds to 130 km/hr at the source? Do we allow these killer speeds because removing them would infringe on greater rights we have! Humbug!


Monica
said
0 0

Communication in driving process should be proper only for emergency cars :ambulance,firetrucks, service vehicles. I think they have a radio communications anyway.


What I think
said
0 0

DUHH! A good driver can ignore the distraction and concentrate on the road, until he/she can pull off to deal with the distraction safely. Be it a cellphone, the kids, or a chatty passenger!
"Hands free" still will not guarantee a driver's full attention is being paid to the many tasks involved while driving.
It's too bad that because people can't use their common sense we must create laws to protect them from themselves. ie, seatbelts, winter tires, cell phones, etc. Stay tuned for the next ban---distracting passengers!


Pat K
said
0 0

What did we do before cell phones? Dah! Driving is dangerous enough without being distracted and paying attention while yacking on a phone while driving. Great law - at last - which is truly a safety issue - should have been in force long ago! Wish it was consistent all across the country. Hey B.C. government - take note.


Metro Man
said
0 0

Nathan - it has been proven that using a cell phone is just as dangerous drunk driving. All of Canada will get on board and the sooner the better. If you are a passenger and you talk to the driver you are just endangering your own life as well as others.


Zach
said
0 0

I'm going to go with martin from ottawa's response to this. It's a ridiculous and selective piece of legislation. Ban the 1000 other things that distract you while driving along with cell phones.


Gis
said
0 0

Even holding a cellphone but not using it is illegal in Quebec.

I will hopefully see an improvement on the roads. Seen too many people talking on the cell phone in one hand, have a lit cigarette in the other and trying to turn [no signals of course].

Hands-free usage is a distractions as well.


mike
said
0 0

''nathan
First thing about this article, how can you single out "holding a cell phone to your ear". It is still just talking, whether you are talking with a person in the seat next to you and actually concentrating on a conversation while driving, or on a cell phone there is very little difference. I disagree with this law for many reasons:

-If you cannot concentrate enough to be able to use a cell phone while driving then there is a serious issue with your driving ability in the first place.

-How will this be enforced? you could see a cell phone on someone's ear, so why not just send a text message, its out of view from any oncoming traffic.

I would like to be clear that talking by intense driving can be a distraction, but how can you prove that talking on a cell phone is more distracting that talking to the person in the seat next to you. Conversations in person usually generate hand gestures which in my unbiased opinion would require more concentration than listening to a voice on a phone.

Before implementation of this kind of thing, make sure that it is well proven, I do not feel this is the case.''


hi all
well i think your hands are to be in a better place called the ''steering wheel''.so how many ppl do you want dead before its proven?? why just error on the side of caution.. get rid of cell phones in cars/trucks

mike


Tori
said
0 0

Nathan, Using one hand on the steering wheel and one on the cell phone is not an option. If, you were driving and needed to respond immediately to someone pulling in front of you or being on a wet or slippery road you cannot get the phone down, both hands on the wheel and respond quick enough to avoid the accident.

Only Cellphones, I agree with you but believe me I have seen men shaving with an electric razon looking in the rearview mirror instead where driving. I have seen a man eating a bowl of cereal and others smoking a joint. It is not only women who are doing things in the car that should not be happening.

Steve in the West, you are so right, but until it is manditory to take DDC courses before getting a license and learning the hazards involved in doing too many tasks at the same time the Cellphone ban is a start.

That being said, there will always be distractions when driving but I believe Newfoundland got it right when they started this ball. Ban the cellphones that are held by hand.

It is just like the seatbelt laws back in the 70's. No one wanted them, did not believe in them and felt they were not needed. Now we even have our children in specialized seating while driving anything less is unacceptable.

This law regarding the cellphone will become just as routine as the seatbelt in no time.


Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz