CTV News | Embattled N.Y. governor quits amid controversy

Top Stories -   

Embattled N.Y. governor quits amid controversy

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News: Tom Clark on the aftermath of shame
CTV News: Tom Walters on the spurned spouses
Canada AM: John Fortier, research fellow at the American Enterprise Institute, expalins the 'hold up' in the resignation and why he waited
Canada AM: Jacob Frenkel, former U.S. federal prosecutor, explains the options for Spitzer
Canada AM: Clinical psychologist Dr. Judy Kuriansky on why political spouses stand by their men
CTV Newsnet: Alan Greenblatt, Governing Magazine, explains whether it's over for Spitzer

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(60)

CTV.ca News Staff

Date: Wed. Mar. 12 2008 6:21 PM ET

Embattled New York Gov. Eliot Spitzer has yielded to the intense pressure to resign over his prostitution scandal.

Spitzer's wife Silda was beside him as made his announcement in New York on Monday. Spitzer's resignation will be effective as of March 17.

"To those whom much is given, much is expected," Spitzer told his news conference. "I'm deeply sorry that I did not live up to what expected of me."

Lieutenant governor David Paterson will replace Spitzer and become the state's first black governor. Paterson is legally blind, but can recognize people and read text at very close distances.

Spitzer said he couldn't allow his "private failings to disrupt the people's work" and that he would do what he must to heal. He also suggested he would serve the public again at some future point, but outside of politics.

The Spitzer scandal has rocked New York for the last three days and has become a sensational international story. His mother-in-law spoke out Wednesday about the ordeal. Silda Spitzer's mother, Trilby Wall, did not say if she forgives the soon-to-be ex-governor.

"Don't you think it's enough to say we love and support Eliot and let it go there? It's very hard," she said.

"It's very hard. Love is a very big word. And it takes a lot of the first to overcome the second. You handle the second."

CTV's Tom Clark told Canada AM that Spitzer never confessed to being a customer of a high-end prostitution ring. "He never said he went to room 847 of the Mayflower hotel where he paid Kristen $4,300 for less than two hours," he said.

Spitzer's resignation announcement this morning will please New York's residents, if a poll is an accurate measure of public opinion.

The poll, released late Tuesday by the Marist College Institute for Public Opinion, found 70 per cent think Spitzer should step down.

Sixty-six per cent would have supported the impeachment option.

The survey was conducted Tuesday by telephone and polled 624 people, with a margin of error of plus or minus four per cent.

New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg said Wednesday that it was time for the state to move past the scandal.

"My thoughts are with the governor and his family at this difficult time and I think what we have to do now is to move forward," he said.

On Monday afternoon, a bombshell dropped when it became known that Spitzer, once a crusading prosecutor, had used the services of a high-priced call girl.

Investigators alleged Tuesday that the married father of three may have spent up to US$80,000 on such affairs. Spitzer has become known as "Client 9" of the Emperor's Club V.I.P. The Emperor's Club made news last week when four people allegedly involved with the group were arrested.

Spitzer had reportedly been in seclusion with his family. Silda, who appeared shellshocked during her joint appearance with him on Monday, had urged him to say on, the New York Times reported Wednesday. It cited Spitzer aides.

State Republicans gave him 48 hours to step down or face impeachment. Almost no Democrats came forward to defend him.

Jacob Frenkel, a former U.S. federal prosecutor, told CTV's Canada AM on Wednesday that the "bargaining chip" aspect of a resignation may be a key consideration for Spitzer.

The governor had the call girl Kristen travel from New York to Washington for their US$4,300 Feb. 13 tryst in a swanky hotel.

"He has genuinely put himself in the crosshairs of prosecutors," Frenkel said, noting that transporting someone across state lines for the purposes of prostitution is a federal offence in the U.S.

However, there are a number of other offences with which Spitzer could be charged, he said.

There is also the issue of enticement across state lines, and possibly even money-laundering, given the way Spitzer broke up bank transactions into small pieces to avoid currency reporting rules, Frenkel said.

Investigators will also likely be trying to determine if any state funds were used, he said.

"Gov. Spitzer would love to get this wrapped up before investigators and prosecutors really get into the depth of what he may have done," he said.

U.S. Attorney Michael Garcia issued a statement after the resignation announcement that "there is no agreement between this office and Governor Eliot Spitzer, relating to his resignation or any other matter."

Spitzer took office on Jan. 1, 2007 after winning a landslide victory. He built his name fighting Wall Street with puritanical zeal. Ironically, he also prosecuted some prostitution rings.

But he has struggled as governor. In January, his approval rating was only 35 per cent.

With files from The Associated Press

Please Add Comments( )

A Montrealer
said
0 0

This high and mighty zealot has breached the public's trust as a prosecutor who is supposed to espouse justice and uphold the law. People in positions of authority somehow think they are above the law and beyond reproach. How foolish of him to ruin his career, and destroy his family with such a scandal. His stupidity and indiscretion will cost him dearly and he has no one to blame it on but himself.

The saying goes, don't play with fire, you might just get burned ... Ouch!


Robin the Hood
said
0 0

I'll bet if this happened in Europe this would not seem such a big deal. Of course, US politics is much more sleazy and puritanical than in most other "civilized" places. Anyhow regardless, this guy has little choice now but to resign willingly.

In a more general sense, this issue gives me the impression - or adds to it - there is an increasing undercurrent of "Roman like" corruption and decadence in the politics - and society - of the "American Empire". Because of the diversity there it's a complex issue but many Americans seem to have lost touch with what constitutes a moral value system based on good common sense. Their lives have been willingly polluted by corporate and material interests and a decadent media. Americans have become the most inward looking and, hence, uninformed people in the developed world. I hope this Obama event there, to take an example, is a real shift in attitudes away from the politics of fear and not just a fad. Otherwise I do not think that this century will be a good one for the US and, if increasingly conservative attitudes here continue, for Canada as well.

James
said
0 0

What more can be said? He's a man in a position of power who believes that he is above the law and that women should be "beneath" him. I think he's hoping for a "Bill Clinton." However, he's not nearly as popular as Mr Cigar Man. Even Bill's cloak of invincibility is threadbare after all these years of trying to fool most of the people all of the time. Give up the ghost Eliot, you're no Bill.


Ian - Milton
said
0 0

It is not conservative attitudes that are destroying the Western-way as it was not conservative attitudes that destroyed the Roman-way. Quite the opposite, it was the far-left, too-liberal and morally bankrupt attitudes that destroyed Rome and will destroy us.

Don't blame the right - immoral people make immoral choices!


David
said
0 0

Some comments are making a mistaken comparison between Bill Clinton and Spitzer. Prior to Clinton being elected President, we already knew that he had cheated on his wife. Clinton never presented himself to the public as a paragon of virtue the way Spitzer has.

I don't think people are so upset about the actual act of hiring a prostitute; he might be forgiven for that. They're more upset about Spitzer's hypocrisy.


A New Yorker
said
0 0

Soon-to-be-ex-Governor Spitzer ran as a force that could clean up our incredibly dysfunctional, wasteful, inefficient state government. Since he was inaugurated, most of what he's been able to do is alienate people. Small wonder that no one's speaking up for him to stay now. At least with Bill Clinton, we knew from the beginning that women were going to be an issue. Spitzer pretended that he was above all of that, which has a lot of us feeling betrayed -- I've heard people talk about how this has soured them on other inspiring young-ish politicians talking reform. And now Spitzer's gone from a rising star who might have been our first Jewish president to an alleged felon, and I've gone from a strong supporter to wanting to throw every book available at him.

(Psst - Robin The Hood - Obama may not be talking fear, but his supporters are using the politics of fear all over the place. In their case, it's not fear of terrorism that they're trying to exploit; it's fear of another war, of being crushed under the national debt, and of big business and China. Justified or not, it's not a major tone change.)


Greg from Kitchener
said
0 0

Well I have to laugh... the liberal media still cannot say that he is a Democrat! If he where a Republican, it would have been the headlines all over the Country!!
"REPUBLICAN BUSTED"!




Phineas
said
0 0

It is a shame that people are brought down in the media, when it really should be left to the courts. I'm sick of hearing about polititians having afairs and so on. Let's hear about them being charged and convicted, or aquitted!
Why should someone who has worked long and hard, and climbed to a position, be knocked from it by allegations and lots of media attention? It is HIS JOB, leave him alone!
If he has done anything criminal, than prove it in court.
Additionally, should being a criminal keep one from serving the country? I thought the courts were supposed to punish and the jails make good on what one has done. It shouldn't be a given that breaking the law means forfetting ones job. Laws get broken, by most of us.


Frank
said
0 0

Why is a govenor of a US state making the top news in Candian News? Are tehre not more important news happening today that directly relate to Canadians?...

Lart from Above
said
0 0

Criminalizing prostitution only benefits organized crime. Sex scandals are the proper business of tabloids, not legislatures. The worst penalty someone like this should suffer should be divorce, not prosecution.


arthur
said
0 0

I don't think these sexual encounters have much to do with power. They probably have more to do with loneliness or desire. I suspect events like these say more about the state of marriage then anything else. As mentioned in a earlier comment Americans (and probably Canadians by association) seem to be more concerned with these events then other parts of the world.

I suspect that if we legalized prostitution like some countries we would be much better off socially.


MHB
said
0 0

I do no really mean to offend anyone but I am really wondering why this guy has to resign!. In the study "Infidelity in America", it was found that 50% of married men cheat on their wives and 25% of married wives cheat on their husbands. Cheating is also widespread outside the marriage cage between common law partners. So, Spitzer is now forced to resign for doing what the others in his country are doing?. Does this make any sense!.


IAN
said
0 0

This guy is one of these 'superdelegates' who is committed to Clinton. Surprise surprise.


bob
said
0 0

I agree with Frank. We have our own scandals to worry about. Like the missing millions in Liberals took, or Belindas floor crossing.


BC Resident
said
0 0

I agree. So many "ordinary" citizens cheat on each other every day and no one cares except the parties involved. However, throw in someone famous and all of a sudden they're being tarred and feathered. It's a private matter for him that needs to be dealt with between him and his wife. If anything else criminal beyond that exists, then it's a different story and that should be focused on. Not on cheating.


Don Kearney
said
0 0

To Ian in Milton:

You seem to be forgetting all the "immoral people" on the right and solely pinning things on the left. Wasn't Larry Craig a hard-core right-wing Senator? Wasn't Trent Lott a hard-core right-wing Senate Majority Leader? Isn't George Bush a hard-core right-wing individual who had lied to congress and the American people repeatedly? Isn't Stephen Harper a hard-core right-wing individual who is allegedly tried to buy the vote of a dying Chuck Cadman? Left or Right, power corrupts and your comments are misguided, partisan and completely unfair with no basis.


A woman's input
said
0 0

I notice that most comments so far are from men. Let me weigh in. Infidelity is wrong, whether a woman does it or a man, whether an ordinary citizen or a politician. This man has a wife and three daughters. How does he explain his behaviour to them? There is no excuse that could possibly restore their faith in their father. If a man or woman want to have an affair, then leave the marriage first. There is no honour in deceipt and immorality.

Whether this story would have played out differently in Europe is irrelevant. Broken vows and disrespect are universal.


Lorne from Brampton
said
0 0

My issue is not with the fact he hired a prostitute (several times). It sounds like many politicians have, and the Simpsons make fun of this all the time. The fact is Spitzer has prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law individuals who did the same thing, not to mention he's made an example of business leaders such as Martha Stewart for political gain. I never bought for a second that he went after those Wall Street people for the "moral good". This is karma, and he is getting it back 100%. I hope the New York AG prosecutes Spitzer to the fullest extent of the law and puts him in the same prison as those he has prosecuted. Please understand I normally wish no ill will on anybody. In this guy's case, I make an exception.


James
said
0 0

This guys wanted it all; a powerful job, a family and something on the side. As far as the cheating goes, whether paid or not, the guy should have said to his wife that things were not working out for him and he needed a change. Get out of any relationship before you cheat. Don't treat your partner like a fool by cheating. Cheating on his wife is only the tip of the iceberg for this guy. How has he literally and figuratively cheated the people of New York state. What else has he done? This behavior goes to the core, not of moral authority but common decency. Eliot is not a decent person!


Scott
said
0 0

Perhaps if she'd had sex with him once in a while since the kids were born, he might not have felt the need to go elsewhere. There are always two sides to personal stories like these.

In any case, I fail to see why the public feels the need to be just as hypocritical by wanting to shred him in public for a private act. Apparently he was a good Attorney General and a good Governor. Why of us has not done things which could not withstand the light of the media?



A. Bica
said
0 0

This is nonsense!!! The man hasn't yet even been charged (and may not be) and his career is ruined by media exposure. Two consenting adults engage in sex and it destroys a man's career. It's time to stop this and legalize prostitution. Turn them into legitimate tax payers and do away with the entire stigma. As for him he must answer to his wife for his infidelity but for her and the children to suffer such humiliation is outrageous.


Jon Davidson, Barie, Ontario .
said
0 0

In my view, Spitzer is paying not for private conduct, but for his hypocrisy. How many people did he help send to jail for participating in the same behaviour that he himself had engaged in?


Lynn
said
0 0

Sex gets them everytime...Where are our heros?


Chris
said
0 0

MBH - Just because one study says that everyone is cheating doesn't make it right. You made vows to faithfulness and fidelity to your spouse. If you can't be trusted to keep even that solemn vow, how can we expect someone to uphold their vows of office?


Kerri
said
0 0

to MHB. Cheating is not illegal! Paying for it is! Bill Clinton cheated, Spitzer broke the law! End of story....


M.
said
0 0

"I am really wondering why this guy has to resign."

He has to resign because he did something illegal. Cheating on your spouse is not illegal, hiring a prostitute is.


Jake
said
0 0

It was a matter of time that some dirt was conjured up on this man, he’s been knocking out the teeth and ruining the smiles of many a corporate goon! He has pursued and exposed matters such as the Price Fixing Scandal of 2006, to the Global Settlement (2002), to the Contingent Commissions (2004) to the Late Trading & Market Timing (2003). He was also involved in the fall of Enron. Well as it seems, but has yet to be proven I must add, but reasonably assumed, he has sex… He also pays for sex, don’t know a man that doesn’t actually, but that’s not the point is it. American politics is about what the politician does in his bedroom, not what he does for the people I guess, how pathetic. I see no need to impeach him, if he used his own money to purchase services that tickled his fancy. Although he broke a law that obviously can’t be overlooked, he had more backbone than most politicians it seems, and it’s a shame that he would be expelled before a President that illegally stole an election from the American people. America home of the Corporation, and something about freedom yadda, yadda!


Pete
said
0 0

I hope it was worth it.


Downtown
said
0 0

It's not prostitution that they've got him nailed on. It's electronic funds transfers. Prostitution is what buries him in the press.


Mike London
said
0 0

This is a story that has no bearing on the lives of Canadians. Why someone has to resign for using the services of a prostitute is the question the media should be asking.


Chad from London
said
0 0

To MHB....Just because others are doing it, doesn't make it right. What used to be sacred is now a joke because people won't commit to another person for life anymore. Marriages are throw-away unions now and our courts continue to make it easier to get divorced. This guy broke the law (more than one if he transported someone across State lines). Morals are non-existent and we wonder why our families are falling apart, why young kids are committing violent crimes, and why our prisons are full - it's because the Liberal-Left Wing media and political juggernaut wants it that way. Go - Figure...you can't have it both ways. The want to dance, but they don't want to pay the piper.


CM
said
0 0

Re: MHB

Why doesnt Spitzer resigning make sense? Sure some men cheat on their wives, but when you are allegedly tied to a prostitution ring that is illegal. If there is sufficient evidence then Spitzer should be prosecuted. Spitzer saying my bad without conceding to his guilt(if it goes to trial)and resigning as Governor of New York is not enough. Also scandal happens in the Demcratic and Republican parties all of the time. No one side is any better or immune to scandal.


Michael
said
0 0

Geez it is very obvious that many people who say prostitution should remain illegal and it is immoral are using their services. It is about time that this service becomes government regulated because it can not be stopped. It is one of the oldest professions. The income and the stop of disease is worth legalizing it.


Jamie
said
0 0

I don't see the big deal. He had desire and the means to pay for it. She had the product and was willing to deliver it for fair compensation. I liked it better when what people do in their bedroom was their own.


Norm
said
0 0

The only people he owes an explanation is his wife and children. Remember Clinton got away with infidelity as well as a few other former presidents and I bet some former prime ministers. There are worst crimes.


Mike Macdonald
said
0 0

Spitzer stated "I'm deeply sorry that I did not live up to what expected of me." What that really means is "I'm deeply sorry I got caught".


lmang
said
0 0

Come on!! Do we not have enough newsworthy events in Canada to report on? Why is this dominating our National News? He is only a state governor, why does the media think Canadians are so interested in this nonsense. Let's focus on Canadian news and what is important to us, like a possible federal election; how we may be able to support those Canadians effected by severe winter storms; or some human interest stories about our brave soldiers fighting overseas and how their families are coping back home.


John, Guelph
said
0 0

I am sorry to see anyone go for this reason. Especially I feel sorry for his wife and family. But that the knight in white shining armor fell is just beautiful!


OH OH
said
0 0

This is not a matter of cheating his family. He certainly did that and hopefully he and his wife can deal with that privately but somehow I doubt it.

What this is about is 80,000 dollars and paying for sex. Now, I am thinking that if the 80,000 came out of his own pocket there would not really have been any notice, other than by his wife.

If, this 80,000 is from the funds of NY, then the book needs to be tossed at this man.

The other customers that were discovered have apparently already been arrested. Why is it taking so long to arrest him?


Stephen
said
0 0

On behalf of the some 3,000 Canadian employees of one of the companies Spitzer decimated, we are grateful for karma.


MHB
said
0 0

To all those who addressed me: I never said that cheating is good. It is indeed a terrible thing!. But when there are studies showing that it is widespread in a certain society, I find it strange to attack the policians over it!. A politician is a person that came out from that same society and he follows the same societal behaviours. Governor Spitzer should resign and get tried only if he paid for his pleasure from state money!. Other than that, the only one who should hold him accountable is his family which is probably devastated already!.


Vincent
said
0 0

I agree with Bob. We also need to look into the Cadman affair more closely which is probably the highest profile case we have seen in a long time, the CNSC affair, and not to mention the Ottawa Mayor bribery issue.

There is a LOT to worry about in Canada rather then the US at the moment.


David
said
0 0

Bill Clinton did break the law. He lied to congress under oath.


jon penenr
said
0 0

Spitzer should resign not becasue he had sex with someone other than his wife, but because he did business with a criminal organization (a prostition ring), exposed himself and the office of the governor to blackmail, and because this action demonstrates a serious lack of judgement and intelligence.


Thw Hawk
said
0 0

So many of these comments are missing the main point: He broke the law. A federal law. He should pay for that and lose his position as governor. Whether the law he broke is a good one or not is a completely different story. My view on that has to do with morality. Whether it's legal in other countries or not is not relevant. Cheating on your spouse is wrong, wrong, wrong. (BTW: What act could possibly be worth $4300? Did he get to keep her car?)


Robin
said
0 0

Who cares, he's a Yank!



Nick J Boragina
said
0 0

The current Lt.Gov of New York is both african-american and blind. Now he will become the governor.


Todd
said
0 0

$4300 for two hours? Wow, that must be some sexual experience! I mean really, what can possibly be worth that much? Never mind the collateral damage -- career, marriage, self-respect, criminal charges, etc. If he did this, he's too stupid to be in charge!


SB
said
0 0

TO SCOTT: "Perhaps if she'd have sex with him once in a while since the kids were born, he might not have felt the need to go elswhere".

What a misguided attempt to explain his behaviour. A very sad excuse to justify his cheating.

I'm so tired of those in the public eye who proclaim their remorse AFTER they've been caught!!

For all those who say the media should leave him alone...part of living in the public eye is to accept that everything you do will be scrutinized.


Calgarian
said
0 0

You know, I detest more than anything are hypocrites on both sides - Conservatives and Liberals. BUT in most cases it IS the Moral right that are the real hypocrites… take for example some unnamed right wing newspaper that condemns prostitution and the people who use prostitution, but yet have scantily clad girls in between so called articles and in it's classifieds and has call girl, massage parlour and escort ads knowing full well what they are really for… that's hypocrisy (I don't have a problem with this, I have a problem with them condemning others for using what they advertise). Hypocrites are what is destroying the west, and in most cases the hypocrites belong to the moral right.

Yes, I will blame the moral right, it's your judgement upon others that destroys lives, families and careers. Pray to your God that you don't ever do something immoral… and I would find it hard to believe that you haven't already.


Russell Crosby
said
0 0

Interesting, isn't it, that it was only after he got caught that he resigned. It bothers me that people think it's ok, unless you get caught. Likely, he would have continued his nefarious ways until he got caught. Shouldn't we have people of greater moral character that this in public office?


ILTIS
said
0 0

I agree with Frank. We have our own scandals to worry about. Like the NAFTA gate,the Cadman fiasco,income trust etc,etc.
Like BOB's post please feel free to post this one.



Alan
said
0 0

To answer Frank's question as to why Canadian media is reporting on news from New York: No, there really isn't anything interesting going on up here. This story is the closest thing (geographically) Canadians are to any form of scandal involving sex and politics in almost 50 years!


Gary
said
0 0

I have to admit, next to hockey, American Politics is becoming a great Canadian spectator sport!


david from canada
said
0 0

How American this is! Dumbo and Darth Vader start an illegal war, are responsible for the death of thousands of American soldiers and hundreds of thousands of Iraqis and no imeachment. But the Republicans answer to this NY Democratic official (who was just having sex) is "resign! or we will impeach you!.
Sex is not OK but killing people is! Amazing.....
What a horrible joke America has become.


rajan
said
0 0

Why didn't the news media mention that he is a Democrat? Who are they trying to protect? I'm sure if he was a Republican, the headline would have been titled "Republican Scandal!", remember Mark Foley everyone?


Richard - KW
said
0 0

First let me point out that Canadian political scandals are boring compared to American dirt...
Spitzer was wrong no doubt about it and should resign. I wonder though when we will find the perfect politician who is immune from poor judgement and faulty morals? The very nature of high pressure politcs lends itself to the kind of hard driving individuals who are susceptible to many kinds of human fragilties. If this guy was an alcoholic would he be impeached? All that said when are the women in lives of these guys going to let them face the music on their own at the podiums? Does this show the wife's strength or weakness?


Binkley
said
0 0

ha ha - how the mighty have fallen!


raj
said
0 0

The pain on his wife face was awful.I don't see her standing by her man for too long.I wonder what his three daughters think now


Matt G.
said
0 0

Mr.Spitzer should not have had his wife behind him when he admitted to the accussations. If he had problems in his marriage, and wasn't getting the "attention" he wanted, he and his wife should have seaked professional help. This should not have ruined his career, and he should not have been penalized. Prostitutes work, and make a living doing what they do. Yes, it's not the best "job" in the world, but everyone has a choice. There is nothing sacred in society today, privacy being one of them! The media/opponents will always try to find a story, no matter how much it screws a person over.


Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz

Most Talked about Stories

I don't blame Roy for wanting to win and as he gets older, it's more important for him to be on a winning team. It sure will be sad to see him go. With this ownership, it's more of a financial issue -- they just don't have and probably never will have the resources to put a winner on the field. Maybe they should look at selling the team to someone who can build a winner. And they wonder why the fan base is drying up.

roy

Report: Halladay 'not inclined' to re-sign with Jays