CTV News | Unhappy Albertans poised to re-elect Tories

Top Stories -   

Unhappy Albertans poised to re-elect Tories

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News: Jed Kahane on the predicted outcome
CTV Edmonton: Scott Roberts on the final push
CTV's Question Period: Preston Manning, former Reform party leader

Font-size:      Share  Print  Comments(66)

Bill Doskoch, CTV.ca News

Date: Sun. Mar. 2 2008 10:56 PM ET

Ed Stelmach will probably remain premier of Alberta in his first electoral test on Monday, but when it's over, no one will likely be calling him King Ed.

Stelmach took over in late 2006 from Ralph Klein, who did wear the political crown in Alberta for 14 years as Progressive Conservative leader and premier.

But even Klein -- who famously proclaimed, "Welcome to Ralph's World," after a landslide victory in 2001 -- saw his popular support erode for the first time in the 2004 provincial election.

The Tories still held 60 of 83 seats going into this campaign.

However, "people are unhappy," Calgary-based political commentator Joan Crockett told CTV.ca.

Media-sponsored polls there have suggested that with the campaign winding down, more than 25 per cent of Alberta voters are undecided about which party to support, she said, adding a substantial number would like to see a change in government.

The Tories are estimated to have about 40 per cent support provincially (the party captured 46 per cent of the vote in 2004), the Liberals less than 20 per cent and the NDP tied with the Green party with around five per cent.

A Strategic Counsel poll for CTV and The Globe and Mail found 50 per cent of Albertans were likely to support the Tories, down eight points from January. Here's the other parties:

  • Liberals - 25 per cent
  • Wildrose Alliance - 10 per cent
  • NDP - 8 per cent
  • Greens - 8 per cent

The poll was conducted Feb. 27 and 28 and surveyed 750 people. The margin of error is 3.6 per cent, 19 times out of 20.

"It's going to be a Conservative majority government, but what is worth noting is that there's a decline in the number of people who think the province is on the right track or an increased number of people who think it's time for a change," The Strategic Counsel's Peter Donolo told CTV.ca. "Beneath the prosperity, there's a growing anxiety, but it hasn't found a vehicle."

Albertan and former Reform Party leader Preston Manning told CTV's Question Period on Sunday that he's worried about low voter turnout. "People do want change, but they don't know where to get it from," he said.

Ed's conundrum

Stelmach is in a strange situation: He's the latest steward of a political dynasty that began with Peter Lougheed's stunning victory over a 36-year-old Social Credit government in 1971.

The province's energy-driven economy is the strongest in Canada and has lured hundreds of thousands of newcomers. Yet prosperity and hyper-growth have brought their own problems, like labour shortages for employers, soaring rents and housing prices for workers and infrastructure everywhere creaking under the strain.

Some companies have recently suggested the pace of oilsands development should be slowed down. Stelmach has rejected that, although he is trying to sound more pro-environment.

All this had the two main opposition parties, the Liberals (16 seats) and NDP (4 seats, all in Edmonton), attacking the Tories as a tired party unable to manage the pressures buffeting the province.

Those two parties are to the left of the Tories, but on the right is the Wildrose Alliance (1 seat; there was one independent MLA and one vacancy at dissolution), whose members think the Tories have drifted away from true conservatism. And in central Alberta, an activist who led a fight against a power line hopes to become the first elected Green Party politician in Canada.

Stelmach tried to sell his party as the one best positioned to deliver change -- despite having been in power for 37 years so far.

His campaigning style has been described as wooden. But even if Stelmach is today's Harry Strom (the last Social Credit premier), none of the opposition leaders appears likely to play the Peter Lougheed role on Monday.

Liberal Leader Kevin Taft, NDP Leader Brian Mason and Wildrose Alliance Leader Paul Hinman all trail Stelmach in leadership, according to polling conducted for CTV Edmonton and CTV Calgary by Teleresearch Inc.

The Calgary problem

Where Stelmach might have a problem is in Calgary.

He won the party leadership as a compromise candidate, mainly through his strength in Edmonton and rural areas. In his first cabinet, Stelmach surrounded himself with loyalists - few of whom were from Calgary.

In a byelection for Klein's old seat, the voters of Calgary-Elbow sent Stelmach a message -- they elected a Liberal.

Last fall, Stelmach announced changes to the province's energy royalties regime, seen by some analysts as under-charging for Alberta's non-renewable resources of oil and natural gas. He announced the province would increase its royalty take by $1.4 billion by 2010 - about 25 per cent less than a panel recommended.

Crockatt said the natural gas industry is the real driver of Alberta's economy, and that sector is furious. Some energy companies are planning on spending their exploration budgets in other jurisdictions, "just to make a point," she said.

Crockatt listed some other controversies:

  • Stelmach wouldn't approve Craig Chandler, a controversial social conservative, as a party candidate. Chandler is now running as an Independent; and
  • He got into spat with former TV journalist Arthur Kent, considered one of the party's star candidates in Calgary.

Stelmach spent all day Saturday in Calgary, which he called Alberta's "Conservative heartland."

Leadership at stake?

Crockatt noted that to win power in Alberta, you need two of the three pillars: Calgary, Edmonton and the rural vote.

Mount Royal College political scientist Keith Brownsey told CTV.ca that Edmonton and Calgary account for 42 of the 83 seats, Red Deer and Lethbridge a couple seats each -- with the rural areas holding virtually everything else.

The rural areas are over-represented relative to their population, he said - and Stelmach is likely to win at least 35 seats there.

"That means he needs 10 more and he's got a majority," he said.

Teleresearch's mid-February poll for CTV Edmonton put the Tories well ahead there. The Strategic Counsel poll buttresses that finding. While Crockatt said the Liberals could win 11 seats in Calgary, up from four, that means the Tories could still win up to 12.

The math is there for a Tory victory. But Ralph Klein was gone within two years of winning 62 seats. Brownsey suspects if Stelmach only delivers a bare majority, his continued hold on the leadership is by no means assured.

"What's going on with the Conservative party now is you have a full-blown leadership race going on," he said. "People are manoeuvring for a post-Stelmach leadership run. They expect him to do very poorly."

Brownsey said there are those who want to take the party further right, those who are more urban and socially liberal -- "and then there's Ed Stelmach."

The potential exists for the Progressive Conservative party to fracture in the future over these factional pressures, he predicted.

"But who knows what's going to happen in this election? (Stelmach) could win 55 or 60 seats and all is well with him."

Comments are now closed for this story

Steve
said

To say Ed Stelmach is a Conservative is a JOKE.He is in my opinion,fiscally and socially very liberal in his policies and does not hold credance in my Alberta.My vote has changed from being strongly a PC supporter to the only true small c Conservative party in Alberta, the Wildrose Alliance.The more I see their policies the more I like what I see.There is a lot of similarities between what is happening now to the Mulroney PC's and the up and coming Reform movement.


Rob
said

I hoping for a change...and I don't see it Ed


James
said

I miss "King Ralph"...he might have ticked us off on many issues, he might have got us frustrated over his policies, he might have got to us with his comments, but we always knew where he stood...a straight shooter! Politics are now boring in Alberta.



Kim
said

Shame on the media....who are you to print a story that says the PC's will be re-elected. Is CTV attempting to sway the undecided voters? It is a very sad day in democracy when the media gets directly involved in the political process.






Scott
said

The Liberals and NDP have run a camapaign against a "Klein"
Government. This is why they have missed the target here.

We have Ed Stelmach , We are getting to know Ed Stelmach. He Is no Ralph Klein! (and that is good thing !)


N. Burman
said

I am hoping for a total change. A Conservative majority can only bring dissaster. The Province's growth is a runaway train and Stemach refuses to touch the brakes even though it appears that that is the wish of at least 75% of Albertans. He is a man who will not listen to the people no matter what he says.


Po
said

haha... too funny to see everyone in the praries blast liberalism like it's some great evil. You guys have been watching CanWest and Fox for so long that you don't even know what you hate so much about liberalism.
It's not so much about liberalism vs. conservatism, it's about what works bets in the current world.

Keeping the pace of development of the oilsands or increasing it will only hurt Alberta (if memory serves me right, it's usually conservative groups that scream "Save the children!" whenever something morally reprehensible happens)... so how do you explain that you have no objections to the contamination of a large amount of pure water to filter out the oil in the oilsands project?
I'm not an environmental nut but if I saw the pools of toxic waste water that I've seen in Alberta in my home province, I would go absolutely ballistic! These things are huge and toxic... and it's not lie they're being kept underground and sealed, no, they're kept in huge lakes of brown disgusting liquid that can easily seep through to your sources of drinkable water.


Anne
said

As a native Calgarian and Albertan, I am hoping that Albertans will wake up to the fact that Ed Stelmach's platform will not be good for the majority of Albertans.

Given the royalty fiasco, I challenge all Albertans in the oil and gas industry to vote for a change. Let's put your money where your mouths are.

Given there is no concrete plan for health care in Alberta, I challenge all of the rural voters to keep this in mind when you place your votes. If you vote PC again, I hope we don't have to hear about how far you have to travel for decent health care. Eliminating the AHC premiums is nothing more than an empty campaign promise....PC's love this approach to suck the voters in.

Infrastructure and education - now this is the plan...toss a small sum and ask Albertans to fund the rest through private donations/funding.

The best one of all, Ed Stelmach has rolled up his sleeves and is seeking to appeal the insurance cap on soft tissue injuries. I just have one question - how much have the insurance companies contributed to Stelmach's campaign? Every Albertan was promised a reduction in insurance premiums as a result of the cap - my decrease was a grand $6 and I have never had a accident or ticket in almost 25 years of driving. For those who have been hindered by recovery for medical expenses - get out and vote.



Ryan
said

It'd be interesting, if nothing else, to see the Green's capture a seat or two. It could give them the kind of momentum and spotlight they need.


anu bose
said

There is a distinct rural-urban divide in Alberta and the incumbent is too closely allied with the rurals. I cannot for the life of me understnd how this man was ever elected to be the party leader.


Jennifer Nevermind
said

When people who have well paying jobs can no longer afford to live, when they're forced out onto the street while they're still wearing suits to their office jobs, as so many have been, something needs to change. Hopefully the next group in charge will be able to figure that out. I want a government with a little humanity for a change - I'm getting tired of stepping over neighbors on the streets on my way to work in downtown Calgary and worrying when I'll be forced to join them. Yes, it really is that bad.


Kathy
said

I'd like to know who is being polled in Edmonton and Calgary. The sense I get as I talk to friends and colleagues is that they are NOT voting PC, anything but PC. I feel many people will vote strategically or a protest vote. I felt the same feelings in the Federal Election when the Reform one most of AB in the 90's.

The rural vote along with the few urban seats they retain will keep the PCs in power but I feel there is an undercurrent of mistrust against the PCs. The real story begins on Monday night as Alberta reflects on the election outcome.


cantuc
said

Po , I don't know where you live and I don't care but went fishing in Ont. Caught lots of fish but got told not to eat them . Nice clean looking lakes but toxins aren't always brown sludge .
Drilling rigs shut down , highways that need improving or twinning ,hospitals that need building and Stelmach spends $50,000,000.00 on "the arts" .I wish Stelmach had to drive to work every at 6:00am morning on the #3 between Medicine Hat and Taber . Might see some actual governing then .


Michael
said

But even to call his policies 'liberal' are just ABSURD. IF any liberal government in Canada were to take a leaf out of Stelmach's book, that would be embarrassing.

His lack of leadership and lack of political gumption are just plain pitiful; but not equated to any political ideology.

The Stelmach campaign isn't about change that works for the people. It can barely be called change that works for the corporations. It's not change.

It's just plain bad.


Mike
said

I am a born and bred Albertan, have lived here over 40 years and I cannot remember anytime in this Province where there has been so many unhappy people. A very recent poll said 70% of Albertans feel they are worse off than they were before the boom. Almost everyone I know wants to move away. People outside of Alberta have no idea. Cost of living and inflation has gone through the roof, waiting times for absolutely everything. I am Conservative but I admit, the Conservatives here are a disaster. Stelmach saying He won't put the brakes on is beyond insane. If you don't cool an economy, the cost of living and Inflation will not only become unbearable for many families (as it currently is), it will eventually bring the whole economy to it's knees. They are destroying Alberta, they are absolutely allowing the destruction of Northern Alberta's environment and all they care about is the oil revenue which will never be able to solve Alberta's current woes. The more people who move here, the worse it becomes.


Dean
said

Oh come on people! With the economy we have in Alberta, we need a governmet with an idea of how to run a business. Liberals and NDP don't have the business savvy to run a lemonade stand. PC's are the only choice.


jg
said

I love it when Albertans cry about Ontario “always electing Liberals” when in fact Ontario is quite capable electing Liberals, Conservatives and the NDP. This reflects the diversity of Ontario and as Alberta’s population grows, it will eventually do the same. But in the foreseeable future, Alberta will continue to be a monolithic one party state.


Out of Dodge
said

Having just left Alberta, I can tell you that no one is happy there, rent is a true hardship, housing costs is criminal, infrastructure is crumbling, Deerfoot is now aptly labeled Deathfoot because of the road rage driving that is killing people. What a mess and all because of rumours of jobs; the hysteria in Alberta is a feeding frenzy of greed.

I've often said Albertans are simply going to start cannibalizing eachother.


Leaving Alberta
said

I have to agree with some of the comments. Alberta has become the Province to LEAVE, not move to. If you're moving here for a better standard of living, turn around, you will not find that here. People from other Provinces seem to think that the cities have all of these high paying Oil jobs. WELL THEY DON'T!! The jobs in the cities pay roughly the same as anywhere in Canada with the exception that they are generally way understaffed so you have to work twice as hard. You also have to sometimes take 2 jobs just to cover your living expenses. This is what the Politicians affectionately refer to as THE ALBERTA ADVANTAGE. By the that they mean, the Province is making lots of money, the Oil companies are making lots of money and the majority of the rest of Alberta is barely keeping their heads above water. Yeah, great place!!! Way to go Conservatives, maybe we should encourage even more growth??


Nick J Boragina
said

The Alliance missed an opportunity bigtime. Many Albertans were angry that the government was seen as taking a too left-wing approach to the royalty dispute. As the only party to the right of the Tories, the Alliance could have really built on that and come out swinging; but their inability to find candidates in two dozen ridings shows how sad the party is in it's current state.

As for the NDP, they are not doing well at all. One of the reasons is "why vote NDP". Two or three decades ago, there were many answers, but today the NDP is seen as "justanother" party. with "justanother" platform. The Greens, even if they are not as left-wing as the NDP, are picking up support because they are truly "different". That leaves only the Liberals to challenge the Tories. The Liberals, however, are not ready to win. They can set themselves up this round to make a serious run at it next time, perhaps with a more charismatic, or more well known leader (just what HAS anne mcclellan been up to recently anyway?)

Sadly, I think the only excitement this round will be weather stelmach’s majority will be by one dozen or two dozen seats.



WJC
said

Why change a good thing. The people of Alberta live a nice lifestyle. The last thing you need is some social whimp in there screwing up the economy. Perhaps another 37 years of conservative rule is needed especially since the alternatives are dismal at best.


JS
said

Taft and the Alberta Liberals sound TOO much like his federal counterpart. Whenever Stelmach announced anything, the first thing that Taft would do is bash it, then announce his own. Sounds more like what Dion is doing. Taft NEVER once announced anything first. He was following Stelmach's lead. Not very good for a leader. He is more like a follower.
If Taft gets in, say hello to higher taxes, higher energy costs, higher. Say goodbye to jobs.


Sam
said

Hey CTV .... so the best you can do is forecast a Tory victory, that's a no brainer. The real question is by how much ? with 25% undecided, a PC minority government would be the best outcome, and makes for an interesting and exciting media feast for the next 3 to 4 years.


Darryl
said

I'd be tempted to vote against the PCs if we had a viable alternative but we don't. Taft and Mason make Stelmach look impressive and he's not. Oh well, maybe we can get a real leader in the next PC leadership review and campaign...


jeremy
said

Stelmach`s biggest problem is Klein. Not the "King Ralph " person, but the lazy Ralph person. Ed is trying to dig us out of Ralphs mess. The ex premier has admitted they had no plan.
People like Steve need to realise that. Fiscal conservatists buy when the time is right not when prices are high,Ralph forgot to do this,and now we have an infrastructure debt that is massive.


Kevin Aubie
said

I think the people of Alberta are fools to vote for Stelmach. He is so out of touch with reality you have to be a idiot not to realize it.


lee
said

To Kim-for once I must defend the media and point out the word poised to you. They are simply going with the overwhelming polling data that clearly shows that there will be a PC majority come Monday night.

To Jennifer Nevermind, the nonsense you spout is amazing. Stepping over your neighbours are you. Perhaps you should have complained about being stuck in traffic with all the brand new SUV's if you wanted to be believable.

While the province may have some problems in fact it has very few, try living in Quebec for a couple of years or perhaps head to Vancouver and see what a real affordable housing crisis looks like, or better yet move to southern Ontario and enjoy your 2 hour daily commut to work since the only house you can afford is in Guelph.

Wake up, quit whining and go vote.


Darrell
said

Change for the sake of change will solve very little. Although there are many problems associated with Alberta's boom, changing governments at this time would not bring better governance because governments alone cannot do everything to correct problems. Most opposition parties expound ideas which if studied closely would increase taxation, hurt investment and in general slow down growth. This kind of change we don't need.


Anne M
said

The Wildrose Alliance has not had time to really get up and going, so I hope for a viable opposition to the PC's, something which they have not ever had. The Wildrose Alliance is the best choice, not the Liberals. I wrote the Libs, asking if they would consider changing their policies and name, and distancing themselves from the federal bunch. Their reply was that they are the "Alberta Liberals", not the federal Liberal party. This did nothing to convince me that they are really different, but made me think they are double talkers and liars.


Mike Fulop
said

It seems to me Albertans are in a holding pattern of fear. They want things to change but are afraid that growth and prosperity will disappear with a change of government. When they are already commenting on a conservative win they are commenting on the air of the fear that's rooted in Alberta's addiction to oil profits and all the money that does or doesn't trickle down.


Colin Creado
said

People are more interested in whats going on in the US than in their backyards... that really ticks me off as change is posible right now... but not with that attitude.

When are we going to get a government that will fix the rural problem of being over-represented. As a person living in Calgary and not out in the boonies and paying damn well more taxes for doing it, i feel i deserve a stronger voice!!


Dixie grateful to be an Albertan
said

If you think things are bad in Alberta, try moving to Ont or Que or the Maritimes. I think we should be grateful we live in such a wonderfully rich province and stop the griping. Sure its not perfect, but look at the alternative. The Libs or NDP? They would devastate the Province in a matter of months. Gov't car insurance... yikes. Why should Albertans who don't drive pay for those that do. Of course the other provinces who have it couldn't get rid of it with a change of gov't because of the mega millions that went into infrastructure around gov't insurance. And no fault accidents....if someone runs into you through no fault of yourself, why should you be deemed 50% responsible simply because you were on the road. We don't need it nor do we need the NDP or Libs.


Curt
said

Its hard to vote for a change when the Liberals dont even field a person in my riding! I will be rolling dice to decide tommorrow!


Thanos
said

I won't vote for Stelmach based on two things:
1) the capping of soft-tissue injuries at $4000 maximum is an insult to anyone who gets injured at work or a road accident
2) governing the province by promoting an urban vs rural power divide is moronic; the way Stelmach and his closest loyalists insulted Calgary (the largest tax base in the province) is just ridiculous

Tories are just starting to reap the whirlwind of the "anyone but Jim Dinning" attitude that ruined the last leadership race. I know who I vote for won't win but I still won't be voting for Stelmach and his rednecks.


Kevin - Edmonton
said

A lot of people would like to see a change, the only problem is no one likes Kevin Taft as an alternative. If the liberals had voted in some new blood for their leadership and mounted a serious campaign in this election the political landscape would look very different today.

The conservatives will take a convincing victory as always simple because there is no credible alternative. Alberta politics has become a joke, with no options do we really have a democratic choice to make or are we all just resigned to accepting the inevitable.


Conrad
said

I will NOT vote for a party that allowed Ralph to rule the roost for so long. Anyone can be ruthless and cut costs. It takes a leader with vision and the best interests of his/her province in mind to move forward with a plan for improvement. Ralph never had that. Not a plan; not the best interests of the people at heart. I will be voting for improvement, not change.


Denis P
said

Where is the Eastern based media getting their information from? Certainly not from the Albertans who will undoubtedly vote the Conservatives back in.
And how can anybody be "unhappy" in Alberta? We're the economic engine of Canada, and we know the Conservatives are at least partly responsible for that.
To Ontarians; we see who you just voted in, and we don't want that. In Alberta, it's not heresy to be right wing. As a matter of fact, we quite enjoy it. So, if the media is expecting a Conservative fall from power, you might as well pack up now, and in the case of the CBC, save the tax payers some money.



Ground Zero
said

If Alberta were a business, this government would have been replaced along time ago. Here's the problem.
Too much growth too fast has caused housing and rent and all services to become very unaffordable. When you have a couple 100 thousand people move here in such a short time, the result is gridlock. That gridlock is traffic, housing, rental shortages, almost all services etc. basically affordability of everything. And they wonder why everyone is miserable? A slow sustained growth would have assured longterm continual growth. All we are setting ourselves up for is another Bust, this time MUCH worse. The Oil sands construction will inevitably come to an end. There is only so much fresh water that can be exploited for the extraction process and there will be mounting world anger at a time when the rest of the world is trying to cut back C02, Alberta is doubling and quadrupling it.

Small businesses and Big businesses such as Dell and others have shutdown and moved from Alberta because the costs are atrocious. What is going to happen when the growth ends? It will be VERY UGLY!! Because there is nothing to fall back on in this "one trick pony" Alberta economy. We will have thousands and thousands of trades people and laborers out of work once the out of control boom finally runs it course. As I said, it will get very ugly.


Lauren Baker
said

The media needs to quit telling me that I am unhappy with the tories. Overall, I am very happy and I really resent being told that I am not. We should be terrified of the Liberals-if they had the chance they would bankrupt us as they have done federally. Has anyone bothered to add up their election promises? They know they don't stand a chance so they continue to make promises that they know they won't have to bring to fruition because they won't get elected. If the city of Calgary chooses to not support the sitting tories then they can suffer the consequences of no representation as we have had to do in Cardston Taber
Warner.


Lee
said

No Albertans have no fear...this PC government will toss each Albertan over 16 years $400 (remeber the Ralph bucks) and they will all be dancing in the streets....those who vote PC are so so gullible and very naive....


Rick
said

There are a lot of interesting opinions but no real valid facts being told.

First of all, most of the anger and whining is coming to this province from those that have relocated here during the boom. Yes there is going to be major growing pains associated with the largest engineering expansion on the planet. What do you expect. You wanted the healthy pay cheque, now put up with the healthy problems that go with. And by the way, how many of those paycheques are being sent out of province??

I do agree that Ed should listen to the citizens and business's when a slow down is called for. It will allow us to patch some of the holes and it certainly won't stop the rising price of oil. That was something that King Ralph did quite well and was even seen reversing himself over. The true mark of a leader.

I also agree that none of the other parties have anything to offer but mud slinging. Not an intelligent approach.

One thing I think Ed should take the lead on is not only fixing the support structure in Alberta, but protecting the environment, namely water and keeping a close eye on those who want to eport our raw resources to others and losing the jobs that go with it. He's shown that he will stand up to big business.

I'm voting PC because I think Ed is just getting started and I want to give him a chance to do a better job.


jg
said

Oh come on Dean. Did you forget Jim Flaherty left Ontario with a 5.6 billion dollar deficit ? Now he wants to do the same for Canada !


True Albertan
said

To people like "James" who miss 'King Ralph' - what are you, masochists? What part of our decimated health care system, crumbling infrasatructure, or BILLIONS of dollars of missing resource revenue do you miss? If Kevin Taft (Liberal Leader) can't pull off a victory in this election, it's his leadership that's in jeopardy.


Bob,Calgary
said

Alberta has the same problem that Canada has always had "mediocre polital leadership". Canadians are polite,nice people but don't really have the inclination to say enough is enough. The conservatives under King Ralph and now under honest Ed are at best a D+ government. Sure Taft is like watching paint dry but would he be any worse than a tired Conservative government that hasn't had an original idea in many, many years. I detest the Federal liberals but I'm willing to take a chance on their provincial counterparts just to see some hope of new ideas. After all, if Taft can't cut the mustard we can throw him out in four years. At least defeat may teach the Cons in Alberta a lesson.


Ontario
said

Well not being from Alberta it's really hard to judge. However the province has become more multi-national and multi-ethnic and I would say that change is sometimes very good. Sweeps things clean and gives a fresh new set of ideas and ideals .... Ontario has learned that over the years and I sure hope Alberta does too tomorrow. From all the news articles ... Ed is a throw back (not a bad guy) ... and I happen to agree with all the media .. CTV in particular ... stop declaring winners and taking sides ... where are your ethics?


Geoffrey
said

First of all, little over a year ago, I was not a Stelmach fan, and had been driven away from the PC Party by Klein and co. However, since then, after seeing him as premier, I have become a huge fan.

To address some of the above comments,

Rob - Ed Stelmach is a huge change from Ralph Klein. We have gone from a "leader" with no plan who shot from the lip, and may or may not have thought later about what he said to a real leader who, although not the most exciting guy in the room, thinks carefully before he makes a decision, and then makes the best decision he can.

An example is his commitment to solving a huge pension issue with teachers that had gone on for decades. He promised to solve it, and he has.

Regarding the royalties, while the left wanted them higher, the right was screaming not to raise them, and one of the commission members suddenly began contradicting her own report after it was published. Ed made the best decision he could.

Regarding slowing the economy, I can't imagine supporting someone who campaigns with the line "Vote for me and I'll destroy the economy!"

Kim is upset at the reporting? I agree with lee. I've been following the polls since before the campaign, and every single one predicts a Tory majority. The big question is the large undecided vote, but I wonder what percentage of these will actually turn out to vote if they haven't made up their minds by this time.

And anu bose wonders how Stelmach became the leader? Because his was the voice of reason between the front-runner candidates on the extreme left and right of the party, who argued that if the left candidate won, Tories would switch to the Alliance, and if the right candidate won, Tories would switch to the Liberals. Ed seemed the best hope for the PC Party and its unity, and party members voted accordingly. Hopefully, they made the best decision, but we'll see after the fallout from whatever happens Monday night.


Jennifer Nevermind
said

Lee,

The 'nonsense' I spouted is simply life in Calgary, honestly as I've lived it. I wonder where you draw such vitrol from to direct towards people you don't know about experiences you obviously have no sympathy for.

This nonsense you mention about SUVs is beyond me because I couldn't possibly afford a car and so couldn't possibly be affected by commuting that way. Maybe you should take your mouth away from your latte for just a moment and look around you at how the other half live. You know, the working poor? They're a well known phenomenon and they're increasingly made up of nine to fivers engaged in well paying jobs in Calgary.

I've lived in Calgary for the past several years in the same rundown slummy apartment, whose owners decided last year that they were justified in almost doubling our rent, making it completely out of my reach - even though I make a good wage and I'm far from the welfare line - at a time when anything less expensive was simply unavailable. Lucky for me I've been able to rely on my family to make up the extra but many of my neighbors were not. As anyone who lives or works downtown in Calgary knows, there are countless people who are not so lucky.

The city of Calgary's affordable housing page states that "Over 58,000 households in Calgary are having difficulty affording adequate housing due to the high cost of living and low wages." This and other bona fide info can be found at their website: http://tinyurl.com/28pphq

Unfortunatly they only talk about low income people having trouble, a common misconception which is promoted by the Alberta government because it's less embarrassing than the reality. But there are community action groups formed by those affected which are trying to raise awareness.

Anyone who lives or works in downtown Calgary has seen the numerous poor on the streets, they just may not take the time to know how those people got there.

And for the record I have lived on both the West coast of BC and in Southern Ontario, and I've never experienced the same level of unaffordability in either of those locals as I do in Calgary. Lack of affordable housing is a real issue in Alberta, and it does not just affect the poor.


dale b
said

N. Burman
I am hoping for a total change. A Conservative majority can only bring dissaster. The Province's growth is a runaway train and Stemach refuses to touch the brakes even though it appears that that is the wish of at least 75% of Albertans. He is a man who will not listen to the people no matter what he says.
......lets be real here if 75% of albertans were not happey as you say we would have a change of goverment we wont .i have lived in alberta for a very long time i live in medicine hat small city of 55,000 lots of jobs lots of very nice people rent you can get a nice 2 bedroom appartment 595.00 a month cheep utilitys and good paying jobs a class one driver will make 80,000-120,000 a year house price are still resonable. you do not have to move to calgary or edmonton. there are lots of smaller communitys that have a very good standard of living . so its still where you want to live i have lived in other provinces and i would never move from alberta low taxes.i dont get the big city problems high rent and no doctors i see my doc about 4 times a year and spend 1hr with him and we chat had surgery from a car accident dr were ggreat profetional and hardly any waight time so i know who i am voting for the same as my family so thats 8 vots for the pc


Vince M.
said

Geoffrey - I'll agree - Ed Stelmach makes the best decisions he can.

Which is sad because those decisions are so poor he would be better off not making any at all.

For example, his decision to give the teachers $1.4 BILLION to cover THEIR shortfall in THEIR pension plan was purely to stop them from holding a strike during the election. That was taxpayers' money spent poorly - and it was his decision to do so.

Dave S
said

Anyone who suggests it is not economically hard to live in Alberta nowadays obviously does not rent and probably owns their own home from a few years ago. If they have recently bought, or currently rent they know full well just how expensive this province is. When your rent is doubled in a year and is still going up, struggling just to pay your bills becomes a reality. This Province is NOT the end of the rainbow as some people try to portray it to be! Move here, you'll find out for yourself very quickly "it aint all it's cracked up to be"!!!

Eric in Grande Prairie
said

I would not mind change either, but not big change. The NDP are way too far left (Public insurance? Eliminate homelessness in a year? Are you joking?) and along with the Greens would have the ability to throw the energy giant Alberta into a full blown recession. The Liberals seem to be the least "trustful" of all parties and want you to believe they have the right answer for absolutely everything and of course don't see any value whatsoever in the strides the Conservatives have done lately. The Alliance are so far right wing and business friendly that Dick Cheney would probably even feel a bit uncomfortable.

That leaves the Conservatives. I genuinely believe that Mr. Stelmach is a good, honest man and will deliver on his believable and attainable goals. Let's be honest: like it or not, nobody dared go against Klein at the height of his power at risk of being thrown out. That's respect for the leader not completely different from Trudeau or Chretien. He's gone and long past due changes are already happening. I think they'll continue to happen.

Outsider Looking In
said

I may live in Ontario, and love my province dearly, but the way McGuinty and co. are running the show here gives me some reservations about whether or not it would be better to move out to Alberta. In spite of the some of the problems previously mentioned, your economy is at least growing. The quips about Ontarians always electing Liberals is not far off the mark. McGuinty was returned last fall with a similar majority to which he won in 2003, in spite of a record of broken promises that put Chretien and Martin to shame. Now, some will argue that the PCs here virtually gave the campaign away, and that would not be entirely inaccurate. But my point is that the electorate here seems to have blinders on most of the time.

Anyway, as I said, I don't live in Alberta, but if I did, based on what I've heard, I believe I would be voting for the Wildrose Alliance. They appear to be the only reasonable alternative to the PCs, in my opinion.

Joe
said

The media is groping for a story. The silent majority are quite content and don't give the election much thought one way or the other. I'll be voting Green but half the population will vote PC. There's not much to be grumpy about in Alberta.


Joan
said

I will NOT be voting for Stelmach.

I am displeased with the continued growth (and dangers) of sour gas and methane coal bed production. We are destroying our environment with no forward look to the future.

This governement is also not protecting our water. Oil & gas consume tremendous amounts of water which can not be considered a renewable resource. What happens to all the communities feeding on the rivers when the glaciers are expected to be gone in 20 years?

And nuclear power? I remain vehemently opposed to it. I lived in Germany during the Chernobyl disaster and one could read radiation with a meter outide their homes. And nuclear energy is NOT green - uranium mining is very destructive. And where does one safely place the spent fuel for thousands of years?


Anne M
said

I like the Wildrose Alliance, (which has hardly been mentioned here) because most of their candidates are paying for their own campaign. These are people who are doing what they believe in, and footing their own bills.


Bill
said

The reason that the Progressive Conservatives have governed so long is that they are very much a coalition of a broad range of political views and because they've delivered good government. From time to time the leadership may be more liberal or conservative and this allows them to continue to govern. No change will occur tomorrow. Carry on!


KW
said

I'm Conservative enough that those around me joke that I bleed blue. But, this time, I may just hold my nose and vote Liberal. The reasons why compared to conditions in other cities may not be that bad, but I'll tell you why anyways.

I moved to lethbridge from Saskatchewan in 1999 to go to school. I never paid over 475 for an apartment before, utilities were ridiculously affordable, and I was more or less content.

Nine years later, I actually think that a 1 bedroom suite for 600 dollars is a "good deal", my utilities eat up most of my paycheck that car insurance and rent doesn't (I haven't had an accident in a very long time), I can't even go to Burger King or even Tim Horton's after I get off work at 1 AM without seeing signs stating "closed due to employee shortages" because nobody can afford to pay these employees what they actually need to make to get by. and it's an absolute joke that unless i have a job that provides it, I have to pay health care premiums monthly where in Saskatchewan, if i recall correctly, you apply for the card and don't pay a dime to have it. At 13 dollars an hour, I barely make rent. Yes, Calgary and Edmonton are probably a hell of a lot worse and I dont know how anyone there does it. I hear stories of people being forced to sleep in their cars that work 40 hours a week

Once I complete my degree, I'd be more than happy to leave Alberta if things don't change, and if my home province's economic state improves and if i don't have to move to B.C (Also known as Bring Cash). Stelmach will win, I'm quite sure, but I hope he does poorly enough that the party considers replacing him with someone who is at least fit to run a village post office.

Cheaper rent, cheaper utilities, and being able to go order a double double at 1 AM... That's all I'm asking for.


Dick Varley
said

I wonder what parallel universe many of these respondents live in. I have lived in downtown Calgary for more than ten years. Yes, I have seen change. Yes, I have seen some increase in criminal activity (drug and gang related) offset by increased policing. However I see increased frustration with a lax federal justice system. My rent has increased, but nowhere near the doubling that many here talk about. With relatives in Ontario and BC I hear about the extremely high cost of housing at those locations. Try to buy a house in downtown Toronto. In Alberta there is no provincial tax. Implementation of which would be a death wish for any opposition party. The rate of provincial income tax is ten percent. The social safety net for seniors is the best in the country. Low income seniors do not pay for health care, have rent subsidies, etc. I could go on and on. However, it appears that the critics love to spout off for the sake of hearing themselves talk. The opposition parties can only make their case by spinning and spending. Heaven help us if their vision of change is put upon us.


Debbie (moved on from Alberta)
said

It's too bad you can't vote for the party and vote against the leader. having just left Alberta after 13 years I can tell you that Klein was well liked and that most people who support the PC's, don't like Stelmach.


wendy
said

Heh! I am happy. Ralph was rude and he wasnt MY king! Ed is a gentleman and a gentle man..( he doesnt throw things ) Ed took on a huge project( Ralph mess!!!).he has my blessing.GO steady eddie!:)

Jared
said

It's interesting to compare the Conservative governments of Klein and Stelmach to that of Peter Lougheed, the man who got the Tories into office in the first place.

Almost a year ago now, a talk he gave at the University of Alberta about the need to slow down and stagger the oilsands development up in Fort MacMurray-he said it was "like the surface of the moon." At the same time, he's been expressing worry about the shipments of our water south of the border, and inflation hurting lower-income families.

Here's the ironic part...

The same things Lougheed is worried about are the same things that left-wing groups like the Council of Canadians are worried about these same problems, while right-wing groups like the Canada West Foundation are concerned with whether we're making smart investments by saving some of the oil royalties in the Heritage Fund, the way Lougheed did back in the 1970s.

I wonder whether slowing down the oilsands development might not have several advantages:

1) We cut down on the pollution that other posters in this thread have mentioned, which would probably help out the people at Fort Chipewyan, whose hunting and fishing are being ruined by pollution;

2) We give the infrastructure in Fort MacMurray some time to catch up-the mayor up there has been pleading for help.

3) Inflation could slow down, thus taking off some of the pressure on lower-income families.

Besides which, surely there's more we could be doing to meet our modern challenges, and contribute to Canada as a whole?

-We could take steps to diversify the provincial economy, the way Peter Lougheed did, and make some investments in green technology, new sources of energy so we remain an industrial and energy powerhouse when the oil runs out...

-We could insist that the bitumen currently being shipped to the U.S. for refinement has to be refined in Canada, thus ensuring the jobs remain in Alberta...

-We could form partnerships with the other provinces and the federal government for the companies down there to invest more in our oilsands, thus insuring that, if the jobs can't stay in Alberta, they can at least stay in Canada...

-We could make interest-free loans to other provinces in money and/or oil, the way Lougheed did, both to help out our fellow Canadians and stick it to any idiot who thinks that Alberta doesn't care about the rest of the country...

...and in many ways, these are the things Lougheed did with our natural resources.

Now, don't get me wrong: The NEP was stupid, stupid, stupid. As was typical for Trudeau, he didn't even bother consulting Alberta for its position before implementing the NEP, which probably could have led to a compromise reached beforehand without all the acrimony and economic damage that sorry excuse for a program gave us. Instead, what we got was Albertans pissed off at our Eastern countrymen, and the rest of the country seeing Alberta as greedy and selfish, something that, if you look at the huge interest-free loans Lougheed gave to other cash-strapped provinces, is completely ridiculous.

That's the difference between the conservatism of guys like Peter Lougheed and Robert Stanfield, and the conservatism of guys like Ralph Klein and Stephen Harper: Red Tories like Lougheed and Stanfield know that there needs to be a balance between the private sector and the government, and that the marketplace can't solve everything.

Guys like Klein and Harper, and similarly guys like Dick Cheney and Mike Harris, put so much blind faith in the private sector that it's almost like a religious ideology.

In a way, it's almost like Communism. Communism was a disaster that showed you still need business and the private sector, and that trusting every single thing to the government is stupid. On the other hand, I'm not so sure that a blind faith in the marketplace and the private sector is necessarily the right way to go, either; the shitty conditions for workers in the early 19th century in the early days of capitalism were what gave rise to communism in the first place.

I hope this won't be taken as blind socialism. Like I said, a blind faith in government is stupid; but, as many of the people on here have shown, a blind faith in the private sector, and simply sitting back and letting the marketplace look after everything, as Klein did when he was premier, isn't necessarily any better.

Sask Jim
said

Can't be all that bad under the present government Beer at a buck a can, here it's $1.50. Whats wrong with that.


Brett
said

Funny, you never hear Ontarians talking about "touching the brakes" - why the very idea of shutting down auto-plants or antique coal generation gives them the heaves.

Anyway, they should be happy if Ed Stelmach wins - Ed is a Liberal, as are most of his cronies. That is why Kevin Taft has so much difficulty getting any traction: you can't get much more tax-and-spend than the Stelmachian PCs.


Robert Ward
said

I for one am glad that I considered all the policies of the parties.
Wildrose gets my vote.
I hope they get a few seats and a bigger voice in the legistlature.

Les
said

All I know is that its time to unite the right!

Lloyd
said

As an Albertan, I would like to see change!! I am sick and tired of all promises that the PC party has been telling us to win our votes. They talk about increasing child care sapces, but how long have they been in power? They talk about increasing funding for post-secondary schools, how long have they been in power? They could have these things waaayy long time ago, if they are really sincere in making Alberta a great place to live. I wish that the PC would put on my shoe just for one day, get up early in the morning, wake my kid up so can drop him off at a day care 30 minutes away, go to school full time, work weekends to make ends meet!!

We need change!!!


Share with your social Network:

 

Advertisement

Contest

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Share this article with Facebook

Share this article with Digg

Share this article with Newsvine

Share this article with delicious

Share this article.
Send Email

Share this article with Twitter

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Share this article with Reddit

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz